Purpose and Summary
H.R. 4250, the Protect Reporters from Exploitative State Spying Act, introduced by Rep. Kevin Kiley (R-CA), will prohibit the federal government from compelling journalists and providers of telecommunications services to provide information identifying a source or any other record obtained or created by journalists in the course of their work. Background and Need for the Legislation The First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution states that, ``Congress shall make no law . . . abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press.''\1\ Courts have generally construed these rights broadly. During the formative era for the modern understanding of the First Amendment, the Supreme Court rejected restrictions on the publication of national security information obtained by reporters from government sources.\2\ As recognized by Justice Byron White, the press ``serves and was designed to serve as a powerful antidote to any abuse of power by governmental officials.''\3\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\U.S. Const. Amend. I. \2\See New York Times v. United States, 403 U.S. 713 (1971). \3\Miami Herald Pub. Co., Div. of Knight Newspapers, Inc. v. Tornillo, 418 U.S. 241, 260 (1974) (White, J. concurring). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Historically, the federal and state governments have clashed in court with the press over the compelled disclosure of confidential sources. In 1971, when the government prevented the New York Times and Washington Post from publishing classified material about the Vietnam War that would later become known as the Pentagon Papers, Justice Hugo Black argued ``every moment's continuance of the injunctions against these newspapers amounts to a flagrant, indefensible, and continuing violation of the First Amendment . . . . [Enjoining the publishing of the news] would make a shambles of the First Amendment.''\4\ Justice Black further stated, ``Both the history and language of the First Amendment support the view that the press must be left free to publish news, whatever the source, without censorship, injunctions, or prior restraints.''\5\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \4\New York Times, at 715 (Black, J. concurring). \5\Id. at 717 (Black, J. concurring). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- While the government now rarely seeks to enjoin the publication of certain information by the press, there are still areas where the First Amendment and the government come into conflict. In recent years, this friction has come not in the form of targeting newspapers that publish classified information, but in prosecutions of those who leak classified information to reporters. In these investigations, the government has sought to seize records and documents belonging to journalists and to compel testimony about their sources through both subpoenas and threats of imprisonment.\6\ In some cases, journalists' records are seized from third-party service providers, like phone and internet companies.\7\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \6\See, e.g., Charlie Savage, U.S. Gathered Personal Data on Times Reporter in Case Against Ex-C.I.A. Agency, N.Y. Times (Feb. 25, 2011); Adam Goldman, Nicholas Fandos, and Katie Benner, Ex-Senate Aide Charged in Leak Case Where Times Reporter's Records Were Seized, N.Y. Times (Jun. 7, 2018); Charlie Savage & Leslie Kaufman, Phone Records of Journalists Seized by U.S., N.Y. Times (May 13, 2013). \7\Louis Nelson, Jordan criticizes DOJ for seizing NYT reporter's materials in leak case, Politico (Jun. 21, 2018). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- These actions are not limited to leaks of classified information. Beginning in late 2020, the Justice Department targeted Project Veritas over the group's possession of a diary reportedly belonging to President Biden's daughter.\8\ Despite never publishing the contents of the diary, investigative reporter James O'Keefe, the group's founder, had his home raided at dawn by the FBI in November 2021.\9\ In court filings, Project Veritas alleged that the Justice Department secretly seized its emails and placed a gag order on Microsoft, whose servers housed the group's emails.\10\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \8\The Editorial Board, The FBI's Raid on James O'Keefe, Wall Street Journal (Nov. 18, 2021) (``Attorney General Merrick Garland still refuses to retract the memo he sent last month instructing the Department of Justice to scrutinize parents protesting at local school board meetings. Now his department may have committed another civil- liberties abuse with its raid on Project Veritas leader James O'Keefe.''). \9\Id. \10\Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Journalists argue that these actions have a chilling effect that disincentives whistleblowers and informants from coming forward with critical information.\11\ In turn, Americans may be prevented from learning information of a compelling public interest. In order to ensure that the government does not infringe on the First Amendment rights of journalists, many jurisdictions have adopted shield laws. Shield laws are designed to protect a reporter's privilege to refuse to disclose confidential sources to the government. At times, journalists rely on confidential sources to gather information vital to holding public and private institutions accountable. Any law that protects a reporter's privilege to refuse compulsory testimony or the disclosure of confidential information in court is colloquially referred to as a ``shield law.'' --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \11\See, e.g., Josh Gerstein, Leakers on the defensive, Politico (Jan. 13, 2015). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- STATE SHIELD LAWS While 32 states and D.C. have statutory shield laws and a total of 49 states have either statutory or common law reporter's privilege, there is no federal shield law.\12\ State shield laws serve the common purpose of protecting reporters from revealing sources and confidential information, but states vary in the degree of privilege afforded. For example, some states provide either absolute or qualified privilege depending on whether it is a civil or criminal proceeding.\13\ Additionally, state shield laws can also limit a reporter's privilege based on the definition of a journalist, whether the journalist is a party to the proceeding, and whether the confidential material is published or unpublished.\14\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \12\Alan Wehbe, The Free Press and National Security: Renewing the Case for a Federal Shield Law, 16 First Amend. L. Rev. 512 (2018). \13\Lucy Dalgish and Gregg P. Leslie, The First Amendment Handbook: 7th Edition 23 (2011). \14\Statutory and common law protections; state shield laws, testimonial privileges, and the Privacy Protection Act, Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, https://www.rcfp.org/electronic- communications-surveillance/legal-and-regulatory-protections- journalists/b-statutory-and- (last visited July 13, 2018). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Many states enacted shield laws in response to the 1972 Branzburg v. Hayes Supreme Court case, which found that requiring a reporter to appear before a grand jury to testify about his confidential sources did not violate the First Amendment. In that case, the government required a reporter named Paul Branzburg to testify about unnamed individuals who he had reported were making illegal drugs.\15\ The decision called on Congress to act, saying, ``Congress has freedom to determine whether a statutory newsman's privilege is necessary and desirable and to fashion standards and rules as narrow or broad as deemed necessary.''\16\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \15\Branzburg v. Hayes, 408 U.S. 665 (1972). \16\Id. at 706. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- ATTEMPTS AT A FEDERAL SHIELD LAW In response to public and congressional outrage over the compelled disclosure of journalists' records, the Department of Justice has altered its policies governing the use of certain investigatory tactics in cases involving the press. Most recently updated in July 2021, the Department committed to: no longer us[ing] compulsory legal process for the purpose of obtaining information from or records of members of the news media acting within the scope of newsgathering activities. . . . This new prohibition applies to compulsory legal process issued to reporters directly, to their publishers or employers, and to third-party service providers of any of the foregoing. It extends to the full range of compulsory process covered by the current regulations, specifically, subpoenas, warrants, court orders issued pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Sec. 2703(d) and Sec. 3123, and civil investigative demands. Further, it applies regardless of whether the compulsory legal process seeks testimony, physical documents, telephone toll records, metadata, or digital content.\17\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \17\Memorandum for the Deputy Attorney General, the Associate Attorney General, Heads of Department Components, United States Attorneys, and Federal Prosecutors, from U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland, Use of Compulsory Process to Obtain Information From, or Records of, Members of the News Media, U.S. Dep't of Justice (July 19, 2021), https://www.justice.gov/ag/page/file/1413001/download. The policy provides exceptions for investigations into reporters who are engaged in criminal activity outside the scope of their journalistic activity, such as insider trading.\18\ It also does not apply to a journalist who has used criminal methods, such as breaking and entering or hacking, to obtain government information.\19\ Regarding classified information, the new policy states: --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \18\Id. \19\Id. The prohibition does apply when a member of the news media has, in the course of newsgathering, only possessed or published government information, including classified information. This does not, however, affect the Department's traditional ability to use compulsory legal process to obtain information from or records of, for example, a government employee (rather than a member of the news media) who has unlawfully disclosed government information.\20\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \20\Id. Despite these changes to Justice Department policy, legislation to establish a federal shield law has been and continues to be introduced in various sessions of Congress. In the 109th Congress in 2005, then-Rep. Mike Pence (R-IN) introduced the Free Flow of Information Act in response to New York Times reporter Judith Miller being jailed for refusing to name the confidential source who revealed Valerie Plame's covert identity.\21\ In 2007, the legislation overwhelmingly passed the House, but failed in the Senate due in part to opposition from the Bush Administration that the bill would ``jeopardize national security'' by creating ``roadblocks'' that would ``delay the collection of critical information and ensure that criminals have opportunities to avoid detection.''\22\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \21\Free Flow of Information Act, H.R. 581, 109th Cong. (2005); Bree Nordenson, The Shield Bearer: How a Conservative Congressman from Indiana Became Journalism's Best Ally in the Fight to Protect Anonymous Sources, Columbia Journalism Rev. (Jun. 2007); See also, Reporter Jailed After Refusing to Name Source, N.Y. Times (Jul. 7, 2005). \22\Scott Wong, Key Conservative Presses for Shield Law After Seizure of NYT Reporter's Records, THE HILL (Jun. 15, 2018); See also, Alan Wehbe, The Free Press and National Security: Renewing the Case for a Federal Shield Law, 16 First Amend. L. Rev. 512 (2018); See also, Administration Launches Web Site Opposing Journalist Media Shield, Fox News (Apr. 3, 2008). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In the 113th Congress, then-Rep. Ted Poe (R-TX) introduced similar legislation in the aftermath of the revelation that the Obama Administration had secretly seized phone records from the Associated Press.\23\ The Senate companion, S. 987, was introduced by Senator Chuck Schumer (D-NY) and reported favorably out of the Senate Judiciary Committee. However, no further action was taken on either bill in the 113th Congress. Critics argued the bill's definition of ``journalist'' was too narrow and that the bill did not provide strong enough protections for journalists.\24\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \23\Free Flow of Information Act of 2013, S. 987, 113th Cong. (2013); Reuters Staff, U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee passes media shield law, Reuters (Sept. 12, 2013). \24\Reuters Staff, U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee passes media shield law, Reuters (Sept. 12, 2013); See also, Editorial Board, A shield law is necessary to protect U.S. journalists, The Wash. Post (Sept. 22, 2013). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In the 115th Congress, Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-MD) introduced H.R. 4382, the Free Flow of Information Act, with Rep. Jim Jordan (R-OH). Nearly identical to the iteration from the 109th Congress, the legislation conditioned the federally compelled disclosure of information by members of the news media. In July 2018, Rep. Jordan, then-Chairman of the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform's Subcommittee on Healthcare, Benefits, and Administrative Rules, held a hearing entitled, ``Shielding Sources: Safeguarding the Public's Right to Know,'' at which the investigative correspondent Sharyl Attkisson testified about the challenges that reporters face in maintaining the confidentiality of their sources.\25\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \25\Shielding Sources: Safeguarding the Public's Right to Know: Hearing Before the H. Comm. on Oversight & Gov't Reform, 115th Cong. (2018) (statement of Sharyl Attkisson). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- In the 117th Congress, Rep. Raskin introduced H.R. 4330, the Protect Reporters from Exploitative State Spying Act or PRESS Act.\26\ On April 5, 2022, the Judiciary Committee considered the bill during a business meeting and reported it favorably to the House floor by voice vote. On September 19, 2022, the PRESS Act passed the House under suspension of the rules by voice vote. However, the Senate did not take up the PRESS Act before the end of the Congress. The current version of the PRESS Act, sponsored by Rep. Kiley (R-CA), is identical to the version introduced in the 117th Congress. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \26\H.R. 4330, 117th Cong. (2021). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The PRESS Act prohibits the federal government from compelling a journalist to disclose protected information except in certain limited circumstances, such as in cases involving terrorism or to prevent a threat of imminent violence or significant bodily harm. The bill similarly prohibits the federal government from seizing a journalist's records from a third-party service provider except in similar circumstances. In the event that these exceptions apply, the government's demands must be narrowly tailored and not overbroad or unreasonable.