Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4469]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Energy and Commerce, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 4469) to clarify that eRINs are not authorized
for purposes of satisfying the volume of renewable fuel that
needs to be contained in transportation fuel for purposes of
the Renewable Fuel Program, and for other purposes, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon without
amendment and recommends that the bill do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 2
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 2
Committee Action................................................. 4
Committee Votes.................................................. 4
Oversight Findings and Recommendations........................... 6
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures 6
Congressional Budget Office Estimate............................. 6
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 6
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives............ 6
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 6
Related Committee and Subcommittee Hearings...................... 6
Committee Cost Estimate.......................................... 7
Earmark, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff Benefits....... 7
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 7
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 7
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 7
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 8
Minority Views................................................... 9
Purpose and Summary
The purpose of H.R. 4469 is to clarify that eRINs are not
authorized for the purposes of satisfying the volume of
renewable fuel that needs to be contained in transportation
fuel for the purposes of the Renewable Fuel Standard program.
Background and Need for Legislation
Congress created Clean Air Act (CAA) section 211(o)--also
referred to as the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS)--to reduce
America's reliance on foreign sources (particularly sources
located in politically unstable regions) to meet the United
States' oil needs; build domestic energy and economic security;
and provide value-added opportunities for communities that
produce biofuel feedstocks.\1\ Enacted in 2005 and expanded in
2007, the RFS requires the Administrator of the Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) to set renewable fuel volume
obligations (RVOs) for refiners, blenders, or importers of
transportation fuel sold or introduced into commerce in the
United States. Under the statute, the RFS originally provided
for nine billion gallons of total renewable fuel in 2008; but
increased that amount to 36 billion gallons by 2022--all from
liquid fuels.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\109 Cong. Rec. S9255 (2005) (Statement of Sen. Pete Domenici).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Compliance with the RFS, pursuant to CAA section
211(o)(5)(B), is measured using credits--called Renewable
Identification Numbers (RINs). CAA section 211(o)(5)(A)
authorizes credits for persons that refine, blend, or import
gasoline that is compliant with RFS requirements, for
generating credits for biodiesel, and for generating credits by
small refineries waiving their temporary exemption from the
renewable fuel volume requirement. In practice, when qualifying
biofuels are produced, each gallon is assigned a RIN--a number
with digits corresponding to identifying data, including the
year the RIN was generated, the producer of the fuel, and the
type of fuel. Until the biofuels are sold as fuel or blended
into conventional fuels, the RINs are ``attached'' to the fuel.
Once the biofuel has been blended or sold, the RINs are
detached, and can then be bought and sold like other
commodities.
Under the RFS, starting in 2023, EPA is authorized to
``set'' the fuel standards among the differing statutory
categories of renewable fuel for those RVO levels.
On December 1, 2022, EPA announced a proposed rule to
establish required RVO percentage standards for biofuels for
2023, 2024, and 2025 under the RFS.\2\ Published in the Federal
Register on December 30, 2022, the proposed rule also included
regulatory changes to create a new program to outline how RINs
from renewable electricity (eRINs) would be implemented and
managed under the RFS program. This update to the RFS program
would allow parties to register with EPA and generate eRINs
produced from qualifying renewable biomass used as
transportation fuel. On June 21, 2023, EPA announced a final
rule to establish biofuel volume requirements and associated
percentage standards for cellulosic biofuel, biomass-based
diesel (BBD), advanced biofuel, and total renewable fuel for
2023-2025.\3\ The final rule did not, however, contain an eRINs
program.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\See ``Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) Program: Standards for 2023-
2025 and Other Changes,'' Proposed Rule, December 30, 2022.
\3\See ``Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) Program: Standards for 2023-
2025 and Other Changes,'' Final Rule, July 12, 2023.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The establishment and generation of eRIN credits was a
controversial feature of EPA's proposed ``set'' regulation.
When the RFS was first created in the Energy Policy Act of
2005, the word ``electricity'' was absent from that section.
Two years later in the Energy Independence and Security Act of
2007 (EISA) the notion of generating electricity from renewable
fuel to serve as a transportation fuel for America's vehicles
was also not added to the CAA, including the RFS.
EISA section 206, which included five sections that
dramatically expand the RFS within CAA section 211(o), only
authorized EPA (outside of the CAA) to ``conduct a study on the
feasibility of issuing credits to electric vehicles powered by
electricity produced from renewable energy sources'' and
``issue a report that describes the results of that study,
including a description of existing programs and studies on the
use of renewable electricity'' to power electric vehicles. In
addition, the report was required to describe ``alternatives
for designing a pilot program to determine the feasibility''
and practicality of a program awarding RFS credits for
``renewable electricity to power electric vehicles as an
adjunct to the renewable fuels mandate.'' To this date, the EPA
has not completed or complied with the statutory report
requirements. In addition, EISA required a report on options
for a pilot program but stopped short of authorizing one. Since
then, Congress has not amended CAA section 211(o) to introduce
electricity into the RFS.
H.R. 4469 is necessary for four reasons.
First, despite the lack of clear statutory authorization,
EPA and others believe EPA has the authority to create this
program. For instance, eRINs advocates point to report language
from one or another congressional committee focusing on the
creation of a fuel pathway as justification for eRINs authority
even though creating a pathway, report language, or a joint
explanatory statement is not binding in the same manner as
statutory language.
Second, while the final ``Set'' rule did not formalize the
creation of an eRINS program, the rule and subsequent testimony
by EPA on June 22, 2023, left open the possibility that EPA
would return to creating an eRINs program in the future without
going through another notice and public comment process.
Third, the proposed design of the eRINs program would
insert significant uncertainty into the transportation fuels
market. Under EPA's proposal, original equipment manufacturers
(OEMs) of electric vehicles would generate RINs for light-duty
vehicles and then be responsible for ``establishing contracts
with parties that produce electricity from qualifying biogas.''
In addition to serving as a direct subsidy for electric
vehicles, such a delegation of RIN generation authority would
directly contradict the Clean Air Act, which specifically
grants RIN generation authority to ``any person that refines,
blends, or imports gasoline that contains a quantity of
renewable fuel greater than the quantity required.'' Therefore,
the proposed structure from EPA would undermine the existing
RIN market.
Last, the eRINs program was designed in a way that would
destabilize the use of liquid fuels and the vehicles that use
them in the United States as well as threaten the availability
of reliable and affordable transportation fuel options for cars
driven by the majority of Americans. Congress never delegated
authority this sweeping to EPA, and this legislation makes that
clear.
Committee Action
On June 22, 2023, the Subcommittee on Environment,
Manufacturing, and Critical Materials held a hearing on a
discussion draft titled ``No Fuel Credits for Batteries Act of
2023,'' which was subsequently introduced as H.R. 4469. The
title of the hearing was ``Driving Affordability: Preserving
People's Freedom to Buy Affordable Vehicles and Fuel.'' The
Subcommittee received testimony from:
Joseph Goffman, Principal Deputy
Administrator, Office of Air and Radiation, U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency;
Chet Thompson, President and CEO, American
Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers;
Neil Caskey, CEO, National Corn Growers
Association;
Scott Lambert, President, Minnesota Auto
Dealers Association; and
Genevieve Cullen, President, Electric Drive
Transportation Association.
On July 12, 2023, the Subcommittee on Environment,
Manufacturing, and Critical Materials met in open markup
session and forwarded H.R. 4469, without amendment, to the full
Committee by a record vote of 12 yeas and 7 nays.
On July 27, 2023, the full Committee on Energy and Commerce
met in open markup session and ordered H.R. 4469, without
amendment, favorably reported to the House by a record vote of
26 yeas and 22 nays.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII requires the Committee to list the
record votes on the motion to report legislation and amendments
thereto. The following reflects the record votes taken during
the Committee consideration:
OVERSIGHT FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Pursuant to clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII, the Committee held a hearing and made findings that
are reflected in this report.
NEW BUDGET AUTHORITY, ENTITLEMENT AUTHORITY,
AND TAX EXPENDITURES
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII, the Committee
finds that H.R. 4469 would result in no new or increased budget
authority, entitlement authority, or tax expenditures or
revenues.
Congressional Budget Office Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII, at the time this
report was filed, the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974 was not available.
FEDERAL MANDATES STATEMENT
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of Federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
STATEMENT OF GENERAL PERFORMANCE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general
performance goal or objective of this legislation is to clarify
that eRINs are not authorized for the purposes of satisfying
the volume of renewable fuel that needs to be contained in
transportation fuel for the purposes of the Renewable Fuel
Standard program.
DUPLICATION OF FEDERAL PROGRAMS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII, no provision of
H.R. 4469 is known to be duplicative of another Federal
program, including any program that was included in a report to
Congress pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139 or the
most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance.
RELATED COMMITTEE AND SUBCOMMITTEE HEARINGS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
related hearing was used to develop or consider H.R. 4469:
On June 22, 2023, the Subcommittee on
Environment, Manufacturing, and Critical Materials held
a hearing titled ``Driving Affordability: Preserving
People's Freedom to Buy Affordable Vehicles and Fuel.''
The Subcommittee received testimony from:
Joseph Goffman, Principal Deputy
Administrator, Office of Air and Radiation,
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency;
Chet Thompson, President and
CEO, American Fuel and Petrochemical
Manufacturers;
Neil Caskey, CEO, National Corn
Growers Association;
Scott Lambert, President,
Minnesota Auto Dealers Association; and,
Genevieve Cullen, President,
Electric Drive Transportation Association.
COMMITTEE COST ESTIMATE
Pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII, the Committee
adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974. At the time this report was
filed, the estimate was not available.
EARMARK, LIMITED TAX BENEFITS, AND LIMITED TARIFF BENEFITS
Pursuant to clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI, the
Committee finds that H.R. 4469 contains no earmarks, limited
tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits.
ADVISORY COMMITTEE STATEMENT
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
APPLICABILITY TO LEGISLATIVE BRANCH
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
SECTION-BY-SECTION ANALYSIS OF THE LEGISLATION
Section 1. Short title
Section 1 of H.R. 4469 contains the short title of the ``No
Fuel Credits for Batteries Act of 2023.''
Section 2. Clarification the ERINS not authorized
Section 2 of H.R. 4469 contains two parts: (1) the
clarification that there is no authority under the CAA to
authorize the generation of credits or RINs for electricity as
a transportation fuel; and (2) the definitions used in the
legislation.
Section 2(a)(1) prohibits the Administrator of the EPA from
authorizing the generation of credits for electricity generated
from renewable fuel for the purposes of satisfying the volume
of renewable fuel that needs to be contained in transportation
fuel for the purposes of the RFS program--CAA section
211(o)(2). While the Committee understands that eRINs have
never been generated for transportation fuel and acts of
Congress generally add to or subtract from something in the
law, the Committee believes the declaratory statement in
section 2(a)(1)--which is intentionally drafted outside of the
RFS to avoid the appearance that legal authority is being
removed--is essential both to remind EPA as well as put it on
notice as to its actual statutory authority.
Given that EPA has expressed a willingness to revisit
regulations creating eRINs, and RIN credits are able to satisfy
obligations for the current compliance year or the following
compliance year, section 2(a)(2) prohibits the use or transfer
of any eRINs credits generated before the date of enactment.
The Committee intends this provision to address any gap between
a future EPA eRINs proposal and the date of enactment of H.R.
4469.
Section 2(b) defines ``renewable fuel'' and
``transportation fuel'' using their RFS meanings contained in
CAA section 211(o)(1).
H.R. 4469 reiterates Congress' intent to authorize the
generation of RINs under CAA section 211(o) for transportation
fuel containing liquid fuels only, and not to authorize the
generation of RINs for electricity from renewable resources.
CHANGES IN EXISTING LAW MADE BY THE BILL, AS REPORTED
This legislation does not amend any existing Federal
statute.
Minority Views
We oppose H.R. 4469, legislation that would prevent the
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) from allowing the
generation of credits for renewable electricity for
transportation fuel (eRINs) under the Renewable Fuel Standard
(RFS). H.R. 4469 turns a blind eye to years of regulatory and
Congressional direction to EPA in support of generating eRINs
and hamstrings opportunities for using renewable electricity in
the transportation sector.
Background
Congress established the RFS to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG)
pollution and expand the nation's supply of renewable fuels
while also reducing reliance on imported oil. The RFS has
spurred significant market growth for renewable fuels,
providing strong economic opportunity across the biofuels
sector.
While the Majority's report details the history of the RFS,
it fails to acknowledge the decade-plus history of EPA
regulatory action regarding renewable electricity and the RFS.
There has been over a decade of regulatory action regarding an
eRIN program at EPA. Starting in 2010, EPA finalized a rule to
allow renewable electricity to count as a renewable fuel under
the RFS, as long as it was made from renewable biomass, and it
was used as a transportation fuel.\1\ In 2014, EPA approved a
pathway for eRIN generation from biogas. While the pathways
were approved, EPA had yet to put in place a mechanism for eRIN
generation.\2\ In 2016, EPA proposed the ``Renewable
Enhancement and Growth Support Rule,'' which requested comment
from stakeholders on how EPA should structure its eRIN
generating mechanism.\3\ At the end of 2022, EPA put out a
proposed rule with a detailed compliance mechanism structure
for eRINs.\4\ During a Subcommittee on Environment,
Manufacturing, and Critical Materials legislative hearing, EPA
testified that the eRIN proposal received such extensive
feedback that the Agency chose to further engage with
stakeholders before finalizing.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Environmental Protection Agency, Regulation of Fuels and Fuel
Additives: Changes to Renewable Fuel Standard, 75 Fed. Reg. 14669 (Mar.
26, 2010) (final rule).
\2\Environmental Protection Agency, Regulation of Fuels and Fuel
Additives: RFS Pathways II, and Technical Amendments to the RFS
Standards and E15 Mis-fueling Mitigation Requirements, 79 Fed. Reg.
42127 (July 18, 2014) (final rule).
\3\Environmental Protection Agency, Renewables Enhancement and
Growth Support Rule, 81 Fed. Reg. 80828 (Nov. 16, 2016) (proposed
rule).
\4\Environmental Protection Agency, Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS)
Program: Standards for 2023-2025 and Other Changes, 87 Fed. Reg. 80754
(Dec. 30, 2022) (proposed rule).
\5\House Committee on Energy and Commerce, Testimony of Joseph
Goffman, Principal Deputy Assistant Administrator, Office of Air and
Radiation, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Hearing on Driving
Affordability: Preserving People's Freedom to Buy Affordable Vehicles
and Fuel, 118th Cong. (June 22, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, the Majority asserts that the definition of
transportation fuel under the Clean Air Act (CAA) Section
211(o)(1) is for transportation fuel containing only liquid
fuels. However, nowhere in the CAA does it specify that a
transportation fuel must be a liquid fuel, which EPA confirmed
at the Subcommittee on Environment, Manufacturing, and Critical
Materials hearing.\6\ Therefore, renewable electricity captured
from biogas to power an electric vehicle would constitute a
transportation fuel under the CAA. The Majority claims to be
for an ``all of the above'' energy approach, yet H.R. 4469
picks winners and losers in the renewable fuels market, and is
a deliberate attack on renewable electricity, simply because
the Majority is opposed to EVs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\House Committee on Energy and Commerce, Hearing on Driving
Affordability: Preserving People's Freedom to Buy Affordable Vehicles
and Fuel, 118th Cong. (June 22, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
At the Subcommittee legislative hearing, and during
Committee consideration of H.R. 4469, Subcommittee Ranking
Member Tonko explained the hypocrisy in the Majority's
opposition to eRINs. Currently, the RFS rewards biogas that is
turned into renewable natural gas to fuel a natural gas-powered
vehicle. There is no reason why the RFS program should not
offer the same support for biogas to power an electric vehicle
(EV). Provided that a fuel source meets the definition of an
eligible feedstock, the source should be able to benefit from
the RFS, regardless of the type of vehicle they power. H.R.
4469 cuts off an entire class of stakeholders, including
farmers, municipalities, and landfill operators, from the same
economic and market opportunities granted to liquid renewable
fuel producers. Electricity is an increasingly expanding
portion of our renewable fuel supply and eRINs are an important
component of supporting vehicle electrification and reducing
harmful GHG emissions. eRINs help accomplish the end goal of
the RFS program of reducing GHG emissions and increasing
national security with home-grown fuels.
EPA has the authority to allow fuels produced from eligible
feedstocks to generate renewable electricity to participate in
the RFS. In addition to over a decade of regulatory action
outlined above, Congress has explicitly directed EPA to
continue working on eRINs, appropriating funds for EPA to
process applications for the electric pathway under the RFS in
2020, which H.R. 4469 blatantly ignores.
SUMMARY OF H.R. 4468
Section 2 of H.R. 4469 blocks EPA from allowing the
generation of credits for renewable electricity for
transportation fuel under the RFS, despite two pathways already
being approved. H.R. 4469 limits the availability of fuel
captured from biogas from landfills, municipal wastewater
treatment facility digesters, agricultural digesters, and
separated municipal solid waste digesters.
CONCLUSION
Contrary to Republican claims, the eRIN program would not
destabilize the use of renewable liquid fuels and the vehicles
that operate with liquid fuels. Forming an eRIN program would
merely put renewable electricity on an even playing field with
the other transportation fuels under the RFS, providing the
renewable electricity stakeholders the same economic benefits
granted to renewable liquid fuel producers. Expanding
opportunities under the RFS for renewable electricity will
further our environmental and public health goals.
For the reasons stated above, we dissent from the views
contained in the Committee Report.
Frank Pallone, Jr.,
Ranking Member, Committee on Energy and Commerce.