Committee Action
113TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearings
On June 24, 2014, the Subcommittee on Health, Employment,
Labor, and Pensions (HELP) held a National Labor Relations
Board (NLRB or Board) oversight hearing titled ``What Should
Workers and Employers Expect Next from the National Labor
Relations Board?'' Witnesses were Mr. Andrew F. Puzder, CEO,
CKE Restaurants Holdings, Inc., Carpinteria, CA; Mr. Seth H.
Borden, Partner, McKenna Long & Aldridge, New York, NY; Mr.
James B. Coppess, Associate General Counsel, AFL--CIO,
Washington, D.C.; and Mr. G. Roger King, Of Counsel, Jones Day,
Columbus, OH. Witnesses discussed upcoming NLRB cases and
policy and cited changes to the joint employer standard as one
of the most significant and controversial issues before the
Board at that time.
On September 9, 2014, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
on potential changes to the NLRB's joint employer standard
titled ``Expanding Joint Employer Status: What Does It Mean for
Workers and Job Creators?'' Witnesses were Mr. Todd Duffield,
Shareholder, Ogletree, Deakins, Nash, Smoak and Stewart,
Atlanta, GA; Mr. Clint Ehlers, President, FASTSIGNS of
Lancaster and Willow Grove, Lancaster and Willow Grove, PA,
testifying on behalf of the International Franchise
Association; Mr. Harris Freeman, Professor, Western New England
University School of Law, Springfield, MAs; Ms. Catherine
Monson, Chief Executive Officer, FASTSIGNS International, Inc.,
Carrollton, TX, testifying on behalf of the International
Franchise Association; and Mrs. Jagruti Panwala, owner of
multiple hotel franchises in the northeastern United States,
Bensalem, PA. Witnesses spoke about how an expanded joint
employer standard would negatively impact franchises and other
small businesses.
114TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On August 25, 2015, the HELP Subcommittee held a field
hearing titled ``Redefining `Employer' and the Impact on
Alabama's Workers and Small Business Owners'' in Mobile,
Alabama, in anticipation of the NLRB creating a new joint
employer standard. Witnesses were Mr. Marcel Debruge, Burr and
Forman LLP, Birmingham, AL; Mr. Chris Holmes, CEO, CLH
Development Holdings, Tallahassee, L; and Col. Steve Carey,
USAF, Ret., Owner and Operator, CertaPro Painters of Mobile and
Baldwin Counties, Daphne, AL, testifying on behalf of the
Coalition to Save Local Businesses and the International
Franchise Association. Witnesses testified that the new joint
employer standard would threaten the independence of small
businesses and deter franchisors from licensing new
franchisees.
On August 27, 2015, the HELP Subcommittee held a field
hearing titled ``Redefining `Employer' and the Impact on
Georgia's Workers and Small Business Owners'' in Savannah,
Georgia, regarding the NLRB's joint employer standard.
Witnesses were Mr. Jeffrey M. Mintz, Shareholder, Littler
Mendelson, P.C., Atlanta, GA; Mr. Kalpesh ``Kal'' Patel,
President and COO, Image Hotels, Inc., Pooler, GA; Mr. Alex
Salguerio, Savannah Restaurants Corp., Savannah, GA; and Mr.
Fred Weir, President, Meadowbrook Restaurant Company Inc.,
Cumming, GA, testifying on behalf of the Coalition to Save
Local Businesses and the International Franchise Association.
Witnesses testified the new joint employer standard would hurt
small business growth in Georgia and create barriers to entry
for potential franchise owners.
On September 29, 2015, the HELP Subcommittee held a
legislative hearing on H.R. 3459, the Protecting Local Business
Opportunity Act. Witnesses at the hearing were Mr. Ed Braddy,
President, Winlee Foods, LLC, Timonium, MD, testifying on
behalf of himself and the National Franchisee Association; Mr.
Kevin Cole, CEO, Enniss Electric Company, Manassas, VA,
testifying on behalf of the Independent Electrical Contractors;
Mr. Charles Cohen, former Member of the NLRB and Senior
Counsel, Morgan, Lewis & Bockius, LLP, Washington, D.C.; Ms.
Mara Fortin, President and CEO, Nothing Bundt Cakes, San Diego,
CA, testifying on behalf of herself and the Coalition to Save
Local Businesses; Mr. Michael Harper, Professor, Boston
University School of Law, Boston, MA; and Dr. Anne Lofaso,
Professor, West Virginia University College of Law, Morgantown,
WV. Witnesses testified that H.R. 3459 would restore the joint
employer standard that had worked well for workers and business
owners for decades and would protect opportunities for small
business growth.
First Session--Legislative Action
On September 9, 2015, then-Committee on Education and the
Workforce (Committee) Chairman John Kline (R-MN) introduced the
Protecting Local Business Opportunity Act (H.R. 3459, 114th
Congress). Recognizing the threat to small businesses posed by
the NLRB's August 2015 decision in Browning-Ferris Industries
of California, Inc. (Browning-Ferris),\1\ the legislation
amended the NLRA to restore the long-held standard that two or
more employers can only be considered joint employers for
purposes of the Act if each shares and exercises control over
essential terms and conditions of employment and such control
over these matters is actual, direct and immediate.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\362 NLRB No. 186 (2015).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On October 28, 2015, the Committee considered and marked up
H.R. 3459, the Protecting Local Business Opportunity Act.
Representative Buddy Carter (R-GA) offered an amendment in the
nature of a substitute, making a technical change to clarify
the Act. The Committee voted to adopt the amendment in the
nature of a substitute by voice vote. The Committee then
favorably reported H.R. 3459, as amended, to the House of
Representatives by a vote of 21 to 15.
115TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On February 14, 2017, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
titled ``Restoring Balance and Fairness to the National Labor
Relations Board.'' Witnesses decried the extreme, partisan
decisions of the NLRB during the Obama administration,
including the expanded joint employer standard. Witnesses were
Ms. Reem Aloul, BrightStar Care of Arlington, Arlington, VA,
testifying on behalf of the Coalition to Save Local Businesses;
Ms. Susan Davis, Partner, Cohen, Weiss and Simon, LLP, New
York, NY; Mr. Raymond J. LaJeunesse, Jr., Vice President,
National Right to Work Legal Defense and Education Foundation,
Springfield, VA; and, Mr. Kurt G. Larkin, Partner, Hunton &
Williams LLP, Richmond, VA.
On July 12, 2017, the Committee held a hearing titled
``Redefining Joint Employer Standards: Barriers to Job Creation
and Entrepreneurship'' to examine the impact of expanding joint
employer standards across federal labor laws, including the
NLRA and the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). Witnesses were
Mr. Michael Harper, Professor, Boston University School of Law,
Boston, MA; Mr. Richard Heiser, Vice President, FedEx Ground
Package System, Inc., Chicago, IL; Mr. G. Roger King, Senior
Labor and Employment Counsel, HR Policy Association,
Washington, D.C.; Mr. Jerry Reese II, Director of Franchise
Development, Dat Dog, New Orleans, LA, testifying on behalf of
the Coalition to Save Local Businesses; Ms. Catherine K.
Ruckelhaus, General Counsel, National Employment Law Project,
New York, NY; and Ms. Mary Kennedy Thompson, Chief Operating
Officer of Franchise Brands, Dwyer Group, Waco, TX, testifying
on behalf of the International Franchise Association. Witnesses
testified about the importance of reigning in expanding joint
employer standards.
On September 13, 2017, the HELP and Workforce Protections
Subcommittees held a joint legislative hearing on H.R. 3441.
Witnesses were Mr. Zachary D. Fasman, Partner, Proskauer Rose
LLP, New York, NY; Ms. Tamara Kennedy, President, Twin Cities
T.J.'s Inc., Roseville, MN, testifying on behalf of the
Coalition to Save Local Businesses; Mr. Granger MacDonald,
Chief Executive Officer, The MacDonald Companies, Kerrville,
TX, testifying on behalf of the National Association of Home
Builders; and Mr. Michael Rubin, Partner, Altshuler Berzon LLP,
San Francisco, CA. Witnesses testified that H.R. 3441 clarifies
the joint employer standard used under both the NLRA and FLSA
and benefits workers and business owners.
First Session--Legislative Action
On July 27, 2017, then-Subcommittee on Workforce
Protections Chairman Bradley Byrne (R-AL) introduced the Save
Local Business Act (H.R. 3441, 115th Congress). In response to
expanding joint employer standards under the NLRA and FLSA, the
bill amends both laws to provide that two or more employers can
only be considered joint employers if each shares and exercises
control over essential terms and conditions of employment and
if such control over those matters is actual, direct, and
immediate.
On October 4, 2017, the Committee considered and marked up
H.R. 3441. Then-Subcommittee on Workforce Protections Chairman
Byrne offered an amendment in the nature of a substitute,
making technical changes.\2\ The Committee voted to adopt the
amendment in the nature of a substitute by voice vote. The
Committee then favorably reported H.R. 3441, as amended, to the
House of Representatives by a vote of 23 to 17. On November 7,
2017, H.R. 3441 passed the House by a vote of 242 to 181.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\The amendment in the nature of a substitute clarified that a
list of terms and conditions of employment included in the act are
examples of what can be considered in a joint employer analysis, but
not a comprehensive list, and control of every term and condition is
not required for joint employment to be found.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
116TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On May 8, 2019, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing titled
``Protecting the Right to Organize Act: Deterring Unfair Labor
Practices.'' Witnesses were Mr. Roger King, Senior Labor and
Employment Counsel, HR Policy Association, Arlington, VA; Mr.
Josue Alvarez, Truck Driver, XPO Logistics, Bell Gardens, CA;
Ms. Charlotte Garden, Associate Professor, Seattle University
School of Law, Seattle, WA; and Mr. Richard Griffin, Of
Counsel, Bredhoff and Kaiser, P.L.L.C, Washington, D.C.
Republican Members and Mr. King criticized the Protecting the
Right to Organize Act's potential harmful impact on workers and
businesses, including its expanded joint employer standard.
On July 25, 2019, the HELP Subcommittee held a hearing
titled ``Protecting the Right to Organize Act: Modernizing
America's Labor Laws.'' Witnesses were Mr. Richard Trumka,
President, AFL-CIO, Washington, D.C.; Mr. Jim Status, Former
University of Pittsburgh Medical Center Employee, Pittsburgh,
PA; Mr. Phillip Miscimarra, Senior Fellow, The Wharton School,
University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA; and Mr. Mark
Gaston, Former Chairman, NLRB, Washington, D.C. Republican
Members and Mr. Miscimarra criticized the Protecting the Right
to Organize Act's expanded joint employer standard, among other
provisions.
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On March 28, 2023, the Committee held a hearing titled
``Unleashing America's Opportunities for Hiring and
Employment.'' Witnesses were Chris Spear, President, American
Trucking Association, Washington, D.C.; Mr. Jerry Akers,
Franchisee/Owner, Sharpness, Inc. DBA Great Clips and the Joint
Chiropractic, Palo, IA; Dr. Heidi Shirholz, President, Economic
Policy Institute, Washington, D.C.; and Mr. Stephen Moore,
Senior Fellow in Economics, Heritage Foundation, Washington,
D.C. Witnesses discussed how Biden administration policies,
including the NLRB's joint employer proposed rule, were making
it harder to create jobs and overcome inflation.
First Session--Legislative Action
On November 9, 2023, Representative John James (R-MI)
introduced H.J. Res 98, Providing for congressional disapproval
under chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of the rule
submitted by the National Labor Relations Board relating to
``Standard for Determining Joint Employer Status'' with
Chairwoman Virginia Foxx (R-NC) and Representatives Mike
Johnson (R-LA), Jim Banks (R-IN), Aaron Bean (R-FL), Earl L.
``Buddy'' Carter (R-GA), Tom Cole (R-OK), James Comer (R-KY),
Eric A. ``Rick'' Crawford (R-AR), Jeff Duncan (R-SC), Scott
Fitzgerald (R-WI), Bob Good (R-VA), Lance Gooden (R-TX), Diana
Harshbarger (R-TN), Clay Higgins (R-LA), Ashley Hinson (R-IA),
Erin Houchin (R-IN), Jake LaTurner (R-OK), Julia Letlow (R-LA),
Lisa McClain (R-MI), John R. Moolenaar (R-MI), Alexander X.
Mooney (R-WV), Greg Pence (R-IN), John W. Rose (R-TN), Adrian
Smith (R-NE), Michelle Steel (R-CA), Glenn Thompson (R-PA), Tim
Walberg (R-MI), Elise Stefanik (R-NY), and David G. Valadao (R-
CA). The resolution was referred to the Committee on Education
and the Workforce.
On December 12, 2023, the Committee considered H.J. Res. 98
in legislative session and reported it favorably to the House
of Representatives by a recorded vote of 25-20.
COMMITTEE VIEWS
INTRODUCTION
Small businesses are still recovering from the pandemic,
and owners are not optimistic about the current economic
environment.\3\ Survey after survey finds inflation is the top
challenge for small businesses.\4\ ``Bidenomics'' and the
current administration's policies have led to skyrocketing
inflation and high prices for American households and
employers. Consumer sentiment is equally pessimistic, falling
for the fourth straight month, according to the University of
Michigan Survey of Consumers.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\https://www.nfib.com/content/press-release/economy/nfib-
celebrates-50-years-of-small-business-economic-data-with-october-
survey/.
\4\https://www.uschamber.com/sbindex/quarterly-spotlight.
\5\http://www.sca.isr.umich.edu/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Instead of changing course in light of economic conditions,
the Biden administration has continued to issue costly
regulations that harm workers, small businesses, and consumers.
In total, the Biden administration has finalized 724
regulations, costing $434.8 billion and imposing 223,725,800
paperwork burden hours on the public.\6\ Such rapid
accumulation of rules slows economic growth\7\ while imposing
more significant costs on small businesses.\8\ The NLRB's
``Standard for Determining Joint Employer Status''
significantly adds to existing regulatory burdens and will
cause devastating economic consequences for small businesses,
workers, consumers, and the economy.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\https://www.regrodeo.com/
?year%5B0%5D=2023&year%5B1%5D=2022&year%5B2%5D=2021.
\7\https://www.mercatus.org/research/policy-briefs/regulatory-
accumulation
-and-its-costs#::text=By%20distorting%20the%20investment%
20choices,rate%20of%20the%20US%20GDP.
\8\https://ldr.lafayette.edu/concern/publications/6q182k69n.
\9\Standard for Determining Joint-Employer Status, 88 Fed. Reg.
53,946 (Oct. 27, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Background on joint employer status under the National Labor Relations
Act
Predictability and transparency are crucial to upholding
the rule of law. Regulated parties deserve clear rules and
standards that make it obvious what is proscribed or permitted
by law. Without a clear understanding of the rules, it is
extremely difficult for the regulated community to plan for the
future or know how to act in order to comply with the rules.
H.J. Res. 98 will bring the necessary certainty to the joint
employer standard under the National Labor Relations Act
(NLRA).
From 1984 to August 2015, the NLRB's joint employer
standard provided such certainty and clarity. It examined
whether two or more employers shared control over or co-
determined the essential terms and conditions of employment to
determine whether two separate entities should be considered
``joint employers'' under the NLRA.\10\ Essential terms and
conditions of employment included hiring, firing, discipline,
supervision, and direction of employees. Under this standard,
the joint employers' control over these employment matters must
have been actual, direct, and immediate.\11\ This predictable
and clear standard ensured employers would not be saddled with
collective bargaining obligations or with liability of a
company they do not control.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\TLI, Inc., 271 NLRB 798 (1984), overruled by Browning-Ferris
Indus. of Calif., Inc., 362 NLRB No. 186 (2015).
\11\See Airborne Express, 338 NLRB 597, 597 n.1 (2002) (``[The]
essential element in [joint employer] analysis is whether a putative
joint employer's control over employment matters is direct and
immediate.''); AM Prop. Holding Corp., 350 NLRB 998, 1000 (2007) (``In
assessing whether a joint employer relationship exists, the Board . . .
looks to the actual practice of the parties.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2015, the Obama NLRB issued a decision in Browning-
Ferris Industries of California (Browning-Ferris) that upended
decades of Board precedent by dramatically expanding the
definition of joint employer under the NLRA.\12\ Under this
standard, two entities were deemed joint employers based on the
mere existence of reserved control, indirect control, or
control that was limited and routine. As a result, Browning-
Ferris greatly increased the universe of potential joint
employers.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Browning-Ferris Industries of California, Inc., 362 NLRB No.
186 (2015).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2018, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of
Columbia Circuit upheld portions of Browning-Ferris.\13\ While
the D.C. Circuit ruled that evidence of reserved or indirect
control could be appropriate factors in determining joint
employer status, the court also ruled that the Board applied
the concept of ``indirect control'' too broadly.\14\ The D.C.
Circuit returned the case to the Board, directing that it
reevaluate the case by considering ``indirect control'' of only
those factors directly related to the terms and conditions of
employment of the relevant employees.\15\ The court noted that
by ``failing to distinguish evidence of indirect control that
bears on workers'' essential terms and conditions from evidence
that simply documents the routine parameters of company-to-
company contracting,'' the Board had exceeded its authority and
``overshot the common-law mark.''\16\ Moreover, the court held,
```global oversight' is a routine feature of independent
contracts'' which should not be a factor relevant to the
analysis of a joint-employment relationship.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Browning-Ferris Indus. of Calif., Inc. v. NLRB, 911 F.3d 1195
(D.C. Cir. 2018
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
H.J. Res. 98, Providing for congressional disapproval under
chapter 8 of title 5, United States Code, of the rule submitted
by the National Labor Relations Board relating to ``Standard
for Determining Joint Employer Status,'' would nullify the
National Labor Relations Board's (NLRB's or the Board's) final
joint employer rule ensuring that workers, who are hired
through subcontractors, temporary staffing agencies, and other
intermediaries, can hold all the entities that control their
working conditions accountable for their right to bargain
collectively for higher pay, better benefits, and safer
workplaces. If enacted, H.J. Res. 98 would reinstate the
deficient Trump-era rule that weakened workers' ability to hold
their employers accountable by narrowing the joint employer
standard to only cover entities that directly exercise control
over workers' terms and conditions of employment. H.J. Res. 98
is opposed by numerous organizations including: A Better
Balance, AFL-CIO, American Federation of State, County, and
Municipal Employees, Center for Economic and Policy Research,
Center for Law and Social Policy, Communications Workers of
America, Demos, Economic Policy Institute, International
Brotherhood of Teamsters, Jobs With Justice, National Center
for Law and Economic Justice, National Domestic Workers
Alliance, National Education Association, National Employment
Law Project, National Organization for Women, National
Partnership for Women and Families, National Women's Law
Center, Restaurant Opportunities Centers United, Leadership
Conference on Civil and Human Rights, Legal Aid Society,
Transport Workers Union of America, United Auto Workers, United
Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners of America, United Food
and Commercial Workers International Union, and Young
Invincibles.
HISTORY OF JOINT EMPLOYMENT & THE NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS ACT
For most of the time since the 1935 enactment of the
National Labor Relations Act (NLRA),\1\ the NLRB has held that
an entity may be liable to bargain with the employees of a
contractor as a joint employer even if its control over terms
and conditions of employment was indirect, such as exercised
through an intermediary, or reserved but not yet exercised.\2\
This traditional standard is consistent with the U.S. Supreme
Court's requirement that the NLRB interpret the NLRA's
definition of employer as consistent with the common law\3\ as
well as with the legislative history of the NLRA's 1947
amendments.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\29 U.S.C. Sec. Sec. 151-169.
\2\See, e.g., Greyhound Corp., 153 NLRB 1488, 1495 (1965) (the
first case in which the Board examined the right to control employees'
work and their terms and conditions of employment as determinative in
analyzing whether entities were joint employers of particular
employees); TLI, Inc., 271 NLRB 798 (1984) (finding that two separate
entities are joint employers of a single work force if the evidence
shows that they ``share or codetermine those matters governing the
essential terms and conditions of employment''); Floyd Epperson, 202
NLRB 23, 23 (1973) (finding joint employer status where client employer
had ``some indirect control over [employees'] wages'' and ``some
control, albeit indirect, over [employee] discipline''), enforced 491
F.2d 1390 (6th Cir. 1974); Franklin Stores Corp., 199 NLRB 52, 53
(1972) (finding joint employment where one employer, ``by virtue of the
lease arrangement with'' the other employer, ``has the right to veto
the employment of employees by'' the other ``and to insist on the
discharge of employees by'' the other).
\3\See NLRB v. United Ins. Co. of America, 390 U.S. 254, 256 (1968)
(requiring the Board to ``apply general agency principles in
distinguishing between employees and independent contractors under the
Act'').
\4\See House Conf. Rep. No. 510 on H.R. 3020 at 32-33 (1947)
reprinted in 1 Legislative History of the Labor Management Relations
Act, 1947, at 536-37 (1948) (explaining the exclusion of independent
contractors from the definition of employee in order to overturn a
Supreme Court decision that ``held that ordinary tests of the law of
agency could be ignored by the Board'' in determining the existence of
employment relationships).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Without providing any explanation, the NLRB departed from
this traditional standard in 1984, discounting indirect and
reserved control from the joint employer analysis in two
decisions.\5\ In another decision in 2002, the NLRB explicitly
limited the joint employer standard to only ``direct and
immediate'' control.\6\ In recent decades, temporary and
contingent employment arrangements proliferated rapidly, and
the NLRB's departure from the common law enabled corporations
to use intermediaries to evade any obligation to bargain
collectively with workers.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\TLI, Inc., 271 NLRB 798, 803 (1984); Laerco Transportation, 269
NLRB 324, 325-26 (1984).
\6\Airborne Freight Co., 338 NLRB 597 (2002) (finding the
``essential element'' to be ``whether a putative joint employer's
control over employment matters is direct and immediate'').
\7\Testimony of Catherine K. Ruckelshaus, EDUC. & THE WRKF. COMM.
DEMS. (July 12, 2017), https://democrats-edworkforce.house.gov/
hearings/redefining-joint-employer-standards-barriers-to-job-creation-
and-entrepreneurship, at 4 (``Between 2005 and 2015, the number of
contract workers grew by more than half, while the overall workforce
grew by only five percent.'') (submitted to Redefining Joint Employer
Standards: Hearing Before the H. Comm. on Educ. & the Wrkf., 115th
Cong. (Jul. 12, 2017)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the 2015 Browning-Ferris decision, the NLRB restored
earlier precedent considering an entity's reserved and indirect
control over working conditions.\8\ The NLRB's previous
Republican majority initiated an attempt to overturn Browning-
Ferris by rulemaking.\9\ While that rulemaking was pending, the
D.C. Circuit upheld Browning-Ferris ``as fully consistent with
the common law [because] both reserved authority to control and
indirect control can be relevant factors in the joint-employer
analysis.''\10\ Specifically, the court held that consideration
of a company's right to control ``is an established aspect of
the common law of agency,'' and that Browning-Ferris was also
correct that ``an employer's indirect control over employees
can be a relevant consideration.''\11\ The D.C. Circuit also
warned that, ``[t]he Board's rulemaking . . . must color within
the common-law lines identified by the judiciary.''\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\362 NLRB 1599, 1600 (2015).
\9\See The Standard for Determining Joint Employer Status, 83 Fed.
Reg. 46681 (Sept. 14, 2018).
\10\Browning-Ferris Indus. of Cal. v. NLRB, 911 F.3d 1195, 1222
(D.C. Cir. 2018).
\11\Id. at 1209.
\12\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rather than adhering to the court's warning, in 2020, the
NLRB's Republican majority issued a final rule (2020 Rule) that
narrowed the joint employer standard to only cover entities
that ``possess and actually exercise substantial direct and
immediate control over employees'' essential terms and
conditions of employment.''\13\ To justify sidelining
consideration of indirect and reserved control, which the D.C.
Circuit emphasized, the 2020 Rule stated that indirect and
reserved control may still be considered but could not,
``without more[,] establish a joint-employer
relationship.''\14\ In a 2022 decision, the D.C. Circuit
described this claim as ``dubious,'' emphasizing that it ``took
great pains to inform the Board that the failure to consider
reserved or indirect control is inconsistent with the common
law of agency.''\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\The Standard for Determining Joint Employer Status, 85 Fed.
Reg. 11184, 11185 (Feb. 26, 2020) (codified at 29 C.F.R. pt. 103).
\14\Id. at 11220.
\15\Sanitary Truck Drivers & Helpers Local 350 v. NLRB, 45 F.4th
38, 47 (D.C. Cir. 2022) (considering issues in Browning-Ferris that the
Board addressed after the D.C. Circuit remanded in 2018).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The 2020 Rule eroded workers' rights significantly. For
example, as Committee Democrats observed, the failure to
include safety in the list of ``essential terms and conditions
of employment'' meant that ``if a hospital controls the
workplace safety standards, but refuses to bargain with the
temporary agency workers, these workers will lack recourse
against the party setting working conditions.''\16\ More
broadly, the 2020 Rule created what the AFL CIO described as
``a roadmap to retain ultimate control over key aspects of
workers'' lives--like wages and working conditions--while
avoiding their duty to bargain'':\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\H. COMM. ON EDUC. & LAB., CORRUPTION, CONFLICTS, AND CRISIS:
THE NLRB'S ASSAULT ON WORKERS' RIGHTS UNDER THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION 3
(Oct. 2020), https://democrats-edworkforce.house.gov/imo/media/doc/
NLRB%20Report%20(Final).pdf.
\17\House Letter Supporting NLRB Joint-Employer Rule, AFL-CIO (Nov.
8, 2023), https://aflcio.org/about/advocacy/legislative-alerts/house-
letter-supporting-nlrb-joint-employer-rule.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Companies are adopting business structures
specifically designed to maintain control over the
workers who keep their businesses running while
simultaneously disclaiming any responsibility for those
workers under labor and employment laws. Such
businesses often insert second and third-level
intermediaries between themselves and their workers.
These companies seek to have it both ways--to control
the workplace like an employer but dodge the legal
responsibilities of an employer. . . .
For example, if employees of a subcontractor were to
unionize and bargain only with the subcontractor, it
might simply refuse to bargain over certain issues
because its contract with the prime contractor governs
those aspects of the work (e.g., pay, hours, safety,
etc.). This harms workers because the entity that
effectively determines workplace policy is not at the
bargaining table, placing workers' desired improvements
out of reach.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The radical change effected by the 2020 Rule ``made it
impossible for hundreds of thousands of workers to access the
rights guaranteed them under the NLRA to join a union and
collectively bargain.''\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\Celine McNicholas et al., EPI Comments on NLRB's Proposed
Rulemaking on the Standard for Determining Joint-Employer Status, ECON.
POL. INST. (Dec. 7, 2022), https://www.epi.org/publication/epi-
comments-on-nlrbs-proposed-rulemaking-on-the-standard-for-determining-
joint-employer-status/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In light of these consequences of the 2020 Rule, the Biden-
era NLRB issued a notice and invitation in September 2022 to
file briefs for a proposed rule to update the standard for
determining joint employer status.\20\ The NLRB issued its new
joint employer rule in October 2023 (2023 Rule),\21\ which will
take effect on February 26, 2024.\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\Standard for Determining Joint-Employer Status, 87 Fed. Reg.
54641 (Sept. 7, 2022).
\21\Standard for Determining Joint Employer Status, 88 Fed. Reg.
73946 (Oct. 27, 2023) [hereinafter 2023 Rule].
\22\Id. at 74017.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The 2023 Rule rescinded the 2020 Rule and adopted a new
standard ``grounded in established common-law agency
principles.''\23\ Specifically, the 2023 Rule restores the
NLRB's ability to consider evidence of an employer's reserved
and/or indirect control, along with direct control, whether it
is exercised or not, if employers share or codetermine one or
more of the employees' essential terms and conditions of
employment when determining joint-employer status. Such
essential terms and conditions are defined as the following:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\Press Release, Off. of Pub. Affs. Nat'l Lab. Rel. Bd. Board
Issues Final Rule on Joint-Employer Status (Oct. 26, 2023), https://
www.nlrb.gov/news-outreach/news-story/board-issues-final-rule-on-joint-
employer-status.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
(1) Wages, benefits, and other compensation;
(2) Hours of work and scheduling;
(3) The assignment of duties to be performed;
(4) The supervision of the performance of duties;
(5) Work rules and directions governing the manner,
means, and methods of the performance of duties and the
grounds for discipline;
(6) The tenure of employment, including hiring and
discharge; and
(7) Working conditions related to the safety and
health of employees.\24\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\2023 Rule, supra note 21, at 74017-74018.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The 2023 Rule aligns with the joint employer provision of
the Protecting the Right to Organize Act of 2023 (PRO Act),\25\
which would require the Board or a court of competent
jurisdiction to consider as relevant direct control, indirect
control, reserved authority to control, and control exercised
in fact.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\Protecting the Right to Organize Act of 2023, H.R. 20, 118th
Cong. (2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE 2023 RULE AND THE ``FISSURED WORKPLACE''
Joint employment is a flashpoint because of the recent
trend toward ``fissuring,'' or the disintegration of the firm
using overlapping arrangements of contracting, subcontracting,
franchising, and temping.\26\ The trend appears to be growing,
especially in low-wage work. ``It seems to be spreading like
wildfire,'' says Nelson Lichtenstein, a Research Professor in
the Department of History at the University of California,
Santa Barbara. ``All of these companies, wherever they possibly
can, want to create a workforce that doesn't work for
them.''\27\ The most visible fissured relationship is temping:
approximately 3.1 million workers in America are employed by a
temporary staffing agency on any given day, performing work on
behalf of a client company that directs their work but does not
write their paycheck.\28\ Fissured work arrangements are
associated with increased incidence of a host of workplace
violations.\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\See generally David Weil, The Fissured Workplace: Why Work
Became So Bad for So Many and What Can Be Done to Improve It (2014).
\27\Dave Jamieson, Romney Campaign Boxes Itself in on Outsourcing,
Offshoring Debate, Huff. Post (June 26, 2012), https://
www.huffpost.com/entry/romney-campaign-outsourcing-
offshore_n_1627761.
\28\Employees on Nonfarm Payrolls by Industry Sector and Selected
Industry Data, Bur. of Lab. Stats., https://www.bls.gov/news.release/
empsit.t17.htm (last visited Oct. 11, 2023).
\29\Weil, supra note 26.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The rise of the ``fissured workplace'' can weaken workers'
bargaining power. Absent an appropriate joint employment
doctrine, workers hired by an intermediary firm but laboring
for a larger, more powerful firm with actual control over their
working conditions and wages will find it difficult to bargain
meaningfully. In an age of increased workplace fissuring, it is
imperative that companies not be able to point to another
entity in order to evade bargaining and liability.
The 2023 Rule's return to the NLRB's traditional standard
is necessary to mitigate the fissuring of the workplace, which
exacerbated in the decades after the NLRB departed from
considering indirect and reserved control.\30\ If a lead
business controls any of its subsidiary's workers' terms and
conditions of employment but is not deemed a joint employer,
then those workers cannot engage in collective bargaining with
the lead business to improve their terms and conditions of
employment that are within the lead business's control.\31\
This opens workers to retaliation even when they attempt to
organize a union with the subsidiary alone.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\H. Comm. on Educ. & Lab., The Future of Work: How Congress Can
Support Workers in the Modern Economy 4-5 (2020), https://democrats-
edworkforce.house.gov/imo/media/doc/
Future%20of%20Work%20Report%20(FINAL).pdf [hereinafter The Future of
Work]; see also Ruckelshaus Testimony, supra note 7, at 4.
\31\The Future of Work, supra note 30, at 6.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
By holding employers accountable for their bargaining
obligations when they exercise control, whether direct or
indirect, organized workers can engage in meaningful
negotiations and share in the prosperity they have helped
create. According to the Economic Policy Institute (EPI), the
Biden-era NLRB's proposed 2023 Rule is estimated to raise
workers' earnings by $1.06 billion dollars annually.\32\
Conversely, the Trump-era NLRB's 2020 Rule would transfer $1.3
billion each year from workers to their bosses.\33\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\32\McNicholas et al., supra note 19.
\33\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE 2023 RULE'S IMPACT ON SMALL BUSINESS
The 2023 Rule's potential impact on small businesses has
been thoroughly reviewed. In accordance with the Regulatory
Flexibility Act of 1980,\34\ the NLRB, prior to finalizing the
2023 Rule, conducted an Initial Regulatory Flexibility Analysis
of its impact on small businesses. The analysis concluded that
``since the only quantifiable impact that [the NLRB] ha[s]
identified is the $151.51 or $99.64 that may be incurred in
reviewing and understanding the rule, [the NLRB] d