Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 3564]
The Committee on Financial Services, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 3564) to cancel recent changes made by the
Federal Housing Finance Agency to the up-front loan level
pricing adjustments charged by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac for
guarantee of single-family mortgages, and for other purposes,
having considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Middle Class Borrower Protection Act
of 2023''.
SEC. 2. REPEAL OF RECALIBRATED SINGLE-FAMILY PRICING FRAMEWORK.
Not later than the expiration of the 60-day period beginning on the
date of the enactment of this Act, the Director of the Federal Housing
Finance Agency shall revise the recalibrated single-family pricing
framework charged by the enterprises for guarantee of mortgages on
single-family housing so that such fees are identical to the fees of
the standard single-family pricing framework in effect immediately
before May 1, 2023.
SEC. 3. RESTRICTIONS ON FHFA ADJUSTMENTS TO SINGLE-FAMILY PRICING
FRAMEWORK.
(a) Temporary Prohibition on Further Adjustments to Single-family
Pricing Framework.--During the period beginning upon the date of the
revision of the recalibrated single-family pricing framework pursuant
to section 2 and ending 90 days after the submission to the Congress of
the report required under section 5, the Director may not further
revise the single-family pricing framework from such framework in
effect pursuant to the revision required by section 2.
(b) Administrative Procedures for Adoption of Adjustments to the
Single-family Pricing Framework.--After expiration of the period
referred to in subsection (a), when proposing adjustments to the
single-family pricing framework, the Director shall follow procedures
that are as close as practicable to those requirements for a Federal
agency issuing a rule under chapter 5 of title 5, United States Code
(commonly referred to as the ``Administrative Procedure Act'').
(c) FHFA Requirement for the Use of Risk-based Pricing.--Section
1367(b)(2) of the Federal Housing Enterprises Financial Safety and
Soundness Act of 1992 (12 U.S.C. 4617(b)(2)) is amended by adding at
the end the following new subparagraph:
``(L) Additional powers as conservator.--The Agency
shall, as conservator for an enterprise, to the
greatest extent feasible require that any
modifications, including increases, decreases, or
eliminations, approved to a loan-level pricing
adjustment fee, as such term is defined in section 6 of
the Middle Class Borrower Protection Act of 2023,
charged by an enterprise shall be based on the risk
posed by the mortgage loan to the enterprise.''.
SEC. 4. PROHIBITION OF LOAN-LEVEL PRICE ADJUSTMENTS BASED ON DEBT-TO-
INCOME RATIO.
The Director and the enterprises shall not impose any loan-level
pricing adjustment fee that is based on the ratio of the debt of the
mortgagor to the income of the mortgagor.
SEC. 5. GAO STUDY.
(a) Study.--The Comptroller General of the United States shall
conduct a study of the revisions made by the Federal Housing Finance
Agency to the standard single-family pricing framework under the
recalibrated single-family pricing framework to--
(1) analyze--
(A) the methodology, policy considerations, and any
other objectives used by the Federal Housing Finance
Agency as the basis for such revisions, including the
authority cited by the Director under the Federal
Housing Enterprises Financial Safety and Soundness Act
of 1992 (12 U.S.C. 4501 et seq.) to require such
revisions;
(B) the data, econometric modeling, and other inputs
supplied by the enterprises during the revisions
process;
(C) the extent to which such revisions comply with
the objectives of the Enterprise Regulatory Capital
Framework, including the interaction with and treatment
of any private mortgage insurance required in
connection with a residential mortgage transaction; and
(D) the economic impact of such revisions on various
classes of lenders and borrowers affected by such
revisions; and
(2) determine the extent to which such revisions--
(A) were conducted on the basis of, and how they
might deviate from, the principle of risk-based
pricing;
(B) deviate from the data, econometric modeling, and
other inputs supplied by the enterprises during the
revisions process;
(C) achieve the objectives of the Enterprise
Regulatory Capital Framework, including if such
revisions have resulted in either a negative
profitability gap or negative rate of return on the
targeted rate of return on capital for any business
segment under the recalibrated single-family pricing
framework; and
(D) represent any increased risks to the safety and
soundness of the enterprises.
(b) Report.--The Comptroller General shall submit a report to the
Congress setting forth the findings and conclusions of the study not
later than the expiration of the 14-month period beginning on the date
of the enactment of this Act.
SEC. 6. DEFINITIONS.
In this Act:
(1) Director.--The term ``Director'' means the Director of
the Federal Housing Finance Agency.
(2) Enterprise.--The term ``enterprise'' has the meaning
given such term in section 1303 of the Federal Housing
Enterprises Financial Safety and Soundness Act of 1992 (12
U.S.C. 4502).
(3) Loan-level pricing adjustment fee.--The term ``loan-level
pricing adjustment fee'' means an up-front fee paid by lenders
when a mortgage loan is acquired by an enterprise.
(4) Recalibrated single-family pricing framework.--The term
``recalibrated single-family pricing framework'' means the
loan-level pricing adjustment fee structure as referred to in
the announcement of the Federal Housing Finance Agency on
January 19, 2023, relating to ``Updates to the Enterprises'
Single-Family Pricing Framework'', and set forth in Federal
National Mortgage Association Lender Letter LL-2023-01 and
Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation Bulletin 2023-1.
(5) Risk-based pricing.--The term ``risk-based pricing''
means the calibration of fees based on the expected credit
losses to an enterprise of each single-family mortgage category
as defined by an enterprise based on the credit score and loan-
to-value ratio characteristics of a mortgage.
(6) Standard single-family pricing framework.--The term
``standard single-family pricing framework'' means the loan-
level pricing adjustment fee structure in effect on April 30,
2023.
Background and Need for Legislation
In January 2023, FHFA announced a set of mandated changes
to the LLPA pricing grid for the housing Government Sponsored
Enterprises (GSEs), Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, affecting the
vast majority of single-family purchase and rate-term refinance
loans sold to the GSEs. These changes altered the structure of
the LLPAs, which are one-time upfront fees charged to lenders
when the GSEs purchase their loans. LLPAs get passed on from
lenders to borrowers in the form of higher interest rates.
FHFA's changes increased fees for many higher credit quality
borrowers (half of all borrowers with FICO scores over 680)
while simultaneously decreasing fees for 90 percent of lower
credit quality borrowers (those with FICO scores under 680),
regardless of how much of a down payment they made.
Despite strong opposition to FHFA's action--including a
joint letter on April 25, 2023, by Chairman McHenry and Housing
Subcommittee Chair Davidson urging FHFA to reverse its
decision--the new LLPA changes took effect on May 1. On May 17,
the Housing and Insurance Subcommittee held a hearing on the
issue where it heard testimony that the new LLPA grids are
flawed, there exists much confusion over the process FHFA uses
to price credit risk, and the new pricing means high risk
borrowers gain while low risk borrowers lose. At the hearing,
all four bipartisan witnesses agreed that increasing fairness,
oversight, and accountability in FHFA's pricing process were
important goals. This is what H.R. 3564 is designed to
accomplish.
Hearing
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing
examining matters relating to H.R. 3564 on May 23, 2023, titled
``FHFA Oversight: Protecting Homeowners and Taxpayers.''
The Subcommittee on Housing and Insurance of the Committee
on Financial Services held a hearing examining matters relating
to H.R. 3564 on May 17, 2023, titled ``The Current Mortgage
Market: Undermining Housing Affordability with Politics.''
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires the Committee to list the record votes
on the order to report legislation and amendments thereto. H.R.
3564 was ordered reported favorably to the House as amended by
a recorded vote of 26 ayes to 22 nays (Record vote no. FC-66),
a quorum being present.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Committee Oversight Findings
Pursuant to clause 3(c) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the findings and recommendations of
the Committee, based on oversight activities under clause
2(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives,
are incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
Performance Goals and Objectives
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the goal of H.R. 3564 is to repeal
the recently enacted LLPA fee increases and reinstate the LLPA
fee structure in effect prior to May 1, 2023.
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures
In compliance with clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives, the Committee adopts as its
own the estimate of new budget authority, entitlement
authority, or tax expenditures or revenues contained in the
cost estimate prepared by the Director of the Congressional
Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the Congressional
Budget Act of 1973.
Congressional Budget Office Estimates
Pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section
402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974.
Federal Mandates Statement
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of the Federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Earmark Identification
With respect to clause 9 of rule XXI of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee has carefully reviewed
the provisions of the bill and states that the provisions of
the bill do not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits within the meaning of the
rule.
Duplication of Federal Programs
In compliance with clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives, the Committee states that no
provision of the bill establishes or reauthorizes a program of
the Federal Government known to be duplicative of another
Federal program, including any program that was included in a
report to Congress pursuant to section 21 of the Public Law
111-139 or the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance.
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation
Section 1. Establishes the short title of the bill as the
``Middle Class Borrower Protection Act of 2023.''
Section 2. Requires the Director of FHFA to reinstate the
LLPA fee structure in effect immediately prior to May 1, 2023,
within 6 days of enactment.
Section 3. Establishes a series of restrictions on FHFA's
ability to make adjustments to the LLPA fee structure. Creates
a new temporary prohibition on FHFA making further adjustments
to the LLPA fee structure until 90 days after the submission of
an independent Government Accountability Office (GAO) review of
FHFA's LLPA fee setting process. Requires that any future
adjustments to the LLPA fee structure be carried out as close
as practicable to the requirements for federal agencies under
the Administrative Procedure Act. Amends Section 1367(b)(2) of
the Federal Housing Enterprises Financial Safety and Soundness
Act of 1992 to require that any future adjustments to the LLPA
fee structure made by FHFA, when acting as conservator for a
GSE, shall be based on the risk posed by the mortgage loan to
that GSE.
Section 4. Prohibits FHFA or the GSEs from imposing any
LLPA fee based on the DTI ratio of a borrower.
Section 5. Requires GAO to conduct a study of FHFA's
adjustments to the LLPA fee structure, and report its findings
to Congress within 14 months of enactment, regarding the
following: the methodology, policy considerations, and any
other objectives used by FHFA to support the changes; how the
changes interact with the GSEs' new regulatory capital rule;
the economic impact of the changes on lenders and borrowers;
the extent to which the changes adhere to or deviate from the
principle of risk-based pricing; and if changes represent any
increased risks to the safety and soundness of the GSEs.
Section 6. Establishes the definitions used within the Act.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown below, as prepared by the
Office of Legislative Counsel.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (new matter is
printed in italics and existing law in which no change is
proposed is shown in roman):
FEDERAL HOUSING ENTERPRISES FINANCIAL SAFETY AND SOUNDNESS ACT OF 1992
* * * * * * *
TITLE XIII--GOVERNMENT SPONSORED ENTERPRISES
* * * * * * *
Subtitle B--Required Capital Levels for Regulated Entities, Special
Enforcement Powers, and Reviews of Assets and Liabilities
* * * * * * *
SEC. 1367. AUTHORITY OVER CRITICALLY UNDERCAPITALIZED REGULATED
ENTITIES.
(a) Appointment of the Agency as Conservator or Receiver.--
(1) In general.--Notwithstanding any other provision
of Federal or State law, the Director may appoint the
Agency as conservator or receiver for a regulated
entity in the manner provided under paragraph (2) or
(4). All references to the conservator or receiver
under this section are references to the Agency acting
as conservator or receiver.
(2) Discretionary appointment.--The Agency may, at
the discretion of the Director, be appointed
conservator or receiver for the purpose of
reorganizing, rehabilitating, or winding up the affairs
of a regulated entity.
(3) Grounds for discretionary appointment of
conservator or receiver.--The grounds for appointing
conservator or receiver for any regulated entity under
paragraph (2) are as follows:
(A) Assets insufficient for obligations.--The
assets of the regulated entity are less than
the obligations of the regulated entity to its
creditors and others.
(B) Substantial dissipation.--Substantial
dissipation of assets or earnings due to--
(i) any violation of any provision of
Federal or State law; or
(ii) any unsafe or unsound practice.
(C) Unsafe or unsound condition.--An unsafe
or unsound condition to transact business.
(D) Cease and desist orders.--Any willful
violation of a cease and desist order that has
become final.
(E) Concealment.--Any concealment of the
books, papers, records, or assets of the
regulated entity, or any refusal to submit the
books, papers, records, or affairs of the
regulated entity, for inspection to any
examiner or to any lawful agent of the
Director.
(F) Inability to meet obligations.--The
regulated entity is likely to be unable to pay
its obligations or meet the demands of its
creditors in the normal course of business.
(G) Losses.--The regulated entity has
incurred or is likely to incur losses that will
deplete all or substantially all of its
capital, and there is no reasonable prospect
for the regulated entity to become adequately
capitalized (as defined in section 1364(a)(1)).
(H) Violations of law.--Any violation of any
law or regulation, or any unsafe or unsound
practice or condition that is likely to--
(i) cause insolvency or substantial
dissipation of assets or earnings; or
(ii) weaken the condition of the
regulated entity.
(I) Consent.--The regulated entity, by
resolution of its board of directors or its
shareholders or members, consents to the
appointment.
(J) Undercapitalization.--The regulated
entity is undercapitalized or significantly
undercapitalized (as defined in section
1364(a)(3)), and--
(i) has no reasonable prospect of
becoming adequately capitalized;
(ii) fails to become adequately
capitalized, as required by--
(I) section 1365(a)(1) with
respect to a regulated entity;
or
(II) section 1366(a)(1) with
respect to a significantly
undercapitalized regulated
entity;
(iii) fails to submit a capital
restoration plan acceptable to the
Agency within the time prescribed under
section 1369C; or
(iv) materially fails to implement a
capital restoration plan submitted and
accepted under section 1369C.
(K) Critical undercapitalization.--The
regulated entity is critically
undercapitalized, as defined in section
1364(a)(4).
(L) Money laundering.--The Attorney General
notifies the Director in writing that the
regulated entity has been found guilty of a
criminal offense under section 1956 or 1957 of
title 18, United States Code, or section 5322
or 5324 of title 31, United States Code.
(4) Mandatory receivership.--
(A) In general.--The Director shall appoint
the Agency as receiver for a regulated entity
if the Director determines, in writing, that--
(i) the assets of the regulated
entity are, and during the preceding 60
calendar days have been, less than the
obligations of the regulated entity to
its creditors and others; or
(ii) the regulated entity is not, and
during the preceding 60 calendar days
has not been, generally paying the
debts of the regulated entity (other
than debts that are the subject of a
bona fide dispute) as such debts become
due.
(B) Periodic determination required for
critically undercapitalized regulated entity.--
If a regulated entity is critically
undercapitalized, the Director shall make a
determination, in writing, as to whether the
regulated entity meets the criteria specified
in clause (i) or (ii) of subparagraph (A)--
(i) not later than 30 calendar days
after the regulated entity initially
becomes critically undercapitalized;
and
(ii) at least once during each
succeeding 30-calendar day period.
(C) Determination not required if
receivership already in place.--Subparagraph
(B) does not apply with respect to a regulated
entity in any period during which the Agency
serves as receiver for the regulated entity.
(D) Receivership terminates
conservatorship.--The appointment of the Agency
as receiver of a regulated entity under this
section shall immediately terminate any
conservatorship established for the regulated
entity under this title.
(5) Judicial review.--
(A) In general.--If the Agency is appointed
conservator or receiver under this section, the
regulated entity may, within 30 days of such
appointment, bring an action in the United
States district court for the judicial district
in which the home office of such regulated
entity is located, or in the United States
District Court for the District of Columbia,
for an order requiring the Agency to remove
itself as conservator or receiver.
(B) Review.--Upon the filing of an action
under subparagraph (A), the court shall, upon
the merits, dismiss such action or direct the
Agency to remove itself as such conservator or
receiver.
(6) Directors not liable for acquiescing in
appointment of conservator or receiver.--The members of
the board of directors of a regulated entity shall not
be liable to the shareholders or creditors of the
regulated entity for acquiescing in or consenting in
good faith to the appointment of the Agency as
conservator or receiver for that regulated entity.
(7) Agency not subject to any other federal agency.--
When acting as conservator or receiver, the Agency
shall not be subject to the direction or supervision of
any other agency of the United States or any State in
the exercise of the rights, powers, and privileges of
the Agency.
(b) Powers and Duties of the Agency as Conservator or
Receiver.--
(1) Rulemaking authority of the agency.--The Agency
may prescribe such regulations as the Agency determines
to be appropriate regarding the conduct of
conservatorships or receiverships.
(2) General powers.--
(A) Successor to regulated entity.--The
Agency shall, as conservator or receiver, and
by operation of law, immediately succeed to--
(i) all rights, titles, powers, and
privileges of the regulated entity, and
of any stockholder, officer, or
director of such regulated entity with
respect to the regulated entity and the
assets of the regulated entity; and
(ii) title to the books, records, and
assets of any other legal custodian of
such regulated entity.
(B) Operate the regulated entity.--The Agency
may, as conservator or receiver--
(i) take over the assets of and
operate the regulated entity with all
the powers of the shareholders, the
directors, and the officers of the
regulated entity and conduct all
business of the regulated entity;
(ii) collect all obligations and
money due the regulated entity;
(iii) perform all functions of the
regulated entity in the name of the
regulated entity which are consistent
with the appointment as conservator or
receiver;
(iv) preserve and conserve the assets
and property of the regulated entity;
and
(v) provide by contract for
assistance in fulfilling any function,
activity, action, or duty of the Agency
as conservator or receiver.
(C) Functions of officers, directors, and
shareholders of a regulated entity.--The Agency
may, by regulation or order, provide for the
exercise of any function by any stockholder,
director, or officer of any regulated entity
for which the Agency has been named conservator
or receiver.
(D) Powers as conservator.--The Agency may,
as conservator, take such action as may be--
(i) necessary to put the regulated
entity in a sound and solvent
condition; and
(ii) appropriate to carry on the
business of the regulated entity and
preserve and conserve the assets and
property of the regulated entity.
(E) Additional powers as receiver.--In any
case in which the Agency is acting as receiver,
the Agency shall place the regulated entity in
liquidation and proceed to realize upon the
assets of the regulated entity in such manner
as the Agency deems appropriate, including
through the sale of assets, the transfer of
assets to a limited-life regulated entity
established under subsection (i), or the
exercise of any other rights or privileges
granted to the Agency under this paragraph.
(F) Organization of new enterprise.--The
Agency may, as receiver for an enterprise,
organize a successor enterprise that will
operate pursuant to subsection (i).
(G) Transfer or sale of assets and
liabilities.--The Agency may, as conservator or
receiver, transfer or sell any asset or
Minority Views
This bill would make homeownership more expensive for
middle class borrowers by canceling recent changes made by the
Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) to loan level price
adjustments (LLPAs) charged by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac
(collectively, ``the Enterprises'') for the guarantee of
single-family mortgages beginning May 1, 2023, and
reinstituting the 2008 LLPA pricing framework. This bill would
also require the Government Accountability Office (GAO) to
submit a report to Congress on the latest pricing framework,
and temporarily prohibit the FHFA from making any further
pricing changes until it initiates a rule-making process to
institute such changes. The bill further prohibits the FHFA
from setting LLPAs based on debt-to-income ratios.
Established in 2008, following the mortgage crisis, the
LLPA pricing grid was intended to help the Enterprises raise
more capital. LLPAs are charged to lenders by the Enterprises
for each loan that they purchase, and are passed on to
borrowers as part of the cost of originating Enterprise-backed
mortgages. These fees are charged based on the loan type and
characteristics of a borrower's credit profile, such as loan to
value ratios (based on down payment amount). The 2008 pricing
grid resulted in lower wealth and lower income homebuyers being
charged more for a mortgage than wealthier, higher income
borrowers with similar credit profiles. Effective May 1, 2023,
the FHFA's changes to the LLPAs, in part, ensure that borrowers
with lower wealth or income are not charged more that higher
wealth and income individuals who are otherwise similarly
situated. The reductions in fees for these individuals are
offset by slightly higher fees on loans for second homes,
investment properties, and cash out refinance transactions. The
recent changes to the LLPAs also overall continue to help the
Enterprises build capital as they adhere to increased capital
requirements that became effective in 2022. On May 10th, FHFA
eliminated proposed debt-to-income (DTI) LLPAs from its pricing
framework, which never took effect, and on May 15th , FHFA
announced that it is requesting public input on the entirety of
its single-family pricing framework and overall guarantee fees.
If passed, this bill would: (1) revert back to an unfair
mortgage pricing scheme that charges middle class borrowers
with lower wealth, especially first-time homebuyers and rural
homebuyers, higher fees compared to wealthier homebuyers,
especially those purchasing vacation homes or investment
properties; (2) result in operational challenges for the
Enterprises and lenders as they attempt to revert back to the
2008 pricing grid, as this bill would require, and undo legal
contracts; and (3) prevent FHFA and the Enterprises from
appropriately pricing for credit risk and compromise the safety
and soundness of the housing finance market by subjecting
market-shifting pricing decisions that require swift
implementation to lengthy rulemaking processes. The setting of
guarantee fees, much like the setting of interest rates, is
market sensitive and exposing that process to notice and
comment could lead to market manipulation. Additionally, this
bill could create political uncertainty regarding the pricing
of Enterprise securities and diminish the trust of global
markets in those securities, resulting in increased costs to
the middle-class borrowers this bill purports to help.
For these reasons, the minority opposes H.R. 3654.
Sincerely,
Maxine Waters,
Ranking Member, Committee on
Financial Services.
Nydia M. Velazquez.
Juan Vargas.
Ritchie Torres.
Nikema Williams.
Al Green,
Ranking Member, Subcommittee
on Oversight and
Investigations.
Rashida Tlaib.
Silvia R. Garcia.
Brittany Pettersen.
[all]