Additional Views
[To accompany H.R. 5721]
The Committee on the Judiciary, to whom was referred the
bill (H.R. 5721) to amend the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe
Streets Act of 1968 to require certain reporting on sexual
assault kit testing, having considered the same, reports
favorably thereon with an amendment and recommends that the
bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 3
Background and Need for the Legislation.......................... 3
Hearings......................................................... 5
Committee Consideration.......................................... 5
Committee Votes.................................................. 5
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 7
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures........................ 7
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate........................ 7
Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects.......................... 7
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 7
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 7
Advisory on Earmarks............................................. 8
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 8
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 8
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 8
Section-by-Section Analysis...................................... 8
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 9
Additional Views................................................. 13
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all that follows after the enacting clause and insert
the following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Rape Kit Backlog Progress Act of
2023''.
SEC. 2. FINDINGS.
Congress finds the following:
(1) A sexual assault kit includes a sexual assault forensic
exam, meaning an examination provided to a sexual assault
patient by a health care provider who has specialized education
and clinical experience in the collection of forensic evidence
and treatment of these patients, which includes--
(A) gathering information from the patient for the
medical forensic history;
(B) an examination;
(C) coordinating treatment of injuries, documentation
of biological and physical findings, and collection of
evidence from the patient;
(D) documentation of findings;
(E) providing information, treatment, and referrals
for sexually transmitted infections, pregnancy,
suicidal ideation, alcohol and substance abuse, and
other non-acute medical concerns; and
(F) providing follow-up as needed to provide
additional healing, treatment, or collection of
evidence.
(2) A sexual assault kit is an important forensic tool used
by law enforcement and prosecutors to investigate and prosecute
sexual assault and other crimes.
(3) It is estimated that there are currently well over
100,000 untested sexual assault kits in America, but the exact
number is not known.
(4) Untested sexual assault kits means that there are sexual
assaults unprosecuted, sexual assaults occurring that could
have been prevented, and a delay in uploading DNA to Combined
DNA Index System (commonly known as ``CODIS'') that can assist
law enforcement in solving other violent crimes.
SEC. 3. REPORT TO ATTORNEY GENERAL REQUIRED ON SEXUAL ASSAULT KIT
TESTING.
Section 502 of the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of 1968
(34 U.S.C. 10153) is amended--
(1) in subsection (a), by adding at the end the following:
``(7) A report indicating whether--
``(A) the State or unit of local government has
conducted a comprehensive sexual assault kit inventory,
commonly known as a `backlog inventory', to identify
the physical location, untested or tested status (or
full sexual assault kit status, if available), and any
individual test kit identification or tracking
information of each sexual assault kit in the
possession of such State or unit of local government,
or that has been otherwise transmitted by a State or
unit of local government to a third-party, such as for
testing, storing, processing, or handling;
``(B) with respect to each sexual assault kit that
the victim has consented to have collected, the State
or unit of local government has submitted each such
sexual assault kit to a laboratory for DNA analysis;
``(C) results of any such DNA analysis were uploaded
to the Combined DNA Index System;
``(D) the State or unit of local government has
established an electronic tracking system for a victim
to identify the physical location of their sexual
assault kit and the results of any DNA analysis that
was performed;
``(E) the State or unit of local government has
established a victim notification protocol for
informing a victim of the status of their sexual
assault kit, including where their sexual assault kit
was analyzed;
``(F) the State or unit of local government has in
place a comprehensive sexual assault kit inventory
system to identify sexual assault kit status, physical
location, and any test kit identification or tracking
information of each sexual assault kit in the
possession of such State or unit of local government,
or otherwise transmitted by a State or unit of local
government to a third-party, such as for testing,
storing, processing, or handling; and
``(G) the information in any comprehensive sexual
assault kit inventory system described in subparagraph
(F) is updated, and how and when it is updated.''; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
``(c) Determination by Attorney General.-- Between the receipt of a
grant application and deciding on such application, the Attorney
General shall determine--
``(1) if the State or unit of local government has completed
the conduct described under subsection (a)(7); and
``(2) if such conduct has not been completed, the reason that
it has not been completed.
``(d) Eligibility.--A State or unit or local government shall only be
eligible for a grant under this subpart if the Attorney General
determines such State or unit of local government has completed the
conduct described under subsection (a)(7).
``(e) Requirement for Grant Recipients.--A State or unit of local
government that has been awarded a grant under this subpart as of the
date of the enactment of the `Rape Kit Backlog Progress Act of 2023'
shall have one calendar year from such date of enactment to complete
the conduct described in subsection (a)(7) or such State or unit of
local government shall become ineligible for a grant under this
subpart.
``(g) Definitions.--In this section:
``(1) Sexual assault kit.--The term `sexual assault kit'
means evidence gathered by a medical professional from a victim
following a sexual assault, which evidence may--
``(A) include swabs, test tubes, microscopic slides,
and evidence collection envelopes, for hairs and
fibers; and
``(B) vary in accordance with the circumstances of
the sexual assault and with any applicable rules or
procedures of the jurisdiction.
``(2) Sexual assault kit status.--The term `sexual assault
kit status' means whether an individual sexual assault kit is--
``(A) collected and untested;
``(B) collected and tested;
``(C) lost or missing, expired or spoiled; or
``(D) tested and results reported to the victim,
proper authorities, and the Combined DNA Index
System.''.
SEC. 4. ATTORNEY GENERAL PUBLIC REPORT ON RAPE KIT BACKLOGS.
Subpart 1 of part E of title I of the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe
Streets Act of 1968 (34 U.S.C. 10151 et seq.) is amended by adding at
the end the following:
``SEC. 510. ATTORNEY GENERAL PUBLIC REPORT ON RAPE KIT BACKLOGS.
``(a) In General.--Beginning not later than two years after the date
of the enactment of the `Rape Kit Backlog Progress Act of 2023', and
annually thereafter, the Attorney General shall make publicly available
on the internet website of the Department of Justice a report,
including--
``(1) each report on the conduct described under section
502(a)(7) received from an applicant for a grant under this
subpart;
``(2) an aggregate analysis of the reports described under
paragraph (1);
``(3) if an applicant for a grant under this subpart has been
awarded a grant; and
``(4) if an applicant for a grant under this subpart
completed the conduct described under section 502(a)(7) and if
it has not completed the conduct described under such
subsection, the reason that the conduct has not been completed.
``(b) Prohibition on Personally Identifiable Information.--Any
information published by the Attorney General pursuant to this section
may not contain the personally identifiable information of a victim and
if such information was erroneously published, it shall be removed from
the website of the Department of Justice immediately upon discovery.''.
Purpose and Summary
H.R. 5721, introduced by Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC), amends the
Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of 1968 to require
certain grant applicants and recipients to report to the
Attorney General on whether they have taken steps to inventory,
audit, and track sexual assault kits and their testing.
Background and Need for the Legislation
DNA evidence is an essential part of ensuring that
survivors of sexual violence receive justice and see their
perpetrators held accountable. DNA evidence is often found and
recovered using rape kits.\1\ Despite the availability of
federal funding through the Debbie Smith DNA Backlog Grant
Program for crime labs to process DNA evidence,\2\ many state
and local governments still struggle to process rape kits in a
timely manner. According to USAFacts, a nonpartisan data
center, the number of untested rape kits continues to grow in
crime labs and law enforcement facilities across the United
States.\3\ USAFacts found that across 30 states and the
District of Columbia, there were at least 25,000 kits in need
of testing in 2022.\4\ However, determining the precise number
of untested kits is difficult because of a lack of effective
tracking techniques.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Chris Gilligan, States Struggle With Rape Kit Backlogs Despite
Funding Efforts, U.S. News (June 20, 2023), https://www.usnews.com/
news/best-states/articles/2023-06-20/rape-kit-backlogs-remain-in-
states-despite-funding.
\2\Debbie Smith Act, RAINN, https://www.rainn.org/articles/debbie-
smith-act (last visited Sept. 21, 2023).
\3\Chris Gilligan, States Struggle With Rape Kit Backlogs Despite
Funding Efforts, U.S. News (June 20, 2023), https://www.usnews.com/
news/best-states/articles/2023-06-20/rape-kit-backlogs-remain-in-
states-despite-funding.
\4\Id.
\5\See Emily J. Hanson, Cong. Res. Serv., R44237, Sexual Assault
Kits (SAKs) and the Backlog of Untested Sexual Assault Evidence: In
Brief 6 (2022).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The testing backlog for rape kits often results from
evidence not being sent to the crime lab or evidence arriving
at the crime lab but not being tested.\6\ This may occur due to
a number of reasons, including poor tracking and evidence
logging practices; a general increase in the amount of DNA
evidence requiring testing; and a lack of equipment,
technicians, or funding.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Addressing the Rape Kit Backlog, RAINN, https://www.rainn.org/
articles/addressing-rape-kit-backlog (last visited Sept. 21, 2023).
\7\See generally, Hanson supra note 5, at 5-8.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The backlog has become more widely known due to publicized
failures in the timely testing of rape kits, including a case
in Houston, Texas, in which two women sued the city over
testing delays. In September 2017, a woman filed a class-action
suit against the city of Houston over a backlog of untested
rape kits.\8\ The woman stated that her rapist's DNA was in
several untested rape kits of other alleged victims.\9\ The
rapist was a convicted child rapist whose criminal record
encompassed 20 years of violent crimes, including kidnapping,
unlawful restraint, and sexual assault of a child.\10\ The
woman alleges that if the kits had been tested, police could
have arrested her assailant before he assaulted her.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Keith Garvin, Rape victim sues city of Houston over backlog of
untested rape kits, Click 2 Houston (Sept. 25, 2017), https://
www.click2houston.com/news/2017/09/26/rape-victim-sues-city-of-houston-
over-backlog-of-untested-rape-kits/.
\9\Id.
\10\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another plaintiff joined the lawsuit claiming that her
assault would not have happened if evidence from previous
victims was tested.\11\ Under Texas law, rape kits are supposed
to be tested within 30 days. However, both women did not hear
about the backlog of their rape kits until 5 years after the
evidence was collected.\12\ The victims claimed that it was
unjust for the city of Houston to expect them to continuously
follow up for results of rape kits taken years prior.\13\ The
lawsuit listed the Houston Mayor Sylvester Turner, Houston
Police Chief Art Acevedo, several former mayors, and several
former police chiefs as defendants. While the case was
ultimately dismissed, the lawsuit brought attention to the
issue of untested rape kits across the country.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Id.
\12\Robert Downen, Lawsuit expands allegations that City of Houston
didn't properly investigate rapes, Houston Chronicle (Dec. 23, 2017).
\13\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Despite backlogs in many jurisdictions, some states are
working to reduce the time it takes to test rape kits while
improving transparency for victims by implementing tracking
systems. These systems allow victims to follow the progress and
forensic path of their rape kit.\14\ Advocates argue that
tracking systems provide increased accountability and
transparency, which will in turn speed up a case to
resolution.\15\ At least 40 states and the District of Columbia
have implemented or committed to establishing a sexual assault
kit tracking system in the past nine years.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Amanda Hernandez, Sexual assault survivors can now track their
rape kits in most states, The 19th News (Sept. 12, 2023), https://
19thnews.org/2023/09/sexual-assault-survivors-tracking-rape-kits/.
\15\Addressing the Rape Kit Backlog, RAINN, https://www.rainn.org/
articles/addressing-rape-kit-backlog (last visited Sept. 21, 2023).
\16\Most States Commit To Improve Rape Kit Tracking; 60k Untested,
National Criminal Justice Association (Sept. 8, 2023), https://
www.ncja.org/crimeandjusticenews/most-states-commit-to-improve-rape-
kit-tracking-60k-untested.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6)(A) of House rule XIII,
the Committee states that no hearings were held to assist in
the formulation of H.R. 5721.
Committee Consideration
On September 28, 2023, the Committee met in open session
and ordered the bill, H.R. 5721, favorably reported with an
amendment in the nature of a substitute, by a roll call vote of
26-0, a quorum being present.
Committee Votes
In compliance with clause 3(b) of House rule XIII, the
following roll call votes occurred during the Committee's
consideration of H.R. 5721:
1. Vote on favorably reporting H.R. 5721, as amended--
passed 26 ayes to 0 nays.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Committee Oversight Findings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee advises that the findings and recommendations of the
Committee, based on oversight activities under clause 2(b)(1)
of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives, are
incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and section
308(a) of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 and with respect
to the requirements of clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives and section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the Committee has requested
but not received a cost estimate for this bill from the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office. The Committee has
requested but not received from the Director of the
Congressional Budget Office a statement as to whether this bill
contains any new budget authority, spending authority, credit
authority, or an increase or decrease in revenues or tax
expenditures. The Chairman of the Committee shall cause such
estimate and statement to be printed in the Congressional
Record upon its receipt by the Committee.
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate
With respect to the requirement of clause 3(c)(3) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, a cost
estimate provided by the Congressional Budget Office pursuant
to section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 was not
made available to the Committee in time for the filing of this
report. The Chairman of the Committee shall cause such estimate
to be printed in the Congressional Record upon its receipt by
the Committee.
Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(d)(1) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section
402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII, no provision
of H.R. 5721 establishes or reauthorizes a program of the
federal government known to be duplicative of another federal
program.
Performance Goals and Objectives
The Committee states that pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of
House rule XIII, H.R. 5721 amends the Omnibus Crime Control and
Safe Streets Act of 1968 to require certain grant applicants
and recipients to report to the Attorney General on whether
they have taken steps to inventory, audit, and track sexual
assault kits and their testing.
Advisory on Earmarks
In accordance with clause 9 of House rule XXI, H.R. 5721
does not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in clauses
9(d), 9(e), or 9(f) of House rule XXI.
Federal Mandates Statement
An estimate of federal mandates prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget office pursuant to section 423 of the
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act was not made available to the
Committee in time for the filing of this report. The Chairman
of the Committee shall cause such estimate to be printed in the
Congressional Record upon its receipt by the Committee.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act (Pub. L. 104-
1).
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1: Short Title. ``Rape Kit Backlog Progress Act of
2023.''
Section 2: Findings. This section makes a series of
findings pertaining to sexual assault kits and the testing
backlog, including what is included in a sexual assault kit,
that there are an estimated 100,000 untested kits across the
country, and that untested kits allows criminals to evade
prosecution.
Section 3: Report to Attorney General Required on Sexual
Assault Kit Testing. This section amends Section 502 of the
Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act of 1968 to require a
report on whether state and local governments have conducted a
comprehensive backlog sexual assault kit inventory to identify
the location, whether it has been tested, and/or any tracking
information otherwise transmitted to state/local governments
for the purpose of testing, storing, processing, or handling.
This section also requires the report to include whether
the state or local government has submitted each sexual assault
kit for DNA analysis, whether the results were uploaded to
CODIS, whether the state or local government has developed a
tracking system and victim notification protocol, whether the
state or local government has in place a comprehensive
inventory system to locate and track sexual assault kits, and
how often a state or local governments inventory system is
updated.
This section further requires the Attorney General to
determine whether a state or local government has complied with
the reporting requirements and makes only those state or local
governments that have complied eligible for a grant. A state or
local government that has been awarded a grant prior to the
date of enactment of this bill will have one year to comply
with the new reporting requirements, or will become ineligible
for the grant.
This section also defines ``sexual assault kit'' and
``sexual assault kit status.''
Section 4: Attorney General Public Report on Rape Kit
Backlogs. This section states that beginning not later than two
years after the bill's enactment and annually thereafter, the
Attorney General must publish a report containing: (1) each
report on the required conduct by a state or local government
grant applicant; (2) an aggregate analysis of each of the
reports; (3) whether the grant applicant was awarded a grant;
and (4) if the grant applicant completed the required conduct
as described above, or a reason why the conduct has not been
completed. This section also requires the Attorney General to
ensure that the report does not contain the personally
identifiable information of a victim.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (new matter is
printed in italics, and existing law in which no change is
proposed is shown in roman):
OMNIBUS CRIME CONTROL AND
SAFE STREETS ACT OF 1968
* * * * * * *
TITLE I--JUSTICE SYSTEM IMPROVEMENT
* * * * * * *
Part E--Bureau of Justice Assistance Grant Programs
Subpart 1--Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant Program
* * * * * * *
SEC. 502. APPLICATIONS.
(a) In General.--To request a grant under this subpart, the
chief executive officer of a State or unit of local government
shall submit an application to the Attorney General within 120
days after the date on which funds to carry out this subpart
are appropriated for a fiscal year, in such form as the
Attorney General may require. Such application shall include
the following:
(1) A certification that Federal funds made available
under this subpart will not be used to supplant State
or local funds, but will be used to increase the
amounts of such funds that would, in the absence of
Federal funds, be made available for law enforcement
activities.
(2) An assurance that, not fewer than 30 days before
the application (or any amendment to the application)
was submitted to the Attorney General, the application
(or amendment) was submitted for review to the
governing body of the State or unit of local government
(or to an organization designated by that governing
body).
(3) An assurance that, before the application (or any
amendment to the application) was submitted to the
Attorney General--
(A) the application (or amendment) was made
public; and
(B) an opportunity to comment on the
application (or amendment) was provided to
citizens and to neighborhood or community-based
organizations, to the extent applicable law or
established procedure makes such an opportunity
available.
(4) An assurance that, for each fiscal year covered
by an application, the applicant shall maintain and
report such data, records, and information
(programmatic and financial) as the Attorney General
may reasonably require.
(5) A certification, made in a form acceptable to the
Attorney General and executed by the chief executive
officer of the applicant (or by another officer of the
applicant, if qualified under regulations promulgated
by the Attorney General), that--
(A) the programs to be funded by the grant
meet all the requirements of this subpart;
(B) all the information contained in the
application is correct;
(C) there has been appropriate coordination
with affected agencies; and
(D) the applicant will comply with all
provisions of this subpart and all other
applicable Federal laws.
(6) A comprehensive Statewide plan detailing how
grants received under this section will be used to
improve the administration of the criminal justice
system, which shall--
(A) be designed in consultation with local
governments, and representatives of all
segments of the criminal justice system,
including judges, prosecutors, law enforcement
personnel, corrections personnel, and providers
of indigent defense services, victim services,
juvenile justice delinquency prevention
programs, community corrections, and reentry
services;
(B) include a description of how the State
will allocate funding within and among each of
the uses described in subparagraphs (A) through
(G) of section 501(a)(1);
(C) describe the process used by the State
for gathering evidence-based data and
developing and using evidence-based and
evidence-gathering approaches in support of
funding decisions;
(D) describe the barriers at the State and
local level for accessing data and implementing
evidence-based approaches to preventing and
reducing crime and recidivism; and
(E) be updated every 5 years, with annual
progress reports that--
(i) address changing circumstances in
the State, if any;
(ii) describe how the State plans to
adjust funding within and among each of
the uses described in subparagraphs (A)
through (G) of section 501(a)(1);
(iii) provide an ongoing assessment
of need;
(iv) discuss the accomplishment of
goals identified in any plan previously
prepared under this paragraph; and
(v) reflect how the plan influenced
funding decisions in the previous year.
(7) A report indicating whether--
(A) the State or unit of local government has
conducted a comprehensive sexual assault kit
inventory, commonly known as a `backlog
inventory', to identify the physical location,
untested or tested status (or full sexual
assault kit status, if available), and any
individual test kit identification or tracking
information of each sexual assault kit in the
possession of such State or unit of local
government, or that has been otherwise
transmitted by a State or unit of local
government to a third-party, such as for
testing, storing, processing, or handling;
(B) with respect to each sexual assault kit
that the victim has consented to have
collected, the State or unit of local
government has submitted each such sexual
assault kit to a laboratory for DNA analysis;
(C) results of any such DNA analysis were
uploaded to the Combined DNA Index System;
(D) the State or unit of local government has
established an electronic tracking system for a
victim to identify the physical location of
their sexual assault kit and the results of any
DNA analysis that was performed;
(E) the State or unit of local government has
established a victim notification protocol for
informing a victim of the status of their
sexual assault kit, including where their
sexual assault kit was analyzed;
(F) the State or unit of local government has
in place a comprehensive sexual assault kit
inventory system to identify sexual assault kit
status, physical location, and any test kit
identification or tracking information of each
sexual assault kit in the possession of such
State or unit of local government, or otherwise
transmitted by a State or unit of local
government to a third-party, such as for
testing, storing, processing, or handling; and
(G) the information in any comprehensive
sexual assault kit inventory system described
in subparagraph (F) is updated, and how and
when it is updated.
(b) Technical Assistance.--
(1) Strategic planning.--Not later than 90 days after
the date of enactment of this subsection, the Attorney
General shall begin to provide technical assistance to
States and local governments requesting support to
develop and implement the strategic plan required under
subsection (a)(6). The Attorney General may enter into
agreements with 1 or more non-governmental
organizations to provide technical assistance and
training under this paragraph.
(2) Protection of constitutional rights.--Not later
than 90 days after the date of enactment of this
subsection, the Attorney General shall begin to provide
technical assistance to States and local governments,
including any agent thereof with responsibility for
administration of justice, requesting support to meet
the obligations established by the Sixth Amendment to
the Constitution of the United States, which shall
include--
(A) public dissemination of practices,
structures, or models for the administration of
justice consistent with the requirements of the
Sixth Amendment; and
(B) assistance with adopting and implementing
a system for the administration of justice
consistent with the requirements of the Sixth
Amendment.
(3) Authorization of appropriations.--For each of
fiscal years 2017 through 2021, of the amounts
appropriated to carry out this subpart, not less than
$5,000,000 and not more than $10,000,000 shall be used
to carry out this subsection.
(c) Determination by Attorney General.-- Between the receipt
of a grant application and deciding on such application, the
Attorney General shall determine--
(1) if the State or unit of local government has
completed the conduct described under subsection
(a)(7); and
(2) if such conduct has not been completed, the
reason that it has not been completed.
(d) Eligibility.--A State or unit or local government shall
only be eligible for a grant under this subpart if the Attorney
General determines such State or unit of local government has
completed the conduct described under subsection (a)(7).
(e) Requirement for Grant Recipients.--A State or unit of
local government that has been awarded a grant under this
subpart as of the date of the enactment of the ``Rape Kit
Backlog Progress Act of 2023'' shall have one calendar year
from such date of enactment to complete the conduct described
in subsection (a)(7) or such State or unit of local government
shall become ineligible for a grant under this subpart.
(g) Definitions.--In this section:
(1) Sexual assault kit.--The term ``sexual assault
kit'' means evidence gathered by a medical professional
from a victim following a sexual assault, which
evidence may--
(A) include swabs, test tubes, microscopic
slides, and evidence collection envelopes, for
hairs and fibers; and
(B) vary in accordance with the circumstances
of the sexual assault and with any applicable
rules or procedures of the jurisdiction.
(2) Sexual assault kit status.--The term ``sexual
assault kit status'' means whether an individual sexual
assault kit is--
(A) collected and untested;
(B) collected and tested;
(C) lost or missing, expired or spoiled; or
(D) tested and results reported to the
victim, proper authorities, and the Combined
DNA Index System.
* * * * * * *
SEC. 510. ATTORNEY GENERAL PUBLIC REPORT ON RAPE KIT BACKLOGS.
(a) In General.--Beginning not later than two years after the
date of the enactment of the ``Rape Kit Backlog Progress Act of
2023'', and annually thereafter, the Attorney General shall
make publicly available on the internet website of the
Department of Justice a report, including--
(1) each report on the conduct described under
section 502(a)(7) received from an applicant for a
grant under this subpart;
(2) an aggregate analysis of the reports described
under paragraph (1);
(3) if an applicant for a grant under this subpart
has been awarded a grant; and
(4) if an applicant for a grant under this subpart
completed the conduct described under section 502(a)(7)
and if it has not completed the conduct described under
such subsection, the reason that the conduct has not
been completed.
(b) Prohibition on Personally Identifiable Information.--Any
information published by the Attorney General pursuant to this
section may not contain the personally identifiable information
of a victim and if such information was erroneously published,
it shall be removed from the website of the Department of
Justice immediately upon discovery.
* * * * * * *
Additional Views
I provide these additional views in support of the
favorable reporting of H.R. 5721, the Rape Kit Backlog Progress
Act of 2023. The bill would require state and local governments
that receive or apply for Byrne JAG funding to meet certain
reporting requirements, including whether they have conducted a
comprehensive inventory of rape kits in their possession, if
results of DNA analyses have been uploaded into the Combined
DNA Index System (CODIS), and whether they have developed an
electronic tracking system and a notification protocol for
victims.
For these reasons and those explained below, I support the
overall intent and purposes of the bill. However, I
respectfully urge our colleagues to recognize that the
imposition of a penalty that renders such governments entirely
ineligible to receive or apply for Byrne JAG awards is
misplaced and ineffective to incentivize compliance with
unrelated reporting requirements meant to provide greater
insight into the national rape kit backlog.
OVERVIEW
A. Rape Kits and the Rape Kit Backlog
DNA technology is a powerful tool that helps law
enforcement professionals solve and prevent crime. Testing
sexual assault examination kits (also referred to as rape kits)
can yield evidence in the form of a DNA profile, which can be
entered into local, state, and national databases containing
DNA from offenders. This evidence can identify an unknown
assailant, reveal serial offenders by connecting different
crimes together, and exonerate the wrongfully convicted.
For nearly two decades, increased attention has been paid
to DNA backlogs in cases involving sexual assault (often
referred to as the rape kit backlog) that exist across the
country.\1\ According to the National Institute of Justice
(NIJ), rape kits are typically considered backlogged if they
are either in the possession of law enforcement and have never
been submitted to a laboratory for testing or they have been
submitted to a crime laboratory but remain untested after 30
days.\2\ Research suggests the latter case--of untested rape
kits at a lab--is more common. The definition used for a
backlog can also vary across jurisdictions, for example by the
number of days required or submission status (i.e., whether the
kit is in the lab awaiting a test or unsubmitted to a lab). But
the binding element across all definitions regardless of
location or days counted is that the kits remain untested. The
rape kit backlog is a national problem among all 50 states and
territories.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Pinchevsky, G.M., Criminal Justice Considerations for
Unsubmitted and Untested Sexual Assault Kits: A Review of the
Literature and Suggestions for Moving Forward, Criminal Justice Policy
Review, vol. 29, no. 9 (2018).
\2\National Institute of Justice, Sexual Assault Kits: Using
Science to Find Solutions, https://www.nij.gov/unsubmittedkits/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rape kits may remain untested for various reasons such as
limited resources in crime laboratories, as well as law
enforcement and police discretion. Law enforcement may opt not
to pursue a forensic investigation for a variety of reasons,
including the perception of victim cooperation or a decision
that the results of testing the kit would not be pertinent to
the overall investigation. Regardless of the reasons for not
testing rape kits, the backlog of untested rape kits has raised
concerns that the cases attached to the untested kits are not
being fully investigated and that evidence in untested kits
could have been used to prevent other crimes.
Failure to process these kits could mean missed
opportunities to identify perpetrators, bring them to justice,
and prevent further victimization. The results from four
studies funded by the NIJ indicated that 25%-50% of tested rape
kits generated CODIS-eligible DNA profiles and 50%-60% of those
CODIS profiles resulted in a hit.\3\ Many perpetrators of rape
are serial criminals. Approximately 37% have been found to have
committed at least one previous felony, and DNA in rape kits
can connect crimes together. The failure to submit rape kits
for testing also decreases community trust in law enforcement.
Survivors from Houston to Memphis have filed class action
lawsuits against city officials for their rape kit backlogs,
asserting that timely testing of rape kits could have prevented
their own or others' sexual assaults. Other experts have
pointed out that testing the backlog may also help address
wrongful convictions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Pinchevsky, G.M., Criminal Justice Considerations for
Unsubmitted and Untested Sexual Assault Kits: A Review of the
Literature and Suggestions for Moving Forward, Criminal Justice Policy
Review, vol. 29, no. 9 (2018).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Congressional Efforts to Address the Rape Kit Backlog
There are several federal grants to address rape kit
availability, analysis, and the rape kit backlog. The bulk of
these programs focus on assisting state and local law
enforcement and crime labs to address their backlogs or fund
research about the backlog. These grants include the Sexual
Assault Forensic Exam Program, the Sexual Assault Kit
Initiative, and the largest of the grant programs, the Debbie
Smith DNA Backlog Grant Program, as well as several grants
authorized in the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA).
Since its enactment in 2004, the Debbie Smith Act has been
renewed three times (2008, 2014, 2019) with overwhelming
bipartisan support. While the Debbie Smith Act was authorized
to provide up to $151 million in funding per year through
Fiscal Year 2019, Congress appropriated just $117 million in FY
2015. The Debbie Smith Reauthorization Act of 2019 (P.L. 116-
104) reauthorized the program again at $151 million per fiscal
year through FY 2024. For FY 2021, Congress appropriated $110
million for the Debbie Smith program.
Despite the expenditure of millions of dollars in grant
funding over the last twenty years, the national rape kit
backlog persists. According to the sponsors of the Rape Kit
Backlog Progress Act, there are fifteen states with more than
one thousand untested kits and eight states with no reporting
whatsoever. In co-lead Representative Nancy Mace's state of
South Carolina, there are reportedly over one thousand untested
DNA rape kits and more than 13,000 in California, the state of
co-lead, Representative Barbara Lee. A 2022 analysis by
USAFacts found that Maryland had 3,599 backlogged rape kits in
law enforcement agencies, while North Carolina had 9,045
backlogged rape kits in crime labs.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\USAFacts, How many rape kits are awaiting testing in the U.S.?
See the data by state, https://usafacts.org/articles/how-many-rape-
kits-are-awaiting-testing-in-the-us-see-the-data-by-state/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
C. The Need for Better Data to Assess the Magnitude of the Rape Kit
Backlog
The exact number of untested kits is unknown since many
jurisdictions do not have systems for counting or tracking rape
kits nor is there is a national system for collecting or
tracking rape kits. There is also no federal law mandating the
tracking or testing of rape kits, nor a federal reporting
requirement of any kind. In the absence of more precise data,
many researchers and advocacy organizations have attempted to
estimate the size of the backlog. A 2018 NIJ-funded study
estimated that 200,000 rape kits remained untested in the
custody of police departments.\5\ Although the number has
dwindled since that time, there are still nearly 100,000
untested rape kits piled up in law enforcement facilities and
crime labs across the country, according to some reports.
Another study published in 2021 used data collected from 911
counties in 15 states to generate a national estimate of
300,000 to 400,000 unsubmitted rape kits between 2014 and
2018.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Campbell, R. et al., Tested at Last: How DNA Evidence in
Untested Rape Kits Can Identify Offenders and Serial Sexual Assaults,
Journal of Interpersonal Violence, vol. 33, no. 24 (2018).
\6\Strom, K. et al., How much justice is denied? An estimate of
unsubmitted sexual assault kits in the United States, Journal Of
Criminal Justice, Volume 73 (2021).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Joyful Heart Foundation, a national organization that
advocates on behalf of sexual assault victims, is attempting to
address the lack of complete and timely data by counting the
rape kit backlog through public records requests and tracking
data in cities and states across the country.\7\ As of January
2022, the organization had uncovered more than 52,000 untested
kits in 67 jurisdictions in 29 states, and it estimates that
there are still 400,000 untested rape kits yet to be
discovered.\8\ Joyful Heart has most recently documented nearly
90,000 untested kits in 37 states and Washington, DC.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\See The Joyful Heart Foundation, State of the Backlog, https://
www.endthebacklog.org/state-of-the-backlog/.
\8\Id.
\9\The Joyful Heart Foundation, State of the Backlog, https://
www.endthebacklog.org/state-of-the-backlog/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
D. The Rape Kit Backlog Progress Act of 2023
H.R. 5721, the Rape Kit Backlog Progress Act of 2023, would
impose reporting requirements on states and local governments
to provide greater insight into the national rape kit
backlog.\10\ The bill would require all governments that
receive Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (Byrne
JAG) funding to report the following: whether a comprehensive
inventory of rape kits in their possession has been conducted;
whether the kits have been submitted to a laboratory for DNA
analysis; whether results of any analysis have been uploaded to
the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS); whether an electronic
tracking system for victims to identify the location of their
kits and the results of any DNA analysis has been established;
whether a victim notification protocol to inform victims of the
status of their kits has been established; whether there is a
comprehensive rape kit inventory system to identify the status,
physical location, and identification or tracking of any kit;
and whether the information in the inventory is updated, and
how and when the information is updated. The Attorney General
would be responsible for determining whether these requirements
have been met by Byrne JAG Program applicants and recipients.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Pursuant to 34 U.S.C. Sec. 10251, ``unit of local government''
means any city, county, township, town, borough, parish, village, or
other general purpose political subdivision of a state; any law
enforcement district or judicial enforcement district that meet various
requirements; an Indian Tribe; the District of Columbia; or territory.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Act does not provide new funding, but it conditions
eligibility for Byrne JAG funds on fulfillment of the reporting
requirements outlined in the bill. Administered by the Bureau
of Justice Assistance (BJA), the Byrne JAG Program is the
leading source of criminal justice funding to state and local
jurisdictions. Since FY 2005, BJA has funded over 24,000 direct
Byrne JAG awards, totaling more than $7.6 billion. As the bill
is currently written, failure to comply with the reporting
requirements would render any applicant ineligible to apply for
a Byrne JAG grant. And any recipient of such funds that fails
to meet the reporting requirements within one year of enactment
of the bill would become ineligible for a Byrne JAG grant.
The Byrne JAG Program provides states, territories, tribes,
and local governments with critical funding necessary to
support a range of program areas including: law enforcement;
prosecution and courts; prevention and education; corrections
and community corrections, including reentry; drug treatment
and enforcement; planning, evaluation, and technology
improvement; crime victim and witness initiatives; mental
health programs and related law enforcement and corrections
programs, including behavioral programs and crisis intervention
teams; and implementation of state crisis intervention court
proceedings and related programs or initiatives, including
mental health courts, drug courts, veterans courts, and extreme
risk protection order programs.
Each year, BJA includes areas of emphasis in the Byrne JAG
program solicitations, encouraging state and local award
recipients to consider coordination with federal law
enforcement agencies and other stakeholders, including
communities most impacted by crime and violence, in addressing
these challenges. For FY 2023, the Byrne JAG areas of emphasis
were: advancing justice system reform efforts; advancing racial
equity and support for underserved communities; preventing and
combating hate crimes; crime and violence reduction strategies;
and community-based violence intervention approaches.
CONCERNS
Without the constitutional authority to require changes to
state and local law, Congress has limited tools to incentivize
state and local governments to adopt certain policies and
practices. Legislation is often proposed that conditions
federal grant program eligibility, such as the Byrne JAG
program, as penalty for noncompliance with certain federally
endorsed practices. At present, there are only three statutory
penalty provisions that could trigger the loss of up to 25% of
a state's Byrne JAG award, though new bills with penalty
provisions are introduced regularly, e.g., H.R. 5721, the Rape
Kit Backlog Progress Act of 2023.
Many stakeholder groups with varying interests, including
the Major Cities Chiefs of America and the National Criminal
Justice Association, have long opposed grant penalties in
legislation. These groups argue that grant incentives rather
than penalties are more appropriate to accomplish the intended
goals of the bill. Penalties have proven ineffective in
incentivizing or encouraging action by governments or agencies
within governments, particularly when the cost of compliance--
whether financially or politically--is greater than the loss of
funding. One such example is the Sex Offender Registration and
Notification Act (SORNA), which passed in 2006 and imposes a
10% penalty on Byrne JAG grants. Seventeen years later, fewer
than twenty states have met all the requirements of the Act.
The remaining states forfeit the penalty each year because the
financial cost and political impact of the change in policy are
considered prohibitive.
According to these stakeholders, the penalties imposed in
this legislation on Byrne JAG grant awards are unlikely to
induce compliance by states and local governments. In 2008 and
2010, funding for Byrne JAG decreased dramatically. While
appropriations are slowly restoring the losses in funding,
current funding remains far too low to compel compliance with
any mandate that is determined by localities to be costly,
time-consuming, or complicated. In 2015, state and local
governments spent $226 billion on justice system services,
compared to $319 million in Byrne JAG awards. Currently, Byrne
JAG contributes less than one-quarter of one percent (0.22%) of
state and local governments' own expenditures for policing
services, underscoring the ineffectiveness of these grant
funding penalties as incentives for promoting compliance.
Meanwhile, additional funding is critical at this time given
the burdens state laboratories have faced as their workloads
have increased in response to the rise in violent crime.
Furthermore, the threat of a penalty on grant awards provides
no leverage over most local law enforcement agencies, as fewer
than 1,500 of the nation's 18,000 local law enforcement
agencies receive any Byrne JAG funds. While there are indeed
crime labs that receive Byrne JAG funds, not all crime labs in
all states receive these funds since there are other federal
grants that provide support for forensic activities.
Stakeholders have also pointed out that conditioning these
grants often produces unintended consequences, such as
impacting law enforcement's ability to conduct investigations
and promote public safety. States and local governments could
be forced to suddenly terminate funding for hundreds of Byrne
JAG-funded programs operating in communities across the country
for noncompliance with an unrelated mandate.
Stakeholders representing law enforcement and criminal
justice-related agencies, including the Consortium of Forensic
Science Organizations, have also voiced specific concerns about
the reporting requirements that would be imposed by H.R. 5721
and the penalties that would result if the requirements were
not met. First, failure to comply with the reporting
requirements would result in the loss of 100% of a Byrne JAG
grant award. This could have a devastating impact on many
states, tribes, territories, and local communities given that
the Byrne JAG Program is the primary source of federal justice
funding and the wide range of public safety applications the
funding supports. As a result, the impact of the penalty would
stretch far beyond issues related to rape kits. Second, a 100%
penalty is too severe and inconsistent with other existing
penalties imposed on grant awards. As previously mentioned,
SORNA imposes a penalty of 10% on Byrne JAG funding, while the
Prison Rape Elimination Act provides for a 5% penalty, and the
Death in Custody Reporting Act imposes a discretionary 10%
penalty.
Third, a large portion of Byrne JAG funding passes from
states to local jurisdictions from a single grant award. Due to
the 100% penalty imposed by the bill, several agencies could
lose vital funding if their state or local government, or a
single agency within that state or local government, fails to
comply with the bill's reporting requirements. Fourth, the
reporting requirements are burdensome and would require
additional resources to comply with them while offering no
flexibility for those entities in the process of complying,
failing to consider (or conflicting with) existing protocols
for testing, analyzing, and tracking rape kits, and possibly
violating existing federal law.
For instance, a review and analysis of whether individual
rape kits have been submitted to a lab for DNA analysis and
whether those results have been uploaded to CODIS would require
data from every law enforcement agency and crime lab in the
state or local government. Each of the stakeholder groups
stressed the enormity of such an undertaking. Further
complicating the ability of state and local governments to
collect this data--particularly within one year--rape kits are
sometimes held in the possession of the hospitals where
forensic sexual exams take place. This was pointed out by the
American Society of Crime Lab Directors, an organization among
the CSFO, that also contends that much of the data sought in
this bill already exists, emphasizing the need to c