Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 5585]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on the Judiciary, to whom was referred the
bill (H.R. 5585) to impose criminal and immigration penalties
for intentionally fleeing a pursuing Federal officer while
operating a motor vehicle, having considered the same, reports
favorably thereon with an amendment and recommends that the
bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 3
Background and Need for the Legislation.......................... 3
Hearings......................................................... 6
Committee Consideration.......................................... 6
Committee Votes.................................................. 6
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 11
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures........................ 11
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate........................ 11
Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects.......................... 12
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 12
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 12
Advisory on Earmarks............................................. 12
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 13
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 13
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 13
Section-by-Section Analysis...................................... 13
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 13
Dissenting Views................................................. 74
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all that follows after the enacting clause and insert
the following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as ``Agent Raul Gonzalez Officer Safety Act''.
SEC. 2. CRIMINAL PENALTIES FOR EVADING ARREST OR DETENTION.
(a) In General.--Chapter 2 of title 18, United States Code, is
amended by adding at the end the following:
``Sec. 40B. Evading arrest or detention while operating a motor vehicle
``(a) Offense.--A person commits an offense under this section by
operating a motor vehicle within 100 miles of the United States border
while intentionally fleeing from--
``(1) a pursuing U.S. Border Patrol agent acting pursuant to
lawful authority; or
``(2) any pursuing Federal, State, or local law enforcement
officer who is actively assisting, or under the command of,
U.S. Border Patrol.
``(b) Penalties.--
``(1) In general.--Except as provided in paragraphs (2) and
(3), any person who commits an offense described in subsection
(a) shall be--
``(A) imprisoned for a term of not more than 2 years;
``(B) fined under this title; or
``(C) subject to the penalties described in
subparagraphs (A) and (B).
``(2) Serious bodily injury.--If serious bodily injury
results from the commission of an offense described in
subsection (a), the person committing such offense shall be--
``(A) imprisoned for a term of not less than 5 years
and not more than 20 years;
``(B) fined under this title; or
``(C) subject to the penalties described in
subparagraphs (A) and (B).
``(3) Death.--If the death of any person results from the
commission of an offense described in subsection (a), the
person committing such offense shall be--
``(A) imprisoned for a term of not less than 10 years
and up to life;
``(B) fined under this title; or
``(C) subject to the penalties described in
subparagraphs (A) and (B).''.
(b) Clerical Amendment.--The analysis for chapter 2 of title 18,
United States Code, is amended by adding at the end the following:
``40B. Evading arrest or detention while operating a motor vehicle.''.
SEC. 3. INADMISSIBILITY, DEPORTABILITY, AND INELIGIBILITY RELATED TO
EVADING ARREST OR DETENTION WHILE OPERATING A MOTOR
VEHICLE.
(a) Inadmissibility.--Section 212(a)(2) of the Immigration and
Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1182(a)(2)) is amended by adding at the end
the following:
``(J) Evading arrest or detention while operating a
motor vehicle.--Any alien who has been convicted of,
who admits having committed, or who admits committing
acts which constitute the essential elements of a
violation of section 40B(a) of title 18, United States
Code, is inadmissible.''.
(b) Deportability.--Section 237(a)(2) of the Immigration and
Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1227(a)(2)) is amended by adding at the end
the following:
``(G) Evading arrest or detention while operating a
motor vehicle.--Any alien who has been convicted of,
who admits having committed, or who admits committing
acts which constitute the essential elements of a
violation of section 40B(a) of title 18, United States
Code, is deportable.''.
(c) Ineligibility for Relief.--Chapter 2 of title II of the
Immigration and Nationality Act is amended by inserting after section
208 the following:
``SEC. 208A. INELIGIBILITY FOR RELIEF RELATED TO EVADING ARREST OR
DETENTION WHILE OPERATING A MOTOR VEHICLE.
``Any alien who has been convicted of, who admits having committed,
or who admits committing acts which constitute the essential elements
of a violation of section 40B(a) of title 18, United States Code, shall
be ineligible for relief under the immigration laws, including asylum
under section 208.''.
SEC. 4. ANNUAL REPORT.
The Attorney General shall submit an annual report to the Committee
on the Judiciary of the Senate and the Committee on the Judiciary of
the House of Representatives that--
(1) identifies the number of people who were charged, during
the reporting period, with a violation of section 40B(a) of
title 18, United States Code, as added by section 2(a); and
(2) summarizes--
(A) the penalties sought in the charging documents
pertaining to the violations referred to in paragraph
(1); and
(B) the penalties imposed for such violations.
Purpose and Summary
H.R. 5585, the Agent Raul Gonzalez Officer Safety Act,
introduced by Rep. Juan Ciscomani (R-AZ), imposes criminal
penalties on individuals who evade U.S. Border Patrol agents,
or other federal, state, or local law enforcement officers
assisting Border Patrol agents and makes aliens who are
convicted of or admit to committing such acts inadmissible to
and removable from the U.S. It also ensures such aliens are
ineligible for immigration relief, including asylum.
Background and Need for the Legislation
During the Biden Administration, there have been 35
straight months in which U.S. Customs and Border Protection
(CBP) has encountered more than 100,000 illegal aliens along
the southwest border.\1\ Since President Biden took office,
more than 7 million illegal aliens have been encountered by CBP
along the southwest border.\2\ In September 2023, CBP on the
southwest border encountered 269,735 illegal aliens, shattering
the previous record of 252,315 encounters in December 2022.\3\
In December 2023, according to press reports, the Biden
Administration broke the September 2023 record with a
staggering 302,000 illegal alien encounters.\4\ More than 3.3
million illegal aliens have been released into the United
States by the Biden Administration, and there have been at
least 1.7 million known ``gotaways.''\5\ In addition, an untold
number of unknown ``gotaways'' have evaded Border Patrol agents
and escaped into the interior since January 20, 2021.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\U.S. Customs and Border Prot., Sw. Land Border Encounters, U.S.
Dep't of Homeland Sec. (last accessed Dec. 27, 2023), https://
www.cbp.gov/newsroom/stats/southwest-land-border-encounters (reporting
6,776,255 illegal alien encounters through Nov. 2023); Bill Melugin
(@BillMelugin_), X (Dec. 26, 2023, 11:28 AM), https://x.com/
BillMelugin_/status/1739699696585814515?s=20 (reporting 730,000 illegal
alien encounters thus far in FY 2024). Under the Biden Administration,
CBP has encountered at least 7,022,862 illegal aliens along the
southwest border.
\2\Id.
\3\Id.
\4\Bill Melugin (@BillMelugin_), X (Jan. 2, 2024 10:54 AM), https:/
/x.com/BillMelugin_/status/1742212865803911284?s=20; Bill Melugin
(@BillMelugin_), X (Dec. 19, 2023 8:33 AM), https://x.com/BillMelugin_/
status/1737103946429186105?s=20.
\5\See H. Comm. on the Judiciary, Rep. on The Biden Border Crisis:
How the Biden Admin. Opened the Sw. Border and Abandoned Interior
Immigr. Enf't at App'x 1 (Oct. 9, 2023) (``DHS released at least
2,148,738 illegal aliens into the United States'' through March 2023);
see also U.S. Customs and Border Prot., CBP Releases Nov. 2023 Monthly
Update, U.S. Dep't of Homeland Sec. (Dec. 22, 2023), https://
www.cbp.gov/newsroom/national-media-release/cbp-releases-november-2023-
monthly-update (``297,000 Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans, and
Venezuelans [] were granted parole under the parole processes [through
Nov. 2023]'') [hereinafter Nov. 2023 Monthly Update]; U.S. Customs and
Border Prot., Custody and Transfer Statistics FY 2023, U.S. Dep't of
Homeland Sec. (last accessed Jan. 12, 2024), https://www.cbp.gov/
newsroom/stats/custody-and-transfer-statistics-fy2023 (reporting that,
between April 2023 and September 2023, 507,873 illegal aliens were
released with a notice to appear or paroled); Bill Melugin
(@BillMelugin_), X (Dec. 22, 2023, 12:07 PM), https://x.com/
BillMelugin_/status/1738244827475775910?s=20 (In FY 2024 thus far,
``Border Patrol has released more than 386,500 illegal aliens''); Casey
Harper, Border crisis creates national security threat for U.S.,
observers say, The Center Square (Aug. 5, 2023), https://
www.thecentersquare.com/national/article_37491ca0-32ff-11ee-945b-
7f09d39f7aa0.html. Under the Biden Administration, at least 3,340,111
illegal aliens have been released into the United States and 1.7
million known ``gotaways'' have evaded Border Patrol.
\6\Harper, supra note 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Biden Administration's lax enforcement of the
immigration laws has incentivized illegal alien smuggling.
Smugglers in vehicles routinely evade Border Patrol agents, and
high-speed chases often ensue.\7\ The number of high-speed
chases continues to increase along the southwest border.\8\
While especially prevalent in the Tucson, Arizona, area, where
such chases are ``resulting in deaths and injuries among
innocent residents,''\9\ high-speed chases are also common in
other American communities. For instance, in El Paso, Texas, in
July 2023, ``several people, including a child, were injured
when a driver smuggling [illegal aliens] wrecked into two other
vehicles while running from a Texas state trooper.''\10\ Nine
people were taken to the hospital to receive medical attention
for their injuries.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\See infra notes 93, 95, 97, & 98.
\8\J. David Goodman, High-Speed Police Chases Rise Near Texas
Border, Leaving Locals on Edge, N. Y. Times (Nov. 24, 2023), https://
www.nytimes.com/2023/11/24/us/texas-border-police-
chases.html?searchResultPosition=1.
\9\Lupita Murillo, Operation Safe Streets II in its third week,
News4 Tucson (Nov. 14, 2023), https://www.kvoa.com/news/local/
operation-safe-streets-ii-in-its-third-week/article_6f3ffb18-834c-11ee-
a8ea-5bc1cd972319.html.
\10\Daniel Borunda, Texas DPS pursuit of migrant smuggler vehicle
ends in West El Paso crash, several injured, El Paso Times (July 31,
2023), https://www.elpasotimes.com/story/news/crime/2023/07/31/el-paso-
texas-dps-pursuit-migrant-smuggler-vehicle-crash-south-desert-
boulevard/70499277007/.
\11\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to Americans who live in border communities,
federal, state, and local law enforcement officers have been
injured and killed as a result of high-speed chases with
smugglers. On February 24, 2021, Border Patrol agents pursued a
human smuggler who was attempting to transport nearly a dozen
illegal aliens and who failed to stop at a checkpoint on the
outskirts of San Diego, California.\12\ Four agents were
injured during the chase after ``the [smuggler's] SUV hit
several Border Patrol vehicles before crashing into at least
two civilian vehicles.''\13\ On September 30, 2023, an Arizona
sheriff's deputy was hurt after he fell 15 feet while assisting
in the capture of smugglers attempting to evade
authorities.\14\ On December 7, 2022, Border Patrol Agent Raul
Gonzalez, while in pursuit of a group of illegal aliens evading
Border Patrol agents in Mission, Texas, crashed his all-terrain
vehicle into a gate.\15\ Agent Gonzalez died from his injuries
just a few hours later.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\City News Service, 4 Border Patrol Agents Injured in Crash
During Chase of Migrant Smuggler's SUV, Times of San Diego (Feb. 24,
2021), https://timesofsandiego.com/crime/2021/02/24/4-border-patrol-
agents-injured-in-crash-during-chase-of-migrant-smugglers-suv/.
\13\Id.
\14\Sarah Rumpf-Whitten, Arizona sheriff's deputy near border falls
15-feet, injured in pursuit of human smuggler: `Enough is enough', FOX
NEWS (Sept. 30, 2023), https://www.foxnews.com/us/texas-sheriffs-
deputy-near-border-falls-15-feet-injured-pursuit-human-smuggler-enough-
enough.
\15\MaryAnn Martinez, US Border Patrol agent killed chasing illegal
immigrants in Texas N.Y. Post (Dec. 7, 2022), https://nypost.com/2022/
12/07/border-patrol-agent-killed-chasing-illegal-migrants-in-texas/.
\16\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In October of last year, the Arizona Sheriffs Association
announced it would send deputies from Apache, Coconino, Navajo,
Pinal, and Yavapai County to Cochise County to assist law
enforcement in combatting border-related crime, including high-
speed chases.\17\ One lifelong Cochise County resident
reflected on the dangers of Highway 90, now a major smuggling
route, stating, ``It's scary to the point that you don't want
to drive the highway but to get to work you have to . . . . I'm
actually scared about going out into the public sometimes
because what if there is a high-speed chase and something goes
sideways they get into a car accident, hop on a curb, and hit
anybody . . . .''\18\ In Tombstone, Arizona, U.S. Marshal Jim
Adams spoke of the high-speed chases racing through his town:
``This is a weekly occurrence. Sometimes daily, sometimes
several times a day.''\19\ According to the Marshal's office,
of the 91 calls it handled last year, around 51 involved
smuggler chases.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\ADI Staff, Sheriffs Send Resources To Cochise County To Combat
Border Crime Arizona Daily Independent (Oct. 26, 2023), https://
arizonadailyindependent.com/2023/10/26/sheriffs-send-resources-to-
cochise-county-to-combat-border-crime/.
\18\Murillo, supra note 9.
\19\Craig Smith, High-speed smugglers risk your life on Tombstone
streets, ABC KGUN Tucson (Oct. 3, 2023), https://www.kgun9.com/news/
local-news/cochise-county/on-tombstone-streets-high-speed-smugglers-
risk-your-life.
\20\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Human smuggling is an incredibly lucrative business.
According to Border Patrol estimates, in the Del Rio Sector
alone, cartels' human smuggling profit is $32 million per week,
for a staggering total of $1.6 billion per year.\21\ With a
continuing demand for human smuggling because of the open
southwest border, cartels are also recruiting minors to drive
illegal aliens across the border. Minors are falsely told they
will not face legal consequences if caught.\22\ According to
Cochise County, Arizona, Sheriff Mark Dannels, ``We have over a
hundred juveniles in the last 18 months that we've apprehended
in this county smuggling, all the way to the age of 13 and 12
years of age down here, driving grandma's car, a friend's car,
or mom and dad's car down here . . . .''\23\ In March 2022, law
enforcement in Arizona started a task force to address human
smuggling across the border.\24\ The task force, called
Operation Safe Streets, helped to pass a law that made human
trafficking a state violation, allowing for easier prosecutions
of juveniles for such crimes and deterring other potential
criminals.\25\ However, even with this state legislation,
police face challenges in apprehending smugglers through high-
speed chases as historic numbers of illegal alien encounters
continue at the border.\26\ Indeed, the lack of specific
federal criminal and immigration consequences has incentivized
criminals and aliens to evade the Border Patrol, resulting in
the rising number of dangerous high-speed chases.\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\Stephen Dinan, Cartels make $32 million a week off migrants in
one stretch of Texas border, Wash. Examiner (Jan. 3, 2024), https://
www.washingtontimes.com/news/2024/jan/3/cartels-make-32-million-week-
off-migrants-in-one-s/?utm_source=Twitter&utm_medium=SocialFlow.
\22\Melissa Ford Maldonado & Zach Whiting, Parents, beware of
Mexican Drug Cartel Operatives trying to `slide into your child's DMs',
Texas Public Policy Foundation (March 28, 2023), https://
www.texaspolicy.com/parents-beware-of-mexican-drug-cartel-operatives-
trying-to-slide-into-your-childs-dms/
#::text=With%20demand%20for%20human%20smugglers,
apprehended%20because%20they%20are%20minors.
\23\Kris Van Cleave, Cochise County turning into a drug and human
smuggling raceway as border crossings surge, Arizona's Family (Oct. 5,
2023), https://www.azfamily.com/2023/10/06/ cochise-county-turning-
into-drug-human-smuggling-raceway-border-crossings-surge/.
\24\Aleix Oliveira, Babyfaced Arizona teens suspected of working as
people smugglers for a cartel in worrying new trend: cops N.Y. Post
(Nov. 13, 2023), https://nypost.com/2023/11/13/news/arizona-teens-eli-
laclaire-and-landon-vert-arrested-for-people-smuggling/.
\25\Id.
\26\Id.; CBP Sw. Land Border Encounters, supra note 1.
\27\Id.; Goodman, supra note 8.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During Committee consideration of H.R. 5585, the Minority
argued that to be subject to the bill's immigration penalties,
an alien should have to have been convicted of fleeing a law
enforcement officer. However, under current law, not every
ground of inadmissibility or removability requires a
conviction.\28\ Indeed, by requiring, at a minimum, that an
alien admits to the elements of the offense, H.R. 5585 conforms
to the pattern of other grounds of inadmissibility and
removability.\29\ Moreover, by ensuring an alien may be
inadmissible or removable based on his own admission, this
legislation guards against cases in which an activist
prosecutor may decline to prosecute these offenses or allow
aliens to plead down to crimes that do not render such aliens
removable.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\See INA Sec. 212(a)(2); INA Sec. 237(a)(1)(C); INA Sec.
237(a)(1)(E); INA Sec. 237(a)(1)(G).
\29\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R.5585 gives authorities the necessary tools to fully
prosecute and punish criminals who intentionally fail to yield
to Border Patrol agents, and law enforcement officials
assisting the Border Patrol.
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6)(A) of House rule XIII,
the following hearing was used to develop H.R. 5585: ``The
Biden Border Crisis: Part I,'' a hearing held on February 1,
2023, before the Judiciary Committee. The Committee heard
testimony from the following witnesses:
Brandon Dunn, co-founder, Forever15Project;
The Honorable Mark J. Dannels, Sheriff,
Cochise County, Arizona;
The Honorable Dale Lynn Carruthers, County
Judge, Terrell County, Texas; and
The Honorable Ricardo Samaniego, County
Judge, El Paso County, Texas.
The hearing addressed how President Biden's open-borders
policies affect Americans with rising crime and lawlessness at
the southwest border and beyond. In his opening statement,
Sheriff Mark Dannels of Cochise County, Arizona, testified how
his deputies have been placed in life-threatening situations
with aliens and how border-related crimes, including high-speed
chases resulting from criminals and illegal aliens evading
Border Patrol and state and local law enforcement, are at an
all-time high.\30\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\30\The Biden Border Crisis: Part I: Hearing Before the H. Comm. On
the Judiciary, 118th Cong. (2023) (statement of Mark J. Dannels,
Sheriff, Cochise County, Arizona).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Consideration
On January 18, 2024, the Committee met in open session and
ordered the bill, H.R. 5585, favorably reported with an
amendment in the nature of a substitute, by a roll call vote of
14-10, a quorum being present.
Committee Votes
In compliance with clause 3(b) of House rule XIII, the
following roll call votes occurred during the Committee's
consideration of H.R. 5585:
1. Vote on Amendment #1 to the H.R. 5585 ANS, offered
by Ms. Escobar of Texas--failed 11 ayes to 13 nays.
2. Vote on Amendment #2 to the H.R. 5585 ANS, offered
by Ms. Jackson Lee of Texas--failed 9 ayes to 13 nays.
3. Vote on favorably reporting H.R. 5585, as
amended--passed 14 ayes to 10 nays.
Committee Oversight Findings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee advises that the findings and recommendations of the
Committee, based on oversight activities under clause 2(b)(1)
of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives, are
incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures
Clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives does not apply where a cost estimate and
comparison prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office under section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974 has been timely submitted prior to filing of the report
and is included in the report. Such a cost estimate is included
in this report.
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate
With respect to the requirement of clause 3(c)(3) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and section
402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the Committee has
received the enclosed cost estimate for H.R. 5585 from the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office:
H.R. 5585 would create new criminal penalties for using a
motor vehicle to flee a border patrol agent within 100 miles of
the United States border. Those penalties would increase if the
offense resulted in death or serious injury. H.R. 5585 also
would make an alien (a non-U.S. national) inadmissible to or
deportable from the United States if that person admitted to or
was convicted of such an offense. Lastly, the bill would
require the Department of Justice to report annually to the
Congress on the number of people charged with the offense
specified in the bill and the sentencing outcome for each
offense.
Based on data from the U.S. Sentencing Commission, a small
number of people who are convicted of immigration offenses pay
criminal fines. Criminal fines are recorded in the budget as
revenues, deposited in the Crime Victims Fund, and later spent
without further appropriation. Using data on fines collected
for other immigration offenses, CBO estimates that enacting
H.R. 5585 would increase revenues and direct spending from
fines by less than $500,000 over the 2024-2033 period.
Under current law, driving recklessly to evade police is
deemed to be a crime involving moral turpitude; the admission
of or conviction for such crimes makes an alien inadmissible.
Further, a conviction for high-speed flight from an immigration
checkpoint renders an alien deportable. Therefore, CBO expects
that only a few people would be deported based solely on
enacting this bill.
Enacting H.R. 5585 would reduce direct spending and
spending subject to appropriation because aliens are eligible
for certain federal benefits, such as emergency Medicaid, if
they otherwise meet the eligibility requirements for those
benefits. Removing aliens under the bill would reduce spending
for those benefits. Because few people would be affected by the
bill, CBO estimates that those effects would not be significant
in any year and over the 2024-2033 period.
Finally, based on the costs of similar activities, CBO
estimates that implementing the reporting requirement would
cost less than $500,000 over the 2024-2028 period. That
spending would be subject to the availability of appropriated
funds.
The CBO staff contacts for this estimate are Jeremy Crimm
(for the Department of Justice) and David Rafferty (for
immigration). The estimate was reviewed by H. Samuel Papenfuss,
Deputy Director of Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(d)(1) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section
402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII, no provision
of H.R. 5585 establishes or reauthorizes a program of the
federal government known to be duplicative of another federal
program.
Performance Goals and Objectives
The Committee states that pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of
House rule XIII, H.R. 5585 imposes criminal penalties on
individuals who evade U.S. Border Patrol agents, or other
federal,state, or local law enforcement officers assisting
Border Patrol agents, makes aliens who are convicted of or admit to
committing such acts inadmissible to and removable from the U.S., and
ensures such aliens are ineligible for immigration relief, including
asylum.
Advisory on Earmarks
In accordance with clause 9 of House rule XXI, H.R. 5585
does not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in clauses
9(d), 9(e), or 9(f) of House rule XXI.
Federal Mandates Statement
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act (Pub. L. 104-
1).
Section-by-Section Analysis
Sec. 1: Short Title: This section states the title of H.R.
5585 as the ``Agent Raul Gonzalez Officer Safety Act.''
Sec. 2(a): This section amends title 18 of the U.S. Code by
adding a new offense of evading arrest or detention while
operating a motor vehicle. Specifically, a person commits an
offense by operating a vehicle within 100 miles of the border
while intentionally fleeing from border patrol, state or local
law enforcement, or other federal law enforcement.
Sec. 2(b): Penalties. A person committing this offense will
be imprisoned for up to 2 years or fined. If the evasion
results in serious bodily injury, the person will be imprisoned
for 5 to 20 years, fined or both. If the evasion results in
death, the person will be imprisoned for not less than 10
years, fined or both.
Sec. 3. Inadmissibility, Deportability, and Ineligibility
Related to Evading Arrest or Detention While Operating a Motor
Vehicle: This section creates a ground of inadmissibility and a
ground of removability for aliens who have been convicted of,
admit to, or admit to committing acts that constitute the
essential elements of a violation of 18 U.S.C. Sec. 40B(a),
evading arrest or detention while operating a motor vehicle.
The section makes such aliens ineligible for all immigration
relief.
Sec. 4: Annual Report: This section requires the Attorney
General to submit an annual report to both the House and Senate
Judiciary Committees. The report will identify the number of
people charged, and summarize the penalties sought and the
penalties imposed for the violations.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (new matter is
printed in italics and existing law in which no change is
proposed is shown in roman):
TITLE 18, UNITED STATES CODE
* * * * * * *
PART I--CRIMES
* * * * * * *
CHAPTER 2--AIRCRAFT AND MOTOR VEHICLES
Sec.
31. Definitions.
* * * * * * *
40B. Evading arrest or detention while operating a motor vehicle.
* * * * * * *
Sec. 40B. Evading arrest or detention while operating a motor vehicle
(a) Offense.--A person commits an offense under this section
by operating a motor vehicle within 100 miles of the United
States border while intentionally fleeing from--
(1) a pursuing U.S. Border Patrol agent acting
pursuant to lawful authority; or
(2) any pursuing Federal, State, or local law
enforcement officer who is actively assisting, or under
the command of, U.S. Border Patrol.
(b) Penalties.--
(1) In general.--Except as provided in paragraphs (2)
and (3), any person who commits an offense described in
subsection (a) shall be--
(A) imprisoned for a term of not more than 2
years;
(B) fined under this title; or
(C) subject to the penalties described in
subparagraphs (A) and (B).
(2) Serious bodily injury.--If serious bodily injury
results from the commission of an offense described in
subsection (a), the person committing such offense
shall be--
(A) imprisoned for a term of not less than 5
years and not more than 20 years;
(B) fined under this title; or
(C) subject to the penalties described in
subparagraphs (A) and (B).
(3) Death.--If the death of any person results from
the commission of an offense described in subsection
(a), the person committing such offense shall be--
(A) imprisoned for a term of not less than 10
years and up to life;
(B) fined under this title; or
(C) subject to the penalties described in
subparagraphs (A) and (B).
* * * * * * *
----------
IMMIGRATION AND NATIONALITY ACT
* * * * * * *
TITLE II--IMMIGRATION
* * * * * * *
Chapter 2--Qualifications for Admission of Aliens; Travel Control of
Citizens and Aliens
* * * * * * *
SEC. 208A. INELIGIBILITY FOR RELIEF RELATED TO EVADING ARREST OR
DETENTION WHILE OPERATING A MOTOR VEHICLE.
Any alien who has been convicted of, who admits having
committed, or who admits committing acts which constitute the
essential elements of a violation of section 40B(a) of title
18, United States Code, shall be ineligible for relief under
the immigration laws, including asylum under section 208.
* * * * * * *
general classes of aliens ineligible to receive visas and ineligible
for admission; waivers of inadmissibility
Sec. 212. (a) Classes of Aliens Ineligible for Visas or
Admission.--Except as otherwise provided in this Act, aliens
who are inadmissible under the following paragraphs are
ineligible to receive visas and ineligible to be admitted to
the United States:
(1) Health-related grounds.--
(A) In general.--Any alien--
(i) who is determined (in accordance
with regulations prescribed by the
Secretary of Health and Human Services)
to have a communicable disease of
public health significance;
(ii) except as provided in
subparagraph (C), who seeks admission
as an immigrant, or who seeks
adjustment of status to the status of
an alien lawfully admitted for
permanent residence, and who has failed
to present documentation of having
received vaccination against vaccine-
preventable diseases, which shall
include at least the following
diseases: mumps, measles, rubella,
polio, tetanus and diphtheria toxoids,
pertussis, influenza type B and
hepatitis B, and any other vaccinations
against vaccine-preventable diseases
recommended by the Advisory Committee
for Immunization Practices,
(iii) who is determined (in
accordance with regulations prescribed
by the Secretary of Health and Human
Services in consultation with the
Attorney General)--
(I) to have a physical or
mental disorder and behavior
associated with the disorder
that may pose, or has posed, a
threat to the property, safety,
or welfare of the alien or
others, or
(II) to have had a physical
or mental disorder and a
history of behavior associated
with the disorder, which
behavior has posed a threat to
the property, safety, or
welfare of the alien or others
and which behavior is likely to
recur or to lead to other
harmful behavior, or
(iv) who is determined (in accordance
with regulations prescribed by the
Secretary of Health and Human Services)
to be a drug abuser or addict,
is inadmissibility.
(B) Waiver authorized.--For provision
authorizing waiver of certain clauses of
subparagraph (A), see subsection (g).
(C) Exception from immunization requirement
for adopted children 10 years of age or
younger.--Clause (ii) of subparagraph (A) shall
not apply to a child who--
(i) is 10 years of age or younger,
(ii) is described in subparagraph (F)
or (G) of section 101(b)(1); and
(iii) is seeking an immigrant visa as
an immediate relative under section
201(b),
if, prior to the admission of the child, an
adoptive parent or prospective adoptive parent
of the child, who has sponsored the child for
admission as an immediate relative, has
executed an affidavit stating that the parent
is aware of the provisions of subparagraph
(A)(ii) and will ensure that, within 30 days of
the child's admission, or at the earliest time
that is medically appropriate, the child will
receive the vaccinations identified in such
subparagraph.
(2) Criminal and related grounds.--
(A) Conviction of certain crimes.--
(i) In general.--Except as provided
in clause (ii), any alien convicted of,
or who admits having committed, or who
admits committing acts which constitute
the essential elements of--
(I) a crime involving moral
turpitude (other than a purely
political offense) or an
attempt or conspiracy to commit
such a crime, or
(II) a violation of (or a
conspiracy or attempt to
violate) any law or regulation
of a State, the United States,
or a foreign country relating
to a controlled substance (as
defined in section 102 of the
Controlled Substances Act (21
U.S.C. 802)),
is inadmissible.
(ii) Exception.--Clause (i)(I) shall
not apply to an alien who committed
only one crime if--
(I) the crime was committed
when the alien was under 18
years of age, and the crime was
committed (and the alien
released from any confinement
to a prison or correctional
institution imposed for the
crime) more than 5 years before
the date of application for a
visa or other documentation and
the date of application for
admission to the United States,
or
(II) the maximum penalty
possible for the crime of which
the alien was convicted (or
which the alien admits having
committed or of which the acts
that the alien admits having
committed constituted the
essential elements) did not
exceed imprisonment for one
year and, if the alien was
convicted of such crime, the
alien was not sentenced to a
term of imprisonment in excess
of 6 months (regardless of the
extent to which the sentence
was ultimately executed).
(B) Multiple criminal convictions.--Any alien
convicted of 2 or more offenses (other than
purely political offenses), regardless of
whether the conviction was in a single trial or
whether the offenses arose from a single scheme
of misconduct and regardless of whether the
offenses involved moral turpitude, for which
the aggregate sentences to confinement were 5
years or more is inadmissible.
(C) Controlled substance traffickers.--Any
alien who the consular officer or the Attorney
General knows or has reason to believe--
(i) is or has been an illicit
trafficker in any controlled substance
or in any listed chemical (as defined
in section 102 of the Controlled
Substances Act (21 U.S.C. 802)), or is
or has been a knowing aider, abettor,
assister, conspirator, or colluder with
others in the illicit trafficking in
any such controlled or listed substance
or chemical, or endeavored to do so; or
(ii) is the spouse, son, or daughter
of an alien inadmissible under clause
(i), has, within the previous 5 years,
obtained any financial or other benefit
from the illicit activity of that
alien, and knew or reasonably should
have known that the financial or other
benefit was the product of such illicit
activity,
is inadmissible.
(D) Prostitution and commercialized vice.--
Any alien who--
(i) is coming to the United States
solely, principally, or incidentally to
engage in prostitution, or has engaged
in prostitution within 10 years of the
date of application for a visa,
admission, or adjustment of status,
(ii) directly or indirectly procures
or attempts to procure, or (within 10
years of the date of application for a
visa, entry, or adjustment of status)
procured or attempted to procure or to
import, prostitutes or persons for the
purpose of prostitution, or receives or
(within such 10-year period) received,
in whole or in part, the proceeds of
prostitution, or
(iii) is coming to the United States
to engage in any other unlawful
commercialized vice, whether or not
related to prostitution,
is inadmissible.
(E) Certain aliens involved in serious
criminal activity who have asserted immunity
from prosecution.--Any alien--
(i) who has committed in the United
States at any time a serious criminal
offense (as defined in section 101(h)),
(ii) for whom immunity from criminal
jurisdiction was exercised with respect
to that offense,
(iii) who as a consequence of the
offense and exercise of immunity has
departed from the United States, and
(iv) who has not subsequently
submitted fully to the jurisdiction of
the court in the United States having
jurisdiction with respect to that
offense,
is inadmissible.
(F) Waiver authorized.--For provision
authorizing waiver of certain subparagraphs of
this paragraph, see subsection (h).
(G) Foreign government officials who have
committed particularly severe violations of
religious freedom.--Any alien who, while
serving as a foreign government official, was
responsible for or directly carried out, at any
time, particularly severe violations of
religious freedom, as defined in section 3 of
the International Religious Freedom Act of 1998
(22 U.S.C. 6402), is inadmissible.
(H) Significant traffickers in persons.--
(i) In general.--Any alien who
commits or conspires to commit human
trafficking offenses in the United
States or outside the United States, or
who the consular officer, the Secretary
of Homeland Security, the Secretary of
State, or the Attorney General knows or
has reason to believe is or has been a
knowing aider, abettor, assister,
conspirator, or colluder with such a
trafficker in severe forms of
trafficking in persons, as defined in
the section 103 of such Act, is
inadmissible.
(ii) Beneficiaries of trafficking.--
Except as provided in clause (iii), any
alien who the consular officer or the
Attorney General knows or has reason to
believe is the spouse, son, or daughter
of an alien inadmissible under clause
(i), has, within the previous 5 years,
obtained any financial or other benefit
from the illicit activity of that
alien, and knew or reasonably should
have known that the financial or other
benefit was the product of such illicit
activity, is inadmissible.
(iii) Exception for certain sons and
Dissenting Views
H.R. 5585, the ``Agent Raul Gonzalez Officer Safety Act,''
would establish criminal and immigration penalties for flight
in a motor vehicle from a pursuing U.S. Border Patrol agent or
any federal, state, or local law enforcement assisting in such
pursuit.
I. Background
The United States' border region has long borne the brunt
of the most aggressive immigration enforcement efforts,
including high-speed vehicle pursuits by Border Patrol agents
that too often end in serious injuries and death, most often
for those being pursued.\1\ The number of fatalities resulting
from Border Patrol vehicle pursuits grew from 2 deaths in 2019
to 22 in 2021.\2\ Although law enforcement agencies across the
country have increasingly restricted when vehicle pursuits
could be undertaken, high speed chases along the border have
continued to rise. And while many agencies issued policies
authorizing chases only when there is an immediate risk of
danger to the public, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP)
was slow to revise its own pursuit policy.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Sheff, R., Inherent Risks: Policy Analysis and Recommendations
on Revised CBP Vehicle Pursuit Policy, ACLU of New Mexico and ACLU of
Texas (June 2023).
\2\Fact Sheet: The Deadly Trend of Border Patrol Vehicle Pursuits,
ACLU of New Mexico and ACLU of Texas.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 2021, following years of public outcry, CBP began making
efforts to update its high- speed vehicle pursuit policies to
better align with public safety concerns.\3\ In September of
2022, several members of Congress (led by Representative
Veronica Escobar (D TX)) wrote a letter to the Commissioner and
Deputy Commissioner of U.S. Customs and Border Protection
pointing out the urgent need to revise the agency's vehicle
pursuit policy following the deaths of 44 people, including
citizens, migrants, and innocent bystanders in the preceding
two years.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\U.S. Customs and Border Protection Emergency Driving and
Vehicular Pursuits 4510-026A, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (May
2023).
\4\U.S. Congress, House of Representatives, letter to Commissioner
Chris Magnus and Deputy Commissioner, U.S. Customs and Border
Protection (September 13, 2022).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
CBP's Law Enforcement Safety and Compliance (LESC)
Directorate ultimately conducted an extensive review of vehicle
pursuit policies.\5\ The review examined trends, statistics,
and outcomes associated with CBP pursuits and culminated in
several recommendations for improvement.\6\ Based on the review
and resulting recommendations, the policy that governed CBP
vehicular pursuits was updated to reflect that vehicular
pursuits pose inherent risks to members of the public, officers
and agents, and vehicle occupants. The newly revised CBP
Emergency Driving and Vehicular Pursuits Directive (ED-VP) was
published In January of 2023 and became effective in May of
that year.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\U.S. Customs and Border Protection, letter to the Honorable
Veronica Escobar, House of Representatives.
\6\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The updated ED-VP acknowledges the risks and shifts the
agency's overall approach to a risk-based model when pursuits
occur. Most importantly, the ED-VP adopts a `` reasonableness''
standard that is familiar to, and found throughout, most law
enforcement agencies across the United States.\7\ The ED-VP
also requires application of a Graham Factors Analysis to
vehicular pursuits (identical to the requirement already
established under CBP's use of force directive).\8\ The ED-VP
entrusts agents, officers, and their supervisors with the
ability to conduct pursuits based on their analysis of risk
factors, encourages them to consider other available means of
apprehending suspects, and reaffirms the overall law
enforcement need to conduct pursuits. The ED-VP further
clarifies the role of supervisors and establishes clear
reporting requirements to ensure continuous learning and
performance improvements over time.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Id.
\8\See Graham v. Connor, which is used to measure the justification
of use of force by law enforcement officers based upon severity of the
crime committed by a subject, the immediacy of threat posed by a
subject, and the level of resistance encountered from a subject while
considering the foreseeable risk of injury to officers/agents and
others.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The ED-VP provides a framework for weighing the risks of
conducting pursuits, such as danger to the public, against the
law enforcement benefit or need. The ED-VP further provides
factors to consider when deciding whether a vehicle should be
pursued, and when a pursuit should be terminated. Many of these
risk factors are self-evident, including road and weather
conditions, speed, and nearby population centers. Officers and
agents must now consider the government's interest in
immediately apprehending an individual, including the severity
of the crime at issue and the level of threat posed by the
individual. The policy prohibits officers and agents from
initiating or continuing pursuit of a vehicle that is exceeding
the speed limit and appears to be overloaded, unless they have
probable cause that a felony involving the use, or threatened
use, of physical force or violence that poses an imminent
threat has been or is about to be committed, and a reasonable
belief that the immediate need to apprehend clearly outweighs
the inherent risks.
II. Concerns Regarding This Legislation
H.R. 5585 is a solution in search of a problem. The ACLU's
CBP Fatal Encounter tracker reported 107 total deaths of non-
law enforcement officers that resulted from Border Patrol-
involved vehicle pursuits between January 2010 and November
2023. In the absence of a hearing on this issue, very little
information is publicly available about the number of Border
Patrol agents who have been killed in high-speed chases.
Notably, the proposed legislation is named in honor of Border
Patrol agent, Raul Gonzalez, Jr., who was killed in an ATV
accident while tracking a group of migrants in December of
2022. However, the facts are unclear as to whether Agent
Gonzalez was involved in a high-speed pursuit at the time of
the crash or even if the migrants he pursued were in a vehicle
at the time of the incident.
It is also important to note that in many of the pursuits
that occur near the border, migrants in the vehicle being
pursued have little to no control over the vehicle they are
being transported in and are typically not suspected of
committing an offense more serious than misdemeanor entry
without inspection. And in the vast majority of these pursuits,
the risks taken, and the harm caused, are largely
disproportionate to any suspected criminal activity.
Moreover, the bill attempts to create a new criminal
offense without defining facts that would make otherwise lawful
conduct unlawful. As drafted, the bill does not require a nexus
between the flight and knowledge or criminal intent, such as a
refusal to heed a law enforcement officer's visual or audible
signal to initiate a vehicle stop. And despite repeated
references to thedangers associated with high-speed chases
during the markup, the bill does not require high-speed flight, such as
speed exceeding the posted speed limit.
Even overlooking the vague definition of the offense as
proposed, prosecutors would be required to prove not that the
Border Patrol agent was acting within their duties as an agent
or employee but that the agent had the legal authority to
engage in a pursuit--which is a considerably more involved
question. In other words, a factfinder would have to determine
whether the agent was abiding by laws and regulations in effect
at the time of the pursuit.
Representative Sheila Jackson Lee (D-TX) offered an
amendment at the markup that would have required proof that a
pursuing Border Patrol agent was acting within their official
duties--meaning within the scope of what an agent is employed
to do. The Jackson Lee amendment's proposed language mirrored
existing federal criminal statutes that prohibit the commission
of various offenses, including assault, murder, and
manslaughter, perpetrated against officers and employees of the
United States, and foreign officials, while engaged in the
performance of their official duties.
In addition to its technical deficiencies, H.R. 5585 is of
great concern because it would also expand mandatory minimum
penalties that would apply to conduct without proof of intent.
In general, flight from a Border Patrol agent in a motor
vehicle would be a felony punishable by not more than two years
imprisonment and a fine. The bill would require mandatory
sentences of at least five years and up to ten years, depending
on whether serious bodily injury or death occurs. These
mandatory minimum penalties would be triggered without proof
that a defendant intentionally caused serious bodily injury or
death.
Democrats have long opposed the creation of new criminal
offenses and the imposition and expansion of mandatory minimum
penalties. Mandatory minimum sentencing schemes undermine the
overarching directive set forth in 18 U.S.C. 3553(a), which
directs sentencing judges to consider the totality of the
circumstances to impose a sentence sufficient but not greater
than necessary to achieve the goals and purposes of federal
sentencing. The Jackson Lee amendment would have eliminated the
mandatory minimum penalties in the bill while maintaining the
proposed maximum penalties.
In addition to the concerns regarding the criminal aspects
of this bill, the immigration portion of this bill is a
solution in search of a problem. People who are convicted of
fleeing law enforcement are already deportable and
inadmissible. U.S. immigration law gives the federal government
the power to strip lawfully present immigrants of their
immigration status and to prevent others from gaining entry or
status.
Section 212 of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA)
provides the reasons a non-citizen may be determined to be
inadmissible, and Section 237 contains the INA's deportability
provisions.\10\ Both sections contain similar, but not entirely
identical grounds, ranging from criminal convictions and
security/terrorism grounds to foreign policy and public charge-
related grounds. Section 212 applies to individuals who are
applying for status in the United States, whereas Section 237
generally applies to individuals who have been lawfully
admitted into the United States and are lawfully present in the
United States.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\INA Sec. Sec. 212; 237.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 212(a)(2) and Section 237(a)(2) of the INA contain
the criminal-related inadmissibility and deportability
grounds.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\INA Sec. Sec. 212(a)(2); 237(a)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 237(a)(2)(A) renders deportable any noncitizen who
``is convicted of some crime involving moral turpitude
committed within five years . . . after the date of
admission.''\12\ Further, the conviction must be one ``for
which a sentence of one year or longer may be imposed.''\13\
This means that the actual sentence imposed need not be one
year of imprisonment, but rather that if one is convicted of
the offense, one could be sentenced to at least one year in
prison.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\INA Sec. Sec. 212(a)(2).
\13\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 212(a)(2)(A)(i) is broader--it states that any
noncitizen ``convicted of, or who admits to committing acts
which constitute essential elements of . . . a crime involving
moral turpitude (other than a purely political offense) or an
attempt or conspiracy to commit such a crime . . . is
inadmissible.''\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\INA Sec. 212(a)(2)(A)(i).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
People who are convicted of fleeing law enforcement are
already deportable and inadmissible. The Board of Immigration
Appeals, as upheld by multiple appellate circuits, previously
determined that knowingly fleeing or eluding law enforcement is
a crime involving moral turpitude (CIMT).\15\ In many
jurisdictions, such a crime, especially if it results in injury
or death, is punishable by a year or more in prison. Under
current immigration law, a CIMT conviction where the crime is
punishable by one year or more makes an individual deportable,
and any conviction of or admission to acts constituting a CIMT
makes an individual inadmissible.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\See, e.g., Granados v. Garland, 992 F.3d 755 (9th Cir. 2021);
Cano-Oyarzabal v. Holder, 774 F.3d 914 (7th Cir. 2014) (``Knowingly
fleeing or attempting to elude an officer is an act wrong in itself and
therefore a crime involving moral turpitude.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
However, this bill makes a significant change by not
requiring that an individual be convicted of the crime to
render them deportable. Right now, if someone commits or admits
to committing acts constituting the elements of the crime of
knowingly fleeing or evading law enforcement, they would be
rendered inadmissible, but to be rendered deportable,
currently, a conviction is required. This bill would erase that
conviction requirement--allowing someone to be rendered
deportable, even if they have never been convicted of a crime.
The deportability grounds are not about undocumented
immigrants, who are already removable. They apply only to
people who are lawfully present in the United States. Without
requiring a conviction, this raises serious due process
concerns for longstanding legal residents. At markup,
Representative Escobar (D-TX) offered an amendment to require a
conviction before a person can be deported under this new
ground. Republicans defeated the amendment on a party line
vote.
The majority consistently conflated the deportability and
inadmissibility grounds in their reasoning for opposing the
amendment. While there are exceptions, the vast majority of the
deportability grounds require a conviction. That is because
deportability grounds generally apply to those who are already
here and came lawfully and have often lived in the United State
for a long time. As was discussed by Representatives Escobar
and Jayapal (D-WA), sadly, there are legitimate, non-extralegal
reasons why an individual might be concerned about being pulled
over by a Border Patrol officer or law enforcement officer.
H.R. 5585 is an unnecessary piece of legislation that would
create new mandatory minimum sentences and have significant
unintended consequences for long-term residents of this county.
Instead of working with Democrats to advance bipartisan
legislation, the Majority has once again advanced a
fundamentally unserious proposal to close an imaginary gap in
the law.
For all of these reasons, I dissent, and I urge all of my
colleagues to oppose this legislation.
Jerrold Nadler,
Ranking Member.