Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4820]
The Committee on Appropriations submits the following
report in explanation of the accompanying bill making
appropriations for the Departments of Transportation, Housing
and Urban Development, and related agencies for the fiscal year
ending September 30, 2024.
INDEX TO BILL AND REPORT
Page number
Bill Report
Title I--Department of Transportation...................... 2
5
Title II--Department of Housing and Urban Development...... 80
74
Title III--Related Agencies................................ 179
106
Title IV--General Provisions............................... 183
111
House of Representatives Report Requirements...............
PROGRAM, PROJECT, AND ACTIVITY
During fiscal year 2024, the terms ``program, project, and
activity'' (PPA) shall mean any item for which a dollar amount
is contained in appropriations acts (including joint
resolutions providing continuing appropriations), accompanying
reports of the House and Senate Committees on Appropriations,
or accompanying conference reports and joint explanatory
statements of the committee of conference. This definition
shall apply to all programs for which new budget (obligational)
authority is provided, as well as to discretionary grants and
discretionary grant allocations made through either bill or
report language.
The Committee directs the departments and agencies funded
by this Act to address each number listed in the reports in its
respective operating plans and warns that efforts to operate
programs at levels contrary to the levels recommended and
directed in these reports would not be advised.
OPERATING PLANS AND REPROGRAMMING GUIDELINES
The Committee includes a provision (section 405)
establishing the authority by which funding made available to
the agencies funded by this Act may be reprogrammed for other
purposes. The provision specifically requires the advance
approval of the House and Senate Committees on Appropriations
of any proposal to reprogram funds that:
creates a new program;
eliminates a PPA;
increases funds or personnel for any PPA for
which funds have been denied or restricted by Congress;
redirects funds that were directed in such
reports for a specific activity to a different purpose;
augments an existing PPA in excess of
$5,000,000 or 10 percent, whichever is less;
reduces an existing PPA by $5,000,000 or 10
percent, whichever is less; or
creates, reorganizes, or restructures
offices different from the congressional budget
justifications or the table at the end of the Committee
report, whichever is more detailed.
The Committee retains the requirement that each agency
submit an operating plan to the House and Senate Committees on
Appropriations not later than 60 days after enactment of this
Act to establish the baseline for application of reprogramming
and transfer authorities provided in this Act. Specifically,
each agency must provide a table for each appropriation with
columns displaying the prior year enacted level; budget
request; adjustments made by Congress; adjustments for
rescissions, if appropriate; and the fiscal year enacted level.
The table shall delineate the appropriation and prior year
enacted level both by object class and by PPA, as detailed in
this Act, accompanying reports of the House and Senate
Committees on Appropriations, accompanying conference reports
and joint explanatory statements of the committee of
conference, or in the budget appendix for the respective
appropriations, whichever is more detailed, and shall apply to
all items for which new budget (obligational) authority is
provided, as well as to discretionary grants and discretionary
grant allocations. The operating plan also must identify items
of special Congressional interest. Should the agency create,
alter, discontinue, or otherwise change any program as
described in the agency's budget justification, those changes
must be a part of the agency's operating plan. Finally, the
agency shall submit with the operating plan a summary of the
reporting requirements contained in this Act, the House and
Senate reports, and the accompanying conference reports and
joint explanatory statements of the committee of conference.
The summary should include Inspector General and Government
Accountability Office (GAO) reports as well. In certain
instances, the Committee may direct the agency to submit a
revised operating plan for approval or may direct changes to
the operating plan, if the plan is not consistent with the
directives of the accompanying conference reports and joint
explanatory statements of the committee of conference.
The Committee expects the agencies and bureaus to submit
reprogramming requests in a timely manner and to provide a
thorough explanation of the proposed reallocations, including a
detailed justification of increases and reductions and the
specific impact of proposed changes on the budget request for
the following fiscal year. Any reprogramming request shall
include any out-year budgetary impacts and a separate
accounting of program or mission impacts on estimated carryover
funds. Reprogramming procedures shall apply to funds provided
in this Act, unobligated balances from previous appropriations
Acts that are available for obligation or expenditure in fiscal
year 2024, and non-appropriated resources such as fee
collections that are used to meet program requirements in
fiscal year 2024.
The Committee expects each agency to manage its programs
and activities within the amounts appropriated by Congress. The
Committee reminds agencies that reprogramming requests should
be submitted only in the case of an unforeseeable emergency or
a situation that could not have been anticipated when
formulating the budget request for the current fiscal year.
Except in emergency situations, reprogramming requests should
be submitted no later than June 30, 2024. Further, the
Committee notes that when an agency submits a reprogramming or
transfer request to the Committees on Appropriations and does
not receive identical responses from the House and Senate, it
is the responsibility of the agency to reconcile the House and
Senate differences before proceeding and, if reconciliation is
not possible, to consider the request to reprogram funds
unapproved.
The Committee would also like to clarify that this section
applies to working capital funds of both the Department of
Transportation (DOT) and the Department of Housing and Urban
Development (HUD) and that no funds may be obligated from
working capital fund accounts to augment programs, projects, or
activities for which appropriations have been specifically
rejected by Congress, or to increase funds or personnel for any
PPA above the amounts appropriated by this Act.
CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET JUSTIFICATIONS
Budget justifications are the primary tool used by the
House and Senate Committees on Appropriations to evaluate the
resource requirements and fiscal needs of agencies. The
Committee is aware that the format and presentation of budget
materials is largely left to the agency within presentation
objectives set forth by the Office of Management and Budget.
The Committee expects all the budget justifications to provide
the data needed to make appropriate and meaningful funding
decisions. The Committee continues the direction that
justifications submitted with the fiscal year 2025 budget
request by agencies funded by this Act contain the customary
level of detailed data and explanatory statements to support
the appropriations requests at the level of detail contained in
the funding table included at the end of this report. Among
other items, agencies shall provide a detailed discussion of
proposed new initiatives, proposed changes in the agency's
financial plan from prior year enactment, detailed data on all
programs, and comprehensive information on any office or agency
restructurings. At a minimum, each agency must also provide
adequate justification for funding and staffing changes for
each individual office and materials that compare programs,
projects, and activities that are proposed for fiscal year 2025
to the fiscal year 2024 enacted levels.
The Committee is aware that the analytical materials
required for review by the Committee are unique to each agency
in this Act. Therefore, the Committee expects that each agency
will coordinate with the House and Senate Committees on
Appropriations in advance on its planned presentation for its
budget justification materials in support of the fiscal year
2025 budget request. The Committee also reminds all agencies
funded by this Act to provide accurate organizational charts in
the budget justifications. The Committee considers any changes
to the organizational charts to be a reprogramming requiring
approval of the House and Senate Committees on Appropriations
under section 405 of this Act.
OTHER MATTERS
Performance measures.--The Committee directs each of the
departments and agencies funded by this Act to comply with
title 31 of the United States Code, including the development
of its organizational priority goals and outcomes such as
performance outcome measures, output measures, efficiency
measures, and customer service measures.
Customer service.--The Committee continues to support
efforts to improve customer service in accordance with
Executive Order 13571. The Committee directs all departments
and agencies funded by this Act to develop standards to improve
customer service and incorporate the standards into the
performance plans required under title 31 of the United States
Code. Further, the Committee recognizes that not all
departments and agencies are subject to Executive Order 13571.
For such departments and agencies funded by this Act, the
Committee directs the departments and agencies to make
continuous improvements and adopt best practices for improving
customer service.
Improving cross-agency coordination.--The Committee directs
the Secretaries of HUD and DOT to collaborate as appropriate to
identify Federal resources which could be leveraged by HUD and
DOT applicants and awardees and improve cross-agency
coordination with respect to notices of funding opportunities
(NOFOs). The Committee directs HUD and DOT to jointly brief the
House and Senate Committees on Appropriations on its initial
cross-agency engagement and findings no later than 180 days
after the enactment of this Act.
Late reports.--Reports requested by the House and Senate
Appropriations Committees are an important part of the exercise
of the Committees' oversight responsibilities. The Committee is
concerned about the Departments' delinquency in completing
these reports. The reports are due on the dates specified in
either the House, Senate, or conference report, and submission
of reports is not to be delayed pending completion of the
conference on this bill. Each DOT and HUD agency is expected to
comply with the deadlines. The Committee reserves the right to
call before it any agency that does not submit its report or
reports on time.
Reporting on grant awards to Congress.--The Committee
appreciates that both HUD and DOT have followed the
Congressional mandate to provide advance notice to relevant
committees on grant awards. However, the Committee notes with
frustration that notices from both Departments have sent grant
awards that are incomplete, inaccurate, and un-manipulable for
dissemination. The Committee requests that both Departments
ensure that the notices include--at a minimum--project name,
project description, program description, State, Member(s) of
Congress/Senators who currently represent the awardee's
address, awardee, and award amount. This should be shared via a
grant notification system, manipulable processing software such
as Microsoft Excel or successor program, or both.
Workspace utilization plans.--The Committee understands
agencies are updating Work Environment Plans under the guidance
of the Office of Management and Budget. The Committee expects
savings from rental payments and other physical space costs if
in-person work at federal offices stays below the pre-pandemic
levels. The Committee requests DOT and HUD to provide updates
on its agencies' workspace utilization and related costs for
fiscal year 2024 no later than December 31, 2023. The Committee
expects the fiscal year 2025 budget requests from both
departments to reflect final assessments of its workspace
needs.
TITLE I--DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
Office of the Secretary
Section 3 of the Department of Transportation Act (P.L. 89-
670) provides for the establishment of the Office of the
Secretary of Transportation (OST).
SALARIES AND EXPENSES
Appropriation, fiscal year 2023....................... $171,014,000
Budget request, fiscal year 2024...................... 220,406,000
Recommended in the bill............................... 176,859,000
Bill compared with:
Appropriation, fiscal year 2023................... +5,845,000
Budget request, fiscal year 2024.................. -43,547,000
Office of the Secretary.--The Office of the Secretary has
primary responsibility to provide overall planning, direction,
and control of departmental affairs.
Office of the Deputy Secretary.--The Office of the Deputy
Secretary assists the Office of the Secretary and the Deputy
Secretary serves as the Department's chief operating officer.
Office of the General Counsel.--The Office of the General
Counsel provides legal services to the Office of the Secretary
and coordinates and reviews the legal work of the chief
counsels' offices of the operating administrations.
Office of the Under Secretary of Transportation for
Policy.--The Office of the Under Secretary of Transportation
for Policy provides leadership in the development of policies
for the Department, developing proposals and providing advice
to the Secretary regarding legislative and regulatory
initiatives across all modes of transportation.
Office of the Assistant Secretary for Budget and
Programs.--The Office of the Assistant Secretary for Budget and
Programs directs and coordinates all of the Department's
budget, performance, and finance activities.
Office of the Assistant Secretary for Governmental
Affairs.--The Office of the Assistant Secretary for
Governmental Affairs is responsible for Congressional and
intergovernmental relations.
Office of the Assistant Secretary for Administration.--The
Office of the Assistant Secretary for Administration
establishes policies and provides operational services with
respect to acquisition, office space and facilities, security,
and human resources.
Office of Public Affairs and Public Engagement.--The Office
of Public Affairs and Public Engagement is responsible for the
Department's press releases, social media, fact sheets, and
responses to press inquiries and creating opportunities for
direct dialogue with the public.
Office of the Executive Secretariat.--The Office of the
Executive Secretariat assists the Secretary and Deputy
Secretary in carrying out its responsibilities by controlling
and coordinating internal and external documents.
Office of Intelligence, Security, and Emergency Response.--
The Office of Intelligence, Security, and Emergency Response is
responsible for intelligence, security policy, preparedness,
training and exercises, national security, and operations.
Office of the Chief Information Officer.--The Office of the
Chief Information Officer serves as the principal advisor to
the Secretary on information technology (IT) operations,
systems, management, and security.
Office of Tribal Government Affairs.--The Office of Tribal
Government Affairs plans, coordinates, and implements policies
and programs serving Indian Tribes and is responsible for
Tribal relations.
Office of Multimodal Freight Infrastructure and Policy.--
The Office of Multimodal Freight Infrastructure and Policy
develops and manages the National Freight Strategic Plan and
the National Multimodal Freight Network and oversees the
development and updating of state freight plans.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION
The Committee recommendation provides $176,859,000 for the
salaries and expenses of the offices comprising the Office of
the Secretary of Transportation (OST), to remain available
until September 30, 2025.
The following table shows a comparison of the budget
request and the Committee recommendation by office.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Enacted Request Recommendation
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Office of the Secretary......................................... $3,569,000 n/a $3,569,000
Office of the Deputy Secretary.................................. 1,277,000 n/a 1,277,000
Office of the General Counsel................................... 28,089,000 n/a 28,089,000
Office of the Under Secretary for Policy*....................... 17,469,000 n/a 22,769,000
Office of the Assistant Secretary for Budget and Programs....... 21,026,000 n/a 21,026,000
Office of the Assistant Secretary for Government Affairs........ 3,968,000 n/a 3,968,000
Office of the Assistant Secretary for Administration............ 41,399,000 n/a 41,399,000
Office of Public Affairs and Public Engagement.................. 5,727,000 n/a 2,093,000
Office of the Executive Secretariat............................. 2,312,000 n/a 2,312,000
Office of Intelligence, Security, and Emergency Response........ 15,533,000 n/a 15,533,000
Office of the Chief Information Officer......................... 29,195,000 n/a 33,195,000
Office of Tribal Government Affairs............................. 1,450,000 n/a 1,629,000
-----------------------------------------------
Total....................................................... 171,014,000 220,406,000 176,859,000
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*Includes the Office of Multimodal Freight Infrastructure and Policy.
Airline regulations.--The Committee remains concerned about
the reliability and resiliency of the national aviation system.
With regard to recent operational disruptions and unrealistic
scheduling incidences, the Committee encourages the Department
to use its existing notice and comment rulemaking authority in
which the advantages of enforcing reliable flight schedule
Minority Views
This bill represents a step in the wrong direction for
America. The Republican majority's Fiscal Year 2024
appropriations bill for the Subcommittee on Transportation,
Housing and Urban Development and Related Agencies (T-HUD) cuts
discretionary spending by $26 billion for critical
transportation, housing, and community development programs-
while cutting $25 billion from the Internal Revenue Service's
(IRS) Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) funding used to ensure
billionaires pay taxes. This year's grossly short-sighted T-HUD
allocation of $65 billion, combined with $25 billion in offsets
from IRS funding that Democrats in neither chamber can support,
is still insufficient to address our nation's housing and
infrastructure challenges. Not merely insufficient with respect
to future investments, the bill goes even further by pulling
back $564 million in previously appropriated funding to
remediate health hazards, including leadbased paint, in low-
income housing. This bill does not represent what our
constituents have called on us to do, which is to maintain and
upgrade our nation's transportation and housing infrastructure
and protect jobs.
Despite recently passing the Fiscal Responsibility Act of
2023, a bipartisan debt deal that included a path forward on
spending levels and a way to get us back to regular order, the
majority has chosen to turn their back on those promises and
proceed with a partisan bill. This bill demonstrates
Republicans' continued attempts to not just undermine the
agreement, but also to double down on their broken promises by
injecting unrealistic efforts to repeal prior funding
agreements into already-partisan appropriations legislation.
The majority's bill has no chance to garner Democratic support
as it is written now.Throughout America, we are seeing outdated
infrastructure continue to impact the safety of our
transportation workers and communities. Americans also
experience constant congestion on our roads, delays at our
airports, and bottlenecks at train stations. Yet, this bill
cuts funding for the Department of Transportation by more than
$7 billion, which means fewer workers improving our roads,
bridges, and rail lines and longer delays. The American Society
of Civil Engineers' (ASCE) most recent report gave U.S.
infrastructure an overall ``C-minus'', with 43 percent of our
public roadways in poor or mediocre condition. Yet, this is an
improvement; it took this country more than 20 years just to
get out of the ``D'' range. The Republican majoritycannot
honestly believe that either grade is satisfactory when it
comes to safety. In order to bring our transportation into a
state of good repair, ASCE estimates $2.59 trillion is required
over 10 years.
While the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA)
provides for historic investments in transportation, it is not
without limitation. The backlog of capital improvements for our
airport runways and terminals, subways, and railways cannot be
transformed with those resources alone. The IIJA was never
intended to replace the necessary investments we provide
through this bill. Instead, this bill would expect governors
and mayors to make impossible decisions on how to prioritize
labor and local resources--as state and local budgets are still
recovering from the effects of COVID--against the laundry list
of must-do projects that span transportation modes and increase
safety. If the Republican majority continues to neglect
infrastructure that is crumbling before our very eyes, it will
only get more expensive to address in the future and will
become more dangerous for all Americans.
Meanwhile, more than 580,000 people experience homelessness
on any given day and millions of families struggle to pay rent
as incomes struggle to keep pace with rising housing costs.
Yet, the allocation for this bill diminishes investments in the
HOME program, which funds the construction of new affordable
housing for renters and those seeking homeownership, cutting it
by $1 billion. The bill also makes housing less safe for low-
income children and families, cutting resources for mold,
carbon monoxide, lead, and radon exposures, which would
devastate our young families dealing with lead exposure and
cause harmful effects on our local health care and education
systems. We should be investing in programs that put people to
work to build more affordable housing, repair and make more
accessible aging housing, and create healthy environments that
help communities thrive.
During full Committee consideration of this bill, Democrats
offered amendments to remove harmful riders that would reverse
progress to address climate change, unnecessarily attack high
speed rail, roll back transportation safety protections for the
traveling public, and reverse progress on meaningful efforts to
advance civil rights and equity in this country. Republicans
rejected these amendments.
The austerity of the prejudice and discrimination in the
Republican majority's policies became even more evident when an
amendment was offered by Chairman Cole to intentionally
eliminate funding to support brick and mortar projects for
organizations that provide critical housing and services for
the LGBTQI+ and ally communities. Eligible projects that met
the House rules, statutory requirements, and published
Republican guidance were intentionally targeted and singled out
because of the inclusion of ``LGBTQI+'' or related terms in
their intended recipients' names and subsequently eliminated
upon adoption of the amendment. These projects include the
``Senior Affordable Housing'' project for LGBTQ Senior Housing,
Inc. sponsored by Rep. Pressley (MA-07); the ``William Way
Renovation and Expansion Project'' for the Gay Community Center
of Philadelphia d/b/a William Way LGBT Center sponsored by
Rep.Boyle (PA-02); and the ``Center of Greater Reading--
Transitional Housing Program Berks County'' project for the
LGBT Center of Greater Reading sponsored by Rep. Houlahan (PA-
06).
This discriminatory amendment removed a combined $3.62
million for these projects that were favorably reported out of
Subcommittee by Republican Representatives Cole (OK-04), Diaz-
Balart (FL-26), Womack (AR-03), Rutherford (FL-05), Gonzales
(TX-23), Valadao (CA-22), Cline (VA-06), Zinke (MT-01), and
Ciscomani (AZ-06), when they voted by voice to advance these
projects. Ranking Member Quigley offered an amendment during
full Committeemarkup to restore funding for these projects
which was supported by all 27 Democrats on the Committee and
rejected by all 30 Republican majority members present, and
ultimately not adopted.
The T-HUD bill impacts the day-to-day lives of every person
in our country in a positive way, but this measure does the
opposite. To date, Republicans have chosen to close ranks
around a partisan effort to cut spending and target already
marginalized communities, which will be to the detriment of
millions of Americans, even though the Republican majority
knows it will precipitate another forced crisis that will lead
to a government shutdown. We all know thatDemocratic votes will
be needed to reach a spending agreement that can be enacted.
When Republicans get serious about meeting the true needs of
most Americans, we will be ready and willing to work with our
colleagues to make sure this bill better funds initiatives that
Americans rely on to pursue the American dream.
Rosa DeLauro.
Mike Quigley.