Minority Views
The Committee on the Judiciary, having considered this
Report, reports favorably thereon and recommends that the
Report be approved.
The form of the Resolution that the Committee on the
Judiciary would recommend to the House of Representatives
citing Robert Hunter Biden for contempt of Congress pursuant to
this Report is as follows:
Resolved, That Robert Hunter Biden shall be found to be in
contempt of Congress for failure to comply with a congressional
subpoena.
Resolved, That pursuant to 2 U.S.C. Sec. Sec. 192 and 194,
the Speaker of the House of Representatives shall certify the
report of the Committee on the Judiciary, detailing the refusal
of Robert Hunter Biden to appear for a deposition before the
Committee on the Judiciary as directed by subpoena, to an
appropriate United States attorney, to the end that Mr. Biden
be proceeded against in the manner and form provided by law.
Resolved, That the Speaker of the House shall otherwise
take all appropriate action to enforce the subpoena.
CONTENTS
Page
Executive Summary................................................ 2
Authority and Purpose............................................ 3
Background on the Investigation.................................. 5
A. The Committees Seek Information from Hunter Biden Central
to the Investigative Purpose of the Impeachment Inquiry of
President Joe Biden and the Committees' Legislative
Oversight Investigation.................................... 7
B. Hunter Biden's Refusal to Comply with the Committees'
Subpoenas for a Deposition................................. 11
C. Hunter Biden's Purported Reasons for Non-Compliance with
the Subpoenas Are Without Merit............................ 14
D. Precedent Supports the Committees' Decision to Proceed
with Holding Hunter Biden in Contempt...................... 16
Conclusion....................................................... 17
Committee Consideration.......................................... 17
Committee Votes.................................................. 18
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 28
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures........................ 28
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 28
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 28
Advisory on Earmarks............................................. 28
Minority Views................................................... 28
Executive Summary
On December 13, 2023, Robert Hunter Biden failed to comply
with deposition subpoenas issued by the Committees on the
Judiciary and Oversight and Accountability for testimony
relevant to the House of Representatives' impeachment inquiry
and the Committees' oversight investigations.\1\ Instead, Mr.
Biden opted to read a short, prepared statement in front of the
Capitol. Accordingly, Mr. Biden has violated federal law,\2\
and must be held in contempt of Congress. Mr. Biden's testimony
is a critical component of the impeachment inquiry into, among
other things, whether Joseph R. Biden, Jr., as Vice President
and/or President: (1) took any official action or effected any
change in government policy because of money or other things of
value provided to himself or his family; (2) abused his office
of public trust by providing foreign interests with access to
him and his office in exchange for payments to his family or
him; or (3) abused his office of public trust by knowingly
participating in a scheme to enrich himself or his family by
giving foreign interests the impression that they would receive
access to him and his office in exchange for payments to his
family or him.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Letter from Rep. Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm. on the
Judiciary, and Rep. James Comer, Chairman, H. Comm. on Oversight &
Accountability, to Abbe D. Lowell, Partner, Winston & Strawn LLP (Nov.
8, 2023) [hereinafter ``Nov. 8 Letter''].
\2\See 2 U.S.C. Sec. 192 (``Every person who having been summoned
as a witness by the authority of either House of Congress to give
testimony . . . upon any matter under inquiry before either House . . .
or any committee of either House of Congress, willfully makes default .
. . shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor . . . .'').
\3\Nov. 8 Letter, supra note 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The testimony sought by the subpoenas is also relevant to
ongoing efforts to craft legislative reforms to federal ethics
and financial disclosure laws. The Committees seek to craft
legislative solutions that provide transparency when the
President's or Vice President's family members engage in
lucrative financial transactions. As part of our investigation,
the Committees seek to craft legislative solutions aimed at
deficiencies we have identified in the current legal framework
regarding ethics laws and the disclosure of financial interests
related to the immediate family members of Vice Presidents and
Presidents--deficiencies that may place American national
security and interests at risk. Specifically, the Committees
are concerned that foreign nationals appear to have sought
access and influence by engaging in lucrative business
relationships with high-profile political figures' immediate
family members.
Mr. Biden's flagrant defiance of the Committees' deposition
subpoenas--while choosing to appear nearby on the Capitol
grounds to read a prepared statement on the same matters--is
contemptuous, and he must be held accountable for his unlawful
actions. Accordingly, the Chairman of the Committee on the
Judiciary recommends that Congress find Robert Hunter Biden in
contempt for his failure to comply with the Committee subpoena
issued to him.
Authority and Purpose
The Constitution vests the House of Representatives with
the ``sole Power of Impeachment''\4\ and provides that the
``President, Vice President and all civil Officers of the
United States, shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for,
and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and
Misdemeanors.''\5\ As the U.S. Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia Circuit has stated, ``[t]o level the grave
accusation that a President may have committed `Treason,
Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors,' U.S. Const.
art. II, Sec. 4, the House must be appropriately informed.''\6\
Congress's authority to access information during an
impeachment investigation can be broader in certain instances
than in a purely legislative investigation,\7\ a fact that the
Executive Branch traditionally has recognized.\8\ An
impeachment inquiry is the traditional means by which the House
assembles and evaluates relevant information.\9\ Indeed,
conducting an impeachment inquiry without all pertinent
evidence would be an affront to the Constitution and
irreparably damage public faith in the impeachment process.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\U.S. Const. art. I, Sec. 2, cl. 5.
\5\Id. art. II, Sec. 4.
\6\Comm. on Judiciary of U.S. House of Representatives v. McGahn,
968 F.3d 755, 765 (D.C. Cir. 2020) (en banc).
\7\Todd Garvey, Cong. Rsch. Serv.: Legal Sidebar, LSB11083,
Impeachment Investigations, Part II: Access, at 1 (2023) (``[T]here is
reason to believe that invocation of the impeachment power could
improve the committees' legal claims of access to certain types of
evidence relevant to the allegations of misconduct against President
Biden.''). See also In re Application of Comm. on Judiciary, 414 F.
Supp. 3d 129, 176 (D. D.C. 2019) (``[D]enying [the House Judiciary
Committee] evidence relevant to an impeachment inquiry could pose
constitutional problems.''), aff'd, 951 F.3d 589 (D.C. Cir. 2020),
vacated and remanded sub nom. on other grounds, DOJ v. House Comm. on
the Judiciary, 142 S. Ct. 46 (2021); In re Request for Access to Grand
Jury Materials, 833 F.2d 1438, 1445 (11th Cir. 1987) (concluding that
``limit[ing] the investigatory power of the House in impeachment
proceedings . . . would clearly violate separation of powers
principles'').
\8\See Garvey, supra note 7 (``As a historical matter, all three
branches have suggested that the House possesses a robust right of
access to information when it is investigating for impeachment
purposes.''); Jonathan David Schaub, The Executive's Privilege, 70 Duke
L.J. 1, 87 (2020) (``[P]residents and others have recognized throughout
the history of the country that their ability to withhold information
from Congress disappears in the context of impeachment.'').
\9\See, e.g., H.R. Rep. No. 116-346, at 28 (2019) (``Here,
consistent with historical practice, the House divided its impeachment
inquiry into two phases, first collecting evidence and then bringing
that evidence before the Judiciary Committee for its consideration of
articles of impeachment.''); H.R. Rep. No. 111-427, at 7 (2010)
(``[T]he impeachment inquiry was referred by the Committee on the
Judiciary to a Task Force on Judicial Impeachment . . . , comprised of
12 Committee Members, to conduct the investigation.''). See also
Hearing on the Basis for the Impeachment Inquiry of President Joseph R.
Biden: Before the H. Comm. on Oversight & Accountability, 118th Cong.
(Sept. 28, 2023) (statement of Jonathan Turley, Professor, The George
Washington University Law School); Memorandum from Rep. Jim Jordan,
Chairman, H. Comm. on the Judiciary, Rep. James Comer, Chairman, H.
Comm. on Oversight & Accountability, and Rep. Jason Smith, Chairman, H.
Comm. on Ways & Means, to Members of the H. Comm. on the Judiciary, H.
Comm. on Oversight & Accountability, and H. Comm. on Ways & Means
(Sept. 27, 2023) [hereinafter ``Sept. 27 Memo''].
\10\See In re Application of Comm. on Judiciary, 414 F. Supp. 3d at
176 (``Impeachment based on anything less than all relevant evidence
would compromise the public's faith in the process.''); In re Request
for Access to Grand Jury Materials, 833 F.2d at 1445 (``Public
confidence in a procedure as political and public as impeachment is an
important consideration justifying disclosure.''); In re Report and
Recommendation of June 5, 1972 Grand Jury, 370 F. Supp. 1219, 1230 (D.
D.C. 1974) (``It would be difficult to conceive of a more compelling
need than that of this country for an unswervingly fair [impeachment]
inquiry based on all the pertinent information.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On September 27, 2023, pursuant to the directive of the
Speaker, the Chairs of the Committees, along with the Chair of
the Committee on Ways and Means, released a memorandum setting
forth the justification for and scope of the inquiry into
whether sufficient grounds exist to draft articles of
impeachment against President Biden.\11\ On December 13, 2023,
the House of Representatives adopted House Resolution 918,
directing the Committees, along with the Committee on Ways and
Means, to continue the ongoing impeachment inquiry.\12\ By
approving House Resolution 918, the House also adopted House
Resolution 917,\13\ which affirmed that ``[t]he authority
provided by clause 2(m) of Rule XI of the Rules of the House of
Representatives to the Chairs of the Committees . . . included,
from the beginning of the existing House of Representatives
impeachment inquiry . . . the authority to issue subpoenas on
behalf of such Committees for the purpose of furthering the
impeachment inquiry.''\14\ House Resolution 917 also
``ratifie[d] and affirm[ed] any subpoenas previously issued . .
. by the Chairs of the Committees on Oversight and
Accountability, Ways and Means, or the Judiciary as part of the
impeachment inquiry.''\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Sept. 27 Memo, supra note 9.
\12\H.R. Res. 918, 118th Cong. (2023).
\13\Id.
\14\H.R. Res. 917, 118th Cong. (2023).
\15\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The deposition subpoenas to Mr. Biden were issued as part
of the Committees' impeachment inquiry. As will be explained in
detail below, Mr. Biden's testimony is necessary for the
Committees to determine whether sufficient grounds exist for
the Committees to draft articles of impeachment against
President Biden.
However, the impeachment inquiry was not the only purpose
underlying these deposition subpoenas; the subpoenas were also
issued to Mr. Biden pursuant to the Committees' authorities to
conduct legislative oversight.\16\ Article I of the
Constitution vests in Congress a ``broad and indispensable''
power to conduct oversight and investigations that
``encompasses inquiries into the administration of existing
laws, studies of proposed laws, and surveys in our social,
economic or political system for the purpose of enabling
Congress to remedy them.''\17\ Pursuant to the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee on the Judiciary is
authorized to conduct oversight of the Department of Justice
(DOJ) and criminal justice matters in the United States to
inform potential legislative reforms,\18\ while the Committee
on Oversight and Accountability has been delegated broad
authority to investigate ``any matter'' at ``any time.''\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\See Rules of the U.S. House of Representatives, R. XI, cl.
2(m)(1) (2023) (providing that ``a committee or subcommittee is
authorized . . . (B) to require, by subpoena or otherwise, the
attendance and testimony of such witnesses and the production of such
books, records, correspondence, memoranda, papers, and documents as it
considers necessary''); Rules of the H. Comm. on Oversight &
Accountability, R. 12(g) (``The Chair of the Committee shall . . .
[a]uthorize and issue subpoenas as provided in House Rule XI, clause
2(m), in the conduct of any investigation or activity or series of
investigations or activities within the jurisdiction of the
Committee.); Rules of the H. Comm. on the Judiciary, R. IV(a) (``A
subpoena may be authorized and issued by the Chair, in accordance with
clause 2(m) of rule XI of the House of Representatives, in the conduct
of any investigation or activity or series of investigations or
activities within the jurisdiction of the Committee, following
consultation with the Ranking Minority Member.'').
\17\Trump v. Mazars USA, LLP, 140 S. Ct. 2019, 2031 (2020).
\18\Rules of the U.S. House of Representatives, R. X, cl. 1(l)
(2023).
\19\Id., cl. 4(c)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To further the Committees' constitutionally mandated
oversight and legislative duties, full compliance with the
Committees' duly authorized subpoenas must be obtained, which
includes unrestricted testimony on all relevant matters. The
information that the Committees seek from Mr. Biden relates to,
among other matters, his knowledge of President Biden's
involvement in his family's business dealings, and whether
President Biden, as President and/or Vice President, took any
official action or effected any change in government policy to
enrich or improperly benefit himself or his family, or traded
access or the appearance of access to himself and his office in
exchange for payments to himself or his family. This
information is necessary to inform the need for and shape of
potential legislative reforms, including criminal law reforms,
to address influence-peddling by Presidential and Vice-
Presidential family members.
The Supreme Court has repeatedly upheld Congress' inherent
contempt power to fine, detain, or imprison individuals who
refuse to comply with a congressional subpoena. In Anderson v.
Dunn, 19 U.S. 204 (1821), the Court held that the Speaker of
the House may command the Sergeant-at-Arms to take a
noncompliant witness into custody, and that this power is
essential to the fulfillment of Congress' duties. In Jurney v.
MacCracken, 294 U.S. 125 (1935), the Court opined that the
Senate ``had authority to require the production of papers as a
necessary incident of the power of legislation; and that the
Senate had the power to coerce their production by means of
arrest.''\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\Jurney v. MacCracken, 294 U.S. 125, 144 (1935) (citing McGrain
v. Daugherty, 273 U.S. 135).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Background on the Investigation
In February 2023, the Committee on Oversight and
Accountability launched an oversight investigation into the
Biden family's foreign business dealings by issuing subpoenas
for bank records related to companies and individuals who
conducted business with certain Biden family members and their
related companies.\21\ Through those records, the Committee
uncovered evidence that Biden family members and their
associates received over $24 million from foreign companies and
foreign nationals, with more than $15 million received by the
Biden family and $9 million by business associates during the
five-year period from 2014 to 2019.\22\ The Oversight
Committee's subpoenas issued to various banks for Biden family
members' bank records also showed a direct benefit to President
Biden through a series of complicated financial
transactions.\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\See, e.g., Subpoena from Rep. James Comer, Chairman, H. Comm.
on Oversight & Accountability, to Financial Institution 1 (Feb. 27,
2023).
\22\See Memorandum from Maj. Comm. staff, H. Comm. on Oversight &
Accountability, to Members of the H. Comm. on Oversight &
Accountability, Re: New Evidence Resulting from the Oversight
Committee's Investigation into the Biden Family's Influence Peddling
and Business Schemes (Mar. 16, 2023); Memorandum from Maj. Comm. staff,
H. Comm. on Oversight & Accountability, Members of the H. Comm. on
Oversight & Accountability, Re: Second Bank Records Memorandum from the
Oversight Committee's Investigation into the Biden Family's Influence
Peddling and Business Schemes (May 10, 2023) [hereinafter ``May 10
Memo'']; Memorandum from Maj. Comm. staff, H. Comm. on Oversight &
Accountability, Members of the H. Comm. on Oversight & Accountability,
Re: Third Bank Records Memorandum from the Oversight Committee's
Investigation into the Biden Family's Influence Peddling and Business
Schemes (Aug. 9, 2023) [hereinafter ``Aug. 9 Memo''].
\23\See Memorandum from Maj. Comm. staff, H. Comm. on Oversight &
Accountability, to Members of the H. Comm. on Oversight &
Accountability, Re: Fourth Bank Records Memorandum from the Oversight
Committee's Investigation into the Biden Family's Influence Peddling
and Business Schemes (Nov. 1, 2023) [hereinafter ``Nov. 1 Memo''].
------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Consideration
On January 10, 2024, the Committee met in open session and
ordered the report favorably reported to the House with an
amendment in the nature of a substitute by a recorded vote of
23 to 14, a quorum being present.
Committee Votes
In compliance with clause 3(b) of House rule XIII, the
Committee states that the following recorded votes occurred
during the Committee's consideration of the Report:
1. Vote on Motion to Adjourn offered by Mr.
Swalwell--failed 12 ayes to 15 nays.
2. Vote on Motion to Table [appealing the ruling of
the Chair in respect to the germaneness of Amendment #1
to the Report ANS offered by Mr. Schiff]--passed 18
ayes to 13 nays.
3. Vote on Amendment #2 to the Report ANS offered by
Ms. Jackson Lee--failed 8 ayes to 15 nays.
4. Vote on Amendment #3 to the Report ANS offered by
Ms. Dean--failed 9 ayes to 16 nays.
5. Vote on Amendment #4 to the Report ANS offered by
Mr. Nadler--failed 9 ayes to 18 nays.
6. Vote on Amendment #6 to the Report ANS offered by
Mr. Ivey--failed 11 ayes to 20 nays.
7. Vote on Amendment #8 to the Ivey Amendment #7 to
the Report ANS offered by Mr. Gaetz--failed 18 ayes to
18 nays.
8. Vote on Amendment #7 to the Report ANS offered by
Mr. Ivey--failed 14 ayes to 23 nays.
9. Vote on favorably reporting the Report, as
amended--passed 23 ayes to 14 nays.
Committee Oversight Findings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee advises that the findings and recommendations of the
Committee, based on oversight activities under clause 2(b)(1)
of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives, are
incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures
The Committee finds the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) of
rule XIII and section 308(a) of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974, and the requirements of clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII and
section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, to be
inapplicable to this Report. Accordingly, the Committee did not
request or receive a cost estimate from the Congressional
Budget Office and makes no findings as to the budgetary impacts
of this Report or costs incurred to carry out the Report.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII, no provision
of this Report establishes or reauthorizes a program of the
federal government known to be duplicative of another federal
program.
Performance Goals and Objectives
The Committee states that pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of
House rule XIII, this Report is to enforce the Committee's
authority to subpoena and obtain testimony related to
determining whether sufficient grounds exist to impeach
President Joseph Robinette Biden Jr. and the sufficiency of
federal ethics and financial disclosure laws.
Advisory on Earmarks
In accordance with clause 9 of House rule XXI, this Report
does not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in clauses
9(d), 9(e), or 9(f) of House rule XXI.
Minority Views
Since the start of the 118th Congress, House Judiciary
Chairman Jordan and House Oversight Chairman Comer have devoted
significant resources to continuing congressional Republicans'
multi-year probe into President Biden's family. The Chairmen
have received what Chairman Comer has referred to as
``mountains of evidence,''\1\ including from the Biden-Harris
Administration, banks, and private citizens, which all show no
wrongdoing by President Biden.\2\ Instead, it has shown that,
as Vice President, Joe Biden led a bipartisan, international
coalition to help Ukraine fight corruption; as a private
citizen, he received substantial income from book royalties and
speaking engagements and helped his brother and son with short-
term loans; and as President, he retained a U.S. Attorney
appointed by former President Trump and hand-picked by former
Attorney General Barr with full authority to investigate and
prosecute his son. Notwithstanding the facts, Chairman Jordan
has continuously distorted and cherry-picked facts to falsely
assert that ``the Biden crime family,'' including the
President, has been implicated in financial misconduct, and to
falsely claim his investigation is being obstructed.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Joe Biden's House of Horrors! Benny's Halloween Spooky Special
with Chairman James Comer, The Benny Show (Oct. 31, 2023) (online at
www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOH1CHaxvlY&t=2s).
\2\See Memorandum from Minority Staff to Interested Parties, Fact
Sheet: Mountain of Evidence Shows No Wrongdoing by President Biden,
House Committee on Oversight and Accountability (Dec. 1, 2023) (online
at https://oversightdemocrats.house.gov/sites/
democrats.oversight.house.gov/files/
20231201%20Oversight%20Democrats%20Staff%20Memo%20
on%20Impeachment%20Inquiry.pdf).
\3\See, e.g., Biden Continues to Lie to Americans About What He
Knew About the Crimes His Family was Committing: Rep. James Comer, Fox
Business (Dec. 7, 2023) (online at www.foxbusiness.com/video/
6342522748112).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
After insisting that the committees required the testimony
of Hunter Biden to further its fruitless investigation, Hunter
Biden accepted Republicans' invitation to answer questions,
merely asking to do so in public, where his words could not be
taken out of context and cherry-picked like so many other
witnesses throughout the course of the investigation. Despite
this simple request, Chairman Jordan and Chairman Comer have
refused to take yes for an answer and have pushed forward with
this contempt resolution instead.
I. Hunter Biden Accepted Republicans' Invitation To Answer Questions in
Public at a Committee Hearing--Chairman Jordan Refused To Take Yes for
an Answer
House Republican have had ample opportunity to obtain
testimony and information from Hunter Biden in this matter but
have repeatedly refused these opportunities.
Notably, on February 8, 2023, House Oversight Chairman
Comer transmitted a letter to Hunter Biden seeking ``documents
and communications related to our investigation of President
Biden's involvement in your financial conduct.''\4\ In
particular, Chairman Comer sought a wide variety of Hunter
Biden's personal records spanning over a decade, including
personal financial statements and communications with his
family.\5\ The next day, Hunter Biden's attorney responded to
Chairman Comer's requests with an offer ``to sit with you and
your staff, including the ranking member and his staff, to see
whether Hunter Biden has information that may inform some
legitimate legislative purpose and be helpful to the
Committee.''\6\ Chairman Comer did not respond to this offer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Letter from Chairman James Comer, House Committee on Oversight
and Accountability, to Robert Hunter Biden (Feb. 8, 2023) (online at
https://oversight.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/ 2023/02/2023-02-08-
Letter-R.H.-Biden.pdf).
\5\Id.
\6\Letter from Abbe D. Lowell, Counsel for Robert Hunter Biden, to
Chairman James Comer, House Committee on Oversight and Accountability
(Feb. 9, 2023) (online at https://oversightdemocrats.house.gov/sites/
democrats.oversight.house.gov/files/2023.02.09%20Letter%20
to%20Rep.%20Comer%20re%20Your%20February%208%2C%202023%20Request%20for%2
0Docu
ments.pdf).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On September 12, 2023, nearly seven months later, Chairman
Comer appeared on Newsmax to discuss his investigation of
President Biden, stating ``we requested bank records from
Hunter Biden and Jim Biden early on, and obviously we never got
a response back.''\7\ He further explained:
\7\Newsmax (@Newsmax), X (Sept. 13, 2023) (online at https://
twitter.com/newsmax/status/
1701928094003511311?s=46&t=a0UGYR3ho6S39dDafp8SGg).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hunter Biden is more than welcome to come in front of
the Committee. If he wants to clear his good name--if
he wants to come and say, you know, these weren't 20
shell companies, they actually did something--he's
invited today. We will drop everything.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Id.
On September 13, 2023, Hunter Biden's attorney responded to
Chairman Comer's statements, noting ``On February 9, we wrote
back to you . . . You never responded to that offer.''\9\
Nonetheless, Hunter Biden's attorney reiterated his offer to
sit with Chairman Comer and his staff, explaining that he and
his team ``remain available to have the discussion.''\10\
Chairman Comer again ignored this offer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Letter from Abbe D. Lowell, Counsel for Robert Hunter Biden, to
Chairman James Comer, House Committee on Oversight and Accountability
(Sept. 13, 2023) (online at https://oversightdemocrats.house.gov/sites/
democrats.oversight.house.gov/files/2023.09.13%20Letter%20to%20
Rep.%20Comer%20re%20September%2013%2C%202023%20
Statement%20on%20Newsmax%E2%80%99s%20Wak e%20Up%20America.pdf); see
also James Comer Is Lying About His Requests for Hunter Biden's Bank
Records, The New Republic (Sept. 14, 2023) (online at https://
newrepublic.com/post/175558/james-comer-hunter-biden- bank-records-
meeting-legal-team).
\10\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In October 2023, Chairman Comer appeared on The Benny Show
and extended another offer to Hunter Biden and other
individuals to testify at a Committee hearing:
We're, we're in the downhill phase of this
investigation now because we have so many documents
and, and we can bring these people in for depositions
or committee hearings, whichever they choose, and we
can ask these questions with evidence.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Joe Biden's House of Horrors! Benny's Halloween Spooky Special
with Chairman James Comer, The Benny Show (Oct. 31, 2023) (online at
www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOH1CHaxvlY&t=2s) (emphasis added).
On November 8, 2023, the Committee on Oversight and
Accountability and the Committee on the Judiciary issued
identical subpoenas to Hunter Biden compelling his appearance
at a deposition on December 13, 2023.\12\ In a letter
accompanying the subpoenas, Chairmen Comer and Jordan wrote
``Given your client's willingness to address this investigation
publicly up to this point, we would expect him to be willing to
testify before Congress.''\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Subpoena from Chairman James Comer, House Committee on
Oversight and Accountability, to Robert Hunter Biden (Nov. 8, 2023)
(online at https://oversight.house.gov/wp-content/ uploads/2023/11/
Subpoena-Robert-Hunter-Biden.pdf).
\13\Letter from Chairman James Comer, House Committee on Oversight
and Accountability, and Chairman Jim Jordan, House Judiciary Committee,
to Abbe D. Lowell, Counsel for Robert Hunter Biden, (Nov. 8, 2023)
(online at https://oversight.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/ 2023/11/
Letter-to-HB-Abbe-Lowell-11.8.23-1.pdf).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to these subpoenas, Hunter Biden's attorney
transmitted a letter on November 28, 2023, to Chairmen Comer
and Jordan indicating that Hunter Biden would agree to testify
at a public hearing before the Oversight and Accountability
Committee on December 13, 2023, or a date of their
choosing.\14\ The letter from Hunter Biden's attorney
emphasized the importance of a public proceeding that ``would
prevent selective leaks, manipulated transcripts, doctored
exhibits, or one-sided press statements,'' especially in light
of Chairman Comer's repeated use of ``closed-door sessions to
manipulate, even distort the facts and misinform the
public.''\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Letter from Abbe D. Lowell, Counsel to Robert Hunter Biden, to
Chairman James Comer, House Committee on Oversight and Accountability
(Nov. 28, 2023) (online at https://oversightdemocrats.house.gov/sites/
democrats.oversight.house.gov/files/HunterBiden.231128.Res
ponse%20to%20Comer%20re%20Impeachment%20Inquiry%20-
%20Subpoena%20110823.pdf).
\15\Id.; see, also e.g., Oversight Committee Democrats
(@OversightDems), X (Nov. 29, 2023) (online at https://twitter.com/
oversightdems/status/1730011731986927930?s=42&t=GDbkgrVUTqiw
1AI5jGgYww) (Chairman Comer selectively releasing one page of a bank
record to falsely accuse President Biden of bribery while hiding three
other pages in the same document contradicting his claims); Rep. Jamie
Raskin (@RepRaskin), X (Dec. 4, 2023) (online at https://twitter.com/
RepRaskin/status/1731777276730036702?s=20) (Chairman Comer
misrepresenting records to claim then-private citizen-Joe Biden
received payments from foreign companies when the records simply show
that payments were monthly payments for a truck Joe Biden had purchased
for Hunter Biden).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Independent fact-checkers have also concluded that Chairman
Comer has distorted witnesses' testimony in closed-door
interviews. In particular, when Chairman Comer released the
transcript of the interview of Devon Archer, Hunter Biden's
former business partner--one of only two transcripts he has
released out of more than 18 interviews conducted by the
Oversight Committee this Congress--his false statements about
Mr. Archer's testimony were suddenly plain for all to see.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\FactCheck.Org, Republicans Oversell Archer's Testimony About
Hunter and Joe Biden (Aug. 14, 2023) (online at www.factcheck.org/2023/
08/republicans-oversell-archers-testimony-about-hunter-and-joe-biden/);
Politifact, Transcript of Devon Archer testimony doesn't back key
claims about Joe and Hunter Biden (Aug. 4, 2023) (online at
www.politifact.com/article/2023/aug/04/transcript-of-devon-archer-
testimony-doesnt-back-k/).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On December 1, 2023, Chairmen Comer and Jordan rejected
Hunter Biden's offer to testify publicly at a hearing,
insisting that he appear for a closed-door deposition on
December 13, 2023, instead.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\Letter from Chairman James Comer, House Committee on Oversight
and Accountability, to Abbe D. Lowell, Counsel for Robert Hunter Biden
(Dec. 1, 2023) (online at https://oversight.house.gov/wp-content/
uploads/2023/12/Response-to-A.-Lowell-1.pdf).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In a December 6, 2023 letter, Hunter Biden's attorney again
reiterated Hunter Biden's willingness to appear before the
Committee at a public hearing on December 13, or other date in
December, ``to answer any question pertinent and relevant to
the subject matter stated in your November 8, 2023,
letter.''\18\ As with prior correspondence, Hunter Biden's
attorney expressed concern that Chairman Comer has ``use[d]
closed-door sessions to manipulate, even distort, the facts and
misinform the American public--a hearing would ensure
transparency and truth in these proceedings.''\19\ That same
day, Chairmen Comer and Jordan explained in response ``If Mr.
Biden does not appear for his deposition on December 13, 2023,
the Committees will initiate contempt of Congress
proceedings.''\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Letter from Abbe D. Lowell, Counsel to Robert Hunter Biden, to
Chairman James Comer, House Committee on Oversight and Accountability
(Dec. 6, 2023) (online at https://oversightdemocrats.house.gov/sites/
democrats.oversight.house.gov/files/
HunterBiden.231206.Response%20to%20Comer%20re%20Subpoena%20follow-
up%20120623.pdf).
\19\Id.
\20\Letter from Chairman James Comer, House Committee on Oversight
and Accountability, and Chairman Jim Jordan, House Judiciary Committee,
to Abbe D. Lowell, Counsel for Robert Hunter Biden (Dec. 6, 2023)
(online at https://oversight.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/
Response-to-A.-Lowell-12.6.23.pdf).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On December 13, 2023, Chairmen Comer and Jordan proceeded
with the planned deposition of Hunter Biden, behind closed-
doors and unavailable to the press.\21\ Hunter Biden did not
appear for the closed-door deposition on that day but held a
press conference on Capitol Hill to again express his
willingness to testify in a public setting.\22\ On January 5,
2024, Chairman Jordan officially noticed a markup for January
10, 2024, to consider a resolution recommending that the House
of Representatives find Robert Hunter Biden in contempt of
Congress for failing to appear at the scheduled deposition.\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Although the subpoena to Hunter Biden and the notice for the
deposition showed the deposition would take place in Room 2157 of the
Rayburn House Office Building, Republicans held the deposition in Room
2154.
\22\Hunter Biden, Defying Deposition Subpoena, Again Offers Public
Testimony, New York Times (Dec. 13, 2023) (online at www.nytimes.com/
2023/12/13/us/politics/hunter-biden-
impeachment-testimony.html).
\23\Committee on Oversight and Accountability, Press Release: Comer
Announces Markup of Resolution to Hold Hunter Biden in Contempt of
Congress (Jan. 5, 2024) (online at https://oversight.house.gov/release/
comer-announces-markup-of-resolution-to-hold-hunter-biden-in-contempt-
of-congress/); see also Committee on Oversight and Accountability,
Press Release: Ranking Member Raskin's Statement on Committee
Republicans Contempt Vote (Jan. 5, 2024) (online at https://
oversightdemocrats.house.gov/news/press-releases/ranking-member-raskin-
s-statement-on-committee-republicans-contempt-vote).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During that markup, Rep. Glenn Ivey (D-MD) proposed yet one
more route to obtaining Mr. Biden's testimony. Specifically, he
introduced an amendment which would have permitted Hunter Biden
to avoid being held in contempt if he agreed to testify at a
public hearing on the topics outlined in the Committees'
subpoenas within 30 days of passage of a contempt Resolution.
As Rep. Ivey explained:
``[T]his is not somebody stonewalling and refusing to
come under any circumstances. This is not somebody
who's asserted a privilege that's been rejected but
still refusing to come. This is not somebody who hasn't
produced any documents. You've got somebody here who's
put an offer on the table to come and testify publicly.
So the question in a court would be in absence of the
negotiations and reasonable discussions that
Congressman Cline mentioned earlier and some of you
other members have mentioned as well, what's the record
we would be sending forward at this point and would a
judge look at this and say--or a court of appeals and
say, yeah, you know, the House Judiciary Committee
really made the effort to negotiate through this with
Hunter Biden. He offered to publicly testify. They
didn't take him up on it even though they said that he
could do it at one point. I mean, why would we want
that set of facts to go forward and put the risk of--
you know, if we had the courts rule against us it
actually undermines subpoena authority for this
committee and this--and this chamber.
So if we can move forward with a reasonable--let's
give them 14 days, whatever number you all want to
pick, but some additional time after the resolution
goes which increases our chances of actually getting
the information that you all are saying you want as
opposed to just moving forward with a resolution that's
just strictly contempt--criminal contempt.''\24\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\Markup of Report Recommending that the House of Representatives
Cite Robert Hunter Biden For Contempt of Congress (Jan. 10, 2024).
As Rep. Ivey and Judiciary Committee Ranking Member Nadler
(D-NY) explained during debate on this amendment, a public
hearing with Hunter Biden could take the form of a deposition,
including with alternating extended rounds of questioning for
the majority and the minority, in order to alleviate Committee
Republicans' concerns about the limitations on questioning
imposed by the five minute rule. Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-FL)
indicated that he was amenable to the proposal but introduced a
second degree amendment which would shorten the time period to
fourteen days. Four Committee Republicans ultimately joined
with Democrats in support of this amendment, which ultimately
failed by a vote of 18-18. Chairman Jordan did not support the
amendment.
Finally, on January 12, 2024, Hunter Biden's attorney again
wrote to Chairman Jordan and Chairman Comer.\25\ He explained
that while his client believed the original subpoenas were
legally invalid because they were issued prior to the House of
Representatives expressly authorizing an impeachment inquiry,
``If you issue a new proper subpoena, now that there is a duly
authorized impeachment inquiry, Mr. Biden will comply for a
hearing or deposition.''\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\Letter from Abbe Lowell, Counsel to Robert Hunter Biden, to
Chairman Jim Jordan, House Judiciary Committee, and Chairman James
Comer, House Committee on Oversight and Accountability (Jan. 12, 2024).
\26\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Committee's decision to move for