Dissenting Views
CONTENTS
Page
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND............................................1
A. Purpose and Summary................................. 1
B. Background on The Committee's Jurisdiction and
Statutory Authority................................ 3
C. Background on The Committee's Work.................. 4
II. EXPLANATION OF THE SUBMITTED MATERIALS............................6
A. Background on the Submitted Materials............... 6
B. Description of the Submitted Materials.............. 7
C. Description of Committee Redactions................. 7
III.VOTES OF THE COMMITTEE............................................9
IV. DISSENTING VIEWS.................................................11
ATTACHMENT A--COMMITTEE ON WAYS AND MEANS EXECUTIVE SESSION
TRANSCRIPT--SEPTEMBER 27, 2023................................. 15
I. SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND
A. Purpose and Summary
The Committee on Ways and Means (``Committee'') met in
closed executive session on September 27, 2023, to consider
materials protected by 26 U.S.C. Sec. 6103 (``Section 6103''),
comprised of the following.
SECTION 6103 MATERIALS SUBMITTED BY JOSEPH ZIEGLER
Mr. Joseph Ziegler (``Mr. Ziegler''), an Internal Revenue
Service (``IRS'') Criminal Investigator, provided five separate
productions of documents to the Committee after his testimony
before the Committee on Oversight and Accountability on July
19, 2023.\1\ Each of these productions (``affidavits''')
included an affidavit created by Mr. Ziegler, and each
affidavit was accompanied by exhibits.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ H. Comm. on Oversight and Accountability, Hearing with IRS
Whistleblowers About the Biden Criminal Investigation (July 19, 2023),
https://oversight.house.gov/hearing/hearing-with-irs-whistleblowers-
about-the-biden-criminal-investigation/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The first affidavit was provided to the Committee on August
30, 2023.\2\ This production included a document titled
``Affidavit 1'' and 20 accompanying exhibits. This affidavit
and the related exhibits included specific details about the
nature of the tax charges the IRS recommended to be filed
against Hunter Biden. The exhibits also included worksheets on
his unreported income and taxes due and owing, details about
allegedly improper business deductions, formation documents for
Hudson West III (an entity in which Hunter Biden holds a 50
percent stake), tax returns for Hudson West III, memoranda of
interviews with Hunter Biden associates, including of Hunter
Biden's uncle, James Biden, relevant Hunter Biden email
messages, and a WhatsApp message from Hunter Biden.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\ To avoid confusion, the affidavits are discussed in the order
in which Mr. Ziegler numbered them even though Affidavit 2 was received
by the Committee first on August 22, 2023, and Affidavit 1 was received
on August 30, 2022.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The second affidavit was provided to the Committee on
August 22, 2023. This production included a document titled
``Affidavit 2'' and 14 accompanying exhibits. This affidavit
and related exhibits included email messages and related
documents exchanged among the investigators, prosecutors, and
U.S. Department of Justice (``DOJ'') tax attorneys. These
communications relate to investigative activities into the
Hunter Biden case, many of which had been discussed in Mr.
Ziegler's prior testimony before the Committee.
The third affidavit was provided to the Committee on
September 7, 2023. This production included a document titled
``Affidavit 3'' and 23 accompanying exhibits. This affidavit
and related exhibits included an expansive set of messages
between Hunter Biden and his associates, including messages
that had been discussed in Mr. Gary Shapley's (``Mr. Shapley'')
prior testimony before the Committee. Also included in the
exhibits is a timeline regarding Burisma (a Ukrainian company
from which Hunter Biden received payments) and contact with
U.S. government officials. Additionally, this production
included emails and attachments related to the timeline, an
excerpt of a presentation for a ``tax summit'' meeting in June
2022, and filter memos related to the Hunter Biden laptop.
The fourth affidavit was provided to the Committee on
September 7, 2023. This production included a document titled
``Affidavit 4'' and four accompanying exhibits. This affidavit
and related exhibits included a Federal Bureau of Investigation
(``FBI'') FD-302 interview memorandum regarding an interview
with Hunter Biden associate Tony Bobulinski, a full transcript
of a December 8, 2020, interview with John Robinson (``Rob'')
Walker, and an FBI-FD 302 memorandum of an interview with Rob
Walker.
The fifth production was provided to the Committee on
September 19, 2023. This production included a document titled
``Affidavit 5'' and nine accompanying exhibits. On September
20, 2023, the Committee received an updated affidavit from Mr.
Ziegler's counsel. That is the version that was presented to
the Committee consideration. This affidavit and related
exhibits included email messages and related documents
exchanged among the investigators, prosecutors, and DOJ tax
attorneys regarding investigative activities into the Hunter
Biden case.
SECTION 6103 MATERIALS SUBMITTED BY GARY SHAPLEY
Mr. Shapley provided three productions of documents to the
Committee after his testimony before the Committee on Oversight
and Accountability on July 19, 2023.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\ H. Comm. on Oversight and Accountability, Hearing with IRS
Whistleblowers About the Biden Criminal Investigation (July 19, 2023),
https://oversight.house.gov/hearing/hearing-with-irs-whistleblowers-
about-the-biden-criminal-investigation/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The first production was provided to the Committee on
September 11, 2023. This production included a cover letter
addressed to Chairman Smith and Ranking Member Neal, and Senate
Finance Committee Chairman Wyden and Ranking Member Crapo. The
production also included nine attachments. The nine attachments
contain email chains related to the scheduling of an October 7,
2022, meeting referenced in Mr. Ziegler and Mr. Shapley's
testimonies previously provided to the Committee--including
emails related to concerns Mr. Shapley raised during the
investigation into Hunter Biden, as well as Mr. Shapley's notes
regarding interactions he had with a supervisor about his
decision to make protected disclosures to Congress.
The second production was provided to the Committee on
September 13, 2023. This production included two cover letters.
One cover letter was addressed to Chairman Smith and Ranking
Member Neal, and Senate Finance Committee Chairman Wyden and
Ranking Member Crapo. The attachment to this letter included
Mr. Shapley's unredacted, handwritten notes from the October 7,
2022, meeting. The other cover letter was addressed to House
Judiciary Committee Chairman Jim Jordan and Ranking Member
Jerrold Nadler. The attachment to this letter included Mr.
Shapley's redacted, handwritten notes from the October 7, 2022,
meeting.
The third production was provided to the Committee on
September 20, 2023. This production included a written
statement from Mr. Shapley along with numerous attachments. The
attachments included email chains, case reports, and memorandum
of conversations regarding the investigation of Hunter Biden.
Many of these materials relate to Mr. Shapley's prior testimony
before the Committee.
By a recorded vote of 24 to 17, the Committee favorably
adopted the motion to submit these materials to the U.S. House
of Representatives.
B. Background on the Committee's Jurisdiction and Statutory Authority
The Committee has sole jurisdiction in the United States to
originate federal tax legislation and has oversight authority
over tax administration by the IRS and the U.S. Department of
the Treasury.\4\ Under Section 6103, there is a ``general rule
that [tax] returns and return information are confidential.''
\5\ Therefore, ``[r]eturns and return information cannot be
disclosed unless a specific exception for such disclosure is
provided for in the Code.'' \6\ There are ``a number of
specific exceptions to the general rule of confidentiality'' in
Section 6103, including ``authorizations to furnish information
to Congress, the Department of Justice, and certain designees
of the taxpayer pursuant to taxpayer consent.'' \7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\ Article I, Section 7, U.S. Constitution; H. Comm. on Ways and
Means, About, https://waysandmeans.house.gov/about/.
\5\ Joint Committee on Taxation, Background Regarding the
Confidentiality and Disclosure of Federal Tax Returns (JCX-3-19) (Feb.
4, 2019), https://www.jct.gov/getattachment/4c176272-a1d4-468e-ba68-
1c1c51a11d61/x-3-19-5159.pdf.
\6\ Id.
\7\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 6103 also authorizes the Chairmen of the House
Committee on Ways and Means, the Senate Committee on Finance,
and the Joint Committee on Taxation to receive returns and
return information; and the Chairmen of those Committees, along
with the Chief of Staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation, may
``designate examiners and agents to inspect returns and return
information.'' \8\ Section 6103 also contains a whistleblower
provision:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\ Id.; 26 U.S.C. Sec. 6103(f)(4)(A).
Any person who otherwise has or had access to any
return or return information under this section may
disclose such return or return information to a
committee referred to in paragraph (1) or any
individual authorized to receive or inspect information
under paragraph (4)(A) if such person believes such
return or return information may relate to possible
misconduct, maladministration, or taxpayer abuse.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\ 6 U.S.C. Sec. 6103(f)(5).
Moreover, any return or return information obtained by or
on behalf of the aforementioned Committees ``may be submitted
by the committee to either the Senate or the House of
Representatives, or to both. Such submission does not require
the Senate or House of Representatives to be sitting in closed
executive session.'' \10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\ 26 U.S.C. Sec. 6103(f)(4)(A); Joint Committee on Taxation,
Background Regarding the Confidentiality and Disclosure of Federal Tax
Returns (JCX-3-19) (Feb. 4, 2019), https://www.jct.gov/getattachment/
4c176272-a1d4-468e-ba68-1c1c51a11d61/x-3-19-5159.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
C. Background on The Committee's Work
Chairman Smith, Ranking Member Neal, and the Chairs and
Ranking Members of other House and Senate Committees received a
letter on April 19, 2023, from counsel for an IRS Criminal
Supervisory Special Agent (Whistleblower 1), who was later
identified as Mr. Shapley.\11\ That letter outlined, in very
general terms, the nature of information Mr. Shapley wished to
share with the Committee, including information that would:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\ Statement from Chairman Smith on IRS Whistleblower Outreach,
H. Comm. on Ways and Means (Apr. 19, 2023), https://
waysandmeans.house.gov/statement-from-chairman-smith-on-irs-
whistleblower-outreach/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(1) Contradict sworn testimony provided to Congress by a
senior political official;
(2) Identify unmitigated conflicts of interest; and
(3) Provide examples of preferential treatment based on
political considerations.
Counsel for Mr. Shapley offered to provide a proffer to the
Committee to outline the nature of the testimony Mr. Shapley
could provide.
On May 5, 2023, Committee staff received that attorney
proffer, which disclosed that the subject of the investigation
was R. Hunter Biden. Majority and minority staff were
designated by Chairman Smith under Section 6103 to receive the
information; both majority and minority staff were present at
the attorney proffer and were afforded equal opportunity to ask
questions. After receiving the proffer, a voluntary interview
of Mr. Shapley was scheduled for later in May.
On May 15, 2023, the Committee received a letter from Mr.
Shapley's legal counsel notifying the Committee that he and his
entire IRS investigative team had been removed from the ongoing
and sensitive investigation about which Mr. Shapley sought to
make a disclosure to Congress.\12\ The letter noted that Mr.
Shapley was informed that the removal occurred at the request
of DOJ.\13\ Following that removal, the Committee learned that
another IRS employee had retained counsel and had interest in
providing additional relevant information to the Committee.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\ Letter from Mark D. Lytle and Tristan Leavitt, to The Hon.
Jason Smith, Chairman, H. Comm. on Ways and Means, The Hon. Jim Jordan,
Chairman, H. Comm. on the Judiciary, et al. (May 15, 2023).
\13\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On May 22, 2023, the Committee received a letter from Mr.
Shapley's legal counsel alleging that the IRS had taken further
actions against Mr. Shapley.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\ Letter from Tristan Leavitt and Mark D. Lytle to The Hon.
Jason Smith, Chairman, H. Comm on Ways and Means, et al., (May 22,
2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On May 24, 2023, the Committee received a letter from an
IRS Criminal Investigator's legal counsel noting that
Whistleblower 2, who later identified himself as Mr. Ziegler,
shared the concerns about the management of the high-profile
case raised by Mr. Shapley.\15\ The letter also notes that
despite Mr. Ziegler's good faith efforts to engage in a
dialogue with supervisors at the IRS about this case and the
management of the case, to date, this has resulted in no
constructive engagement.\16\ Rather, IRS management responded
in a manner that raised significant alarm for Mr. Ziegler of
possible retaliation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\ Letter from Dean Zerbe to The Hon. Jason Smith, Chairman, and
The Hon. Richard Neal, Ranking Member, H. Comm on Ways and Means, et
al., (May 22, 2023).
\16\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On May 26, 2023, and June 1, 2023, Committee staff
conducted voluntary transcribed interviews of Mr. Shapley and
Mr. Ziegler. Each interview lasted for approximately seven
hours. Majority and minority staff had equal opportunity to ask
questions of the whistleblowers and were able to ask questions
until none remained.
On June 22, 2023, the Committee held an executive session
to consider materials protected by Section 6103, including the
transcripts of the transcribed interviews of the two
whistleblowers and two supplemental documents submitted by the
whistleblowers.\17\ The minority also requested that the
Committee include and consider a June 7, 2023, letter from IRS
Commissioner Daniel Werfel to Chairman Smith.\18\ The Committee
voted to submit those materials to the U.S. House of
Representatives and thereby make public all five documents. The
Committee also voted to make a transcript of the closed
executive session public.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\ H. Comm. on Ways and Means, Smith: Testimony of IRS Employees
Reveals Biden IRS, DOJ Interfered in Tax Investigation of Hunter Biden,
Revealing Preferential Treatment for Wealthy and Politically Connected
(June 22, 2023), https://gop-waysandmeans.house.gov/smith-testimony-of-
irs-employees-reveals-biden-irs-doj-interfered-in-tax-investigation-of-
hunter-biden-revealing-preferential-treatment-for-wealthy-and-
politically-connected/.
\18\ Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On June 29, 2023, the Chairmen of the Committee on Ways and
Means, the Committee on the Judiciary, and the Committee on
Oversight and Accountability sent letters requesting interviews
with 13 federal government employees--including two IRS
officials--likely to have information relevant to Mr. Shapley's
and Mr. Ziegler's allegations.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\ Letter from Chairmen Jim Jordan, Jason Smith, and James Comer,
to Daniel Werfel, Commissioner, Internal Revenue Service (June 29,
2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The DOJ and IRS did not initially make any of those
individuals available for interviews on a voluntary basis.
Chairman Smith therefore issued deposition subpoenas to the two
IRS employees--Michael Batdorf and Darrel Waldon.\20\ After the
subpoenas were issued, the IRS agreed to make Mr. Batdorf and
Mr. Waldon available for voluntary transcribed interviews on a
limited set of topics. Specifically, in advance of their
interviews with the Committee, Mr. Batdorf and Mr. Waldon were
directed by the IRS not to answer certain questions relevant to
the Committee's investigation. During the interviews, IRS
lawyers intervened on numerous occasions to instruct Mr.
Batdorf and Mr. Waldon not to answer certain questions.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\ H. Comm. on Ways and Means, Ways and Means, Judiciary
Committees Issue Subpoenas Compelling Witness Testimony on Political
Interference and Preferential Treatment in Hunter Biden Investigation
(Aug. 21, 2023), https://waysandmeans.house.gov/ways-and-means-
judiciary-committees-issue-subpoenas-compelling-witness-testimony-on-
political-interference-and-
preferential-treatment-in-hunter-biden-investigation/.
\21\ See e.g., Memorandum for Darrell Waldon, Director, Advanced
Analytics & Innovation, Criminal Investigation, from Daniel I. Werfel,
Commissioner, Subject: Testimony Authorization (Sept. 7, 2023);
Memorandum for Michael Batdorf, Director of Field Operations, Southern
Area, Criminal Investigation, from Daniel I. Werfel, Commissioner,
Subject: Testimony Authorization (Sept. 11, 2023); Transcribed
Interview of Darrell Waldon, Director, Advanced Analytics & Innovation,
Internal Revenue Service Criminal Investigation at 9 (Sept. 8, 2023);
Transcribed Interview of Michael Batdorf, Director of Fie