Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4366] The Committee on Appropriations submits the following report in explanation of the accompanying bill making appropriations for military construction, veterans affairs, and related agencies for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2024. INDEX TO BILL AND REPORT Page Number Bill Report Purpose of the Bill........................................ 2 Summary of Committee Recommendation........................ 2 Title I--Department of Defense: 2 3 Military Construction.............................. 2 3 NATO Security Investment Program................... 9 14 Department of Defense Base Closure Account......... 10 14 Family Housing Construction and Operation and Maintenance.................................... 10 16 Department of Defense Family Housing Improvement Fund........................................... 12 16 Department of Defense Military Unaccompanied Housing Improvement Fund....................... 12 17 Administrative Provisions.......................... 12 17 Title II--Department of Veterans Affairs: 30 19 Veterans Benefits Administration................... 30 22 Veterans Health Administration..................... 34 27 National Cemetery Administration................... 39 49 Departmental Administration........................ 39 50 Administrative Provisions.......................... 48 57 Title III--Related Agencies: 82 62 American Battle Monuments Commission............... 82 62 U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims.......... 83 63 Cemeterial Expenses, Army.......................... 83 63 Armed Forces Retirement Home....................... 84 64 Administrative Provision........................... 85 64 Title IV--General Provisions: 86 65 Purpose of the Bill The Military Construction, Veterans Affairs, and Related Agencies Appropriations bill funds the Department of Defense's activities related to military construction; family housing construction, maintenance, and oversight; and environmental remediation at closed military bases. The bill also funds the Department of Veterans Affairs, including programs to assist veterans, such as disability and pension benefits, education, healthcare, and insurance and loan programs. The bill funds four related agencies that honor and respect the Nation's veterans including the American Battle Monuments Commission; Cemeterial Expenses, Army (including Arlington National Cemetery); the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims; and the Armed Forces Retirement Home. Summary of Committee Recommendation The Committee recommends $317,441,342,000 in total budget authority for the fiscal year 2024 programs and activities funded in the bill. The bill includes $161,740,342,000 for mandatory programs and $155,701,000,000 for discretionary programs. The bill provides $17,474,000,000 for military construction and family housing. This is $1,526,000,000 below the fiscal year 2023 enacted level and $799,056,000 above the budget request. It includes $2,095,810,000 to address unfunded requirements of the Services and Combatant Commanders and increases investment in infrastructure in the Pacific region, unaccompanied personnel housing, and child development centers. The bill provides $299,495,645,000 for fiscal year 2024 for the Department of Veterans Affairs, which is a decrease of $3,786,953,000 below the fiscal year 2023 enacted level. Of the total, $161,740,342,000 is provided for mandatory benefit programs and $137,755,303,000 is provided for discretionary programs. Of the total for fiscal year 2024, $128,104,000,000 for veterans' healthcare was advanced in the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2023 (P.L 117-328). For fiscal year 2025, the Committee recommendation includes $112,582,000,000 in advance appropriations for the four discretionary veterans' medical care accounts and $193,048,534,000 in advance appropriations for mandatory benefits programs. The Committee recommendation provides a total of $471,697,000, which is $29,037,000 above the fiscal year 2023 enacted level, for the four Related Agencies: The American Battle Monuments Commission, the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims, Army Cemeterial Expenses (including Arlington National Cemetery), and the Armed Forces Retirement Home. TITLE I DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE Military Construction Overview Appropriation, fiscal year 2023....................... $19,000,000,000 Budget request, fiscal year 2024...................... 16,674,944,000 Committee recommendation, fiscal year 2024............ 17,474,000,000 Change from enacted level......................... -1,526,000,000 Change from budget request........................ +799,056,000 Military construction accounts provide funds for new construction, construction improvements, planning and design, and host nation support. Projects funded by these accounts include facilities for operations, training, readiness, maintenance, research and development, supply, medical care, and force protection as well as unaccompanied housing, military-owned family housing, utilities infrastructure, and land acquisition. COMMITTEE DIRECTIVES In addition to the notification and reporting requirements for military construction programs contained in Title 10, United States Code, the Committee's recommendations include several provisions requiring the Department of Defense to report on various aspects of military construction programs and to provide notification to the Committee when certain actions are taken. The Committee also retains prior approval authority for any reprogramming of funds exceeding a specific threshold. Reprogramming Guidelines.--The following reprogramming guidelines apply for all military construction and family housing projects. A project or account (including the sub- elements of an account) that has been specifically reduced by Congress in acting on the budget request is considered to be a Congressional interest item and as such, prior approval is required. Accordingly, no reprogramming to an item specifically reduced below the threshold by Congress is permitted, except that the Department may seek reprogramming for appropriated increments. The reprogramming criteria that applies to military construction projects is 25 percent of the funded amount or $6,000,000 and includes new housing construction projects and improvements. To provide the Services the flexibility to proceed with construction contracts without disruption or delay, the costs associated with environmental hazard remediation such as asbestos removal, radon abatement, lead- based paint removal or abatement, and any other legislated environmental hazard remediation may be excluded, if such remediation requirements could not be reasonably anticipated at the time of the budget submission. Reprogramming is a courtesy provided to the Department and can be taken away if the authority is abused. This exclusion applies to projects authorized in this budget year as well as projects authorized in prior years for which construction has not been completed. Planning and design costs associated with military construction and family housing projects may also be excluded from these guidelines. In instances where prior approval for a reprogramming request for a project or account has been received from the Committees on Appropriations of both Houses of Congress, the adjusted amount approved becomes the new base for any future increase or decrease via below-threshold reprogramming (provided that the project or account is not a Congressional interest item as defined above). In addition to these guidelines, the Services are directed to adhere to the guidance for military construction reprogramming actions and notifications, including the pertinent statutory authorities contained in DOD Financial Management Regulation 7000.14-R and relevant updates and policy memoranda. The Committee further encourages the Office of the Director of National Intelligence to use a format similar to that used by the Office of the Secretary of Defense to submit reprogramming requests. Facilities Sustainment, Restoration and Modernization (FSRM).--The Department is directed to continue describing on form 1390 the backlog of FSRM requirements at installations with future construction projects. For troop housing requests, form 1391 should describe any FSRM conducted in the past two years. Likewise, future requirements for unaccompanied housing at the corresponding installation should be included. Additionally, the forms should include English equivalent measurements for projects presented in metric measurement. Rules for funding repairs of facilities under the operation and maintenance accounts are described below: (1) components of the facility may be repaired by replacement. Such replacement can be up to current standards or codes; (2) interior arrangements and restorations may be included as repair; (3) additions and new facilities, may be done concurrently with repair projects as long as the final conjunctively funded project is a complete and usable facility; and (4) the appropriate Service Secretary shall notify the appropriate committees 21 days prior to carrying out any repair project with an estimated cost in excess of $7,500,000. Quarterly Summary of Notifications.--The Committee directs the Services and the Office of the Secretary of Defense (on behalf of itself and defense agencies) to continue to submit a quarterly report listing all notifications that have been submitted to the Committees during the preceding three-month period. Work in Progress or Planned (WIP) Curve.--The Committee directs the Services and the Office of the Secretary of Defense (on behalf of itself and defense agencies) to submit a WIP curve for each project requested in a budget submission above $90,000,000 with the form 1391 justification to the congressional defense committees. The Committee also directs the Secretary of Defense to report to the congressional defense committees quarterly, beginning in the second quarter of fiscal year 2024 and each quarter thereafter, of projects that remain unawarded from the current and prior fiscal years and the reasons for delay. Transfer of Funds to and from the Foreign Currency Fluctuations, Construction, Defense Account.--The Committee directs the Department of Defense to submit a quarterly report to the Committees on Appropriations of both Houses of Congress on the transfer of funds from military construction and family housing accounts to the Foreign Currency Fluctuations, Construction, Defense account. The report shall specify the amount transferred to the Foreign Currency account from each military construction and/or family housing account, and all other accounts for which an appropriation is provided in this Act, during the preceding fiscal quarter, and the amounts transferred from the Foreign Currency account to the above accounts during the same period. This report shall be submitted no later than 30 days after the close of each fiscal quarter. In addition, the Department shall notify the Committees on Appropriations of both Houses of Congress within 7 days of transferring any amount in excess of $10,000,000 to or from the Foreign Currency account. Bid Savings.--The Committee directs the Secretary of Defense to submit 1002 reports on military construction bid savings not later than 180 days after enactment of this Act, and biannually thereafter, to the Committees on Appropriations of both Houses of Congress. Incremental Funding of Projects.--In general, the Committee supports full funding for military construction projects if they are executable. However, it continues to be the practice of the Committee to provide incremental funding for certain large projects to enable the Services to more efficiently allocate military construction dollars among projects that can be executed in the year of appropriation. Unfunded Priority List (UPL) and Future Years Defense Program (FYDP).--The Committee directs the Department of Defense and Military Services, active and reserve components as well as Combatant Commanders, as required by law, to submit a UPL and FYDP to the congressional defense committees for military construction projects no later than 10 days and 5 days, respectively, after the President's budget is submitted to Congress. ITEMS OF INTEREST Advanced Manufacturing.--The Committee is encouraged by reports that three-dimensional (3D) construction could provide military civil engineers with a faster means of building facilities which could reduce supply lines and the number of personnel needed for construction and related activities. The Department of Defense is encouraged to study, develop, and utilize advanced manufacturing capabilities to the extent practicable. Barracks.--The bill provides $362,300,000 for 9 construction projects to ensure that servicemembers who live in barracks have safe, modern, and secure living facilities. The Committee also provides $195,000,000 for barracks replacement planning and design. Blood Processing Laboratory Infrastructure.--The Committee continues to recognize the importance of Department of Defense laboratory infrastructure and the investment needed to modernize outdated facilities and equipment. While the Department has taken steps in recent years to upgrade its laboratory infrastructure, the Committee is concerned that the Department is not properly prioritizing critical improvements to blood processing laboratory infrastructure and that this presents a risk to readiness. Therefore, the Committee directs the Department to provide a report on the status of blood processing laboratory infrastructure and its strategy to modernize such infrastructure within 180 days of enactment of this Act. Delivery and Cost of Military Construction Projects.--The Committee appreciates the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers' March 2023 report titled, ``U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Contracting Study Response: Recommended Reforms to Reduce Cost and Accelerate Project Delivery.'' The Committee encourages the Department to review progressive design-build as a potential construction contract method as it may provide efficiencies. Demolition of Excess Infrastructure.--The bill includes $90,000,000 for unspecified minor military construction for demolition across the active and reserve components. The Committee is concerned about the amount of excess and obsolete infrastructure found on installations. While the Committee understands the need to balance demolition with other infrastructure needs, excess infrastructure can be costly to maintain and diverts resources away from current requirements. Child Development Centers (CDCs).--The bill includes $75,000,000 for planning and design and $293,820,000 for construction of 7 CDC projects. Infrastructure Needs to Support Alliance with the Philippines.--The Committee notes the importance of the recently reinvigorated alliance with the Philippines. To better understand the Department of Defense's needs to support the expanded alliance, the Committee directs the Secretary of Defense to provide a report, not later than 180 days after the date of the enactment of this Act, summarizing the plans for military construction and associated infrastructure needs to maximize the effectiveness of an enhanced posture in and alliance with the Philippines. Laboratory Infrastructure.--The Committee is concerned that aging laboratory infrastructure threatens the ability of Services to maintain the advanced technology necessary to keep ahead of U.S. adversaries across all domains. Accordingly, the Committee provides an additional $90,000,000 for planning and design for laboratory infrastructure projects. The Services are directed to provide a spend plan not later than 90 days after enactment of this Act regarding the use of these funds. Mass Timber.--The Committee is aware that the use of cross laminated timber and other mass timber products as a building material has the potential to reduce costs, limit environmental impact, and increase functionality of various military structures. The Committee encourages the Department of Defense to continue exploring the application of these innovative technologies in future planning and design for military construction projects. Open Air Burn Pans.--The Committee remains concerned about the burning of hazardous materials, including open air burn pans, at installations located in the United States and looks forward to receiving the report on the Department's plans to address this issue as required by House Report 117-391. Resilient Military Installations.--The Committee supports the Department's continued efforts to build lasting and resilient military installations. These efforts include using methods that update hurricane-resistant building codes for bases, barracks, hospitals, and airfields and reviewing the effect of severe drought and desertification and how these two hazards effect installations and missions. The Committee encourages the Department to continue investing in innovative infrastructure projects to increase infrastructure resiliency and reduce costs. Unspecified Minor Military Construction (UMMC).--The bill includes $414,192,000