Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 7122]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Foreign Affairs, to whom was referred the
bill (H.R. 7122) to prohibit aid that will benefit Hamas, and
for other purposes, having considered the same, reports
favorably thereon with an amendment and recommends that the
bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Summary and Purpose.............................................. 2
Hearings......................................................... 3
Committee Consideration and Votes................................ 4
Oversight Findings and Recommendations........................... 5
New Budget Authority, Tax Expenditures, and Federal Mandates..... 5
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate........................ 6
Committee Cost Estimate.......................................... 6
Federal Mandates................................................. 7
Non-Duplication of Federal Programs.............................. 7
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 7
Congressional Accountability Act................................. 7
New Advisory Committees.......................................... 7
Earmark Identification........................................... 7
Section-by-Section Analysis...................................... 7
Changes in Existing Law.......................................... 8
Dissenting Views................................................. 9
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Stop Support for United Nations Relief
and Works Agency Act of 2024'' or the ``Stop Support for UNRWA Act of
2024''.
SEC. 2. UNITED STATES CONTRIBUTIONS TO UNRWA.
The United States may not make any voluntary or assessed
contributions to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for
Palestine Refugees in the Near East (referred to in this Act as
``UNRWA'') or to the regular budget of the United Nations for the
support of UNRWA.
SEC. 3. NONPRECLUSION OF HUMANITARIAN ASSISTANCE.
Nothing in this Act may be construed to preclude the provision of
humanitarian assistance through any agency or entity other than UNRWA
to individuals or entities that also receive assistance from UNRWA if
the Secretary of State certifies to Congress that such other agency or
entity--
(1) does not promote, espouse, or affiliate with entities or
individuals that promote violence, terrorism, or antisemitism,
as such term is defined by the IHRA Working Definition of
Antisemitism; and
(2) does not employ individuals who promote, espouse, or
affiliate with such entities or individuals.
SUMMARY AND PURPOSE
H.R. 7122, the Stop Support for United Nations Relief and
Works Agency Act of 2024, prohibits the United States from
making any voluntary or assessed contributions to the United
Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the
Near East (UNRWA), or to the regular budget of the UN for the
support of UNRWA. The purpose of this legislation is to ensure
that no United States assistance is being provided to an
entity, like UNRWA, that promotes violence, terrorism, or anti-
Semitism, or employs individuals who do so, following
disturbing revelations regarding the conduct of UNRWA employees
and years of concern regarding UNRWA's relationship with the
foreign terrorist organization Hamas.
On January 26, 2024, UNRWA announced that it was
investigating allegations that several of its employees may
have been involved in Hamas' October 7, 2023 massacre in
Israel, which was the deadliest day for Jews since the
Holocaust. The October 7 attack killed over 1,200 people,
resulted in more than 240 people being taken hostage, including
babies, and included widespread rape and sexual violence.
Information subsequently published by the Wall Street Journal
indicated that at least 12 UNRWA employees had connections to
the October 7 attacks, and that 10 percent of UNRWA employees
in Gaza have ties to Hamas.
On January 26, the same day as UNRWA's investigation
announcement, the Biden Administration announced that it had
``temporarily paused additional funding for UNRWA while we
review these allegations and the steps the United Nations has
taken to address them.'' It is unclear how long this temporary
pause will last. H.R. 7122 was introduced as an urgent response
to these events to permanently end U.S. contributions to UNRWA
given long-term concerns about systemic anti-Israel and
antisemitic actions by UNRWA employees and UNRWA complicity
with Hamas in Gaza. Notably, evidence of UNRWA's concerning
relationship with Hamas has continued to build even since the
Committee's markup of H.R. 7122. On February 10, 2024, public
reports indicated the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) had
discovered a major Hamas data center hidden beneath UNRWA's
headquarters in the Gaza Strip.
UNRWA was founded in 1949 to provide humanitarian
assistance and protection to Palestinian refugees living in the
West Bank, Gaza Strip, Jordan, Lebanon, and Syria. UNRWA is
part of the United Nations system. UNRWA continues to serve
individuals registered as Palestinian refugees at the time of
UNRWA's founding and their descendants--according to UNRWA,
their mandate currently covers 5.9 million people. Notably,
UNRWA operates separately from UNHCR, the UN refugee agency
that covers all other refugees globally. UNRWA provides life-
saving assistance, health care, education, and other services
directly to its beneficiaries. Ninety-five percent of the UNRWA
budget is funded through voluntary contributions from
governments and the European Union. The United States has
typically been a leading donor to UNRWA, including in 2022,
when the United States provided $343.9 million dollars to UNRWA
(with the next highest donor providing $202 million). Notably,
President Trump stopped U.S. contributions to UNRWA in 2018 and
did not resume such contributions during his Presidency.
President Biden resumed U.S. funding to UNRWA in 2021.
Concerns about UNRWA's ties to Hamas and its teaching of
anti-Israel, antisemitic content are longstanding. Reviews of
textbooks used in UNRWA schools in Gaza by non-government
organizations (NGOs) show these textbooks exclude Israel on
maps and depict Jews as colonialist dividers and enemy
occupiers, and praise violence and martyrdom. Notably, as
reported in Foreign Policy, a 5th grade class in an UNRWA
school was taught about Dalal Mughrabi, with the lesson
reading, ``our Palestinian history is full of many names of
shuhada (martyrs) who sacrificed their lives for the homeland,
including the shahida (martyr) Dalal Mughrabi whose struggle
took the form of defiance and heroism, which made her memory
immortal in our hearts and minds.'' There are also longtime
concerns about UNRWA employees' ties to Hamas. In 2017, UNRWA
school principal Suhail al-Hindi and UNRWA engineer Muhammad
al-jamassi were elected to the Hamas politburo. In January
2024, an NGO published a report documenting how 30 UNRWA staff
in a social media group for UNRWA employees celebrated and
endorsed Hamas' October 7 massacre.
The Committee has previously considered and supported
legislation to address problematic materials in textbooks used
in UNRWA schools. H.R. 3266, the Peace and Tolerance in
Palestinian Education Act (sponsored by Rep. Brad Sherman (D-
CA)) requires a report on the curriculum used in schools in
areas controlled by the Palestinian Authority, which include
the textbooks used in UNRWA schools in the West Bank and Gaza.
The Committee ordered H.R. 3266 favorably reported to the House
by a vote of 46-0 on October 18, 2023. The House subsequently
passed H.R. 3266 by voice vote on November 1, 2023.
Hearings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII of the rules
of the House of Representatives, the Committee held the
following hearings related to--and used to develop--the text of
H.R. 7122 as favorably reported by the Committee:
The January 30, 2024 joint hearing of the
Subcommittee on Oversight & Accountability and Subcommittee on
Global Health, Global Human Rights, and International
Organizations titled ``UNRWA Exposed: Examining the Agency's
Mission and Failures,'' discussed the wide range of allegations
related to UNRWA's relationship with Hamas and role in teaching
anti-Israel, antisemitic content, and whether the United States
should stop funding UNRWA.
The November 8, 2023 full Committee hearing
titled, ``Friend and Ally: U.S. Support for Israel after Hamas'
Barbaric Attack'' included discussion of: whether UNRWA employs
Hamas members; whether U.S. funding to UNRWA has been diverted
to Hamas; how the Administration works to bring problematic
education materials to UNRWA's attention; and UNRWA's role in
providing humanitarian assistance and services in Syria,
Lebanon, Gaza, the West Bank, and Jordan.
The November 8, 2023 hearing of the Subcommittee
on Global Health, Global Human Rights, and International
Organizations titled, ``United Nations' Bigotry Toward Israel:
UNRWA Anti-semitism Poisons Palestinian Youth,'' discussed
concerns about systemic anti-Israel, antisemitism bias at UNRWA
and other UN entities, and how UNRWA's biases engender
antisemitic, anti-Israel views among Palestinians.
The September 27, 2023 hearing of the Subcommittee
on the Middle East, North Africa, and Central Asia titled, ``No
Incentive for Terrorism: U.S. Implementation of the Taylor
Force Act and Efforts to Stop `Pay to Slay''' discussed
concerns that UNRWA teaches problematic materials in schools,
and whether the United States should continue funding UNRWA.
The June 22, 2023 hearing of the Subcommittee on
Global Health, Global Human Rights, and International
Organizations titled, ``Responding to Anti-Semitism and Anti-
Israel Bias in the UN, Palestinian Authority, and NGO
Community,'' included discussion of UNRWA, including UNRWA
teachers and staff promoting violence and antisemitism on
social media.
COMMITTEE CONSIDERATION AND VOTES
The Committee considered H.R. 7122 pursuant to notice, in
open session, at a markup on February 6, 2024. By unanimous
consent, Smith amendment #95 (in the nature of a substitute)
was considered base text for purposes of markup. The following,
additional amendments were considered by the Committee:
Schneider Amendment #60 (in the Nature of a
Substitute) was offered and withdrawn.
Smith amendment #96 (to clarify that nothing in
this act precludes humanitarian assistance provided by entities
that do not promote violence, terrorism or antisemitism) was
adopted by voice vote.
Meeks amendment #63 (to delay implementation of
the funding prohibition until the Secretary of State certifies
that there is a replacement for UNRWA), failed by a vote of 21
Ayes to 26 Noes.
Ayes (21): Meeks, Sherman, Connolly,
Keating, Bera, Castro, Titus, Wild, Allred, Kim (NJ),
Jacobs, Manning, Cherfilus-McCormick, Stanton, Dean,
Moskowitz, Jackson (IL), Kamlager-Dove, Crow, Amo,
Schneider.
Noes (26): McCaul, Smith, Wilson, Issa,
Wagner, Mast, Buck, Burchett, Green, Barr, Jackson
(TX), Kim (CA), Salazar, Huizenga, Radewagen, Hill,
Davidson, Baird, Waltz, Kean, Lawler, Mills, McCormick,
Moran, James, Self.
Manning amendment #48 (to create a waiver to the
funding prohibition) failed by a vote of 22 Ayes to 27 Noes.
Ayes (22): Meeks, Sherman, Connolly,
Keating, Bera, Castro, Titus, Wild, Allred, Kim (NJ),
Jacobs, Manning, Cherfilus-McCormick, Stanton, Dean,
Moskowitz, Jackson (IL), Kamlager-Dove, Costa, Crow,
Amo, Schneider.
Noes (27): McCaul, Smith, Wilson, Perry,
Issa, Wagner, Mast, Buck, Burchett, Green, Barr,
Jackson (TX), Kim (CA), Salazar, Huizenga, Radewagen,
Hill, Davidson, Baird, Waltz, Kean, Lawler, Mills,
McCormick, Moran, James, Self.
H.R. 7122, as amended, was ordered favorably reported to
the House by a vote of 30 Ayes to 19 Noes.
Ayes (30): McCaul, Smith, Wilson, Perry, Issa,
Wagner, Mast, Buck, Burchett, Green, Barr, Jackson (TX), Kim
(CA), Salazar, Huizenga, Radewagen, Hill, Davidson, Baird,
Waltz, Kean, Lawler, Mills, McCormick, Moran, James, Self,
Manning, Moskowitz, Schneider.
Noes (19): Meeks, Sherman, Connolly, Keating,
Bera, Castro, Titus, Wild, Allred, Kim (NJ), Jacobs, Cherfilus-
McCormick, Stanton, Dean, Jackson (IL), Kamlager-Dove, Costa,
Crow, Amo.
OVERSIGHT FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
In compliance with Clause 3(c)(1) of rule XIII of the rules
of the House of Representatives, the Committee reports that the
findings and recommendations of the Committee, based on
oversight activities under Clause 2(b)(1) of rule X of the
House of Representatives, are incorporated in the ``Summary and
Purpose'' section of this report, above.
NEW BUDGET AUTHORITY, TAX EXPENDITURES, AND FEDERAL
MANDATES
Clause 3(c)(2) of House rule XIII is inapplicable because
this bill does not provide new budget authority or increased
tax expenditures.
CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE COST ESTIMATE
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
H.R. 7122 would prohibit the federal government from making
any voluntary or assessed contributions to the United Nations
Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA), the international agency that
provides humanitarian and other assistance to Palestinians in
the Middle East. Subject to certification by the Department of
State, the bill would allow contributions to other entities
that could provide such humanitarian assistance.
Over the 2021-2023 period, U.S. funding for UNRWA averaged
$350 million a year. According to the Administration, in fiscal
year 2024 it provided about $122 million to UNRWA before
suspending financial support in January 2024.
CBO estimates that under the bill, the Administration would
redirect any pending or future contributions to other entities;
thus, the prohibition would change which entities receive U.S.
support but would not substantially affect the amount of
humanitarian support provided for Palestinians.
Based on the costs of similar activities, CBO further
estimates that providing the certifications required under the
bill would cost less than $500,000 over the 2024-2029 period.
Any spending would be subject to the availability of
appropriated funds.
The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Sunita D'Monte.
The estimate was reviewed by Christina Hawley Anthony, Deputy
Director of Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
COMMITTEE COST ESTIMATE
The Committee adopts as its own the Congressional Budget
Office cost estimate on this measure.
FEDERAL MANDATES
The Committee adopts as its own the identification,
description, and assessment of federal mandates contained in
the Congressional Budget Office cost estimate on this measure.
NON-DUPLICATION OF FEDERAL PROGRAMS
Clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII is not applicable to this
measure, as it is not a bill or joint resolution that
establishes or reauthorizes a federal program.
PERFORMANCE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
The goal of H.R. 7122 is to ensure that no United States
assistance is being provided to an entity, like UNRWA, that
promotes violence, terrorism, or anti-Semitism, or employs
individuals who do so, following disturbing revelations
regarding the conduct of UNRWA employees and years of concern
regarding UNRWA's relationship with the Foreign Terrorist
Organization Hamas.
CONGRESSIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY ACT
H.R. 7122 does not apply to terms and conditions of
employment or to access to public services or accommodations
within the legislative branch.
NEW ADVISORY COMMITTEES
H.R. 7122 does not establish or authorize any new advisory
committees.
EARMARK IDENTIFICATION
H.R. 7122 contains no congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits as described in clauses
9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of House rule XXI.
Dissenting Views
Cutting U.S. funding for the United Nations Relief and
Works Agency (UNRWA) while the people of Gaza are suffering an
acute humanitarian disaster undermines U.S. and Israeli
interests and erodes U.S. moral authority. Blocking funding for
UNRWA would also further-endanger the lives of the more than 2
million Palestinians residing in Gaza, most of whom rely on
UNRWA for life sustaining or life-saving assistance. UNRWA
remains the sole entity capable of addressing the life-saving
needs of Palestinians in Gaza in the near term. Even the
Israeli government recognizes the critical role UNRWA plays and
has informed the United States government that there is no
alternative to UNRWA for supporting humanitarian operations
inside Gaza at this time.
H.R. 7122 is designed to immediately eliminate U.S.
financial support for UNRWA and, if implemented, could rapidly
result in the starvation of millions. The Government of Israel
agrees, which is why a senior Israeli official told the Times
of Israel on January 31, 2024: ``If UNRWA ceases operating on
the ground, this could cause a humanitarian catastrophe that
would force Israel to halt its fighting against Hamas. This
would not be in Israel's interest, and it would not be in the
interest of Israel's allies either.'' When President Trump
eliminated funding to UNRWA, Israel was forced to turn to
Germany and other partners to keep UNRWA functioning and
prevent social and political turmoil in the West Bank and Gaza.
UNRWA's collapse would further harm regional instability,
including in the West Bank, Lebanon, Jordan, and Syria, at a
time when the United States and Israel are seeking to de-
escalate and contain spillover from the war in Gaza. It would
be a gift to Iran and its allies Hamas, Hezbollah, and Bashar
Al Assad. A humanitarian collapse in Gaza may also threaten
Israel and our own relationships with Abraham Accords partners,
and other regional partners.
We must recognize that the elimination of UNRWA without a
viable and immediate replacement would undermine American and
Israeli national security. Our allies and partners in the
region and around the world also do not want the collapse of
UNRWA, because we all know its elimination will further the
humanitarian crisis facing Gazans.
Members of this Committee shared concerns regarding UNRWA
well before the disturbing allegations against the 12 UNRWA
employees and welcomed Secretary Blinken's decision to
temporarily pause UNRWA funding while the U.S. investigates. We
must continue to work with UNRWA and other UN bodies to develop
measures to strengthen vetting and oversight of UNRWA's
operations, but we should not stop our funding for 2 million
people, including women and children, because of the wrongdoing
of 12. Without UNWRA's staff and logistical support, the
humanitarian situation in Gaza would be significantly worse
than the disastrous conditions today.
This legislative effort is wildly irresponsible. Despite
UNRWA's major flaws, calling for its immediate elimination and
attempting to jettison UNRWA funding with no realistic plan to
replace it, would have dire consequences for the Palestinian
people, the State of Israel, and the United States.
Successive Israeli governments have supported UNRWA's
continued existence, and U.S. funding for UNRWA, because if it
ceased to exist, Israel would be forced to replace the
organization with its own resources--something that would be
impossible to achieve. That is why Israel opposed President
Trump's UNRWA cuts and lobbied behind the scenes in Washington,
D.C. to get Congress to move forward with funding. Our
colleagues on the other side of the aisle refuse to listen to
our partners in Israel who they claim to support. Committee
Republicans are also ignoring our own intelligence community,
defense community, and diplomatic community who know the real
harm that will result from this measure. There are two million
lives at stake. Israel's future is at stake, and this bill
abruptly increases the risk to all.
We must support all efforts to advance U.S. interests in
peace and stability in Gaza and the broader Middle East region.
This bill undermines our interests, and Committee Democrats,
overwhelmingly rejected this irresponsible and careless
measure.
Sincerely,
Gregory W. Meeks,
Ranking Member.
[all]