Committee Action
112TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On February 9, 2011, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce (Committee) held a hearing entitled ``The Impact of
the Health Care Law on the Economy, Employers, and the
Workforce,'' which examined, among other things, the benefits
of self-insuring. Testifying before the Committee were Dr. Paul
Howard, Senior Fellow, Manhattan Institute, New York, New York;
Ms. Gail Johnson, President and CEO, Rainbow Station, Inc.,
Glenn Allen, Virginia; Dr. Paul Van de Water, Senior Fellow,
Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, Washington, D.C.; and
Mr. Neil Trautwein, Vice President and Employee Benefits Policy
Counsel, National Retail Federation, Washington, D.C.
On March 10, 2011, the Subcommittee on Health, Employment,
Labor and Pensions (HELP) held a hearing entitled ``The
Pressures of Rising Costs on Employer Provided Health Care,''
which examined, among other things, the benefits of self-
insurance. The witnesses were Mr. Tom Miller, Resident Fellow,
American Enterprise Institute, Washington, D.C.; Mr. Brett
Parker, Vice Chairman and Chief Financial Officer, Bowlmor
Lanes, New York, New York; Mr. Jim Houser, Owner, Hawthorne
Auto, Portland, Oregon; and Mr. J. Michael Brewer, President,
Lockton Benefit Group, Lockton Companies, LLC, Kansas City,
Missouri.
On June 7, 2011, the HELP Subcommittee held a field hearing
in Evansville, Indiana, entitled ``The Recent Health Care Law:
Consequences for Indiana Families and Workers,'' which
examined, among other things, the impact of the Affordable Care
Act (ACA) on self-funded plans. The witnesses were the
Honorable Mark Messmer, Indiana House of Representatives,
Messmer Mechanical, Jasper, Indiana; Ms. Robyn Crosson, Company
Compliance Services, State of Indiana Department of Insurance,
Indianapolis, Indiana; Ms. Sherry Lang, Human Resources
Director, Womack Restaurants, Terre Haute, Indiana; Mr. Denis
Johnson, VP of Operations, Boston Scientific, Spencer, Indiana;
Mr. David J. Carlson, M.D., General Surgeon, Deaconess
Hospital, Evansville, Indiana; and Mr. Glen Graber, President,
Graber Post Building, Inc., Odon, Indiana.
On October 13, 2011, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``Regulations, Costs, and Uncertainty in Employer
Provided Health Care,'' which examined, among other things, the
characteristics and attributes of self-funded plans. The
witnesses were Ms. Grace-Marie Turner, President, Galen
Institute, Alexandria, Virginia; Mr. Dennis M. Donahue,
Managing Director, Wells Fargo Insurance Services USA, Inc.,
Chicago, Illinois; Mr. Ron Pollack, Executive Director,
Families USA, Washington, D.C.; and Ms. Robyn Piper, President,
Piper Jordan, San Diego, California.
Second Session--Hearings
On February 22, 2012, the HELP Subcommittee held a field
hearing in Butler, Pennsylvania, entitled ``Health Care:
Challenges Facing Pennsylvania's Workers and Job Creators,''
which examined, among other things, the benefits of self-
insuring. The witnesses were the Honorable Donald C. White,
Senator, Pennsylvania State Senate, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania;
Ms. Kathleen Bishop, President and CEO, Meadville-Western
Crawford, County Chamber of Commerce, Meadville, Pennsylvania;
Ms. Georgeanne Koehler, Pittsburg, Pennsylvania; Ms. Lori
Joint, Director of Government Affairs, Manufacturer and
Business Association, Erie, Pennsylvania; Ms.Patti-Ann
Kanterman, Chief Financial Officer, Associated Ceramics and
Technology, Inc., Sarver, Pennsylvania; Mr. Paul T. Nelson,
Owner and CEO, Waldameer Park, Inc., Erie, Pennsylvania; Mr.
Ralph Vitt, Owner, Vitt Insure, Pittsburg, Pennsylvania; and
Mr. Will Knecht, President, Wendell August Forge, Grove City,
Pennsylvania.
On May 31, 2012, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``Barriers to Lower Health Care Costs for Workers and
Employers,'' which examined, among other things, self-insured
plans. The witnesses were Mr. Ed Fensholt, Senior Vice
President, Lockton Companies, LLC, Kansas City, Missouri; Mr.
Roy Ramthun, President, HAS Consulting Services, Washington,
D.C.; Ms. Jody Hall, Founder & Owner, Cupcake Royale, Seattle,
Washington; and Mr. Bill Streitberger, Vice President of Human
Resources, Red Robin, Greenwood Village, Colorado.
113TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On April 30, 2013, the HELP Subcommittee held a field
hearing in Concord, North Carolina, entitled ``Health Care
Challenges Facing North Carolina's Workers and Job Creators,''
during which witnesses discussed the negative impact of the
ACA, including on businesses that self-insure. The witnesses
were Mr. Chuck Horne, President, Hornwood Inc., Lilesville,
North Carolina; Ms. Tina Haynes, Chief Human Resource Officer,
Rowan-Cabarrus Community College, Salisbury, North Carolina;
Mr. Adam Searing, Director, Health Access Coalition, Raleigh,
North Carolina; Mr. Ken Conrad, Chairman, Libby Hill Seafood
Restaurants, Greenboro, North Carolina; Mr. Dave Bass, Vice
President, Compensation and Associate Wellness, Delhaize
America, Concord, North Carolina; Mr. Ed Tubel, Founder and
CEO, Tricor Inc., Charlotte, North Carolina; Dr. Olson Huff,
Pediatrician, Asheville, North Carolina; and Mr. Bruce Silver,
President and CEO, Racing Electronics, Concord, North Carolina.
On June 4, 2013, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``Reviewing the President's Fiscal Year 2014 Budget Proposal
for the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services,'' during
which members discussed the experiences of employers that self-
insure. The sole witness at the hearing was the Honorable
Kathleen Sebelius, Secretary of the U.S. Department of Health
and Human Services, Washington, D.C.
On July 23, 2013, the HELP Subcommittee and the Workforce
Protections Subcommittee jointly held a hearing entitled ``The
Employer Mandate: Examining the Delay and Its Effect on
Workplaces,'' which reviewed, among other things, the impact of
the ACA on the self-insured market. Witnesses were Ms. Grace-
Marie Turner, President, Galen Institute, Alexandria, Virginia;
Mr. Jamie T. Richardson, Vice President, White Castle System,
Inc., Columbus, Ohio; Mr. Ron Pollack, Executive Director,
Families USA, Washington, D.C.; and Dr. Douglas Holtz-Eakin,
President, American Action Forum, Washington, D.C.
On August 27, 2013, the HELP Subcommittee held a field
hearing in Lexington, Kentucky, entitled ``Health Care
Challenges Facing Kentucky's Workers and Job Creators,'' which
included an examination of self-insurance. Witnesses before the
subcommittee were Mr. Tim Kanaly, Owner and President, Gary
Force Honda, Bowling Green, Kentucky; Mr. Joe Bologna, Owner,
Joe Bologna's--Italian Pizzeria and Restaurant, Lexington,
Kentucky; Ms. Carrie Banahan, Executive Director, Office of the
Kentucky Health Benefit Exchange, Frankfort, Kentucky; Mr. John
Humkey, President, Employee Benefit Associates, Inc.,
Lexington, Kentucky; Ms. Janey Moores, President and CEO, BJM
and Associates, Inc., Lexington, Kentucky; Mr. Donnie Meadows,
Vice President of Human Resources, K-VA-T Food Stores, Inc.,
Abingdon, Virginia; Ms. Debbie Basham, Southwest Breast Cancer
Awareness Group, Louisville, Kentucky; and Mr. John McPhearson,
CEO, Lectrodryer, Richmond, Kentucky.
Second Session--Hearings
On February 26, 2014, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``Providing Access to Affordable, Flexible Health
Plans through Self-Insurance,'' which examined self-insurance
and stop-loss insurance. The witnesses were Mr. Michael
Ferguson, President and CEO, Self-Insurance Institute of
America, Simpsonville, South Carolina; Mr. Wes Kelley,
Executive Director, Columbia Power and Water Systems, Columbia,
Tennessee; Ms. Maura Calsyn, Director of Health Policy, Center
for American Progress, Washington, D.C.; and Mr. Robert
Melillo, National Vice President of Risk Financing Solutions,
USI Insurance, Glastonbury, Connecticut.
On March 26, 2014, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``Reviewing the President's Fiscal Year 2015 Budget Proposal
for the Department of Labor,'' during which the Secretary of
Labor was questioned about whether the Department had plans to
regulate stop-loss insurance. The sole witness was the
Honorable Thomas E. Perez, Secretary of the U.S. Department of
Labor, Washington, D.C.
On September 4, 2014, the HELP Subcommittee held a field
hearing in Greenfield, Indiana, entitled ``The Effects of the
President's Health Care Law on Indiana's Classrooms and
Workplaces,'' during which witnesses testified about employer-
provided health coverage and self- insured plans. The witnesses
were Mr. Mike Shafer, Chief Financial Officer, Zionsville
Community Schools, Zionsville, Indiana; Mr. Tom Snyder,
President, Ivy Tech Community College, Indianapolis, Indiana;
Mr. Danny Tanoos, Superintendent, Vigo County School
Corporation, Terre Haute, Indiana; Mr. Tom Forkner, President,
Anderson Federation of Teachers, AFT Local 519, Anderson,
Indiana; Mr. Mark DeFabis, President and Chief Executive
Officer, Integrated Distribution Services, Plainfield, Indiana;
Mr. Nate LaMar, International Regional Manager, Draper, Inc.,
Spiceland, Indiana; Mr. Dan Wolfe, Owner, Wolfe's Auto Auction,
Terre Haute, Indiana; and Mr. Robert Stone, Director of
Palliative Care, IU Health Bloomington Hospital, Bloomington,
Indiana.
114TH CONGRESS
First Session--Legislative Action
On March 18, 2015, Rep. David ``Phil'' Roe (R-TN), then-
Chairman of the HELP Subcommittee, introduced the Self-
Insurance Protection Act (H.R. 1423), to ensure employees and
employers could continue to have access to affordable, flexible
health care plans by having the option to self-fund those
plans.
First Session--Hearings
On March 18, 2015, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``Reviewing the President's Fiscal Year 2016 Budget Proposal
for the Department of Labor,'' during which the Secretary of
Labor was questioned about the Department's plans to regulate
stop-loss. The sole witness was the Honorable Thomas E. Perez,
Secretary of the U.S. Department of Labor, Washington, D.C.
On April 14, 2015, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``Five Years of Broken Promises: How the President's
Health Care Law is Affecting America's Workplaces,'' which
examined the continuing negative impact of the ACA on employer-
sponsored health coverage, including on self-insured plans.
Witnesses were the Honorable Tevi Troy, President, American
Health Policy Institute, Washington, D.C.; Mr. Rutland Paal,
Jr., President, Rutland Beard Floral Group, Scotch Plains, New
Jersey; Michael Brev, President, Brev Corp. t/a Hobby Works,
WingTOTE Manufacturing, LLC, Laurel, Maryland; and Ms. Sally
Roberts, Human Resources Director, Morris Communications
Company, LLC, Augusta, Georgia.
Second Session--Hearings
On March 15, 2016, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``Examining the Policies and Priorities of the U.S. Department
of Health and Human Services,'' during which self-insured plans
were discussed. The sole witness at the hearing was the
Honorable Sylvia Mathews Burwell, Secretary of the U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services, Washington, D.C.
On April 14, 2016, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``Innovations in Health Care: Exploring Free-Market
Solutions for a Healthy Workforce,'' which examined, among
other things, the benefits of self-insuring. Witnesses before
the subcommittee were Ms. Sabrina Corlette, Senior Research
Professor, Center on Health Insurance Reforms, Georgetown
University's Health Policy Institute, Washington, D.C.; Ms.
Tresia Franklin, Director, Total Rewards and Employee
Relations, Hallmark Cards, Inc. Kansas City, Missouri; Ms. Amy
McDonough, Vice President and General Manager of Corporate
Wellness, Fitbit, San Francisco, California; and Mr. John Zern,
Executive Vice President and Global Health Leader, Aon,
Chicago, Illinois.
115TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On February 1, 2017, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``Rescuing Americans from the Failed Health Care Law and
Advancing Patient-Centered Solutions,'' which examined failures
of the ACA, including its effects on self-insurance. Witnesses
were Mr. Scott Bollenbacher, CPA, Managing Partner,
Bollenbacher and Associates, LLC, Portland, Indiana; Mr. Joe
Eddy, President and Chief Executive Officer, Eagle
Manufacturing Company, Wellsburg, West Virginia; Ms. Angela
Schlaack, St. Joseph, Michigan; and Dr. Tevi Troy, Chief
Executive Officer, American Health Policy Institute,
Washington, D.C.
On March 1, 2017, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``Legislative Proposals to Improve Health Care Coverage and
Provide Lower Costs for Families,'' which examined H.R. the
Self-Insurance Protection Act (H.R. 1304), among other
proposals. Witnesses were Mr. Jon B. Hurst, President,
Retailers Association of Massachusetts, Boston, Massachusetts;
Ms. Allison R. Klausner, Principal, Government Relations
Leader, Conduent, Secaucus, New Jersey; Ms. Lydia Mitts,
Associate Director of Affordability Initiatives, Families USA,
Washington, D.C.; and Mr. Jay Ritchie, Executive Vice
President, Tokio Marine HHC, Kennesaw, Georgia.
Legislative Action
On March 2, 2017, Rep. Roe introduced the Self-Insurance
Protection Act (H.R. 1304) along with then-HELP Subcommittee
Chairman Tim Walberg (R-MI) to ensure self-funding remains an
option for employee and employers offering health care
coverage.
On March 8, 2017, the Committee considered the Self-
Insurance Protection Act (H.R. 1304). Rep. Roe offered an
amendment in the nature of a substitute, making a technical
change to the introduced bill. The Committee voted to adopt the
amendment in the nature of a substitute by voice vote. Rep.
Jared Polis (D-CO) offered an amendment that was ruled non-
germane, and the ruling of the Chair was upheld by a vote of 22
to 17 on a motion to table the appeal of the ruling of the
Chair. Rep. Bonamici (D-OR) offered a clarifying amendment to
ensure that the legislation would not be construed to restrict
the ability of states to regulate stop-loss policies. H.R. 1304
does not preempt states from regulating stop-loss coverage. At
the request of Ranking Member Robert C. ``Bobby'' Scott (D-VA),
Committee Chairwoman Virginia Foxx (R-NC) agreed to include
such clarifying language in the Committee report. This
clarification ensures that nothing in the bill is erroneously
construed to restrict states' ability to regulate stop-loss
policies. Based on the understanding between Chairwoman Foxx
and Ranking Member Scott that this clarification would be
included in the Committee's official report, Rep. Bonamici
withdrew her amendment. The Committee favorably reported H.R.
1304, as amended, to the House of Representatives by voice
vote.
On April 5, 2017, the House of Representatives passed H.R.
1304, the Self-Insurance Protection Act by a vote of 400-16.
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearing
On April 24, 2023, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
entitled ``Reducing Health Care Costs for Working Americans and
Their Families,'' which examined the Self-Insurance Protection
Act (H.R. 2813), among other proposals. Witnesses were Mr. Joel
White, President, Council for Affordable Health Coverage
(CAHC), Washington, D.C.; Mrs. Tracy Watts, Senior Partner,
Mercer, Washington, D.C.; Ms. Marcie Strouse, Partner, Capitol
Benefits Group, Des Moines, Iowa; and Ms. Sabrina Corlette,
J.D., Senior Research Professor, Center on Health Insurance
Reforms, Georgetown University's Health Policy Institute,
Washington, D.C.
Legislative Action
On April 25, 2023, HELP Subcommittee Chairman Bob Good (R-
VA) introduced the Self-Insurance Protection Act (H.R. 2813)
along with Rep. Tim Walberg (R-MI) to ensure self-funding
remains an option for employee and employers offering health
care coverage. The bill was referred to the Committee on
Education and the Workforce, the Committee on Energy and
Commerce, and the Committee on Ways and Means. On June 6, 2023,
the Committee considered H.R. 2813 in legislative session and
reported it favorably, as amended, to the House of
Representatives by a recorded vote of 24-18. The Committee
adopted the following amendment to H.R. 2813: Rep. Good offered
an Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute (ANS) that, with
respect to the language amending ERISA, strikes duplicate
language amending the Public Health Service Act and the
Internal Revenue Code. The ANS also changes the term ``self-
funded health plan'' to ``self-insured group health plan.''
Committee Views
INTRODUCTION
Background on employer-sponsored insurance coverage
Since World War II, employers have offered health care
benefits to recruit and retain talent and to ensure a healthy
and productive workforce. Employer-sponsored health insurance
is one of the primary means by which Americans obtain health
care coverage. Almost 159 million American workers and family
members are covered by a health benefit plan offered by an
employer.\2\ The U.S. Census Bureau reports that 54.3 percent
of Americans were covered by employment-based health coverage
in 2021.\3\ When given the option for employment-based health
coverage, 77 percent of workers take up coverage.\4\ Almost all
businesses with at least 200 or more employees offer health
benefits.\5\ According to the Kaiser Family Foundation,
however, smaller firms (with 3 to 199 employees) are
significantly less likely to offer health benefits.\6\ As a
result, in 2022, just over half of all employers offered some
health benefits.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Kaiser Family Found., Employer Health Benefits: 2022 Annual
Survey, 2022 Employer Health Benefits Survey 58, http://files.kff.org/
attachment/Report-Employer-Health-Benefits-2022-Annual-Survey.pdf.
\3\U.S. Census Bur., U.S. Dep't of Com., Health Insurance Coverage
in the United States: 2021, http://census.gov/content/dam/Census/
library/publications/2022/demo/p60-278.pdf.
\4\Kaiser Family Found., supra note 2, Summary of Findings, 12.
\5\Id.
\6\Id.
\7\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Employer-provided health benefits are regulated by a number
of laws, including ERISA as amended by the ACA. The Department
of Labor (DOL) implements and enforces ERISA. By virtue of its
jurisdiction over ERISA, the Committee has jurisdiction over
employer-provided health coverage.
Self-insured health plans
Small and large employers offer health care coverage to
employees in self-funded arrangements (self-insurance) or
purchase fully insured plans. ERISA regulates both fully
insured and self-insured plans, but only self-insured plans are
exempt from a patchwork of benefit mandates and regulations
imposed under state insurance law. Employers sponsoring self-
insured plans are not subject to the same requirements under
ACA as those with fully-insured plans. Therefore, employer-
provided plans have different requirements and costs depending
on funding arrangements. Last year, approximately 65 percent of
workers with employer-sponsored health coverage were enrolled
in a self-funded plan, up from 44 percent in 1999 and
Minority Views
Introduction
Congressional Democrats and the Biden and Obama
Administrations have made historic progress to improve the
affordability of health insurance and combating growth in the
overall cost of providing care in the United States. This has
made the system fairer for consumers and helped bring the
uninsured rate down to 8 percent--the lowest level in
history.\1\ While more work needs to be done to achieve an
affordable health care system, H.R. 2813, the Self-Insurance
Protection Act, would be counterproductive to these efforts.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Aiden Lee et al., National Uninsured Rate Reaches All-Time Low
in Early 2022, Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation, U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services (Aug. 2022), https://
aspe.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/documents/
15c1f9899b3f203887deba90e3005f5a/
Uninsured-Q1-2022-Data-Point-HP-2022-23-08.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Democrats do not oppose the purchase of stop loss
insurance to help plan sponsors mitigate their risk when they
self-insure. However, stop loss, like any other insurance
product, must be subject to reasonable oversight and consumer
protections. Unfortunately, H.R. 2813 would prevent both the
federal government and state regulators from performing
necessary oversight and taking action to protect consumers and
small businesses. Therefore, Committee Democrats oppose H.R.
2813.
Regulatory Framework of Self-Insurance
In general, a group health plan can be funded through two
different mechanisms. The plan can either be: (1) self-insured,
where the plan sponsor is responsible for the costs of health
care claims incurred by plan participants and beneficiaries; or
(2) fully insured, where the plan sponsor shifts the financial
risk by purchasing coverage from an insurance company who is
responsible for costs incurred under the plan.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Gary Claxon et. al., 2022 Employer Health Benefits Survey,
Kaiser Family Foundation at 163 (Oct. 27, 2022), https://files.kff.org/
attachment/Report-Employer-Health-Benefits-2022-Annual-Survey.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Many self-insured plans purchase additional insurance
coverage known as ``stop loss,''\3\ in which an insurance
carrier bears the financial responsibility for claims that are
incurred above a certain threshold (known as the ``attachment
point'').\4\ Although states generally have authority to
regulate insurers offering coverage in the group market (as
well as the individual market), self-insured group health plans
are generally exempt from state regulation due to the broad
preemption provision of the Employee Retirement Income Security
Act (ERISA).\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Both ``stop loss'' and ``stop-loss'' are used interchangeably.
\4\Claxon at al., supra note 2 at 160.
\5\29 U.S.C. Sec. 1144(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Federal law does not generally apply any substantive
standards to stop loss insurance, as this market is
traditionally within the purview of state insurance regulators.
However, stop loss issuers may be subject to certain ERISA
requirements as group health plan service providers.\6\ In
addition, ERISA, the Public Health Service Act (PHSA) and the
Internal Revenue Code (IRC) provide authority to the
Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services, and the
Treasury, respectively, to interpret and enforce requirements
applicable to group health plans and issuers offering health
insurance coverage in connection with a group health plan.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\29 U.S.C. Sec. Sec. 1106, 1108(b)(2).
\7\Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996,
Pub. L. No. 104-91 Sec. 104.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Stop Loss as a Potential Workaround From ACA Consumer Protections
While stop loss insurance, when used for its intended
purpose, can provide appropriate financial protection for self-
funded employers against large losses, experts have
increasingly observed that it is often used as a tool to evade
regulatory and statutory requirements. Specifically, there has
been a marked growth in the number of so-called ``level-
funded'' group health plans, in which plan sponsors--generally
small employers--purchase stop loss coverage with extremely low
attachment points that essentially insulate the sponsor from
meaningful financial responsibility for claims.\8\ This allows
the plan to operate as a de facto fully insured plan, in which
the plan sponsor is only responsible for making fixed payments
to the insurer. However, because the plan is legally considered
self-insured, ERISA preempts state laws that seek to regulate
the plan, and certain requirements of the Affordable Care Act
(ACA)\9\ do not apply.\10\ As a result, the plan is effectively
exempt from key consumer protections, most notably the
requirement to provide all ten Essential Health Benefits under
the ACA.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Claxton et al., supra note 2 at 156. See also Christen Linke
Young, Taking a Broader View of ``Junk Insurance,'' Brookings
Institution at 16-17 (July 6, 2020), https://www.brookings.edu/wp-
content/uploads/2020/07/Broader-View_July_2020.pdf.
\9\Pub. L. No. 111-148 (2010).
\10\Young, supra note 8 at 16, https://www.brookings.edu/wp-
content/uploads/2020/07/Broader-View_July_2020.pdf.
\11\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 2813 Obstructs Federal Oversight of Health Insurance Coverage
In recognition that the federal government has authority to
clarify that health insurance that masquerades as stop-loss is
subject to relevant consumer protections,\12\ Republicans have
in the past proposed legislation to exempt stop loss from the
definition of ``health insurance coverage'' under federal
law.\13\ Similarly, H.R. 2813 would amend federal law to exempt
stop loss insurance from the definition of ``health insurance
coverage.'' This is unnecessary and would only serve to hinder
potential efforts to protect consumers and small businesses.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\See Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services, and the
Treasury, Request for Information Regarding Stop Loss Insurance, 77
Fed. Reg. 25788 (May 1, 2012), https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-
2012-05-01/pdf/2012-10441.pdf.
\13\H.R. 1304, Self-Insurance Protection Act (115th Congress).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
It is well established that traditional stop loss insurance
policies that insulate employers from catastrophic risk are not
health insurance coverage, and there is no indication that the
federal government plans to regulate stop loss. Therefore, H.R.
2813 would have little immediate impact on federal oversight of
this sector. However, as noted above, the proliferation of
level-funded plans using stop loss as a workaround from
consumer protections may necessitate future action. Indeed,
experts have expressed concern about the inadequacy of the
current federal regulatory framework and argue that it would be
appropriate to clarify that stop loss functioning as de facto
health insurance is subject to rules that apply to other forms
of health insurance coverage.\14\ However, by redefining health
insurance coverage to explicitly exclude stop loss, H.R. 2813
seeks to prevent such action in the future.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Young, supra note 8 at 33-4. See also, Mark Hall, Regulating
Stop-Loss Coverage May Be Needed To Deter Self-Insuring Small Employers
From Undermining Market Reforms, Health Affairs (Feb. 2012), https://
www.healthaffairs.org/doi/10.1377/hlthaff.2011.1017.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 2813 Undermines Well-Established State Authority Over Stop Loss
In addition, H.R. 2813 takes the extraordinary step of
amending ERISA's preemption provision to specifically restrict
states that wish to regulate stop loss insurance to protect
consumers and small businesses. The bill provides that all
requirements of title I of ERISA ``shall preempt State laws
insofar as they may now or hereafter prevent an employee
benefit plan that is a group health plan from insuring against
the risk of excess or unexpected health plan claims
losses.''\15\ This undoes decades of jurisprudence that has
long recognized the states' role in regulating the sale of
insurance\16\ and goes beyond previous legislative efforts by
Committee Republicans to prevent regulation of stop loss.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\H.R. 2813, Self-Insurance Protection Act (118th Congress),
Sec. 4.
\16\See Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. Massachusetts, 471 U.S. 724
(1985).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 2813 would call into question numerous existing state
laws and would impede other states from taking future actions
to protect consumers and businesses. For example, Connecticut
law requires that stop loss policies be filed with and approved
by the insurance commissioner,\17\ who has issued strong
substantive standards to ensure that attachment points are set
at reasonable levels.\18\ In addition, some states, including
Delaware, New York, and Oregon, have prohibited the sale of
stop loss to small employers with fewer than a certain
threshold number of employees.\19\ In at least four states,
legislation has been enacted that is similar to the model law
endorsed by the National Association of Insurance
Commissioners, which provides standards regarding attachment
points and prevents stop loss from directly paying health
claims.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\C.G.S. Sec. 38a-8b.
\18\State of Connecticut Insurance Department, Bulletin HC-126 (May
6, 2019), https://portal.ct.gov/-/media/CID/1_Bulletins/Bulletin-HC-
126.pdf.
\19\Alex Reger & Kristen Miller, State Regulation of Stop Loss
Insurance, Office of Legislative Research (Sept. 27, 2019), https://
www.cga.ct.gov/2019/rpt/pdf/2019-R00193.pdf.
\20\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 2813's Preemption Provision Could Further Hinder State Solvency
and Consumer Protection Standards
In addition to preempting states' authority to enact
specific restrictions on the content of stop loss policies,
H.R. 2813 may even restrict states from applying other
protections that govern insurance carriers generally--including
solvency requirements that prevent underfunding, mismanagement,
and fraud. Under current law, ERISA already broadly exempts
self-insured plans from state law and H.R. 2813's preemption
provision could further hinder states that wish to apply
solvency standards on stop loss sold in connection with the
plan. This could leave states with no clear authority to
regulate the solvency of either the underlying group health
plan or the stop loss policy, placing both workers and
employers at risk of financial harm. It could also leave
individuals harmed by insolvencies with little recourse for
unpaid medical claims.
History has shown the very real risks this presents for
consumers. The historically lax regulation of multiple employer
welfare arrangements (MEWAs) under state solvency and consumer
protection standards has led to numerous high-profile
insolvencies, including numerous instances in which MEWAs left
individuals, employers, and health care providers with tens of
millions in unpaid medical claims.\21\ As the National
Association of Insurance Commissioners put it in 1982 when
state authority to regulate MEWAs was similarly undermined by
preemption:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Mila Kofman, et al., MEWAs: The Threat of Plan Insolvency and
Other Challenges, Commonwealth Fund (March 2004), https://
www.commonwealthfund.org/sites/default/files/
documents/
_media_files_publications_issue_brief_2004_mar_mewas_the_threat_of_plan_
insolvency_and_other_challenges_kofman_mewas_pdf.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
There is one common theme, however, and that is the
inability of the State regulators to adequately monitor
and regulate the activities of [self-funded MEWAs] that
purport to be welfare benefit programs in order to
insure solvency and proper claims practices. . . .
Simply put, we feel that with respect to the solvency
of these employee welfare benefit plans, no one is in
charge: Not the Labor Department, not the IRS, and by
Federal law, not the State insurance commissioners.\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\Oversight Investigation of Certain Multiple Employer Health
Insurance Trusts (METs), Evading State and Federal Regulation: Hearing
Before the Subcomm. on Lab.-Mgmt. Rel. of the H. Comm. on Educ. & Lab.,
97th Cong. 51 (1982) (Testimony of Beth Kravetz, Federal Affairs
Counsel, National Association of Insurance Commissioners).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 2813's erosion of state authority--when paired with
the bill's similar restriction on federal authority--is
particularly alarming to consumer and patient advocates. A
group of over two dozen consumer and patient advocacy
organizations, including the American Cancer Society Cancer
Action Network, the American Heart Association, and the
Leukemia & Lymphoma Society, expressed grave concerns with H.R.
2813's preemption of state law, warning the Committee that
``[r]emoving states'' ability to regulate stop-loss coverage
would lead to less oversight of these plans, which would
increase the likelihood of misleading marketing and other
fraudulent practices that would prove harmful to employers
purchasing stop-loss coverage as well as their employees.''\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\Patient community concerns about the detrimental impact of
policies included in HR 2868, the Association Health Plans Act; HR 824,
the Telehealth Benefit Expansion for Workers Act; and HR 2813, the
Self-Insurance Protection Act, Letter to Chair Virginia Foxx and
Ranking Member Bobby Scott, H. Comm. on Educ. & the Workforce, Full
Committee Markup (June 6, 2023) (on file with author).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R 2813 Poses Additional Risks to Consumers and Small Businesses
While employers might view level-funding as a way to avoid
the financial risk of self-insuring while achieving potential
savings, these arrangements nonetheless pose serious risks to
employers and to workers. Families USA, a nonprofit,
nonpartisan consumer health advocacy and policy organization,
points out that ``some small employers may not fully understand
the risks of `level-funded' plans'' and that stop loss is
exempt from protections that apply to health insurance
coverage.\24\ The Massachusetts' Division of Insurance has
publicly advised that small employers should ``take extreme
caution when considering self-funded health plans'' and ``urges
such employers to consider the financial consequences of a year
with higher than projected health claims.''\25\ For example, an
insurer may offer a low rate to a small business for stop loss
that makes level-funding attractive initially, but following a
year in which claims are unexpectedly high may immediately
raise premiums to an unaffordable level. Because it is not
health insurance coverage, stop loss is exempt from provisions
that could mitigate such harms--such as the ACA's requirement
of annual rate review of unreasonable premium increases.\26\ By
further tying the hands of state and federal regulators that
seek to protect consumers and employers from these
arrangements, H.R. 2813 would exacerbate these risks.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\Families USA, Statement for the Record, H. Comm. on Educ. & the
Workforce, Full Committee Markup (June 6, 2023) (on file with author).
\25\Massachusetts Division of Insurance, Consumer Alert: Beware of
the Risks in Self-Funded Health Plans, accessed June 9, 2023, https://
www.mass.gov/service-details/consumer-alert-beware-of-the-risks-in-
self-funded-health-plans.
\26\42 U.S.C. Sec. 300gg-94.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, as with proposals to expand association health
plans, H.R. 2813 threatens the broader insurance market. The
ACA ensured a level playing field in the small group market by
requiring insurers to use a single risk pool and comply with
consumer protections such as coverage of Essential Health
Benefits. However, because self-insured plans are not subject
to these requirements, increasing incentives for sponsors to
level-fund their plans risks segmenting the insurance market
and--when healthier groups leave the single risk pool--
disadvantages those left behind. As Families USA notes,
``level-funded plans not only pose risks to those families who
rely on them for insurance, they can negatively impact families
that access insurance in the traditional insurance markets by
eroding risk pools.''\27\ The Center on Budget and Policy
Priorities similarly warns that the legislation would ``segment
insurance markets.''\28\ When market segmentation occurs,
older, sicker groups suffer, and health coverage becomes less
affordable and potentially out of reach.\29\ As a result, H.R.
2813 threatens to raise costs throughout the broader health
insurance market and could make it more difficult for certain
groups to access affordable coverage.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\Id.
\28\Sarah Lueck, House Health Proposals Would Undermine Consumer
Protections and Expand High-Income Tax Benefits, Center on Budget and
Policy Priorities (June 5, 2023), https://www.cbpp.org/blog/house-
health-proposals-would-undermine-consumer-protections-and-expand-high-
income-tax.
\29\See, e.g., American Academy of Actuaries, Drivers of 2020
Health Insurance Premium Changes (June 2019), https://www.actuary.org/
sites/default/files/2019-06/PremiumDrivers
2020.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Democratic Amendment Offered During Markup of H.R. 2813
Committee Democrats put forward an amendment to improve the
bill. The amendment would have mitigated the harm posed by the
legislation by preserving the ability of states to regulate
stop loss insurance and act in the best interests of their
residents. Committee Republicans unanimously rejected the
amendment.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------