Committee Action
109TH CONGRESS
Legislative Action
On February 2, 2005, Rep. Sam Johnson (R-TX), then-Chairman
of the Employer-Employee Relations Subcommittee of the
Committee on Education and the Workforce (Committee),
introduced the Small Business Health Fairness Act (H.R. 525),
along with 53 bipartisan original cosponsors, including then-
Chairman of the Committee, John Boehner (R-OH), and Reps. Nydia
Velazquez (D-NY) and Albert Wynn (D-MD).
On March 16, 2005, the Committee ordered H.R. 525, without
amendment, favorably reported to the House of Representatives
by a vote of 25 to 22. On April 13, 2005, the Committee filed
its committee report, which detailed the history of the need
for the legislation and prior committee action.\1\ On July 26,
2015, H.R. 525 passed the full House by a vote of 263 to 165.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\H.R. Rep. No. 109-41 (2005).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
111TH CONGRESS
Legislative Action
Between July 15-17, 2009, the Committee met to mark up H.R.
3200, the America's Affordable Health Choices Act of 2009.\2\
During the markup, Rep. Howard P. ``Buck'' McKeon (R-CA)
offered an amendment to create a new title at the end of
Division A of H.R. 3200, titled Title IV--Small Business Health
Fairness. The amendment included rules governing AHPs, the
treatment of single-employer arrangements, enforcement
provisions, and other provisions related to AHPs. The amendment
was defeated by a vote of 21 to 27.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\H.R. 3200 was the House precursor to the law known as the
Affordable Care Act.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On November 7, 2009, the House passed H.R. 3962, the
Affordable Health Care for America Act. During the debate,
former Speaker John Boehner (R-OH) included the AHP legislative
text in the Republican motion to recommit.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\H. Amend. 510 to H.R. 3962, 111th Cong. (2009).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On March 21, 2010, the House passed the Patient Protection
and Affordable Care Act by a vote of 219 to 212 to resolve
differences with the Senate. The bill was signed by President
Obama on March 23, 2010.\4\ On March 25, 2010, the House passed
the Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010 by a
vote of 220 to 207 to resolve differences with the Senate. This
bill was signed into law by President Obama on March 30,
2010.\5\ Collectively, the two bills are known as the
Affordable Care Act (ACA or Obamacare).\6\ The ACA did not
include AHP legislative text.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, Pub. L. No. 111-148
(2010).
\5\Health and Education Reconciliation Act, Pub. L. No. 111-152
(2010).
\6\Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, Pub. L. No. 111-148
(2010), and Health and Education Reconciliation Act, Pub. L. No. 111-
152 (2010).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
112TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On February 9, 2011, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``The Impact of the Health Care Law on the Economy, Employers,
and the Workforce.'' This was the Committee's first hearing to
investigate Obamacare and hear directly from job creators about
how the 2010 law affects their ability to expand their business
and hire new workers. The hearing also examined AHPs. The
witnesses were Dr. Paul Howard, Senior Fellow, Manhattan
Institute, New York, New York; Ms. Gail Johnson, President and
CEO, Rainbow Station, Inc., Glenn Allen, Virginia; Dr. Paul Van
de Water, Senior Fellow, Center on Budget and Policy
Priorities, Washington, D.C.; and Mr. Neil Trautwein, Vice
President and Employee Benefits Policy Counsel, National Retail
Federation, Washington, D.C.
115TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On February 1, 2017, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``Rescuing Americans from the Failed Health Care Law and
Advancing Patient-Centered Solutions,'' which examined failures
of the ACA and also examined association health plans.
Witnesses were Mr. Scott Bollenbacher, CPA, Managing Partner,
Bollenbacher and Associates, LLC, Portland, Indiana; Mr. Joe
Eddy, President and Chief Executive Officer, Eagle
Manufacturing Company, Wellsburg, West Virginia; Ms. Angela
Schlaack, St. Joseph, Michigan; and Dr. Tevi Troy, Chief
Executive Officer, American Health Policy Institute,
Washington, D.C.
On February 1, 2017, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``Rescuing Americans from the Failed Health Care Law and
Advancing Patient-Centered Solutions,'' which examined failures
of the ACA and also examined association health plans.
Witnesses were Mr. Scott Bollenbacher, CPA, Managing Partner,
Bollenbacher and Associates, LLC, Portland, Indiana; Mr. Joe
Eddy, President and Chief Executive Officer, Eagle
Manufacturing Company, Wellsburg, West Virginia; Ms. Angela
Schlaack, St. Joseph, Michigan; and Dr. Tevi Troy, Chief
Executive Officer, American Health Policy Institute,
Washington, D.C.
On March 1, 2017, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``Legislative Proposals to Improve Health Care Coverage and
Provide Lower Costs for Families,'' which examined the Small
Business Health Fairness Act of 2017 (H.R. 1101), among other
proposals. H.R. 1101 provides a legislative solution for
association health plans. Witnesses were Mr. Jon B. Hurst,
President, Retailers Association of Massachusetts, Boston,
Massachusetts; Ms. Allison R. Klausner, J.D., Principal,
Government Relations Leader, Conduent, Secaucus, New Jersey;
Ms. Lydia Mitts, Associate Director of Affordability
Initiatives, Families USA, Washington, D.C.; and Mr. Jay
Ritchie, Executive Vice President, Tokio Marine HHC, Kennesaw,
Georgia.
Legislative Action
On February 16, 2017, Rep. Sam Johnson (R-TX) introduced
the Small Business Health Fairness Act of 2017 (H.R. 1101)
along with then-Subcommittee on Health, Employment, Labor, and
Pensions (HELP) Chairman Tim Walberg (R-MI).\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\H.R. 1101, 115th Cong. (2017).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On March 8, 2017, the Committee considered H.R. 1101, the
Small Business Health Fairness Act of 2017.\8\ Then-HELP
Subcommittee Chairman Walberg offered an amendment in the
nature of a substitute, making technical changes to the
introduced bill. The Committee voted to adopt the amendment in
the nature of a substitute by voice vote. Rep. Susan Davis (D-
CA) offered an amendment to prevent the bill from taking effect
under certain circumstances. The amendment failed by a vote of
17 to 22. The Committee favorably reported H.R. 1101, as
amended, to the House of Representatives by a vote of 22 to 17.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\H.R. 1101, Small Business Health Fairness Act of 2017: Markup
Before the H. Comm. on Educ. & the Workforce, 115th Cong. (Mar. 8,
2017).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On March 22, 2017, the House passed H.R. 1101, the Small
Business Health Fairness Act of 2017 by a vote of 236-175.
Second Session--Hearing
On March 16, 2018, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``Expanding Affordable Health Care Options: Examining
the Department of Labor's Proposed Rule on Association Health
Plans,'' which examined the U.S. Department of Labor's (DOL)
recent proposed rule on AHPs as an alternative to Obamacare.
Witnesses were Mr. Christopher Condeluci, Principal and Sole
Shareholder, CC Law and Policy PLLC, Washington, D.C.; Mr.
Michael McGrew, CEO McGrew Real Estate, Lawrence, Kansas; Ms.
Catherine Monson, CEO and President, FASTSIGNS International,
Inc., Carrollton, Texas; and Mr. John Arensmeyer, Founder and
CEO, Small Business Majority, Washington, D.C.
117TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On June 9, 2021, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``Examining the Policies and Priorities of the U.S. Department
of Labor,'' during which the Secretary of Labor was questioned
about the Department's Fiscal Year 2022 budget priorities. The
Committee also examined the Department's views on the Trump
administration's rule to expand AHPs. The sole witness was the
Honorable Martin J. Walsh, Secretary of DOL, Washington, D.C.
Second Session--Hearing
On February 17, 2022, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``Exploring Pathways to Affordable, Universal Health
Coverage,'' which examined, among other things, the benefits of
expanding AHPs. The witnesses were Dr. Brian Blase, President,
Paragon Health Institute, Ponte Verde, Florida; Dr. Georges C.
Benjamin, Executive Director, the American Public Health
Association, Washington, D.C.; Ms. Katie Keith, Center on
Health Insurance Reforms, Georgetown University, Washington,
D.C.; and Mr. Robert B. Reich, Carmel P. Friesen Professor of
Public Policy, Goldman School of Public Policy, University of
California, Berkley, California.
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On April 26, 2023, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``Reducing Health Care Costs for Working Americans and
Their Families,'' which examined H.R. 2868, the Association
Health Plans Act, among other proposals, and also examined the
continuing negative impact of the ACA on employer-sponsored
health coverage and on lowering costs by expanding AHPs.
Witnesses were Mr. Joel White, President, Council for
Affordable Health Coverage (CAHC), Washington, D.C.; Mrs. Tracy
Watts, Senior Partner, Mercer, Washington, D.C.; Marcie
Strouse, Partner, Capitol Benefits Group, Des Moines, Iowa; and
Ms. Sabrina Corlette, J.D., Senior Research Professor, Center
on Health Insurance Reforms, Georgetown University's Health
Policy Institute, Washington, D.C.
Legislative Action
On April 25, 2023, Rep. Walberg introduced the Association
Health Plans Act (H.R. 2868) with Chairwoman Foxx, HELP
Subcommittee Chairman Bob Good (R-VA), Rep. Rick Allen (R-GA),
Rep. Dan Crenshaw (R-TX), and Rep. Michael Burgess (R-TX) as
original cosponsors. The bill was referred solely to the
Committee on Education and the Workforce. On June 6, 2023, the
Committee considered H.R. 2868, the Association Health Plans
Act in legislative session and reported it favorably, as
amended, to the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of
23-18. The Committee adopted the following amendment to H.R.
2868: Rep. Walberg offered an Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute (ANS) clarifying that an organization has to be
actively in existence for two years prior to the establishment
of an AHP in order for the AHP to qualify as a group health
plan under H.R. 2868. In Section 3, the ANS also strikes
``employee welfare benefit plan'' and inserts ``group health
plan'' to clarify that premium rates are for health care only.
Committee Views
INTRODUCTION
Background on employer-sponsored insurance coverage
Since World War II, employers have offered health care
benefits to recruit and retain talent and to ensure a healthy
and productive workforce. Employer-sponsored health insurance
covers almost 159 million American workers and family
members.\9\ According to the U.S. Census Bureau, 54.3 percent
of Americans were covered by employment-based health coverage
in 2021.\10\ When given the option for employment-based health
coverage, 77 percent of workers take up coverage.\11\ Almost
all businesses with at least 200 or more employees offer health
benefits.\12\ According to the Kaiser Family Foundation,
however, smaller firms (with 3 to 199 employees) are
significantly less likely to offer health benefits.\13\ As a
result, in 2022, just over half of all employers offered some
health benefits.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Kaiser Family Found., Employer Health Benefits: 2022 Annual
Survey, 2022 Employer Health Benefits Survey 58, http://files.kff.org/
attachment/Report-Employer-Health-Benefits-2022-Annual-Survey.pdf.
\10\U.S. Census Bur., U.S. Dep't of Com., Health Insurance Coverage
in the United States: 2021, http://census.gov/content/dam/Census/
library/publications/2022/demo/p60-278.pdf.
\11\Kaiser Family Found., supra note 9, at 12.
\12\Id.
\13\Id.
\14\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Employer-provided health benefits are regulated by a number
of laws, including ERISA as amended by the ACA. DOL implements
and enforces ERISA. By virtue of its jurisdiction over ERISA,
the Committee has jurisdiction over employer-provided health
coverage.
Small and large employers offer health care coverage to
employees in self-funded arrangements (self-insurance) or
purchase fully insured plans. ERISA regulates both fully
insured and self-insured plans, but only self-insured plans are
exempt from a patchwork of benefit mandates imposed under state
insurance law. Employers sponsoring self-insured plans are not
subject to the same requirements under the ACA as those with
fully insured plans. Therefore, employer-provided plans have
different requirements and costs depending on funding
arrangements. Last year, approximately 65 percent of workers
with employer-sponsored health coverage were enrolled in a
self-funded plan, up from 44 percent in 1999 and 55 percent in
2007.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Id. at 157.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Obamacare has failed, proving the need for a better way of providing
access to affordable, quality health care
The ACA attempted to expand access to health insurance
through a complicated structure of federal subsidies, Medicaid
expansion, and new rules governing health insurance markets.
The law has severely damaged America's health care system and
is collapsing under its own weight. For example, President
Obama famously promised the ACA would ``lower premiums by up to
$2,500 for a typical family per year,'' yet the evidence
suggests otherwise.\16\ Additionally, small businesses and
their employees have been ``hurt badly by the cost increases
caused by the ACA.''\17\ Small businesses continue to struggle
with the cost of health care coverage, with adverse impacts to
growth, hiring, and workforce pay.\18\ In June 2022, Kaiser
Family Foundation reported that individual health care debt is
a significant problem in the United States. The same study
reports that half of adults find it difficult to afford health
care and that cost is often a barrier to obtaining needed
health care or filling prescriptions. \19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\Jess Henig & Lori Robertson, Obama's Inflated Health `Savings',
FactCheck.org, Jun. 16, 2008, http://www.factcheck.org/2008/06/obamas-
inflated-health-savings/.
\17\Rescuing Americans from the Failed Health Care Law and
Advancing Patient-Centered Solutions: Hearing Before the H. Comm. on
Educ. & the Workforce, 115th Cong. 42 (2017) (statement of Scott
Bollenbacher, Managing Partner, Bollenbacher & Assoc., LLC).
\18\Small Bus. for Am. Future, Survey: Health Care Costs Putting
Financial Pressure on Small Business (Oct. 2022), http://irp.cdn-
website.com/b4559992/files/uploaded/
SBAF%20National%20_health_care%20Survey%20Oct.%202022.pdf (reporting
survey results of 1,209 small business owners finding that, to offset
rising health care costs, nearly half increased prices of goods or
services, 38 percent delayed growth opportunities, and 28 percent
slowed hiring).
\19\Alex Montero et al., Kaiser Family Found., Americans'
Challenges with Health Care Costs (July 14, 2022), https://www.kff.org/
health-costs/issue-brief/americans-challenges-with-health-care-costs/
(reporting that 41 percent of adults have medical or dental care debt
owed to credit cards, collections agencies, families and friends,
banks, and other lenders).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The ACA placed additional mandates and administrative
burdens on employers, increasing the cost of insurance coverage
and making it more difficult to hire workers and grow their
businesses. According to a study by the American Action Forum,
ACA regulations have a significant negative impact on the labor
market. The study concluded that roughly 300,000 small business
jobs were lost, and 10,000 small businesses closed as a result
of ACA's costs and regulations.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\Ben Gitis & Sam Batkins, Update: Obamacare's Impact on Small
Business Wages and Employment, Am. Action Forum (2017), https://
americanactionforum.org/research/update-obamacares-impact-small-
business-wages-employment/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the aftermath of ACA, approximately 36 percent of small
businesses with fewer than 10 employees stopped offering
coverage, leaving workers with even fewer health care
options.\21\ In 2021, the offer rate for businesses with fewer
than 50 employees had dropped to 31.9 percent, compared with 39
percent in 2010 when ACA passed.\22\ Due to their size and
economies of scale, large businesses and labor organizations
have the ability to negotiate on behalf of their employees for
high-quality health care at more affordable costs. By offering
a qualified group health plan under ERISA, these large
employers and labor organizations are also exempt from myriad
state rules and regulations on health insurance. Small
businesses, however, do not have the same bargaining power as
larger businesses and are unable to band together to increase
their bargaining power in the health insurance marketplace.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Paul Fronstin, EBRI Educ. & Research Fund, Fewer Small
Employers Offering Health Coverage; Large Employers Holding Steady
(2016) (Jul. 2016), http://ebri.org/content/fewer-small-employers-
offering-health-coverage-large-employers-holding-steady-3367 (studying
the impact of the ACA on employer health insurance offer rates).
\22\Agency for Healthcare & Quality, Ctr. for Financing, Access and
Cost Trends 2021 Medical Expenditure Panel Survey-Insurance Component,
Table 1.A.2. (2021), http://meps.ahrq.gov/data_stats/summ_tables/insr/
state/series_2/2021/ic21_iia_f_pdf; Agency for Healthcare & Quality,
Ctr. for Financing, Access and Costs Trends 2010 Medical Expenditure
Panel Survey--Insurance Component, Table I.A.2 (2010), http://
meps.ahrq.gov/data_stats/summ_tables/insr/state/series_2/2010/
9c10_iaa_f.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
According to a survey released by the National Federation
of Independent Business (NFIB) in March of 2023, 65 percent of
small business employers that do not currently offer coverage
cite the cost of health insurance cove
Minority Views
Introduction
Committee Democrats oppose H.R. 2868, the Association
Health Plans Act. This misguided legislation would put
comprehensive and affordable coverage for small businesses and
workers at risk, create loopholes that undermine critical
consumer protections, and raise costs across the broader health
insurance market.
Before the Affordable Care Act (ACA),\1\ workers often had
limited options for obtaining affordable health coverage.\2\
People with preexisting conditions were particularly
disadvantaged, because they could be charged higher rates or
denied coverage altogether in the individual market. Small
businesses employing women or workers with chronic or high-cost
illnesses could be charged higher premiums, often making
coverage unaffordable. Those who could afford to buy coverage
in the individual and small group market often found their
insurance did not cover vital services, such as behavioral
health or maternity care.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Pub. L. No. 111-148 (2010).
\2\Sara R. Collins et al., How the Affordable Care Act Has Improved
Americans' Ability to Buy Health Insurance on Their Own, Commonwealth
Fund (Feb. 1, 2017), https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/
issue-briefs/2017/feb/how-affordable-care-act-has-improved-americans-
ability-buy.
\3\Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, Essential Health
Benefits Under Threat, https://www.cbpp.org/essential-health-benefits-
under-threat (last visited June 8, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The ACA took steps to level the playing field--establishing
safeguards for workers and employers alike. The ACA created
Marketplaces where individuals, self-employed people, and
families can access affordable health coverage, and the law has
also protected workers and businesses in the small group market
from unfair practices.\4\ Consumers have benefited from these
protections for over a decade despite dozens of attempts to
undermine this progress through Republican votes to repeal the
ACA in Congress\5\ and ideologically-driven litigation--most
recently through a lawsuit attacking coverage for lifesaving
preventive health services such as lung cancer screenings,
preexposure prophylaxis for HIV prevention, and medications to
lower the risk of breast cancer for high-risk women.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Nicole Rapfogel et al., 10 Ways the ACA Has Improved Health Care
in the Past Decade, Center for American Progress (Mar. 23, 2020),
https://www.americanprogress.org/article/10-ways-aca-improved-health-
care-past-decade/.
\5\Chris Riotta, GOP Aims To Kill Bazaar Yet Again After Failing 70
Times, Newsweek (July 29, 2017), http://www/gop-health-care-bill-
repeal-and-replace-70-failed-attempts-643832.
\6\Laurie Sob el et al., Explaining Litigation Challenging the
ACA's Preventive Services Requirements: Braid wood Management Inc. v.
Becker, Kaiser Family Foundation (May 15, 2023), http://www/omens-
health-policy/issue-brief/explaining-litigation-challenging-the-acas-
preventive-services-requirements-braidwood-management/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to instituting crucial consumer protections,
the ACA has led to historic improvements in the number of
people with health coverage. In 2022, the uninsured rate fell
to 8 percent--the lowest level in history.\7\ During the 117th
Congress, Democrats took bold action to build upon this
progress and further improve affordability. The American Rescue
Plan Act (ARPA)\8\ and the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA)\9\
strengthened the advance premium tax credits and eliminated the
subsidy ``cliff'' for individuals earning over 400 percent of
the Federal Poverty Level through 2025. Thanks to these
reforms, during the most recent Open Enrollment Period, a
record 16.3 million people signed up for coverage through
Healthcare and State-Based Marketplaces, and the average
consumer saved $800 per year in premiums.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Aiden Lee et al., National Uninsured Rate Reaches All-Time Low
in Early 2022, Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation, U.S.
Dept. of Health and Human Services (Aug. 2022), http://ape/sites/
default/files/documents/15c1f9899b3f203887deba90e3005f5a/Uninsured-Q1-
2022-Data-Point-HP 2022 23 08.pdf.
\8\Pub. L. No. 117-2 (2021).
\9\Pub. L. No. 117-169 (2022).
\10\Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Biden-Harris
Administration Announces Record-Breaking 16.3 Million People Signed Up
for Health Care Coverage in ACA Marketplaces During 2022-2023 Open
Enrollment Season (Jan. 25, 2023), http://www/about/news/2023/01/25/
maidenhair-breaking-16-3-million-people-signed-up-health-care-coverage-
aca-marketplaces-during-2022 2023-open-enrollment-season.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While health care costs for many workers and businesses
remain a challenge, association health plans (Apes) are not the
answer. Apes are arrangements sponsored by small employer
groups or individuals to provide health insurance to their
members outside the traditional small group and individual
market. Expanding these arrangements, as proposed under H.R.
2868, threatens to harm workers and small businesses by making
coverage more expensive for many and entirely out of reach for
some. In the April 26, 2023, hearing held by the Subcommittee
on Health, Employment, Labor, and Pensions titled Reducing
Health Care Costs for Working Americans and Their Families,
Sabrina Corvette, Research Professor and Co-Director of the
Center on Health Insurance Reforms at Georgetown University's
McCourt School of Public Policy, warned of the consequences of
AHPs, stating that ``AHPs just create new winners and losers,
with the losers being those who are older and sicker.''\11\
This is why more than 30 leading consumer and patient groups
have expressed serious concerns with H.R. 2868\12\ and why
Committee Democrats unanimously reject this harmful
legislation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Reducing Health Care Costs for Working Americans and Their
Families: Hearing Before the Subcomm. on Health, Empl., Lab., and
Pensions of the H. Comm. On Educ. & the Workforce, 118th Cong. 10
(2023) (testimony of Sabrina Corlette, Research Professor and Co-
Director, Center on Health Insurance Reforms at the Georgetown
University McCourt School of Public Policy).
\12\Patient community concerns about the detrimental impact of
policies included in HR 2868, the Association Health Plans Act; HR 824,
the Telehealth Benefit Expansion for Workers Act; and HR 2813, the
Self-Insurance Protection Act, Letter to Chair Virginia Foxx and
Ranking Member Bobby Scott, H. Comm. on Educ. & the Workforce, Full
Committee Markup (June 6, 2023) (on file with author).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 2868 Recycles Failed Republican Policies
Under current law, coverage offered through a group or
association to individuals or small employers must generally
comply with the patient protections of the ACA and state
insurance law.\13\ However, Republicans have long sought
legislative and regulatory changes that eliminate guardrails
that protect consumers, portraying such proposals as extending
affordable health insurance options to small businesses. By
radically expanding the circumstances in which AHPs can provide
coverage to small employers and individuals without complying
with critical safeguards, H.R. 2868 recycles this harmful idea.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\29 U.S.C. Sec. 1144(b)(6); Centers for Medicare and Medicaid
Services, Application of Individual and Group Market Requirements under
Title XXVII of the Public Health Service Act when Insurance Coverage Is
Sold to, or through, Associations (Sept. 1, 2011), https://www.cms.gov/
CCIIO/Resources/Files/Downloads/association_9coverage_9_1_2011.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Expansion of AHPs has been central to the Republican health
care agenda for decades, most recently in Republican attempts
to repeal the ACA.\14\ In 2017, the Committee marked up H.R.
1101, the Small Business Health Fairness Act, which would have
expanded AHPs in a manner that would undermine important
consumer protections. At the time, Committee Republicans
described this legislation as a key component of their plan for
``repealing and replacing Obamacare in the 115th
Congress.''\15\ These partisan repeal efforts were rejected in
the Senate and the ACA remains the law of the land.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\See, e.g., H.R. 1136, Affordable Health Care Act of 1999 (106th
Congress); H.R. 1101, Small Business Health Fairness Act of 2017 (115th
Congress).
\15\H. Rep. 115-43 at 24 (2017).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Since Republicans failed to enact their AHP proposals
legislatively, in 2018, the Trump Administration attempted to
do so through executive action by proposing and finalizing a
rule\16\ to expand AHPs under the Employee Retirement Income
Security Act of 1974 (ERISA).\17\ This rule would have
dramatically expanded the circumstances under which AHPs could
be offered as single-employer group health plans--even to self-
employed individuals without any common law employees. However,
on March 28, 2019, in State of New York v. United States
Department of Labor, Judge John D. Bates, an appointee of
President George W. Bush, struck down the core provisions of
the final rule, describing it as ``an end-run around the
ACA''\18\ that ``does violence to ERISA.''\19\ Accordingly, the
court vacated and remanded the remaining provisions of the
final rule to the Department of Labor for reconsideration.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\U.S. Dep't of Lab., Final Rule: Definition of ``Employer''
Under Section 3(5) of ERISA Association Health Plans, 83 Fed. Reg.
28912 (June 21, 2018), https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/
06/21/2018-12992/definition-of-employer-under-section-35-of-erisa-
association-health
-plans.
\17\Pub. L. No. 93-406 (1974).
\18\New York v. United States Dep't of Lab., 363 F. Supp. 3d 109,
117 (D.D.C. 2019).
\19\Id.
\20\Id. at 141. Note that the ruling was appealed to the United
States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit but has
been on hold since February 8, 2021, while ``[t]he matter remains under
consideration by the Department.'' Status Report at 1, New York v.
United States Dep't of Lab., Case No. 19-5125 (D.C. Cir. Aug. 2022).
Democrats have since encouraged the Department to act to protect
consumers from harm. On Feb. 13, 2023, Ranking Member Scott and HELP
Subcommittee Ranking Member DeSaulnier wrote to the Assistant Secretary
for the Employee Benefits Security Administration to express support
for the agency's proposed rulemaking to rescind the Trump
Administration's AHP final rule. See Letter from Ranking Member Bobby
Scott and Ranking Member Mark DeSaulnier to the Assistant Secretary of
Labor Lisa M. Gomez (Feb. 13, 2023), https://democrats-
edworkforce.house.gov/imo/media/doc/rm_ scott_letter_ to_ebsa_ on_
trump-era_association_ health_ plan_rule.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Having failed time and again in their efforts to expand
AHPs, Committee Republicans have now put forward H.R. 2868 in
yet another attempt to achieve this goal. Under this
legislation, ERISA's standards would be eroded such that sole
proprietors with no common law employees would be considered
``employers,'' and AHP arrangements would be able to evade many
of the consumer protections that would otherwise apply to the
individual or small group market. In addition, the bill would
treat AHPs as ERISA-covered group health plans exempt from
state law, thereby circumventing the authority of state
insurance regulators.
H.R. 2868 Creates Market Fragmentation and Raises Health Care Costs
Under the ACA, health insurance sold through an association
to individuals and small employers generally must meet the same
standards that apply to coverage sold in the individual and
small group market.\21\ However, by allowing small employers
and individuals to instead be subject to requirements
applicable to large employers, H.R. 2868 unravels these
protections and allows association health plans to operate
under different rules.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, supra note 13 (2011).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Experts have consistently warned that this approach--which
is antithetical to the foundational principles of the ACA that
ensure no one gets left behind--would fragment the health
insurance market. According to the American Academy of
Actuaries, allowing AHPs to operate under different rules could
result in adverse selection that raises costs throughout the
insurance pool and creates a market in which higher-cost
groups--namely, those that are generally sicker or older--
``could find it more difficult to obtain coverage.''\22\
Similarly, in its assessment of the Trump Administration's
final rule on AHPs, the Congressional Budget Office determined
that ``the primary factor driving lower premiums for AHPs is
the ability to price premiums on the basis of each
association's expected health care spending and thereby attract
employers with relatively low-risk employees and avoid those
with higher-risk employees.''\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\American Academy of Actuaries, Issue Brief: Association Health
Plans (Feb. 2017), http://www.actuary.org/content/association- health-
plans-0.
\23\Cong. Budget Office, How CBO and JCT Analyzed Coverage Effects
of New Rules for Association Health Plans and Short-Term Plans 5 (Jan.
2019), https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2019 01/54915-New_Rules_
for_AHPs_STPs.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 2868 Threatens Comprehensive, Affordable Coverage
Under H.R. 2868, AHPs could evade state and federal benefit
standards and consumer protections, threatening the quality of
coverage provided to their own enrollees. As a result,
enrollees run the risk of--potentially unknowingly--losing out
on comprehensive care that would otherwise be guaranteed under
the ACA and state law. While the bill applies some superficial
consumer protections to AHPs (e.g., nominal protections against
discrimination based on preexisting conditions), it creates
other large loopholes that leave consumers vulnerable.
Disturbingly, this legislation explicitly authorizes AHPs
to set premiums based on the ``specific risk profile'' of
employer members, enabling AHPs to charge higher premiums to
groups based on their age, gender, or other factors. Moreover,
even if premiums are not set directly on health-related factors
by an association, under this bill, premiums could take into
account numerous other factors that raise costs for people who
are older or have preexisting conditions.\24\ As a result, this
bill would all but invite AHPs to charge workers with more
expensive health needs far higher premiums--if those workers
could even afford to participate in the associations at all.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\See Sarah Lueck, Association Health Plan Expansion Likely to
Hurt Consumers, State Insurance Markets, Cen. on Budg. & Poli.
Priorities (Mar. 7, 2019), https://www.cbpp.org/research/health/
association-health-plan-expansion-likely-to-hurt-consumers-state-
insurance-markets.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Allowing insurers and health plans to avoid covering needed
benefits is a longstanding tenet of Republicans' approach to
health care.\25\ H.R. 2868 is no different. Despite coverage of
essential health benefits being both popular and necessary,\26\
under the legislation, AHPs would be exempt from this
foundational protection of the ACA. As a result, AHPs could
exclude certain categories of coverage, such as maternity care,
mental health, or substance use disorder, to dissuade certain
groups or individuals from enrolling. Reducing benefit levels
or avoiding the costs of providing comprehensive benefits can
reduce costs in the short-term but will ultimately negatively
impact consumers and people who need coverage the most.
Individuals enrolled in AHPs could be shocked to find they do
not have access to the care they need or the financial security
they expected.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\See e.g., Lydia Mitts et al., House Republicans Gut Protections
for Pre-Existing Conditions in Latest Proposal, Families USA (Mar. 26,
2017), https://familiesusa.org/ resources/house-republicans-gut-
protections-for-pre-existing-conditions-in- latest-proposal/.
\26\Dania Palanker, Eliminating Essential Health Benefits Will
Shift Financial Risk Back to Consumers, The Commonwealth Fund (Mar. 24,
2017), https://www.commonwealthfund.org/
blog/2017/eliminating-essential-health-benefits-will-shift-financial-
risk-back-consumers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 2868 Gambles With the Financial Security of Workers, Employers,
and Providers
H.R. 2868 allows AHPs to evade state regulations that
prevent fraud and mismanagement. This is profoundly dangerous
for consumers and employers who participate in these
arrangements, as well as the doctors, health centers, and
hospitals who may not receive reimbursement for the medical
care they provide. Ms. Corlette explained the high stakes at
the HELP Subcommittee hearing:
[I]f history is any guide, many AHPs may seem strong
at first because they are able to attract healthy
groups and can offer low rates and generous benefits to
those groups. Over time, however, as workers get older
and sicker, the risk in the pool deteriorates. AHPs
then either must raise rates, reduce benefits, disband,
or, in the worst cases, become insolvent.\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\Corlette, supra note 11 at 10.
The history of multiple employer welfare arrangements
(MEWAs) offers a sobering warning for the financial risks posed
by the proliferation of AHPs. H.R. 2868 allows AHPs to form
under limited regulation and oversight, hearkening back to the
time when MEWAs also enjoyed limited regulation and gambled
with the financial security of both workers and employers.\28\
In 2001, Sunkist Growers, Inc., a California-based MEWA that
covered 23,000 people, became insolvent, leaving behind
approximately $11 million in unpaid claims.\29\ Similarly, New
Jersey's Coalition of Automotive Retailers became insolvent in
2002, leaving 20,000 individuals without coverage and $15
million in unpaid claims.\30\
-----