Background and Need for Legislation
H.R. 929 would take approximately 17 acres of fee land in Pierce County, Washington, into trust for the benefit of the Puyallup Tribe of Indians. The land taken into trust would be part of the tribe's reservation. Gaming, pursuant to the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act,\1\ would be prohibited on the land placed into trust under the bill. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\25 USC 2701 et seq. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Puyallup tribe is located south of Seattle in Tacoma, Washington. In 1854, the Puyallup Tribe, alongside two other tribes, entered into a treaty with the United States, now known as the Medicine Creek Treaty.\2\ As a result, all three tribes were moved onto small reservations located away from the resources the tribe relied on, leading to the Treaty Wars from 1855 to 1856.\3\ In August of 1856, the United States came into agreement with the three tribes resulting in an additional 18,062 acres being added to the Puyallup Reservation on Commencement Bay within Puget Sound.\4\ Further settlement of the area by non-Indians, the arrival of the Northern Pacific Railroad terminal in the 1870s, and the signing of the General Allotment Act in 1887 led to the tribe holding only around three percent of their designated reservation lands by 1984.\5\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\Puyallup tribe of Indians'', Tiller's Guide to Indian Country, Ed. by Veronica E. Velarde Tiller (2015). \3\``Our Story,'' Puyallup Tribe. http://puyallup-tribe.com/ ourtribe/. \4\Id. \5\Michael Douglas, ``Puyallup Land Claims Settlement,'' HistoryLink.org, Oct. 12, 2016. www.historylink.org/File/20157 (hereinafter Douglas, Puyallup Land Claims Settlement); and Timothy Egan, ``Indian Tribe Agrees to Drop Claim to Tacoma Land for $162 Million,'' New York Times, Aug. 29.1988. https://www.nytimes.com/1988/ 08/29/us/indian-tribe-agrees-to-drop-claim-to-tacoma-land-for-162- million.html. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Puyallup tribe began to pursue reacquisition of their reservation lands in the late 1970s, working to place several tracts of land into trust for their tribal members within the City of Tacoma, which were within the tribe's historic reservation. In 1978, the Secretary of the Interior's authority to place land into trust for the Puyallup was confirmed in Andrus v. City of Tacoma.\6\ The 1983 case of Puyallup Indian Tribe v. Port of Tacoma affirmed the tribe's title to 12 acres of riverbed land exposed when the Army Corps of Engineers rechanneled the Puyallup River from 1948 to 1950.\7\ The tribe continued to pursue the reacquisition of reservation lands by filing a complaint against the Port of Tacoma and the Union Pacific Railroad to reacquire 120 acres of tideland along Commencement Bay and Puyallup River, disrupting title to lands where much of the city's industry was located.\8\ After years of negotiations, the Puyallup Land Claims Settlement Act\9\ was enacted in 1990 by Congress to formalize the land claim settlement negotiated between all parties, including the Puyallup tribe, the Federal government, the State of Washington, local governments, and private entities.\10\ In exchange for relinquishing any legal claims to various acres of land, the tribe received $162 million and 900 acres of land.\11\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \6\City of Tacoma, Wash. v. Andrus, 457 F. Supp. 342 (D.D.C. 1978). \7\Puyallup Indian Tribe v. Port of Tacoma, 717 F.2d 1251 (9th Cir. 1983). \8\Douglas, Puyallup Land Claims Settlement. \9\P.L. 101-41. \10\Douglas, Puyallup Land Claims Settlement. \11\Associated Press. ``Tribe Wins Money in Settlement of Land Suit.'' The New York Times, Mar. 25, 1990. https://www.nytimes.com/ 1990/03/25/us/tribe-wins-money-in-settlement-of-land-suit.html. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Since the 1990 settlement, the Puyallup tribe has engaged in several economic development projects on their trust lands within the Tacoma area and continues to seek restoration of the tribe's homelands. In the mid-2010s, the Puyallup tribe began the process of taking the East Alexander Avenue parcels and the Ruston Way parcels into trust as a discretionary trust acquisition through the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) administrative process. However, likely soil and groundwater contamination of the land was found through Environmental Site Assessments. The findings triggered the Department of the Interior's policy to ``minimize the exposure of bureaus/offices to liabilities and potential remediation costs by avoiding the acquisition of real property that is contaminated, unless otherwise specifically directed by Congress . . .''\12\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \12\Department of Interior, Department Manual, effective Oct. 12, 2016. 602 DM 2, at 2.5, available at: https://www.doi.gov/sites/ doi.gov/files/elips/documents/602-dm-2_0.pdf. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- According to the tribe, the BIA is unwilling to take the land into trust with the current documented environmental contamination. The BIA has stated to the tribe in correspondence that, because of the liability implications for the federal government and the cost implications if the tribe proceeds through the regulatory process, congressional action is ``the most viable option'' for the Puyallup tribe to have these lands placed into trust, partially because further environmental remediation would be prohibitively expensive to the tribe.\13\ H.R. 929 includes language stating that the United States shall not be liable for any environmental contamination that occurred on or before the date on which the land is taken into trust. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \13\Letter to Chairman Bill Sterud, Puyallup Tribe of Indians, from Bryan Mercier, Northwest Regional Director, BIA. August 15, 2022. On file with committee staff. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------