Committee Action
The Committee on Ways and Means marked up H.R. 5988, the
``United States-Taiwan Expedited Double-Tax Relief Act of
2023,'' on November 30, 2023. By amendment in the nature of a
substitute, the Committee added the United States-Taiwan Tax
Agreement Authorization Act as Title II of H.R. 5988, and
ordered the bill, as amended, favorably reported (with a quorum
being present) by a roll call vote of 40 ayes and 0 nays.
D. Designated Hearing
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearings were used to develop and consider H.R. 5988:
On March 10, 2023, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``President Biden's Fiscal Year 2024 Budget Request with
Treasury Secretary Yellen.''
On March 24, 2023, the Committee held a hearing entitled
``The Biden Administration's 2023 Trade Policy Agenda with
United States Trade Representative, Ambassador Tai.''
On May 9, 2023, the Committee held a field hearing entitled
``Trade in America: Securing Supply Chains and Protecting the
American Worker--Staten Island.''
II. EXPLANATION OF THE BILL
A. United States-Taiwan Expedited Double-Tax Relief Act (Title I of the
Bill; Code sections 860C, 871, 881, 882, 884, 894, 897, 1441, 1442, and
7874; new Code sections 894A and 1447)
PRESENT LAW
The following discussion summarizes U.S. taxation of income
from cross-border business activity, with emphasis on how the
rules determine whether the income is subject to tax by the
United States or another jurisdiction in either the Internal
Revenue Code\2\ or in bilateral agreements in which the United
States agrees to relieve double taxation when its jurisdiction
to tax overlaps or is in conflict with that of another
jurisdiction.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Unless otherwise stated, section references are to the Internal
Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the ``Code'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
International law generally recognizes the right of each
sovereign nation to prescribe rules to regulate conduct and
persons (whether natural or juridical) with a sufficient nexus
to the sovereign nation. The nexus may be based on nationality
(i.e., a nexus based on a connection between the relevant
person and the sovereign nation) or may be territorial (i.e., a
nexus based on a connection between the relevant conduct and
the sovereign nation). These concepts have been refined and
adapted to form the principles for determining whether
sufficient nexus with a jurisdiction exists to conclude that
the jurisdiction may enforce its right to tax.
1. U.S. Tax Principles Common to Inbound and Outbound Taxation
Taxes based on where activities occur, or where property is
located, are source-based taxes. The United States generally
taxes the U.S. trades or businesses of foreign persons and
sales or other dispositions of interests in U.S. real property
by foreign persons. In addition, the United States generally
taxes items of income that are paid by U.S. persons to foreign
persons. Most jurisdictions, including the United States, have
rules for determining the source of items of income and expense
in a broad range of categories, such as compensation for
services, dividends, interest, royalties, and gains.
Income taxes based on a person's citizenship, nationality,
or residence are residence-based taxes. The United States
generally imposes residence-based taxation on U.S. persons in
the year in which income is earned. For individuals and
domestic entities, this results in taxing them on their
worldwide income, whether derived in the United States or
abroad, with limited opportunity for deferral of taxation of
income earned by foreign corporations owned by U.S.
shareholders. As explained below, income earned by a resident
of the United States from foreign activities conducted through
a foreign entity generally is subject to U.S. tax in the year
earned or not at all. The United States generally taxes foreign
persons on only U.S.-source income.
The United States imposes source-based taxation on U.S.-
source income of nonresident alien individuals and other
foreign persons. Under this system, the application of the Code
differs depending on whether income arises from outbound
investment (i.e., foreign investments by U.S. persons) or
inbound investment (i.e., U.S. investment by foreign persons).
While the United States taxes inbound and outbound investments
differently, certain rules are common to the taxation of both,
including rules relating to residency, entity classification,
source determination, and transfer pricing.
Residence
The Code defines a U.S. person to include all U.S. citizens
and residents as well as domestic entities such as
partnerships, corporations, trusts and estates.\3\ Partnerships
and corporations are domestic if organized or created under the
laws of the United States, any State, or the District of
Columbia, unless, in the case of a partnership, the Secretary
prescribes otherwise by regulation.\4\ All other partnerships
and corporations (i.e., those organized under the laws of
foreign countries) are foreign.\5\ Other jurisdictions may use
factors such as situs or management and control to determine
residence. As a result, legal entities may have more than one
tax residence, or, in some cases, no residence. In such cases,
bilateral treaties may resolve conflicting claims of residence.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Sec. 7701(a)(30).
\4\Sec. 7701(a)(4) and (10).
\5\Sec. 7701(a)(5) and (9). Entities organized in a possession or
territory of the United States are not considered to have been
organized under the laws of the United States.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exception for corporate inversions
In certain cases, a foreign corporation that acquires a
domestic corporation or partnership may be treated as a
domestic corporation for Federal tax purposes.\6\ This result
generally applies following a transaction in which, pursuant to
a plan or a series of related transactions:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Sec. 7874. The Treasury Department and the IRS have promulgated
detailed guidance, through both regulations and several notices,
addressing these requirements under section 7874 since its enactment in
2004, and have sought to expand the reach of the section or reduce the
tax benefits of inversion transactions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. A domestic corporation becomes a subsidiary of a
foreign-incorporated entity or otherwise transfers
substantially all of its properties to such an entity;
2. The former shareholders of the domestic
corporation hold (by reason of the stock they had held
in the domestic corporation) at least 80 percent (by
vote or value) of the stock of the foreign-incorporated
entity after the transaction (often referred to as
``stock held by reason of''); and
3. The foreign-incorporated entity, considered
together with all companies connected to it by a chain
of greater than 50-percent ownership (the ``expanded
affiliated group''), does not have substantial business
activities in the entity's country of organization,
compared to the total worldwide business activities of
the expanded affiliated group.
If the ``stock held by reason of'' the acquisition is less
than 80 percent, but at least 60 percent of the stock of the
foreign corporation, and the other requirements above are
satisfied, then the foreign corporation is not treated as a
domestic corporation. Instead, the foreign corporation is
considered a surrogate foreign corporation for the acquired
domestic company, which is an expatriated entity that must
recognize certain ``inversion gain'' post-acquisition
restructuring\7\ and may be subject to other consequences under
the provisions enacted in 2017.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\An excise tax may be imposed on certain stock compensation of
executives of companies that undertake inversion transactions. Sec.
4985. In addition, dividends from certain surrogate foreign
corporations are excluded from qualified dividend income within the
meaning of section 1(h)(11)(B) and are ineligible to be taxed as net
capital gains. Sec. 1(h)(11)(C)(iii). As a result, individual
shareholders in such corporations cannot claim the reduced rate on
dividends otherwise available under section 1(h)(11).
\8\See secs. 59A(d)(4) (providing that payments made to expatriated
entities that reduce gross receipts are base erosion payments) and
965(l) (disallowing the partial participation exemption deduction for
computing the transition tax and assessing the additional transition
tax in the year of inversion if an entity inverts within the 10-year
period beginning on December 22, 2017).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Source of income rules
Various factors determine the source of income for U.S. tax
purposes, including the status or nationality of the payor or
recipient and the location of the activities or assets that
generate the income. Extensive rules determine whether income
is considered to be from U.S. sources or foreign sources.\9\
Special rules are provided for certain industries, (e.g.,
transportation, shipping, and certain space and ocean
activities) as well as for income partly from within and partly
from without the United States.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Sections 861 through 865, generally.
\10\Sec. 863.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gains, profits, and income from the sale or exchange of
inventory property that is either (1) produced (in whole or in
part) inside the United States and then sold or exchanged
outside the United States or (2) produced (in whole or part)
outside the United States and then sold or exchanged inside the
United States is allocated and apportioned solely on the basis
of the location of the production activities.\11\ For example,
income derived from the sale of inventory produced entirely in
the United States is wholly from U.S. sources, even if title
passage occurs elsewhere. Likewise, income derived from the
sale of inventory produced entirely in another country is
wholly from foreign sources, even if title passage occurs in
the United States. If inventory is produced only partly in the
United States, the income derived from its sale is sourced
partly in the United States regardless of where title to the
property passes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Sec. 863(b). Prior to Public Law 115-97, enacted on December
22, 2017, the source of income from sale of inventory was determined by
passage of title.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. U.S. Tax Rules Applicable to Foreign Activities of U.S. Persons
In general, income earned directly by a U.S. person from
the conduct of a foreign trade or business is taxed
currently,\12\ while income earned indirectly through certain
related foreign entities (i.e., controlled foreign corporations
(``CFCs''))\13\ is taxed in the year earned or not at all.
Earnings and profits of CFCs are generally taxable in one of
two ways. First, the earnings may constitute income to U.S.
shareholders under the traditional anti-deferral regime of
subpart F, which applies to certain passive income and income
that is readily movable from one jurisdiction to another.\14\
Subpart F was designed as an anti-abuse regime to prevent U.S.
taxpayers from shifting passive and mobile income to low-tax
jurisdictions.\15\ Second, the earnings may be subject to
section 951A, which applies to some foreign-source income of a
CFC that is not subpart F income (referred to as global
intangible low-taxed income (``GILTI'')). GILTI was enacted as
a base protection measure to counter the participation
exemption system, established by the dividends-received-
deduction, under which the income could potentially be
distributed back to the U.S. corporation with no U.S. tax
imposed.\16\ Subpart F income is taxed at full rates with
related foreign taxes generally eligible for the foreign tax
credit; GILTI is taxed at reduced rates with additional
limitations on the use of related foreign tax credits. Both
subpart F income and GILTI are included by the U.S. shareholder
without regard to whether the earnings are distributed by the
CFC.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Such income is called foreign branch income.
\13\A CFC generally is defined as any foreign corporation in which
U.S. persons own (directly, indirectly, or constructively) more than 50
percent of the corporation's stock (measured by vote or value), taking
into account only ``U.S. shareholders,'' that is, U.S. persons who own
at least 10 percent of the stock (measured by vote or value). See secs.
951(b), 957, and 958. Special rules apply with respect to U.S. persons
that are shareholders (regardless of their percentage ownership) in any
foreign corporation that is not a CFC but is a passive foreign
investment company (``PFIC''). See secs. 1291 through 1298. The PFIC
rules generally seek to prevent the deferral of passive income through
the use of foreign corporations.
\14\Subpart F comprises sections 951 through 965.
\15\See JCS-5-61, ``Tax Effects of Conducting Foreign Business
through Foreign Corporations'' (July 21, 1961), Part V. See also Rev.
Act. of 1962, Pub. L. No. 87-834.
\16\See Reconciliation Recommendations Pursuant to H. Con. Res. 71
(December 2017).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to the taxation of GILTI at reduced rates, U.S.
corporations generally are taxed at reduced rates on their
foreign-derived intangible income (``FDII'').\17\ Foreign
earnings not subject to tax as subpart F income or GILTI
generally are exempt from U.S. tax. To exempt those earnings,
dividends received by corporate U.S. shareholders from
specified 10-percent owned foreign corporations (including
CFCs) generally are eligible for a 100-percent dividends-
received deduction (``DRD'').\18\ Special rules apply in
situations in which a U.S. person transfers property to a
foreign corporation or certain partnerships in certain
nonrecognition transactions.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\Sec. 250(a)(1)(A).
\18\Sec. 245A. The DRD is not limited to dividends from CFCs, but
rather may be available with respect to any dividend received from a
specified 10-percent owned foreign corporation by a domestic
corporation which is a U.S. shareholder with respect to such foreign
corporation.
\19\Secs. 367 and 721(c); Treas. Reg. sec. 1.721(c)-1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. U.S. Tax Rules Applicable to Foreign Persons
Nonresident aliens and foreign corporations generally are
subject to U.S. tax only on their U.S.-source income. There are
two broad types of taxation of U.S.-source income of foreign
taxpayers: (1) gross-basis tax on income that is ``fixed or
determinable annual or periodical gains, profits, and income''
(i.e., FDAP income), and (2) net-basis tax on income that is
``effectively connected with the conduct of a trade or business
within the United States'' (i.e., ECI). FDAP income, although
nominally subject to a statutory 30-percent gross-basis tax
withheld at its source, in many cases is subject to a reduced
rate of, or entirely exempt from, U.S. tax under the Code or a
bilateral income tax treaty. ECI generally is subject to the
same U.S. tax rules and rates that apply to business income
earned by U.S. persons.
Finally, certain corporations are subject to a base erosion
and anti-abuse tax (``BEAT'') that is in the nature of a
minimum tax and payable in addition to all other tax
liabilities.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\Sec. 59A.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Gross-basis taxation of U.S.-source income
FDAP income received by foreign persons from U.S. sources
is subject to a 30-percent gross-basis tax (i.e., a tax on
gross income without reduction for related expenses), which is
collected by withholding at the source of the payment. FDAP
income includes interest, dividends, rents, salaries, wages,
premiums, annuities, compensations, remunerations, and
emoluments.\21\ The items enumerated in defining FDAP income
are illustrative, and the words ``annual or periodical'' are
``merely generally descriptive'' of the payments within the
purview of the statute.\22\ The categories of income subject to
the 30-percent tax and the categories for which withholding is
required generally are coextensive.\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Secs. 871(a) and 881. FDAP income that is ECI is taxed as ECI.
\22\Commissioner v. Wodehouse, 337 U.S. 369, 393 (1949).
\23\See secs. 1441 and 1442.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusions from FDAP income
FDAP income encompasses a broad range of gross income but
has important exceptions. Capital gains of nonresident aliens
generally are foreign source; however, capital gains of
nonresident aliens present in the United States for 183 days or
more\24\ during the year are income from U.S. sources subject
to gross-basis taxation.\25\ In addition, U.S.-source gains
from the sale or exchange of intangibles are subject to tax and
withholding if they are contingent on the productivity, use, or
disposition of the property sold.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\For purposes of this rule, whether a person is considered a
resident in the United States is determined by application of the rules
under section 7701(b).
\25\Sec. 871(a)(2). In addition, certain capital gains from sales
of U.S. real property interests are subject to tax as ECI under the
Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act of 1980 (``FIRPTA''). See
sec. 897(a)(1).
\26\Secs. 871(a)(1)(D) and 881(a)(4).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Interest on bank deposits may qualify for exemption from
treatment as FDAP income on two grounds. First, interest on
deposits with domestic banks and savings and loan associations,
and certain amounts held by insurance companies, is U.S.-source
income but is exempt from the 30-percent tax when paid to a
foreign person.\27\ Second, interest on deposits with foreign
branches of domestic banks and domestic savings and loan
associations is not U.S.-source income and, thus, is not
subject to U.S. tax.\28\ Interest and original issue discount
on certain short-term obligations also is exempt from U.S. tax
when paid to