Dissenting Views
The Committee on Ways and Means submits to the U.S. House
of Representatives the following report and materials relating
to the testimony of Internal Revenue Service whistleblowers,
having considered the same.
CONTENTS
Page
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND...................................... 1
A. Purpose and Summary................................. 1
B. Background on the Committee's Work.................. 2
II. EXPLANATION OF THE SUBMITTED MATERIALS...................... 2
A. Background on the Submitted Materials............... 2
B. Description of the Submitted Materials.............. 4
III. VOTE OF THE COMMITTEE....................................... 4
IV. DISSENTING VIEWS............................................ 6
Attachment A..................................................... 9
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND
A. Purpose and Summary
The Committee on Ways and Means (``Committee'') met in
closed executive session on June 22, 2023, to consider
materials protected by 26 U.S.C. Sec. 6103, comprised of the
transcripts of the interviews of the two Internal Revenue
Service (``IRS'') whistleblowers, the whistleblowers'
supplemental materials, and a letter from IRS Commissioner
Daniel Werfel, dated June 7, 2023. By a recorded vote of 25 to
18, the Committee favorably adopted the motion to submit these
materials to the U.S. House of Representatives.
B. Background on the Committee's Work
The Committee has oversight and legislative authority over
our federal tax laws. With this authority comes the
responsibility to ensure the IRS is enforcing the laws in a
fair and impartial manner.
26 U.S.C. Sec. 6103 makes tax returns and return
information confidential, subject to specific authorizations or
exceptions in the statute. The statute anticipates and allows
for whistleblowers to come forward to share information with
Congress under 26 U.S.C. Sec. 6103(f)(5) if the whistleblower
believes such return or return information may relate to
possible misconduct, maladministration, or taxpayer abuse.
Specifically, the statute permits a person with access to
returns or return information to disclose it to the Committee
or any person designated by the Chairman of the Committee to
receive such information.
The same statute provides for a process by which the
Committee can receive information, consider it, and submit it
to the House of Representatives. That process has been used
several times in the Committee's history and twice in recent
years, both in 2019 and 2022.
On April 19, 2023, Chairman Smith, Ranking Member Neal, and
the Chairs and Ranking Members of other House and Senate
Committees received a letter from counsel for an IRS Criminal
Supervisory Special Agent (``Whistleblower 1''). That letter
informed the Committee that Whistleblower 1 wished to make a
protected disclosure to the Committee, and outlined the nature
of information the individual wished to share with the
Committee. Additional information regarding the process by
which the Committee received the testimony of Whistleblower 1,
and another IRS employee--an IRS Criminal Investigator--
(``Whistleblower 2'') is detailed in Section II.C of this
report.
The allegations brought to the Committee by the two IRS
whistleblowers raise issues that fall squarely within this
Committee's jurisdiction and may require additional oversight
to inform potential legislative solutions.
II. EXPLANATION OF THE SUBMITTED MATERIALS
A. Background on the Submitted Materials
The materials considered during the executive session arose
out of voluntary testimony provided by two whistleblowers
employed by the IRS. Chairman Smith, Ranking Member Neal, and
the Chairs and Ranking Members of other House and Senate
Committees received a letter on April 19, 2023, from counsel
for Whistleblower 1. That letter outlined, at a high-level, the
nature of information the individual wished to share with the
Committee. The letter indicated that Whistleblower 1 wanted to
share information that would:
(1) Contradict sworn testimony provided to Congress by a
senior political official,
(2) Identify unmitigated conflicts of interest, and
(3) Provide examples of politically-motivated preferential
treatment.
Counsel for Whistleblower 1 offered to provide a proffer to
the Committee to outline the nature of the testimony his client
would provide.
On May 5, 2023, Committee staff received that attorney
proffer, which disclosed that the subject of the investigation
was Robert Hunter Biden. Majority and minority staff were
designated by the Chairman under 26 U.S.C. Sec. 6103 and both
majority and minority staff were present at the attorney
proffer. After receiving the proffer, a voluntary interview of
Whistleblower 1 was scheduled for May 26, 2023.
On May 15, 2023, the Committee received another letter from
Whistleblower 1's legal counsel notifying the Committee that
Whistleblower 1 and his entire investigative team had been
removed from the ongoing and sensitive investigation about
which Whistleblower 1 sought to make a disclosure to Congress.
The letter notes that the IRS employee was informed that the
removal occurred at the request of the U.S. Department of
Justice (``DOJ''). Following that removal, the Committee
learned that another IRS employee (``Whistleblower 2'') had
retained counsel and may be interested in providing additional
relevant information to the Committee.
On May 16, 2023, one day after learning of the removal of
the IRS investigative team, Chairman Smith sent a letter to
Commissioner Werfel requesting an urgent briefing on the
retaliation allegations. Commissioner Werfel agreed to brief
the Chairman.
On May 22, 2023, the Committee received another letter from
Whistleblower 1's legal counsel notifying the Committee that
the IRS proceeded to take further retaliatory actions against
the IRS employee.
On May 24, 2023, the Committee received a letter from
Whistleblower 2's legal counsel noting that Whistleblower 2
shares the concerns about the management of the high-profile
case raised by Whistleblower 1. The letter also notes that
despite Whistleblower 2's good faith efforts to engage in a
dialogue with supervisors at the IRS about this case and the
management of the case, to date, his efforts resulted in no
constructive engagement. Rather, IRS management responded in a
manner that raised significant alarm for Whistleblower 2 of
possible retaliation.
On May 26, 2023, and June 1, 2023, Committee staff
conducted voluntary transcribed interviews of Whistleblowers 1
and 2, respectively. Each interview lasted for approximately 7
hours. To ensure a complete and thorough disclosure was made by
the whistleblowers, information protected by 26 U.S.C.
Sec. 6103 was discussed. Majority and minority staff had equal
opportunity to ask questions of the whistleblowers and were
able to ask questions until none remained.
On May 31, 2023, IRS Commissioner Werfel briefed Chairman
Smith in person at the Chairman's request.
On June 7, 2023, IRS Commissioner Werfel sent a letter to
Chairman Smith with a copy also to Ranking Member Neal. That
letter followed up on the numerous concerns Chairman Smith
raised during the May 31, 2023, meeting about alleged
retaliation against IRS employees.
B. Description of the Submitted Materials
The documents presented during executive session for the
Committee's consideration include the following:
1. Transcript of voluntary interview of Whistleblower 1.
2. Affidavit further clarifying Whistleblower 1's
testimony.
3. Transcript of voluntary interview of Whistleblower 2.
4. Letter further clarifying Whistleblower 2's testimony.
5. Letter from IRS Commissioner Daniel Werfel to Chairman
Smith and copied to Ranking Member Neal dated June 7, 2023.
The materials include minor redactions covering the
following topics:
Whistleblower 2's name and a small number of
other personal identifiers.
The names of the children of the subject of
the investigation at issue.
Personally identifiable information,
including phone numbers, signatures, physical address,
email addresses, account numbers, and similar
information.
Staff names--these names were either
redacted, or, where possible they were changed to
``Majority Counsel'' or ``Minority Counsel'' for
clarity.
III. VOTE OF THE COMMITTEE
Pursuant to clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the following statement is made
concerning the vote of the Committee on Ways and Means in its
consideration of materials that were considered by the
Committee during the Executive Session, comprised of the
transcripts of the interviews of the two whistleblowers, the
whistleblowers' supplemental materials, and the letter from IRS
Commissioner Daniel Werfel, dated June 7, 2023, on June 22,
2023.
The following statements are made concerning the votes of
the Committee on Ways and Means during the consideration of the
materials reviewed in an open and closed executive session on
June 22, 2023.
A motion, offered by Mr. Smith of Nebraska, to make public
the transcript of the executive session proceedings should the
Committee vote to submit to the House any information. The
motion was agreed to by unanimous consent. See Attachment A at
end of report.
A motion, pursuant to clause 2(g)(1) of House Rule 11, that
the Committee proceed to a closed executive session, offered by
Mr. Schweikert. The motion was agreed to by voice vote.
A motion, offered by Mr. Schweikert, to submit to the House
of Representatives the materials that were considered by the
Committee during the Executive Session, comprised of the
transcripts of the interviews of the two whistleblowers, the
whistleblowers' supplemental materials, and the letter from IRS
Commissioner Daniel Werfel, dated June 7, 2023. The motion was
agreed to by a recorded vote of 25 to 18 (with a quorum being
present). The vote was as follows:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Representative Yea Nay Present Representative Yea Nay Present
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. Smith (MO)................... X ....... ......... Mr. Neal........... ....... X .........
Mr. Buchanan..................... X ....... ......... Mr. Doggett........ ....... X .........
Mr. Smith (NE)................... X ....... ......... Mr. Thompson....... ....... X .........
Mr. Kelly........................ X ....... ......... Mr. Larson......... ....... X .........
Mr. Schweikert................... X ....... ......... Mr. Blumenauer..... ....... X .........
Mr. LaHood....................... X ....... ......... Mr. Pascrell....... ....... X .........
Dr. Wenstrup..................... X ....... ......... Mr. Davis.......... ....... X .........
Mr. Arrington.................... X ....... ......... Ms. Sanchez........ ....... X .........
Dr. Ferguson..................... X ....... ......... Mr. Higgins........ ....... X .........
Mr. Estes........................ X ....... ......... Ms. Sewell......... ....... X .........
Mr. Smucker...................... X ....... ......... Ms. DelBene........ ....... X .........
Mr. Hern......................... X ....... ......... Ms. Chu............ ....... X .........
Ms. Miller....................... X ....... ......... Ms. Moore.......... ....... X .........
Dr. Murphy....................... X ....... ......... Mr. Kildee......... ....... X .........
Mr. Kustoff...................... X ....... ......... Mr. Beyer.......... ....... X .........
Mr. Fitzpatrick.................. X ....... ......... Mr. Evans.......... ....... X .........
Mr. Steube....................... X ....... ......... Mr. Schneider...... ....... X .........
Ms. Tenney....................... X ....... ......... Mr. Panetta........ ....... X .........
Mrs. Fischbach................... X ....... .........
Mr. Moore........................ X ....... .........
Mrs. Steel....................... X ....... .........
Ms. Van Duyne.................... X ....... .........
Mr. Feenstra..................... X ....... .........
Ms. Malliotakis.................. X ....... .........
Mr. Carey........................ X ....... .........
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IV. DISSENTING VIEWS
The Minority agrees that all whistleblower allegations must
be taken seriously and that taxpayers should pay their fair
share of taxes. The Minority opposed the submission of a
private citizen's confidential tax information to the House of
Representatives because the material released is an
unsubstantiated, premature, and incomplete record of a years-
long investigation being handled by the Internal Revenue
Service (IRS) and the Department of Justice (DOJ)--spanning
both Republican and Democratic Administrations. The Minority is
deeply troubled that unsubstantiated allegations were released
to the public before the Committee took any further steps to
corroborate them. The unsubstantiated allegations of two
employees--one who spoke on his own free will and the other at
the request of the Majority--do not justify the release of a
private citizen's confidential tax information. Other reasons
the Minority opposed the public release are below.
The whistleblower transcript contains documents from
unknown sources, giving an appearance that these documents are
from IRS files provided by the whistleblower when, in fact,
they are not. Exhibit 4 and Exhibit 5 were not produced by
Whistleblower #1 to the Committee. The Majority presented these
exhibits to the whistleblower, included them in the transcript,
and did not reveal their source. At the Executive Session, in
response to questions, the Minority found out that these
exhibits were obtained by the Majority from ``open sources''--
i.e., the Internet. Yet, the exact source remains unknown, and
the exhibits were not authenticated. The exhibits are not from
IRS files despite their appearance in the transcript. With
respect to Exhibit 5, the whistleblower stated, ``And, if I
wasn't taken off the case, I would have been tainted by this
document.'' These unauthenticated exhibits from unknown sources
should not be included in the transcript as if they are
documents provided by the whistleblower or his attorney.
The Majority did not interview any of the more than 50
government employees identified in the transcripts, or verify
any of the documents, before rushing to release these
allegations to the public. The Majority interviewed two
individuals and then rushed to release the allegations. The
case began in November 2018 under the former Administration,
and many of the allegations regarding delay and slow-walking
occurred under Trump-appointed officials (e.g., the former
Attorney General and former IRS Commissioner). The prosecutors,
investigators, and key employees largely have remained the
same. The Majority did not interview any of the government
employees (more than 50 individuals) identified in the
transcripts or verify the exhibits, including those produced by
the Majority from unknown sources. At the Executive Session,
the Minority repeatedly questioned whether certain individuals
or any of the more than 50 employees identified in the
transcripts had been interviewed, called, e-mailed, sent a
letter, or otherwise contacted by the Majority. The Majority
did not. These government employees, including our nation's law
enforcement agents, were given no opportunity to defend their
names or respond to the allegations prior to release to the
public.
The Minority discovered that the second whistleblower was
selected and contacted by the Majority and did not come to the
Committee on his own volition directly or through the
whistleblower portal. The Minority discovered that the employee
who asked to remain anonymous was selected and contacted by the
Majority for an interview. The Majority, who holds the subpoena
power for the Committee, contacted the employee's attorney and
``asked'' for an interview. Generally, whistleblowers contact
the Committee and not the other way around. This employee made
clear on several occasions during the interview that he was
there at the request of the Majority. He began his interview by
stating, ``I wanted to start out by saying I'm coming here to
you today after someone from your committee reached out to my
counsel to come in and testify.'' He further states, ``I felt
that it was my duty as a government employee to abide by your
request.'' The Minority questions why the Majority only
selected and contacted this employee and no others.
The second witness recants key element of his testimony
days before the Executive Session. During the interview, the
second witness stated that in early 2019 he was ``told that
William Barr made the decision to join two investigations
together.'' Those investigations were this case and another
case opened by DOJ earlier that year. When asked how this
decision was communicated to him, he replied that it came from
his supervisor at the time. However, just days before the
Executive Session, he filed a supplemental statement that, ``on
further reflection, Mr. X cannot definitively state that his
then-supervisor said that that the Department of Justice
official directing the merger of the cases was AG Barr.'' In
light of this change, the Committee should have done further
work to corroborate the allegations before releasing the
transcripts to the public.
The Majority has no legitimate legislative purpose for
releasing confidential tax information of a private citizen to
the public. The court in the Committee's recent case stated,
``[T]here is no general authority to expose the private affairs
of individuals without justification in terms of the functions
of Congress.'' Further, ``[t]here is no congressional power to
expose for the sake of exposure.'' We question whether the
Majority has a legitimate legislative purpose for exposing the
confidential tax information of this private citizen. The bar
for this type of exposure should be exceedingly high. If the
alleged purpose was to expose misconduct or maladministration,
it could have been done without the breadth of confidential tax
information released to the public. This purpose is pretextual
and abuses the power of this Committee.
The Committee is not a law enforcement body. The Majority
is misguided about the authority of the Committee. The court in
the