Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4367] The Committee on Appropriations submits the following report in explanation of the accompanying bill making appropriations for the Department of Homeland Security for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2024. INDEX TO BILL AND REPORT Page number Bill Report TITLE I--DEPARTMENTAL MANAGEMENT, OPERATIONS, INTELLIGENCE, AND OVERSIGHT Office of the Secretary and Executive Management... 3 6 Operations and Support..................... 3 6 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 11 Federal Assistance......................... 11 Management Directorate............................. 4 12 Operations and Support..................... 4 12 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 4 14 Federal Protective Service................. 4 15 Intelligence, Analysis, and Situational Awareness.. 5 15 Operations and Support..................... 5 15 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 16 Office of Inspector General........................ 5 17 Operations and Support..................... 5 17 Administrative Provisions.......................... 5 17 TITLE II--SECURITY, ENFORCEMENT, AND INVESTIGATIONS U.S. Customs and Border Protection................. 13 18 Operations and Support..................... 13 18 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 14 30 U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement........... 15 33 Operations and Support..................... 15 33 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 16 42 Transportation Security Administration............. 17 43 Operations and Support..................... 17 43 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 17 45 Research and Development................... 17 45 Coast Guard........................................ 18 46 Operations and Support..................... 18 46 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 19 48 Research and Development................... 19 51 Health Care Fund Contribution.............. 51 Retired Pay................................ 20 52 United States Secret Service....................... 20 52 Operations and Support..................... 20 52 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 22 53 Research and Development................... 22 53 Administrative Provisions.......................... 22 53 TITLE III--PROTECTION, PREPAREDNESS, RESPONSE, AND RECOVERY Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency... 41 56 Operations and Support..................... 41 56 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 41 65 Research and Development................... 41 66 Federal Emergency Management Agency................ 42 66 Operations and Support..................... 42 66 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 42 70 Federal Assistance......................... 42 70 Disaster Relief Fund....................... 46 73 National Flood Insurance Fund.............. 47 74 Administrative Provisions.......................... 49 74 TITLE IV--RESEARCH, DEVELOPMENT, TRAINING, AND SERVICES U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.......... 54 75 Operations and Support..................... 54 75 Federal Assistance......................... 78 Federal Law Enforcement Training Centers........... 54 78 Operations and Support..................... 54 79 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 55 79 Science and Technology Directorate................. 55 79 Operations and Support..................... 55 80 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 55 80 Research and Development................... 55 81 Countering Weapons of Mass Destruction Office...... 56 85 Operations and Support..................... 56 85 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 56 85 Research and Development................... 56 86 Federal Assistance......................... 56 86 Administrative Provisions.......................... 57 86 TITLE V--GENERAL PROVISIONS This Act........................................... 87 House of Representatives Reporting Requirements.... 92 Overview March 1, 2023, marked the twentieth anniversary for the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, which was created in the wake of the deadliest terrorist attack on U.S. soil. The 22 legacy agencies that were hastily cobbled together in the Homeland Security Act of 2002 have matured into an organization that now employs over 260,000 people, making it the third largest federal cabinet department. The Committee recommendation includes $91,515,476,000 in total discretionary appropriations for the Department of Homeland Security, including $62,793,000,000 within the bill's 302(b) budget allocation, $5,837,370,000 in discretionary appropriations offset by fee collections, and $20,261,000,000 as an allocation adjustment for major disaster response and recovery activities. The total within the 302(b) allocation is $2,090,000,000 above the fiscal year 2023 level. Homeland Security Investments Investments in this bill are intended to balance competing priorities across the Department's important missions, all of which are critical to the security of the country. The bill makes important investments in border security and immigration enforcement to help address the ongoing border security crisis, including providing funding for physical barriers, border security technology, and additional Border Patrol Agents; funds the deployment of additional Non-Intrusive Inspection technology at ports of entry to increase the detection of fentanyl; funds artificial intelligence and machine learning capabilities to reduce manual review of cargo and vehicle images; invests in detention capacity and removal operations; continues recapitalization of the Coast Guard surface and aviation fleets, including continued support for the Fast Response Cutter, Polar Security Cutter, and Offshore Patrol Cutter programs; provides funds for the U.S. Secret Service to prepare for the 2024 Presidential campaign; and continues modernization of intrusion detection and prevention cybersecurity efforts for federal civilian networks. Border Security For the last two years, migrant encounters have skyrocketed, straining U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agents and officers in the field. In lieu of managing the crisis at the border through the use of temporary and costly measures that have minimal impact on illicit migration flows, this bill includes long-term border security investments that seek to increase the agency's ability to deter would-be illicit border activity. The bill recommends $856,757,000 above the request level for CBP operations, including $496,260,000 for additional U.S. Border Patrol personnel to bring total end strength to 22,000 agents, and $35,000,000 for innovative technology. Within the funds provided, the bill recommends not less than the following: $43,988,000 for workforce care; $6,000,000 for carrizo cane control; $21,000,000 for autonomous surveillance towers; $18,500,000 for tactical aerostats; and $10,440,000 for cross border tunnel threat detection. Within CBP's Procurement, Construction, and Improvements account, the recommendation includes $2,246,512,000 above the request for new physical barriers and border security technology both at and between the ports of entry. Immigration Enforcement Immigration detention is a critical element of our immigration system. Appropriate levels of detention allow U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to detain migrants subject to mandatory detention under the Immigration and Nationality Act, as well as recent border crossers and migrants who present a risk to public safety. Most of the migrants encountered at the border do not eventually receive asylum. The Committee recognizes that detention can be a deterrent for migrants without valid asylum claims, including many who are coached by the cartels to game the asylum system, harming legitimate asylum seekers in the process. Increased detention capacity also ensures that ICE law enforcement can effectuate removal orders for aliens who no longer have a basis to remain in the country. In stark contrast to the request and previous years, this bill provides $1,235,176,000 above the request to significantly expand detention capacity by providing funding consistent with an average daily population of 41,500 during fiscal year 2024, an increase of 7,500 over last year and 16,500 higher than the request. Such detention capacity will allow ICE to arrest, detain, and remove additional migrants who are recent border crossers or public safety threats. Transportation Security The Committee supports the Transportation Security Administration's (TSA) implementation of changes to the agency's pay structure to ensure its frontline workforce is paid at a level that is commensurate with other federal agencies. The bill provides $855,989,000 to implement the proposed pay adjustments for Transportation Security Officers. The Committee hopes that this investment lives up to the promises of TSA leadership and addresses the agency's long- standing recruitment and retention challenges. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Recognizing that the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) budget has grown 44 percent over the last three fiscal years, the bill provides $2,926,291,000 to sustain investments in securing federal civilian cyber networks and helping state and local governments and the private sector secure both cyber and physical infrastructure. The amount is $19,153,000 above the fiscal year 2023 enacted level. This strategic pause in significant budget growth provides CISA the opportunity to mature its operations commensurate with the enacted level. Citizenship and Immigration Processing With few exceptions, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) has historically operated as a fee-funded agency, with its operating expenses originating primarily from fees charged to applicants and petitioners seeking immigration benefits. The bill returns to this traditional funding structure and includes appropriated funding only for the E- Verify program. The Committee encourages USCIS to reevaluate its fee structure to recover the costs of its operations, as the law allows. Southwest Border Contingency Fund For the last two years, this Administration has focused on ``managing'' the border, which in practice has meant building more capacity to process aliens more quickly into the country, rather than enforcing the nation's immigration laws. The request doubles down on that failed policy by proposing a $4,700,000,000 slush fund which would release funds if certain thresholds of illicit migration are reached at certain points in the fiscal year. Such a structure incentivizes the Department to do nothing to secure the border and deter migrants from making a dangerous journey to this country. Increased encounters at the border indicate that migrants view the border as ``open for business,'' despite claims to the contrary. Opening false ``pathways'' under the illusion of an orderly process only exacerbates the problem, giving false hope to many migrants who have no legal basis for entry. The Committee urges the Secretary to swiftly reverse course and send a message that migrants will be expeditiously removed by securing the border and robustly enforcing immigration laws already available under Title 8, United States Code. The recommendation does not include the proposed Southwest Border Contingency Fund. References in the Report This report refers to certain entities, persons, funds, and documents as follows: the ``Department of Homeland Security'' is referenced as DHS or the Department; ``full-time equivalents'' are referred to as FTE; ``Government Accountability Office'' is referenced as GAO; ``Information Technology'' is referred to as IT; ``Office of Inspector General'' is referenced as OIG; ``program, project, and activity'' is referred to as PPA; any reference to ``the Secretary'' should be interpreted to mean the Secretary of Homeland Security; ``component'' should be interpreted to mean an agency, administration, or directorate within DHS; any reference to ``SLTT'' should be interpreted to mean state, local, tribal, and territorial; and ``budget request'' or ``the request'' should be interpreted to mean the budget of the U.S. Government for fiscal year 2024 that was submitted to Congress on March 9, 2023. Administrative and General Provisions The bill does not continue several administrative and general provisions which have been carried for years. The Committee's intent is to remove provisions that are no longer needed or are outdated; reduce redundancy with current law; and eliminate duplication with existing provisions in the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) or existing Department policies, such as the Homeland Security Acquisition Manual. The Committee continues to fully support the legislative intent of these provisions. TITLE I--DEPARTMENTAL MANAGEMENT, OPERATIONS, INTELLIGENCE, AND OVERSIGHT Mission The mission of Departmental Management, Operations, Intelligence, and Oversight is to provide leadership and services to Department of Homeland Security (DHS) components; formulate policy guidance and directives; disseminate intelligence; identify and track performance measurements relating to DHS missions; and provide oversight for all DHS operations. Office of the Secretary and Executive Management Appropriation, fiscal year 2023....................... $384,794,000 Budget request, fiscal year 2024...................... 328,055,000 Recommended in the bill............................... 279,606,000 Bill compared with: Appropriation, fiscal year 2023..................... -105,188,000 Budget request, fiscal year 2024.................... -48,449,000 The Office of th