Additional Views
[to accompany h.r. 4665]
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
July 17, 2023.--Committed to the Committee of the Whole House on the
State of the Union and ordered to be printed
_________
U.S. GOVERNMENT PUBLISHING OFFICE
*52-871 WASHINGTON : 2023
118th Congress } { Report
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
1st Session } { 118-146
======================================================================
STATE, FOREIGN OPERATIONS, AND RELATED PROGRAMS APPROPRIATIONS BILL,
2024
_______
July 17, 2023.--Committed to the Committee of the Whole House on the
State of the Union and ordered to be printed
_______
Mr. Diaz-Balart of Florida, from the Committee on
Appropriations, submitted the following
R E P O R T
together with
Additional Views
[To accompany H.R. 4665]
The Committee on Appropriations submits the following
report in explanation of the accompanying bill making
appropriations for the Department of State, foreign operations,
and related programs, for the fiscal year ending September 30,
2024, and for other purposes.
INDEX TO BILL AND REPORT
Page Number
Bill Report
Overview................................................... 1
3
Title I--Department of State and Related Agency:
Department of State:
Administration of Foreign Affairs.................. 2
6
Diplomatic Programs........................ 2
7
Consular and Border Security Programs...... 3
13
Capital Investment Fund.................... 4
16
Office of Inspector General................ 4
16
Educational and Cultural Exchange Programs. 4
17
Representation Expenses.................... 5
20
Protection of Foreign Missions and
Officials.............................. 5
20
Embassy Security, Construction, and
Maintenance............................ 5
21
Emergencies in the Diplomatic and Consular
Service................................ 6
23
Repatriation Loans Program Account......... 6
24
Payment to the American Institute in Taiwan 7
24
International Center, Washington, District
of Columbia............................ 7
24
Payment to the Foreign Service Retirement
and Disability Fund.................... 7
25
International Organizations:
Contributions to International Organizations....... 7
25
Contributions for International Peacekeeping
Activities..................................... 10
27
International Commissions:
International Boundary and Water Commission, United
States and Mexico.............................. 13
28
American Sections, International Commissions....... 14
29
International Fisheries Commissions................ 15
29
Related Agency:
United States Agency for Global Media.............. 15
30
International Broadcasting Operations...... 15
30
Broadcasting Capital Improvements.......... 18
32
Related Programs:
The Asia Foundation................................ 18
32
United States Institute of Peace................... 18
33
Center for Middle Eastern-Western Dialogue Trust
Fund........................................... 19
33
Eisenhower Exchange Fellowship Program............. 19
33
Israeli Arab Scholarship Program................... 20
34
East-West Center................................... 20
34
National Endowment for Democracy................... 20
34
Other Commissions:
Commission for the Preservation of America's
Heritage Abroad................................ 21
35
United States Commission on International Religious
Freedom........................................ 21
35
Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe... 22
35
Congressional-Executive Commission on the People's
Republic of China.............................. 22
36
United States-China Economic and Security Review
Commission..................................... 22
36
Title II--United States Agency for International
Development:
Funds Appropriated to the President:
Operating Expenses......................... 24
36
Capital Investment Fund.................... 25
40
Office of Inspector General................ 26
40
Title III--Bilateral Economic Assistance:
Funds Appropriated to the President:
Global Health Programs..................... 27
40
Development Assistance..................... 32
49
International Disaster Assistance.......... 32
54
Transition Initiatives..................... 33
54
Complex Crises Fund........................ 34
55
Economic Support Fund...................... 34
55
Democracy Fund............................. 35
57
Assistance for Europe, Eurasia and Central
Asia................................... 36
58
Department of State:
Migration and Refugee Assistance........... 37
59
United States Emergency Refugee and
Migration Assistance Fund..............
61
Independent Agencies:
Peace Corps................................ 37
61
Millennium Challenge Corporation........... 39
61
Inter-American Foundation.................. 39
62
United States African Development
Foundation............................. 40
63
Department of the Treasury:
International Affairs Technical Assistance. 41
63
Debt Restructuring......................... 42
63
Tropical Forest and Coral Reef Conservation 42
63
Title IV--International Security Assistance:
Department of State:
International Narcotics Control and Law
Enforcement............................ 44
64
Nonproliferation, Anti-terrorism, Demining
and Related Programs................... 45
67
Peacekeeping Operations.................... 47
68
Funds Appropriated to the President:
International Military Education and
Training............................... 48
69
Foreign Military Financing Program......... 48
69
Title V--Multilateral Assistance:
Funds Appropriated to the President:
International Organizations and Programs... 52
71
International Financial Institutions............... 52
71
Global Environment Facility................ 52
71
Contribution to the Green Climate Fund.....
72
Contribution to the Clean Technology Fund..
72
Multilateral Development Banks Trust Funds.
72
Contribution to the International Bank for
Reconstruction and Development......... 52
72
Contribution to the International
Development Association................ 53
72
Contribution to the Asian Development Fund. 53
73
Contribution to the Asian Development Bank. 53
73
Contribution to the African Development
Bank................................... 53
73
Contribution to the African Development
Fund...................................
73
Contribution to the Inter-American
Development Bank.......................
73
Contribution to the International Fund for
Agricultural Development............... 53
74
Global Agriculture and Food Security
Program................................
74
Contributions to International Monetary
Fund Facilities and Trust Funds........
74
Global Infrastructure Facility.............
74
Treasury International Assistance Programs.
74
Title VI--Export and Investment Assistance:
Export-Import Bank of the United States............ 54
75
United States International Development Finance
Corporation.................................... 57
75
Trade and Development Agency....................... 61
78
Title VII--General Provisions.............................. 62
78
OVERVIEW
The Committee recommendation for fiscal year 2024 for
activities under the jurisdiction of the Subcommittee on State,
Foreign Operations and Related Programs includes
$52,502,000,000 in new budget authority for programs and
activities within the subcommittee's purview, which is twelve
percent below the fiscal year 2023 enacted level and twenty-
four percent below the fiscal year 2024 request. Such amount is
offset by $11,135,000,000 in rescissions from partisan funding
provided in the last session of Congress, which yields
$41,367,000,000 in net budget authority for fiscal year 2024.
The fiscal year 2024 Department of State, Foreign
Operations, and Related Programs Appropriations Act (``this
Act'') demonstrates prioritization of programs and activities
that support American values and United States national
interests. With United States fiscal deficits expanding and the
national debt exceeding $32 trillion, the Committee is wisely
reducing spending and providing funding for operations,
programs, and activities that have demonstrated results and are
important to United States national security. The Committee
also seeks to ensure that funds appropriated by this Act are
directed toward the core diplomatic and foreign assistance
missions of the United States and are not used to advance
superfluous and divisive cultural agendas or extreme climate
change goals that do nothing to lower global temperatures.
NATIONAL SECURITY
The Committee recommendation supports allies and partners
while countering adversaries of the United States and those
countries who support them. The Committee recommendation
continues unwavering support for Israel by providing
$3,300,000,000 from funds made available under Foreign Military
Financing Program, consistent with the United States-Israel
Memorandum of Understanding. Other critical allies in the
Middle East such as Egypt and Jordan also receive full support.
The Committee is deeply concerned about Iran's dangerous
and hostile activities around the globe and its growing nuclear
capabilities, which threaten the United States and our allies,
as well as the potential for the Administration to enter into
another deeply flawed agreement with Iran. The Committee
recommendation prohibits funding to implement or enforce any
agreement with Iran regarding its nuclear program or renewal of
the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action unless such agreement
has received the concurrence of two-thirds of the Senate. The
Committee also prohibits the use of funds to revoke the
designation of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps as a
Foreign Terrorist Organization.
The Committee recognizes the far-reaching and generational
challenge posed to United States economic and national security
interests by the People's Republic of China (PRC) and the
Chinese Communist Party (CCP). As assessed by the United States
Intelligence Community's latest Annual Threat Assessment, the
CCP will continue to strive to make China the preeminent power
in East Asia and a major power on the world stage. As that
assessment noted, the CCP will maintain pressure on Taiwan for
unification, seek to undercut United States influence, drive
wedges between the United States and its partners, and
undermine democratic norms in favor of its repressive,
authoritarian system.
Accordingly, the Committee supports efforts to counter such
threats by directing not less than $4,400,000,000 to advance
United States national security interests in the Indo-Pacific
and to counter the malign influence of the PRC, including by
increasing funding for the Countering PRC Influence Fund to the
requested level of $400,000,000 and by providing funding above
the request for the Indo-Pacific Strategy and Asia Reassurance
Initiative Act of 2018. Funds included in title VIII of this
Act to counter the malign influence of the PRC may be made
available for the first-year costs of the amended Compacts of
Free Association, if expressly authorized for such purpose.
The Committee notes the urgent need to strengthen
deterrence across the Taiwan Strait and recommends $500,000,000
from funds made available under Foreign Military Financing
Program for Taiwan, as well as up to $2,000,000,000 in loans
and loan guarantees for such purpose, as authorized by section
5502(g) of the Taiwan Enhanced Resilience Act (Public Law 117-
263).
In the Western Hemisphere, this Act prioritizes funds to
combat the flow of illicit fentanyl and other synthetic drugs
into the United States and prohibits funds for organizations
that support organized migrant caravans to the United States.
This Act also withholds funds from the Secretary of State's
budget until progress is made renegotiating the Migration
Protection Protocols. In addition, the Committee also supports
efforts by Federal departments and agencies funded in this Act
to reallocate critical global supply chains away from the PRC
and nearshore them to the Americas to support enhanced economic
growth and security.
As the two-year anniversary approaches of the historic
uprising by the people of Cuba to demand freedom, the Committee
provides $30,000,000 for democracy programs and $35,000,000 for
broadcasting in support of their brave and tireless efforts in
their continued fight for freedom. The Committee recommendation
also includes strong support for democracy programs for the
people of Venezuela and Nicaragua, and incentivizes European
partners seeking support in Ukraine to stand for freedom and
democracy in the Western Hemisphere as well, especially in
Cuba, Venezuela, Bolivia, and Nicaragua.
The Committee continues to support efforts to defeat
Russian aggression in Ukraine, including efforts to both
strengthen our NATO allies and other partners in Europe and
Eurasia threatened by Putin's imperial ambitions. This Act
requires unprecedented ov
Additional Views
The Department of State, Foreign Operations, and Related
Programs appropriations bill supports the diplomatic and
development efforts critical to maintaining U.S. global
leadership and protecting our country's national security.
Investments in this bill provide the State Department, U.S.
Agency for International Development (USAID), and other
agencies the resources needed to help reduce global poverty,
strengthen democratic political systems, and create greater
political and economic stability. Our country's national
security is dependent on robust diplomatic, defense and
development investments. Yet, the House fiscal year 2024 bill
would underinvest in development and diplomacy in such an
extreme way as to undermine our national security and American
global leadership.
The bill's allocation reflects a level not seen since 2009
and does not recognize the multidimensional and complex
problems the United States faces globally. In recognition of
the inadequate allocation, the bill proposes multiple
recissions including a $11 billion rescission of funds provided
through the Inflation Reduction Act. These are funds are out of
the jurisdiction of this bill and would cut programs that
assist our constituents to transition to more environmentally
friendly practices.
Historic migration, a changing climate, growing conflict
within and between states, and economic stagnation are
challenges that cannot be addressed by one country. Our only
chance at success is to work together with our partners and
allies to tackle these problems. This is not always easy, and
we will not always agree with every country about everything.
This bill's cynical characterization of countries into
black and white; good and evil is inflexible and unnuanced. We
will not be able to lead on international issues if we refuse
to engage or compromise. But by holding onto our values and
seeking common ground, we will make sustainable and lasting
progress on the interests of the United States.
And the challenges are great. Disease, disaster, terrorism,
and economic strife around the world continue to threaten the
security, safety, and well-being of Americans at home and
abroad. People are fleeing their homes in record numbers driven
by conflict and climate change. Last year saw more than 108
million people forcibly displaced, the largest number in
history. One in every four countries have populations facing
severe hunger, exacerbating conflict and instability. Around
the world, 600 million people are already living in areas unfit
for human life due to life-threatening heat waves, water-
shortages and coastal flooding caused by climate change. Many
of these problems were exacerbated by the historic COVID-19
pandemic, which interrupted three decades of progress in
reducing poverty and produced the largest rise in inequality
between countries. Failure to maintain our international
commitments reduces American influence around the world,
confronting our allies and partners with dangerous instability
and putting American interests at risk.
This bill purports to take a hardline against our
adversaries, but the evidence shows otherwise. The United
States currently has a smaller diplomatic presence overseas
than the People's Republic of China (PRC). A strong and capable
State Department and USAID withwell-staffed embassies and
missions effectively represents our interests by supporting and
building bridges with host governments, civil societies,
communities and the private sector that are at the core of our
national security and economic interests. However, this bill
asks our diplomats and development experts to do more
monitoring, reporting, and oversight, but cuts administrative
accounts by more than $1.4 billion.
This bill would also provide fewer tools to partner with
countries that are looking for our assistance and decimate
support for multilateral agencies and international financial
institutions. We have watched as the PRC challenges the United
States at the United Nations and other multilateral
institutions, working to insert their values of
authoritarianism and disrespect for human rights. By cutting
all funding to the United Nations and its agencies, this bill
leaves a void for our adversaries to fill.
The bill also injects domestic politics into our foreign
policy in an attempt to accommodate the most extreme views in
Congress without the consideration of real-life consequences
for national security and well-being of our allies. For
example, it removes longstanding conditions on human rights,
political prisoners, and corruption in countries that are
recognized to struggle with those challenges. It distracts from
real problems by including many divisive provisions around the
culture wars. Support for diversity and human rights for all
people are a bedrock of American values and millions of people
look to the United States for inspiration and support on these
issues.
Several amendments were offered to address some of the most
destructive provisions, but unfortunately, were defeated in
largely partisan votes. An amendment to strike the harmful
riders affecting women's health offered by Representative
Barbara Lee was rejected along party lines. I also commend
Representative Adriano Espaillat for proposing an amendment to
strike the numerous prohibitions of funding to address climate
change.In another amendment rejected by a party line vote,
Representative Lois Frankel offered an amendment to strike
several of the most counter-productive riders regarding LGBTQ+
rights, diversity and inclusion, and disinformation. These
riders have a tenuous connection to the work of the State,
Foreign Operations bill and do not reflect American values.
Representative Lee also offered an amendment to increase access
to the internet to activists in closed societies through the
Open Technology Fund which failed by voice vote.
Finally, we are deeply concerned about the process that
produced this bill. The majority and minority have always,
despite recognized policy differences, worked together to
produce a State, Foreign Operations, and Related Programs bill
in which all Members can pursue their priorities and United
States commitments are honored. In a radical departure from
prior years, the minority was not an active participant in the
drafting process of this bill, often not receiving drafts or
being provided with adequate time to review appropriations
provisions until shortly before they were made public. This has
led to a more partisan and contentious measure that is unlikely
to gain broad-based support.
This bill would have severe consequences for United States
leadership, our ability to work with others on shared
challenges, and our long-term national security. The world is
full of threats that do not respect borders, from climate
change, to pandemics, to assertivedictators. Democrats will not
support a bill if it means turning our backs to the world's
most vulnerable women or the looming threat of climate change.
We look forward to working with Chairman Diaz Balart and
our colleagues in the House to improve the bill and hope my
Republican colleagues will reconsider the included policy
riders that will make it more difficult to achieve U.S.
priorities.
Rosa DeLauro.
Barbara Lee.
[all]