Skip to content

house · Committee report

H. Rept. 118-12

PROVIDING FOR CONSIDERATION OF THE BILL (H.R. 5) TO ENSURE THE RIGHTS OF PARENTS ARE HONORED AND PROTECTED IN THE NATION'S PUBLIC SCHOOLS

2023-03-22

Committees

Associated legislation

Text

Committee Votes

The results of each record vote on an amendment or motion to report, together with the names of those voting for and against, are printed below: Rules Committee record vote No. 22 Motion by Mr. McGovern to amend the rule to make in order amendment #16 to H.R. 5, offered by Representative Grijalva, which would prohibit the Act to be construed to allow the banning or censorship of books in public elementary or public secondary schools. Defeated: 3-8 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Majority Members Vote Minority Members Vote ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Burgess..................................... Nay Mr. McGovern...................... Yea Mr. Reschenthaler............................... ............ Ms. Scanlon....................... Yea Mrs. Fischbach.................................. Nay Mr. Neguse........................ Yea Mr. Massie...................................... Nay Ms. Leger Fernandez............... ............ Mr. Norman...................................... Nay Mr. Roy......................................... Nay Mrs. Houchin.................................... Nay Mr. Langworthy.................................. Nay Mr. Cole, Chairman.............................. Nay ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Rules Committee record vote No. 23 Motion by Mr. McGovern to amend the rule to make in order amendment #24 to H.R. 5, offered by Representative Landsman, which allows for individual school districts to opt-out of compliance with the Act in order to maintain local control. Defeated: 3-9 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Majority Members Vote Minority Members Vote ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Burgess..................................... Nay Mr. McGovern...................... Yea Mr. Reschenthaler............................... Nay Ms. Scanlon....................... Yea Mrs. Fischbach.................................. Nay Mr. Neguse........................ Yea Mr. Massie...................................... Nay Ms. Leger Fernandez............... ............ Mr. Norman...................................... Nay Mr. Roy......................................... Nay Mrs. Houchin.................................... Nay Mr. Langworthy.................................. Nay Mr. Cole, Chairman.............................. Nay ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Rules Committee record vote No. 24 Motion by Ms. Scanlon to amend the rule to make in order amendment #18 to H.R. 5, offered by Representative Frost, which would amend the Sense of Congress on First Amendment Rights to state that parents have a First Amendment right to express support for their children accessing best practice medical care. Defeated: 3-9 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Majority Members Vote Minority Members Vote ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Burgess..................................... Nay Mr. McGovern...................... Yea Mr. Reschenthaler............................... Nay Ms. Scanlon....................... Yea Mrs. Fischbach.................................. Nay Mr. Neguse........................ Yea Mr. Massie...................................... Nay Ms. Leger Fernandez............... ............ Mr. Norman...................................... Nay Mr. Roy......................................... Nay Mrs. Houchin.................................... Nay Mr. Langworthy.................................. Nay Mr. Cole, Chairman.............................. Nay ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Rules Committee record vote No. 25 Motion by Mrs. Houchin to report the rule. Adopted: 9-3 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Majority Members Vote Minority Members Vote ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Mr. Burgess..................................... Yea Mr. McGovern...................... Nay Mr. Reschenthaler............................... Yea Ms. Scanlon....................... Nay Mrs. Fischbach.................................. Yea Mr. Neguse........................ Nay Mr. Massie...................................... Yea Ms. Leger Fernandez............... ............ Mr. Norman...................................... Yea Mr. Roy......................................... Yea Mrs. Houchin.................................... Yea Mr. Langworthy.................................. Yea Mr. Cole, Chairman.............................. Yea ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- SUMMARY OF THE AMENDMENTS TO H.R. 5 MADE IN ORDER 1. Bacon (NE): Requires Local Education Agencies (LEA) to provide the parents of a child who is a student in an elementary school or secondary school the number of school counselors in that school. (10 minutes) 2. Foxx (NC): Amends H.R. 5 to align the list of rights school districts must provide notice of to actions school districts must take; amends a sense of Congress to express support for parents fundamental rights to direct the education of their children and that courts should use the strict scrutiny test to evaluate laws involving those rights. (10 minutes) 3. Boebert (CO): Amends Section 104 to include Parent's Right to Know if their child's school operates, sponsors, or facilitates athletic programs or activities to permit a person whose biological sex is male to participate in an athletic program or activity that is designated for women or girls. (10 minutes) 4. Boebert (CO): Amends Section 104 to include Parent's Right to Know if their child's school allows a person whose biological sex is male to use restrooms or changing rooms designated for women or girls. (10 minutes) 5. Bonamici (OR): Strikes line 1 and all that follows in H.R.5. Includes a findings section and sense of Congress regarding public education and rights that parents have access to in public schools. Includes titles creating a parent coordinator position in public schools, increasing the authorization level for Full-Service Community Schools, increasing the authorization level for Statewide Family Engagement Centers, and establishing rules of construction prohibiting the banning of books or certain curricular materials. (10 minutes) 6. Crane (AZ), Greene (GA): Adds a private right of action for parents to hold schools accountable for not honoring the rights set forth in Title I and Title II of this bill. (10 minutes) 7. Davidson (OH): Prohibits federal funds under Title I and Title II from going to a local educational agency unless they hold an open enrollment period. (10 minutes) 8. Fitzpatrick (PA): Amends the bill to require the Comptroller General of the United States (GAO) to submit a report to Congress on the cost of the requirements of H.R. 5 to SEAs, LEAs, and elementary and secondary schools and requires the report to also analyze and evaluate the impact of H.R. 5 on protecting parents' rights in the education of the children. (10 minutes) 9. Garbarino (NY), D'Esposito (NY): Provides that nothing in this Act, or the amendments made by this Act, should be construed as authorizing or granting parents the ability to deny any student who is not their own child from accessing any books or other reading materials otherwise available in the library of their child's school. (10 minutes) 10. Green (TN): Revises the bill to include the right to timely notice of any major cyberattack against their child's school that may have compromised student or parent information. (10 minutes) 11. Hunt (TX): Revises H.R.5 to add a provision including whether diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives factor into a school's plan to eliminate gifted and talented programs. (10 minutes) 12. Jacobs (CA): Strikes ``at no cost'' in the new paragraph (1)(A) of section 1112(e) of the ESEA, as added by section 104(2) of the bill. (10 minutes) 13. Jacobs (CA): Strikes the provisions relating to reviewing professional development materials in sections 104 and 202. (10 minutes) 14. Lawler (NY): Ensures this bill does not impose requirements on non-public elementary or secondary schools. Adds a sense of Congress that LEAs do not have authority over the curriculums of non-public elementary or secondary schools. (10 minutes) 15. Massie (KY), Boebert (CO), Gaetz (FL), Self (TX): Adds a sense of Congress that the authority of the Department of Education and the Secretary of Education to operate or administer any office or program related to elementary or secondary education should be terminated on or before December 31, 2023. (10 minutes) 16. McCormick (GA): Establishes that parents will be granted the opportunity to address their school board regarding a complaint about a violation of parental rights. (10 minutes) 17. McCormick (GA): Establishes parents' right to be informed of non-curriculum-based initiatives and events, and allows parents to opt-in their children to such initiatives and events. (10 minutes) 18. Miller (OH): Expands the definition of schools to include secondary career and technical schools. (10 minutes) 19. Roy (TX): Allows Title I funds to follow the student to the school they attend (i.e., public, private, or home school). These funds may be used for educational and instructional materials, tutoring, tuition for private school, and extracurricular activities. (10 minutes) 20. Roy (TX): Ensures all funds made available under the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 after the date of the enactment shall be consolidated and awarded to each State. (10 minutes) 21. Smith (NJ): Requires that the local educational agency discloses to parents any videos or recordings of violent activity of which they are aware. (10 minutes) 22. Tenney (NY): Adds plans to eliminate college credit courses to the list of required disclosures. (10 minutes) TEXT OF AMENDMENTS TO H.R. 5 MADE IN ORDER 1. An Amendment To Be Offered by Representative Bacon of Nebraska or His Designee, Debatable for 10 Minutes Page 9, line 4, strike ``and'' at the end. Page 9, line 9, strike the period, closed quotation mark, and semicolon and insert ``; and''. Page 9, after line 9, insert the following: ``(O) the right to be informed of the total number of school counselors in their child's school.''. Page 11, line 4, strike the closed quotation mark and ``; and''. Page 11, after line 4, insert the following new clause: ``(v) School counselors.--A local educational agency receiving funds under this part shall ensure that each elementary school and secondary school served by such agency provides the parents of each child who is a student in such school the information described in paragraph (1)(O).''. ---------- 2. An Amendment To Be Offered by Representative Foxx of North Carolina or Her Designee, Debatable for 10 Minutes Page 6, line 13, insert after ``right'' the following: ``(provided in accordance with the requirements of section 445(a)(2) of the General Education Provisions Act (20 U.S.C. 1232h(a)(2)) with respect to such local educational agency)''. Page 11, line 4, strike the closed quotes, and ``; and'', and insert the following: ``(v) Enrollment options.--A local educational agency receiving funds under this part shall ensure that each elementary school and secondary school served by such agency provides the parents of each child who is a student in such school the information described in paragraph (1)(F), including the enrollment and transfer options described in such paragraph. ``(vi) School employee or contractor actions.--A local educational agency receiving funds under this part shall ensure that each elementary school and secondary school served by such agency notifies the parents of any child who is a student in such school if a school employee or contractor takes, with respect to such child, any action described in clause (i) or (ii) of paragraph (1)(L). ``(vii) School and student safety.--A local educational agency receiving funds under this part shall ensure that each elementary school and secondary school served by such agency notifies-- ``(I) the parents of any child who is a student in such school if a school employee or contractor takes, with respect to such child, any action described in clause (i) of paragraph (1)(M); and ``(II) the parents of each child who is a student in such school if any child takes the action described in clause (ii) of paragraph (1)(M). ``(viii) Professional development materials.--A local educational agency receiving funds under this part shall ensure that each elementary school and secondary school served by such agency provides the parents of each child who is a student in such school the opportunity to review professional development materials to ensure the parental right described in paragraph (1)(J); and''. Page 12, line 3, strike ``Title VIII'' and insert the following: (a) In General.--Title VIII Page 13, after line 21, insert the following: (b) Table of Contents.--The table of contents in section 2 of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 is amended-- (1) by striking the item relating to section 8549C; and (2) by inserting after the item relating to section 8549B the following: Sec. 8549C. Sense of Congress on First Amendment Rights. Sec. 8549D. Technical assistance. Page 12, after line 11, insert the following new paragraph, and redesignate the succeeding paragraphs accordingly: ``(1) The right of parents to educate their children is a pre-political natural right that the U.S. Supreme Court has recognized as `beyond debate' and rooted in the `history and culture of Western civilization'.''. Page 13, strike lines 15 through 21, and insert the following: ``(b) Sense of Congress.--It is the sense of Congress that-- ``(1) the First Amendment guarantees parents and other stakeholders the right to assemble and express their opinions on decisions affecting their children and communities, and that educators and policymakers should welcome and encourage that engagement and consider that feedback when making decisions; and ``(2) parents have a fundamental right, protected by the U.S. Constitution, to direct the education of their children, and the strict scrutiny test used by courts to evaluate cases concerning fundamental rights is the correct standard of review for government actions that interfere with the right of parents to educate their children.''. Page 28, line 22, insert ``from the Department of Education'' after ``Federal funds''. Page 29, line 2, insert ``such'' before ``Federal funds''. ---------- 3. An Amendment To Be Offered by Representative Boebert of Colorado or Her Designee, Debatable for 10 Minutes Page 9, line 4, strike ``and''. Page 9, line 9, strike the semicolon, closed quotation marks, and period and insert ``; and''. Page 9, after line 9, insert the following: ``(O) the right to know if their child's school operates, sponsors, or facilitates athletic programs or activities that permit an individual whose biological sex is male to participate in an athletic program or activity that is designated for individuals whose biological sex is female.''. Page 11, line 4, strike the closed quotation marks and ``; and''. Page 11, after line 4, insert the following: ``(v) Athletic programs or activities.--A local educational agency receiving funds under this part shall ensure that each elementary school and secondary school served by such agency provides the parents of each child who is a student in such school the information described in paragraph (1)(O).''; and ---------- 4. An Amendment To Be Offered by Representative Boebert of Colorado or Her Designee, Deb

Source: https://api.congress.gov/v3/committee-report/118/hrpt/12