Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 3557]
The Committee on Energy and Commerce, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 3557) to streamline Federal, State, and local
permitting and regulatory reviews to expedite the deployment of
communications facilities, and for other purposes, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 24
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 25
Committee Action................................................. 29
Committee Votes.................................................. 30
Oversight Findings and Recommendations........................... 37
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures 37
Congressional Budget Office Estimate............................. 37
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 37
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives............ 37
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 37
Related Committee and Subcommittee Hearings...................... 37
Committee Cost Estimate.......................................... 38
Earmark, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff Benefits....... 38
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 38
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 38
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 38
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 50
Minority Views................................................... 125
Exchange of Letters with Additional Committees of Referral....... 127
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
(a) Short Title.--This Act may be cited as the ``American Broadband
Deployment Act of 2023''.
(b) Table of Contents.--The table of contents for this Act is as
follows:
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
TITLE I--STATE AND LOCAL SITING PROCESSES
Sec. 101. Preservation of local zoning authority.
Sec. 102. Removal of barriers to entry.
Sec. 103. Requests for modification of certain existing wireless and
telecommunications service facilities.
TITLE II--CABLE
Sec. 201. Request for new franchise.
Sec. 202. Request regarding placement, construction, or modification of
cable equipment.
Sec. 203. Cable franchise term and termination.
Sec. 204. Sales of cable systems.
TITLE III--ENVIRONMENTAL AND HISTORIC PRESERVATION REVIEWS
Sec. 301. Application of NEPA and NHPA to certain communications
projects.
Sec. 302. Presumption with respect to certain complete FCC forms.
Sec. 303. Rule of construction.
Sec. 304. Definitions.
TITLE IV--OTHER MATTERS
Sec. 401. Timely consideration of applications for Federal easements,
rights-of-way, and leases.
Sec. 402. Streamlining of certain fees relating to broadband
infrastructure deployed using grant funds under BEAD Program.
TITLE I--STATE AND LOCAL SITING PROCESSES
SEC. 101. PRESERVATION OF LOCAL ZONING AUTHORITY.
Section 332(c) of the Communications Act of 1934 (47 U.S.C. 332(c))
is amended by striking paragraph (7) and inserting the following:
``(7) Preservation of local zoning authority.--
``(A) General authority.--Except as provided in this
paragraph, nothing in this Act shall limit or affect
the authority of a State or local government or
instrumentality thereof over decisions regarding the
placement, construction, or modification of personal
wireless service facilities.
``(B) Limitations.--
``(i) In general.--The regulation of the
placement, construction, or modification of a
personal wireless service facility by any State
or local government or instrumentality
thereof--
``(I) shall not discriminate among
personal wireless service facilities or
providers of communications service,
including by providing exclusive or
preferential use of facilities to a
particular provider or class of
providers of personal wireless service;
and
``(II) shall not prohibit or have the
effect of prohibiting the provision,
improvement, or enhancement of personal
wireless service.
``(ii) Engineering standards; aesthetic
requirements.--It is not a violation of clause
(i) for a State or local government or
instrumentality thereof to establish for
personal wireless service facilities, or
structures that support such facilities,
objective, reasonable, and nondiscriminatory--
``(I) structural engineering
standards based on generally applicable
codes;
``(II) safety requirements (subject
to clause (vi)); or
``(III) aesthetic or concealment
requirements (unless such requirements
prohibit or have the effect of
prohibiting the installation or
modification of such facilities or
structures).
``(iii) Timeframes.--
``(I) In general.--A State or local
government or instrumentality thereof
shall grant or deny a request for
authorization to place, construct, or
modify a personal wireless service
facility not later than--
``(aa) in the case of a
request for authorization to
place, construct, or modify a
personal wireless service
facility that is not a small
personal wireless service
facility--
``(AA) if the request
is for authorization to
place, construct, or
modify such facility
using an existing
structure, including
with respect to an area
that has not previously
been zoned for personal
wireless service
facilities (other than
small personal wireless
service facilities), 90
days after the date on
which the request is
submitted by the
requesting party to the
government or
instrumentality; or
``(BB) if the request
is for any other action
relating to such
facility, 150 days
after the date on which
the request is
submitted by the
requesting party to the
government or
instrumentality; and
``(bb) in the case of a
request for authorization to
place, construct, or modify a
small personal wireless service
facility--
``(AA) if the request
is for authorization to
place, construct, or
modify such facility
using an existing
structure, including
with respect to an area
that has not previously
been zoned for personal
wireless service
facilities, 60 days
after the date on which
the request is
submitted by the
requesting party to the
government or
instrumentality; or
``(BB) if the request
is for any other action
relating to such
facility, 90 days after
the date on which the
request is submitted by
the requesting party to
the government or
instrumentality.
``(II) Treatment of batched
requests.--In the case of requests
described in subclause (I) that are
submitted as part of a single batch by
the requesting party to the government
or instrumentality on the same day, the
applicable timeframe under such
subclause for each request in the batch
shall be the longest timeframe under
such subclause that would be applicable
to any request in the batch if such
requests were submitted separately.
``(III) Applicability.--The
applicable timeframe under subclause
(I) shall apply collectively to all
proceedings required by a State or
local government or instrumentality
thereof for the approval of the
request.
``(IV) No moritoria.--A timeframe
under subclause (I) may not be tolled
by any moratorium, whether express or
de facto, imposed by a State or local
government or instrumentality thereof
on the submission, acceptance, or
consideration of any request for
authorization to place, construct, or
modify a personal wireless service
facility.
``(V) Tolling due to
incompleteness.--
``(aa) Initial request
incomplete.--
``(AA) Small personal
wireless service
facilities.--If, not
later than 10 days
after the date on which
a requesting party
submits to a State or
local government or
instrumentality thereof
a request for
authorization to place,
construct, or modify a
small personal wireless
service facility, the
government or
instrumentality
provides to the
requesting party a
written notice
described in item (cc)
with respect to the
request, the timeframe
described in subclause
(I) is tolled with
respect to the request
and shall restart at
zero on the date on
which the requesting
party submits to the
government or
instrumentality a
supplemental submission
in response to the
notice.
``(BB) Other personal
wireless service
facilities.--If, not
later than 30 days
after the date on which
a requesting party
submits to a State or
local government or
instrumentality thereof
a request for
authorization to place,
construct, or modify a
personal wireless
service facility that
is not a small personal
wireless service
facility, the
government or
instrumentality
provides to the
requesting party a
written notice
described in item (cc)
with respect to the
request, the timeframe
described in subclause
(I) is tolled with
respect to the request
until the date on which
the requesting party
submits to the
government or
instrumentality a
supplemental submission
in response to the
notice.
``(bb) Supplemental
submission incomplete.--If, not
later than 10 days after the
date on which a requesting
party submits to a State or
local government or
instrumentality thereof a
supplemental submission in
response to a written notice
described in item (cc), the
government or instrumentality
provides to the requesting
party a written notice
described in item (cc) with
respect to the supplemental
submission, the timeframe under
subclause (I) is further tolled
until the date on which the
requesting party submits to the
government or instrumentality a
subsequent supplemental
submission in response to the
notice.
``(cc) Written notice
Purpose and Summary
H.R. 3557, the ``American Broadband Deployment Act'' would
streamline the broadband permitting process at the federal,
state, and local level. It would amend the Communications Act
of 1934 by establishing predictable timeframes for state and
local permitting processes related to broadband deployment. It
would also cap fees state and local governments charge for
permit application reviews and use of public rights-of-way,
requiring that those fees be based on actual costs.
Additionally, H.R. 3557 would reform the cable franchising
process. It would establish predictable timeframes for reviews
of requests for new franchises and expansion of cable systems.
It would also clarify and make more transparent the terms for
franchises and streamline the process for transferring cable
systems.
H.R 3557 would also exempt certain broadband-deployment
projects from environmental and historic preservation reviews
and codify the Tribal notification process for new wireless
infrastructure.
Finally, H.R 3557 would deem granted applications to deploy
broadband on federal lands that remain pending beyond the
existing 270-day timeframe for such reviews. It would also
require states to certify that projects funded by grants from
the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program are
charged cost-based fees from state and local governments.
Background and Need for Legislation
The United States faces a persistent digital divide.
According to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC),
approximately 8.3 million homes and businesses lack access to
high-speed broadband.\1\ The federal government has dedicated
billions of dollars to address this need, most recently with
$65 billion through the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act
(IIJA) to support broadband deployment, digital equity, and
affordability needs.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Jessica Rosenworcel, FCC, National Broadband Map: It Keeps
Getting Better, https://www.fcc.gov/national-broadband-map-it-keeps-
getting-better, (May 30, 2023); FCC National Broadband Map, https://
broadbandmap.fcc.gov/home (last accessed June 23, 2023).
\2\Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, P.L. 117-58, div. F,
tit. I Sec. 60101 et seq. (2021).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The bulk of this money will be spent on broadband
deployment. Before a broadband provider can begin deploying (or
modifying) broadband infrastructure, however, it must secure
zoning and construction permits, pay application fees, and
conduct environmental and historic preservation reviews. This
process often requires cooperation among providers, federal
agencies, and state and local governments. But the
unpredictable timelines for permit approvals and high fees for
processing applications have made it more expensive and
burdensome to deploy broadband infrastructure.\3\ Streamlining
these regulations is essential to encourage and expedite
broadband infrastructure deployment throughout the United
States, and ensure federal funding is not wasted due to
unnecessary permitting delays or fees.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Breaking Barriers: Streamlining Permitting to Expedite Broadband
Deployment, Hearing before the Sub. on Commc'n. and Tech., H. Comm. on
Energy and Commerce, 118th Cong. (2023) (``Permitting Hearing'')
(Written Testimony of Michael O'Rielly at 3); see, e.g., Streamlining
Federal Siting Working Group Final Report, FCC Broadband Deployment
Advisory Committee (Jan. 23-24, 2018), https://www.fcc.gov/sites/
default/files/bdac-federalsiting-01232018.pdf (discussing Federal
regulatory barriers to broadband deployment); Report Of The Removal of
State and Local Regulatory Barriers Working Group, FCC Broadband
Deployment Advisory Committee (Jan. 10, 2018), https://www.fcc.gov/
sites/default/files/bdac-regulatorybarriers-01232018.pdf (discussing
State and local barriers).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Federal Barriers
The federal government manages a significant amount of land
and buildings across the country. As a result, federal agencies
such as the Department of Interior, Department of Agriculture,
and General Services Administration, are responsible for
reviewing and approving applications to deploy broadband on
federal property. These agencies, however, often take
significant time to review these applications, which results in
project delays.\4\ As one stakeholder testified, ``[t]he
existing federal permitting process takes too long, is too
expensive, and is an impediment to the ability of broadband
providers to meet the needs of their consumers and
communities.''\5\ Problems include agencies not responding
``for long stretches of time regarding the status of
applications or what else might be needed to deem an
application `complete,''' followed by ``serial requests for
additional information that could have been caught earlier or
avoided altogether with better guidance and communication
upfront.''\6\ Agencies also lack coordination or similar
application of rules even within the same agency.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\See Linda Hardesty, Whoa--The Fiber Permitting Process Could
Crush Digital Divide Dreams, Fierce Telecom (Dec. 9, 2021), https://
www.fiercetelecom.com/broadband/whoa-fiber-permitting-process-could-
crush-digital-divide-dreams (describing federal approvals needed to
deploy broadband).
\5\Permitting Hearing (Written Testimony of Louis Finkel at 1).
\6\Permitting Hearing (Written Testimony of Michael Romano at 7).
\7\Permitting Hearing (Testimony of Louis Finkel).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To address this, Congress directed federal agencies to
develop one or more master contracts to govern the placement of
broadband infrastructure on property owned by the federal
government, use a common application form, and established a
270-day shot clock for federal agencies to process applications
to place communications facilities on federal property.\8\
Nonetheless, reviews often last beyond 270 days, as agencies
find ways to avoid starting the shot clock,\9\ and there is
currently no penalty when federal agencies miss this
deadline.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\47 U.S.C. Sec. 1455(b)(3)(A).
\9\Permitting Hearing (Written Testimony of Michael Romano at 8).
\10\Permitting Hearing (Response of Michael Saperstein to The Hon.
Jay Obernolte).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other federal laws, such as the National Historic
Preservation Act (NHPA)\11\ and the National Environmental
Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA),\12\ complicate broadband
infrastructure deployment. NEPA requires federal agencies to
identify and evaluate the environmental effects of proposed
``major Federal actions,''\13\ while NHPA requires agencies to
consider the effects of federal undertakings on historic
properties,\14\ usually through consultation with an
appropriate State Historic Preservation Officer or Tribal
Historic Preservation Officer, and provide notification to
Tribes that have expressed an interest in reviewing projects
proposed in their designated areas of interest.\15\ These two
laws are generally read coextensively\16\--major federal
actions under NEPA are usually considered federal undertakings
under NHPA. Certain broadband projects, such as those involving
federal lands or federal funds or those involving certain
wireless facilities, fall into these categories. Providers are
therefore required to conduct environmental and historic
preservation reviews for these projects. These reviews can cost
tens of thousands of dollars to complete and take years to
obtain approval,\17\ thus delaying and increasing the cost of
deployment.\18\ Worse, these reviews can be required even on
previously disturbed lands where a review previously took
place.\19\ Modernizing these processes would ``give more
certainty and predictability'' to broadband providers seeking
to deploy.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\54 U.S.C. Sec. 300101 et seq.
\12\42 U.S.C. Sec. 4321 et seq.
\13\42 U.S.C. Sec. 4332(2)(C); see also 40 CFR Sec. 1508.18
(defining major Federal action).
\14\54 U.S.C. Sec. 306108; see also see also 54 U.S.C.
Sec. 300320(3); 36 CFR Sec. 800.16(y) (defining undertaking).
\15\Tower and Antenna Siting, FCC, https://www.fcc.gov/wireless/
bureau-divisions/competition-infrastructure-policy-division/tower-and-
antenna-siting (June 29, 2022). https://www.fcc.gov/wireless/bureau-
divisions/competition-infrastructure-policy-division/tower-and-antenna-
siting#NHPA.
\16\Sac and Fox Nation of Mo. v. Norton, 240 F.3d 1250, 1263 (10th
Cir. 2001) (``Because of the operational similarity between the two
statutes, courts generally treat `major federal actions' under the NEPA
as closely analogous to `federal undertakings' under the NHPA.'').
\17\Permitting Hearing (Written Testimony of Michael Romano at 5).
\18\Id. (Written Testimony of Louis Finkel at 1).
\19\Id. (Written Testimony of Louis Finkel at 2).
\20\Id. (Written Testimony of Louis Finkel at 1).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The FCC has tried streamlining the NEPA/NHPA processes. In
the 2018 NEPA/NHPA Order, the FCC exempted construction of
small-cell wireless facilities from NHPA and NEPA,\21\ but the
U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
vacated that action in August 2019.\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Accelerating Wireless Broadband Deployment by Removing Barriers
to Infrastructure Investment, WT Docket No. 17-79, Second Report,
Second Report and Order, 33 FCC Rcd 3102 (2018) (2018 NEPA/NHPA Order).
\22\United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians in Oklahoma v. FCC,
933 F.3d 728 (D.C. Cir. 2019) (vacating an FCC order eliminating NEPA
and NHPA requirements as arbitrary and capricious for failing to
justify that public interest did not require review of small cell
deployments).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The FCC also addressed the Tribal notification process
under its rules implementing NHPA.\23\ The FCC's Nationwide
Programmatic Agreement Regarding the Section 106 National
Historic Preservation Act Review Process directs a provider
seeking to deploy a wireless tower to provide ``all information
reasonably necessary for [an] Indian Tribe or [Native Hawaiian
Organization] to evaluate whether Historic Properties of
religious and cultural significance may be affected'' and
provide the Tribe with a reasonable opportunity to respond.\24\
The FCC's Forms 620 and 621 provide this information--Form 620
addresses new towers and Form 621 addresses collocations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\2018 NEPA/NHPA Order 104-113.
\24\Nationwide Programmatic Agreement for Review of Effects on
Historic Properties for Certain Undertakings Approved by the Federal
Communications Commission, 47 C.F.R. pt.1, Appx. C Sec. IV.F.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the 2018 NEPA/NHPA Order, the FCC required applicants to
provide all potentially affected Tribes with a Form 620/621 and
clarified the timeframe for Tribes to respond to the
submission. The FCC established a 45-day process for moving
forward with construction in cases in which the Tribe does not
respond after having been given the opportunity to review a
Form 620/621 submission.\25\ If an applicant does not receive a
response within 30 calendar days of the date the Tribe can be
shown or may reasonably be expected to have received
notification that the Form 620/621 submission, the applicant
can refer the matter to the FCC for follow-up, and the FCC will
inform the Tribe that it has 15 calendar days to respond. If
the Tribe still does not respond, the applicant's pre-
construction obligations are discharged with respect to that
Tribe. The FCC also determined that ``the detailed information
included in the Form 620/621 submission packet constitutes a
reasonable and good faith effort to provide the information
reasonably necessary for [Tribes] to ascertain whether historic
properties of religious and cultural significance to them may
be affected by the undertaking.''\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\2018 NEPA/NHPA Order 111.
\26\Id. 106.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
State and Local Obstacles
State and local governments play a key role in facilitating
or obstructing broadband infrastructure deployment. They
regulate land use, review siting applications, and issue
relevant permits. State and local franchising authorities also
approve whether cable operators can provide service in a region
and impose other regulations related to their provision of
service.
State and local governments' review processes can be
cumbersome and costly,\27\ which can delay or even prohibit
broadband deployment. For example, some state and local
governments charge excessive fees for reviewing applications or
to access the public rights-of-way for construction and impose
no deadlines to review applications.\28\ One provider reported
that a government charged ``fees amounting to over $125 per
subscriber and with no clear tie to the costs incurred by the
state in processing the application or arising out of the use
of the right-of-way.''\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\Permitting Hearing (Written Testimony of Michael O'Rielly at
5).
\28\See, generally, Accelerating Wireless Broadband Deployment by
Removing Barriers to Infrastructure Investment, WT Docket No. 17-79, WC
Docket No. 17-84, Declaratory Ruling and Third Report and Order, 33 FCC
Rcd. 9088 (2018).
\29\Permitting Hearing (Written Testimony of Michael Romano at 5).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Federal law preempts state and local authority to regulate
communications facilities. Under Section 253 of the
Communications Act of 1934, ``no State or local statute or
regulation, or other State or local legal requirement, may
prohibit or have the effect of prohibiting the ability of any
entity to provide any interstate or intrastate
telecommunications service.''\30\ Section 253 requires the
Commission to preempt the enforcement of any such law.\31\
Similarly, Section 332(c)(7) of the Communications Act states
that ``[t]he regulation of the placement, construction, and
modification of personal wireless service facilities by any
State or local government or instrumentality thereof . . .
shall not prohibit or have the effect of prohibiting the
provision of personal wireless services.''\32\ It further
requires a State or local government or instrumentality thereof
to ``act on any request for authorization to place, construct,
or modify personal wireless service facilities within a
reasonable period of time after the request is duly
filed.''\33\ Finally, under Section 6409(a) of the Middle Class
Tax Relief and Job Creation Act of 2012, ``a State or local
government may not deny, and shall approve, any eligible
facilities request for a modification of an existing wireless
tower or base station that does not substantially change the
physical dimensions of such tower or base station.''\34\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\47 U.S.C. Sec. 253(a).
\31\Id. Sec. 253(d).
\32\Id. Sec. 332(c)(7)(B)(i).
\33\Id. Sec. 332(c)(7)(B)(ii).
\34\Middle Class Tax Relief and Job Creation Act of 2012, P.L. 112-
96, tit. VI, sub. D Sec. 6409(a) codified at 47 U.S.C. Sec. 1455(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The FCC has used its authority to address state and local
barriers to broadband infrastructure deployment. In 2009, the
Commission adopted an interpretation of ``reasonable period of
time'' under Section 332 to be 90 days for reviews of
collocation applications and 150 days for reviews of siting
applications other than collocations.\35\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\35\Petition for Declaratory Ruling to Clarify Provisions of
Section 332(c)(7) to Ensure Timely Siting Review, Declaratory Ruling,
24 FCC Rcd 13994 56 (2009), aff'd, City of Arlington v. FCC, 569 U.S.
290 (2013).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2014, the FCC adopted a Report and Order implementing
Section 6409 that gave State and local governments 60 days to
approve eligible facilities requests to modify existing
wireless facilities.\36\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\36\Acceleration of Broadband Deployment by Improving Wireless
Facilities Siting Policies, Report & Order, 29 FCC Rcd 12865, 12966
243, 270, (2014) (2014 Wireless Infrastructure Order), aff'd,
Montgomery County v. FCC, 811 F.3d 121 (4th Cir. 2015); 47 C.F.R.
Sec. 1.6100.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2018, the FCC codified the timelines for reviews it
adopted in 2009 in a new Declaratory Ruling and Report and
Order.\37\ That item also streamlined state and local
government review of wireless small-cell siting applications by
limiting application fees that state and local governments
could charge an applicant to be based on cost, establishing new
shot clocks for small wireless facilities, and adopting new
remedies for failing to act within the shot-clock. The U.S.
Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit upheld this action after
a challenge from a number of local governments.\38\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\37\Accelerating Wireless Broadband Deployment by Removing Barriers
to Infrastructure Investment, WT Docket No. 17-79, WC Docket No. 17-84,
Declaratory Ruling and Third Report and Order, 33 FCC Rcd. 9088 138-
39 (2018) (2018 Small Cell Order); 47 C.F.R. Sec. 1.6003.
\38\City of Portland v. United States, 969 F.3d 1020 (9th Cir.
2020).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2018, the FCC also issued a Declaratory Ruling declaring
that state and local moratoria on the deployment of
telecommunications services or facilities prohibit or have the
effect of prohibiting the ability of any entity to provide any
interstate or intrastate telecommunications service.\39\ Thus,
state and local governments cannot ban the deployment of
telecommunications services or facilities or enact de facto
bans, such as blanket refusals to process applications,
refusals to issue permits for a category of structures, or
frequent and lengthy delays.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\39\Accelerating Wireline Broadband Deployment by Removing Barriers
to Infrastructure Investment, WC Docket No. 17-84, WT Docket No. 17-79,
Third Report and Order and Declaratory Ruling, 33 FCC Rcd. 7705 140
(2018); 47 U.S.C. Sec. 253.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2020, the FCC adopted a Declaratory Ruling on state and
local government review of modifications to existing wireless
infrastructure to facilitate 5G deployment.\40\ The item
clarified when the 60-day shot clock for local review begins,
how certain aspects of proposed modifications affect
eligibility for streamlined review, and when FCC applicants
need to submit environmental assessments based only on
potential impacts to historic properties.\41\ A number of
municipalities are challenging this item in the U.S. Court of
Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.\42\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\40\Implementation of State and Local Governments' Obligation to
Approve Certain Wireless Facility Modification Requests Under Section
6409(a) of the Spectrum Act of 2012, WT Docket No. 19-250, Declaratory
Ruling and Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, 35 FCC Rcd 5977 14-23
(2020) (5G Upgrade Order).
\41\Id.
\42\League of Calif. Cities, et al. v. FCC, et al., No. 20-71765
(9th Cir., filed June 22, 2020).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although these FCC actions have helped accelerate broadband
infrastructure deployment, the litigation surrounding these
rules and the risk that they could change with new
administrations u
Committee Action
On April 19, 2023, the Subcommittee on Communications and
Technology held a hearing entitled, ``Breaking Barriers:
Streamlining Permitting to Expedite Broadband Deployment.'' The
Subcommittee received testimony from:
Michael Romano, Executive Vice President,
NTCA--The Rural Broadband Association;
Michael Saperstein, Senior Vice President of
Government Affairs and Chief Strategy Officer, Wireless
Infrastructure Association;
Michael O'Rielly, President, MPORielly
Consulting, LLC;
Louis Finkel, Senior Vice President of
Government Relations, National Rural Electric
Cooperative Association; and,
Ernesto Falcon, Senior Legislative Counsel,
Electronic Frontier Foundation.
On May 17, 2023, the Subcommittee on Communications and
Technology met in open markup session and forwarded H.R. 3291,
as amended, to the full Committee by a record vote of 16 yeas
and 12 nays. That text became the base for H.R. 3557, which was
introduced by Rep. Earl L. ``Buddy'' Carter (GA-01) on May 22,
2023.
On May 24, 2023, the full Committee on Energy and Commerce
met in open markup session and ordered H.R. 3557, as amended,
favorably reported to the House by a record vote of 27 yeas and
23 nays.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII requires the Committee to list the
record votes on the motion to report legislation and amendments
thereto. The following reflects the record votes taken during
the Committee consideration:
Oversight Findings and Recommendations
Pursuant to clause 2(b)(1) of rule X and clause 3(c)(1) of
rule XIII, the Committee held a hearing and made findings that
are reflected in this report.
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII, the Committee
finds that H.R. 3557 would result in no new or increased budget
authority, entitlement authority, or tax expenditures or
revenues.
Congressional Budget Office Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII, at the time this
report was filed, the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to Section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974 was not available.
Federal Mandates Statement
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of Federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to Section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general
performance goal or objective of this legislation is to
expedite broadband deployment by streamlining the permitting
process at the federal, state, and local level.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII, no provision of
H.R. 3557 is known to be duplicative of another Federal
program, including any program that was included in a report to
Congress pursuant to Section 21 of Public Law 111-139 or the
most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance.
Related Committee and Subcommittee Hearings
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
related hearing was used to develop or consider H.R. 3557:
On April 19, 2023, the Subcommittee on
Communications and Technology held a hearing. The title
of the hearing was ``Breaking Barriers: Streamlining
Permitting to Expedite Broadband Deployment.'' The
Subcommittee received testimony to develop H.R. 3557
from:
Michael Romano, Executive Vice
President, NTCA--The Rural Broadband Association;
Michael Saperstein, Senior Vice
President of Government Affairs and Chief Strategy
Officer, Wireless Infrastructure Association;
Michael O'Rielly, President, MPORielly
Consulting, LLC;
Louis Finkel, Senior Vice President of
Government Relations, National Rural Electric
Cooperative Association; and,
Ernesto Falcon, Senior Legislative
Counsel, Electronic Frontier Foundation.
Committee Cost Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII, the Committee
adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to Section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974. At the time this report was
filed, the estimate was not available.
Earmark, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff Benefits
Pursuant to clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI, the
Committee finds that H.R. 3557 contains no earmarks, limited
tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of Section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of Section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation
Section 1. Short title; table of contents
This Section designates that the short title may be cited
as the ``American Broadband Deployment Act of 2023.'' It also
includes the table of contents for this legislation.
Section 101. Preservation of local zoning authority
Section 101 would amend Section 332(c) of the
Communications Act of 1934 (47 U.S.C. 332(c)) by striking
paragraph (7) and inserting a new paragraph (7). The amended
subparagraph (7)(A) would provide that nothing in paragraph (7)
shall limit or affect the authority of a State or local
government or instrumentality over decisions regarding
placement, construction, or modification of personal wireless
service facilities.
Subparagraph (B) would limit the general authority of
subparagraph (A). Clause (i) would limit the ability of any
State or local government or instrumentality thereof to
discriminate among personal wireless service facilities or
providers of communications services, and to prohibit or have
the effect of prohibiting the provision, improvement, or
enhancement of personal wireless services. The ``prohibit or
have the effect of prohibiting'' language matches existing
language in Section 332(c)(7), and the Committee intends this
language to be interpreted in the same way, specifically
adopting the ``materially inhibit'' standard used in the FCC's
1997 California Payphone decision.\44\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\44\California Payphone Ass'n, 12 FCC Rcd 14191 31 (1997).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Clause (ii) would state that it is not a violation of
clause (i) for a State or local government or instrumentality
to establish structural engineering standards, safety
requirements, or aesthetic requirements for personal wireless
service facilities as long as those requirements are objective,
reasonable, and nondiscriminatory. Regulations on safety
requirements are subject to clause (vi), which would limit the
ability for a State or local government to regulate personal
wireless service facilities on the basis of the environmental
effects of radio frequency, and aesthetic requirements could
not prohibit or have the effect of prohibiting personal
wireless facilities.
Clause (iii) would establish the timeframes for reviewing a
request for authorization to place, construct, or modify a
personal wireless service facility. Subclause (I) would provide
the timeframes within which a State or local government shall
grant or deny a request for authorization to place, construct,
or modify a personal wireless service facility:
90 days for a request to collocate a
facility that is not a small personal wireless facility
(small cell) on an existing structure;
150 days for a request to deploy a non-small
cell facility on a new structure;
60 days for a request to collocate a small
cell on an existing structure; and
90 days for a request to deploy a small cell
on a new structure.
Subclause (II) would provide that the timeframe to review
requests that are submitted in a batch would be the longest
timeframe under subclause (I) that would be applicable to any
request in the batch. The timeframes and batching requirements
in subclauses (I) and (II) are consistent with current FCC
rules.\45\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\45\47 C.F.R. Sec. 1.6003(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subclause (III) would apply the timeframes under subclause
(I) to all proceedings required by a State or local government
for approval of the request. Subclause (IV) would prohibit a
State or local government from tolling the timeframes under
subclause (I) by placing a moratorium, whether express or de
facto, on the submission, acceptance, or consideration of any
request.
Subclause (V) would address the tolling of the timeframes
due to the initial incompleteness of requests. Like subclause
(I), the requirements differ between small personal wireless
services facilities and other personal wireless service
facilities. Further, the subclause defines supplemental
submissions to provide missing information, written notice
requirements for incomplete requests, and limitations on
subsequent written notices. Subclause (VI) would allow the
State or local government and the requesting party to toll the
timeframe by mutual agreement.
Clause (iv) would deem a request granted if the State or
local government failed to take final action to grant or deny a
request within the timeframes established under clause (iii).
This clause also contains a rule of construction stating that a
request deemed granted shall be authorized without further
action by the government or instrumentality.
Clause (v) would outline the requirements for denial of a
request. A denial would need to be in writing, supported by
substantial evidence contained in a written record, and
publicly released and provided to the requesting party on the
same day the decision is made.
Clause (vi) would prohibit a State or local government from
regulating the operation, placement, construction, or
modification of personal wireless service facilities on the
basis of the environmental effects of radio frequency.
Clause (vii) would address how a State or local government
may charge fees for the consideration of a request or use of a
right-of-way or facility in a right-of-way owned or managed by
the government. Fees must be competitively neutral,
nondiscriminatory, established in advance, calculated based on
actual and direct costs, and described to a requesting party in
a way that distinguishes between various types of fees,
including recurring and nonrecurring fees. As the FCC held in
its 2018 Small Cell Order, the Committee expects that only
objectively reasonable costs may be factored into these
fees.\46\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\46\2018 Small Cell Order 50.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subparagraph (C) would allow for any person adversely
affected by any final action or failure to act by a State or
local government to commence action in any court with competent
jurisdiction. The same action may also be brought in front of
the FCC.
Subparagraph (D) would specify when a request is considered
to be submitted. A request would be considered submitted on the
date on which the applicant takes the first procedural step
within its control to submit the application in accordance with
the procedures established by the government or instrumentality
for the review and approval of such a request or for a standard
review for a similar facility or structure.
Subparagraph (E) would establish a rule of construction
stating that nothing in this paragraph may be construed to
affect Section 6409(a) of the Middle Class Tax Relief and Job
Creation Act of 2012, relating to modifications of certain
facilities. Subparagraph (F) contains the definitions Section
for the new Section 332(c) paragraph (7).
Section 102. Removal of barriers to entry
This Section would amend Section 253 of the Communications
Act of 1934 (47 U.S.C) by replacing the existing section with
new language.
Subsection (a) of this new section would state that no
State or local statute, or other regulations, may prohibit or
have the effect of prohibiting the ability of any entity to
provide, improve, or enhance the provision of an interstate or
intrastate telecommunications service. As noted in Section 101,
the use of the phrase ``prohibit or have the effect of
prohibiting'' matches existing language, with the intent that
it be interpreted consistent with the ``materially inhibit''
standard adopted in the FCC's California Payphone decision.
Subsection (b) would address the placement, construction,
or modification of telecommunications service facilities.
Paragraph (1) would provide that a state or local government
may not discriminate among telecommunications service
facilities based on technology used or services provided, or
against telecommunication service facilities as compared to the
placement, construction, or modification of other facilities.
Paragraph (2) would specify the timeframes that State or
local governments must abide by in processing permit requests.
Like Section 101, this paragraph contains the specified
timelines, applicability, and rules regarding tolling for
incomplete requests or by mutual agreement. Here, a State or
local government would have 90 days to review requests that use
existing infrastructure and 150 days for all other requests.
These timeframes would apply collectively to all proceedings
required by the State or local government for the approval of
the request and may be tolled for incompleteness or by mutual
agreement. Further, the paragraph addresses supplemental
submissions to provide missing information, written notice
requirements, and limitations on subsequent written notices.
Paragraph (3) would deem a request granted if the request
is not granted or denied within the timeframes established by
paragraph (2), and paragraph (4) would require that a decision
to deny a request would need to be in writing, supported by
substantial evidence contained in a written record, and
publicly released and provided to the requesting party on the
same day the decision is made.
Paragraph (5) would address how a State or local government
may charge fees for the consideration of a request or use of a
right-of-way or facility in a right-of-way owned or managed by
the government. As with Section 101, fees must be competitively
neutral, nondiscriminatory, established in advance, calculated
based on actual and direct costs, and described to a requesting
party in a way that distinguishes between various types of
fees, including recurring and nonrecurring fees. Once again,
the Committee expects that only objectively reasonable costs to
be factored into these fees.
Paragraph (6) would state that authorization by a State or
local government to place, construct, or modify a
telecommunications service facility in a right-of-way owned by
that government is sufficient authorization to place,
construct, or modify such a facility above or under a
transportation crossing, such as a railroad crossing,
intersecting that right-of-way. The paragraph would direct the
FCC to coordinate with the Secretary of Transportation to
promulgate regulations to implement this paragraph. These
regulations would be implemented in manner that ensures safety;
prevents interference with transportation crossings and related
transportation operations; allows for the timely and efficient
placement, construction, and modification of telecommunications
service facilities; and establishes requirements and standards
for just and reasonable compensation to private owners of
transportation crossings, including compensation for costs
related to the deployment of such facilities.
The Committee recognizes that a number of states, including
Iowa, Nebraska, Minnesota, and Illinois, have enacted
legislation addressing broadband (or utility) deployment
through transportation crossings. It is the Committee's intent
that these laws serve as a model for the Commission, especially
on the actual, objectively reasonable costs that a railroad can
charge, and the timeframe for reviewing crossing requests. The
Committee also recognizes that railroad companies have
developed their own processes and procedures for the safe
deployment of broadband in their rights of way and expects the
FCC to account for these processes and procedures in developing
rules.
Subsection (c) would allow for any person adversely
affected by any final action or failure to act by a State or
local government to commence action in any court with competent
jurisdiction. This review must be done on an expedited basis
and must commence within 30 days after final action or failure
to act.
Subsection (d) would explicitly preserve the regulatory
authority of States to impose competitively neutral and
nondiscriminatory regulations to preserve and advance universal
service, protect the public safety and welfare, ensure the
continued quality of telecommunications services, and safeguard
the rights of consumers.
Subsection (e) preserves the ability of State and local
governments to manage, on a competitively neutral and
nondiscriminatory basis, the public rights-of-way, and to
require compensation for the use of such rights-of-way
consistent with the requirements of subsection (b)(5).
Subsection (f) would allow the FCC to preempt a State or
local government regulation or statute if, after notice and
public comment, the Commission determines that the imposed
statute, regulation, or legal requirement violates this
section.
Subsection (g) would qualify that the new Section 253 shall
not affect that application of Section 332(c)(3) to commercial
mobile providers or Section 621 to cable operators.
Under subsection (h), it would not be a violation of this
section for a State to require a telecommunications carrier
that seeks to provide telephone exchange service to rural areas
to meet the requirements in Section 214(e)(1) for designation
as an eligible telecommunications carrier. However, paragraph
(1) and (2) would limit this exemption in a service area that
has obtained an exemption, suspension, or modification of
Section 251(c)(4), effectively preventing competitors from
meeting the requirements of Section 214(e)(1), and for
providers of commercial mobile services.
Subsection (i) would establish when a request is considered
submitted. A request would be considered submitted on the date
on which the applicant takes the first procedural step within
its control to submit the application in accordance with the
procedures established by the government or instrumentality for
the review and approval of such a request or for a standard
review for a similar facility or structure.
Subsection (j) contains the definitions section for the new
Section 253.
Sec. 103. Requests for modification of certain existing wireless and
telecommunications service facilities
Subsection (a)(1) would amend Section 6409 of the Middle
Class Tax Relief and Job Creation Act of 2012 (47 U.S.C. 1455)
by striking the word ``wireless'' from the heading and
inserting ``communications''. Subsection (a)(2)(A) would amend
subsection (a) of Section 6409 to state that a State or local
government or instrumentality thereof may not deny, and shall
approve any:
Eligible facilities request for the
modification of an existing wireless tower, base
station, eligible support structure, and
Eligible telecommunications facility request
for the modification of an existing telecommunications
service facility in or on eligible support
infrastructure that does not substantially change the
physical dimensions of the facility.``Eligible support
infrastructure'' would be defined in new subsection
(a)(7) of Section 6409 to mean infrastructure that
supports or houses a telecommunications service
facility at the time when an eligible
telecommunications facilities request for a
modification of such facility is submitted to a State
or local government or instrumentality thereof. The
Committee intends this to include poles, towers,
buildings, ducts, and conduits.
Subsection (a)(2)(B) would amend subsection (a)(2) of
Section 6409 by adding a timeframe for approval. Consistent
with existing FCC rules,\47\ a State or local government would
have to approve a request within 60 days of the submission or
the request is deemed granted. A rule of construction would
further clarify that a deemed granted request requires no
further action by the relevant government or instrumentality.
This subsection further outlines how a determination that a
request is not an eligible facilities request or eligible
telecommunications facility request must be described and
formatted. Finally, this subsection would address tolling due
Minority Views
In November 2021, President Biden signed into law the
Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, or the ``Bipartisan
Infrastructure Law,'' which made historic and long overdue
investments in surface transportation, energy, healthcare, and
communications infrastructure. These investments included
$42.45 billion for the Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment
Program to deploy broadband infrastructure to Americans who
lack reliable access to high-speed internet service. These
investments will do more to connect the unconnected than any
previous congressional action ever has, and Congress and the
Energy and Commerce Committee should focus on maximizing these
dollars and ensuring projects are carried out as efficiently
and expeditiously as possible.
Committee Democrats do not dispute that there are barriers
in the way of deploying broadband infrastructure. H.R. 3557
addresses none of them, unfortunately. If the Republican
Majority adhered to the regular order process that the Energy
and Commerce Committee typically observes, Members could have
worked in a bipartisan fashion to develop legislation that
addresses the concerns that all witnesses raised at the
legislative hearing--most notably, the lack of adequate
resources and qualified personnel to review permit applications
at Federal agencies. Instead, the Republican Majority rushed
directly to a legislative hearing on dozens of partisan bills,
presupposing a handful of misguided legislative ``solutions''
in search of problems that compose H.R. 3557, as reported by
the Energy and Commerce Committee.
H.R. 3557 regrettably proposes to eliminate standard
environmental and historic preservation reviews that simply do
not affect the overwhelming majority of communications
infrastructure projects in the manner suggested by Republicans.
With respect to the application of the National Environmental
Policy Act (NEPA), many projects to deploy communications
infrastructure already qualify for expedited approval under
existing categorical exclusions, which Federal agencies
maintain to alleviate requirements for predetermined activities
that do not have a significant environmental impact. If a
proposed deployment project does not meet the parameters of an
existing categorical exclusion, the grant recipient is still
able to obtain approval after submitting an Environmental
Assessment and receiving a Finding of No Significant Impact.
There is little evidence to suggest that communications
infrastructure deployment projects regularly trigger the
highest level of scrutiny under NEPA and require applicants to
develop and submit an Environmental Impact Statement, and
certainly not enough to warrant the blanket NEPA exemptions
proposed in H.R. 3557.
Perhaps most troubling are provisions in H.R. 3557 which
propose to eliminate local communities' roles in decision-
making over the placement and construction of utility
infrastructure. The bill imposes heavy-handed ``deemed
granted'' provisions on local governments by setting narrow and
arbitrary deadlines to approve requests to install
communications infrastructure in areas managed by county or
municipal governments. The 60-day ``shot clock'' to approve or
deny an application implies an unfamiliarity with the realities
of local government calendars and processes built around
sunshine laws that many local governments follow to ensure
transparency and provide residents with sufficient opportunity
to be heard on important community matters. While the
Republican Majority seems intent on helping big corporations
evade scrutiny in communities they wish to serve, Democrats
understand that mayors, councils, and local boards represent
the best interests of their constituents and disagree with
attempts by Republicans to constrain their ability to do so.
Local officials are responsible for ensuring the safety and
welfare of residents and efforts by House Republicans to
automatically approve certain construction projects that have
not been approved by regular local government processes will
put people in harm's way. Communications providers that proceed
with construction without the proper approvals from state,
county, or municipal governments should recognize the liability
they expose themselves to in doing so. These are just some of
the reasons why H.R. 3557 is opposed by the National League of
Cities, United States Conference of Mayors, the National
Association of Counties, and the National Association of
Telecommunications Officers and Advisors.
The most effective action the Committee Republicans could
have taken to expedite the deployment of high-speed internet to
rural communities was to vote for the Bipartisan Infrastructure
Law, which no current member of the Republican Majority did.
Frank Pallone, Jr.
Ranking Member, Energy and Commerce Committee.