Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 1131]
The Committee on Energy and Commerce, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 1131) to require the Administrator of the
Environmental Protection Agency to authorize the use of
flexible air permitting with respect to certain critical energy
resource facilities, and for other purposes, having considered
the same, reports favorably thereon without amendment and
recommends that the bill do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 2
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 2
Committee Action................................................. 3
Committee Votes.................................................. 4
Oversight Findings and Recommendations........................... 8
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures 8
Congressional Budget Office Estimate............................. 8
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 8
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives............ 8
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 8
Related Committee and Subcommittee Hearings...................... 8
Committee Cost Estimate.......................................... 9
Earmark, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff Benefits....... 9
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 9
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 9
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 9
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 10
Minority Views................................................... 11
Purpose and Summary
H.R. 1131, a bill to require the Administrator of the
Environmental Protection Agency to authorize the use of
flexible air permitting with respect to certain critical energy
resource facilities, and for other purposes, was introduced by
Rep. John Joyce (R-PA) and Rep. Rick W. Allen (R-GA) on
February 21, 2023. H.R. 1131 would require the Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) Administrator to review and, as
necessary, revise regulations concerning the Flexible
Permitting Rule under the Clean Air Act, to authorize flexible
permitting for owners and operators of critical energy resource
facilities, as defined in the bill. Participation in this
process enables owners and operators of the facilities to
receive advance approvals from Clean Air Act permitting
authorities by preparing in advance for potential increased
operations to meet changes in market demand, avoiding future
delays to enable market-responsive operations.
Background and Need for Legislation
As recently as 1990, the United States was the world's
number-one producer of minerals. By 2018, the United States had
fallen to 12th overall in global non-fuel minerals
production.\1\ A 2022 Department of Energy (DOE) assessment of
critical energy resource supply chain risks notes that China's
control of key materials in renewable energy is ``across the
board,'' with China in control of ``80% of rare earths
production and refining that are key for components in
technologies such as direct drive generators in wind turbines,
and China also controls 61% of global lithium refining key for
battery storage and electric vehicles. China also controls 100%
of the processing of natural graphite used for battery
anodes.''\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\See testimony of Michelle Michot Foss before the Subcommittee on
Environment and Climate Change hearing ``Building a 100 Percent Clean
Economy: Opportunities for and Equitable, Low-Carbon Recovery,''
September 16, 2020. (https://docs.house.gov/meetings/IF/IF18/20200916/
111008/HHRG-116-IF18-Wstate-MichotFossM-20200916-U1.pdf)
\2\See Department of Energy ``America's Strategy to Secure the
Supply Chain for a Robust Clean Energy Transition,'' February 2022, p.
13)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The severity of this overdependence on other countries for
critical minerals was brought to the public's attention by the
report released during the Trump administration, which found
the United States relies on imports for 31 of the 35 critical
minerals necessary for the U.S. defense and economy.\3\ For 14
of the listed critical minerals, the United States relies
completely on imports from other countries; having no U.S.
production at all. As indicated in the above DOE assessment,
recent Biden administration reviews confirm U.S. vulnerability.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\See Testimony by the Honorable Mark W. Menezes at the Joint
Energy, Climate, and Grid Security Subcommittee and Environment,
Manufacturing, and Critical Materials Subcommittee Legislative Hearing,
``Unleashing American Energy, Lowering Energy Costs, and Strengthening
Supply Chains,'' February 7, 2023. (energycommerce.gov)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Against this backdrop, Congress has taken action\4\ to
support research and development, incentives, and interagency
planning relating to critical minerals and materials, to reduce
dependence on foreign supplies as demand increases for
minerals- and materials-heavy energy resources.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\See, for example, critical mineral research and development
provision in the Energy Act of 2020, the development of an interagency
task force and other incentives in the Infrastructure Investment and
Job Act, as well as the Inflation Reduction Act tax incentives.
Legislation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Given the importance of encouraging actual operations of
refining and processing of critical energy minerals and
materials for this effort, existing laws and regulations should
be updated to ensure they accommodate domestic operations.
As former DOE Deputy Secretary Mark Menezes has testified
before the Committee:
Since 2009, EPA has allowed the use of its ``Flexible
Air Permitting Rule.'' EPA promulgated this rule ``to
promote flexible air permitting (FAP) approaches that
provide greater operational flexibility and, at the
same time, ensure environmental protection and
compliance with applicable laws.'' EPA, however, limits
FAP's use. Thus, in order for the United States to
accelerate its development of critical energy
resources, a bill is necessary to require the EPA to
allow FAP's use by the owner or operator of a critical
energy resource facility. This bill will facilitate the
development and deployment of energy resources
necessary to accelerate the production and deployment
of materials necessary for the energy transition to a
more decarbonized economy.''\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Ibid.
The Committee finds that H.R. 1131 would provide important
updates to existing Clean Air Act programs to help the
development and growth of domestic operations of critical
energy resource facilities, particularly those facilities
necessary to process critical minerals and materials vulnerable
to supply disruptions, while ensuring operations comply with
all applicable Clean Air Act requirements. The Committee finds
H.R. 1131, by directing the EPA Administrator to consider use
of flexible permitting specifically for critical energy
resource facilities and to ensure regulations would facilitate
market responsive operations of these facilities, will enable
these facilities to make rapid changes to respond to market
demands, save resources for state permitting agencies and help
strengthen competitiveness of domestic resource producers. The
Committee finds that H.R. 1131 represents the kind of practical
reforms necessary to secure American critical energy resources.
Committee Action
On February 7, 2023, the Subcommittees on Energy, Climate,
and Grid Security and Environment, Manufacturing, and Critical
Materials held a joint hearing entitled, ``Unleashing American
Energy, Lowering Energy Costs, and Strengthening Supply
Chains,'' on 17 pieces of legislation, including H.R. 1131. The
Subcommittees received testimony from:
The Honorable Mark Menezes, Former United
States Deputy Secretary of Energy, Department of
Energy;
The Honorable Bernard McNamee, Former
Commissioner, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission;
Jeffrey Eshelman, II, President and Chief
Executive Officer, Independent Petroleum Association of
America;
Katie Sweeney, Executive Vice President and
Chief Operating Officer, National Mining Association;
Raul Garcia, Legislative Director for
Healthy Communities, Earthjustice; and
Tyson Slocum, Director of the Energy
Program, Public Citizen.
On February 28, 2023, the Subcommittee on Environment,
Manufacturing, and Critical Materials met in open markup
session and forwarded H.R. 1131, without amendment, to the full
Committee by a record vote of 13 yeas and 6 nays. On March 9,
the full Committee on Energy and Commerce met in open markup
session and ordered H.R. 1131 favorably reported, without
amendment, to the House by a record vote of 26 yeas and 20
nays.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII requires the Committee to list the
record votes on the motion to report legislation and amendments
thereto. The following reflects the record votes taken during
the Committee consideration:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
OVERSIGHT FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Pursuant to clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII, the Committee held a hearing and made findings that
are reflected in this report.
NEW BUDGET AUTHORITY, ENTITLEMENT AUTHORITY, AND TAX EXPENDITURES
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII, the Committee
finds that H.R. 1131 would result in no new or increased budget
authority, entitlement authority, or tax expenditures or
revenues.
Congressional Budget Office Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII, at the time this
report was filed, the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974 was not available.
FEDERAL MANDATES STATEMENT
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of Federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
STATEMENT OF GENERAL PERFORMANCE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general
performance goal or objective of this legislation is to provide
flexible permitting under the Clean Air Act to enable market-
responsive operations.
The goal of the bill is to increase American energy
production and restore energy leadership by authorizing the use
of flexible air permitting with respect to certain critical
energy resource facilities.
DUPLICATION OF FEDERAL PROGRAMS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII, no provision of
H.R. 1131 is known to be duplicative of another Federal
program, including any program that was included in a report to
Congress pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139 or the
most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance.
RELATED COMMITTEE AND SUBCOMMITTEE HEARINGS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII,
(1) the following hearings were used to develop or consider
H.R. 1131:
On January 31, 2023, the Committee on Energy and Commerce
held an oversight hearing, entitled: ``American Energy
Expansion: Strengthening Economic, Environmental, and National
Security''. The Committee received testimony from:
The Honorable Paul Dabbar, Former U.S.
Undersecretary of Energy, Department of Energy;
Donna Jackson, Director of Membership
Development, National Center for Public Policy
Research, Project 21;
Robert McNally, President, Rapidan Energy
Group; and
Ana Unruh Cohen, Ph.D., Former Staff
Director, U.S House Select Committee on the Climate
Crisis.
(2) The following related hearing was held:
On February 7, 2023, the Subcommittees on Energy, Climate,
and Grid Security and Environment, Manufacturing, and Critical
Materials held a joint hearing entitled, ``Unleashing American
Energy, Lowering Energy Costs, and Strengthening Supply
Chains,'' on 17 pieces of legislation, including H.R. 1131. The
Subcommittees received testimony from:
The Honorable Mark Menezes, Former United
States Deputy Secretary of Energy, Department of
Energy;
The Honorable Bernard McNamee, Former
Commissioner, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission;
Jeffrey Eshelman, II, President and Chief
Executive Officer, Independent Petroleum Association of
America;
Katie Sweeney, Executive Vice President and
Chief Operating Officer, National Mining Association;
Raul Garcia, Legislative Director for
Healthy Communities, Earthjustice; and
Tyson Slocum, Director of the Energy
Program, Public Citizen.
COMMITTEE COST ESTIMATE
Pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII, the Committee
adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974. At the time this report was
filed, the estimate was not available.
EARMARK, LIMITED TAX BENEFITS, AND LIMITED TARIFF BENEFITS
Pursuant to clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI, the
Committee finds that H.R. 1131 contains no earmarks, limited
tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits.
ADVISORY COMMITTEE STATEMENT
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
APPLICABILITY TO LEGISLATIVE BRANCH
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
SECTION-BY-SECTION ANALYSIS OF THE LEGISLATION
Section 1. Flexible Air Permits for Critical Energy Resource Facilities
Section 1 provides that the Administrator of the
Environmental Protection Agency shall review and, as necessary
revise regulations concerning the Flexible Permitting Rule
under the Clean Air Act, to authorize flexible permitting for
owners and operators of critical energy resource facilities and
facilitate flexible, market-responsive operations of these
facilities, and defines critical energy resources and critical
energy resource facilities.
CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW MADE BY THE BILL, AS REPORTED
This legislation does not amend any existing Federal
statute.
Minority Views
We oppose H.R. 1131, a bill that would compel the
Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to
authorize the use of Clean Air Act (CAA) flexible air permits
for all ``critical energy resource facilities.'' H.R. 1131 is
unnecessary, as EPA and states can already issue flexible air
permits, when appropriate. Directing the EPA Administrator to
unilaterally grant flexible air permits to every facility that
the Secretary of Energy deems ``critical,'' regardless of
situation or previous track record, creates a massive loophole
in the CAA and puts public health and the welfare of
communities at risk.
Background
Title V of the CAA requires all states to develop operating
permit programs, requiring each industrial facility that is a
``major source'' of air pollution to obtain an operating
permit.\1\ These permits are legally-enforceable documents
designed to improve compliance by clarifying what facilities
must do to control air pollution, and detail federal and state
air pollution control requirements that apply. State and local
permitting authorities have primary responsibility for issuing
most Title V permits, while EPA regional offices issue permits
in certain circumstances.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Environmental Protection Agency, Operating Permits Issued under
Title V of the Clean Air Act (www.epa.gov/title-v-operating-permits)
(accessed Mar. 21, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2009, EPA finalized a rule to promote the use of
flexible air permits with the goal of providing greater
operational, market-responsive flexibility while ensuring
environmental protection and compliance with applicable CAA
requirements.\2\ A flexible air permit contains approaches that
allow the regulated source to make certain types of operational
changes without the need for further review or approval by the
permitting authority. These permits are considered and granted
by states and EPA on a case-by-case basis, and include
specifications and conditions for each facility based on its
unique operational and regulatory circumstances. Based on a
series of extensive pilot programs that informed the 2009 rule,
EPA found that flexible air permitting approaches would be
relevant for a variety of industries, including: aerospace
manufacturing, automobile manufacturing, industrial organic
chemicals, chemical processes, converted paper and paperboard
products, magnetic tape manufacturing, petroleum refining,
other coating operations, paper mills, pharmaceutical
manufacturing, printing and publishing, pulp and paper mills,
semiconductors, and specialty batch chemical processes.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Environmental Protection Agency, Operating Permit Programs;
Flexible Air Permitting Rule, 74 Fed. Reg. 51417 (Oct. 6, 2009) (rule).
\3\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 1131 is a legislative solution in search of a problem.
The proponents claim it is necessary to give ``critical energy
resource facilities'' the opportunity and flexibility to
promptly respond to market demands through operational changes.
This argument fails to recognize that a wide variety of
facilities, specifically those related to energy production,
are already eligible for flexible air permits, if appropriate.
SUMMARY OF THE ACT
Section 1(a) would require the EPA Administrator to
authorize the use of flexible air permitting for any so-called
``critical energy resource facility.'' This language
demonstrates a failure to recognize the role states play in
issuing flexible air permits, and the importance of thoughtful
review by permitting authorities. Section 1(a) would compel the
EPA Administrator to run roughshod over state and local
permitting authorities, granting flexible air permits with no
regard for each facility's specific situation.
The use of flexible air permits certainly makes sense in
specific situations, however, that's not always the case. This
blanket flexible air permit approach empowers bad actors to
skirt pollution control requirements, as demonstrated by past
abuses of the flexible air permits at facilities like the
former Limetree Bay Refinery in the U.S. Virgin Islands.\4\
Democratic Committee members offered amendments to address the
issue of bad actors qualifying for flexible air permits, to
protect the environment and public health of the communities
living near these facilities. Every Republican Committee member
voted against an amendment excluding facilities that have
previously violated the Clean Air Act from being eligible for
flexible air permits.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Environmental Protection Agency, EPA Withdraws Plantwide
Applicability Limit Permit for Limetree Bay Refinery in the U.S. Virgin
Islands, Will Review Clean Air Act Requirements for the Facility (Mar.
25, 2021) (press release).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 1(b) defines ``critical energy resource'' as ``. .
. any energy resource that is essential to the energy sector
and energy systems of the United States, and the supply chain
of which is vulnerable to disruption,'' as determined by the
Secretary of Energy. The bill does not define, provide
parameters, or metrics for the Secretary to use in making such
determinations, essentially allowing the Secretary to deem
almost anything a ``critical energy resource,'' ``essential to
the energy sector and energy system of the United States,'' and
``vulnerable to supply chain disruptions.'' The bill fails to
include any public review, or accountability measures related
to the Secretary's determinations. And putting the Secretary of
Energy in charge of determining which flexible air permits EPA
and states are allowed to require, sets a troubling precedent.
Due to the all-encompassing definition of ``critical energy
resource,'' essentially any category of industrial facility
could be considered a ``critical energy resource facility,''
and would automatically be eligible for a flexible air permit.
Based on these definitions, EPA would be compelled to grant a
flexible air permit without due process, for the following
facilities: solid waste incinerators, hazardous waste
combustors, Portland cement manufacturers, mercury cell chlor-
alkali plants, secondary lead smelters, carbon black
production, chemical manufacturing, primary copper smelting,
secondary copper smelting, nonferrous metals area sources
(zinc, cadmium, and beryllium), glass manufacturing, and gold
mine ore processing and production, among others.
Since H.R. 1311 grants the Secretary of Energy enormous
latitude to determine what qualifies as a critical energy
resource, this list demonstrates the wide range of polluting
industrial categories that could be granted flexible air
permits, regardless of their regulatory history or operational
needs.
CONCLUSION
We oppose H.R. 1131. As drafted, this bill would force the
EPA Administrator to put public health and the welfare of
communities surrounding so-called critical energy resource
facilities at risk by granting blanket air permits, even to
facilities that have previously violated the CAA. H.R. 1131
will not ``cut red tape'' as the Majority claims. It is a clear
handout to polluters at the expense of vulnerable communities
that will be harmed by the bill's erosion of basic
environmental safeguards.
For the reasons stated above, we dissent from the views
contained in the Committee's report.
Frank Pallone, Jr.,
Ranking Member, Committee on Energy and Commerce.
[all]