Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 1435]
The Committee on Energy and Commerce, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 1435) to amend the Clean Air Act to prevent the
elimination of the sale of internal combustion engines, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon without
amendment and recommends that the bill do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 2
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 2
Committee Action................................................. 6
Committee Votes.................................................. 6
Oversight Findings and Recommendations........................... 10
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures 10
Congressional Budget Office Estimate............................. 10
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 10
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives............ 10
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 10
Related Committee and Subcommittee Hearings...................... 10
Committee Cost Estimate.......................................... 11
Earmark, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff Benefits....... 11
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 11
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 11
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 11
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 12
Minority Views................................................... 15
Purpose and Summary
The purpose of H.R. 1435 is to amend the conditions
contained in the Clean Air Act (CAA) under which the
Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) must
deny a State a waiver for vehicle emissions laws. Specifically,
H.R. 1435 adds a requirement that the EPA cannot grant a waiver
if the State directive ``directly or indirectly'' limits the
sale or use of new motor vehicles with internal combustion
engines.
Background and Need for Legislation
CLEAN AIR ACT
Title II of the CAA addresses mobile (transportation-based)
sources of air pollution emissions via the tailpipe by seeking
to reduce pollutants from both on-road and non-road vehicles
through vehicle emission standards, as well as transportation
fuel through fuel controls on gasoline and diesel. The title
calls for air pollutant emission standards applicable to new
motor vehicles, new motor vehicle engines, and nonroad vehicle
engines that address air pollutants such as particulate matter
(PM), nitrous oxide (NOx), and greenhouse gases (GHGs).
Within Title II, CAA section 202(a) provides EPA with the
authority to set emission standards for new motor vehicles,
``after such period as the Administrator finds necessary to
permit the development and application of the requisite
technology, giving appropriate consideration to the cost of
compliance within such period.'' EPA is required to consider
issues of technological feasibility, cost of compliance, and
lead time.\1\ EPA may also consider other factors, including
the impacts of potential standards on emissions of air
pollutants, the impacts of such standards on public health and
welfare, the impacts on the automotive industry, the impacts on
the vehicle purchasers and consumers, oil conservation, energy
security and other energy impacts, safety, and other relevant
considerations.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\See ``Multi-Pollutant Emissions Standards for Model Years 2027
and Later Light-Duty and Medium-Duty Vehicles,'' 88 Fed. Reg. 87, May
5, 2023.
\2\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While Title II of the CAA generally pre-empts states from
adopting their own emission standards for new motor vehicles or
engines, CAA section 209(b) provides the EPA Administrator with
the authority to grant a State's vehicle emission standards an
exemption to federal preemption, subject to three conditions.
California is the only state eligible for a waiver under CAA
section 209(b), because California adopted emission standards
for new vehicles prior to the enactment of the CAA. In terms of
the specific conditions, the EPA Administrator shall grant
California a waiver unless: (1) the EPA was arbitrary and
capricious in determining that the State's standards are at
least as protective of public health and welfare as federal
standards; (2) California does not need the standards to meet
compelling or extraordinary conditions; or (3) the State's
standards and accompanying enforcement procedures are not
consistent with CAA section 202(a).
CAA section 177 allows additional States to avoid
preemption of their vehicle emission standards if they adopt
California's exact motor vehicle emission standards under
certain conditions. States are not required to seek EPA's
approval to adopt California's standards under CAA section 177.
As of today, 17 States and the District of Columbia are
referred to as ``Section 177 states'' that have passed state
laws adopting California's Low-Emission Vehicle (LEV) criterial
pollutant and greenhouse gas (GHG) emission regulations.\3\ Of
that group, 15 States and the District of Columbia are poised
to adopt California's Zero-Emission Vehicle (ZEV) regulations
as well.\4\ The Section 177 states represent 40.1 percent of
U.S. new light-duty vehicles sales.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\See ``California Section 177 States,'' California Air Resources
Board, May 13, 2022.
\4\Id.
\5\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
CALIFORNIA'S WAIVER REQUEST
On August 25, 2022, the California Air Resources Board
(CARB) voted to approve its Advanced Clean Cars II (ACC II)
regulation.\6\ California recently submitted a request for a
waiver for ACC II under CAA section 209(b). The State's
regulation requires an increasing number of zero-emission
vehicles, including battery-electric, plug-in hybrid electric
vehicles, and hydrogen fuel cell vehicles to meet strict air
quality and GHG emission standards.\7\ It also effectively bans
the sale of new internal combustion engine vehicles by
requiring all new vehicle sales to be zero-emission vehicles by
2035.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\See ``Advanced Clean Cars II Regulations: All New Passenger
Vehicles Sold in California to be Zero Emissions by 2035,'' California
Air Resources Board.
\7\Id.
\8\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A change of this nature would constitute a dramatic change
in vehicles driven regardless of consumer demand. As recently
as 2021, data for light-duty vehicle registrations in the
United States demonstrates that Americans chose a diversity of
engine types and car classes to meet their needs. Specifically,
93.8 percent of these registrations were for cars powered by
gasoline or ethanol/flex fuel, 0.33 percent operated on diesel
or biodiesel, almost 0.02 percent were hybrid vehicles, and
0.008 percent were plug-in hybrid or battery electric
vehicles.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\See, ``Vehicle Registration Counts by State,'' U.S. Department
of Energy Office of Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy, 2022.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
ELECTRIC VEHICLE COSTS
American consumers are directly impacted by the cost of
vehicles. According to Kelley Blue Book, the average price of
an EV is $65,291, which is $17,197 more than the average price
of an internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicle.\10\ Insurance
for an EV is also $44 more expensive per month or $528 more
expensive per year than insurance for gas-powered cars.\11\
Pricing is especially important, because access to a car is
tied to improved economic outcomes for low-income households.
During a Subcommittee on Environment, Manufacturing, and
Critical Materials hearing, Mr. Nunes of the Breakthrough
Institute testified that:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\ See ``Electric Car FAQ: Your Questions Answered,'' Kelley Blue
Book, October 31, 2022.
\11\See ``Electric car insurance 2023 guide,'' Policygenius,
December 29, 2022.
EVs today are more expensive to purchase up front
than [ICE] powered vehicles. Moreover, this price
disadvantage doesn't fully capture the state of the EV
market. In 2011, the inflation adjusted price of a new
EV was nearly $44,000. By 2022, that price had risen to
over $66,000. EV prices aren't just going up; they are
rising faster than inflation and, as Breakthrough's
analysis suggests, faster than ICE vehicle prices.
Should the government nevertheless implicitly mandate
EV adoption, an approach recently adopted by the [EPA],
it would risk worsening existing inequities in new
vehicle ownership while also encouraging some
households to continue driving older, more polluting
ICE vehicles for longer than they ordinarily would,
potentially hindering emissions reductions efforts.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\See Written Testimony of Ashley Nunes, Director of Federal
Policy, Climate, and Energy, The Breakthrough Institute, before the
Committee on Energy and Commerce, April 26, 2023
Additionally, any Inflation Reduction Act funding intended
to subsidize the final purchase price and thus the growth of EV
sales among certain Americans ends in 2032 when EPA's rule--
mandating two-thirds of new motor vehicles sold be EVs--becomes
fully effective.
The costs do not end with the upfront purchase price.
Fueling one's new electric vehicle engine is also an expense of
consequence. A study by the Anderson Economic Group (AEG) found
trucks cost about the same to fuel and charge, while entry and
midlevel cars and SUVs cost more to charge at home and in
public than they do to fuel at a gas station.\13\ AEG found the
cost to charge an entry-priced ICE cars and crossovers was
``around $9.78 per 100 purposeful miles,'' but an entry-priced
EV charged mostly at home was $12.55 and an EV charged mostly
at commercial charging stations was $15.97.\14\ In addition,
AEG found the cost to charge mid-priced ICE cars and crossovers
was ``approximately $11.08 per 100 purposeful miles,'' but a
mid-priced EV charged mostly at home was $12.62 and an EV
charged mostly at commercial charging stations was $16.10.\15\
In the luxury segment, consumers of electric vehicles charged
mostly at home paid around $13.50 per 100 miles, as opposed to
the $17.56 for the ICE version.\16\ However, EV owners paid
slightly more for commercial charging ($17.81).\17\ This study
was based on the latest information on gas and residential
electricity prices, commercial charging prices, tax rates on
fuel and electric cars, fuel economy details, and more to
compare the cost of fueling versus charging for 100 miles of
driving. Moreover, unlike studies that only compare gas and
electricity costs, the AEG study amortized other costs, like
charging installation and EV registration fees, as part of the
cost of home charging, as well as time spent driving to and
waiting at a station as a cost part of commercial charging.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\See ``Some Cars Cheaper to Fuel with Gas than Electric in
2023,'' Anderson Economic Group, August 1, 2023.
\14\Id.
\15\Id.
\16\Id.
\17\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
EV consumers are faced with a myriad of hidden costs in
addition to the vehicle and fuel itself. If consumers choose to
install a charging station at home, J.D. Power estimates that
the price could be as much as $50,000 depending on labor and
existing electric wiring.\18\ Focusing on charging equipment
specifically, Level 2 chargers are the most common at-home EV
charging stations and cost an average of $1,200 to $2,500 per
charger.\19\ Another significant cost of EV ownership is the
cost of battery replacement. If not covered under warranty,
consumers would have to pay between $5,000 and $20,000 to
replace an EV battery.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\See ``How Much Does It Cost to Install an EV Charger?'' J.D.
Power, December 11, 2022.
\19\Id.
\20\See ``Updated: Electric Car Battery Replacement Costs,''
Recurrent Auto, March 26, 2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
ELECTRIC VEHICLE FUNCTIONALITY
There is also the issue of vehicle range and functionality.
An EV's driving range and electric car mileage per charge
varies, but typically drivers can expect the median of 234
miles in a single charge--factors that can affect an EV's
range, including weather, battery size, and towing weight.\21\
Conversely, the median range of gasoline vehicles in the United
States is 403 miles per fill-up. The Subcommittee on
Environment, Manufacturing, and Critical Materials received
testimony from the President of the Minnesota Automobile
Dealers Association (MADA) that in colder weather areas the
``need to defrost and heat a vehicle can reduce the batteries
range by as much as 40%''\22\ citing a study by J.D. Power and
Plugshare that found ``cold places that receive nasty winter
weather . . . can experience significant declines in [vehicle]
satisfaction.''\23\ The head of MADA also testified that EVs
have a limited towing capability--a significant problem for
contractors, farmers, loggers and miners, stating ``[t]owing
anything with any weight to it dramatically reduces the
potential vehicle range even in ideal weather conditions.''\24\
Also, there are 55,509 EV charging stations in the United
States,\25\ while the National Association of Convenience
Stores reports that there are more than 150,174 fueling
stations across the United States.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\See ``FOTW #1221, January 17, 2022: Year 2021 All-Electric
Vehicles Had a Median Driving Range about 60% of Gasoline Powered
Vehicles,'' Vehicles Technology Office, Department of Energy, January
12, 2022.
\22\See Written Testimony of Scott Lambert, President, Minnesota
Automobile Dealers Association, before the Committee on Energy and
Commerce, June 22, 2023.
\23\Id.
\24\Id.
\25\See ``Electric Vehicle Charging Station Locations,'' Office of
Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Department of Energy, August
21, 2023.
\26\See ``U.S. Convenient Store Count,'' National Association of
Convenience Stores, February 2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
CONSUMER PREFERENCES
Data from a study by Cox Automotive noted that consumer
interest in EVs is not translating into purchases of EVs. Cox's
report found the unsold inventory of EVs in the United States
grew from Memorial Day Weekend 2023 to June 26, 2023 with most
EV models at more than a 100 days' supply, which was more than
twice the rate of gas-powered and hybrid vehicles.\27\ The
unsold inventory was 171 percent higher than what is considered
``normal and ideal'' for auto dealers.\28\ Specifically, 90,953
EVs were sitting on dealership lots across the country during
that 30-day period.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\See ``Path to EV Adoption: Consumer and Dealer Perspectives,''
Cox Automotive, June 2023.
\28\Id.
\29\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 1435 is necessary to prevent California's law from
creating a de facto national effort to ban or otherwise
eliminate the sale of new internal combustion engine cars and
light trucks through the involvement of Section 177 states.
Committee Action
On June 22, 2023, the Subcommittee on Environment,
Manufacturing, and Critical Materials held a hearing on H.R.
1435. The title of the hearing was ``Driving Affordability:
Preserving People's Freedom to Buy Affordable Vehicles and
Fuel.'' The Subcommittee received testimony from:
Joseph Goffman, Principal Deputy
Administrator, Office of Air and Radiation, U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency;
Chet Thompson, President and CEO, American
Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers;
Neil Caskey, CEO, National Corn Growers
Association;
Scott Lambert, President, Minnesota Auto
Dealers Association; and,
Genevieve Cullen, President, Electric Drive
Transportation Association.
On July 12, 2023, the Subcommittee on Environment,
Manufacturing, and Critical Materials met in open markup
session and forwarded H.R. 1435, without amendment, to the full
Committee by a record vote of 13 yeas and 8 nays.
On July 27, 2023, the full Committee on Energy and Commerce
met in open markup session and ordered H.R. 1435 without
amendment, favorably reported to the House by a record vote of
26 yeas and 22 nays.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII requires the Committee to list the
record votes on the motion to report legislation and amendments
thereto. The following reflects the record votes taken during
the Committee consideration:
Oversight Findings and Recommendations
Pursuant to clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII, the Committee held hearings and made findings that
are reflected in this report.
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII, the Committee
finds that H.R. 1435 would result in no new or increased budget
authority, entitlement authority, or tax expenditures or
revenues.
Congressional Budget Office Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII, at the time this
report was filed, the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974 was not available.
Federal Mandates Statement
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of Federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general
performance goal or objective of this legislation is to amend
the conditions under which the EPA Administrator under the
Clean Air Act must deny a State a waiver for vehicle emissions
laws.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII, no provision of
H.R. 1435 is known to be duplicative of another Federal
program, including any program that was included in a report to
Congress pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139 or the
most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance.
Related Committee and Subcommittee Hearings
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII,
(1) The following related hearing was used to develop or
consider H.R. 1435:
On June 22, 2023, the Subcommittee on
Environment, Manufacturing, and Critical Materials held
a hearing on H.R. 1435. The title of the hearing was
``Driving Affordability: Preserving People's Freedom to
Buy Affordable Vehicles and Fuel.'' The Subcommittee
received testimony from:
Joseph Goffman, Principal Deputy
Administrator, Office of Air and Radiation,
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency;
Chet Thompson, President and CEO, American
Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers;
Neil Caskey, CEO, National Corn Growers
Association;
Scott Lambert, President, Minnesota Auto
Dealers Association; and,
Genevieve Cullen, President, Electric Drive
Transportation Association.
(2) The following related hearing was held:
On Wednesday, April 26, 2023, the
Subcommittee on Environment, Manufacturing, and
Critical Materials held a hearing entitled, ``Exposing
the Environmental, Human Rights, and National Security
Risks of the Biden Administration's Rush to Green
Policies.'' The Subcommittee received testimony from:
Mark Mills, Senior Fellow, Manhattan
Institute;
Ashley Nunes, Director of Federal Policy,
Climate, and Energy, Breakthrough Institute;
Daniel Simmons, Vice President for Policy,
Institute for Energy Research; and,
Trevor Higgins, Senior Vice President,
Energy and Environment, Center for American
Progress.
Committee Cost Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII, the Committee
adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974. At the time this report was
filed, the estimate was not available.
Earmark, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff Benefits
Pursuant to clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI, the
Committee finds that H.R. 1435 contains no earmarks, limited
tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation
Section 1. Short title
Section 1 of H.R. 1435 provides that the Act may be cited
as the ``Preserving Choice in Vehicle Purchases Act.''
Section 2. State standards
Section 2 of H.R. 1435 contains three parts:
(1) First, the section amends CAA section 209(b), the
conditions under which EPA can grant a waiver to a
State for motor vehicle emission standards, by adding a
requirement that the EPA cannot grant a waiver if the
State directive ``directly or indirectly'' limits the
sale or use of new motor vehicles with internal
combustion engines.
(2) Second, the section prevents EPA from considering
State standards amended after the date of enactment of
this bill as having qualified under an existing waiver.
(3) Third, section 2(b) revokes any CAA section
209(b) waivers that California received between January
1, 2022, and the date that H.R. 1435 becomes law if the
State standard ``directly or indirectly'' limited the
sale or use of new motor vehicles with internal
combustion engines. As drafted, the Committee
understands that Section 2(b) could apply to
California's Advanced Clean Cars II, Advanced Clean
Cars I, Advanced Clean Trucks, Heavy-Duty Vehicle
Engines Emission Warranty and Maintenance, Nonroad
Engine Pollution Control Standards regulations,\30\ and
the Advanced Clean Fleets regulation.\31\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\See ``Vehicle Emissions California Waivers and
Authorizations,'' Environmental Protection Agency, August 4, 2023.
\31\See ``Recent Actions Taken by OAL on Proposed Regulations,''
Office of Administrative Law, State of California, 2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
CLEAN AIR ACT
* * * * * * *
TITLE II--EMISSION STANDARDS FOR MOVING SOURCES
* * * * * * *
Part A--Motor Vehicle Emission and Fuel Standards
* * * * * * *
state standards
Sec. 209. (a) No State or any political subdivision thereof
shall adopt or attempt to enforce any standard relating to the
control of emissions from new motor vehicles or new motor
vehicle engines subject to this part. No State shall require
certification, inspection, or any other approval relating to
the control of emissions from any new motor vehicle or new
motor vehicle engine as condition precedent to the initial
retail sale, titling (if any), or registration of such motor
vehicle, motor vehicle engine, or equipment.
(b)(1) The Administrator shall, after notice and opportunity
for public hearing, waive application of this section to any
State which has adopted standards (other than crankcase
emission standards) for the control of emissions from new motor
vehicles or new motor vehicle engines prior to March 30, 1966,
if the State determines that the State standards will be, in
the aggregate, at least as protective of public health and
welfare as applicable Federal standards. No such waiver shall
be granted if the Administrator finds that--
(A) the determination of the State is arbitrary and
capricious,
(B) such State does not need such State standards to
meet compelling and extraordinary conditions, [or]
(C) such State standards and accompanying enforcement
procedures are not consistent with section 202(a) of
this [part.] part, or
(D) such State standards directly or indirectly limit
the sale or use of new motor vehicles with internal
combustion engines, as such term is defined in section
63.9375 of title 40, Code of Federal Regulations, as in
effect January 1, 2023.
(2) If each State standard is at least as stringent as the
comparable applicable Federal standard, such State standard
shall be deemed to be at least as protective of health and
welfare as such Federal standards for purposes of paragraph
(1).
(3) In the case of any new motor vehicle or new motor vehicle
engine to which State standards apply pursuant to a waiver
granted under paragraph (1), compliance with such State
standards shall be treated as compliance with applicable
Federal standards for purposes of this title.
(4) The Administrator may not determine that any State
standards amended after the date of enactment of this paragraph
are within the scope of a waiver granted under paragraph (1)
before the date of enactment of this paragraph.
(c) Whenever a regulation with respect to any motor vehicle
part or motor vehicle engine part is in effect under section
207(a)(2), no State or political subdivision thereof shall
adopt or attempt to enforce any standard or any requirement of
certification, inspection, or approval which relates to motor
vehicle emissions and is applicable to the same aspect of such
part. The preceding sentence shall not apply in the case of a
State with respect to which a waiver is in effect under
subsection (b).
(d) Nothing in this part shall preclude or deny to any State
or political subdivision thereof the right otherwise to
control, regulate, or restrict the use, operation, or movement
of registered or licensed motor vehicles.
(e) Nonroad Engines or Vehicles.--
(1) Prohibition on certain state standards.--No State
or any political subdivision thereof shall adopt or
attempt to enforce any standard or other requirement
relating to the control of emissions from either of the
following new nonroad engines or nonroad vehicles
subject to regulation under this Act--
(A) New engines which are used in
construction equipment or vehicles or used in
farm equipment or vehicles and which are
smaller than 175 horsepower.
(B) New locomotives or new engines used in
locomotives.
Subsection (b) shall not apply for purposes of this
paragraph.
(2) Other nonroad engines or vehicles.--(A) In the
case of any nonroad vehicles or engines other than
those referred to in subparagraph (A) or (B) of
paragraph (1), the Administrator shall, after notice
and opportunity for public hearing, authorize
California to adopt and enforce standards and other
requirements relating to the control of emissions from
such vehicles or engines if California determines that
California standards will be, in the aggregate, at
least as protective of public health and welfare as
applicable Federal standards. No such authorization
shall be granted if the Administrator finds that--
(i) the determination of California is
arbitrary and capricious,
(ii) California does not need such California
standards to meet compelling and extraordinary
conditions, or
(iii) California standards and accompanying
enforcement procedures are not consistent with
this section.
(B) Any State other than California which has plan
provisions approved under part D of title I may adopt
and enforce, after notice to the Administrator, for any
period, standards relating to control of emissions from
nonroad vehicles or engines (other than those referred
to in subparagraph (A) or (B) of paragraph (1)) and
take such other actions as are referred to in
subparagraph (A) of this paragraph respecting such
vehicles or engines if--
(i) such standards and implementation and
enforcement are identical, for the period
concerned, to the California standards
authorized by the Administrator under
subparagraph (A), and
(ii) California and such State adopt such
standards at least 2 years before commencement
of the period for which the standards take
effect.
The Administrator shall issue regulations to implement
this subsection.
* * * * * * *
Minority Views
We oppose H.R. 1435, legislation to prevent the
Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) from
granting a waiver of federal preemption under the Clean Air Act
(CAA) for any California vehicle emissions standard that
``directly or indirectly limit[s] the sale or use of'' vehicles
with internal combustion engines and directs EPA to revoke
already-granted waivers that do not comply with this vague
metric. This would put existing waivers dating back to 2013 in
jeopardy, upend the entire clean vehicle supply chain, and
create uncertainty for the U.S. automotive industry. This bill
is a direct attack on over 50 years of Congress and EPA
recognizing California's ability to voluntarily adopt those
standards to protect their citizens from dangerous air
pollution and climate change.
Background
Congress and EPA have viewed California as a leader in
reducing air pollution for decades due to its unique air
pollution challenges, and as the first state to regulate
tailpipe emissions from vehicles back in 1966.\1\ This is
reflected in Section 209 of the CAA, which requires EPA to
grant California waivers so it can set vehicle emissions
standards that are more protective than those set by EPA at the
federal level.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\California Air Resources Board, History (ww2.arb.ca.gov/about/
history#::text=In%201966%20 California
%20established%20the,Air%20Resources %20Board%20was%20established.)
(accessed Aug. 25, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, Section 177 of the CAA allows other
pollution-burdened states to voluntarily adopt any California
emissions standard that has been granted a waiver from EPA.
Section 177 authority has allowed over a dozen states to adopt
California's low-emission vehicle (LEV) or zero-emission
vehicle (ZEV) standards and reap the environmental and public
health benefits of the more stringent standards.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\The International Council on Clean Transportation, Benefits of
Adopting California Advanced Clean Cars II Regulations Under Clean Air
Act Section 177 (May 24, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 1435 seeks to erase decades of historic progress on
addressing air pollution from the transportation sector,
driving innovation, and protecting public health.
The bill would put existing waivers dating back to 2013 in
jeopardy. The Majority seeks to retroactively reverse nearly a
decade's worth of clean vehicle standards, choosing polluters
over people, instead of building upon the industry's innovation
and where market trends are leading. Recently, the California
Air Resources Board (CARB) and truck and engine manufacturers
announced the Clean Truck Partnership to cut dangerous
pollution from the heavy-duty transportation sector and assure
a path to zero-emission trucks. However, if enacted, H.R. 1435
would revoke existing waivers and block any future waivers
related to this historic agreement.
The Majority claims H.R. 1435 is necessary to prevent
California from creating a de facto national ban on new
internal combustion engine cars and light trucks. This
reasoning is short-sighted and fails to recognize market demand
for EVs, the public health and environmental benefits of moving
towards zero-emission vehicles, states' rights, and where auto
industry innovation is already heading. American demand for EVs
is already outpacing supply, as EV demand increased by 350
percent from 2020 to 2022, and the EV market share increased by
377 percent from 2020 to the first quarter of 2023.\3\ Auto
manufacturers are also leading the way, with Ford having
announced an investment of $3.7 billion in its Michigan, Ohio,
and Missouri factories to manufacture both electric and
internal combustion engine vehicles.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Consumer Reports, Excess Demand: The Looming EV Shortage (Mar.
2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, H.R. 1435 sends the wrong signal to our
domestic vehicle manufacturing industry. Industry desires
predictability, regulatory certainty, and long-term stability.
During a Subcommittee on Environment, Manufacturing, and
Critical Materials legislative hearing on H.R. 1435, the only
witness representing the vehicle manufacturing industry
testified that the disruption and uncertainty that would ensue
from this bill, ``. . . would work against U.S. market
leadership and consumers' access to EV choices.''\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\House Committee on Energy and Commerce, Testimony of Genevieve
Cullen, President, Electric Drive Transportation Association, Hearing
on Driving Affordability: Preserving People's Freedom to Buy Affordable
Vehicles and Fuel, 118th Cong. (June 22, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The detrimental impacts of H.R. 1435 would extend well
beyond California, to any Section 177 state that chose to adopt
California's standards. Combined, these states represent more
than 40 percent of new vehicle sales.\5\ Thus, by making
egregious changes to the CAA Section 209 waiver authority, the
bill directly infringes upon states' rights to make regulatory
decisions that fit their needs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY OF H.R. 1435
Section 2(a) of H.R. 1435 amends CAA Section 209(b) by
adding that the EPA Administrator shall not grant a waiver of
federal preemption if the state standards ``directly or
indirectly limit[s] the sale or use of'' vehicles with internal
combustion engines, providing a destructively vague metric.
Additionally, the section prevents EPA from determining any
state standards are within scope of existing waivers after the
date of enactment--blocking California from amending existing
waivers to avoid the bill's requirements.
Section 2(b) of H.R. 1435 requires the EPA Administrator to
revoke all waivers granted after January 1, 2022, if the state
standard ``directly or indirectly limit[s] the sale or use of''
vehicles with internal combustion engines, requiring the EPA
Administrator to revoke already-existing waivers that do not
comply with this vague metric.
CONCLUSION
H.R 1435 disregards decades of legal precedent, upends the
CAA's Section 209 waiver process, and imperils the
technological advancement in the transportation sector. Instead
of joining Democrats in addressing dangerous air pollution,
strengthening domestic vehicle manufacturing supply chains, and
driving innovation, the Majority is choosing to help their
polluter friends at the expensive of public health,
technological innovation, states' rights, and a stronger,
cleaner economy for American families.
For the reasons stated above, we dissent from the views
contained in the Committee Report.
Frank Pallone, Jr.
Ranking Member, Committee on Energy and Commerce.