Minority Views
This resolution would nullify the Consumer Financial
Protection Bureau's (CFPB) recently finalized small business
lending rule, implementing Section 1071 of the Dodd-Frank Wall
Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank). Section
1071 was led by Ranking Member Waters and Rep. Velazquez. The
CFPB rule implementing this section seeks to: provide
transparency in an opaque lending marketplace; promote
competition among lenders that would drive down costs; and
provide new lending opportunities for small businesses,
especially women-owned, LGBTQ-owned businesses and businesses
owned by people of color. The passage of this Congressional
Review Act resolution would not only reverse this rule, it
would further restrict the CFPB's ability to issue any future
rules to promote small business lending market transparency.
The CFPB finalized its rule implementing Section 1071 in
March 2023.\1\ The rule requires lenders to collect and report
information about the small business credit applications they
receive, including geographic and demographic data (that's
self-reported by business owners on a voluntary basis), lending
decisions, and the price of credit. The rule will work in
tandem with the Community Reinvestment Act, which requires
certain financial institutions to meet the needs of the
communities they serve. The increased transparency will benefit
small businesses, family farms, financial institutions, and the
broader economy. Since its finalization, Section 1071 has come
under attack in both district courts and Congress. In May 2023,
plaintiffs filed a lawsuit in a Texas federal district court
challenging the validity of the rule and a motion seeking a
preliminary injunction.\2\ Community lenders and small business
advocates alike have underlined the importance of CFPB's small
lending rules to creating a more transparent and fair
marketplace for lenders and small businesses.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\CFPB, Small business lending rulemaking (Accessed June 8, 2023).
\2\John L. Culhane, Jr., Richard J. Andreano, Jr. & Michael Gordon,
Plaintiffs challenging Section 1071 final rule seek preliminary
injunction; Ballard Spahr to hold June 15 webinar, Ballard Spahr
(accessed Jun, 8, 2023).
\3\Accion Opportunity Fund, CEO Luz Urrutia's Congressional
Testimony on Lending Transparency (Mar. 2023); and NCRC, NCRC and Over
150 Organizations Unite in Support of Section 1071 of Dodd-Frank,
Rejecting Congressional Repeal Efforts (Jul. 25, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The CFPB's 1071 rule is expected to result in increased
lending to underserved businesses, including farms, as was
observed in the implementation of similar sunshine statutes
like the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA). HMDA data has
helped regulators to identify discriminatory practices, like
modern-day redlining. Congress drafted Section 1071 of Dodd-
Frank following the 2008 financial crisis to provide similar
transparency to the small business lending market. In the early
days of the pandemic, we saw how the biggest banks prioritized
their concierge clients in the first round of the Paycheck
Protection Program (PPP), leaving millions of small businesses,
especially those owned by women and people of color, out of the
program. Recent research from the Fed found that Black-owned
small businesses were 9% less likely to receive a PPP loan
compared to White-owned firms. Make no mistake, if we had this
CFPB small business data rule in place before the pandemic, we
would have had much more data on who was receiving support and
who wasn't, and who was lending to diverse small businesses and
who wasn't. Going forward, Congress would be better positioned
and equipped with data to craft legislation to more fairly
support small business lending.
CFPB's 1071 rule is an important step towards transparency
and fairness in small business lending. We appreciate that the
CFPB is phasing this rule in, giving community banks and credit
unions adequate time to prepare to comply with the rule. The
arguments that this rule will stop small business lending are a
red herring. Again, financial institutions have complied with
HMDA for decades, and yet they continue to make mortgage loans.
Greater transparency will promote competition and ensure that
all businesses have a fair chance to thrive. We must protect
the financial needs of small businesses and hold financial
institutions accountable for their lending practices.
During the markup, Rep. Casten opened a parliamentary
inquiry about the resolution and noted that this resolution
does not comply with typical Congressional Review Act
procedures for fast-track consideration in the Senate because
H.J. Res. 66 was introduced on May 31st, but the papers for the
rule that it seeks to overturn was not referred to the Senate
Banking Committee until June 12th. According to information
staff received from the Senate Parliamentarian's office and
Congressional Research Service, even if the House were to pass
H.J. Res. 66, the Senate would be unable to take up the measure
under fast-track consideration. While we strongly oppose this
measure, it would add insult to injury for the House to take
valuable floor time to pass H.J. Res. 66, only to have to take
additional floor time to pass a different measure approved by
the Senate for the measure to advance to the President's desk.
Finally, more than 150 organizations oppose H.J. Res. 66,
including: National Community Reinvestment Coalition (NCRC),
20/20 Vision, Access Plus Capital, Accountable.US, African
American Alliance of CDFI CEOs, Alliance 85, Inc., American
Economic Liberties Project, Americans for Financial Reform,
Anacostia Economic Development Corporation, ANHD--The,
Association for Neighborhood & Housing Development, Avenue CDC,
BBIF, Inc., Birmingham Business Resource Center, Bridgeport
Neighborhood Trust, Brotherhood and Sisterhood International,
Building Alabama Reinvestment, CAARMA, California Capital,
Financial Development Corporation, California Community
Economic Development Association, CAMEO--California Association
for Micro Enterprise Opportunity, Camino Financial, Inc., CASA
of Oregon, Cash Community Development Organization, Catapult
Pittsburgh, Catholic charities usa, CDC Small Business Finance,
Ceiba, Center for Responsible Lending, Centre for Homeownership
& Economic Development Corporation, Centro Cultural, Chicago
Community Loan Fund, CHWC Inc., City of Gary, IN, City of
Tampa, CLARIFI, Coalition for Non Profit Housing and Economic
Development, Coastal Enterprises, Inc., Community Enterprise
Investments, Inc., Community Growth Fund, Community Housing
Development Corporation, Community Link, Community Reinvestment
Alliance of South Florida, Consumer Action, Consumer Federation
of America, Delaware Community Reinvestment Action Council,
Inc., Demand Progress, Divine Direction, Economic Action
Maryland, Economic Growth Corporation, Empire Justice Center,
ExploreUSTV and Travel, Fair Finance Watch, Fair Housing Center
of Metropolitan Detroit, Fair Housing Center of Southwest
Michigan, Famicos Foundation, Family Resources of New Orleans,
FHCNA, First Community Capital, Frayser Community Development
Corporation, Gen-Wealth Empowerment, Georgia Advancing
Communities Together, Inc., Greater Cincinnati Microenterprise
Initiative, Habitat For Humanity of Michigan, Hawai`i Alliance
for Community-Based Economic Development, HEAL Food Alliance,
Henderson and Company, Home Ownership Center of Greater
Cincinnati, Homes on the Hill, CDC, Housing and Education
Alliance, Inc. (HEA), Housing, Education and Economic
Development, Housing Justice Center, Housing Options & Planning
Enterprises, Inc., HousingWorks RI, I Give Back USA, IGNITE!
Alabama, Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility, Jewish
Community Action, JOVIS, Latino Economic Development Center,
Latino Leadership Council, Latino Policy Council, Legacy
Foundation, Legal Aid Society of San Diego, LINC UP Nonprofit
Housing Corporation, Local First Arizona, Local Initiatives
Support Corporation (LISC), Logan Heights Community Development
Corporation, Main Street Alliance, Massachusetts Action for
Justice, Massachusetts Affordable Housing Alliance, Memorial
CDC, Metro Milwaukee Fair Housing Council, Metro North
Community Development Corporation, Metropolitan Milwaukee Fair
Housing Council, Metropolitan St. Louis Equal Housing and
Opportunity Council, MS Communities United for Prosperity
(MCUP), MY Project USA, National Association for Latino
Community Asset Builders, National Association of American
Veterans, Inc., National Coalition for Asian Pacific American
Community Development (National CAPACD), Native Community
Capital, National NeighborWorks Association, National Urban
League, NCRC CDF, Neighborhood Improvement Association,
NeighborWorks Southern Colorado, New Future Foundation, New
Hope Community Development, New Jersey Citizen Action, New
Jersey Institute for Social Justice, New Mexico Community
Capital, New York StateWide Senior Action Council, Nichols
Temple AME Ministries, North Carolina Housing Coalition, Inc.,
Northwest Indiana Reinvestment Alliance, Olive Hill Community
Economic Development Corporation, Inc, Opportunity Finance
Network, Over-the-Rhine Community Housing, Philadelphia
Association of Community Development Corporations, Pima County
Community Land Trust, Pittsburgh Community Reinvestment Group,
Prosperity Indiana, Public Citizen, Public Good Law Center,
REBOUND, Inc., Reinvestment Partners, Responsible Business
Lending Coalition, Revolving Door Project, Rise Economy, River
Cities Development Services, River City Housing, Inc.,
Roosevelt, Southwest Community Development Corporation, San
Joaquin Valley Housing Collaborative, SaverLife, Self-Help
Enterprises, SLEHCRA, Small Business Majority, South Dallas
Fair Park Innercity Community Development Corporation, South
Florida Community Development Coalition, Southern Dallas
Progress Community Development Corporation, Southwest CDC,
Southwest Economic Solutions, Southwest Georgia United,
Southwest Neighborhood Housing Services, The Food Trust, The
Greenlining Institute, The National Council of Asian Pacific
Americans (NCAPA), The Sacramento Environmental Justice
Coalition, Tierra del Sol Housing Corporation, Town of Apex,
Ubuntu Institute of Learning, UIC Law School, Universal Housing
Solutions CDC, Urban Economic Development Association of
Wisconsin (UEDA), Urban Land Conservancy, Utah Housing
Coalition, Vermont Slauson LDC, Washington Area Community
Investment Fund, Welfare Reform Liaison Project, Inc.,
Wisconsin Black Chamber of Commerce, Inc, With Action,
Woodstock Institute, Working In Neighborhoods, and Working
Solutions CDFI.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\NCRC, NCRC and Over 150 Organizations Unite in Support of
Section 1071 of Dodd-Frank, Rejecting Congressional Repeal Efforts
(Jul. 25, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons, we oppose H.J. Res. 66.
Sincerely,
Maxine Waters,
Ranking Member, Committee on
Financial Services.
Nydia M. Velazquez.
Brad Sherman.
Gregory W. Meeks.
David Scott.
Stephen F. Lynch.
Al Green.
Emanuel Cleaver, II.
Jim Himes.
Bill Foster.
Joyce Beatty.
Juan Vargas.
Vicente Gonzalez.
Sean Casten.
Ayanna Pressley.
Rashida Tlaib.
Sylvia R. Garcia.
Nikema Williams.
Brittany Pettersen.