Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 4664]
The Committee on Appropriations submits the following
report in explanation of the accompanying bill making
appropriations for Financial Services and General Government
for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2024.
INDEX TO BILL AND REPORT
Page Number
Bill Report
Title I--Department of the Treasury........................ 2
5
Title II--Executive Office of the President and Funds
Appropriated to the President.......................... 33
21
Title III--The Judiciary................................... 51
31
Title IV--District of Columbia............................. 61
36
Title V--Independent Agencies.............................. 73
40
Administrative Conference of the United States..... 73
40
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau............... 73
41
Consumer Product Safety Commission................. 89
41
Election Assistance Commission..................... 91
42
Federal Communications Commission.................. 91
43
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.............. 94
46
Federal Election Commission........................ 94
46
Federal Labor Relations Authority.................. 94
47
Federal Permitting Improvement Steering Council.... 95
47
Federal Trade Commission........................... 95
47
General Services Administration.................... 98
50
Harry S Truman Scholarship Foundation.............. 110
61
Merit Systems Protection Board..................... 111
61
Morris K. Udall and Stewart L. Udall Foundation.... 111
62
National Archives and Records Administration....... 113
63
National Credit Union Administration............... 114
65
Office of Government Ethics........................ 114
65
Office of Personnel Management..................... 115
66
Office of Special Counsel.......................... 118
68
Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board........ 119
69
Public Buildings Reform Board...................... 119
69
Securities and Exchange Commission................. 119
69
Selective Service System........................... 125
72
Small Business Administration...................... 125
72
United States Postal Service....................... 132
77
United States Tax Court............................ 133
80
Title VI--General Provisions--This Act..................... 135
81
Title VII--General Provisions--Government-wide:
Departments, Agencies, and Corporations................ 156
84
Title VIII--General Provisions, District of Columbia....... 202
88
Title IX--Additional General Provisions.................... 217
90
House of Representatives Report Requirements...............
90
Introduction
The fiscal year 2024 allocation is $11,311,000,000 in
addition to $14,013,000,000 in reallocated funds, for a
discretionary spending total of $25,324,000,000. This is
$1,867,300,000 below the fiscal year 2023 enacted level and
$6,232,084,000 below the President's budget request for fiscal
year 2024.
The Committee report refers to certain organizations,
offices, and institutions as follows: the Government
Accountability Office as GAO; the Office of Management and
Budget as OMB; the Office of Personnel Management as OPM; the
Internal Revenue Service as IRS; the General Services
Administration as GSA; and full-time equivalent as FTE.
References to ``the Committee'' means the Committee on
Appropriations of the House of Representatives, unless
otherwise noted. In addition, any reference to the ``budget
request'' or ``the request'' should be interpreted to mean the
Budget of the U.S. Government, fiscal year 2024, that was
submitted to Congress on March 9, 2023.
Highlights of the Bill
The Financial Services and General Government bill has
jurisdiction over a broad and varied range of government
functions and services encompassing both the Executive and
Judicial branches. These appropriations support the Department
of the Treasury, the Executive Office of the President, Federal
Payments to the District of Columbia, and the Federal
Judiciary. The bill also provides resources for over a dozen
independent agencies and commissions, each of which serves the
public with a distinct mission.
The fiscal year 2024 FSGG bill promotes fiscal
responsibility by reducing non-defense discretionary levels,
rescinding unobligated Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) funding,
bringing oversight to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
and reducing spending in unauthorized programs.
Oversight and Management
The Committee strongly believes in the need for careful
oversight of government expenditure of taxpayer dollars and is
committed to providing the necessary oversight to reduce waste,
fraud, and inefficiency in the operations and programs funded
by the Financial Services and General Government bill.
To this end, the Committee does not support the
administration's request to fund climate change initiatives,
staff diversity and inclusion offices, train Federal employees
on critical race theory, expand agencies' regulatory agendas,
and buy a Federal fleet of electric vehicles. The Committee
strongly believes agencies under its jurisdiction should
maintain focus on assisting small businesses, providing high
levels of customer service, investing in rural and low-income
communities, countering illicit finance, cyber threats, and
fentanyl trafficking, and maintaining a strong judicial system.
Within 30 days of enactment of this Act, the Committee
requires Federal agencies to reinstate and apply their pre-
pandemic telework policies, practices, and levels in effect as
of December 31, 2019, or they cannot obligate or expend funding
for fiscal year 2024. The FSGG bill provides increases for
agencies' relocation, building improvements, rental payments,
and critical infrastructure, and therefore expects employees to
return to the office to provide value to the American taypayer.
The Committee includes a provision requiring OMB to remind
all Federal agencies of the compliance obligations detailed in
title VII of this Act.
Reprogramming and Operating Plan Procedures
Section 608 and Section 739 of this Act detail department
and agency responsibilities and procedures relating to
reprogramming of funds among programs, projects, and
activities. Each department and agency funded in this Act shall
follow the directions set forth in this Act and its
accompanying report and shall not reallocate resources or
reorganize activities except as provided herein. The Committee
expects that agencies or entities that fulfill the requirements
of Section 608 will also be in compliance with the requirements
of Section 739.
Section 608 requires agencies and entities funded by this
Act to receive prior approval from the Committees on
Appropriations of the House of Representatives and the Senate
for any reprogramming of funds that (1) creates a new program;
(2) eliminates a program, project, or activity; (3) increases
funds or personnel for any program, project, or activity for
which funds have been denied or restricted by Congress; (4)
proposes to use funds directed for a specific activity by the
Committee on Appropriations of either the House of
Representatives or the Senate for a different purpose; (5)
augments existing programs, projects, or activities in excess
of $5,000,000 or 10 percent, whichever is less; (6) reduces
existing programs, projects, or activities by $5,000,000 or 10
percent, whichever is less; or (7) creates or reorganizes
offices, programs, or activities. In addition, prior to any
significant reorganization, restructuring, relocation, or
closing of offices, programs, or activities, each agency or
entity funded in this Act shall consult with the Committees on
Appropriations.
Not later than 60 days after the date of enactment of this
Act, each agency shall submit a report to establish the
baseline for application of reprogramming and transfer
authorities for fiscal year 2024. The amount appropriated for
agencies shall be reduced by $100,000 per day for each day
after the required date that the report has not been submitted
to the Committees.
Reprogramming procedures shall apply to funds provided in
this bill, unobligated balances from previous appropriations
Acts that are available for obligation or expenditure in fiscal
year 2024, and non-appropriated resources such as fee
collections that are used to meet program requirements in
fiscal year 2024.
To assess a reprogramming request, the Committee requires
the following information, at minimum: a thorough justification
for the reprogramming, the impact of the reprogramming on
budget requirements for future fiscal years, and the impact of
the reprogramming on carryover funding. These requirements also
apply to significant reorganizations or restructurings of
programs, projects, or activities, even if such a
reorganization or restructuring does not involve reprogramming
of funding. The Committee also expects prompt notification of
any reprogramming that does not meet the above criteria but
might have significant impacts on budgetary requirements for
future fiscal years.
The Committee directs that, for purposes of this report and
the Act, the term ``consult'' means a pre-decisional engagement
between a relevant Federal agency and the Committee during
which the Committee is provided a meaningful opportunity to
provide facts and opinions to inform: (1) the use of funds; (2)
the development, content, or conduct of a program or activity;
or (3) a decision to be taken.
Except in emergency situations, reprogramming requests
should be submitted no later than June 30, 2024. Moreover, the
Committee notes that when an agency or entity submits a
reprogramming or transfer request to the Committees on
Appropriations and does not receive identical responses from
the House and Senate, it is the responsibility of the
Department or agency to reconcile the House and Senate
differences before proceeding and, if reconciliation is not
possible, to consider the request to reprogram funds
unapproved.
Other Matters and Directives
Reports.--The Committee stresses that all reports are
required to be completed in compliance with the timeframe
outlined for each respective directive. Furthermore, the
Committee expects that the specifications and conditions
associated with funding appropriated by this Act shall be
accomplished in the manner as directed in the report.
Budget Justifications.--Budget justifications are the
primary tool used by the Committees on Appropriations to
evaluate the resource requirements and fiscal needs of
agencies. The Committee is aware that the format and
presentation of budget materials is largely left to the agency
within presentation objectives set forth by OMB. In fact, OMB
Circular A-11, part 1 specifically instructs agencies to
consult with Congressional committees beforehand. The Committee
expects that all agencies funded under this Act will heed this
directive.
The Committee continues the direction that justifications
submitted with the fiscal year 2025 budget request by agencies
funded under this Act contain the customary level of detailed
data and explanatory statements to support the appropriations
requests at the level of detail contained in the funding table
included at the end of this report. Among other items, agencies
shall provide a detailed discussion of proposed new
initiatives, proposed changes in the agency's financial plan
from prior year enactment, detailed data on all programs, and
comprehensive information on any office or agency
restructurings. At a minimum, each agency must also provide
adequate justification for funding and staffing changes for
each individual office and materials that compare programs,
projects, and activities that are proposed for fiscal year 2025
to the fiscal year 2024 enacted levels.
American Flag Purchases.--The Committee once again urges
all Federal agencies to only purchase flags that contain 100
percent American-made materials even though the All American
Flag Act requires the Federal Government to purchase flags made
of only 50 percent American-made materials.
TITLE I--DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY
Departmental Offices
SALARIES AND EXPENSES
Appropriation, fiscal year 2023....................... $273,882,000
Budget request, fiscal year 2024...................... 332,199,000
Recommended in the bill............................... 248,109,000
Bill compared with:
Appropriation, fiscal year 2023................... -25,773,000
Budget request, fiscal year 2024.................. -84,090,000
The Departmental Offices support the Secretary of the
Treasury as the chief operating executive of the Department and
in their role in determining the tax, economic, and financial
management policies of the Federal Government. The Secretary's
responsibilities funded by the Salaries and Expenses
appropriation include: recommending and implementing domestic
and international economic and tax policy; providing
recommendations regarding fiscal policy; governing the fiscal
operations of the government; managing the public debt;
managing development of financial policy; representing the U.S.
on international monetary, trade, and investment issues;
overseeing Treasury Department international operations;
directing the administrative operations of the Treasury
Department; and providing executive oversight of the bureaus
within the Treasury Department.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION
The Committee recommends $248,109,000 for Departmental
Offices, Salaries and Expenses.
Treasury Forfeiture Fund.--The Department is directed to
continue to submit a detailed table each month reporting the
interest earned, forfeiture revenue collected, unobligated
balances, recoveries, expenses to date, and expenses estimated
for the remainder of the fiscal year.
Financial Literacy for Students.--The Committee is
encouraged by the Department's work to help promote financial
literacy, particularly among the school-age population. As of
January 2023, 33 states have a high-school personal finance
requirement. The Committee strongly encourages the Department
to partner with entities offering financial literacy programs,
where appropriate, to broaden the scope of the Financial
Literacy Education Commission to reach more students to
encourage economic inclusion and lasting financial resilience.
Cybersecurity in the Financial Services Sector.--The
Committee encourages the Office of Cybersecurity and Critical
Infrastructure Protection (OCCIP) to improve resilience to
cyberattacks by expanding risk assessment and mitigation
capabilities as a part of its role as a Sector Risk Management
Agency. OCCIP is further encouraged to engage in efforts to map
third-party dependencies in the financial sector, provide
analysis of domestic and international cybersecurity threats
and vulnerabilities, and support bilateral and multilateral
engagement on financial sector cybersecurity in strategically
important regions, including Eastern Europe and East Asia.
Outbound Investment.--In fiscal year 2023, the Department
established a program to address national security concerns
arising from outbound investments from the United States into
advanced technologies that are critical to U.S. national
security. The Department realigned $7,000,000 from the
Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States to
implement and administer the program. The Committee looks
forward to an update on its progress and the timing of final
policy determinations, including an opportunity for public
comment.
Relation of Government Sponsored Enterprise Charters and
Senior Preferred Stock Purchase Agreements.--The Committee is
aware of concerns regarding the Federal National Mortgage
Association and Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation's
efforts to develop new activities and operations beyond the
authorities vested in their charter, including a pilot program
to serve as a title insurer by self-insuring title-related
risks. The Committee believes that the terms of the Senior
Preferred Stock Purchase Agreements that provide ongoing
capital support for the government sponsored enterprises should
be construed to restrict the activities of the Government
Sponsored Entities to their core mission under the Charter Acts
and that deviation from these missions such as by serving as a
title insurer could carry unreasonable risks for home buyers
and to the Department of Treasury's rights under the Senior
Preferred Stock Purchase Agreements. Therefore, the Committee
directs the Department within 120 days to provide a re
Dissenting Views
The Financial Services and General Government (FSGG) bill
funds critical programs that impact the lives of every American
in their capacity as consumers, as investors, and as taxpayers.
The bill's jurisdiction covers a diverse range of agencies
including those that provide oversight and regulation of the
financial and telecommunications industries, manage government
buildings and infrastructure projects, and oversee the federal
workforce. In addition, funding in this bill supports the
operations of the White House, the Federal Judiciary, and the
District of Columbia.
We appreciate Chairman Womack's efforts in assembling the
Fiscal Year (FY) 2024 FSGG bill. We were pleased to cooperate
with the Chairman to identify areas of common ground. However,
the overwhelming share of funding decisions and policy
provisions in this bill reflect an unprecedented degree of
focus on partisan priorities from the Majority's side.
The bill's FY 2024 allocation is $11.3 billion, 58 percent
below the 2023 level and 64 percent below the President's
budget request.
President Biden, Speaker McCarthy, and 314 House Members
came together to enact a law to address the deficit. Now that
agreement is not being honored because of a small but willful
minority. The bill breaks this agreement by rescinding over $13
billion in funding from the Inflation Reduction Act.
Perhaps the most egregious cut in this bill targets the IRS
and its enforcement abilities. For decades, the IRS has been
severely under-funded. This funding supports IRS revenue agents
with the expertise necessary to conduct complex, high-income
audits. Less funding means fewer agents. Meanwhile, the number
of tax returns filed, and the GDP have both increased. These
reckless budget and staffing cuts have caused the number of IRS
audits on the wealthiest Americans to plummet.
Instead of addressing this problem, this legislation
exacerbates it with a cut to IRS enforcement, protecting high-
earners and corporations. Such a drastic cut has severe
consequences for our government to collect the owed taxes it
needs to serve the people. Cutting enforcement funding reduces
revenue and increases the debt. The result is the same as
simply reducing taxes on wealthy Americans--a cause Republicans
have also championed. Republicans claim to be the party of
fiscal responsibility. This legislation is a dereliction of
that responsibility.
Other Treasury Department functions that are key to
national security--the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network and
the office of Terrorism and Financial Intelligence are also
irresponsibly cut. We hear a great deal from the other side of
the aisle talk about wanting to be ``tough on China'' and yet,
the bill includes no funding for the Administration's efforts
to restrict outbound investment in countries that threaten our
national security.
This bill makes it harder to enforce the law by imposing
irresponsible cuts on key regulatory agencies and resources.
That includes the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), the
Securities Exchange Commission (SEC), the Consumer Financial
Protection Bureau, the Consumer Products Safety Commission, the
Federal Communications Commission (FCC), and DC's Emergency
Planning and Security Costs account. In doing so, this bill
leaves Americans vulnerable to a variety of threats--from fraud
and scams to dangerous products that can harm and even kill
adults and children.
Additionally, the bill doesn't provide any funding for
Election Assistance Commission Election Security Grants, making
our elections more vulnerable to interference and tampering,
about which Republicans have been so outspoken.
Another particularly irresponsible cut targets the General
Services Administration (GSA), which functions as the Federal
Government's developer and landlord. This includes no funding
for the Technology Modernization Fund or the Electric Vehicles
Fund.
The bill provides no funding for a much-needed
consolidation and modernization for the headquarters of the
Federal Bureau Investigations (FBI). The current FBI
headquarters is in such disrepair that it constitutes a
national security threat by preventing FBI employees from
having access to necessary and secure facilities to do their
important work protecting our nation. This project has been
years in the making, and this lack of funding stalls the nation
in addressing this urgently needed infrastructure improvement.
Each year that project is delayed costs taxpayers $268 million
dollars and undermines FBI's mission and the safety of its
employees.
Cuts to the Small Business Administration would cut off
assistance and resources that help small businesses start,
grow, and compete. At a time when our economy is returning
following pandemic business closures, this reduction is
especially irresponsible.
The bill contains numerous harmful riders on a wide range
of topics. They prohibit the government from improving
diversity and equality, limit our ability to combat climate
change, further undermine FTC and SEC consumer protections,
restrict reproductive health-care access, and interfere with
the home rule authority of the District of Columbia.
The Committee adopted several additional outrageous
amendments that would significantly further weaken the SEC,
FTC, outbound investment review at Treasury, and home rule in
the District of Columbia. One amendment adopted would permit
concealed carry of firearms in the District of Columbia and on
public transportation.
In an effort to improve the bill, Rep. Pocan offered an
amendment to strike a provision that would prohibit the IRS
from developing a free electronic filing software for all
Americans.
Rep. Torres offered an amendment to strike these harmful
provisions and protect a woman's right to make legal and
private health choices without government interference. By
opposing adoption of this amendment, the Republican Majority
continued its hypocritical allegiance to limited government,
until it concerns a women's right to choose.
Rep. Aguilar offered an amendment, which was not adopted,
to make sure that Dreamers, certain non-criminal immigrants
that entered the country as children and remain without U.S.
citizenship, can lend their talents to the Federal workforce.
These poison-pill riders are utterly unnecessary and make
completing the appropriations process much more difficult.
In a rare instance of bipartisanship, Committee Members on
both sides of the aisle united to defeat an amendment which
would have rescinded all the unobligated funding for the new
consolidated FBI Headquarters.
All across the bill, these unwise cuts will reduce the
ability of the government to effectively protect consumers and
investors and investigate tax cheats and collect revenues.
Overall, the proposed spending reductions are not fiscally
responsible since they will actually increase costs in the
future through reduced revenue and diminished enforcement. As a
consequence, we are gravely concerned that the bill fails to
make the necessary investments to confront the challenges
facing this nation. Of equal concern are the reckless and ill-
advised policy riders that do not belong on an appropriations
bill. Many of these provisions threaten to impose even greater
damage to the nation's democratic principles and core financial
infrastructure.
Rosa L. DeLauro.
Steny H. Hoyer.
[all]