Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 7023]
The Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure, to whom
was referred the bill (H.R. 7023) to amend section 404 of the
Federal Water Pollution Control Act to codify certain
regulatory provisions relating to nationwide permits for
dredged or fill material, and for other purposes, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon with amendments
and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose of Legislation........................................... 5
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 5
Hearings......................................................... 12
Legislative History and Consideration............................ 14
Committee Votes.................................................. 18
Committee Oversight Findings and Recommendations................. 21
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures........................ 21
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate........................ 22
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 22
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 22
Congressional Earmarks, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff
Benefits....................................................... 22
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 22
Preemption Clarification......................................... 22
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 23
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 23
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 23
Section 1. Short Title....................................... 23
Section 2. Water Quality Criteria Development and
Transparency............................................... 23
Section 3. Federal General Permits........................... 23
Section 4. Confidence in Clean Water Permits................. 23
Section 5. Reducing Permitting Uncertainty................... 24
Section 6. Nationwide Permitting Improvement................. 24
Section 7. Judicial Review Timeline Clarity.................. 24
Section 8. Implementation Guidance........................... 24
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 25
Minority Views................................................... 57
The amendments are as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Creating Confidence in Clean Water
Permitting Act''.
SEC. 2. WATER QUALITY CRITERIA DEVELOPMENT AND TRANSPARENCY.
(a) Information and Guidelines.--Section 304(a) of the Federal Water
Pollution Control Act (33 U.S.C. 1314(a)) is amended by adding at the
end the following:
``(10) Administrative procedure.--After the date of enactment
of this paragraph, the Administrator shall issue any new or
revised water quality criteria under paragraph (1) or (9) by
rule.''.
(b) Administrative Procedure and Judicial Review.--Section 509(b)(1)
of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (33 U.S.C. 1369(b)(1)) is
amended--
(1) by striking ``section 402, and'' and inserting ``section
402,''; and
(2) by inserting ``and (H) in issuing any criteria for water
quality pursuant to section 304(a)(10),'' after ``strategy
under section 304(l),''.
SEC. 3. FEDERAL GENERAL PERMITS.
Section 402(a) of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (33 U.S.C.
1342(a)) is amended by adding at the end the following:
``(6)(A) The Administrator is authorized to issue general permits
under this section for discharges of similar types from similar
sources.
``(B) The Administrator may require submission of a notice of intent
to be covered under a general permit issued under this section,
including additional information that the Administrator determines
necessary.
``(C) If a general permit issued under this section will expire and
the Administrator decides not to issue a new general permit for
discharges similar to those covered by the expiring general permit, the
Administrator shall publish in the Federal Register a notice of such
decision at least two years prior to the expiration of the general
permit.
``(D) If a general permit issued under this section expires and the
Administrator has not published a notice in accordance with
subparagraph (C), until such time as the Administrator issues a new
general permit for discharges similar to those covered by the expired
general permit, the Administrator shall--
``(i) continue to apply the terms, conditions, and
requirements of the expired general permit to any discharge
that was covered by the expired general permit; and
``(ii) apply such terms, conditions, and requirements to any
discharge that would have been covered by the expired general
permit (in accordance with any relevant requirements for such
coverage) if the discharge had occurred before such
expiration.''.
SEC. 4. CONFIDENCE IN CLEAN WATER PERMITS.
(a) Compliance With Permits.--Section 402(k) of the Federal Water
Pollution Control Act (33 U.S.C. 1342(k)) is amended--
(1) by striking ``(k) Compliance with'' and inserting the
following:
``(k) Compliance With Permits.--
``(1) In general.--Subject to paragraph (2), compliance
with''; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
``(2) Scope.--For purposes of paragraph (1), compliance with
the conditions of a permit issued under this section shall be
considered compliance with respect to a discharge of--
``(A) any pollutant for which an effluent limitation
is included in the permit; and
``(B) any pollutant for which an effluent limitation
is not included in the permit that is--
``(i) specifically identified as controlled
or monitored through indicator parameters in
the permit, the fact sheet for the permit, or
the administrative record relating to the
permit;
``(ii) specifically identified during the
permit application process as present in
discharges to which the permit will apply; or
``(iii) whether or not specifically
identified in the permit or during the permit
application process--
``(I) present in any waste streams or
processes of the point source to which
the permit applies, which waste streams
or processes are specifically
identified during the permit
application process; or
``(II) otherwise within the scope of
any operations of the point source to
which the permit applies, which scope
of operations is specifically
identified during the permit
application process.''.
(b) Expression of Water Quality-based Effluent Limitations.--Section
402 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (33 U.S.C. 1342) is
amended by adding at the end the following:
``(t) Expression of Water Quality-based Effluent Limitations.--If the
Administrator (or a State, in the case of a permit program approved by
the Administrator) determines that a water quality-based limitation on
a discharge of a pollutant is necessary to include in a permit under
this section in addition to any appropriate technology-based effluent
limitations included in such permit, the Administrator (or the State)
may include such water quality-based limitation in such permit only in
the form of an effluent limitation that specifies--
``(1) the pollutant to which it applies; and
``(2) the numerical limit on the discharge of such pollutant,
or the precise waterbody conditions to be attained with respect
to such pollutant, required to comply with the permit.''.
SEC. 5. REDUCING PERMITTING UNCERTAINTY.
(a) In General.--Section 404(c) of the Federal Water Pollution
Control Act (33 U.S.C. 1344(c)) is amended--
(1) by striking ``(c) The Administrator'' and inserting the
following:
``(c) Specification or Use of Defined Area.--
``(1) In general.--The Administrator'';
(2) in paragraph (1), as so designated, by inserting ``during
the period described in paragraph (2) and'' before ``after
notice and opportunity for public hearings''; and
(3) by adding at the end the following:
``(2) Period of prohibition.--The period during which the
Administrator may prohibit the specification (including the
withdrawal of specification) of any defined area as a disposal
site, or deny or restrict the use of any defined area for
specification (including the withdrawal of specification) as a
disposal site, under paragraph (1) shall--
``(A) begin on the date on which an applicant submits
all the information required to complete an application
for a permit under this section; and
``(B) end on the date on which the Secretary issues
the permit.''.
(b) Applicability.--The amendments made by subsection (a) shall apply
to a permit application submitted under section 404 of the Federal
Water Pollution Control Act (33 U.S.C. 1344) after the date of
enactment of this Act.
SEC. 6. NATIONWIDE PERMITTING IMPROVEMENT.
(a) In General.--Section 404(e) of the Federal Water Pollution
Control Act (33 U.S.C. 1344) is amended--
(1) by striking ``(e)(1) In carrying'' and inserting the
following:
``(e) General Permits on State, Regional, or Nationwide Basis.--
``(1) Permits authorized.--In carrying'';
(2) in paragraph (2)--
(A) by striking ``(2) No general'' and inserting the
following:
``(2) Term.--No general''; and
(B) by striking ``five years'' and inserting ``ten
years''; and
(3) by adding at the end the following:
``(3) Considerations.--In determining the environmental
effects of an activity under paragraph (1) or (2), the
Secretary shall consider only the effects of any discharge of
dredged or fill material resulting from such activity.
``(4) Nationwide permits for linear infrastructure
projects.--
``(A) In general.--Notwithstanding any other
provision of this section, the Secretary shall maintain
general permits on a nationwide basis for linear
infrastructure projects that do not result in the loss
of greater than 1/2-acre of waters of the United States
for each single and complete project (as defined in
section 330.2 of title 33, Code of Federal Regulations
(as in effect on the date of enactment of this
paragraph)).
``(B) Definition of linear infrastructure project.--
In this paragraph, the term `linear infrastructure
project' means a project to carry out any activity
required for the construction, expansion, maintenance,
modification, or removal of infrastructure and
associated facility for the transmission from a point
of origin to a terminal point of communications or
electricity or the transportation from a point of
origin to a terminal point of people, water,
wastewater, carbon dioxide, or fuel or hydrocarbons (in
the form of a liquid, liquescent, gaseous, or slurry
substance or supercritical fluid), including oil and
gas pipeline facilities.
``(5) Reissuance of nationwide permits.--In determining
whether to reissue a general permit issued under this
subsection on a nationwide basis--
``(A) no consultation with an applicable State
pursuant to section 6(a) of the Endangered Species Act
of 1973 (16 U.S.C. 1535(a)) is required;
``(B) no consultation with a Federal agency pursuant
to section 7(a)(2) of such Act (16 U.S.C. 1536(a)(2))
is required; and
``(C) the requirements of section 102(2)(C) of the
National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C.
4332(2)(C)) shall be satisfied by preparing an
environmental assessment with respect to such general
permit.''.
(b) Administration of Nationwide Permit Program.--In carrying out
section 404(e) of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (33 U.S.C.
1344), the Secretary of the Army, acting through the Chief of
Engineers, may not finalize or implement any modification to--
(1) general condition 15 (relating to single and complete
projects), as included in the final rule titled ``Reissuance
and Modification of Nationwide Permits'' and published on
January 13, 2021, by the Department of the Army, Corps of
Engineers (86 Fed. Reg. 2868);
(2) the definition of single and complete linear project, as
included in such final rule (86 Fed. Reg. 2877); or
(3) the definition of single and complete project, as
included in section 330.2 of title 33, Code of Federal
Regulations (as in effect on the date of enactment of this
Act).
SEC. 7. JUDICIAL REVIEW TIMELINE CLARITY.
Section 404 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (33 U.S.C.
1344) is amended--
(1) by redesignating subsection (t) as subsection (u);
(2) in subsection (u), as so redesignated, by striking
``Nothing in the section'' and inserting ``Savings Provision.--
Nothing in this section''; and
(3) by inserting after subsection (s) the following:
``(t) Judicial Review.--
``(1) Statute of limitations.--
``(A) In general.--Notwithstanding any applicable
provision of law relating to statutes of limitations,
an action seeking judicial review of--
``(i) an individual or general permit issued
under this section shall be filed not later
than the date that is 60 days after the date on
which the permit was issued; and
``(ii) verification that an activity is
authorized by a general permit issued under
this section shall be filed not later than the
date that is 60 days after the date on which
such verification was issued.
``(B) Savings provision.--Nothing in subparagraph (A)
may be construed to authorize an action seeking
judicial review of the structure of, or authorization
for, a State permit program approved pursuant to this
section.
``(2) Limitation on commencement of certain actions.--
Notwithstanding any other provision of law, no action described
in paragraph (1)(A) may be commenced unless the action--
``(A) is filed by a party that submitted a comment,
during the public comment period for the administrative
proceedings related to the applicable action described
in such paragraph, which comment was sufficiently
detailed to put the Secretary or the State, as
applicable, on notice of the issue upon which the party
seeks judicial review; and
``(B) is related to such comment.
``(3) Remedy.--If a court determines that the Secretary or
the State, as applicable, did not comply with the requirements
of this section in issuing an individual or general permit
under this section, or in verifying that an activity is
authorized by a general permit issued under this section, as
applicable--
``(A) the court shall remand the matter to the
Secretary or the State, as applicable, for further
proceedings consistent with the court's determination;
``(B) with respect to a determination regarding the
issuance of an individual or general permit under this
section, the court may not vacate, revoke, enjoin, or
otherwise limit the permit, unless the court finds that
activities authorized under the permit would present an
imminent and substantial danger to human health or the
environment for which there is no other equitable
remedy available under the law; and
``(C) with respect to a determination regarding a
verification that an activity is authorized by a
general permit issued under this section, the court may
not enjoin the activity, unless the court finds that
the activity would present an imminent and substantial
danger to human health or the environment for which
there is no other equitable remedy available under the
law.
``(4) Timeline to act on court order.--If a court remands a
matter under paragraph (2), the court shall set and enforce a
reasonable schedule and deadline, which may not exceed 180 days
from the date on which the court remands such matter, except as
otherwise required by law, for the Secretary or the State, as
applicable, to take such actions as the court may order.''.
SEC. 8. IMPLEMENTATION GUIDANCE.
(a) In General.--Not later than 30 days after the date of enactment
of this Act, the Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency
and the Secretary of the Army, acting through the Chief of Engineers,
shall begin a process to issue guidance on the implementation of the
final rule published on September 8, 2023, by the Department of the
Army, Corps of Engineers, Department of Defense and the Environmental
Protection Agency and titled ``Revised Definition of `Waters of the
United States'; Conforming'' (88 Fed. Reg. 61964).
(b) Public Comment.--In issuing the guidance required under
subsection (a), the Administrator and the Secretary shall--
(1) prior to such issuance, solicit comments from the public
on such guidance; and
(2) ensure that such comments and any responses to such
Background and Need for Legislation
The Clean Water Act (CWA) is the primary law governing
water quality of the Nation's surface waters.\1\ Congress
enacted the 1972 amendments to the Federal Water Pollution
Control Act, which is commonly referred to as the CWA, with the
objective to ``restore and maintain the chemical, physical, and
biological integrity of the Nation's waters.''\2\ To achieve
this objective, two goals were established: (1) to eliminate
pollutant discharge into navigable waters by 1985, and (2)
where possible, to ensure water quality that is ``fishable''
and ``swimmable'' by 1983.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\H. Comm. on Transp. & Infrastructure, Jurisdiction and
Activities of the Subcomm. on Water Resources and Environment, 118th
Cong., (2023) (on file with Comm.) [hereinafter Jurisdiction and
Activities Report].
\2\CWA, Pub. L. 92-500, 86 Stat. 816 [hereinafter CWA].
\3\Laura Gatz, Cong. Rsch. Serv. (RL30030), Clean Water Act: A
Summary of the Law, (Updated Oct. 18, 2016), available at https://
www.crs.gov/Reports/RL30030 [hereinafter CRS Report RL30030].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The CWA consists of two major parts: (1) the authorization
of financial assistance for construction of municipal
wastewater treatment plants, and (2) the regulatory
requirements that apply to those who discharge into navigable
waters, including industrial and municipal actors.\4\ Planning,
financial, and technical assistance for various regions and
issues are also addressed.\5\ Title III of the CWA establishes
the authority for the technological and water quality-based
effluent limitation guidelines that must be abided by point
source dischargers.\6\ Whereas Title III of the CWA largely
focuses on the creation of water quality guidelines and
limitations, Title IV primarily deals with application of the
regulatory program, informed by the guidelines created pursuant
to Title III, through which dischargers must receive permits or
certifications.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\Id.
\5\Id.
\6\See CRS Report RL30030, supra note 3; see also CWA, supra note
2, Sec. Sec. 301-320.
\7\See CRS Report RL30030, supra note 3; see also CWA, supra note
2, Sec. Sec. 301, 402, 404.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In order to achieve its objectives, the CWA is predicated
on the principle that discharges into waters of the United
States are only lawful if authorized by a permit.\8\ Therefore,
the application of various CWA components require a regulatory
program. While certain regulatory programs under the law may
only be carried out by the Federal Government, through either
the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) or the United States
Army Corps of Engineers (Corps), certain responsibilities can
be assumed by states approved by the EPA.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\See CRS Report RL30030, supra note 3.
\9\See e.g. CWA, supra note 2, Sec. Sec. 401, 402, 404.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Broadly, H.R. 7023, as amended, strives to once again find
balance within the regulatory and permitting process originally
envisioned by the CWA by providing a comprehensive package of
commonsense reforms to permitting processes for energy
producers, agriculture sector, builders, and water utilities.
The bill includes necessary reforms to promote regulatory
efficiency while increasing transparency and continuing to
protect and promote clean water.
One need for Congressional action relates to the term
``waters of the United States'' (WOTUS). Notably, while the CWA
protects ``navigable waters,'' which are broadly defined in the
CWA as the ``waters of the United States, including the
territorial seas.''\10\ The CWA does not further define the
term WOTUS. Ultimately, the CWA grants authority to the EPA and
the Corps to implement the CWA, and EPA and the Corps have
promulgated several sets of rules defining a WOTUS to define
the scope of CWA authority. There has been a substantial amount
of litigation in the Federal Courts on the scope of CWA
jurisdiction over the years, including multiple United States
Supreme Court cases. Most recently, the EPA and the Corps
published a final rule issuing a new WOTUS definition in
response to the Supreme Court's ruling in Sackett v. EPA
(Sackett).\11\ The Supreme Court concluded in Sackett that the
CWA's jurisdiction encompasses waters that are ``relatively
permanent, standing or continuously flowing bodies of water
`forming geographical features' that are described in ordinary
parlance as `streams, oceans, rivers, and lakes.'''\12\ The
Supreme Court also held that jurisdictional wetlands ``must be
indistinguishably part of a body of water that itself
constitutes `waters' under the CWA.''\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Id.
\11\Revised Definition of ``Waters of the United States'';
Conforming, 88 Fed. Reg. 61964 (Sept. 8, 2023).
\12\Sackett v. Environmental Protection Agency, 598 U.S. 651
(2023).
\13\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The recent Sackett decision provided additional direction
on the WOTUS definition, and therefore, the jurisdiction of the
CWA. However, the conforming rule issued by the EPA and the
Corps does not include or clarify certain phrases and terms
applied in Sackett. For example, in a hearing before the
Subcommittee on Water Resources and Environment of the
Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure (Subcommittee),
on December 5, 2023, Assistant Secretary for the Army (Civil
Works) Michael Connor testified that the agencies will develop
additional guidance to implement the ``continuous surface
connection'' test outlined by Sackett, while simultaneously
working through individual requests for Clean Water Act
jurisdictional determinations in light of the Sackett
decision.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Water Resources Development Acts: Status of Past Provisions and
Future Needs Before the Subcomm. on Water Resources and Environment of
the H. Comm. on Transp. And Infrastructure, 118th Cong. (Dec. 5, 2023)
(statement of The Honorable Michael L. Connor, Assistant Secretary of
the Army for Civil Works, United States Department of the Army)
[hereinafter Status of Past Provisions].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
These ambiguities have caused confusion in applying the
rule, especially for Corps districts who are tasked with
issuing jurisdictional determinations (JDs).\15\ Assistant
Secretary Connor also stated during the December 5, 2023,
hearing that there was a backlog of more than 4,000 JDs in
Corps districts across the country.\16\ However, neither the
EPA nor the Corps has, to date, publicly issued additional
implementation guidance for JDs or initiated a process to do
so. The Corps and EPA are providing public information on
recent JDs under the CWA post Sackett and posting these JDs on
the Corps and EPA's websites.\17\ Given this, to help provide
additional clarity, Section Eight of H.R. 7023, as amended,
would require the EPA and the Corps to initiate a process to
receive public comment and issue implementation guidance that
is consistent with recent Sackett decision.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Jurisdictional determinations are performed on a property in
order to delineate which waters are Waters of the U.S. and are
therefore subject to CWA Sec. 404.
\16\Status of Past Provisions, supra note 14.
\17\See Corps, USACE Jurisdictional Determinations and Permit
Decisions, available at https://permits.ops.usace.army.mil/orm-public
EPA, Clean Water Act Approved Jurisdictional Determinations, available
at https://watersgeo.epa.gov/cwa/CWA-JDs/?pageNum=2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Additionally, Section 402 of the CWA authorizes the
National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) program
to regulate discharges of pollutants from point sources into
navigable waters.\18\ Point sources are defined as ``any
discernible, confined and discrete conveyance, such as a pipe,
ditch, channel, conduit, discrete fissure, or container,''\19\
and also include ``vessels or other floating craft'' from which
pollutants may be discharged.\20\ Section 402 excludes certain
agriculture and stormwater runoff from requiring a NPDES
permit.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\CWA, supra note 2, Sec. 402.
\19\Id.
\20\Id.; see generally also EPA, NPDES Permit Basics, available at
https://www.epa.gov/npdes/npdes-permit-basics [hereinafter NPDES Permit
Basics].
\21\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Since all point source dischargers are subject to the NPDES
program, a total of more than 65,000 industrial and municipal
conventional dischargers are required to obtain permits
pursuant to Section 402.\22\ In addition, NPDES permits are
required for stormwater discharges from industrial and
municipal sources, including over 150,000 individual
sources.\23\ NPDES permits require the point source to attain
technology-based effluent limits, while specifying the
numerical effluent limitations that sources must meet in order
to guarantee water quality where possible, and a deadline for
compliance.\24\ Point sources may, in some instances, apply for
a NPDES general permit as opposed to a NPDES individual permit.
A NPDES individual permit is written for site-specific
discharges that are unique to a specific location or
discharge.\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\CRS Report RL30030, supra note 3.
\23\Id.
\24\Id.
\25\See NPDES Permit Basics, supra note 20.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The CWA authorizes the EPA to approve individual states and
tribes to manage their own NPDES permitting programs.\26\
Nearly all states have assumed administration of their own
NPDES permitting programs, with only three exceptions:
Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and New Mexico.\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\CRS Report RL30030, supra note 3.
\27\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under Section 304(a) of the CWA, the EPA is required to
develop, publish, and, from time to time, revise criteria for
water quality. These criteria serve as recommendations to
states for defining ambient surface water conditions of a water
body to protect against adverse effects to aquatic life and
human health.\28\ These criteria are often adopted by states
and help inform the development of water quality-based effluent
limits included in NPDES permits.\29\ Currently, the EPA
voluntarily accepts comments on proposed criteria under 304(a)
and subjects them to review from its own Science Advisory
Board. In a hearing before the Subcommittee on May 16, 2023, a
witness representing the National Association of Clean Water
Agencies, Mickey Conway, Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of Metro
Water Recovery in Denver, CO, testified, ``[a]s utilities face
complex and costly infrastructure challenges over the next
fifty years, it is critical that the limits imposed in NPDES
permits be based on the best available science and a complete
record, not political whim or expedience.''\30\ Section Two of
H.R. 7023, as amended, increases the transparency of the
process of creating limits for NPDES permits by requiring that
water quality criteria are developed through an official
rulemaking, which allows outside comments made by stakeholders,
experts, and others, to be considered. It also ensures that the
rulemaking is subject to limited judicial review.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\EPA, NPDES Permit Writers' Manual, available at https://
www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2015-09/documents/pwm_2010.pdf.
\29\Id.
\30\The Next Fifty Years of the Clean Water Act: Examining the Law
and Infrastructure Project Completion, Before the Subcomm. on Water
Resources and Environment of the H. Comm. on Transp. And
Infrastructure, 118th Cong., (May 16, 2023) (written testimony of Mr.
Mickey Conway, CEO, Metro Water Recovery, Denver Colorado, on behalf of
National Association of Clean Water Agencies) [hereinafter Conway
Testimony].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 402(k) of the CWA provides a ``permit shield'' for
permit holders. Under this provision, if a permittee is in
compliance with its NPDES permit terms, they are shielded from
enforcement action from agencies and third parties. The United
States Supreme Court has held that this permit shield serves to
``insulate permit holders from changes in various regulations
during the period of a permit and to relieve permit holders of
having to litigate the question of whether their permits are
sufficiently strict. In short, Section 402(k) serves the
purpose of giving permits finality.''\31\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\31\E. I. du Pont de Nemours & and Co. v. Train, 430 U.S. 112
(1977).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The CWA provides for two types of general limits on
pollution discharges--a technology-based limit (TBEL) and a
more-stringent water quality-based limit (WQBEL) when
technology-based limits alone, are insufficient to address
local water quality concerns. Permit writers must consider the
potential impact of every proposed surface water discharge on
the quality of the receiving water. If TBELs are not sufficient
to meet the water quality standards in the receiving water, the
CWA (section 303(b)(1)(B)) and NPDES regulations (40 C.F.R.
122.44(d)) require that the permit writer develop more
stringent, water quality-based effluent limits (WQBELs).\32\
Some permit holders contend that permit writers are
inappropriately incorporating generic requirements within NPDES
permits as enforceable effluent limitations, which have
attracted legal challenges. For example, the San Francisco
Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) is currently appealing a
case before the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Circuit in which the court required its NPDES permit to
maintain broad language outside of clear effluent limitations
mandating it not ``cause or contribute to the violation of
water quality standards.''\33\ Testimony to the Subcommittee
from Mickey Conway, from the National Association of Clean
Water Agencies, suggests that this language is not unique to
the SFPUC permit, and is frequently included in NPDES permits
throughout the country.\34\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\32\EPA, Permit Limits--TBELs and WQBELs, available at https://
www.epa.gov/npdes/permit-limits-tbels-and-wqbels.
\33\City and County of San Francisco v. U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency (2023).
\34\Conway Testimony, supra note 30.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Due to this, Section Four of H.R. 7023, as amended, would
clarify the scope of the permit shield a 1994 EPA policy
guidance document, which specified that permittees are shielded
from liability under lawful NPDES permits for (1) pollutants
specifically limited in a permit; (2) pollutants specifically
identified as present in a permit; or (3) pollutants not
specifically identified as present, but which are constituents
of operations or processes that are specifically identified in
a permit.\35\ It would also require permit writers to include a
``numerical limit'' on specified pollutants covered by the
permit, or ``the precise waterbody conditions to be attained
with respect to such pollutant[s],'' which will help limit
ambiguity and ensure that any discharges authorized by the
permit do not violate water quality standards.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\35\EPA, Policy Statement on Scope of Discharge Authorization and
Shield Associated with NPDES Permits, available at https://
www3.epa.gov/npdes/pubs/owm615.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Both general and individual NPDES permits are issued for up
to five years and must be renewed thereafter if discharge is to
continue.\36\ However, if the permittee provides a complete
application, but is not reissued a permit prior the date of
expiration, the permit may be ``administratively
continued.''\37\ Permit applications are considered backlogged
for new applications if they are not issued or denied within
365 days of receipt, and for extensions if they are
administratively continued for 180 days or more.\38\ Section
Three of H.R. 7023, as amended, seeks to provide more certainty
for general permit holders by clarifying that if the EPA does
not provide at least two years notice to general permit holders
that the general permit will not be reissued, existing permit
holders are provided continued coverage until a new permit is
issued.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\36\See NPDES Permit Basics, supra note 20 (stating applicants for
NPDES permit renewals must complete an application for renewal at least
180 days prior to original expiration).
\37\Id.
\38\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 404 of the CWA authorizes a separate type of permit
required to discharge dredged or fill materials into navigable
waters. Activities covered under the Section 404 program
include those associated with pipeline projects; water
resources projects such as levees and dams; mining projects
such as those for critical minerals; infrastructure development
such as highways and airports; and other development.\39\ Some
activities are exempt from Section 404 permitting requirements,
such as certain farming and forestry activities.\40\ Section
404 permits are typically issued for a term of five years.\41\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\39\EPA, Permit Program under CWA Section 404, available at https:/
/www.epa.gov/cwa-404/permit-program-under-cwa-section-404 [hereinafter
Permit Program under CWA Section 404].
\40\Id.
\41\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The EPA and the Corps play complementary roles in
implementing the Section 404 program, with the Corps in charge
of issuing permits for discharge of dredged or fill material,
using a set of environmental guidelines promulgated by the EPA
in conjunction with the Corps to evaluate permit
applications.\42\ Similar to the NPDES permitting process, the
EPA can approve states and tribes to assume authority to grant
or deny dredge and fill permits under Section 404, under the
condition that states or tribes develop a wetlands permit
program consistent with the CWA.\43\ Currently three states
have assumed authorit
Hearings
For the purposes of rule XIII, clause 3(c)(6)(A) of the
118th Congress, the following related hearings were held to
develop or consider H.R. 7023, as amended:
On February 8, 2023, the Subcommittee on Water Resources
and Environment of the Committee on Transportation and
Infrastructure held a hearing entitled, ``Stakeholder
Perspectives on the Impacts of the Biden Administration's
Waters of the United States (WOTUS) Rule.'' At the hearing
Members received testimony from Mr. Garrett Hawkins, President,
Missouri Farm Bureau; Ms. Alicia Huey, Chairman, National
Association of Home Builders; Mr. Mark Williams, Environmental
Manager, Luck Companies, on behalf of National Stone, Sand &
Gravel Association; Ms. Susan Parker Bodine, Partner, Earth &
Water Law LLC; and Mr. Dave Owen, Professor of Law and Faculty
Director of Scholarly Publications, UC College of the Law, San
Francisco. This hearing examined the EPA and the Corps defining
``waters of the United States'' under the CWA, and its
regulatory impact on stakeholders. During the hearing,
witnesses also broadly discussed the need for permitting and
regulatory reform under the CWA.
On Tuesday, May 16, 2023, the Subcommittee on Water
Resources and Environment of the Committee on Transportation
and Infrastructure held a hearing entitled, ``The Next Fifty
Years of the Clean Water Act: Examining the Law and
Infrastructure Project Completion.'' The Subcommittee received
testimony from Dr. Andrea Travnicek, Director, Department of
Resources, State of North Dakota; Hon. Serena Coleman McIlwain,
Secretary of the Environment, State of Maryland; Mr. Mickey
Conway, CEO, Metro Water Recovery, Denver, Colorado on behalf
of the National Association of Clean Water Agencies; and Mr.
Brandon Farris, Vice President, Energy and Resources Policy,
National Association of Manufacturers. This hearing examined
proposals on how to modernize the CWA to ensure the completion
of infrastructure and energy projects, reduce supply chain
challenges, and promote commerce, while protecting water
quality.
On Thursday, June 22, 2023, the Subcommittee on Water
Resources and Environment of the Committee on Transportation
and Infrastructure held a hearing entitled, ``Review of Fiscal
Year 2024 Budget Request: Agency Perspectives (Part I). The
Subcommittee received testimony from The Honorable Michael L.
Connor, Assistant Secretary of the Army for Civil Works,
Department of the Army; Major General William ``Butch'' H.
Graham, Deputy Chief of Engineers and Deputy Commanding
General, United States Army Corps of Engineers; Mr. Jeff Lyash,
President and CEO, Tennessee Valley Authority; and Mr. Adam
Tindall-Schlicht, Administrator, Great Lakes St. Lawrence
Seaway Development Corporation. This hearing provided Members
with an opportunity to review the President's Fiscal Year 2024
Budget Request, as well as the Administration's program
priorities within the jurisdiction of the Subcommittee,
including permitting issues pursuant to the CWA.
On July 13, 2023, the Subcommittee on Water Resources and
Environment of the Committee on Transportation and
Infrastructure held a hearing entitled, ``Review of Fiscal Year
2024 Budget Request: Agency Perspectives (Part II).'' The
hearing gave Members the opportunity to review the Fiscal Year
2024 budget request, as well as the Administration's program
priorities within the jurisdiction of the Subcommittee,
including permitting issues pursuant to the CWA. The
Subcommittee received testimony from the Honorable Radhika Fox,
Assistant Administrator, Office of Water, EPA; Dr. Maria-Elena
Giner, Commissioner, IWBC, United States Section; Mr. Louis
Aspey Associate Chief, Natural Resources Conservation Service,
United States Department of Agriculture; Dr. Aaron Bernstein,
Director, Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry; and
Ms. Nicole R. LeBoeuf, Assistant Administrator, National Ocean
Service, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.
On December 5, 2023, the Subcommittee on Water Resources
and Environment of the Committee on Transportation and
Infrastructure held a hearing entitled, ``Water Resources
Development Acts: Status of Past Provisions and Future Needs.''
At the hearing Members received testimony from The Honorable
Michael L. Connor, Assistant Secretary of the Army for Civil
Works, Department of the Army and Lieutenant General Scott A.
Spellmon, Commanding General and Chief of Engineers, United
States Army Corps of Engineers. The hearing gave Members the
opportunity to review past provisions in Water Resources
Development Acts (WRDAs) and discuss needs for future WRDAs.
Also at the hearing, Members discussed various CWA permitting
processes, including implementation of the post-Sackett WOTUS
rule.
On Wednesday, January 17, 2024, the Full Committee on
Transportation and Infrastructure held a hearing entitled,
``The State of Transportation.'' At the hearing, Members
received testimony from Mr. Stephen A. Edwards, CEO and
Executive Director, Virginia Port Authority; Mr. Roger Millar,
Secretary of Transportation, Washington State Department of
Transportation; Mr. Jeffrey G. Tucker, CEO, Tucker Company
Worldwide, on behalf of Transportation Intermediaries
Association (TIA); and Ms. Lauren Benford, Controller, Reiman
Corporation, on behalf of Associated General Contractors of
America (AGC). The hearing provided a forum for Members to
discuss the current state of transportation infrastructure and
supply chain challenges, along with potential improvements that
could be made, including streamlining permitting process to
provide certainty and efficiency.
Legislative History and Consideration
H.R. 7023, the ``Creating Confidence in Clean Water
Permitting Act,'' was introduced in the United States House of
Representatives on January 17, 2024, by Mr. Rouzer of North
Carolina, and referred to the Committee on Transportation and
Infrastructure. Within the Committee on Transportation and
Infrastructure, H.R. 7023 was referred to the Subcommittee on
Water Resources and Environment. The Subcommittee on Water
Resources on Environment was discharged from further
consideration of H.R. 7023 on January 31, 2024.
The Committee considered H.R. 7023 on January 31, 2024, and
ordered the measure to be reported to the House with a
favorable recommendation, as amended, by a recorded vote of 32
ayes to 30 nays.
The following amendments were offered:
An Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 7023, as
amended, offered by Mr. Rouzer of North Carolina was AGREED TO
by voice vote.
An Amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute
to H.R. 7023, offered by Mr. Graves of Louisiana (Garret Graves
089); Page 11, after line 21, insert the following: SEC. 7.
FEDERAL GENERAL PERMITS. Section 402(a) of the Federal Water
Pollution Control Act (33 U.S.C. 1342(a)) is amended by adding
at the end the following: ``(6)(A) The Administrator is
authorized to issue general permits under this section for
discharges of similar types from similar sources. ``(B) The
Administrator may require submission of a notice of intent to
be covered under a general permit issued under this section,
including additional information that the Administrator
determines necessary. ``(C) If a general permit issued under
this section will expire and the Administrator decides not to
issue a new general permit for discharges similar to those
covered by the expiring general permit, the Administrator shall
publish in the Federal Register a notice of such decision at
least two years prior to the expiration of the general permit.
``(D) If a general permit issued under this section expires and
the Administrator has not published a notice in accordance with
subparagraph (C), until such time as the Administrator issues a
new general permit for discharges similar to those covered by
the expired general permit, the Administrator shall--``(i)
continue to apply the terms, conditions, and requirements of
the expired general permit to any discharge that was covered by
the expired general permit; and ``(ii) apply such terms,
conditions, and requirements to any discharge that would have
been covered by the expired general permit (in accordance with
any relevant requirements for such coverage) if the discharge
had occurred before such expiration.''.; was AGREED TO by a
recorded vote of 34 yeas and 27 nays (Roll Call No. 37).
An Amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute
to H.R. 7023, offered by Mr. Garamendi of California (Garamendi
164 Revision 2); Page 11, after line 21, insert the following:
SEC. 7. PROJECTS AND ACTIVITIES ELIGIBLE FOR ASSISTANCE.
Section 603 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (33
U.S.C. 1383) is amended--(1) in subsection (c)--(A) in
paragraph (11)(B) by striking ``and'' at the end; (B) in
paragraph (12)(B) by striking the period at the end and
inserting ``; and''; and (C) by adding at the end the
following: ``(13) to any qualified nonprofit entity, as
determined by the Administrator, to provide assistance for the
construction or acquisition of, or improvements to, a treatment
works, or for any other activity described in paragraphs (1)
through (10).''; (2) in subsection (i)(3), by adding at the end
the following: ``(E) CERTAIN ACTIVITIES INELIGIBLE.--A State
may not provide additional subsidization under this subsection
to a qualified nonprofit entity for assistance described in
subsection (c)(13) or to the owner or operator of a privately
owned treatment works for assistance described in subsection
(k).''; and (3) by adding at the end the following: ``(l)
SPECIAL RULE FOR PRIVATELY OWNED TREATMENT WORKS.--``(1) IN
GENERAL.--In any fiscal year for which the total amount
appropriated to carry out this title exceeds $1,638,861,000,
any such amounts appropriated in excess of $1,638,861,000 for
such fiscal year may be used to provide financial assistance
under this section to the owner or operator of a privately
owned treatment works for--``(A) improvements to such privately
owned treatment works; ``(B) the construction of, or
improvements to, another privately owned treatment works; ``(C)
measures to reduce the demand for privately owned treatment
works capacity through water conservation, efficiency, or
reuse; ``(D) measures to reduce the energy consumption needs
for privately owned treatment works; ``(E) measures to increase
the security of privately owned treatment works; and ``(F) any
other activity described in paragraphs (1) through (10) of
subsection (c). ``(2) LIMITATION.--Financial assistance may
only be provided under this subsection to the owner or operator
of a privately owned treatment works for activities described
in paragraph (1) that primarily and directly benefit the
individuals or entities served by the privately owned treatment
works, and not the shareholders or owners of the treatment
works, as determined by the instrumentality of the State
responsible for administering the water pollution control
revolving fund through which such financial assistance is
provided.''.; was WITHDRAWN.
An Amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute
to H.R. 7023, offered by Mr. Huffman of California (Huffman
076); Page 1, strike lines 2 through 3 and insert ``This Act
may be cited as the `Dirty Water Permitting Act' ''. Page 1,
beginning on line 4, strike ``WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
DEVELOPMENT AND TRANSPARENCY'' and insert ``DIRTY WATER
DEVELOPMENT''. Page 2, line 4, strike ``CONFIDENCE IN CLEAN
WATER PERMITS'' and insert ``DIRTY WATER PERMITS''. Page 4,
line 16, strike ``REDUCING PERMITTING UNCERTAINTY'' and insert
``EXPANDING DIRTY WATER PERMITTING''. Page 5, line 22, strike
``NATIONWIDE PERMITTING IMPROVEMENT'' and insert ``NATIONWIDE
DIRTY WATER PERMITTING''. Page 9, line 3, strike ``JUDICIAL
REVIEW TIMELINE CLARITY'' and insert ``PROMOTING THE POLLUTION
OF OUR WATERWAYS BY RESTRICTING JUDICIAL REVIEW.''; was NOT
AGREED TO by voice vote.
An Amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute
to H.R. 7023, offered by Mr. Stanton of Arizona (Stanton 040);
Page 11, after line 21, insert the following: SEC. 7.
DETERMINATION ON WATER SUPPLY SOURCES. This Act, including the
amendments made by this Act, shall not take effect until the
date on which the Administrator of the Environmental Protection
Agency issues a determination that the implementation of this
Act, including the amendments made by this Act, will not--(1)
result in a surface water body failing to meet its State-
designated uses under the Federal Water Pollution Control Act,
including use as a source of public water supply; or (2)
adversely affect the availability and quality of surface water
for communities in arid regions or drought-prone areas.; was
NOT AGREED TO by a recorded vote of 30 yeas and 32 nays (Roll
Call No. 38).
An Amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute
to H.R. 7023, offered by Mr. Pappas of New Hampshire (Pappas
097); Page 4, after line 15, insert the following (c)
MONITORING OF EMERGING CONTAMINANTS.--Section 402 of the
Federal Water Pollution Control Act (33 U.S.C. 1342) is further
amended by adding at the end the following: ``(u) MONITORING OF
EMERGING CONTAMINANTS.--``(1) IN GENERAL.--Any person who
discharges a pollutant pursuant to a permit issued under this
section shall monitor and report to the Administrator (or the
applicable State, in the case of a permit program approved by
the Administrator) discharges of emerging contaminants,
including perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances. ``(2)
GRANTS AUTHORIZED.--``(A) IN GENERAL.--The Administrator may
award grants to owners and operators of publicly owned
treatment works to carry out the monitoring and reporting of
emerging contaminants required under paragraph (1). ``(B)
AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.--There is authorized to be
appropriated to the Administrator to carry out the grant
program authorized under this paragraph $20,000,000 for each of
fiscal years 2024 through 2028, to remain available until
expended.''.; was NOT AGREED TO by voice vote.
An Amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute
to H.R. 7023, offered by Mr. Ryan of New York (Ryan 054); Page
11, after line 21, insert the following: SEC. 7. DETERMINATION
ON INCREASE IN DISCHARGES. This Act, including the amendments
made by this Act, shall not take effect until the date on which
the Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency issues
a determination that the implementation of this Act, including
the amendments made by this Act, will not result in an increase
in the discharge of pollutants (within the meaning of the
Federal Water Pollution Control Act), including an increase in
the discharge of--(1) any emerging contaminant or forever
chemical, as determined by the Administrator, such as a
perfluoroalkyl substance or polyfluoroalkyl substance; or (2)
any nutrient, including those associated with excessive algae
growth and harmful algal blooms.; was NOT AGREED TO by a
recorded vote of 30 yeas and 32 nays (Roll Call No. 39).
An Amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute
to H.R. 7023, offered by Mr. Graves of Louisiana (Garret Graves
090); After line 10 on page 10, insert the following: (2)
LIMITATION ON COMMENCEMENT OF ACTION.--Notwithstanding any
other provision of law, no action described in paragraph (1)(A)
may be commenced unless the action--(A) is filed by a party
that submitted a comment, during the public comment period for
the administrative proceedings related to the applicable action
described in such paragraph, which comment was sufficiently
detailed to put the Secretary or the State, as applicable, on
notice of the issue upon which the party seeks judicial review;
and (B) is related to such comment.''; was AGREED TO by a
recorded vote of 33 yeas and 29 nays (Roll Call No. 40).
An Amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute
to H.R. 7023, offered by Mr. Garamendi of California (Garamendi
165); Page 11, after line 21, insert the following: SEC. 7.
NATIONAL POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM (NPDES) TERMS.
(a) IN GENERAL.--Section 402(b)(1)(B) of the Federal Water
Pollution Control Act (33 U.S.C. 1342(b)(1)(B)) is amended to
read as follows: ``(B) are for fixed terms--(i) not exceeding
10 years, for a permit issued to a State or municipality; and
(ii) not exceeding 5 years, for a permit issued to any person
not described in clause (i); and''. (b) TECHNICAL
CORRECTIONS.--Section 402(l)(3) of the Federal Water Pollution
Control Act (33 U.S.C. 1342(l)(3)) is amended--(1) in
subparagraph (B)--(A) by striking ``section 402'' and inserting
``this section''; and (B) by striking ``federal'' and inserting
``Federal''; and (2) in subparagraph (C)--(A) by striking
``Section'' and inserting ``section''; (B) by striking
``402(p)(6)'' and inserting ``subsection (p)(6)''; (C) by
striking ``402(l)(3)(A),'' and inserting ``subparagraph (A),'';
and (D) by striking ``402(l)(3)(A).'' and inserting ``such
subparagraph.''; was WITHDRAWN.
An Amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute
to H.R. 7023, offered by Mr. Graves of Louisiana (Garret Graves
092 Revision 1); Page 11, after line 21, insert the following:
SEC. 7. IMPLEMENTATION GUIDANCE. (a) IN GENERAL.--Not later
than 30 days after the date of enactment of this Act, the
Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency and the
Secretary of the Army, acting through the Chief of Engineers,
shall begin a process to issue guidance on the implementation
of the final rule published on September 8, 2023 by the
Department of the Army, Corps of Engineers, Department of
Defense, and the Environmental Protection Agency and titled
``Revised Definition of `Waters of the United States';
Conforming'' (88 Fed. Reg. 61964). (b) PUBLIC COMMENT.--In
issuing the guidance required under subsection (a), the
Administrator and the Secretary shall--(1) prior to such
issuance, solicit comments from the public on such guidance;
and (2) ensure that such comments and any responses to such
comments are made publicly available. (c) COMPLIANCE.--Any
guidance issued pursuant to this section shall comply with the
decision of the Supreme Court in Sackett v. EPA, 598 U.S. 651
(2023).; was AGREED TO by voice vote.
An Amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute
to H.R. 7023, offered by Mr. Graves of Louisiana (Garret Graves
091); Page 6, line 21, insert after ``section'' the following:
``and provided that this authorization will not apply to any
project that would benefit from financial incentives made
available through any Act that would cost more than the score
estimated by the Congressional Budget Office estimate for
Public Law 117-169 (commonly known as the Inflation Reduction
Act)''.; was WITHDRAWN.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires each committee report to include the
total number of votes cast for and against on each record vote
on a motion to report and on any amendment offered to the
measure or matter, and the names of those members voting for
and against.
Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure Roll Call Vote No. 037
On: agreeing to Amendment No. 089, an Amendment to the
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 7023, offered
by Mr. Graves of Louisiana
Agreed to: 34 yeas and 27 nays
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Member Vote Member Vote
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. Graves of MO................................ Y Mr. Larsen of WA.................. N
Mr. Crawford.................................... Y Ms. Norton........................ N
Mr. Webster of FL............................... Y Mrs. Napolitano................... N
Mr. Massie...................................... Y Mr. Cohen......................... N
Mr. Perry....................................... Y Mr. Garamendi..................... Y
Mr. Babin....................................... ............ Mr. Johnson of GA................. N
Mr. Graves of LA................................ Y Mr. Carson........................ N
Mr. Rouzer...................................... Y Ms. Titus......................... N
Mr. Bost........................................ Y Mr. Huffman....................... N
Mr. LaMalfa..................................... Y Ms. Brownley...................... N
Mr. Westerman................................... Y Ms. Wilson of FL.................. ............
Mr. Mast........................................ Y Mr. Payne......................... N
Mrs. Gonzalez-Colon............................. ............ Mr. DeSaulnier.................... N
Mr. Stauber..................................... Y Mr. Carbajal...................... N
Mr. Burchett.................................... Y Mr. Stanton....................... N
Mr. Johnson of SD............................... Y Mr. Allred........................ N
Mr. Van Drew.................................... Y Ms. Davids of KS.................. N
Mr. Nehls....................................... Y Mr. Garcia of IL.................. N
Mr. Mann........................................ Y Mr. Pappas........................ N
Mr. Owens....................................... Y Mr. Moulton....................... N
Mr. Yakym....................................... Y Mr. Auchincloss................... N
Mrs. Chavez-DeRemer............................. Y Ms. Strickland.................... N
Mr. Kean of NJ.................................. Y Mr. Carter of LA.................. N
Mr. D'Esposito.................................. Y Mr. Ryan.......................... N
Mr. Burlison.................................... Y Mrs. Peltola...................... Y
Mr. James....................................... Y Mr. Menendez...................... N
Mr. Van Orden................................... Y Ms. Hoyle of OR................... N
Mr. Williams of NY.............................. Y Mrs. Sykes........................ N
Mr. Molinaro.................................... Y Ms. Scholten...................... N
Mr. Collins..................................... Y Mrs. Foushee...................... N
Mr. Ezell....................................... Y
Mr. Duarte...................................... Y
Mr. Bean of FL.................................. Y
Ms. Maloy....................................... Y
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure Roll Call Vote No. 038
On: agreeing to Amendment No. 040, an Amendment to the
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 7023, offered
by Mr. Stanton
Not Agreed to: 30 yeas and 32 nays
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Member Vote Member Vote
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. Graves of MO................................ N Mr. Larsen of WA.................. Y
Mr. Crawford.................................... N Ms. Norton........................ Y
Mr. Webster of FL............................... N Mrs. Napolitano................... Y
Mr. Massie...................................... N Mr. Cohen......................... Y
Mr. Perry....................................... N Mr. Garamendi..................... Y
Mr. Babin....................................... ............ Mr. Johnson of GA................. Y
Mr. Graves of LA................................ N Mr. Carson........................ Y
Mr. Rouzer...................................... N Ms. Titus......................... Y
Mr. Bost........................................ N Mr. Huffman....................... Y
Mr. LaMalfa..................................... N Ms. Brownley...................... Y
Mr. Westerman................................... N Ms. Wilson of FL.................. Y
Mr. Mast........................................ N Mr. Payne......................... Y
Mrs. Gonzalez-Colon............................. ............ Mr. DeSaulnier.................... Y
Mr. Stauber..................................... N Mr. Carbajal...................... Y
Mr. Burchett.................................... N Mr. Stanton....................... Y
Mr. Johnson of SD............................... N Mr. Allred........................ Y
Mr. Van Drew.................................... N Ms. Davids of KS.................. Y
Mr. Nehls....................................... N Mr. Garcia of IL.................. Y
Mr. Mann........................................ N Mr. Pappas........................ Y
Mr. Owens....................................... N Mr. Moulton....................... Y
Mr. Yakym....................................... N Mr. Auchincloss................... Y
Mrs. Chavez-DeRemer............................. N Ms. Strickland.................... Y
Mr. Kean of NJ.................................. N Mr. Carter of LA.................. Y
Mr. D'Esposito.................................. N Mr. Ryan.......................... Y
Mr. Burlison.................................... N Mrs. Peltola...................... Y
Mr. James....................................... N Mr. Menendez...................... Y
Mr. Van Orden................................... N Ms. Hoyle of OR................... Y
Mr. Williams of NY.............................. N Mrs. Sykes........................ Y
Mr. Molinaro.................................... N Ms. Scholten...................... Y
Mr. Collins..................................... N Mrs. Foushee...................... Y
Mr. Ezell....................................... N
Mr. Duarte...................................... N
Mr. Bean of FL.................................. N
Ms. Maloy....................................... N
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure Roll Call Vote No. 039
On: agreeing to Amendment No. 054, an Amendment to the
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 7023, offered
by Mr. Ryan
Not Agreed to: 30 yeas and 32 nays
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Member Vote Member Vote
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. Graves of MO................................ N Mr. Larsen of WA.................. Y
Mr. Crawford.................................... N Ms. Norton........................ Y
Mr. Webster of FL............................... N Mrs. Napolitano................... Y
Mr. Massie...................................... N Mr. Cohen......................... Y
Mr. Perry....................................... N Mr. Garamendi..................... Y
Mr. Babin....................................... ............ Mr. Johnson of GA................. Y
Mr. Graves of LA................................ N Mr. Carson........................ Y
Mr. Rouzer...................................... N Ms. Titus......................... Y
Mr. Bost........................................ N Mr. Huffman....................... Y
Mr. LaMalfa..................................... N Ms. Brownley...................... Y
Mr. Westerman................................... N Ms. Wilson of FL.................. Y
Mr. Mast........................................ N Mr. Payne......................... Y
Mrs. Gonzalez-Colon............................. ............ Mr. DeSaulnier.................... Y
Mr. Stauber..................................... N Mr. Carbajal...................... Y
Mr. Burchett.................................... N Mr. Stanton....................... Y
Mr. Johnson of SD............................... N Mr. Allred........................ Y
Mr. Van Drew.................................... N Ms. Davids of KS.................. Y
Mr. Nehls....................................... N Mr. Garcia of IL.................. Y
Mr. Mann........................................ N Mr. Pappas........................ Y
Mr. Owens....................................... N Mr. Moulton....................... Y
Mr. Yakym....................................... N Mr. Auchincloss................... Y
Mrs. Chavez-DeRemer............................. N Ms. Strickland.................... Y
Mr. Kean of NJ.................................. N Mr. Carter of LA.................. Y
Mr. D'Esposito.................................. N Mr. Ryan.......................... Y
Mr. Burlison.................................... N Mrs. Peltola...................... Y
Mr. James....................................... N Mr. Menendez...................... Y
Mr. Van Orden................................... N Ms. Hoyle of OR................... Y
Mr. Williams of NY.............................. N Mrs. Sykes........................ Y
Mr. Molinaro.................................... N Ms. Scholten...................... Y
Mr. Collins..................................... N Mrs. Foushee...................... Y
Mr. Ezell....................................... N
Mr. Duarte...................................... N
Mr. Bean of FL.................................. N
Ms. Maloy....................................... N
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure Roll Call Vote No. 040
On: agreeing to Amendment No. 090, an Amendment to the
Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 7023, offered
by Mr. Graves of Louisiana
Agreed to: 33 yeas and 29 nays
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Member Vote Member Vote
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. Graves of MO................................ Y Mr. Larsen of WA.................. N
Mr. Crawford.................................... Y Ms. Norton........................ N
Mr. Webster of FL............................... Y Mrs. Napolitano................... N
Mr. Massie...................................... Y Mr. Cohen......................... N
Mr. Perry....................................... Y Mr. Garamendi..................... N
Mr. Babin....................................... ............ Mr. Johnson of GA................. N
Mr. Graves of LA................................ Y Mr. Carson........................ N
Mr. Rouzer...................................... Y Ms. Titus......................... N
Mr. Bost........................................ Y Mr. Huffman....................... N
Mr. LaMalfa..................................... Y Ms. Brownley...................... N
Mr. Westerman................................... Y Ms. Wilson of FL.................. N
Mr. Mast........................................ Y Mr. Payne......................... N
Mrs. Gonzalez-Colon............................. ............ Mr. DeSaulnier.................... N
Mr. Stauber..................................... Y Mr. Carbajal...................... N
Mr. Burchett.................................... Y Mr. Stanton....................... N
Mr. Johnson of SD............................... Y Mr. Allred........................ N
Mr. Van Drew.................................... Y Ms. Davids of KS.................. N
Mr. Nehls....................................... Y Mr. Garcia of IL.................. N
Mr. Mann........................................ Y Mr. Pappas........................ N
Mr. Owens....................................... Y Mr. Moulton....................... N
Mr. Yakym....................................... Y Mr. Auchincloss................... N
Mrs. Chavez-DeRemer............................. Y Ms. Strickland.................... N
Mr. Kean of NJ.................................. Y Mr. Carter of LA.................. N
Mr. D'Esposito.................................. Y Mr. Ryan.......................... N
Mr. Burlison.................................... Y Mrs. Peltola...................... Y
Mr. James....................................... Y Mr. Menendez...................... N
Mr. Van Orden................................... Y Ms. Hoyle of OR................... N
Mr. Williams of NY.............................. Y Mrs. Sykes........................ N
Mr. Molinaro.................................... Y Ms. Scholten...................... N
Mr. Collins..................................... Y Mrs. Foushee...................... N
Mr. Ezell....................................... Y
Mr. Duarte...................................... Y
Mr. Bean of FL.................................. Y
Ms. Maloy....................................... Y
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure Roll Call Vote No. 041
On: agreeing to Final Passage, H.R. 7023, as amended
Agreed to: 32 yeas and 30 nays
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Member Vote Member Vote
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. Graves of MO................................ Y Mr. Larsen of WA.................. N
Mr. Crawford.................................... Y Ms. Norton........................ N
Mr. Webster of FL............................... Y Mrs. Napolitano................... N
Mr. Massie...................................... Y Mr. Cohen......................... N
Mr. Perry....................................... Y Mr. Garamendi..................... N
Mr. Babin....................................... ............ Mr. Johnson of GA................. N
Mr. Graves of LA................................ Y Mr. Carson........................ N
Mr. Rouzer...................................... Y Ms. Titus......................... N
Mr. Bost........................................ Y Mr. Huffman....................... N
Mr. LaMalfa..................................... Y Ms. Brownley...................... N
Mr. Westerman................................... Y Ms. Wilson of FL.................. N
Mr. Mast........................................ Y Mr. Payne......................... N
Mrs. Gonzalez-Colon............................. ............ Mr. DeSaulnier.................... N
Mr. Stauber..................................... Y Mr. Carbajal...................... N
Mr. Burchett.................................... Y Mr. Stanton....................... N
Mr. Johnson of SD............................... Y Mr. Allred........................ N
Mr. Van Drew.................................... Y Ms. Davids of KS.................. N
Mr. Nehls.............
Minority Views
We oppose H.R. 7023. This bill significantly restricts U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and U.S. Army Corps of
Engineers (Corps) oversight and regulatory authorities under
the Clean Water Act (CWA). The Clean Water Act, enacted over 50
years ago, is the nation's bedrock environmental law for
``restoring and maintaining the chemical, physical, and
biological integrity of the Nation's waters'' and water
resources.
However, the changes in H.R. 7023 defy the overarching
intent of the Clean Water Act and gut the independent authority
of both agencies to ensure that projects and activities are
carried out with only minimal impacts to water resources. This
partisan bill weakens CWA protections while providing
exemptions, legal shields, and limited oversight for special
interests, polluters, and large-scale projects that demand
higher scrutiny.
The bill disregards Congressional intent in establishing
EPA's independent oversight authority over CWA permits;
undermines permitting requirements; eliminates judicial review
and public engagement; rolls back oversight of mining companies
and industrial polluters; inadvertently slows down permit
processing with increased bureaucracy and complicates state-
determined decisions.
This legislation offers these anti-CWA changes as a salve
to specific projects and grievances rather than a sustainable
solution to permitting. Large-scale mining proposals, such as
Pebble Mine in Alaska or Spruce Mine in West Virginia, or
ecologically devastating flood control projects, such as the
Yazoo Pumps in Mississippi, were blocked by bipartisan
presidential administrations under the EPA's Section 404(c)
authority once the impacts were thoroughly evaluated. Although
EPA has utilized this authority very sparingly (only 14 times
since its creation in 1972), H.R. 7023 will effectively
eliminate the authority altogether.
H.R. 7023 also seeks to alter the review of ``linear''
projects, which includes oil and gas pipelines, electrical
transmission lines, and similar projects. These projects often
span hundreds of miles and cross multiple state lines; however,
H.R. 7023 will limit the consideration of the environmental
impacts of these projects, in apparent violation of the Clean
Water Act requirement that such projects have only a minimal
cumulative adverse impact on the environment. The bill also
prevents judicial review by vastly shortening the statute of
limitations; limiting standing to file suit; and limiting the
Court's options for recourse. In short, H.R. 7023 will
greenlight large projects with minimal review while also
limiting opportunities for legal challenges to ecologically
damaging permits or projects.
If this sounds familiar, that is because it is. The changes
proposed in H.R. 7023 will remove opportunities for local
communities to review and, where appropriate, challenge the
ecological, economic, and public health effects of projects
with potentially significant local impacts. H.R. 7023 seeks to
allow private industry and development to steamroll through
towns and states, constructing projects with minimal review and
disregard of local perspectives. If H.R. 7023 is enacted, the
potential adverse impacts to waterbodies (such as reduced water
quality or availability); to the environment (such as increased
greenhouse gas emissions or other contamination); and to
residents (such as perpetuating environmental justice concerns)
will be borne by the local and surrounding communities without
a voice or venue to have their concerns heard.
Lastly, H.R 7023 contradicts itself by slowing down
permitting processes, sowing uncertainty, and decreasing
flexibility. As one example, Section 2 of H.R. 7023 will add a
formal rulemaking process in place of an existing and more
efficient guidance process. This will slow down the issuance of
water quality standards without increasing transparency or
public participation and remove flexibility for updates. It
will also open the standards to judicial review.
The impacts of the CWA rollbacks in H.R. 7023 are
exacerbated by the context in which this bill is considered. In
May 2023, the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Sackett v. EPA
severely restricted the waters that are subject to CWA
protections. It is estimated that the decision removed
protection nationwide from at least 50% of wetlands, and at
least 60% of streams. With a much smaller number of waters
subject to permitting or CWA requirements, additional
limitations, expediting, and loopholes to the process are the
opposite of what Congress needs to be doing to protect our
water resources. Exposing the waters and wetlands that remain
under Clean Water Act protections to additional pollution or
destruction will do nothing to restore and maintain water
quality.
During consideration of H.R. 7023, Committee Democrats
sought to lessen the negative impacts of this legislation and
require EPA to verify that the changes in the bill would not
have negative impacts to water quality and availability issues
that communities currently face nationwide.
Representative Pat Ryan (NY) offered an amendment to delay
the effective date of the bill until the EPA Administrator
determines that the changes will not result in increased
discharges of forever chemicals (such as PFAS) or nutrients
that cause harmful algal blooms. Providing legal cover for
chemicals in waste streams from mines or other industrial
polluters and limiting technologies that could remove pollution
could certainly lead to increased discharges and pollution
levels. The amendment would have ensured that communities are
not left with the environmental and economic burden of cleaning
up and removing such pollutants.
Representative Greg Stanton (AZ) offered an amendment to
prohibit changes made by the bill from taking effect until the
EPA Administrator determines that the bill will not result in
contamination of state-designated drinking water sources,
reduce surface water availability or reduce water quality in
drought-prone areas. Additional fill activities or pollutants
could severely limit public drinking water sources for
communities in arid or drought-stricken areas.
Representative Chris Pappas (NH) offered an amendment to
require permittees to conduct proactive monitoring for emerging
contaminants and forever chemicals at wastewater treatment
plants in order to receive the permit shield offered under the
legislation. Industrial polluters should not be incentivized to
hide potential discharges of forever chemicals, such as PFAS
pollution. Instead, we must work to identify and measure these
chemicals in our waste streams.
The Clean Water Act has been an effective tool for
improving the health of our rivers, streams, lakes, and
wetlands. Unfortunately, progress restoring impaired
waterbodies has slowed and, in some areas, reversed.
Communities face new challenges from emerging contaminants,
impacts of climate change, and declines in Federal assistance.
Waterbodies subject to the CWA have already shrunk
significantly. H.R. 7023 ignores all these realities and
provides additional loopholes for polluters, industry, and
developers.
In our view, this legislation is unnecessary, unwarranted,
and a further attack on clean water nationwide. For these
reasons, we oppose H.R. 7023.
Rick Larsen,
Ranking Member.
Grace F. Napolitano,
Ranking Member, Subcommittee
on Water Resources and
Environment.
Eleanor Holmes Norton.
Steve Cohen.
Henry C. ``Hank'' Johnson, Jr.
Andre Carson.
Dina Titus.
Jared Huffman.
Julia Brownley.
Frederica S. Wilson.
Donald M. Payne, Jr.
Mark DeSaulnier.
Salud Carbajal.
Jesus ``Chuy'' Garcia.
Chris Pappas.
Seth Moulton.
Marilyn Strickland.
Pat Ryan.
Rob Menendez.
Val Hoyle.
Hillary Scholten.
Valerie P. Foushee.