Skip to content

house · Committee report

H. Rept. 118-124

AGRICULTURE, RURAL DEVELOPMENT, FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION, AND RELATED AGENCIES APPROPRIATIONS BILL, 2024

2023-06-27

Committees

Associated legislation

Text

Dissenting Views

[To accompany H.R. 4368] The Committee on Appropriations submits the following report in explanation of the accompanying bill making appropriations for Agriculture, Rural Development, Food and Drug Administration, and Related Agencies for fiscal year 2024. CONTENTS Page Title I--Agricultural Programs................................... 3 Title II--Farm Production and Conservation Programs.............. 42 Title III--Rural Development Programs............................ 52 Title IV--Domestic Food Programs................................. 64 Title V--Foreign Assistance and Related Programs................. 70 Title VI--Related Agencies and Food and Drug Administration...... 72 Title VII--General Provisions.................................... 92 OVERVIEW The Agriculture, Rural Development, Food and Drug Administration, and Related Agencies Subcommittee has jurisdiction over the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) except for the Forest Service, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), and the Farm Credit Administration (FCA). The Subcommittee's responsibility covers matters of importance to Americans every day of the year. The fiscal year 2024 allocation is $17,838,000,000, in addition to $7,475,000,000 in reallocated funds, for a discretionary spending total of $25,313,000,000. This is $532,000,000 below the fiscal year 2023 enacted level and $3,621,922,000 below the President's budget request for fiscal year 2024. The funding levels provided in this appropriations bill continue to demonstrate how seriously this Committee takes its responsibility to fund the highest priority programs and activities while helping to address the nation's debt, deficit, and economic challenges and rein in regulatory overreach at USDA, FDA, and CFTC. The Committee does not include funding to begin new programs and, except where specifically noted, does not provide additional funding for pay increases. In this report, ``the Committees'' refers to the Committees on Appropriations of the House of Representatives and the Senate. The Subcommittee held five hearings related to the agencies it funds. Those hearings were: USDA Inspector General--March 9, 2023 Member Day--March 23, 2023 The FY 2024 Budget Request for the Commodity Futures Trading Commission--March 28, 2023 The FY 2024 Budget Request for the Food and Drug Administration--March 29, 2023 The FY 2024 Budget Request for the Department of Agriculture--March 30, 2023 Agroforestry Strategic Framework.--The Department created an Agroforestry Framework in 2018 which provided a mechanism to coordinate and facilitate wide scale adoption of agroforestry. The framework is an opportunity to highlight Agroforestry across the breadth of USDA's authorities, including but not limited to the Natural Resource Conservation Service, Agricultural Research Service, Forest Service, and the National Agricultural Statistical Service. The framework expires in 2024 and as the Department begins to update the framework, the Committee urges the Department to seek extensive external stakeholder input and brief the committee on the status of the framework. Cybersecurity.--The Committee remains concerned about continued cybersecurity threats and attacks on the nation's food and agriculture sector. The Committee recognizes the importance of strong cybersecurity in critical sectors like agriculture and urges the Department to improve its cybersecurity posture, including through collaboration with appropriate Federal agencies to mitigate potential cybersecurity threats. Persistent Poverty Areas.--The Committee supports targeted investments in impoverished areas. The Committee directs the Department to develop and implement measures to increase the share of investments in persistent poverty counties, distressed communities, and other impoverished areas. The Committee directs the Department to submit a report to the Committee that includes the total amount of Federal investments targeted toward such areas; a list of the programs under which the amount of Federal investments to such areas were increased in fiscal year 2024; the percent change in the amount of funds that were targeted to such areas from fiscal year 2023; and to the extent practicable, an assessment of the economic impact of departmental programs in these areas. Promoting U.S. Competitiveness in Biotechnology.--The Committee acknowledges that the U.S. is a world leader in agricultural biotechnology. As the world faces changing rainfall patterns, increased input costs, and strains on the global supply chains, agricultural biotechnology offers solutions that can increase yields, reduce land and water use, and improve crop resilience. The Committee urges USDA mission areas, including the Foreign Agriculture Service and Rural Development, to bolster U.S.-developed biotechnology through their respective programs. TITLE I AGRICULTURAL PROGRAMS Processing, Research and Marketing Office of the Secretary (INCLUDING TRANSFERS OF FUNDS) 2023 appropriation.................................... $65,067,000 2024 budget estimate.................................. 112,634,000 Provided in the bill.................................. 41,072,000 Comparison: 2023 appropriation.................................. -23,995,000 2024 budget estimate................................ -71,562,000 The following table reflects the amount provided by the Committee for each office and activity: [Dollars in thousands] ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Committee FY 2023 FY 2024 enacted estimate provision ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Office of the Secretary.............. $7,432 $34,713 $5,051 Office of Homeland Security.......... 1,396 2,396 1,578 Office of Tribal Relations........... 5,190 6,533 2,215 Office of Partnerships and Public 9,280 10,357 7,044 Engagement.......................... Office of the Assistant Secretary for 1,706 1,742 875 Administration...................... Departmental Administration.......... 26,716 35,627 20,440 Office of the Assistant Secretary for 4,609 4,727 3,869 Congressional Relations and Intergovernmental Affairs........... Office of Communications............. 8,738 16,539 0 ---------------------------------- Total, Office of the Secretary... 65,067 112,634 41,072 ------------------------------------------------------------------------ COMMITTEE PROVISIONS For the Office of the Secretary, the Committee provides an appropriation of $41,072,000. Similar to prior years, the Committee does not include direct funding for activities that are currently funded through other resources, such as the Working Capital Fund, or that have historically been funded through other means. California Storms and Flooding.--The Committee is aware of the recent historic storms in the State of California. The Committee is concerned about the impact flooding from these storms is currently having on productive farmland in the State. While damage is still being assessed and its ultimate extent is not yet known, it appears damage to farmland and crops could be extensive. Furthermore, the Committee notes that the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) predicts an increased threat of additional flooding in the spring due to snowmelt from the Sierra Nevada snowpack that will likely be exacerbated by already elevated soil moisture levels. Accordingly, the Committee directs the Secretary to expeditiously exercise, to the fullest extent, all disaster response and assistance authorities provided under the law to assist agricultural producers in the State of California adversely impacted by recent flooding and to ensure that, should additional flooding occur later this year, the Department is prepared to respond efficiently and quickly to assist agricultural producers who are adversely impacted. Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC) Report.--The Committee directs the Secretary to provide a report on November 15, 2023, and May 15, 2024, on planned uses of funding under the authorities of Section 4 and Section 11 of the CCC Charter Act. CCC Obligations and Commitments.--The Secretary is directed to notify the Committees in writing 15 days prior to any announcement on the use of funds from the CCC or the obligation or commitment of any emergency funds from the CCC. Communication from USDA.--A collaborative working relationship between the Committee and USDA is necessary to ensure efficient and effective implementation of Congress' funding decisions. USDA is directed to ensure that the Committee is notified of major changes to existing policies and any significant developments in its operations before providing non-governmental stakeholders such information, before making the changes public, and before implementing them. Communications Services.--The Committee urges the Department to establish uniform communication practices across all mission areas utilizing local digital, television, and radio advertising. The Committee further directs the Department and agencies funded by this Act with annual advertising budgets to submit a report within 30 days of enactment of this Act on expenditures related to local media advertising, including expenditures on local digital, television, and radio advertising. Construction Management.--The Committee intends to provide local governments and local utilities with the necessary tools to maximize Federal investments and encourages USDA to allow local governments and units of local governments to utilize Construction Management services in addition to traditional design-build services within all USDA-funded construction and infrastructure projects. Construction Management services provide a level of construction management expertise and experience that many rural communities and governmental units lack and can ensure a more efficient and cost-effective project execution during the construction process. Contracting and Procurement.--The Committee believes that, as one of the largest contractors in the United States, USDA should work to ensure fair access to its contracts for small businesses. Accordingly, the Committee urges each agency and office with a procurement function to increase awareness of technical assistance and strategic planning grants available for small businesses. Customer Service.--The Committee continues to support the Department's efforts to improve customer service. The Committee directs the Secretary to develop standards to improve customer service, incorporate the standards into the performance plans required under 31 U.S.C. 1115, and submit a report on these efforts within 60 days of enactment of this Act. Explanatory Notes.--The Committee appreciates the Department's work to restore the Explanatory Notes to the same format as they had been presented in prior to fiscal year 2021 and directs that this format be maintained for fiscal year 2025 and beyond. Farmworkers.--Strong working conditions for our farmworkers are critical to the resiliency of the food and agricultural supply chain. The Committee is supportive of USDA's efforts to improve working conditions for women farmworkers who are vulnerable to exploitation in the workplace. The Committee requests the Department to conduct a study to understand the work conditions and challenges faced by women farmworkers and to develop recommendations on how the Department can promote improvements through its programs and pilots. A report shall be submitted to the Committee on these efforts within 60 days of enactment of this Act. Food Waste Consumer Education.--The Committee recommends that USDA enter into public-private partnerships to provide consumer-facing outreach on food loss and waste and prevention strategies. Grain Terminals.--The Committee notes the ongoing contract negotiations between West Coast grain terminal operators and the union and recognizes the importance of reaching an agreement that works for both parties. Failure to reach an agreement could result in an interruption in grain terminal service that would negatively impact the nation's grain exports. The Committee urges all parties to continue negotiating in good faith to ensure a favorable outcome. Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza (HPAI).--The Committee is concerned by the ongoing outbreak of HPAI that has resulted in the loss of over 58 million birds and the correlation to increased egg prices. The Committee recognizes and is sensitive to the effects a voluntary vaccine may have on international trade relationships. However, the Committee is also aware that USDA has used vaccines against low pathogenic avian influenza and that the Southeast Poultry Research Laboratory has conducted substantial research in the development of a vaccine, including a candidate vaccine seed strain for an inactivated vaccine. The Committee directs USDA to report on the status of vaccine development and engage with other relevant agencies to develop a comprehensive HPAI strategy that includes a voluntary vaccine for laying hens and turkeys only, mitigates concerns of international trade partners, and is in line with applicable international standards and agreements. Improved Customer Service.--Pursuant to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Memorandum on ``Measuring, Monitoring, and Improving Organizational Health and Organization Performance in the Context of Evolving Agency Work Environments'' (M-23-15) published on April 13, 2023, the Committee directs the Department to increase USDA in-person presence at both USDA headquarters offices located in the National Capital Region and in USDA regional, State, and county offices in order to provide improved customer service. Improving Tribal Consultation.--The Committee encourages the Office of Tribal Relations and the Office of Budget and Program Analysis (OBPA) to establish a regular tribal consultation process when formulating budget requests and multi-year program reauthorizations that have budgetary impacts. Intermediate Crops.--The Committee is aware of a burgeoning industry of nonfood crops, such as camelina, that can be grown on existing farmland between primary crops to produce feedstock for renewable biofuels and chemicals. These intermediate crops offer similar environmental benefits to cover crops and represent a new source of additive income for agricultural producers. The Committee encourages USDA to consider opportunities to utilize existing programs and resources to support intermediate crop production in the United States. Loan and Grant Programs.--The Committee directs that if an estimate of loan activity for any program funded in Titles II and III of this bill indicates that a limitation on authority to make commitments for a fiscal year will be reached before the end of that fiscal year, or in any event when 75 percent of the authority to make commitments has been utilized, the Secretary shall promptly notify the Committees through OBPA. The Committee directs the Department, through OBPA, to provide quarterly reports to the Committees on the status of obligations and funds availability for the loan and grant programs provided in this bill. Multiagency Broadband Program Study.--The Committee directs the Government Accountability Office (GAO) to conduct a study of all federal broadband connectivity programs funded in the previous five fiscal years, including through emergency supplemental appropriations and the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (P.L. 117-58), in order to evaluate each program's efficacy rates in providing internet access to underserved and not-yet-served communities. Such study shall identify the total amount of federal broadband funding appropriated, the number of grants awarded, the average award size, and the specific geographic location of grant awards for each program and evaluate the effectiveness of each broadband program in providing internet access to individuals in communities that were below rates of 25/3 Mbps prior to relevant grant awards. National Finance Center.--The National Finance Center (NFC) is the largest designated Federal Government Payroll Shared Service Provider, and it provides integrated payroll and personnel services for over 640,000 Federal employees. To ensure that thousands of Federal employees' pay and human resources services are not interrupted or adversely impacted by major organizational changes, the Committee continues requirements under current law relating to NFC payroll and shared services operations, missions, personnel, and functions. The Committee also directs USDA to provide quarterly reports on full-time equivalent (FTE) levels for each of the current NFC divisions, operations, and functions, as well as each of the Office of the Chief Financial Officer (OCFO) and Office of the Chief Information Officer (OCIO) divisions, operations, and functions currently co-located with the NFC. The reports also are to include a detailed breakdown of the FTEs for each and any of these same divisions, functions, or operations for the NFC and the co-located OCFO and OCIO functions compared to those during FY 2017 and 2018. New Initiatives.--The Committee directs USDA, no later than 120 days after enactment, to submit an execution plan for each new initiative funded in this Act. This strategy should include, but is not limited to, the steps necessary to make funding available, the timeline thereof, targeted beneficiaries, and expected results. The Committee requests quarterly reports on these initiatives until the initiative has been fully implemented. Notification Requirements.--The Committee reminds the Department that the Committee uses the definitions for transfer, reprogramming, and program, project, and activity as defined by the Government Accountability Office (GAO). As noted in the fiscal year 2023 Joint Explanatory Statement, a program, project, or activity (PPA) is an element within a budget account. PPAs are identified by reference to include the most specific level of budget items identified in the Agriculture, Rural Development, Food and Drug Administration, and Related Agencies Act, 2023, accompanying Committee reports, explanatory statements, and budget justifications. The Committee notes that the most specific level of budget items in USDA budget justifications is not limited to tables titled ``Project Statement''. PFAS.--The Committee notes that there are previously provided funds related to polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) which remain available. The Committee remains concerned that there are significant knowledge gaps related to PFAS and its impact on agriculture. Therefore, the Committee awaits a

Dissenting Views

This is a dreadful bill that we very strongly oppose. As Secretary Vilsack said, the bill is ``pathetic, punitive, and petty.'' It takes food from women, infants, and children by slashing the monthly funds provided for WIC participants to buy fruits and vegetables by as much as 70% and drastically underfunding the WIC account itself at a time of rising participation and food costs. It favors farmer foreclosure over farming by rescinding the funds provided to assist farmers and ranchers who are underwater in their FSA loans. To date, USDA has helped 20,000 farmers get out from under the financial burdens. The producers who remain to be served as those who took extraordinary personal financial risks to try to stay current on their loans and who will need one-on-one assistance from USDA. It handicaps the ability of the Secretary to assist farmers under the Commodity Credit Corporation. This is based on the belief that the Secretary somehow ``over-used'' CCC, when in fact his use of $10 billion is dwarfed by his predecessor's drawdown of $52 billion. That was so excessive Congress had to twice refill the CCC to prevent USDA not being able to meet obligations to farmers under existing programs. It harms women of child-bearing age by reversing FDA's 2021 decision to remove the in-person dispensing requirement for Mifepristone. The experts on this issue are not Republicans on the Appropriations Committee, but the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. They said: There is no clinical evidence that in-person dispensing improves the safety of this medication or patient outcomes; instead, this requirement unnecessarily restricted patient access to a safe and effective medication. The bill slaps our rural electric coops and their customers in the face by rescinding $1 billion from funding that Congress said was to be used ``for the long-term resiliency, reliability, and affordability of rural electric systems.'' This funding is the largest investment in rural electricity since 1936. An effort to modify language related to purchase of agricultural land by our foreign adversaries was unsuccessful. This resulted in poorly drafted and ambiguous language being added to the bill. No American wants to allow hostile countries to control our agricultural land. It contains a laundry list of petty, mean-spirited provisions that are aimed at LGBTQ Americans, persons of color, disabled persons, and underserved communities, which includes an enormous swath of rural America. Despite decades of litigation over USDA's past discriminatory practices against producers of color, women, and Native Americans, for which the government has paid billions of dollars in compensation, the bill not only prohibits implementation of Executive Orders aimed at preventing similar practices going forward, but the bill also cuts the Office of Civil Rights and the Office of Tribal Relations. Although in two successive full committee markups no Republican has been able to define it, the bill adopts the request of 15 committee members for language banning the agencies in the bill from promoting or advancing ``critical race theory.'' It is extremely unwise to ban agencies from doing something you cannot define. In the Farm Services Agency and Rural Development Salaries and Expenses accounts, the report is very critical of agency staffing, yet both accounts are cut severely below the President's request and the 2023 levels. Both, like almost every other agency, will also be required to absorb a 5.2% pay increase with these diminished funds. For some reason, the bill zeroes out the tiny Office of Codex Alimentarius, whose whole purpose is to ensure science- and rules-based international trade. Its work has protected American producers against a laundry list of foreign protectionist policies that would shut U.S. products from foreign markets. In an act of pettiness, the bill zeroes out the USDA Office of Communications, in retribution for a USDA press release that criticized the Republicans' debt limit legislation, despite conclusive proof by the Department that the press release was lawfully issued. A final note on process. After abruptly canceling the original scheduled full committee markup, the process was halted by chaos in the Republican caucus. Perhaps as a distraction, the full committee markup was suddenly rescheduled, with major changes needed to address offsets lost in the debt limit bill. The Democrats were not allowed to see the changes until 21 hours before the markup. This is an outrageous violation of the comity that previously governed the sharing of information between the parties and contributed to what was an unnecessarily chaotic and confusing markup. We will oppose the bill and will work to produce a bipartisan bill in conference with an appropriate 302(b) level that allows the egregious rescissions in the committee bill to be dropped. Rosa L. DeLauro. Sanford D. Bishop, Jr. [all]

Source: https://api.congress.gov/v3/committee-report/118/hrpt/124