Dissenting Views
[To accompany H. Res. 158]
The Committee on Foreign Affairs, to whom was referred the
resolution (H. Res. 158) of inquiry requesting the President
and directing the Secretary of Defense and Secretary of State
to transmit, respectively, certain documents to the House of
Representatives relating to congressionally appropriated funds
to the nation of Ukraine from January 20, 2021 to February 24,
2023, having considered the same, reports favorably thereon
without amendment and recommends that the resolution be agreed
to.
CONTENTS
Page
Summary.......................................................... 2
Background....................................................... 2
Committee Consideration and Vote................................. 4
Oversight Findings and Recommendations........................... 4
New Budget Authority, Tax Expenditures, and Federal Mandates..... 4
Directed Rule Making............................................. 4
Non-Duplication of Federal Programs.............................. 5
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 5
Congressional Accountability Act................................. 5
New Advisory Committees.......................................... 5
Earmark Identification........................................... 5
Section-by-Section Analysis...................................... 5
Dissenting Views................................................. 6
SUMMARY
House Resolution 158 requests the President, and directs
the Secretary of State to transmit, respectively, to the House
of Representatives, not later than 14 days after the date of
the adoption of this resolution, copies of all documents,
charts, or tables, including notes from meetings, audio
recordings, records (including telephone and email records),
correspondence, and other communications, and any financial
statements detailing purchases, recipients, and government
expenditures to the extent that any such one or more items are
within the possession of the President or Secretaries
aforementioned, respectively, and refer or relate to
congressionally appropriated funds directed to the nation of
Ukraine--whether in regard to military, civilian, or financial
aid--between January 20, 2021 to February 24, 2023.
Background
According to House rules and precedents, House Resolution
158 qualifies for consideration as a resolution of inquiry.
Although the resolution does not have the requisite cosponsors
typically required for committee action under committee rules
(25 cosponsors, including 10 committee members), clause 7 of
rule XIII of the Rules of the House requires the committee to
act on resolutions of inquiry within 14 legislative days.
The Committee is committed to--and is in the process of--
conducting vigorous oversight of the congressionally-
appropriated security, humanitarian, and economic assistance to
Ukraine being provided by the Department of State and United
States Agency for International Development (USAID). It is
unfortunate that this resolution was drafted and introduced
without regard for the robust oversight already underway. It is
also unfortunate that some misunderstand strong oversight as
somehow at odds with strong U.S. support for Ukraine's self-
defense against Vladimir Putin's brutal, illegal invasion. To
the contrary, such oversight is critical for maintaining strong
U.S. support, and for ensuring that such support is effective.
The Committee is advancing transparency and accountability
not only to fulfill its constitutionally-mandated
responsibility to conduct oversight of our constituents'
taxpayer dollars, but also to sustain U.S. and allied support
for Ukraine. The American people have a right to know how U.S.
assistance responding to Russia's war in Ukraine is being
spent, and how the safeguards in place are ensuring that there
is no fraud, waste, or misuse involving American taxpayer
money.
The Committee's first classified briefing of the 118th
Congress with the Biden Administration was on Russia's
unprovoked war of aggression against Ukraine. The Chairman then
led a Congressional Delegation to Poland and Ukraine from
February 19-23, 2023 to receive a firsthand perspective of how
U.S. assistance to Ukraine is being used to support a Ukrainian
victory as soon as possible. The delegation met with the 101st
Airborne Division, USAID's Disaster Assistance Response Team in
Poland, Embassy Kyiv staff, and President Zelenskyy in Ukraine,
to deepen its understanding of the transparency and
accountability mechanisms the U.S. has in place to track U.S.
weapon systems sent to the frontlines, and to ensure that our
non-security assistance reaches its intended beneficiaries. The
delegation was encouraged to learn that, to date, no
significant acts of fraud or misuse involving U.S. assistance
have occurred.
The Subcommittee on Europe's first official activity of the
118th Congress was a briefing with State Department and USAID
officials on the transparency and accountability safeguards in
place for U.S. aid to Ukraine. The briefing focused on U.S.
humanitarian and economic assistance, particularly the
accountability mechanisms and planned audits for the $22.9
billion in direct budget support, as well as U.S. diplomatic
efforts to encourage greater assistance to Ukraine from U.S.
allies and partners. Later this month, the Committee will hold
a hearing with the inspectors general from the Department of
Defense, Department of State, and USAID to hear their
assessments of the transparency and accountability mechanisms
the Administration has put in place for U.S. assistance to
Ukraine. In this hearing, Members will also have the
opportunity to evaluate the inspectors' general Joint Strategic
Oversight Plan for monitoring, tracking, and accounting for the
totality of assistance provided to Ukraine. This will be the
first time any of the inspectors general have appeared publicly
before this Committee since the beginning of Russia's full-
scale invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022.
Likewise, Committee staff have organized biweekly briefings
with Administration officials to discuss updates on the war and
U.S. support for Ukraine. Committee staff have also requested
briefings from the Department of State and USAID on each
advanced notification of how the Administration plans to spend
U.S. government-provided assistance to ensure that every dollar
of American taxpayer funding directly contributes to Ukraine's
war effort and that the relevant oversight mechanisms are
functioning.
However, the Administration continues to fail to answer
critical questions about the end goal for U.S. assistance to
Ukraine. A pledge to ``support Ukraine for as long as it
takes'' is, unfortunately, not a strategy. Moreover, the
Committee remains frustrated by the Administration's opaque and
constantly changing rationales for refusing to provide Ukraine
with critical weapon systems, such as ATACMS, which would help
Ukraine win the war quickly and avert a bloody stalemate which
will benefit Vladimir Putin and ultimately cost taxpayers more.
Notably, this resolution requests information from the
Administration starting on January 20, 2021--more than a full
year before Russia's unprovoked war of aggression began.
Congress needs to closely examine the Administration's failure
of deterrence leading up to Russia's full-scale invasion so
that, in the future, such brutal wars of aggression can be
deterred by American strength, not encouraged by American
weakness. Thus the Committee also intends to conduct oversight
to obtain detailed answers regarding critical administration
decisions that preceded the February 24, 2022 Russian invasion,
including:
The administration's flawed decision to
agree to a clean, five-year extension of the New START
Treaty mere days after President Biden was sworn in, a
unilateral concession to Putin which gave him exactly
what he wanted and demanded nothing in return;
the administration's decision to waive
congressionally-mandated sanctions on the Nord Stream 2
pipeline, threatening the credibility of Western
sanctions at a critical juncture;
how the surrender to the Taliban and the
disastrous, unconditional withdrawal of U.S. troops
from Afghanistan emboldened Vladimir Putin and damaged
U.S. credibility with our allies, partners, and
adversaries alike; and
the failure of the administration to provide
significant security assistance to Ukraine or impose
severe sanctions on the Putin regime in the months
leading up to Russia's full-scale invasion, despite
tens of thousands of Russian troops amassing on
Ukraine's borders and intelligence indicating that the
invasion was imminent.
The Foreign Affairs Committee is dedicated to pursuing
clarity on all of these issues to ensure that U.S. assistance
is funding a sound strategy, and to maintain robust
Congressional oversight. House Resolution 158 is consistent
with that aim.
COMMITTEE CONSIDERATION AND VOTE
On March 24, 2023, the committee marked up House Resolution
158 pursuant to notice, in open session. The committee agreed
to a motion to report the resolution favorably to the House by
a record vote of 26 ayes to 20 noes.
On the vote to report H. Res. 158 to the House favorably:
Voting aye (26): McCaul, Smith, Wilson, Perry, Issa,
Wagner, Mast, Burchett, Green, Barr, R. Jackson (TX), Y. Kim
(CA), Salazar, Huizenga, Radewagen, Hill, Davidson, Baird,
Waltz, Kean, Lawler, Mills, McCormick, Moran, James, Self.
Voting no (20): Meeks, Connolly, Keating, Cicilline, Bera,
Titus, Lieu, Wild, Phillips, Allred, A. Kim (NJ), Jacobs,
Manning, Cherfilus-McCormick, Stanton, Dean, J. Jackson (IL),
Kamlager-Dove, Crow, Schneider.
OVERSIGHT FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
In compliance with Clause 3(c)(1) of rule XIII of the rules
of the House of Representatives, the Committee reports that the
findings and recommendations of the Committee, based on
oversight activities under Clause 2(b)(1) of rule X of the
House of Representatives, are incorporated in the
``Background'' section of this report, above.
NEW BUDGET AUTHORITY, TAX EXPENDITURES, AND FEDERAL MANDATES
Clause 3(c)(2) of House rule XIII and the Unfunded Mandates
Reform Act (Public Law 104-4) are inapplicable because House
Resolution 158 does not provide new budget authority or
increased tax expenditures.
DIRECTED RULE MAKING
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII, the
committee notes that House Resolution 158 contains no directed
rule-making provisions.
NON-DUPLICATION OF FEDERAL PROGRAMS
Clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII is not applicable to this
resolution, as it is not a bill or joint resolution that
establishes or reauthorizes a federal program.
PERFORMANCE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
Clause 3(c)(4) of House rule XIII is not applicable to this
resolution, as it is not a measure that authorizes funding.
CONGRESSIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY ACT
House Resolution 158 does not apply to terms and conditions
of employment or to access to public services or accommodations
within the legislative branch.
NEW ADVISORY COMMITTEES
House Resolution 158 does not establish or authorize any
new advisory committees.
EARMARK IDENTIFICATION
House Resolution 158 contains no congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as described
in clauses 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of House rule XXI.
Dissenting Views
Rather than engaging in constructive oversight through the
various mechanisms at Congress' disposal and through the
legislative process, the sponsors of H. Res. 158 are
politicizing oversight, as evidenced by the cosponsors'
decision to request documentation dating only back to the
beginning of the Biden Administration. This timeline fails to
consider the significant U.S. assistance provided to Ukraine
for almost a decade to withstand sustained malign Kremlin
influence and armed aggression.
The House Foreign Affairs Committee has consistently
spearheaded thorough oversight of congressionally appropriated
political-military, humanitarian, and economic assistance to
Ukraine for decades. Likewise, the Administration has
voluntarily and regularly provided briefings, documentation,
and justifications for assistance to Ukraine to the committees
of jurisdiction--and to the Congress--in an effort to
facilitate Congress' legislative and oversight
responsibilities. The Department of State (State), Department
of Defense (DOD), and U.S. Agency for International Development
(USAID) have provided advance notification and detailed
breakdowns of how American taxpayer funding would be spent
ahead of every tranche of U.S. government-provided assistance.
Additionally, Executive Branch officials and the State, DOD,
and USAID Inspectors General have briefed the Committee on
their detailed plan to monitor, track, and account for the
totality of assistance provided to Ukraine--as well as to
assess for themselves the established safeguards on U.S.
assistance. Committee Democrats are firmly in favor of these
unprecedented oversight efforts as U.S. assistance continues to
be provided to Ukraine, including the Committee's upcoming
hearing with the State, DOD, and USAID inspectors general on
their efforts to monitor Ukraine assistance. Such oversight is
important not only to deter potential waste, fraud, or abuse in
the provision of U.S. assistance, but also to ensure that the
assistance supports the United States' national security
objectives.
Since Russia's February 2022 renewed invasion of Ukraine,
the Committee has held dozens of public briefings, hearings,
and closed briefings on the war in Ukraine and related issues
at the Member level. State, often with participation from the
DOD--has provided Committee Staff, on a biweekly basis and
totaling over 25 separate engagements, updates on the status of
the war as well as on U.S., ally, and partner assistance
efforts to Ukraine. Additionally, State and USAID have briefed
Committee staff on nearly 20 occasions on non-security
assistance to Ukraine and the operating status of Embassy Kyiv.
Altogether, the Administration has engaged on more than 60
occasions with the Congress at the staff and Member level about
the war in Ukraine, the assistance the United States is
providing, assistance our allies and partners are providing,
and related security issues. This includes several hearings and
briefings at the Cabinet-level or Deputy-level. This regular
series of briefings and information exchanges between the
executive and legislative branches and the relevant inspectors
general has continued unabated since the 117th Congress and is
unprecedented.
The very sponsors of this resolution of inquiry--including
Members of this Committee--and others launching attacks on the
transparency of the Biden Administration's response to the war
in Ukraine have failed to participate actively in many of the
briefings and other opportunities made available to learn about
the U.S. strategy to support Ukraine to defeat Russia.
Furthermore, their public comments minimize the threat posed by
the Kremlin to U.S. national security and bluntly assert that
the Biden Administration's vital assistance to Ukraine should
cease. Such attempts to politicize Ukraine oversight--including
through unfounded claims in this report attempting to blame
President Biden for President Putin's unprovoked, unjustified
war--only strengthen Russia's hand. While Committee Democrats
will remain engaged in rigorous oversight of U.S. funding to
support Ukraine and our other allies and partners, H. Res. 158
is a dangerous fishing expedition that chooses partisanship
over responsible oversight and transatlantic unity.
Sincerely,
Gregory W. Meeks,
Ranking Member.