Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4394] The Committee on Appropriations submits the following report in explanation of the accompanying bill making appropriations for energy and water development for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2024, and for other purposes. INDEX TO BILL AND REPORT Page Number Bill Report Introduction............................................... 5 I. Department of Defense--Civil:........................... 1 8 Corps of Engineers--Civil:......................... 2 8 Investigations............................. 2 15 Construction............................... 3 25 Mississippi River and Tributaries.......... 4 34 Operation and Maintenance.................. 4 38 Regulatory Program......................... 6 65 Formerly Utilized Sites Remedial Action Program................................ 6 66 Flood Control and Coastal Emergencies...... 7 66 Expenses................................... 7 66 Office of the Assistant Secretary of the Army (Civil Works)..................... 8 67 Water Infrastructure Finance and Innovation Program................................ 8 68 General Provisions................................. 9 68 II. Department of the Interior:............................ 16 69 Central Utah Project:.............................. 16 69 Central Utah Project Completion Account.... 16 69 Bureau of Reclamation:............................. 17 69 Water and Related Resources................ 17 70 Central Valley Project Restoration Fund.... 19 83 California Bay-Delta Restoration........... 20 83 Policy and Administration.................. 21 83 General Provisions................................. 21 84 III. Department of Energy:................................. 25 84 Introduction....................................... 25 84 Committee Recommendations.......................... 84 Energy Programs:................................... 25 88 Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy..... 25 88 Cybersecurity, Energy Security, and Emergency Response..................... 26 101 Electricity................................ 26 102 Nuclear Energy............................. 27 104 Fossil Energy Research and Development..... 27 109 Naval Petroleum and Oil Shale Reserves..... 28 113 Strategic Petroleum Reserve................ 28 114 Northeast Home Heating Oil Reserve......... 29 114 Energy Information Administration.......... 29 114 Non-Defense Environmental Cleanup.......... 29 114 Uranium Enrichment Decontamination and Decommissioning Fund................... 30 115 Science.................................... 30 115 Nuclear Waste Disposal..................... 31 122 Technology Transitions..................... 31 122 Clean Energy Demonstrations................ 31 123 Advanced Research Projects Agency--Energy.. 31 123 Title 17 Innovative Technology Loan Guarantee Program...................... 32 124 Advanced Technology Vehicles Manufacturing Loan Program........................... 33 124 Tribal Energy Loan Guarantee Program....... 33 124 Indian Energy Policy and Programs.......... 34 125 Departmental Administration................ 34 125 Office of the Inspector General............ 35 126 Atomic Energy Defense Activities:.................. 35 127 National Nuclear Security Administration:.......... 35 127 Weapons Activities......................... 35 128 Defense Nuclear Nonproliferation........... 36 132 Naval Reactors............................. 36 133 Federal Salaries and Expenses.............. 37 133 Environmental and Other Defense Activities......... 37 134 Defense Environmental Cleanup.............. 37 134 Other Defense Activities................... 37 135 Power Marketing Administrations:................... 38 135 Bonneville Power Administration............ 38 136 Southeastern Power Administration.......... 38 136 Southwestern Power Administration.......... 40 136 Western Area Power Administration.......... 41 136 Falcon and Amistad Operating and Maintenance Fund....................... 43 137 Federal Energy Regulatory Commission............... 44 137 Committee Recommendation........................... 137 General Provisions................................. 45 184 IV. Independent Agencies:.................................. 58 185 Appalachian Regional Commission.................... 58 185 Defense Nuclear Facilities Safety Board............ 58 185 Delta Regional Authority........................... 58 186 Denali Commission.................................. 59 186 Northern Border Regional Commission................ 60 187 Southeast Crescent Regional Commission............. 60 187 Southwest Border Regional Commission............... 60 187 Great Lakes Authority.............................. 60 188 Nuclear Regulatory Commission...................... 61 188 Nuclear Waste Technical Review Board............... 62 191 General Provisions................................. 62 191 V. Water for California:................................... 64 191 VI. General Provisions:.................................... 94 192 House of Representatives Report Requirements............... 193 SUMMARY OF ESTIMATES AND RECOMMENDATIONS The Committee has considered budget estimates, which are contained in the Budget of the United States Government, Fiscal Year 2024. The following table summarizes appropriations for fiscal year 2023, the budget estimates, and amounts recommended in the bill for fiscal year 2024. INTRODUCTION The Energy and Water Development and Related Agencies Appropriations bill for fiscal year 2024 totals $52,378,000,000, $1,622,000,000 below fiscal year 2023 and $7,542,590,000 below the budget request. Title I of the bill provides $9,570,000,000 for the Civil Works programs of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, $1,260,000,000 above fiscal year 2023 and $2,157,000,000 above the budget request. The bill makes use of the adjustments provided in Public Law 116-136 and Public Law 116-260 regarding the Harbor Maintenance Trust Fund and section 2106(c) of the Water Resources Reform and Development Act of 2014. Total funding for activities eligible for reimbursement from the Harbor Maintenance Trust Fund (HMTF) are estimated at $2,771,000,000, $453,000 above fiscal year 2023 and $1,045,000,000 above the budget request. Title II provides $1,862,953,000 for the Department of the Interior and the Bureau of Reclamation, $394,083,000 above the budget request. The Committee recommends $1,839,953,000 for the Bureau of Reclamation, $390,639,000 above the budget request. The Committee recommends $23,000,000 for the Central Utah Project, equal to fiscal year 2023 and $3,444,000 above the budget request. Title III provides $43,298,519,000 for the Department of Energy, $2,944,840,000 below fiscal year 2023 and $9,272,593,000 below the budget request. Funding for the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA), which includes Weapons Activities, Defense Nuclear Nonproliferation, Naval Reactors, and Federal Salaries and Expenses, is $23,959,247,000, $1,796,683,000 above fiscal year 2023 and $114,247,000 above the budget request. Funding for energy programs within the Department of Energy, which includes basic science research and the applied energy programs, is $16,901,979,000, $1,578,787,000 above fiscal year 2023 and $3,134,809,000 below the budget request. Environmental Management activities--Non-defense Environmental Cleanup, Uranium Enrichment Decontamination and Decommissioning, and Defense Environmental Cleanup--are funded at $8,280,464,000. The net amount appropriated for the Power Marketing Administrations is provided at the requested levels. Title IV provides $523,164,000 for several Independent Agencies, $28,718,000 above fiscal year 2023 and $36,230,000 below the budget request. Net funding for the Nuclear Regulatory Commission is $156,000,000, $19,000,000 above fiscal year 2023 and equal to the budget request. National Defense Programs The Committee considers the national defense programs of the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) to be the Department of Energy's top priority. As the global nuclear threat landscape continues to evolve, so, too, must the U.S. nuclear deterrent. The nation's defense against all adversaries, including China and Russia, rests on a strong nuclear deterrent. Therefore, the recommendation strongly supports efforts to modernize the nuclear weapons stockpile, increase investment in the NNSA's infrastructure, prevent the proliferation of nuclear materials, and provide for the needs of the naval nuclear propulsion program. Within funding for the NNSA's Weapons Activities, the recommendation continues support of the multi-year modernization plans for the nation's nuclear weapons stockpile and its supporting infrastructure. The Committee recommendation also addresses deficiencies in the budget request, such as funding for the Sea-Launched Cruise Missile (SLCM) and plutonium pit production. The NNSA and the Department must do more than pay lip service to ensuring these critical activities move forward on-time and on-budget. Program and project management efforts must be improved to prevent further schedule delays and cost increases, particularly on major construction projects. The recommendation provides strong support for the NNSA's nuclear nonproliferation programs. The Committee views these programs as key to combating the proliferation threat posed by both state and non-state actors. The recommendation does not support expansion of the NNSA's mission to activities better suited to other federal agencies. The Committee also strongly supports the activities to maintain our country's nuclear naval fleet, which is funded through the Naval Reactors account. The Naval Reactors funding supports the current operational nuclear fleet, continues the Columbia-class ballistic missile submarine reactor development, and ensures research and development efforts for the next generation of nuclear-powered warships continue to progress. Energy Security The Department of Energy and its national laboratory system have been instrumental in advancing scientific and technological developments contributing to ensuring a safe, reliable, and affordable energy system for the nation. Unfortunately, the Department seems to have lost this focus in recent years and instead has focused inordinate attention and resources on ancillary goals, some of which may reduce energy security. The recommendation targets investments to the activities most important to refocusing the Department on its fundamental mission and to advancing energy security. Programs that have received significant supplemental funding in recent years and that still have significant unspent balances are funded at more reasonable levels in this annual appropriations bill. The Committee has long supported nuclear power as a significant contributor to the nation's energy mix. This baseload, carbon-free source of electricity will be essential to achieving any emissions reduction goals, so the Administration's relatively low budget priority for Nuclear Energy is puzzling. A revitalized American nuclear industry also provides an additional energy export of geopolitical consequence, especially for countries seeking alternatives to Russian and Chinese entanglements. The recommendation strongly supports key activities furthering the development of advanced reactors and fuel supply technologies, including small modular reactors and domestic uranium enrichment capabilities. The Administration's overwhelming rush to electrification and deployment of certain energy sources without alignment with the availability of domestic sources of critical minerals threatens to make our energy system dependent on China. The recommendation seeks to avoid this decrease in energy security through funding the full spectrum of production technologies of critical minerals, including extraction, separation, processing, manufacturing, and recycling. This approach makes full use of the nation's vast domestic resources and enhances our technological capabilities while securing the full supply chain of critical minerals. These investments will lay the foundation to reduce our reliance on foreign sources and bring further production capabilities back to America. The recommendation continues strong support for basic science research programs, which provide the foundation for new energy technologies. The recommendation includes strong support for continued operations of experimental user facilities, construction of large-scale and innovative scientific experiments,