Minority Views
Legislative Branch Oversight
INTRODUCTION
The oversight and authorization activities of the Committee
on House Administration are key to the operations of the
Legislative Branch. During the 116th and 117th Congresses,
Committee Democrats guided the House through several
generational challenges, ensuring continuity of operations
during the COVID-19 pandemic and in the aftermath of the
January 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol. Even in the face of
these historic obstacles, the Committee made unprecedented
improvements to House operations, particularly with respect to
human capital and institutional capacity.
According to Demand Progress, a nonpartisan, non-
governmental organization focused on strengthening democracy,
the House ``improve[d] the working conditions for its staff in
the 117th Congress than Congress has over the last three
decades combined.''\1\ These reforms improved the ability for
the House to recruit and retain top talent and provided Members
and staff with tools to perform their jobs more effectively,
strengthening the institution. Advances included, among others:
creating the House Office of Diversity and Inclusion and House
Office of Whistleblower Ombuds; imposing a $45,000.00 pay floor
for full-time House staff; decoupling of Member and staff pay;
raising the staff pay cap; increasing the lifetime maximum for
the Student Loan Repayment Program (SLRP) and exempting SLRP
payments from the pay cap; adoption of regulations recommended
by the nonpartisan Office of Congressional Workplace Rights
(OCWR) providing for unionization and collective bargaining for
House staff who choose to exercise such rights; adoption of
regulations recommended by OCWR relating to application of
rights under the Family and Medical Leave Act and Fair Labor
Standards Act for House staff; extending the House Paid
Internship Program to committees; raising the maximum allowable
compensation for interns; growing committee capacity by
increasing committee funding; expanding the Congressional Staff
Academy; launching the CAO Coach Program; creating the House
Human Resources Hub; and enlarging the House Child Care Center;
and increasing the capacity of the Office of Employee
Assistance.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Demand Progress, Statement on House Unionization Vote +
Establishment of Minimum Wage (May 7, 2022), https://
demandprogress.org/statement-on-house-unionization-vote-
establishment-of-minimum-wage/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The accomplishments of Committee Democrats in the 116th and
117th Congresses led Axios to declare that the Committee,
``once seen as a bureaucratic backwater is now at the center of
some of the biggest policy fights in Congress.''\2\ In addition
to the reforms discussed above, Committee Democrats took a
leading role on issues related to election administration and
the assault on voting rights; disinformation surrounding U.S.
elections; both physical and cyber security; and the removal of
white supremacist and Confederate statuary and art from places
of honor in the Capitol. The Committee also drove the
authorization of two new Smithsonian museums: the National
Museum of the American Latino and American Women's History
Museum.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Lachlan Markay, Capitol Hill's Smallest Committee Takes Center
Stage, Axios (May 26, 2022), https://www.axios.com/2022/05/26/house-
administrative-committee-capitol-security.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Committee Minority looks forward to working with the
new Committee Majority to further strengthen the institution.
In particular, the Committee Minority appreciates the Committee
Majority's establishment of the Subcommittee on the
Modernization of Congress, and the fact that the Majority
agreed to an even split among Democratic and Republican
Members. The Select Committee on the Modernization of Congress,
established by House Rules packages in both the 116th and 117th
Congress made many recommendations to improve the institution,
and while the Committee implemented or partially implemented
more than 130 such recommendations in the previous Congresses,
additional implementation work remains.
The Committee Minority is committed to working in a
bipartisan fashion in its oversight of the Legislative Branch.
However, there will inevitably be matters in which the
Committee Minority will disagree with the Committee Majority.
For example, the Committee Minority is deeply troubled by
public reporting that the Speaker of the House Kevin McCarthy
made a deal with Fox News personality Tucker Carlson, who has
referred to the January 6, 2021, attack as a ``false flag
operation''\3\ to provide him--and him alone--with ``unfettered
access''\4\ to tens of thousands of hours of security footage
of the Capitol related to the January 6, 2021, attack.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Meryl Kornfield and Jacqueline Alemany, McCarthy gives Tucker
Carlson exclusive access to Jan. 6 riot video, The Washington Post
(Feb. 21, 2023), http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/02/21/
tucker-carlson-kevin-mccarthy-jan-6-insurrection/.
\4\Id.
\5\Mike Allen, Exclusive: McCarthy gives Tucker Carlson access to
trove of Jan. 6 riot tape, Axios (February 20, 2023), https://
www.axios.com/2023/02/20/kevin-mccarthy-tucker-carlson-jan-6-riot-
footage.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
United States Capitol Police (USCP or Department)
leadership has repeatedly stressed the danger of publicly
releasing this footage, explaining that it puts the Capitol at
significant risk. For example, in July 2022, the USCP Acting
Assistant Chief of Police for Uniformed Operations said, in an
affidavit made as part of a federal prosecution, ``USCP
continues to consider any interior footage of the U.S. Capitol
to be highly sensitive information, and any access to it should
be strictly limited.''\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Declaration of Sean P. Gallagher, U.S. v. Egtvedt, No. 1:21-cr-
00177 (D.D.C.).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As has been well publicized, in the runup to the January 6,
2021, attack, rioters attempted to gather information about the
interior of the Capitol, including tunnels and non-publicly
available floor plans. Providing access to hours of footage
will result in security vulnerabilities of the Capitol being
collected, exposed, and passed on to those who might wish to
attack the Capitol again. That the Capitol is open to the
public and that video footage of the January 6 attack is widely
available does not diminish the need to prevent large swaths of
unvetted security footage from being made public. According to
a federal judge who issued a protective order related to the
footage, ``Even if some information about the U.S. Capitol's
layout is available online, USCP's footage provides far more
detailed information, which could raise security concerns if
copied and publicized.''\7\ In addition, sophisticated foreign
and nonstate actors may be able to use the security camera
footage to identify weaknesses in Capitol security, such as
potential blind spots and Member evacuation routes. Moreover,
release of the footage would cause issues in the prosecutions
of January 6 defendants, whose attorneys only have access to
security camera footage under a protective order.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\U.S. v. Cudd, 534 F.Supp. 3d 48, 54 (D.D.C. 2021).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The danger associated with these actions is even more
significant when considering the individual being provided the
footage. Mr. Carlson has a lengthy record of lying and
spreading disinformation about the January 6, 2021, attack on
his television show in an apparent attempt to rewrite history.
According to the Washington Post,
``Carlson promoted false and debunked claims about
government agents stoking the riot, from the wife of an
accused rioter (whom he later interviewed on his show
without comment) to elevating evidence-free and
obviously flimsy claims about a man named Ray Epps to a
national audience. He produced a widely debunked three-
part series aimed at reframing the Capitol riot in a
way that attributed responsibility to government
actors--and slotted the response to the riot in his
exhaustingly simplistic us-vs.-them narrative. When the
House select committee investigating the riot first
aired a hearing in prime time, Carlson's show was an
ad-free hour of handing the microphone to riot
sympathizers and conspiracy theorists.''\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Kornfield, supra note 3.
Historically, Mr. Carlson's conspiracy theories and false
claims are so outrageous that attorneys for Fox News have
forced to concede in federal court that he should not be
considered an objective source of information.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\McDougal v. Fox News Network, LLC, 489 F.Supp. 174 (2020); see
also David Folkenflik, You Literally Can't Believe The Facts Tucker
Carlson Tells You. So Say Fox's Lawyers, NPR (September 29, 2020),
https://www.npr.org/2020/09/29/917747123/you-literally-cant-believe-
the-facts-tucker-carlson-tells-you-so-say-fox-s-lawye.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Any attempts by defenders of these actions to create a
false equivalence with the work of the Select Committee to
Investigate the January 6, 2021, Attack on the Capitol (Select
Committee) should be dismissed. During the course of its
investigation, the Select Committee worked directly with the
Department to ensure the security camera footage that was
ultimately released to the public did not pose a security
threat. The Select Committee was required to clear all footage
it released publicly with the Department. In some cases, the
Department did voice such objections, and the Select Committee
worked with the Department to address its concerns. In
addition, any individual that reviewed security footage signed
a user agreement, and their individual actions were tracked so
there was a record of who accessed what and when. No such
safeguards appear to be in place in the present case, and,
according to the New York Times, Mr. Carlson has explicitly
stated that ``he and a large team of staff members [are]
looking at the footage.''\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Luke Broadwater and Jonathan Swan, In Sharing Video With Fox
Host, McCarthy Hits Rewind on Jan. 6, N.Y. Times (Feb. 22, 2023),
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/22/us/politics/
tucker-carlson-jan-6-mccarthy.html.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Committee Minority intends to conduct robust oversight
on this issue and hopes that the Committee Majority will
rethink this decision, which, according to security
professionals, presents a significant security risk. Among the
unknowns the Minority intends to uncover are:
What footage has Tucker Carlson's representatives
already viewed?
What conditions did the Speaker's Office put on
the review of that footage?
Does the Speaker intend to physically transfer
video files to Tucker Carlson or anybody else?
What does Tucker Carlson intend to do with the
footage?
As part of this Authorization and Oversight Plan, the
Majority says that it will ``empower security experts, not
politicians, to make security related decisions.'' Yet, the
Department has made clear that it views release of security
footage as a prodigious security threat.
HOUSE OFFICERS AND OPERATIONS, GENERALLY
The Committee Minority agrees with the Committee Majority
that the House should be accountable, open, accessible,
transparent, professional, modern and resilient. In particular,
the Minority shares the Majority's interest in ``facilitat[ing]
more opportunities for Americans to engage with Congress.'' The
Minority is therefore disappointed that the new House Majority
eliminated the option for hearing witnesses to provide
testimony remotely. Remote testimony allows individuals without
the financial means to travel to Washington, DC to engage
directly with Congress. It also makes it easier for individuals
with disabilities, rural Americans, and those with job
restrictions to engage with their elected representatives. When
Congress limits hearing witnesses to those with enough time,
money, child care and job flexibility to travel to Washington
for several days, it takes away the voice of millions of
Americans who deserve to heard.
The Committee Majority also expresses a desire to ``oversee
the coordination of services across the House entities to
ensure Committees may host field hearings across the country
and U.S. territories safely and effectively.'' With the
assistance of the House Recording Studio the Committee Minority
convened nine field hearings, two field roundtables and one
field listening session during the 116th and 117th Congresses.
The Minority looks forward to continuing to provide oversight
of the House Recording Studio's field hearing capabilities by
participating in additional proceedings outside Washington, DC.
CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER
The Committee Minority agrees with the Committee Majority's
oversight goals for the Chief Administrative Officer (CAO). In
addition, the Committee Minority intends to:
Provide vigorous oversight of services provided to
district offices, including the concept of enterprise-wide
district office WiFi.
Examine the House's relationship with the General
Services Administration (GSA) to ensure Members can effectively
serve their constituents through district offices in GSA-owned
buildings.
Review efforts to diversify the CAO workforce,
including oversight of CAO diversity working groups and
mentoring programs.
Continue efforts to improve customer service and
communications across all CAO functions and business units.
Continue oversight of House technology upgrades,
including MyExpenses.
Review proposed reforms to the Office of Finance
and Payroll and Benefits, including potential implementation of
the Select Committee on the Modernization of Congress
recommendation to shift to bimonthly pay periods.
Continue oversight of the Student Loan Repayment
Program.
Review and oversee information technology services
provided, maintained or hosted by House Information Resources
(HIR).
Continue oversight of failsafe procedures to
guarantee continuity of operations.
Continue oversight of House cybersecurity
practices, including network security and threat prevention.
Provide oversight of the House Disaster Recovery
Program.
Oversee web services activities, including new
Member website development, with a focus on accessibility.
Oversee the Technology Partner Program.
Oversee continued efforts to move toward cloud
computing.
HOUSE SERGEANT AT ARMS
The Committee Minority also agrees with the Committee
Majority's stated goal of independently empowering security
experts, not politicians, to make security related decisions.
Unfortunately, this stands in stark contrast with the decision
to provide a Fox News personality access to Capitol security
camera footage, in direct contravention of the wishes of
security experts within USCP.
In addition to many of the priorities noted by the
Majority, the Minority intends to:
Oversee continued implementation of the
Residential Security Program initiated during the 117th
Congress.
Continue to review the effectiveness of the
district office security center and law enforcement coordinator
program.
Review the HSAA role on the Capitol Police Board
and study potential reforms thereto.
Monitor implementation of security recommendations
made by various security experts in the aftermath of the
January 6, 2021, attack, including those made by Lt. General
Russel Honore's task force, the USCP Office of Inspector
General and Architect of the Capitol Office of Inspector
General.
Oversee efforts to improving emergency
preparedness training for Members and staff, both in
Washington, DC and in their respective districts.
Monitor efforts to appoint a permanent Sergeant at
Arms, including progress of any national search.
CLERK OF THE HOUSE
The Committee Minority commends the Office of the Clerk for
its work during the protracted election for Speaker of the
House. The Minority intends to focus its Office of the Clerk-
related oversight on the following:
Review the Clerk's current IT configuration and
redundancy posture.
Oversee the House document repository.
Oversee lobbying disclosure process, including
ways to make data more easily accessible for the general
public.
Review standards for the electronic exchange of
legislative information among the chambers of congress and
Legislative Branch agencies.
Coordinate on matters under the jurisdiction of
the House Fine Arts Board and the Capitol Preservation Board.
Continue review of functions and administrative
operations assigned to the Clerk.
Review of semi-annual financial and operational
status reports; recommend changes in operations to improve
services and increase efficiencies.
Review the printing needs of the Clerk to evaluate
the potential for eliminating duplication.
Review the application programming interface
incorporated in the Clerk's website.
Oversee preparation of congressionally authorized
publications.
Oversee participation in the Congressional Data
Task Force.
Continued oversight of official reporter
participation in field hearings.
HOUSE OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GENERAL
The Committee Minority agrees with the Committee Majority's
oversight priorities for the House Office of Inspector General
and looks forward to providing direction on audits management
advisories on a bipartisan basis.
ARCHITECT OF THE CAPITOL
The Committee Minority agrees with many of the Committee
Majority's oversight priorities for the Architect of the
Capitol (AOC). In addition to the priorities noted by the
Majority, the Minority intends to:
Review and improve, where it is within the
Committee's jurisdiction to do so, the process by which the
Architect of the Capitol and the Deputy Architect are
appointed.
Oversee AOC hiring practices, with an emphasis on
improving diversity across the AOC, including the C-Suite.
Oversee continued restoration, repairs and
security improvements necessitated by the January 6, 2021,
attack at the Capitol.
Review AOC efforts to improve discipline program
and accountability systems, including those applicable to
exempt personnel.
Review mechanisms put in place by the AOC to
ensure unallowable costs re
Minority Views
In a disappointing departure from prior Homeland Security
Committee authorization and oversight plans--where there was
high-level bipartisan agreement on a range of areas for
review--this plan reads like a roadmap for the extreme, MAGA
House Republican majority. It fails to give needed attention to
a wide range of longstanding areas for oversight within the
Department of Homeland Security (DHS), the third-largest
Federal Department. The most glaring omission is its failure to
give specific attention to domestic terrorism, a threat that
our top national security officials have unequivocally
recognized as persistent and pervasive.
Officials from administrations representing both parties
have recognized the growing threat of domestic terrorism. In
the 116th and 117th Congresses, the Committee held 13 hearings
on the increasing and dynamic domestic terrorist threat. In
addition to those hearings, the Committee held annual hearings
on worldwide threats where DHS and Intelligence Community
officials--in both the Trump and Biden administrations--warned
of the heightened threat posed by domestic violent extremists.
The Trump administration's October 2020 Homeland Threat
Assessment stated: ``The primary terrorist threat inside the
United States will stem from lone offenders and small cells of
individuals, including Domestic Violent Extremists (DVEs) and
foreign terrorist-inspired Homegrown Violent Extremists
(HVEs).''\1\ The same threat assessment also foreshadowed the
January 6, 2021, domestic terrorist attack on the U.S. Congress
stating, ``political tensions in 2020 . . . will drive an
elevated threat environment at least through early 2021.''\2\
And the 2021 threat assessment produced by the Director of
National Intelligence appointed by President Biden stated:
``US-based lone actors and small cells with a broad range of
ideological motivations pose a greater immediate domestic
threat'' than ISIS or al Qaeda.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\``Homeland Threat Assessment,'' Department of Homeland Security,
(Oct. 2020), available at https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/
publications/2020_10_06_homeland-threat-assessment.pdf, p. 17 (internal
citations omitted).
\2\Ibid.
\3\``Annual Threat Assessment of the US Intelligence Community,''
Office of the Director of National Intelligence, (April 9, 2021),
available at https://www.dni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/
assessments/ATA 2021-Unclassified-Report.pdf, p. 23.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Domestic terrorism should not be a partisan issue. Since
2010, domestic violent extremists have conducted at least 47
lethal attacks that have killed 152 people in the United
States.\4\ Antisemitism drove many of these attacks, like the
murder of 11 Jewish people at the Tree of Life synagogue in
Pittsburgh in 2018. The Committee has received testimony that
antisemitism is often a throughline between domestic and
international terrorist threats. As such, it deserves specific
mention in the Committee's oversight plan.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\``Strategic Intelligence Assessment and Data on Domestic
Terrorism,'' Federal Bureau of Investigation and Department of Homeland
Security, (Oct. 2022), available at https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/
files/2022-10/22_1025_strategic-intelligence-assessment-data-domestic-
terrorism.pdf, p. 38.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Democrats gave Republicans an opportunity to correct this
fatal flaw in the plan during the Committee's February 28th
business meeting. A two-sentence Democratic amendment would
have ensured the Committee continued to examine domestic
terrorism on a bipartisan basis, like it did in the last two
Congresses. Instead, Committee Republicans bowed to the will of
their most extreme elements and adopted another amendment that
struck the word ``domestic'' each time it appeared in the
Democratic amendment and appended conclusory language about
Federal agencies being politicized and abusive. Committee
Democrats are profoundly disappointed that extreme, MAGA
Republican talking points now appear to inspire the Committee's
oversight and legislative work. The 260,000 hardworking women
and men at DHS and other Federal law enforcement agencies
deserve better.
This authorization and oversight plan is also rife with
nods to anti-immigrant elements in the Republican Party. For
example, the plan refers to undocumented noncitizens as
``illegal aliens'' or ``criminal aliens.'' Committee Democrats
cannot support such charged language that seeks to divide and
stigmatize fellow human beings. Similarly, the plan seems to
walk back the Committee's previous extensive oversight of how
migrants and others are treated in DHS custody.
There are other serious concerns with this plan:
Republicans are so preoccupied with the Southwest
border that their plan's border security section omits any
mention of the Northern border and only passing mention of air
and sea borders, despite the fact that foreign terrorists have
repeatedly arrived by air.
The plan lacks any mention of equity in disaster
relief--a persistent challenge for many communities in both
urban and rural America.
It makes scant mention of the human capital and
morale issues at DHS, which have been a major concern for the
Committee over successive Congresses.
There is no mention of diversity in the
Department's leadership and developing a workforce that
reflects the country through stronger recruiting and hiring
practices.
Finally, Committee Democrats are concerned that Republican
attempts to examine waste, fraud, and abuse at DHS could be a
thinly veiled attempt to target Federal workers. Recent media
reports have suggested that other House committees could be
pressuring low- to mid-level career civil servants,\5\ and we
hope this Committee does not go down the same road given the
DHS workforce's morale problems.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Lisa Rein and Jacqueline Alemany, ``Emboldened by its majority,
House GOP turns up heat on federal workers,'' Washington Post, (Feb.
27, 2023), available at https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/
02/27/house-gop-federal-workers-jim-jordan/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Committee on Homeland Security has broad oversight
jurisdiction under House rule X. And notwithstanding this
exercise in partisan politics, Democrats welcome support for
bipartisan collaboration on homeland security issues important
to the communities we serve. We regret such collaboration is
not evident in this authorization and oversight plan.
Bennie G. Thompson.
Sheila Jackson Lee.
Donald M. Payne, Jr.
Eric Swalwell.
J. Luis Correa.
Troy A. Carter.
Shri Thanedar.
Seth Magaziner.
Glenn Ivey.
Daniel S. Goldman.
Robert Garcia.
Delia C. Ramirez.
Robert Menendez.
Yvette D. Clarke.
Dina Titus.
COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY
AUTHORIZATION AND OVERSIGHT PLAN FOR THE 118TH CONGRESS
February 28, 2023
In accordance with House rule X, the Committee on the
Judiciary is responsible for determining whether the laws and
programs within its jurisdiction are implemented and carried
out in accordance with the intent of Congress and whether they
should be continued, altered, or eliminated. Accordingly, in
the 118th Congress, the Committee will review the laws and
programs within its jurisdiction to assess their application,
administration, execution, and effectiveness. The Committee
will also review the organization and operation of federal
agencies and entities within its jurisdiction for the
administration and execution of laws and programs.
The Committee will review the mission and operations of the
agencies and programs within its jurisdiction, including
assessing the potential reauthorization or reorganization of
components of the Department of Justice, Department of Homeland
Security, and other agencies. In doing so, the Committee will
identify wasteful, inefficient, or duplicative programs that
should be streamlined or eliminated, as well as those that
could be enhanced. The Committee also seeks to eliminate fraud,
abuse, and mismanagement. The Committee hopes to streamline and
eliminate wasteful spending on agencies and programs within its
jurisdiction.
This document outlines the current plans of the Committee
on the Judiciary for authorization and oversight activities in
the 118th Congress. As required by House Rules, Part I includes
a description of programs and agencies the Committee will
consider reauthorizing during the 118th Congress and notes
which programs and agencies received funding in fiscal year
2022 despite having lapsed authorizations. Part II includes
oversight the Committee intends to conduct to help determine
whether to authorize certain programs and agencies or to inform
potential legislative reforms for these entities.
PART I
The following programs and agencies are potentially subject
to reauthorization in the 118th Congress. Programs or agencies
designated with an asterisk received funding during fiscal year
2022 despite having no current authorization for appropriation.
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
GENERAL ADMINISTRATION*
General Administration (GA) supports the Attorney General
and the Department of Justice's senior policy level officials
in managing Department resources and developing policies for
legal, law enforcement, and criminal justice activities.
Justice Information Sharing Technology*
Justice Information Sharing Technology programs fund the
Department's enterprise investments in information technology.
Office of the Inspector General*
The Office of the Inspector General is an independent
office within the Department of Justice that is charged with
investigating allegations of fraud, waste, abuse, and
misconduct by Department employees, contractors, and grantees
and promoting economy and efficiency in Department operations.
Administrative Review and Appeals*
The Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) includes
Immigration Judges, the Board of Immigration Appeals, and the
Office of the Chief Administrative Hearing Officer. EOIR
presides over administrative immigration hearings such as
benefits adjudications, removal, bond, and employer sanctions
proceedings.
U.S. PAROLE COMMISSION
The Parole Commission is responsible for granting or
denying parole to, and supervising the parole releases of,
incarcerated individuals who fall under its jurisdiction.
LEGAL ACTIVITIES
Office of the Solicitor General*
The office of the Solicitor General supervises and
processes all appellate matters and represents the U.S. and
federal agencies before the Supreme Court.
Tax Division*
The Tax Division represents the U.S. in litigation arising
under the internal revenue laws.
Criminal Division*
The Criminal Division is responsible for supervising the
application of all federal criminal laws except those
specifically assigned to other divisions. The Criminal Division
prosecutes the most significant financial crimes, including
mortgage fraud, corporate fraud, and sophisticated investment
fraud; coordinates multi-district financial crime cases; and
assists U.S. Attorneys' Offices in financial crime cases with
significant money laundering and asset forfeiture components.
Civil Division*
The Civil Division represents the United States, its
departments and agencies, and other federal employees in
litigation in federal and state courts. The Division also
brings suits on behalf of the United States in litigation,
primarily to recoup money lost through fraud, loan defaults,
and the abuse of federal funds.
Environmental and Natural Resources Division*
The Environmental and Natural Resources Division enforces
the nation's civil and criminal environmental laws; defends
environmental challenges to federal law and actions; and
performs a variety of other legal activities related to the
environment and our Nation's natural resources.
Civil Rights Division*
The Civil Rights Division is responsible for enforcing
federal statutes that protect the civil rights of all Americans
and prohibit discrimination based on race, sex, disability,
religion, and national origin.
INTERPOL Washington*
INTERPOL Washington facilitates cooperation and
information-sharing among police agencies in different
countries. It coordinates with more than 18,000 federal, state,
and local law enforcement authorities and the 193 other member
countries for INTERPOL-related matters.
EXECUTIVE OFFICE FOR U.S. ATTORNEYS*
There are 94 U.S. Attorneys located throughout the United
States, the District of Columbia, Guam, the Northern Mariana
Islands, Puerto Rico, and the Virgin Islands. The U.S.
Attorneys who lead each office are the chief law enforcement
representatives of the Attorney General. Each U.S. Attorney
enforces federal criminal law; handles most of the civil
litigation in which the United States is involved; and
initiates proceedings for the collection of fines, penalties,
and forfeitures owed to the United States.
ASSETS FORFEITURE FUND*
The Assets Forfeiture Fund (AFF), administered by the U.S.
Marshals Service, manages and disposes of properties seized by
and forfeited to federal law enforcement agencies and U.S.
Attorneys nationwide. The Attorney General is authorized to use
the AFF to pay necessary expenses associated with forfeitures.
The Fund may also be used to finance certain general
investigative expenses, such as those enumerated in 28 U.S.C.
Sec. 524(c).
The AFF is also used to compensate victims of specific
crimes for which the proceeds were subject to forfeiture. After
those costs, the Department uses the funds to pay for the
management costs associated with disposing and forfeiting
property. The AFF is also used to help fund law enforcement at
the state and local level who assist with federal law
enforcement priorities.
U.S. MARSHALS SERVICE*
The U.S. Marshals Service administers the Asset Forfeiture
Program of the Justice Department; conducts investigations
involving escaped federal prisoners, unregistered sex
offenders, and other fugitives; ensures safety at federal
judicial proceedings; assumes custody of individuals arrested
by all federal agencies; houses and transports prisoners; and
manages the Witness Security Program.
NATIONAL SECURITY DIVISION*
Congress created the National Security Division in the USA
PATRIOT Improvement and Reauthorization Act of 2005. The NSD
consists of the elements of Department of Justice, other than
the Federal Bureau of Investigation, engaged primarily in
support of the intelligence and intelligence-related activities
of the federal government, including: (1) the Assistant
Attorney General for National Security, (2) the Office of
Intelligence Policy and Review, (3) the counterterrorism
section, (4) the counterespionage section, and (5) any other
offices designated by the Attorney General.
ANTITRUST DIVISION*
The mission of the Antitrust Division is to promote
economic competition through enforcing the nation's antitrust
laws and providing guidance on antitrust laws and principles.
ORGANIZED CRIME DRUG ENFORCEMENT TASK FORCES (OCDETF) PROGRAM*
The OCDETF program is part of the Department's intra-and
inter-agency drug enforcement strategy. It coordinates with
elements of federal law enforcement--including components of
the Department of Homeland Security and the Department of the
Treasury--to disrupt national and transnational criminal
organizations engaged in drug trafficking and money laundering,
and those organizations primarily responsible for the nation's
illegal drug supply.
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION*
The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) is charged with
investigating terrorism, cybercrimes, public corruption, white-
collar crime, organized crime, civil rights violations, and
other federal offenses.
DRUG ENFORCEMENT ADMINISTRATION*
The Drug Enforcement Administration is the federal agency
tasked with reducing the illicit supply and abuse of narcotics
and drugs through drug interdiction and seizing of illicit
revenues and assets from drug trafficking organizations.
BUREAU OF ALCOHOL, TOBACCO, FIREARMS AND EXPLOSIVES*
The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives is
tasked with investigating violent crime, terrorism, and the
illegal trafficking of alcohol and tobacco products.
FEDERAL PRISON SYSTEM*
The Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) is responsible for the
custody and care of federal offenders in prisons and community-
based facilities. BOP is currently responsible for housing more
than 145,000 federal offenders, which includes sentenced
inmates as well as persons awaiting trial and/or sentencing.
FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION
BUREAU OF COMPETITION*
The Federal Trade Commission's Bureau of Competition shares
jurisdiction with the Justice Department's Antitrust Division
for the enforcement of the nation's antitrust laws.
DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY
U.S. CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) oversees
the adjudication of applications and petitions for immigration
benefits. USCIS is funded primarily by immigration and
naturalization benefit fees charged to applicants and
petitioners. However, Congress did provide some fiscal year
2022 and 2023 funding for certain USCIS activities, and it
appropriates funding annually for the E-Verify Program.
E-Verify Program
Section 401 of the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant
Responsibility Act of 1996 authorizes the Department of
Homeland Security to ``conduct 3 pilot programs of employment
eligibility confirmation'' including the E-Verify program,
which allows employers to electronically check the employment
eligibility of potential employees. Section 401(b) of that Act,
as amended, currently provides that ``[u]nless the Congress
otherwise provides, the Secretary of Homeland Security shall
terminate a pilot program on September 30, 2023.''
Dissenting Views
On February 7, 2023, the House Natural Resources Committee
considered its Authorization and Oversight (A&O) Plan for the
118th Congress, pursuant to clause 2(d)(1) of rule X of the
House of Representatives. This plan, which was crafted by the
Committee's Republican majority, and which passed on a party-
line vote, ignores crucial components of the Committee's
jurisdiction--including the climate crisis and environmental
justice--while uplifting a litany of industry priorities.
Throughout debate on the plan itself and on amendments offered
by Committee Democrats, all of which Republicans voted down
along party lines, Committee Republicans demonstrated an
interest in advancing an industry wish-list agenda over
protecting the interests of the American people.
As Members of the House Natural Resources Committee, we are
charged with the monumental tasks of protecting our planet from
climate change and improving the quality of life of our
communities for generations to come. This Authorization and
Oversight Plan proves that Committee Republicans are not yet
ready to meet that charge.
Ironically, Committee Republicans' A&O Plan focuses on
attacking, rather than building on, the successes of the
Infrastructure, Investment, and Jobs Act (IIJA) and the
Inflation Reduction Act (IRA). Both bills were historic climate
and environment wins--the IRA is the largest climate bill in
history--which included funding for supposed Republican
priorities like forest management, drought resilience,
environmental permitting, and renewable deployment. Yet,
Committee Republicans vehemently opposed both bills, and their
oversight plan continues their misguided attacks on these
essential investments in the future of the United States.
Committee Republicans' A&O Plan mentions climate change
only twice: once in a section railing against investments in
science-based climate programs at the United States Geological
Survey (USGS) and again in a section citing scientifically
dubious, wholly insufficient efforts like restorative grazing
as climate solutions. Not including climate change as a major
component of this plan is a blatant disservice to the American
people, especially those who live in communities that are being
hit hardest by climate change.
The A&O Plan put forth by Committee Republicans would see
the Committee work to drastically expand fossil fuel extraction
on public lands, all while lowering environmental and community
protection standards, despite the fact that fossil fuels
extracted from public lands and waters are already responsible
for 25 percent of United States carbon pollution. The plan does
not include pathways for oversight of the fossil fuel
industry's record profits year after year--earned while prices
soared for consumers--nor does the plan consider the public
health impact of fossil fuel extraction, which we know is
disproportionality borne by communities of color, low-income
communities, and Indigenous communities. When Energy and
Mineral Resources Subcommittee Ranking Member Ocasio-Cortez
offered an amendment to consider the health impacts of
extraction, Republicans uniformly opposed this addition. The
Ocasio-Cortez amendment would have added the following to the
A&O Plan:
Community Impacts of Extraction--Federal fossil fuel
extraction is a significant driver of carbon pollution,
air and water quality, and public health impacts. These
burdens are disproportionately concentrated in
communities of color, low-income communities, and
Indigenous communities. The Committee will perform
oversight to understand how federal fossil fuel
programs impact community health and safety.
Notably, the amendment would not have removed any of the
Republican A&O Plan as proposed. It only would have required
the Committee to perform its duty to conduct oversight into the
disproportionate burdens created by fossil fuel development on
public lands and waters. It is disappointing, to say the least,
that Republicans unanimously voted against including this item
in the Committee's agenda.
Reducing emissions and prioritizing clean, renewable energy
on public lands could be a huge step toward our country's
climate goals, yet Committee Republicans apparently have no
serious plans to address these priorities. Our Committee has
the ability to deliver real climate solutions to the
communities that have been overburdened by climate change,
including poor communities, communities of color, Indigenous
communities, and the U.S. Insular Areas, but those solutions
are only coming from Committee Democrats.
Rather than opening public lands and waters to oil and gas
extraction or attacking science-based and community protections
like the Endangered Species Act (ESA) and the National
Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), Committee Democrats want to
focus on real issues that will benefit communities across the
country.
Committee Democrats want to build on the historic successes
of the past several years under the Biden administration. We
must ensure that the unprecedented investments in American
infrastructure and climate resilience achieved under IIJA and
IRA are benefitting the communities that need it most. We must
ensure the build-out of renewable energy generation,
incorporate Indigenous Traditional Ecological Knowledge into
federal planning and decision-making, and advance self-
determination and decolonization in the Insular areas.
To meet these priorities, I offered a comprehensive
amendment to the Republican majority's A&O Plan. This amendment
would not have reduced or altered any of the priorities
highlighted by Committee Republicans. It simply would have
added the following categories as Committee oversight
priorities:
Reducing Carbon Pollution
Helping Communities Impacted by Climate Change
Elevating Indigenous Traditional Ecological
Knowledge in Climate Solutions
Pursuing Ocean-Based and Other Nature-Based
Climate Solutions
Ensuring Use of the Best Available Climate
Science
Unfortunately, Committee Republicans clearly indicated that
they do not see these areas as priorities, given that they
uniformly voted against the amendment.
While Committee Republicans continue to offer policies that
would benefit the fossil fuel industry, Committee Democrats
will continue to uplift climate and communities and to champion
an agenda for the American people. Committee Democrats will
prioritize:
Putting people and communities first
Ensure communities on the frontline of
environmental harm have a seat at the table in federal
decision-making.
Support under-resourced communities in securing
their own livelihoods, health, and safety to combat the climate
crisis and other environmental harms.
Acknowledge and work to correct the historically
racist policies within our jurisdiction.
Protecting our planet and people
Prioritize policies that improve Americans'
quality of life and put the health and well-being of
communities above polluter profits.
Conserve our natural resources by promoting ocean
health, protecting wildlife, safeguarding irreplaceable
landscapes, preserving our public lands, and ensuring cleaner
water and air.
Reduce pollution, prevent catastrophic climate
impacts, and help communities and ecosystems adapt to climate
change.
Working with Indigenous Peoples
Respect tribal sovereignty by ensuring that
Indigenous voices are heard and incorporated into federal
decision-making.
Protect tribal land and water rights by supporting
tribal economic, infrastructure, and clean energy development.
Ensure Indigenous communities have access to the
federal resources to which they are legally entitled.
Promote tribal consultation with federal agencies
to ensure the incorporation of Indigenous points of view prior
to policy and regulation implementation.
Supporting Insular Areas
Foster political self-determination and economic
development of U.S. Territories.
Ensure residents of U.S. Territories have the
resources they need to recover from and prepare for natural
disasters.
Provide needed oversight of the Puerto Rico
Oversight, Management, and Economic Stability Act (PROMESA) and
the Financial Oversight and Management Board for Puerto Rico.
Continue efforts to advance the economic self-
sufficiency of the Freely Associated States.
Building an economy for the future that works for everyone
Support innovative, sustainable clean energy
sources that meet our country's needs and support our climate
goals.
Grow the outdoor recreation economy by protecting
and responsibly enhancing access to public lands.
Encourage responsible energy development that
safeguards our environment and community health.
Working with the Biden administration to hold the federal government to
the highest standard
Ensure timely and responsible implementation of
the historic investments in the IIJA and IRA for priorities
like forest management, drought resilience, environmental
permitting, and renewable deployment.
Hold polluting industries and federal officials
accountable to the public through transparency and oversight.
Restore scientific integrity in the executive
branch.
Identify and eliminate waste, fraud, and abuse at
the agencies under our jurisdiction.
Support leadership that promotes justice, equity,
diversity, and inclusion in the recruitment, promotion, and
retention of the federal workforce.
Our Committee is also charged with the solemn duty of
jurisdiction over the Insular Areas of the United States,
including Puerto Rico. To that end, Representative Nydia
Velazquez offered an amendment that would have added the
following to the A&O Plan in the paragraph regarding Puerto
Rico:
The Committee will continue to monitor the recovery
efforts on the island, including the reconstruction of
the electric grid. The Committee will also provide
oversight to ensure environmental and natural resources
are being protected under federal law.
As with the Grijalva and Ocasio-Cortez amendments, this
amendment would not have reduced or altered any of the
priorities highlighted by Committee Republicans. It simply
would have added vital priorities to the Committee's agenda.
It is disappointing and frankly baffling that Republicans
unanimously voted against including these priorities in the
Committee's agenda.
As this Congress gets underway, I hope the majority will
reconsider and join Democrats in pursuing oversight of recovery
efforts in Puerto Rico and in ensuring that the island's
environmental and natural resources are being protected under
federal law.
For the reasons discussed in these views, I oppose the
Committee's Authorization and Oversight Plan as approved by
Republicans.
Raul M. Grijalva,
Ranking Member, House Committee
on Natural Resources.
COMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND ACCOUNTABILITY
AUTHORIZATION AND OVERSIGHT PLAN
Committee on Oversight and Accountability
U.S. House of Representatives
118th Congress
Under clause 2(d) of House Rule X, the Chair of each
Committee is required to adopt and submit to the Committees on
Oversight and Accountability and House Administration an
authorization and oversight plan not later than March 1 of the
first session of Congress.
This following is the authorization and oversight plan of
the Committee on Oversight and Accountability. The Committee
will conduct oversight and investigations pursuant to its
legislative and oversight jurisdiction under Rule X.
The Committee's mission is to ensure the economy,
efficiency, effectiveness, and accountability of the federal
government and all its agencies. The following list is not
exhaustive. The Committee will retain the flexibility to
investigate instances of waste, fraud, abuse, and mismanagement
as they emerge, and to conduct oversight of other issues as
appropriate.
LAPSED AUTHORIZATIONS
The Committee will consider lapsed authorizations in its
jurisdiction in the 118th Congress, and work to enact necessary
authorizations and reforms. These include the Merit Systems
Protection Board; the National Archives Historical Publications
and Records Commission; the Office of Government Ethics; and
the DC Tuition Assistance Grant Program.
EXPIRING AUTHORIZATIONS THIS CONGRESS
The Committee will consider expiring authorizations in its
jurisdiction in the 118th Congress, and work to enact necessary
authorization and reforms. These include: the Scholarships for
Opportunity and Results (SOAR) Act--which provides scholarships
to students in Washington, DC--expires September 30, 2023; the
Office of National Drug Control Policy (ONDCP), whose
authorization expires September 30, 2023; and the Office of
Special Counsel (OSC), whose authorization expires September
30, 2023.
WASTE, FRAUD, ABUSE, AND MISMANAGEMENT
The Committee will continue to examine instances of waste,
fraud, abuse, and mismanagement of the activities of the
federal government, with an emphasis on spending. The
Committee's oversight will cover all federal government
departments, agencies, and programs with an eye toward
solutions for eliminating wasteful spending and abuse of
authority. Furthermore, the Committee will continue to examine
the scope of and reasons for unprecedented levels of fraud and
improper payments in COVID-relief programs. It will offer
targeted legislative proposals that proactively address
identified waste, fraud, abuse, and mismanagement.
THE FEDERAL WORKFORCE
As the authorizer of civil service rules under Title 5 of
the United States Code, the Committee will conduct oversight to
ensure the federal workforce is operating efficiently and
effectively and serves the needs of this nation. The Committee
will ensure expanded telework and remote work policies do not
adversely affect agency performance and achievement of mission.
The federal hiring process must be competitive, merit-based,
technology-based, and conducted in a cost-effective manner.
FEDERAL REGULATION AND THE REGULATORY PROCESS
While some federal regulations are necessary to effectively
implement the laws that Congress passes, federal regulations
can also impose significant burdens on industry, affecting the
Nation's economic growth. The Committee will place special
emphasis on oversight of the federal regulatory process to
ensure that federal regulators work to minimize unnecessary
burdens on small businesses, job creation, economic growth, and
competitiveness in the global marketplace while maintaining
protections for the American people.
THE GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY OFFICE
As the authorizer of the Government Accountability Office
(GAO), the Committee will continue to support its mission. In
addition, and as required by House rule X, clause 4(c)(1)(A),
the Committee will continue to receive and examine GAO reports
and submit to the House such recommendations as it considers
necessary or desirable in connection with the subject matter of
the reports.
In April 2023, the GAO will issue its biennial ``High Risk
List'' report, which identifies government programs that are
particularly vulnerable to waste, fraud, abuse, or
mismanagement, or are in need of transformation. The Committee
will provide ongoing oversight of agencies and programs
included on the High Risk List by holding hearings, meeting
with agency officials responsible for included programs, and
monitoring agencies' corrective plans and actions.
INSPECTORS GENERAL
The Committee will continue to work closely with the
inspectors general to ensure they have the tools needed to
effectively perform their important oversight and investigative
work. The Committee intends to help inspectors general ensure
accountability from their respective agencies. The Committee
will also consider the Pandemic Response Accountability
Committee (PRAC), which is set to terminate on September 30,
2025. The Committee will review the potential need to extend
the PRAC beyond that date, including the existing centralized
data analytics unit within the PRAC--the Pandemic Analytics
Center of Excellence--to ensure continued efforts to prevent,
identify, and combat fraud in federal programs.
GSA REAL PROPERTY DISPOSAL
The management of Federal real property has been on GAO's
High-Risk list since 2003 because it can take years to sell or
otherwise dispose of unneeded government properties, which can
require millions of dollars of taxpayer funds to maintain. The
Committee will examine the results to date of the pilot
programs authorized by the Federal Assets Sale and Transfer Act
of 2016, which was intended to achieve cost savings by
expediting property sales through new mechanisms, including a
temporary Public Buildings Reform Board. With the
Administration emphasizing permanent, expanded telework and
remote policies, the Committee will ensure the federal real
property footprint aligns with evolving workforce needs and
agency mission demands.
WHISTLEBLOWER PROTECTION
The Committee will maintain its efforts related to the
protection of whistleblowers in the federal government. The
Committee will continue to work directly with whistleblowers,
including those who make disclosures of waste, fraud, abuse,
and mismanagement to the Committee. The Committee will continue
to advance policies that protect federal employees' rights, and
those of federal contractors and other recipients of financial
assistance, to communicate directly with Congress and to ensure
such employees are aware of these rights, encouraging other
whistleblowers to come forward. The Committee will examine
directives restricting federal employees from communicating
freely with Congress, as well as allegations of retaliation or
reprisal for communicating with Congress.
FEDERAL FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
The Committee will examine federal financial management.
The Committee will focus on agency efforts to reduce improper
payments, ensure payment integrity and proper accounting
practices, and achieve an unqualified audit opinion for the
federal government. The CFO Act as amended requires federal
agencies to prepare agency-wide financial statements that
undergo outside audit. To date, GAO has been unable to issue an
audit opinion on the consolidated, government-wide financial
statements, in part due to serious financial management
problems at the Department of Defense. In particular, the
Committee will focus on overseeing the Department of Defense's
financial management processes and its progress towards
becoming auditable.
The Committee will also continue to investigate improper
payments distributed by federal agencies. Under the 2002
Improper Payments Information Act (IPIA), federal agencies are
required to annually review all programs and activities to
identify those entities susceptible to significant improper
payments.
GOVERNMENT CONTRACTING
Controlling federal government contract spending is
critically important. The federal government buys a wide
variety of goods