Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4278]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Veterans' Affairs, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 4278) to amend title 38, United States Code, to
modify personnel action procedures with respect to employees of
the Department of Veterans Affairs, and for other purposes,
having considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Amendment........................................................ 2
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 6
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 7
Hearings......................................................... 13
Subcommittee Consideration....................................... 13
Committee Consideration.......................................... 13
Committee Votes.................................................. 15
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 15
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives............ 15
Earmarks and Tax and Tariff Benefits............................. 15
Committee Cost Estimate.......................................... 15
Budget Authority and Congressional Budget Office Estimate........ 15
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 16
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 17
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 17
Statement on Duplication of Federal Programs..................... 17
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 17
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 20
Minority Views................................................... 34
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Restore Department of Veterans Affairs
Accountability Act of 2023'' or the ``Restore VA Accountability Act of
2023''.
SEC. 2. SUPERVISORS: REMOVAL, DEMOTION, OR SUSPENSION BASED ON
PERFORMANCE OR MISCONDUCT.
(a) Discipline of Supervisors.--
(1) In general.--Title 38, United States Code, is amended by
inserting after section 711 the following:
``Sec. 712. Supervisors: removal, demotion, or suspension based on
performance or misconduct
``(a) In General.--The Secretary may remove from civil service,
demote, or suspend a covered individual who is an employee of the
Department if the Secretary determines by substantial evidence that the
performance or misconduct of the covered individual warrants such
action.
``(b) Rights and Procedures.--(1)(A) When making an initial decision
under subsection (a) with respect to determining whether a covered
individual should be removed, demoted, or suspended, the deciding
employee of the Department shall exclusively apply the following
factors:
``(i) The nature and seriousness of the offense, and its
relation to the covered individual's duties, position, and
responsibilities, including whether the offense was intentional
or technical or inadvertent, or was committed maliciously or
for gain, or was frequently repeated.
``(ii) The covered individual's job level and type of
employment, including supervisory or fiduciary role, and
prominence of the position.
``(B) The Secretary shall review the initial decision and uphold such
decision if it is supported by substantial evidence.
``(2) A covered individual subject to an action under subsection (a)
is entitled to--
``(A) advance notice of the action and a file containing all
evidence in support of the proposed action;
``(B) be represented by an attorney or other representative
of the covered individual's choice; and
``(C) grieve the action in accordance with an internal
grievance process that the Secretary, in consultation with the
Assistant Secretary for Accountability and Whistleblower
Protection, shall establish for purposes of this subsection.
``(3) A final decision by the Secretary under paragraph (1)(B) that
is not grieved, and a grievance decision under paragraph (2)(C), shall
be final and conclusive.
``(4) The procedures under chapter 43 of title 5 shall not apply to a
removal, demotion, or suspension under this section, and the Secretary
may carry out such a removal, demotion, or suspension without first
placing a covered individual on a performance improvement plan.
``(c) Timing.--(A) The aggregate period for notice, response, and
final decision by the Secretary of an action under this section may not
exceed 15 business days.
``(B) The period for the response of a covered individual to a notice
under subsection (b)(2)(A) shall be 7 business days.
``(C) The final decision by the Secretary under subsection (b)(1)(B)
shall--
``(i) be issued not later than 15 business days after notice
is provided under subsection (b)(2)(A); and
``(ii) be in writing and shall include the specific reasons
for the decision.
``(D) The Secretary shall ensure that the grievance process
established under paragraph (2)(C) takes fewer than 21 days after the
final decision.
``(d) Judicial Review.--(1) A covered individual adversely affected
by a final decision under this section that is not grieved, or by a
grievance decision under subsection (b)(2)(C), may obtain judicial
review of such decision.
``(2) Any removal, demotion, or suspension under this section is not
appealable to the Merit Systems Protection Board, or to any
administrative judge or other person appointed by the Merit Systems
Protection Board.
``(3) In any case in which judicial review is sought under paragraph
(1), the court shall review the record and may set aside any Department
action found to be--
``(A) arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or
otherwise not in accordance with a provision of law;
``(B) obtained without procedures required by a provision of
law having been followed; or
``(C) unsupported by substantial evidence.
``(4) Except to the extent that an appeal under this subsection
presents a constitutional issue, such court may not review a challenge
to the penalty imposed against the covered individual or mitigate such
penalty.
``(e) Demoted Individuals.--(1) A demotion under subsection (a) shall
be carried out as a reduction in grade for which the covered individual
is qualified, that the Secretary determines is appropriate, and that
reduces the annual rate of pay of the covered individual.
``(2) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, any covered
individual so demoted--
``(A) shall, beginning on the date of such demotion, receive
the annual rate of pay applicable to such grade;
``(B) may not be placed on administrative leave during the
period during which an appeal (if any) under this section is
ongoing, and may only receive pay if the covered individual
reports for duty or is approved to use accrued unused annual,
sick, family medical, military, or court leave; and
``(C) who does not report for duty or receive approval to use
accrued unused leave shall not receive pay or other benefits.
``(f) Whistleblower Protection.--(1) In the case of a covered
individual seeking corrective action (or on behalf of whom corrective
action is sought) from the Office of Special Counsel based on an
alleged prohibited personnel practice described in section 2302(b) of
title 5, the Secretary may not remove, demote, or suspend such covered
individual under subsection (a) without the approval of the Special
Counsel under section 1214(f) of title 5.
``(2) In the case of a covered individual who has made a
whistleblower disclosure to the Assistant Secretary for Accountability
and Whistleblower Protection, the Secretary may not remove, demote, or
suspend such covered individual under subsection (a) until--
``(A) in the case in which the Assistant Secretary determines
to refer the whistleblower disclosure under section
323(c)(1)(D) of this title to an office or other investigative
entity, a final decision with respect to the whistleblower
disclosure has been made by such office or other investigative
entity; or
``(B) in the case in which the Assistant Secretary determines
not to refer the whistleblower disclosure under such section,
the Assistant Secretary makes such determination.
``(g) Termination of Investigations by Office of Special Counsel.--
(1) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the Special Counsel
(established by section 1211 of title 5) may terminate an investigation
of a prohibited personnel practice alleged by an employee or former
employee of the Department after the Special Counsel provides to the
employee or former employee a written statement of the reasons for the
termination of the investigation.
``(2) Such statement may not be admissible as evidence in any
judicial or administrative proceeding without the consent of such
employee or former employee.
``(h) Application.--This section shall apply to any performance or
misconduct of a covered individual beginning on the date of enactment
of the Department of Veterans Affairs Accountability and Whistleblower
Protection Act of 2017 (Public Law 115-41).
``(i) Definitions.--In this section:
``(1) The term `civil service' has the meaning given that
term in section 2101 of title 5.
``(2) The term `covered individual' means an employee of the
Department who is a supervisor or management official as
defined in section 7103(a) of title 5 occupying a position at
the Department, including individuals appointed pursuant to
this title, title 5, and hybrid employees appointed pursuant to
section 7401 of this title, but does not include--
``(A) an individual occupying a senior executive
position (as defined in section 713(d) of this title);
``(B) an individual appointed pursuant to section
7306, 7401(1), 7401(4), or 7405 of this title;
``(C) an individual who has not completed a
probationary or trial period; or
``(D) a political appointee.
``(3) The term `grade' has the meaning given such term in
section 7511(a) of title 5.
``(4) The term `misconduct' includes neglect of duty,
malfeasance, or failure to accept a directed reassignment or to
accompany a position in a transfer of function.
``(5) The term `political appointee' means an individual who
is--
``(A) employed in a position described under sections
5312 through 5316 of title 5 (relating to the Executive
Schedule);
``(B) a limited term appointee, limited emergency
appointee, or noncareer appointee in the Senior
Executive Service, as defined under paragraphs (5),
(6), and (7), respectively, of section 3132(a) of title
5; or
``(C) employed in a position of a confidential or
policy-determining character under schedule C of
subpart C of part 213 of title 5, Code of Federal
Regulations, or successor regulation.
``(6) The term `suspend' means the placing of an employee,
for disciplinary reasons, in a temporary status without duties
and pay for a period in excess of 14 days.
``(7) The term `whistleblower disclosure' has the meaning
given such term in section 323(g) of this title.''.
(2) Clerical amendment.--The table of contents for title 38,
United States Code, is amended by inserting after the item
relating to section 711 the following:
``712. Supervisors: removal, demotion, or suspension based on
performance or misconduct.''.
SEC. 3. SENIOR EXECUTIVES: MODIFICATION OF PROCEDURES TO REMOVE,
DEMOTE, OR SUSPEND BASED ON PERFORMANCE OR
MISCONDUCT.
Section 713 of title 38, United States Code, is amended--
(1) in subsection (a)--
(A) by inserting ``by substantial evidence'', after
``determines''; and
(B) by adding at the end the following:
``(3) When making an initial decision under this subsection with
respect to determining whether a covered individual should be
reprimanded or suspended, involuntarily reassigned, demoted, or
removed, the deciding employee of the Department shall exclusively
apply the following factors:
``(A) The nature and seriousness of the offense, and its
relation to the covered individual's duties, position, and
responsibilities, including whether the offense was intentional
or technical or inadvertent, or was committed maliciously or
for gain, or was frequently repeated.
``(B) The covered individual's job level and type of
employment, including supervisory or fiduciary role, and
prominence of the position.
``(4) The Secretary shall review the initial decision and uphold such
decision if it is supported by substantial evidence.'';
(2) in subsection (b)--
(A) in paragraph (3), by inserting ``after the final
decision'' after ``21 days''; and
(B) by adding at the end the following:
``(7) Except to the extent that an appeal under this subsection
presents a constitutional issue, such court may not review a challenge
to the penalty imposed against the covered individual or mitigate such
penalty.''; and
(3) by inserting after subsection (c) the following (and
redesignating subsection (d) as subsection (e)):
``(d) Application.--This section shall apply to any misconduct or
performance of a covered individual beginning on the date of enactment
of the Department of Veterans Affairs Accountability and Whistleblower
Protection Act of 2017 (Public Law 115-41).''.
SEC. 4. MODIFICATION OF DISCIPLINARY PROCEDURES FOR EMPLOYEES OF THE
DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS.
(a) Department of Veterans Affairs Employee Discipline
Modifications.--Section 714 of title 38, United States Code, is
amended--
(1) in subsection (a),
(A) in paragraph (1), by inserting ``by substantial
evidence'' after ``the Secretary determines''; and
(B) by adding at the end the following:
``(3)(A) When making an initial decision under this subsection with
respect to determining whether a covered individual should be removed,
demoted, or suspended, the deciding employee of the Department shall
exclusively apply the following factors:
``(i) The nature and seriousness of the offense, and its
relation to the covered individual's duties, position, and
responsibilities, including whether the offense was intentional
or technical or inadvertent, or was committed maliciously or
for gain, or was frequently repeated.
``(ii) The covered individual's job level and type of
employment, including supervisory or fiduciary role, and
prominence of the position.
``(iii) The covered individual's past disciplinary record.
``(iv) The covered individual's past work record, including
length of service, performance on the job, ability to get along
with fellow workers, and dependability.
``(v) Mitigating circumstances surrounding the offense such
as unusual job tensions, personality problems, mental
impairment, harassment, or bad faith, malice, or provocation on
the part of others involved in the matter.
``(B) The Secretary shall review the initial decision and uphold such
decision if it is supported by substantial evidence.''.
(2) in subsection (c)--
(A) by striking paragraph (1)(D); and
(B) in paragraph (3), by inserting before the period
the following: ``, and the Secretary may carry out such
a removal, demotion, or suspension without first
placing a covered individual on a performance
improvement plan'';
(3) in subsection (d)--
(A) in paragraph (2), by adding at the end the
following:
``(C) Except to the extent that an appeal under this subsection
presents a constitutional issue, the administrative judge may not
review a challenge to the penalty imposed against the covered
individual.'';
(B) in paragraph (3), by adding at the end the
following:
``(D) Except to the extent that an appeal under this subsection
presents a constitutional issue, the Merit Systems Protection Board may
not review a challenge to the penalty imposed against the covered
individual.'';
(C) in paragraph (5), by adding at the end the
following:
``(C) Except to the extent that an appeal under this subsection
presents a constitutional issue, such Court may not review a challenge
to the penalty imposed against the covered individual or mitigate such
penalty.''; and
(D) by striking paragraph (10);
(4) by redesignating subsection (h) as subsection (j);
(5) by inserting after subsection (g) the following:
``(h) Collective Bargaining Agreements.--The procedures in this
section shall supersede any collective bargaining agreement to the
extent that such agreement is inconsistent with such procedures.
``(i) Application.--This section shall apply to any performance or
misconduct of a covered individual beginning on the date of enactment
of the Department of Veterans Affairs Accountability and Whistleblower
Protection Act of 2017 (Public Law 115-41).''; and
(6) in paragraph (1) of subsection (j), as redesignated by
paragraph (4)--
(A) by inserting ``including individuals appointed
pursuant to this title, title 5, and hybrid employees
appointed pursuant to section 7401 of this title''
after ``Department'';
(B) in subparagraph (D), by striking the period and
inserting ``; or''; and
(C) by adding after subparagraph (D) the following:
``(E) a supervisor or management official as defined
in section 7103(a) of title 5.''.
(b) VHA Employee Discipline Modifications.--Section 7403(f)(3) of
such title is amended--
(1) by striking ``Notwithstanding any other provision of this
title or other law,'' and inserting ``(A) Notwithstanding any
other provision of this title or other law, and consistent with
subparagraph (B),''; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
``(B
Purpose and Summary
H.R. 4278, the ``Restore VA Accountability Act of 2023''
was introduced by Rep. Mike Bost of Illinois on June 22, 2023.
The bill as ameded would amend Title 38 of the United States
Code (U.S.C.) to modify personnel action procedures with
respect to U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (``VA'')
employees. This bill would restore authorities Congress granted
VA in 2017 through the 2017 VA Accountability and Whistleblower
Protection Act (Pub. L. No 115-41) ensuring VA has the
authority it needs to hold its employees accountable and
provide quality care and benefits to the veterans it serves.
Background and Need for Legislation
Section 1: Short title
This Act may be cited as the ``Restore Department of
Veterans Affairs Accountability Act of 2023'' or the ``Restore
VA Accountability Act of 2023''.
Section 2. Supervisors: Removal, demotion, or suspension based on
performance or misconduct
In 2014, Committee oversight found that as many as forty
veterans at the Phoenix VA Health Care System died while
awaiting medical care. Further, the evidence showed that
Phoenix VA Health Care System employees concealed these long
wait times. The allegations of several whistleblowers,
including Drs. Samuel Foote and Kathleen Mitchell from Phoenix,
shed light on these issues and improper practices, which
resulted in one of the largest scandals VA has ever endured.
Subsequently, on August 7, 2014, in part to address the
problems related to the scandal exposed by the Committee, the
Veterans Access, Choice and Accountability Act (``Choice Act'')
was signed into law by President Barack Obama, which, among
many other provisions, gave the Secretary the expedited
authority, found in 38 U.S.C. Sec. 714, to remove Senior
Executive Service employees for poor performance or misconduct.
After passage of the Choice Act, the Committee continued to
uncover many instances of poor performance or misconduct by VA
employees. Instances included allegations of the manipulation
of disability claims data at the Philadelphia Regional Benefit
Office;\1\ construction failures of a new medical center in
Aurora, Colorado that was many years delayed and a billion
dollars over budget;\2\ allegations of illegal use of
government purchase cards resulting in the waste of billions of
dollars annually;\3\ allegations of a VA employee remaining in
her job after participating in an armed robbery;\4\ and
numerous instances of not properly disciplining employees
involved with the opioid theft or missing prescriptions.\5\
Throughout all of these incidents, it became clear that VA
often did not hold individuals appropriately accountable for
their actions, and additional legislation was needed to hold VA
employees accountable.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\After 10-month probe, report slams Phila. VA, Philly.com, April
17, 2015 http://articles. philly.com/2015-04-17/news/
61222505_1_allison-hickey-veterans-affairs-benefits-officediana-rubens.
\2\Aurora VA official: No line-by-line account of where $1 billion
went, The Denver Post, July 2015 http://www.denverpost.com/news/
ci_28415366/va-deputy-secretary-making-eighth-tripdenver-hospital.
\3\VA Put Vets at Risk by Spending Billions Unlawfully,
Whistleblower Says, Government Executive, May 14, 2015 http://
www.govexec.com/contracting/2015/05/va-put-vets-risk-spendingbillions-
unlawfully-whistleblower-says/112828/.
\4\VA Worker Gets Job Back Despite Armed Robbery Charge, The Daily
Caller News Foundation, March 22, 2016 https://dailycaller.com/2016/03/
22/va-worker-gets-job-back-despite-armed-robbery-charge/.
\5\AP: VA data show low rate of discipline for drug loss, theft,
February 27, 2017 https://www.denverpost.com/2017/02/27/veterans-
affairs-hospitals-opioid-theft/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To compound these issues, the Committee found that VA was
often not effectively able to discipline its employees. The
U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO), found that, on
average, it takes six months to a year, if not longer, to
remove a permanent civil servant in the Federal Government.\6\
This problem is epitomized by an example from 2014 where a VA
peer-support specialist took a veteran, who was an inpatient at
the substance abuse clinic of the Central Alabama Veterans
Health Care System, to an off-campus location where he helped
the veteran purchase illegal drugs and paid for the veteran to
partake in other illicit behaviors.\7\ It took VA over a year
to even begin the removal process for this employee.\8\ A study
by Vanderbilt University's Center for the Study of Democratic
Institutions found that when they surveyed non-management
federal workers across the government and asked them how often
under-performing, non-management employees are reassigned or
dismissed, 70% said it ``rarely or never happens.''\9\ The
Committee therefore concluded that VA employees were caught in
a failed and antiquated bureaucracy in desperate need or
reform.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\U.S. Government Accountability Office, Federal Workforce:
Improved Supervision and Better Use of Probationary Periods are Needed
to Address Substandard Employee Performance http://www.gao.gov/assets/
670/668339.pdf.
\7\Report: VA employee took recovering vet to crack house,
Montgomery Advertiser, August 16, 2014 http://
www.montgomeryadvertiser.com/story/news/local/alabama/2014/08/17/
reportva-employee-took-recovering-vet-crack-house/14190573/.
\8\A VA employee, a crack house, and a lengthy firing process, The
Washington Post, August 29, 2014 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/
federal-eye/wp/2014/08/29/a-va-employee-a-crack-house-and-a-lengthy-
firing-process/.
\9\The Fiscal Times, Federal Employees: Can't Hire the Best, Can't
Fire the Worst, July 17, 2015 http://www.thefiscaltimes.com/2015/07/17/
Federal-Employees-Can-t-Hire-Best-Can-t-Fire-Worst.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In an attempt to reform the failed system, the Committee
worked on a bipartisan basis to pass the Department of Veterans
Affairs Accountability and Whistleblower Protection Act of 2017
(``Accountability Act''). On June 23, 2017, President Trump
signed the Accountability Act into law.
The Accountability Act gave VA authorities that were needed
to hold its employees accountable. The Accountability Act, in
part, strengthened the authorities intended to keep it Senior
Executives accountable, found in 38 U.S.C. Sec. 713, and
created 38 U.S.C. Sec. 714 which was intended to create a more
fair and efficient disciplinary process at VA for many of its
supervisory and non-supervisory employees. 38 U.S.C. Sec. 714
includes provisions intended by Congress to: (a) provide a
substantial evidence (reasonableness) test to the VA
Secretary's and MSPB's review of disciplinary proposals; (b)
mandate an expedited timeline for disciplinary decisions and
reviews; (c) prevent the Merit System Protections Board (MSPB)
from mitigating the penalty VA imposed; (d) provide protections
for employees in the disciplinary process who are also
whistleblowers; and (e) allow VA to implement these provisions
without coordination with federal unions.
Evidence examined shows that the Accountability Act gave VA
the authority it needed to hold its employees accountable. Data
provided by VA, excerpted below, shows that removal,
suspension, and demotion disciplinary actions increased more
than 50% the year after the Accountability Act was passed,
compared with the year prior. Slowly, as portions of the
Accountability Act were stripped of the law, disciplinary
numbers returned to historical averages. Committee oversight
suggests that these large changes in disciplinary actions,
resulted directly from authorities included in the VA
Accountability and Whistleblower Protection Act.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Count of Actions Pre- or Post-Act
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 Year 1st Year 2nd Year 3rd Year 4th Year 5th Year 6th Year
Pre* (06/ Post* (06/ Post* (06/ Post* (06/ Post* (06/ Post* (06/ Post* (06/ Grand
Nature of Action 23/16- 06/ 23/17- 06/ 23/18- 06/ 23/19- 06/ 23/20- 06/ 23/21- 06/ 23/22- 06/ Total
22/17) 22/18) 22/19) 22/20) 22/21) 22/22) 22/23)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
REMOVAL Total........................................... 1,006 1,567 1,358 1,410 1,252 1,123 1,009 8,725
SUSPENSION More Than 14 Days Total...................... 100 136 107 156 117 57 56 739
DEMOTION to Lower Grade, Level, or Band................. 69 88 98 81 56 57 63 512
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Grand Total......................................... 1,175 1,791 1,563 1,647 1,425 1,247 1,128 9,976
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unfortunately, starting in 2018, decisions from the U.S.
Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, the MSPB, and the
Federal Labor Relations Authority (FLRA) significantly reduced
the effectiveness of the authorities the Accountability Act
gave VA in 38 U.S.C. Sec. 714, leading to a slow decrease in
removal, suspension, and demotion actions at VA.\10\ Due to
these court decision, as of April 30, 2021, VA stopped using 38
U.S.C. Sec. 714 to take action against AFGE bargaining unit
employees and on January 17, 2023, VA stopped using 38 U.S.C.
Sec. 714 to take action against many of its remaining
employees, called ``hybrid Title 38 employees.''\11\ On April
3, 2023, VA wholesale stopped using 38 U.S.C. Sec. 714, against
employees who were still eligible for 38 U.S.C. Sec. 714
disciplinary action, many of whom are supervisory
employees.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\A January 23, 2023 letter from the Secretary of Veterans
Affairs Denis McDonough to Committee Chairman Mike Bost, provided the
following descriptions of relevant court cases:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sayers vs. VA, 954 F.3d 1370 (Fed. Cir. 2020)--The
Federal Circuit ruled that section 714 could not be applied
retroactively to misconduct and performance predating VAAWPA.
The Court further stated that the MSPB must review not only the
evidence establishing the misconduct, but also the penalty to
assess whether it is supported by substantial evidence. It
acknowledged that the MSPB lacks authority to mitigate the
penalty under the statute. See also Brenner v. VA, 990 F.3d
1313 (Fed. Cir. 2021).
Connor vs. VA, 8 F.4th 1319 (Fed. Cir. 2021) and
Rodriguez vs. VA, 8 F.4th 1290 (Fed. Cir. 2021)--The Federal
Circuit ruled that section 714's reduction of the evidentiary
standard to substantial evidence did not apply to VA's deciding
official, who was required to use the higher preponderance of
the evidence standard. The Court also ruled that VA must
consider the relevant factors when assessing the appropriate
penalty in section 714 actions.
Richardson vs. VA, 2023 M.S.P.B 1 (MSPB 2023)--MSPB
found that section 714's definition of covered individuals did
not include title 38 hybrid employees, meaning they cannot be
disciplined using the enhanced authority.
Labor Decisions, VA has also faced labor challenges
to its implementation of section 714 under its collective
bargaining agreements (CBA), including but not limited to the
following:
Performance Improvement Plans (PIP) in
AFGE CBA: In 2018, an arbitrator issued an award that
was upheld by the FLRA in 2021, following VA's request
for reconsideration. The FLRA found that VA violated
the American Federation of Government Employees' (AFGE)
CBA by failing to provide AFGE bargaining unit
employees (BUE) performance improvement plans prior to
taking a performance action under section 714. VA was
required to resume the use of PIPs for AFGE BUEs and to
rescind any actions that violated the CBA and to make
all employees whole. VA is currently implementing this
award.
Impact and Implementation Bargaining:
Under VA's CBA, AFGE filed a national grievance
alleging VA failed to bargain regarding implementation
of section 714. The arbitrator's initial decision in
favor of VA was reversed by the FLRA which found that
VA violated 5 U.S.C. Sec. 7106(b)(3) by failing to
bargain impact and implementation of section 714.
Subsequent arbitration led to an order for VA to cease
using section 714 against AFGE BUEs until retroactive
impact and implementation bargaining was complete and
to make impacted AFGE BUEs whole. AFGE has filed unfair
labor practice (ULP) complaints with FLRA alleging VA
failed to comply with this order. VA and AFGE are
currently in confidential mediation to discuss the ULP
complaint, the arbitration award, and a memorandum of
understanding concerning impact and implementation of
section 714 for AFGE BUEs.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Statement of Ms. Tracey Therit, Chief Human Capital Officer
Human Resources and Administration/ Operations, Security and
Preparedness, Department of Veterans Affairs, ``Accountability at VA:
Leadership Decisions Impacting Its Employees And Veterans,''
Subcomittee On Oversight and Investigations Subcommittee, Committee On
Veterans' Affairs, U.S. House Of Representatives, March 9, 2023 https:/
/docs.house.gov/meetings/VR/VR08/20230309/115445/HHRG 118-VR08-Wstate-
TheritT 20230309.pdf.
\12\VA no longer uses Trump-era law allowing officials to fire feds
faster, The Washington Post, August 7, 2023, https://
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/04/07/va-trump-rule-federal-
employee-firings/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Simultaneous with VA's decision to rollback use of 38
U.S.C. Sec. 714, Committee oversight uncovered situations where
VA still failed to keep its employees accountable. A recent
Committee investigation uncovered a supervisor, who was the
subject of three investigations, including an Administrative
Investigation Board (AIB) report, which includes roughly 4,000
pages and 57 hours of incriminating evidence.\13\ The AIB found
that the supervisory employee made racially charged statements,
forced subordinates to give him meals and rides, lied to his
subordinates, bribed his subordinates, retaliated against
subordinates by giving them the worst work assignments, and
consistently didn't even do his job.\14\ Under traditional
authorities VA believed they did not have enough evidence to
appropriately discipline an obviously problematic employee.
Because of VA's policy decision to stop using 38 U.S.C.
Sec. 714, VA believes it does not have the authority to remove
the individual.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Letters sent to VA about the investigation include those
referenced in the following: Chairman Bost, Rep. Obernolte Continue to
Press VA on Lack of Accountability at Loma Linda, House Committee on
Veterans' Affairs, Press Release, August 3, 2023, https://
veterans.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=6247.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As VA is unwilling or unable to use its 38 U.S.C. Sec. 714
authority to discipline supervisors, this section would create
a new disciplinary authority, 38 U.S.C. Sec. 712, under which
VA would have authority to discipline many of its supervisory
personnel. Committee oversight has made clear a small
proportion of VA's middle managers cause disproportionate harm
for their subordinates and the veterans they serve.
Furthermore, unlike many of their subordinates, supervisors are
often not held accountable for their misconduct and poor
performance. 38 U.S.C. Sec. 712 mirrors the legal authorities
VA has available to keep its Senior Executives accountable in
38 U.S.C. Sec. 713. Like Senior Executives, VA supervisors are
non-union employees with great responsibility. Additionally, VA
supervisors, like Senior Executives, are often not held
accountable for their actions and therefore require more
effective disciplinary procedures.
Like the preexisting 38 U.S.C. Sec. 713, the proposed 38
U.S.C. Sec. 712 would remove MSPB review of disciplinary cases
against VA supervisors, preserving that review right for non-
supervisory union VA employees. The section would create levels
of VA review, in addition to judicial appeal rights, to ensure
VA quality supervisors are not unfairly disciplined.
In addition to applying disciplinary procedures found in 38
U.S.C. Sec. 713, to supervisors, 38 U.S.C. Sec. 712 also
specifies factors VA must consider when making disciplinary
decisions. Court decisions have found that VA must apply a 12-
step-test, called the Douglas Factors, when deciding to
discipline an employee. The MSPB, an unelected body, created
the Douglas Factors over 40 years ago. The factors are not
stated in law and may provide employees unnecessary
opportunities to dispute, and overturn, their discipline when
all boxes aren't checked, rather than when leadership
determines an employee is not providing veterans quality care
and benefits. To streamline the VA discipline process, and
provide transparency to VA employees, this section would codify
the following two Douglas Factors: (A) The nature and
seriousness of the offense, and its relation to the covered
individual's duties, position, and responsibilities, including
whether the offense was intentional or technical or
inadvertent, or was committed maliciously or for gain, or was
frequently repeated; and (B) The covered individual's job level
and type of employment, including supervisory or fiduciary
role, and prominence of the position. These factors simply
ensure supervisors are held accountable for their actions,
whether poor performance or misconduct, and ensure their
actions are held against the standard expected of a VA employee
of their seniority.
Unlike the factors which would apply to bargaining unit
employees, under 38 U.S.C. Sec. 714 (discussed below), 38
U.S.C. Sec. 712 would not give supervisors the opportunity to
argue their past good performance should give them a pass for
their recent poor performance or misconduct. By removing
Douglas Factors which enable lawyers to argue that their client
deserves another chance, despite their client's poor
performance or miscon
Hearings
On July 12, 2023, the Subcommittee on Oversight and
Investigation held a legislative hearing on H.R. 4278 and other
bills that were pending before the subcommittee.
The following witnesses testified:
Mr. Lewis Ratchford, Chief Security Officer,
U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs;
Mr. Rondy Waye, Executive Director, Human
Capital Programs, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs;
Mr. Ray Tellez, Acting Deputy Under
Secretary for Automated Benefits Delivery, U.S.
Department of Veterans Affairs;
Dr. Angela Billups, Executive Director,
Office of Acquisition and Logistics, U.S. Department of
Veterans Affairs;
Mr. David Case, Deputy Inspector General,
U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs;
Mr. Joshua Hastings, Veterans Benefits
Policy Analyst, The American Legion;
Mr. Patrick Murray, Director, National
Legislative Service, Veterans of Foreign Wars;
Mr. Clint Romesha, SSG (ret.), Board of
Director, Emeritus, America's Warrior Partnership;
Ms. Terry Gerton, President and Chief
Executive Officer, National Academy of Public
Administration.
The following individuals and organizations submitted
statements for the record:
Concerned Veterans for America;
National Federation of Federal Employees;
Senior Executives Association;
American Federation of Government Employees
Partnership for Public Service;
Dr. Donald F. Kettl;
United Nurses Association of California/
Union of Health Care Professionals;
Service Employees International Union.
Subcommittee Consideration
On July 19, 2023, the Subcommittee on Oversight and
Investigations held a markup on the legislation included in the
text of this bill. The bill was ordered favorably forwarded to
the full Committee on Veterans Affairs by voice vote.
Committee Consideration
On July 26, 2023, the full Committee met in open markup
session, a quorum being present, and ordered H.R. 4278, as
amended, be reported favorably to the House of Representatives
by a recorded vote with 14 yays and 11 nays. During the
consideration of the bill, the following amendments were
considered:
1. An amendment offered by Mr. Levin that would strike the
``substantial'' evidentiary standard and replace it with a
``preponderance'' for the review of the initial fact-finding.
The amendment failed by a recorded vote of 11 yays and 14 nays.
2. An amendment offered by Mr. Takano that would require VA
to consider all twelve Douglas Factors for disciplinary
decisions under sections 712, 713, and 714. The amendment
failed by voice vote.
3. An amendment offered by Mr. Landsman that would strike a
provision that gives the Secretary the flexibility to forgo
implementing a Performance Improvement Plan before initiating
disciplinary action. The amendment failed by voice vote.
4. An amendment offered by Ms. Cherfilus-McCormick that
would strike the provision eliminating MSPB review for non-
union supervisors. This amendment would also strike the
provision limiting MSPB review to appeals on the facts of the
case, rather than the chosen penalty. The amendment failed by a
recorded vote of 11 yays to 14 nays.
5. An amendment offered by Mr. Deluzio would strike the
provision that allows the disciplinary authorities in this bill
to be applied retroactively going back to the enactment of the
2017 Accountability Act. The amendment failed by a recorded
vote of 11 yays to 14 nays.
6. An amendment offered by Mr. McGarvey that would strike
Section 4 of the underlying bill text. The amendment failed by
a recorded vote of 11 yays to 14 nays.
7. An amendment offered by Mrs. Budzinski that would
require VA's implementation of the Restore VA Accountability
Act to be collectively bargained with its employee unions. The
amendment failed by a recorded vote of 11 yays to 14 nays.
8. An amendment offered by Mr. Mrvan that would authorize
an independent study performed by the National Academy of
Public Administration regarding the management structures of
the Department of Veterans Affairs. The amendment was approved
by voice vote.
9. An amendment offered by Ms. Brownley that would
authorize the Comptroller General to perform a study on
Veterans Health Administration oversight functions. The
amendment was approved by voice vote.
10. An amendment offered by Mr. Mrvan that would require
the Secretary to report to Congress the Department's costs
related to the 2017 Accountability Act since its enactment and
how much money has been spent on attorney's representing the
Department on appeals related to disciplinary actions taken
under 38 U.S.C. Sec. 713 and 714 authorities. The amendment
failed by a recorded vote of 11 yays to 14 nays.
11. An amendment offered by Mr. Pappas that would require
training for all employees that are covered under 38 U.S.C.
Sec. 712 and 713. The amendment would require the training be
developed in consolation with at least three other federal
agencies and require refresher training every two years. The
amendment failed by a recorded vote of 12 yays to 13 nays.
A motion by Representative Bergman to report H.R. 4278, as
amended, favorably to the House of Representatives was approved
by a recorded vote of 14 yays to 11 nays.
Committee Votes
In compliance with clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, seven recorded votes were taken
on amendments or in connection with ordering H.R. 4278, as
amended, reported to the House.
Committee Oversight Findings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of rule XIII and clause
(2)(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of
Representatives, the Committee's oversight findings and
recommendations are reflected in the descriptive portions of
this report.
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives
In accordance with clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives, the Committee's performance
goals and objectives of H.R. 4278, as amended, are to restore
Congress's intent in the VA Accountability and Whistleblower
Protection Act of 2017 to give VA the authority it needs to
quickly remove, demote, and suspend employees who are a
disservice to veterans.
Earmarks and Tax and Tariff Benefits
H.R. 4278 does not contain any Congressional earmarks,
limited tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in
clause 9 of rule XXI of the Rules of the House of
Representatives.
Committee Cost Estimate
The Committee adopts as its own the cost estimate on H.R.
4278, as amended, prepared by the Director of the Congressional
Budget Office.
Budget Authority and Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the following is the cost estimate
for H.R. 4278, as amended, provided by the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act
of 1974:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
H.R. 4278 would make several changes to disciplinary
policies for employees of the Department of Veterans Affairs
(VA).
The bill would:
Allow VA to more quickly remove, demote, or
suspend employees;
Truncate the grievance processes for
employees affected by adverse disciplinary action; and
Require two studies of VA's performance
management processes and oversight.
Allowing VA to remove, demote, or suspend employees more
quickly would change which people VA employs, but would not
significantly affect the number of people who work for the
department. Thus, those changes would have an insignificant
effect on the budget.
The bill would require VA to contract with the National
Academy of Public Administration to study the department's
performance management systems. The bill also would require the
Government Accountability Office to conduct a study of the
oversight functions of the Veterans Health Administration.
Based on the cost of similar studies, CBO estimates the studies
required by H.R. 4278 would each cost $1 million. In total,
implementing H.R. 4278 would cost $2 million over the 2023-2028
period; any spending would be subject to the availability of
appropriated funds.
The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Logan Smith. The
estimate was reviewed by Christina Hawley Anthony, Deputy
Director of Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
Federal Mandates Statement
Section 423 of the Congressional Budget and Impoundment
Control Act (as amended by Section 101(a)(2) of the Unfunded
Mandate Reform Act, P.L. 104-4 is inapplicable to H.R. 4278, as
amended.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of Section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act would be created by H.R.
4278, as amended.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that H.R. 4278, as amended, does not
relate to the terms and conditions of employment or access to
public services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Statement on Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee finds that no provision
of H.R. 4278, as amended, establishes or reauthorizes a program
of the Federal Government known to be duplicative of another
Federal program, a program that was included in any report from
the Government Accountability Office to Congress pursuant to
section 21 of Public Law 111-139, or a program related to a
program identified in the most recent Catalog of Federal
Domestic Assistance.
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation
Section 1: Short title
Section 1 would establish the short title of the bill as
``Restore Department of Veterans Affairs Accountability Act of
2023 or the ``Restore VA Accountability Act of 2023.''
Section 2: Supervisors: Removal, demotion, or suspension based on
performance or misconduct
Section 2(a) would insert a new 38 U.S.C. Sec. 712. This
section would create a new disciplinary authority, 38 U.S.C.
Sec. 712, under which VA would have authority to discipline
many of its supervisory personnel. The new disciplinary
authority would mirror legal authorities VA has available to
keep its Senior Executives Accountable in 38 U.S.C. Sec. 713.
Section 712(a) would give the VA Secretary authority
to discipline supervisors who they determine, as
supported by substantial evidence, warrant such action
because of misconduct or poor performance.
Section 712(b) details the rights and procedures that
would apply to disciplining a VA supervisory employee.
Importantly, the section would: codify two factors
which must exclusively be considered when deciding
whether to discipline a supervisor;\16\ specify that
the VA Secretary should review a proposing disciplinary
authority's disciplinary decision, using a substantial
evidence (reasonableness) test; specify that VA
supervisors are entitled to advanced notice of
disciplinary actions, and representation by an
attorney; and would have a grievance process within VA
to dispute proposed discipline.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\The two factors are (1) the nature and seriousness of the
offense, and its relation to the covered individual's duties, position,
and responsibilities, including whether the offense was intentional or
technical or inadvertent, or was committed maliciously or for gain, or
was frequently repeated; and (2) the covered individual's job level and
type of employment, including supervisory or fiduciary role, and
prominence of the position.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 712(c) would mandate time limits for steps
taken by the Secretary and the covered supervisor
during the disciplinary process.
Section 712(d) would provide certain judicial review
rights for VA supervisors, including the right to seek
judicial review of a disciplinary decision, but would
specify that VA supervisors may not appeal a
disciplinary decision to the Merit System Protection
Board.
Section 712(e) would specify the required process VA
must follow when demoting a supervisor for disciplinary
reasons.
Section 712(f) would create certain whistleblower
protection procedures, including Office of Special
Counsel investigations, which would create a process
which would protect VA supervisors from whistleblower
retaliation.
Section 712(g) would require the Office of Special
Counsel to provide a written explanation before
terminating an investigation into whistleblower
retaliation.
Section 712(h) would specify that the authorities in
38 U.S.C. Sec. 712 can be applied to actions taken by
the covered supervisors starting on the date the
Accountability Act became law.
Section 712(i) includes the definitions to be
included in the section, and specifies that 38 U.S.C.
Sec. 712 applies to certain VA supervisors.
Section 3. Senior Executives: Modification of procedures to remove,
demote, or suspend based on performance or misconduct
Section 3 ensures VA has authority it needs to hold Senior
Executives accountable by making technical changes to 38 U.S.C.
Sec. 713 to make Congress's intent in the VA Accountability and
Whistleblower Protection Act clear. Section 3 would make the
following modifications to 38 U.S.C. Sec. 713:
Section 713(a) would be modified by giving the VA
Secretary authority to discipline covered senior
executives who the Secretary determines, as supported
by substantial evidence, warrant such action because of
misconduct or poor performance; codifying two
factors\17\ VA must exclusively consider when deciding
whether to discipline senior executives; and specifying
the VA Secretary shall review a proposing disciplinary
authority's disciplinary decision using a substantial
evidence test.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\The two factors are (1) the nature and seriousness of the
offense, and its relation to the covered individual's duties, position,
and responsibilities, including whether the offense was intentional or
technical or inadvertent, or was committed maliciously or for gain, or
was frequently repeated; and (2) the covered individual's job level and
type of employment, including supervisory or fiduciary role, and
prominence of the position.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 713(b) would be modified by specifying the
Secretary shall ensure the grievance process takes
fewer than 21 days after a final disciplinary decision;
and adding language specifying absent a constitutional
issue, courts may not review a challenge to penalties
imposed against covered individuals or mitigate such
penalties.
Section 713(d) would be added specifying that the
authorities in 38 U.S.C. Sec. 713 apply to covered
senior executives starting on the date the
Accountability Act became law.
Subsection 713(d) would be redesignated as subsection
713(e).
Section 4: Modification of disciplinary procedures for employees of the
Department of Veterans Affairs
Section 4(a) would make technical changes to 38 U.S.C.
Sec. 714 to make Congress's intent in the Accountability Act
clearer and make the disciplinary authorities in 38 U.S.C.
Sec. 714 usable so VA can keep employees accountable. Section
4(a) would make the following modifications to 38 U.S.C.
Sec. 714:
Section 714(a) would be modified by giving the VA
Secretary authority to discipline covered individuals
who the Secretary determines, as supported by
substantial evidence, warrant such action because of
misconduct or poor performance; codifying five
factors\18\ VA must exclusively consider when deciding
whether to discipline covered individuals; and adding
language specifying the VA Secretary must review a
proposing disciplinary authority's disciplinary
decision using a substantial evidence test.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\The five factors are (1) the nature and seriousness of the
offense, and its relation to the covered individual's duties, position,
and responsibilities, including whether the offense was intentional or
technical or inadvertent, or was committed maliciously or for gain, or
was frequently repeated; (2) the covered individual's job level and
type of employment, including supervisory or fiduciary role, and
prominence of the position; (3) the covered individual's past
disciplinary record; (4) the covered individual's past work record,
including length of service, performance on the job, ability to get
along with fellow workers, and dependability; and (5) mitigating
circumstances surrounding the offense such as unusual job tensions,
personality problems, mental impairment, harassment, or bad faith,
malice, or provocation on the part of others involved in the matter.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 714(c) would be modified by striking
paragraph (1)(D), which specifies Section 714(c)
supersedes inconsistent collective bargaining
agreements; and inserting language giving the Secretary
the ability to remove, demote, or suspend a covered
individual without first placing the individual on a
performance improvement plan.
Section 714(d) would be modified by adding language
preventing, absent a constitutional issue,
administrative judges or the MSPB from reviewing
challenges to penalties imposed against covered
individuals; specifying courts, absent a constitutional
issue, may not review challenges to penalties imposed
against covered individuals or mitigate such penalties;
and striking Section 714(d)(10), which states if
employees subject to a collective bargaining agreement
choose to grieve actions taken under Section 714(d)
through procedures provided in the bargaining
agreement, Section 714(c) and (d) procedures apply.
Section 714(h) would be redesignated as Section
714(j).
Section 714(i) would be added to specify Section 714
procedures supersede collective bargaining agreements
if the agreements are inconsistent with Section 714 and
Section 714(i), Application, specifying Section 714 can
be applied to actions taken against covered individuals
starting on the date the Accountability Act was
enacted, would be added after Section 714(g).
Section 714(j), as redesignated by Section 4(a)(4),
would be modified by making the following changes to
the covered individual definition: specifying covered
individuals include individuals appointed pursuant to
Title 38, Title 5, and hybrid employees appointed
pursuant to Title 38 Sec. 7401; specifying a
supervisors or management officials as defined in Title
5 7103(a) are not covered individuals.
Section 4(b) would amend Title 38 U.S.C.
Sec. 7403(f)(3) by adding a subsection (B) stating
matters involving covered individuals, as defined in
Section 712 or Section 714, will be resolved at the
Secretary's sole discretion under Section 712, Section
714, or Title 5 as though such individuals had been
appointed under that title.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, existing law in which no change
is proposed is shown in roman):
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
TITLE 38, UNITED STATES CODE
* * * * * * *
PART I--GENERAL PROVISIONS
* * * * * * *
CHAPTER 7--EMPLOYEES
SUBCHAPTER I--GENERAL EMPLOYEE MATTERS
Sec.
* * * * * * *
712. Supervisors: removal, demotion, or suspension based on performance
or misconduct.
* * * * * * *
SUBCHAPTER I--GENERAL EMPLOYEE MATTERS
* * * * * * *
Sec. 712. Supervisors: removal, demotion, or suspension based on
performance or misconduct
(a) In General.--The Secretary may remove from civil service,
demote, or suspend a covered individual who is an employee of
the Department if the Secretary determines by substantial
evidence that the performance or misconduct of the covered
individual warrants such action.
(b) Rights and Procedures.--(1)(A) When making an initial
decision under subsection (a) with respect to determining
whether a covered individual should be removed, demoted, or
suspended, the deciding employee of the Department shall
exclusively apply the following factors:
(i) The nature and seriousness of the offense, and
its relation to the covered individual's duties,
position, and responsibilities, including whether the
offense was intentional or technical or inadvertent, or
was committed maliciously or for gain, or was
frequently repeated.
(ii) The covered individual's job level and type of
employment, including supervisory or fiduciary role,
and prominence of the position.
(B) The Secretary shall review the initial decision and
uphold such decision if it is supported by substantial
evidence.
(2) A covered individual subject to an action under
subsection (a) is entitled to--
(A) advance notice of the action and a file
containing all evidence in support of the proposed
action;
(B) be represented by an attorney or other
representative of the covered individual's choice; and
(C) grieve the action in accordance with an internal
grievance process that the Secretary, in consultation
with the Assistant Secretary for Accountability and
Whistleblower Protection, shall establish for purposes
of this subsection.
(3) A final decision by the Secretary under paragraph (1)(B)
that is not grieved, and a grievance decision under paragraph
(2)(C), shall be final and conclusive.
(4) The procedures under chapter 43 of title 5 shall not
apply to a removal, demotion, or suspension under this section,
and the Secretary may carry out such a removal, demotion, or
suspension without first placing a covered individual on a
performance improvement plan.
(c) Timing.--(A) The aggregate period for notice, response,
and final decision by the Secretary of an action under this
section may not exceed 15 business days.
(B) The period for the response of a covered individual to a
notice under subsection (b)(2)(A) shall be 7 business days.
(C) The final decision by the Secretary under subsection
(b)(1)(B) shall--
(i) be issued not later than 15 business days after
notice is provided under subsection (b)(2)(A); and
(ii) be in writing and shall include the specific
reasons for the decision.
(D) The Secretary shall ensure that the grievance process
established under paragraph (2)(C) takes fewer than 21 days
after the final decision.
(d) Judicial Review.--(1) A covered individual adversely
affected by a final decision u
Minority Views
This legislation presents significant due process issues
and constitutional concerns. In its written testimony for the
July 12, 2023, Oversight & Investigations Subcommittee
legislative hearing, where H.R. 4278 was on the agenda, the
Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) stated:
We are confident that the authorities currently available
to the VA are sufficient to hold employees accountable for
misconduct and poor performance. We do not believe any
legislation is necessary right now to ensure accountability. VA
has legal concerns regarding some of the language in the draft
bill. Specifically, VA is concerned this language will continue
to be the subject of extensive litigation and constitutional
challenges, creating uncertainty and potentially leading to a
continued pattern of overturned disciplinary actions.
If this legislation becomes law, it will be challenged in
the courts, making VA no better off than it has been in its
attempts to utilize the authorities provided under the VA
Accountability and Whistleblower Protection Act of 2017 (P.L.
115-41). At the same time, VA--particularly, its healthcare
system--is struggling with widespread post-pandemic
understaffing, while rapidly trying to staff up to implement
the landmark Honoring Our PACT Act (P.L. 117-168). Veterans
would be much better served if the Committee instead focused on
legislation that would help fill VA staff vacancies, rather
than create more of them.
VA officials contend there is much better predictability
and lower likelihood of disciplinary actions being mitigated or
overturned when they exercise existing Title 5 disciplinary
authorities, as there are decades of case law that stakeholders
and the courts are familiar with. Furthermore, contrary to
claims made by the Majority, H.R. 4278 would do very little to
expedite processes for addressing employee misconduct at VA.
Compared to existing authorities under Title 5 and Title 38,
this bill does not make significant adjustments to the number
of days allowed for each step of the process--from the point at
which a disciplinary action is proposed by the deciding
official until it is finalized. Properly and thoroughly
investigating misconduct takes much longer than proposing and
finalizing disciplinary actions.
Among the most problematic provisions of H.R. 4278 are
those that would strip VA civil servants of due process rights
that are afforded to all other federal employees and upend
existing collective bargaining agreements. This legislation
would have a chilling effect on VA recruitment and retention--
especially for supervisors and senior executives, as H.R. 4278
is particularly harsh in its treatment of these two categories
of employees. In addition, there is significant risk that
implementing this legislation will be quite costly, as it is
likely to be challenged, leading to VA incurring costs related
to litigation and the potential award of monetary damages. It
is therefore concerning that Rep. Mrvan's amendment to examine
the costs of implementing P.L. 115-41 was not adopted, as it
would have provided the committee valuable insight about the
potential cost of H.R. 4278.
It is also perplexing that all but one member of the
Majority voted against the amendment offered by Rep. Pappas,
which would have improved management training for VA
supervisors, management officials, and senior executives and
improved their understanding of the disciplinary options and
procedures available to address poor performance and
misconduct. Specifically, the amendment would have required VA
to develop mandatory training focusing on areas such as
developing and discussing relevant performance goals and
objectives with employees; communicating and discussing
employees' progress relative to the performance goals and
objectives; conducting performance appraisals; mentoring and
motivating employees; and effectively managing employees with
unacceptable performance. Congress cannot simply strip away
constitutional rights as a means of arriving at accountability.
Rather, Congress must provide VA with the resources and tools
to develop and support effective management.
Mark Takano,
Ranking Member.
[all]