Minority Views
[To accompany H. R. 4468]
The Committee on Energy and Commerce, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 4468) to prohibit the Administrator of the
Environmental Protection Agency from finalizing, implementing,
or enforcing a proposed rule with respect to emissions from
vehicles, and for other purposes, having considered the same,
reports favorably thereon without amendment and recommends that
the bill do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 2
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 2
Committee Action................................................. 8
Committee Votes.................................................. 9
Oversight Findings and Recommendations........................... 13
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures 13
Congressional Budget Office Estimate............................. 13
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 13
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives............ 13
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 13
Related Committee and Subcommittee Hearings...................... 13
Committee Cost Estimate.......................................... 14
Earmark, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff Benefits....... 14
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 14
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 14
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 14
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 16
Minority Views................................................... 32
Purpose and Summary
The purpose of H.R. 4468 is to prohibit the Administrator
of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) from finalizing,
implementing, or enforcing a regulation with respect to
emissions from light-duty and medium-duty vehicles starting
with model year 2027; to prevent EPA from mandating the use of
specific technology in new motor vehicles or issuing rules that
result in limited availability of vehicles to end-use consumers
based upon the engine in that vehicle; and to preserve American
automobile manufacturing and protect access for American
consumers to choose affordable, reliable, and functional
automobiles for their needs.
Background and Need for Legislation
AMERICA AND THE CAR
The automobile was a key force for change in twentieth-
century America, becoming one of the backbones of a consumer
goods-oriented society,\1\ providing upward mobility and
personal freedom, spawning the growth of suburbs, and ending
rural isolation from medical care and schools.\2\ A total of
278,063,737 personal and commercial vehicles were registered to
drivers in the U.S. in 2021; and 91.7 percent of households had
at least one vehicle that same year.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\See ``Automobile History,'' History.com Editors, August 21,
2018.
\2\Id.
\3\See ``Car Ownership Statistics 2023,'' Forbes, August 17, 2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Yet, despite the reliance on the car to commute to work or
school, handle personal or other employment obligations, and
travel long distances; Americans have not settled for accepting
just any model of vehicle. Affordable and reliable automobiles
are a hallmark demand of Americans to help them meet their
transportation needs. This demand dates to the first modern
motor cars when the central problem of automotive technology
was reconciling the advanced design of the 1901 Mercedes with
the moderate price and low operating expenses of the Olds\4\
and continues today.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\See note 1.
\5\See ``Worth the Watt: A Brief History of the Electric Car, 1830
to Present,'' Car and Driver, March 31, 2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY AND THE CLEAN AIR ACT
Title II of the Clean Air Act (CAA) addresses mobile
(transportation-based) sources of air pollution emissions via
the tailpipe by seeking to reduce pollutants from both on-road
and nonroad vehicles (vehicle emission standards), as well as
transportation (gasoline & diesel) fuel (fuel controls). It
calls for air pollutant emissions standards applicable to new
motor vehicles and new motor vehicle engines, as well as
nonroad vehicles and nonroad engines--these address air
pollutants, including particulate matter (PM), nitrous oxide
(NOx), and greenhouse gases (GHGs).
Within Title II, CAA section 202 provides the Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) with the authority to set emission
standards for new motor vehicles. Standards under section
202(a) take effect ``after such period as the Administrator
finds necessary to permit the development and application of
the requisite technology, giving appropriate consideration to
the cost of compliance within such period.'' The EPA must
consider issues of technological feasibility, the cost of
compliance, and lead time.\6\ The EPA also may consider other
factors, including the impacts of potential standards on
emissions of air pollutants and associated public health and
welfare effects, impacts on the automotive industry, impacts on
the vehicle purchasers/consumers, oil conservation, energy
security and other energy impacts, safety, and other relevant
considerations.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\See ``Multi-Pollutant Emissions Standards for Model Years 2027
and Later Light-Duty and Medium-Duty Vehicles,'' 88 Fed. Reg. 87, May
5, 2023.
\7\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Beginning in 2010, EPA began to interpret CAA section 202
as providing the Agency authority to regulate greenhouse gas
(GHGs) emissions from cars and trucks. CAA section 202 requires
the EPA administrator to prescribe ``standards applicable to
the emission of any air pollutant from any class or classes of
new motor vehicles or new motor vehicle engines,'' which EPA
believes ``cause, or contribute to, air pollution which may
reasonably be anticipated to endanger public health or
welfare.'' Between 2010 and the end of 2022, EPA had
promulgated three rounds of GHG standards for light-duty
vehicles, covering model years 2012-2026, and two rounds of GHG
standards for medium- and heavy-duty trucks, covering model
years 2014-2027.
On April 12, 2023, EPA announced new, more ambitious
standards to reduce air pollutant emissions from light-duty and
medium-duty vehicles starting with model year 2027.\8\ The
proposal, published May 5, 2023, builds upon EPA's final
standards for federal greenhouse gas emissions standards for
passenger cars and light trucks for model years 2023 through
2026, and the proposed standards would phase in over model
years 2027 through 2032.\9\ According to EPA, these ``proposed
standards are projected to accelerate the transition to
electric vehicles'' and the Agency ``projects that EVs could
account for 67% of new light-duty vehicle sales and 46% of new
medium-duty vehicle sales in MY 2032.''\10\ EPA received more
that 252,400 comments on this rule and had 359 comments posted
to its rulemaking docket,\11\ including a statement from the
Alliance for Automotive Innovation which called the proposal
``neither reasonable nor achievable in the timeframe
provided.''\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\See ``Biden-Harris Administration Proposes Strongest-Ever
Pollution Standards for Cars and Trucks to Accelerate Transition to a
Clean-Transportation Future,'' Environmental Protection Agency, April
12, 2023.
\9\See ``Multi-Pollutant Emissions Standards for Model Years 2027
and Later Light-Duty and Medium-Duty Vehicles,'' 88 Fed. Reg. 87, May
5, 2023.
\10\Id.
\11\See ``Multi-Pollutant Emissions Standards for Model Years 2027
and Later Light-Duty and Medium Duty Vehicles: Rulemaking Docket,''
Environmental Protection Agency, August 2023.
\12\See ``Comment Submitted by Alliance for Automotive
Innovation,'' Posted by the Environmental Protection Agency, May 22,
2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE CHALLENGES OF CONVERTING THE UNITED STATES TO A LARGELY ELECTRIC
FLEET OF VEHICLES
Critical Minerals
Energy technology for electric vehicles (EVs) requires a
specific mix of critical materials, including critical minerals
and rare earth elements. The International Energy Agency (IEA)
emphasized, ``[m]inerals offer a different and distinct set of
challenges, but their rising importance in a decarbonizing
energy system requires energy policy makers to expand their
horizons and consider potential new vulnerabilities.''\13\ As
production increases to meet demand, current challenges with
critical mineral mining, processing, and refining will only
intensify.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\See ``The Role of Critical Minerals in Clean Energy
Transitions,'' International Energy Agency, March 2022.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The United States Geological Survey's (USGS) 2022 list of
critical minerals includes 50 unique commodities, and the
Energy Act of 2020 requires the Department of the Interior to
update a list of critical minerals at least every three
years.\14\ The most recent list includes aluminum, chromium,
cobalt, copper, manganese, nickel, and zinc.\15\ The Department
of Energy (DOE) defines rare earth elements as 17 elements\16\
that ``play a critical role to our national security, energy
independence, environmental future, and economic growth.''\17\
Sixteen of the 17 individual rare earth elements are included
in the 2022 USGS list of critical minerals.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\P.L. 116-260.
\15\See ``2022 Final List of Critical Minerals,'' DOI-2021-0013,
Department of the Interior, U.S. Geological Survey, February 22, 2022.
\16\See the list of 17 rare earth elements from the ``Report on
Rare Earth Elements from Coal and Coal Byproducts,'' Department of
Energy, January 2017.
\17\See ``Rare Earth Elements,'' Department of Energy, April 2023.
\18\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
EV batteries rely upon five critical minerals: lithium,
cobalt, manganese, nickel, and graphite.\19\ Compared to a
conventional internal combustion engine car, an electric car
requires six times the mineral inputs.\20\ Furthermore, IEA
estimated that the demand for lithium will increase by 43 times
by 2040.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\See ``Critical Minerals in Electric Vehicle Batteries,''
Congressional Research Service, August 29, 2022.
\20\See ``The Role of Critical Minerals in Clean Energy
Transitions: Mineral Requirements for Clean Energy Transitions,''
International Energy Agency, March 2022.
\21\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
China
Critical minerals are crucial for EVs and batteries, and
China dominates much of the supply chains for EV batteries.
According to a recent Brookings report:
China refines 68 percent of nickel globally,
59 percent of lithium, and 73 percent of cobalt;
China dominates global production of battery
cells, including 70 percent of cathodes, 85 percent of
anodes, 66 percent of separators, and 62 percent of
electrolytes;
China has 78 percent of the world's cell
manufacturing capacity for EV batteries;
Three-fourths of the world's lithium-ion
battery mega-factories are in China; and
China is ``the largest consumer of the
minerals it refines.''\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\See ``China's Role in Supplying Critical Minerals for the
Global Energy Transition: What Could the Future Hold?'' Brookings,
August 1, 2022.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Meanwhile, China is unquestionably the largest emitter of
greenhouse gas emissions in the world, far surpassing all other
developed countries.\23\ Consequently, a push for overwhelming
U.S. vehicle consumers primarily with EVs, without first
building out our domestic critical minerals supply chains,
means we will be dependent upon China and its environmental
practices.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\See ``Global Emissions,'' Center for Climate and Energy
Solutions (C2ES), August 4, 2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Negative Environmental Impacts
The IEA has identified several negative environmental
impacts associated with critical minerals production around the
world, such as increased greenhouse gas emissions from mining
and processing, environmental degradation due to changes in
land use, pollution of the surrounding air and water resources,
and waste from excavation.\24\ Additionally, raw ores need to
be processed into usable minerals for renewable technologies.
In 2019, China was found to contribute 27 percent of all global
greenhouse gas emissions--more than all the other nations of
the earth, combined.\25\ Moreover, to help fuel these efforts,
China permitted two new coal power plants per week in 2022.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\See ``The Role of Critical Minerals in Clean Energy
Transitions: Sustainable and Responsible Development of Minerals,''
International Energy Agency, March 2022.
\25\See ``New report says China emits more greenhouse gases than
all other developed nations combined,'' The Hill, May 7, 2021.
\26\See ``China Permits Two New Coal Power Plants per Week in
2022,'' Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air and the Global
Energy Monitor, February 27, 2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, EVs do not necessarily provide environmental
benefits through reduced emissions. Over its lifetime, an EV
only has lower emissions than an internal combustion engine
vehicle if it travels between 28,069 and 68,160 miles and
remains in service for more than 10 years--circumstances which
are not being realized today.\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\See Written Testimony of Ashley Nunes, Director, Federal
Policy, Climate and Energy, The Breakthrough Institute, before the
Committee on Energy and Commerce, April 26, 2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
EVs also have significant impacts on land and land use.
According to Mark Mills of the Manhattan Institute, who
testified before the Committee, one EV battery requires the
extraction of 100,000 pounds of ore (60,000 pounds of cobalt
ore, 20,000 pounds of lithium brine, 12,000 pounds of copper
ore, 10,000 pounds of nickel ore, and 2,000 pounds of graphite
ore).\28\ The mining of 100,000 pounds of ore requires miners
to dig up 500,000 pounds of earth--and that is just for one
battery.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\See ``Electric Vehicles for Everyone? The Impossible Dream,''
Mark Mills, July 12, 2023.
\29\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Human Rights Abuses
Human rights abuses are also pervasive in some of the
world's largest critical minerals purveyors. For instance, 70
percent of global cobalt production, which is essential for EV
batteries, occurred in the Democratic Republic of the Congo--
home to more than half of worldwide cobalt reserves.\30\
Approximately 40,000 Congolese children conduct ``artisanal and
small-scale mining'' practices where these children search for
critical minerals by digging with their hands.\31\ Forced labor
(i.e., enslavement) and child labor concerns are not unique to
the Congo. Lithium-ion batteries from China are considered to
include inputs produced with child labor.\32\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\See ``Mineral Commodity Summaries 2022: Cobalt,'' United States
Geological Survey, 2022.
\31\See ``The DRC Mining Industry: Child Labor and Formalization of
Small-Scale Mining,'' Wilson Center, September 1, 2021.
\32\See ``List of Goods Produced by Child Labor or Forced Labor,''
Department of Labor, Bureau of International Labor Affairs, September
28, 2022.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
National Security Risks
Finally, national security risks cannot be ignored when
considering policies that provide major economic advantages to
global adversaries while simultaneously diminishing U.S.
influence internationally and voluntarily placing major
financial burdens on U.S. consumers. The IEA stressed that,
``critical minerals threaten a decades-long trend of cost
declines for clean energy technologies.''\33\ On EVs
specifically, the National Wildlife Federation emphasized that,
``the fluctuating price of critical minerals can greatly affect
battery price,'' which in turn impacts the overall price of an
EV.\34\ The price of lithium, a key input for EV batteries,
increased by 738 percent from January 2021 to March 2022.\35\
Prices for cobalt, nickel, aluminum, and copper all
significantly increased over the same time period and raised
the cost of wind turbines by 9 percent and solar PV modules by
16 percent.\36\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\33\See ``Critical Minerals Threaten a Decades-Long Trend of Cost
Declines for Clean Energy Technologies,'' International Energy Agency,
May 18, 2022.
\34\See ``Critical Minerals for Clean Energy Reference Guide,''
National Wildlife Federation, 2022.
\35\See ``Lithium prices hit record high as market pricing takes
hold,'' Benchmark, December 14, 2022.
\36\See ``The Role of Critical Minerals in Clean Energy
Transitions: Mineral Requirements for Clean Energy Transitions,''
International Energy Agency, March 2022.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Geopolitical events also influence commodity pricing for
critical minerals. On March 8, 2022, the London Metal Exchange
suspended nickel trading after the price of the commodity
doubled to over $100,000 per ton in response to Russia's
invasion of Ukraine and coordinated sanctions by various
countries.\37\ Russia accounted for 9.3 percent of nickel
production in 2021 and represented the third largest producing
country.\38\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\37\See ``LME Forced to Halt Nickel Trading, Cancel Deals, After
Prices Top $100,000,'' Reuters, March 8, 2022.
\38\See ``Distribution of Mine Production of Nickel Worldwide in
2021, by Country,'' Statista, March 3, 2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE U.S. VEHICLE LANDSCAPE AND U.S. CONSUMERS
As recently as 2021, data for light-duty vehicle
registrations in the United States demonstrates that Americans
chose a diversity of engine types and car classes to meet their
needs. Specifically, 93.8 percent of these registrations were
for cars powered by gasoline or ethanol/flex fuel, 0.33 percent
operated on diesel or biodiesel, almost 0.02 percent were
hybrid vehicles, and 0.008 percent were plug-in hybrid or
battery electric vehicles.\39\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\39\See, ``Vehicle Registration Counts by State,'' U.S. Department
of Energy Office of Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy, 2022.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
ELECTRIC VEHICLE COSTS
American consumers are directly impacted by the cost of
vehicles. According to Kelley Blue Book, the average price of
an EV is $65,291, which is $17,197 more than the average price
of an internal combustion engine vehicle.\40\ Insurance for an
EV is also $44 more expensive per month or $528 more expensive
per year than insurance for gas-powered cars.\41\ Pricing is
especially important, because access to a car is tied to
improved economic outcomes for low-income households.
Additionally, any Inflation Reduction Act funding intended to
subsidize the final purchase price and thus the growth of EV
sales among certain Americans ends in 2032 when EPA's rule--
mandating two-thirds of new motor vehicles sold be EVs--becomes
fully effective.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\40\See ``Electric Car FAQ: Your Questions Answered,'' Kelley Blue
Book, October 31, 2022.
\41\See "Electric car insurance 2023 guide", Policygenius, December
29, 2022.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The costs of fueling differing types of new vehicle engines
has also been part of the argument in favor of having the
government require EVs to flood the marketplace. Yet, a study
by the Anderson Economic Group (AEG) found that trucks cost
about the same to f
Committee Action
On June 22, 2023, the Subcommittee on Environment,
Manufacturing, and Critical Materials held a hearing on H.R.
4468. The title of the hearing was ``Driving Affordability:
Preserving People's Freedom to Buy Affordable Vehicles and
Fuel.'' The Subcommittee received testimony from:
Joseph Goffman, Principal Deputy
Administrator, Office of Air and Radiation, U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency;
Chet Thompson, President and CEO, American
Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers;
Neil Caskey, CEO, National Corn Growers
Association;
Scott Lambert, President, Minnesota Auto
Dealers Association; and,
Genevieve Cullen, President, Electric Drive
Transportation Association.
On July 12, 2023, the Subcommittee on Environment,
Manufacturing, and Critical Materials met in open markup
session and forwarded H.R. 4468, without amendment, to the full
Committee by a record vote of 12 yeas and 7 nays.
On July 27, 2023, the full Committee on Energy and Commerce
met in open markup session and ordered H.R. 4468, without
amendment, favorably reported to the House by a record vote of
27 yeas and 23 nays.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII requires the Committee to list the
record votes on the motion to report legislation and amendments
thereto. The following reflects the record votes taken during
the Committee consideration:
Oversight Findings and Recommendations
Pursuant to clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII, the Committee held hearings and made findings that
are reflected in this report.
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII, the Committee
finds that H.R. 4468 would result in no new or increased budget
authority, entitlement authority, or tax expenditures or
revenues.
Congressional Budget Office Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII, at the time this
report was filed, the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974 was not available.
Federal Mandates Statement
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of Federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general
performance goal or objective of this legislation is to
prohibit the Administrator of EPA from finalizing,
implementing, or enforcing a regulation with respect to
emissions from light-duty and medium-duty vehicles starting
with model year 2027; to prevent EPA from mandating the use of
a specific technology in new motor vehicles or issuing rules
that result in limited availability of vehicles to end-use
consumers based upon the engine in that vehicle; and to
preserve American automobile manufacturing and protect access
for American consumers to choose affordable, reliable, and
functional automobiles for their needs.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII, no provision of
H.R. 4468 is known to be duplicative of another Federal
program, including any program that was included in a report to
Congress pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139 or the
most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance.
Related Committee and Subcommittee Hearings
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII,
(1) the following related hearing was used to develop or
consider H.R. 4468:
On June 22, 2023, the Subcommittee on
Environment, Manufacturing, and Critical Materials held
a hearing on H.R. 4468. The title of the hearing is
``Driving Affordability: Preserving People's Freedom to
Buy Affordable Vehicles and Fuel.'' The Subcommittee
received testimony from:
Joseph Goffman, Principal Deputy
Administrator, Office of Air and Radiation,
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency;
Chet Thompson, President and
CEO, American Fuel and Petrochemical
Manufacturers;
Neil Caskey, CEO, National Corn
Growers Association;
Scott Lambert, President,
Minnesota Auto Dealers Association; and,
Genevieve Cullen, President,
Electric Drive Transportation Association.
(2) The following related hearing was held:
On April 26, 2023, the Subcommittee on
Environment, Manufacturing, and Critical Materials held
a hearing entitled, ``Exposing the Environmental, Human
Rights, and National Security Risks of the Biden
Administration's Rush to Green Policies.'' The
Subcommittee received testimony from:
Mark Mills, Senior Fellow,
Manhattan Institute;
Ashley Nunes, Director of
Federal Policy, Climate, and Energy,
Breakthrough Institute;
Daniel Simmons, Vice President
for Policy, Institute for Energy Research; and,
Trevor Higgins, Senior Vice
President, Energy and Environment, Center for
American Progress.
Committee Cost Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII, the Committee
adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974. At the time this report was
filed, the estimate was not available.
Earmark, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff Benefits
Pursuant to clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI, the
Committee finds that H.R. 4468 contains no earmarks, limited
tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation
Section 1. Short title
Section 1 provides the short title of the ``Choice in
Automobile Retail Sales Act of 2023.''
Section 2. Prohibition against finalizing, implementing, or enforcing a
proposed rule with respect to emissions from vehicles
Section 2 prohibits the EPA from finalizing, implementing,
or enforcing its proposed rule titled ``Multi-Pollutant
Emissions Standards for Model Years 2027 and Later Light-Duty
and Medium-Duty Vehicles'' that was published in the Federal
Register on May 5, 2023.
Section 3. Ensuring tailpipe regulations do not limit the availability
of new motor vehicles.
Section 3(a) amends CAA section 202(a)(2) to prevent any
regulations issued under Clean Air Act section 202(a)(1),
including those promulgated prior to the date of enactment of
H.R. 4468, from mandating the use of any specific technology.
While the term ``mandate'' is not defined by H.R. 4468, the
Committee adopts the bill sponsor's view that mandate means to
make something necessary or officially require someone to do
something. During the full committee markup, the bill's sponsor
stated he believed this prohibition included ``drafting a
standard in such a way that [it] knows only one technology can
meet it.'' Based upon this intent, a rule like EPA's ``Multi-
Pollutant Emissions Standards for Model Years 2027 and Later
Light-Duty and Medium-Duty Vehicles'' is a mandate to sell
electric vehicles. In addition, the Committee acknowledges that
the term ``technology'' is both singular and plural and the use
of the term ``specific'' narrows the broadness of the type of
technology subject to the ban or prohibition.
Section 3(a) also prevents EPA from issuing regulations
under CAA section 202(a)(1) that result in the limited
availability of new motor vehicles based on that vehicle's
engine type. The Committee intends that ``limited
availability'' is specific to the ultimate consumer of the
vehicle whose choice in vehicle is most impacted by this
limited availability. The Committee does not believe that
regulations resulting in the availability of unaffordable or
unreliable vehicles or vehicles lacking functionality for the
ultimate consumer's needs satisfactorily meets the requirement
to avoid creating an environment with limited availability.
The Committee believes that the two prohibitions in section
3(a) will reinforce American automobile consumers' ability to
have access to affordable, reliable, and functional vehicles
that meet their needs. The Committee does not believe these
requirements on EPA authority prevent EPA from controlling air
pollution from vehicles that endangers public health or
welfare, but rather cabins any impulse by government to control
the commercial marketplace for ideological reasons. The free-
enterprise system in the United States has not only been a
tremendous engine for domestic innovation and American
leadership in new products, but it is also predicated on
consumers' needs being willingly met; the Committee does not
wish those benefits to be curtailed.
Section 3(b) gives EPA two years to update any regulations
issued, before the date of enactment of H.R. 4468, under CAA
section 202(a)(1), to remove mandates on the use of a specific
technology or correct rules that result in the limited
availability of new vehicles based upon that vehicle's engine.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
CLEAN AIR ACT
* * * * * * *
TITLE II--EMISSION STANDARDS FOR MOVING SOURCES
* * * * * * *
Part A--Motor Vehicle Emission and Fuel Standards
establishment of standards
Sec. 202. (a) Except as otherwise provided in subsection
(b)--
(1) The Administrator shall by regulation prescribe
(and from time to time revise) in accordance with the
provisions of this section, standards applicable to the
emission of any air pollutant from any class or classes
of new motor vehicles or new motor vehicle engines,
which in his judgment cause, or contribute to, air
pollution which may reasonably be anticipated to
endanger public health or welfare. Such standards shall
be applicable to such vehicles and engines for their
useful life (as determined under subsection (d),
relating to useful life of vehicles for purposes of
certification), whether such vehicles and engines are
designed as complete systems or incorporate devices to
prevent or control such pollution.
[(2) Any regulation] (2) (A) Any regulation
prescribed under paragraph (1) of this subsection (and
any revision thereof) shall take effect after such
period as the Administrator finds necessary to permit
the development and application of the requisite
technology, giving appropriate consideration to the
cost of compliance within such period.
(B) Effective beginning on the date of enactment of
this subparagraph, any regulation prescribed under
paragraph (1) (and any revision thereof), including any
such regulation or revision prescribed before the date
of enactment of this subparagraph, shall not--
(i) mandate the use of any specific
technology; or
(ii) result in limited availability of new
motor vehicles based on the type of new motor
vehicle engine in such new motor vehicles.
(3)(A) In General--(i) Unless the standard is changed
as provided in subparagraph (B), regulations under
paragraph (1) of this subsection applicable to
emissions of hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide, oxides of
nitrogen, and particulate matter from classes or
categories of heavy-duty vehicles or engines
manufactured during or after model year 1983 shall
contain standards which reflect the greatest degree of
emission reduction achievable through the application
of technology which the Administrator determines will
be available for the model year to which such standards
apply, giving appropriate consideration to cost,
energy, and safety factors associated with the
application of such technology.
(ii) In establishing classes or categories of
vehicles or engines for purposes of regulations under
this paragraph, the Administrator may base such classes
or categories on gross vehicle weight, horsepower, type
of fuel used or other appropriate factors.
(B) Revised Standards for Heavy Duty Trucks.--(i) On
the basis of information available to the Administrator
concerning the effects of air pollutants emitted from
heavy-duty vehicles or engines and from other sources
of mobile source related pollutants on the public
health and welfare, and taking costs into account, the
Administrator may promulgate regulations under
paragraph (1) of this subsection revising any standard
promulgated under, or before the date of, the enactment
of the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990 (or previously
revised under this subparagraph) and applicable to
classes or categories of heavy-duty vehicles or
engines.
(ii) Effective for the model year 1998 and
thereafter, the regulations under paragraph (1) of this
subsection applicable to emissions of oxides of
nitrogen (NOx) from gasoline and diesel-fueled heavy
duty trucks shall contain standards which provide that
such emissions may not exceed 4.0 grams per brake
horsepower hour (gbh).
(C) Lead Time And Stability.--Any standard
promulgated or revised under this paragraph and
applicable to classes or categories of heavy-duty
vehicles or engines shall apply for a period of no less
than 3 model years beginning no earlier than the model
year commencing 4 years after such revised standard is
promulgated.
(D) Rebulding Practices.--The Administrator shall
study the practice of rebuilding heavy-duty engines and
the impact rebuilding has on engine emissions. On the
basis of that study and other information available to
the Administrator, the Administrator may prescribe
requirements to control rebuilding practices, including
standards applicable to emissions from any rebuilt
heavy-duty engines (whether or not the engine is past
its statutory useful life), which in the
Administrator's judgment cause, or contribute to, air
pollution which may reasonably be anticipated to
endanger public health or welfare taking costs into
account. Any regulation shall take effect after a
period the Administrator finds necessary to permit the
development and application of the requisite control
measures, giving appropriate consideration to the cost
of compliance within the period and energy and safety
factors.
(E) Motorcycles.--For purposes of this paragraph,
motorcycles and motorcycle engines shall be treated in
the same manner as heavy-duty vehicles and engines
(except as otherwise permitted under section 206(f)(1))
unless the the Administrator promulgates a rule
reclassifying motorcycles as light-duty vehicles within
the meaning of this section or unless the Administrator
promulgates regulations under subsection (a) applying
standards applicable to the emission of air pollutants
from motorcycles as a separate class or category. In
any case in which such standards are promulgated for
such emissions from motorcycles as a separate class or
category, the Administrator, in promulgating such
standards, shall consider the need to achieve
equivalency of emission reductions between motorcycles
and other motor vehicles to the maximum extent
practicable.
(4)(A) Effective with respect to vehicles and engines
manufactured after model year 1978, no emission control
device, system, or element of design shall be used in a
new motor vehicle or new motor vehicle engine for
purposes of complying with requirements prescribed
under this title if such device, system, or element of
design will cause or contribute to an unreasonable risk
to public health, welfare, or safety in its operation
or function.
(B) In determining whether an unreasonable risk
exists under subparagraph (A), the Administrator shall
consider, among other factors, (i) whether and to what
extent the use of any device, system, or element of
design causes, increases, reduces, or eliminates
emissions of any unregulated pollutants; (ii) available
methods for reducing or eliminating any risk to public
health, welfare, or safety which may be associated with
the use of such device, system, or element of design,
and (iii) the availability of other devices, systems,
or elements of design which may be used to conform to
requirements prescribed under this title without
causing or contributing to such unreasonable risk. The
Administrator shall include in the consideration
required by this paragraph all relevant information
developed pursuant to section 214.
(5)(A) If the Administrator promulgates final
regulations which define the degree of control required
and the test procedures by which compliance could be
determined for gasoline vapor recovery of uncontrolled
emissions from the fueling of motor vehicles, the
Administrator shall, after consultation with the
Secretary of Transportation with respect to motor
vehicle safety, prescribe, by regulation, fill pipe
standards for new motor vehicles in order to insure
effective connection between such fill pipe and any
vapor recovery system which the Administrator
determines may be required to comply with such vapor
recovery regulations. In promulgating such standards
the Administrator shall take into consideration limits
on fill pipe diameter, minimum design criteria for
nozzle retainer lips, limits on the location of the
unleaded fuel restrictors, a minimum access zone
surrounding a fill pipe, a minimum pipe or nozzle
insertion angle, and such other factors as he deems
pertinent.
(B) Regulations prescribing standards under
subparagraph (A) shall not become effective until the
introduction of the model year for which it would be
feasible to implement such standards, taking into
consideration the restraints of an adequate leadtime
for design and production.
(C) Nothing in subparagraph (A) shall (i) prevent the
Administrator from specifying different nozzle and fill
neck sizes for gasoline with additives and gasoline
without additives or (ii) permit the Administrator to
require a specific location, configuration, modeling,
or styling of the motor vehicle body with respect to
the fuel tank fill neck or fill nozzle clearance
envelope.
(D) For the purpose of this paragraph, the term
``fill pipe'' shall include the fuel tank fill pipe,
fill neck, fill inlet, and closure.
(6) Onboard vapor recovery.--Within 1 year after the
date of the enactment of the Clean Air Act Amendments
of 1990, the Administrator shall, after consultation
with the Secretary of Transportation regarding the
safety of vehicle-based (``onboard'') systems for the
control of vehicle refueling emissions, promulgate
standards under this section requiring that new light-
duty vehicles manufactured beginning in the fourth
model year after the model year in which the standards
are promulgated and thereafter shall be equipped with
such systems. The standards required under this
paragraph shall ap
Minority Views
We oppose H.R. 4468, legislation to prohibit the
Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) from
finalizing the proposed rule on Multi-Pollutant Emissions
Standards beginning in Model Year 2027.\1\ This bill puts in
place far-reaching and ill-defined requirements for any future
vehicle emissions standard, effectively blocking EPA from ever
regulating tailpipe emissions from the transportation sector.
H.R. 4468 is a direct attack on the current and expected future
success of our domestic vehicle manufacturing industry.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Environmental Protection Agency, Multi-Pollutant Emissions
Standards for Model Years 2027 and Later Light-Duty and Medium-Duty
Vehicles, 88 Fed. Reg. 29184 (May 5, 2023) (proposed rule).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Background
The Clean Air Act (CAA) is both explicit and clear in
giving EPA the authority and obligation to protect Americans
from dangerous pollution, including from the transportation
sector. Under Section 202 of the CAA, Congress directed EPA to
set vehicle emission standards for new motor vehicles. These
standards were intended to drive technological innovation,
which they have historically done. The transportation sector is
currently the largest contributor of greenhouse gas (GHG)
emissions at 28 percent of total pollution in the United States
(US).\2\ The vast majority of this pollution comes from burning
fossil fuels for cars, trucks, ships, trains, and planes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Environmental Protection Agency, Sources of Greenhouse Gas
Emissions (Aug. 25, 2023) (www.epa.gov/ghge missions/sources-
greenhouse-gas-emissions#:%7E:text=Transportation %20(28%25%
20of%202021%20 greenhouse,ships%2C%20 trains%2C%20 and%20planes.).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Currently, almost 120 million people across the US live in
places with unhealthy levels of ozone or particle pollution,
which is more than one-third of Americans, with children, the
elderly, low-income communities, and communities of color being
disproportionately impacted.\3\ Health risks associated with
exposure to air pollution from roadway traffic include higher
rates of asthma onset and aggravation, cardiovascular disease,
impaired lung development in children, pre-term and low-
birthweight infants, and childhood leukemia.\4\ These health
impacts have grave consequences, as air pollution is associated
with over 100,000 premature deaths in the US every year, making
EPA's ability to adequately control pollution from the
transportation even more imperative.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\American Lung Association, 1 in 3 People Breathe Unhealthy Air:
New Report Finds (May 2, 2023) (www.lung.org/blog/sota-report-
unhealthy-air#::text=The%20 report%20finds %20that%2017.6,of
%20ozone%20or %20particle%20pollution.).
\4\Environmental Protection Agency, Learn About How Mobile Source
Pollution Affects Your Health (May 18, 2023) (www.epa.gov/mobile-
source-pollution/learn-about-how-mobile-source-pollution-affects-your-
health).
\5\Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Fine-Scale
Damage Estimates of Particulate Matter Air Pollution Reveal
Opportunities for Location-Specific Mitigation of Emissions (Apr. 8,
2019).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To that end, EPA recently proposed ambitious new standards
for light-, medium-, and heavy-duty vehicles that will advance
the transition to a clean transportation future.\6\ These
standards are achievable, will save consumers money, bolster
our economy by promoting American manufacturing, and reduce our
dependence on foreign oil. During a Subcommittee on
Environment, Manufacturing, and Critical Materials legislative
hearing on H.R. 4468, EPA testified that the proposed standards
would avoid 7.3 billion tons of carbon dioxide emissions
through 2055.\7\ Additionally, between 2027 and 2055, the
proposed standards' net benefits are projected to reach up to
$1.6 trillion and would save the average consumer $12,000 over
the lifetime of the vehicle.\8\ The proposed standards are also
expected to deliver significant health benefits, including
fewer cases of premature death, heart attacks, aggravated
asthma, cancer, and heart disease.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Environmental Protection Agency, Biden-Harris Administration
Proposes Strongest-Ever Pollution Standards for Cars and Trucks to
Accelerate Transition to a Clean-Transportation Future (Apr. 12, 2023)
(press release).
\7\House Committee on Energy and Commerce, Hearing on Driving
Affordability: Preserving People's Freedom to Buy Affordable Vehicles
and Fuel, 118th Cong. (June 22, 2023).
\8\See note 6.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Majority's argument that the standards are a mandate to
sell electric vehicles (EVs) is wholly false. As with all
previous vehicle rules, EPA's proposed standards are
performance based, allowing companies to choose the mix of
clean technologies best suited for their fleets. The proposal
recognizes significant changes in the US vehicle market, like
auto manufactures independently moving production toward EVs
because of their increasing popularity with consumers. For
instance, Honda has a goal of 100 percent zero emission
electrified vehicle sales in North America by 2040 and Rivian
is investing $5 billion, in addition to $1.5 billion in public
funding, to build an EV factory in Georgia.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Honda, Honda Targets 100% EV Sales in North America by 2040,
Makes New Commitments to Advances in Environmental and Safety
Technology (Apr. 23, 2021) (press release); Rivian Announces a New $5
Billion Electric Vehicle Factory in Georgia, Electrek (Dec. 16. 2021)
(electrek.co/2021/12/16/rivian-5-billion-electric-vehicle-factory-
georgia/).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During consideration of H.R. 4468, the Majority presented
several unfounded or misleading anti-EV claims that we seek to
correct.
First, EPA's proposed vehicle standards are not part of a
scheme for China to control America's automotive future--the
reality is quite the opposite. China currently controls a
significant portion of the EV market share and of the global EV
supply chain, which is precisely why the US must continue to
leverage the power of the federal government--like the
authority the CAA affords the EPA--to drive innovation, secure
supply chains, and expand the domestic vehicle manufacturing
industry. This strategy is already working. The Bipartisan
Infrastructure Law invested $7 billion in EV battery
components, including critical minerals, which are already
creating new, middle-class jobs in American battery
manufacturing in the US and reducing our dependence on foreign
supply chains.\10\ By trying to legislate away years of
innovation in cleaner transportation technologies, the Majority
would effectively cede global leadership in the clean
transportation sector to China.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\The White House, Fact Sheet: Biden-Harris Administration
Announces New Standards and Major Progress for a Made-in-America
National Network of Electric Vehicle Chargers (Feb. 15, 2023)
(www.whitehouse.gov/ briefing-room/ statements-releases/ 2023/02/15/
fact-sheet-biden- harris-administration- announces-new-standards- and-
major-progress- for-a-made-in- america-national-network- of-electric-
vehicle- chargers/#:%7E:text= President%20Biden's %20Bipartisan%20
Infrastructure %20Law,%2C%20 critical%20minerals
%2C%20and%20materials.).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The claims that EVs can't travel as far as gasoline-powered
vehicles fail to paint the whole picture. Most EVs available
for sale or lease today can go 200 miles or more on a single
charge. According to Kelley Blue Book, the average driver in
the US drives an average of 37 miles per day.\11\ Thus, the EV
driving range is over five times the amount the average driver
in the US drives every day. The Majority also cites concern
over the cost of EVs and fueling. According to a Clean Energy
Group report, EVs deliver significant cost savings to American
families by decreasing fueling costs by 50 percent or more and
are overall 25 percent less expensive than regular cars.\12\ EV
prices have declined more than $5,600 over the last year and
electric passenger cars and light-duty trucks are expected to
reach cost parity with gasoline-powered vehicles in the next
two years, all due to incentives in the Inflation Reduction
Act.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Kelley Blue Book, Average Miles Driven Per Year: Why it is
Important (May 15, 2023) (www.kbb.com/car-advice/average-miles-driven-
per-year/).
\12\Clean Energy Group, Electric Vehicles and Equity: How EVs Work,
Their Pros and Cons, and the Role They Can Play in Making Our
Communities Stronger (June 2023).
\13\Alliance for Automotive Innovation, Get Connected: Electric
Vehicle Quarterly Report (2023); Rocky Mountain Institute, How Policy
Actions Can Spur EV Adoption in the United States (2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, assertions that EVs are worse for the environment
than gasoline-powered vehicles are blatantly false. DOE's
Argonne National Laboratory found that total greenhouse gas
emissions for EVs are significantly lower than gas-powered
models, even when accounting for emissions from vehicle
manufacturing and end-of-life management.\14\ With improvements
across the EV manufacturing supply chain, from battery
manufacturing to recycling, the difference in lifecycle
emissions will continue to increase as EVs get cleaner.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Argonne National Laboratory, Assessment of Light-Duty Plug-in
Electric Vehicles in the United States, 2010-2021 (Nov. 2022) (ANL-22/
71).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY OF H.R. 4468
Section 2 of H.R. 4468 prohibits the EPA Administrator from
finalizing, implementing, or enforcing the proposed rule titled
``Multi Pollutant Emissions Standards for Model Years 2027 and
Later Light-Duty and Medium-Duty Vehicles.'' As outlined above,
there are significant environmental, public health, and
economic benefits associated with the proposed rule. If
enacted, H.R. 4468 would deny these benefits for the American
people.
Section 3 of H.R. 4468 amends the CAA to block EPA from
ever finalizing vehicle emissions standards that mandate the
use of a specific technology or might ``result in the limited
availability of new motor vehicles'' based on the engine type.
The section also directs EPA to revise all past regulations to
conform with the act. The bill fails to define ``limited
availability'', creating a difficult--if not impossible--
threshold for any vehicle emissions standard. This would stifle
innovation from vehicle manufacturers, and subsequently limit
what types of cars are available for consumers to purchase. The
vague language would not only harm the EV market, but other
vehicle types as well, including hybrid, flex fuel, hydrogen
fuel cell, and even internal combustion engines. The Majority
claims the intent of the bill is to ``protect access for
American consumers to choose affordable, reliable, and
functional automobiles,'' yet they are actively limiting
consumer choices with H.R. 4468. Furthermore, by preventing EPA
from ever finalizing standards to cut GHG pollution from
vehicles, the Majority is ignoring EPA's obligation to protect
the public from dangerous air pollution.
CONCLUSION
H.R 4468 hampers EPA's ability to address air pollution
from vehicles, would limit consumer choice, hurt American
global leadership, weaken our ability to compete with China,
and deny Americans the immense public health and environmental
benefits of the EPA proposed standards.
For the reasons stated above, we dissent from the views
contained in the Committee Report.
Frank Pallone, Jr.,
Ranking Member, Committee on Energy and Commerce.
[all]