Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 7322]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on the Judiciary, to whom was referred the
bill (H.R. 7322) to amend the Immigration and Nationality Act
with respect to enforcement by an attorney general of a State,
having considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 3
Background and Need for the Legislation.......................... 3
Hearings......................................................... 10
Committee Consideration.......................................... 11
Committee Votes.................................................. 11
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 15
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures........................ 15
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate........................ 15
Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects.......................... 16
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 16
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 16
Advisory on Earmarks............................................. 16
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 16
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 16
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 17
Section-by-Section Analysis...................................... 17
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 17
Dissenting Views................................................. 94
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Standing Up to the Executive branch
for Immigration Enforcement Act of 2024'' or the ``SUE for Immigration
Enforcement Act of 2024''.
SEC. 2. ENFORCEMENT BY ATTORNEY GENERAL OF A STATE.
(a) Inspection of Applicants for Admission.--Section 235(b) of the
Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1225(b)) is amended--
(1) by redesignating paragraph (3) as paragraph (4); and
(2) by inserting after paragraph (2) the following:
``(3) Enforcement by attorney general of a state.--The
attorney general of a State, or other authorized State officer,
alleging a violation of the detention and removal requirements
under paragraphs (1) or (2) that harms such State or its
residents shall have standing to bring an action against the
Secretary of Homeland Security on behalf of such State or the
residents of such State in an appropriate district court of the
United States to obtain appropriate injunctive relief. The
court shall advance on the docket and expedite the disposition
of a civil action filed under this paragraph to the greatest
extent practicable. For purposes of this paragraph, a State or
its residents shall be considered to have been harmed if the
State or its residents experience harm, including financial
harm in excess of $100.''.
(b) Apprehension and Detention of Aliens.--Section 236 of the
Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1226) is amended--
(1) in subsection (e)--
(A) by striking ``or release''; and
(B) by striking ``grant, revocation, or denial'' and
insert ``revocation or denial''; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
``(f) Enforcement by Attorney General of a State.--The attorney
general of a State, or other authorized State officer, alleging an
action or decision by the Attorney General or Secretary of Homeland
Security under this section to release any alien or grant bond or
parole to any alien that harms such State or its residents shall have
standing to bring an action against the Attorney General or Secretary
of Homeland Security on behalf of such State or the residents of such
State in an appropriate district court of the United States to obtain
appropriate injunctive relief. The court shall advance on the docket
and expedite the disposition of a civil action filed under this
subsection to the greatest extent practicable. For purposes of this
subsection, a State or its residents shall be considered to have been
harmed if the State or its residents experience harm, including
financial harm in excess of $100.''.
(c) Penalties.--Section 243 of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8
U.S.C. 1253) is amended by adding at the end the following:
``(e) Enforcement by Attorney General of a State.--The attorney
general of a State, or other authorized State officer, alleging a
violation of the requirement to discontinue granting visas to citizens,
subjects, nationals, and residents as described in subsection (d) that
harms such State or its residents shall have standing to bring an
action against the Secretary of State on behalf of such State or the
residents of such State in an appropriate district court of the United
States to obtain appropriate injunctive relief. The court shall advance
on the docket and expedite the disposition of a civil action filed
under this subsection to the greatest extent practicable. For purposes
of this subsection, a State or its residents shall be considered to
have been harmed if the State or its residents experience harm,
including financial harm in excess of $100.''.
(d) Certain Classes of Aliens.--Section 212(d)(5) of the Immigration
and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1182(d)(5)) is amended--
(1) by striking ``Attorney General'' each place it appears
and inserting ``Secretary of Homeland Security''; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
``(C) The attorney general of a State, or other authorized State
officer, alleging a violation of the limitation under subparagraph (A)
that parole solely be granted on a case-by-case basis and solely for
urgent humanitarian reasons or a significant public benefit, that harms
such State or its residents shall have standing to bring an action
against the Secretary of Homeland Security on behalf of such State or
the residents of such State in an appropriate district court of the
United States to obtain appropriate injunctive relief. The court shall
advance on the docket and expedite the disposition of a civil action
filed under this subparagraph to the greatest extent practicable. For
purposes of this subparagraph, a State or its residents shall be
considered to have been harmed if the State or its residents experience
harm, including financial harm in excess of $100.''.
(e) Detention.--Section 241(a)(2) of the Immigration and Nationality
Act (8 U.S.C. 1231(a)(2)) is amended--
(1) by striking ``During the removal period,'' and inserting
the following:
``(A) In general.--During the removal period,''; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
``(B) Enforcement by attorney general of a state.--
The attorney general of a State, or other authorized
State officer, alleging a violation of the detention
requirement under subparagraph (A) that harms such
State or its residents shall have standing to bring an
action against the Secretary of Homeland Security on
behalf of such State or the residents of such State in
an appropriate district court of the United States to
obtain appropriate injunctive relief. The court shall
advance on the docket and expedite the disposition of a
civil action filed under this subparagraph to the
greatest extent practicable. For purposes of this
subparagraph, a State or its residents shall be
considered to have been harmed if the State or its
residents experience harm, including financial harm in
excess of $100.''.
(f) Limit on Injunctive Relief.--Section 242(f) of the Immigration
and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1252(f)) is amended by adding at the end
following:
``(3) Certain actions.--Paragraph (1) shall not apply to an
action brought pursuant to section 235(b)(3), subsections (e)
or (f) of section 236, or section 241(a)(2)(B).''.
Purpose and Summary
H.R. 7322, the Standing Up to the Executive branch for
Immigration Enforcement Act, or the SUE for Immigration
Enforcement Act, introduced by Rep. Dan Bishop (R-NC), would
allow state attorneys general, or other authorized state
officials, to bring a civil action against the Department of
Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary, Secretary of State, or
Attorney General for violations of certain immigration laws
that harm the state or its residents. The bill allows such
officials to bring a civil suit for violations of the case-by-
case parole limitation under Immigration and Nationality Act
(INA) Sec. 212(d)(5), the detention and removal requirements
under INA Sec. 235, the parole and release limitations under
INA Sec. 236, the detention requirements under INA
Sec. 241(a)(2), and the visa sanctions requirements under INA
Sec. 243. It also expedites the disposition of such civil
actions.
Background and Need for the Legislation
With the unprecedented border crisis, President Biden and
Secretary Mayorkas have abandoned states and localities that
bear the brunt of the Administration's open-borders policies.
In Denver, Colorado, for example, Democrat Mayor Mike Johnston
warned the city is ``hitting a breaking point at which there's
just not enough . . . work or housing in the city to support
this ongoing volume, not to mention the impact on city
budgets.''\1\ Meanwhile, according to the Texas Attorney
General, the state of Texas paid between $62 million and $90
million per year to cover illegal aliens under its Emergency
Medicaid program.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Alayna Alvarez, Denver's migrant crisis hits a ``breaking
point,'' Axios (Jan. 3, 2024), https://www.axios.com/local/denver/2024/
01/03/migrant-crisis-breaking-point-mike-johnston.
\2\Press Release, Att'y Gen. of Texas, AG Paxton: Illegal
Immigration Costs Texas Taxpayers Over $850 Million Each Year (Mar. 31,
2021), https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/news/releases/ag-paxton-
illegal-immigration-costs-texas-taxpayers-over-850-million-each-year.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While states have been forced to act alone to address the
crisis, the Biden Administration has thwarted them every step
of the way--such as in Texas, where the Administration
``ask[ed] the Supreme Court to allow Border Patrol agents to
cut razor wire that Texas installed on the U.S.-Mexico border,
while a lawsuit over the wire continues.''\3\ At the same time,
following a Supreme Court decision from June 2023, states may
struggle to establish standing to sue to hold Administration
officials accountable for the Administration's violations of
immigration law.\4\ This legislation ensures that states have
standing to bring civil actions against open-borders federal
officials who refuse to enforce immigration law or violate it
to the detriment of Americans.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Biden administration asks Supreme Court to allow border agents
to cut razor wire installed by Texas, Associated Press (Jan. 2, 2024,
5:03 PM), https://apnews.com/article/supreme-court-texas-immigration-
border-patrol-5aa573c05bae06693572826e0154f956.
\4\See United States v. Texas, 599 U.S. 670 (2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Biden Administration's Open-Borders Policies
The Biden Administration has dismantled any semblance of
border security and interior immigration enforcement. Despite
the Administration's rampant violations of the law, states
often are left powerless to challenge them in court. In United
States v. Texas, Texas and Louisiana challenged DHS Secretary
Mayorkas's immigration ``enforcement'' guidelines, but the
Supreme Court held that the states ``lack[ed] Article III
standing to bring [their] suit.''\5\ In the Court's opinion,
Justice Kavanaugh wrote:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\United States v. Texas, 599 U.S. 670, 674 (2023).
The States have not cited any precedent, history, or
tradition of courts ordering the Executive Branch to
change its arrest or prosecution policies so that the
Executive Branch makes more arrests or initiates more
prosecutions. On the contrary, this Court has
previously ruled that a plaintiff lacks standing to
bring such a suit.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Id. at 677.
Under the Trump Administration, meanwhile, far-left groups
had no trouble challenging pro-security and pro-enforcement
policies and regulations. From Remain in Mexico,\7\ to asylum
reforms,\8\ to policy changes at U.S. Citizenship and
Immigration Services,\9\ to visa policies,\10\ leftist
organizations managed, through the courts, to slow down,
undermine, or even derail significant Trump-era policies that
would have strengthened the U.S. immigration system. The
Senate's ``border security'' deal announced in February 2024
would have made it even more difficult for states to challenge
left-wing abuse of immigration authorities, as it limited
judicial review of the bill's new immigration provisions solely
to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Maria Sacchetti, Federal judge blocks Trump administration
program forcing asylum seekers to remain in Mexico while awaiting court
hearings, Wash. Post (Apr. 9, 2019, 6:04 AM), https://
www.washingtonpost.com/immigration/federal-judge-blocks-trump-
administration-program-forcing-asylum-seekers-to-remain-in-mexico-
while-awaiting-court-hearings/2019/04/08/68e96048-5a42-11e9-a00e-
050dc7b82693_story.html.
\8\Daniella Silva, Federal appeals court rules against Trump in two
major immigration cases, NBC News (Feb. 28, 2020, 1:27 PM), https://
www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/federal-appeals-court-rules-against-trump-
two-major-immigration-cases-n1145141.
\9\Josh Gerstein, Judge permanently blocks another Trump
immigration policy, Politico (Feb. 6, 2020, 5:31 PM), https://
www.politico.com/news/2020/02/06/judge-blocks-another-trump-
immigration-policy-111705.
\10\Stuart Anderson, Judge Rules Against Trump's H-1B Visa Ban:
President Is Not A Monarch, Forbes (Oct. 2, 2020, 12:27 AM), https://
www.forbes.com/sites/stuartanderson/2020/10/02/judge-rules-against-
trumps-h-1b-visa-ban-president-is-not-a-monarch/?sh=2ebb49c251cc.
\11\Emergency National Security Supplemental Appropriations Act,
2024, available at https://www.appropriations.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/
emergency_national_security_supplemental_
bill_text.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This bill ensures that a Secretary of State's, DHS
Secretary's, or Attorney General's violations of immigration
law cannot go unchallenged by state attorneys general. H.R.
7322 follows the roadmap outlined in United States v. Texas by
Justice Kavanaugh, who noted that ``the standing analysis might
differ when Congress elevates de facto injuries to the status
of legally cognizable injuries redressable by a federal
court.''\12\ Here, the bill explicitly authorizes states to
bring lawsuits regarding five areas of the law that the Biden
Administration has most frequently abused: parole under INA
Sec. 212(d)(5), detention and removal under INA Sec. 235,
parole and release under INA Sec. 236, detention requirements
pending removal under INA Sec. 241(a)(2), and visa sanctions
under INA Sec. 243.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\United States v. Texas, 599 U.S. at 681-82.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
MASS PAROLE UNDER INA Sec. 212(D)(5)
The Biden Administration has created new categorical parole
programs that turn the parole statute on its head. Despite the
parole statute requiring case-by-case determinations to grant
the benefit, in late 2022 and early 2023, the Administration
created categorical parole programs that allow up to 30,000
aliens per month from Haiti, Venezuela, Nicaragua, and Cuba to
enter the U.S. through ports of entry and remain in the
U.S.\13\ In addition, on April 27, 2023, the Administration
announced the creation of categorical parole programs for
family members of nationals of El Salvador, Guatemala,
Honduras, and Colombia.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Servs., Processes for Cubans,
Haitians, Nicaraguans, and Venezuelans, U.S. Dep't of Homeland Security
(last accessed Feb. 16, 2023), https://www.uscis.gov/CHNV.
\14\Fact Sheet: U.S. Government Announces Sweeping New Actions to
Manage Regional Migration, U.S. Dep't of State (Apr. 27, 2023), https:/
/www.state.gov/u-s-government-announces-sweeping-new-actions-to-manage-
regional-migration/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
According to press reports, the Biden Administration has
used these unlawful categorical parole programs to release into
the United States well over half a million aliens.\15\
Specifically, DHS has paroled 340,000 aliens through the Cuban,
Haitian, Nicaraguan, and Venezuelan parole program; 176,000
aliens through the ``Uniting for Ukraine'' parole policy;
77,000 through the Afghan parole program; and 3,600 through
``family reunification programs.''\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Camilo Montoya-Galvez, Biden administration has admitted more
than 1 million migrants into U.S. under parole policy Congress is
considering restricting, CBS News (Jan. 22, 2024), https://
www.cbsnews.com/news/immigration-parole-biden-administration-1-million-
migrants/.
\16\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Last year, Secretary Mayorkas boasted that bringing illegal
aliens into the United States via routes such as parole is
``working'' to help secure the border.\17\ On March 12, 2023,
however, more than 1,000 illegal aliens from Venezuela, one of
the categorical parole program countries, rushed and nearly
breached the El Paso Port of Entry.\18\ In addition, in late
April 2023, nearly 21,000 Venezuelan nationals crossed
illegally into the Rio Grande Valley Border Patrol Sector in
just 12 days.\19\ Another 1,000-person caravan, largely made up
of Venezuelan nationals, crossed from Guatemala into Mexico
during the weekend of July 15-16, 2023, en route to the
southwest U.S. border.\20\ In October 2023, ``Venezuelans
passed Mexicans as the largest single nationality attempting to
cross the southern border without visas,'' providing even
further proof that the Administration's illegal categorical
parole programs have only supercharged illegal immigration.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\Unlawful Southwest Border Crossings Plummet Under New Border
Enforcement Measures, U.S. Dep't of Homeland Security (Jan. 25, 2023),
https://www.dhs.gov/news/2023/01/25/unlawful-southwest-border-
crossings-plummet-under-new-border-enforcement-measures.
\18\Greg Wehner, Border Crisis: Over 1,000 migrants rush bridge
linking Mexico to U.S. in El Paso, Texas, Fox News (Mar. 12, 2023),
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/border-crisis-migrants-rush-bridge-
linking-mexico-u-s-el-paso-texas-video.
\19\Bob Price and Randy Clark, Exclusive: 21K Venezuelan migrants
in 12 days crossed border into one Texas sector, Breitbart (Apr. 30,
2023), https://www.breitbart.com/border/2023/04/30/exclusive-21k-
venezuelan-migrants-in-12-days-crossed-border-into-one-texas-sector/.
\20\Migrant Caravan Heads Toward U.S. Border (Fox News television
broadcast July 17, 2023), https://www.foxnews.com/video/6331338079112.
\21\Stef W. Kight, Venezuelans surpass Mexicans crossing U.S.
border, Axios (Oct. 25, 2023), https://www.axios.com/2023/10/25/
venezuelans-surpass-mexicans-migrants-southern-border-biden.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
FAILURE TO DETAIN UNDER INA Sec. 235
Like its treatment of the parole statute, the Biden
Administration has ignored and continually violated detention
mandates. The INA mandates detention for aliens arriving at the
border who express an intent to apply for asylum due to a fear
of persecution.\22\ The Supreme Court has emphasized that the
mandatory detention requirements under Sec. 235 ``mandate[s]
detention of aliens throughout the completion of applicable
proceedings and not just until the moment those proceedings
begin.''\23\ A federal judge in Florida agreed, holding,
```shall be detained' means what it says and that is a
mandatory requirement.''\24\ The judge described how the Biden
Administration's failure to detain aliens has:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\See 8 U.S.C. Sec. 1225(b)(1)(B)(ii) (``If the officer
determines at the time of the interview that an alien has a credible
fear of persecution (within the meaning of clause (v)), the alien shall
be detained for further consideration of the application for
asylum.''); 8 U.S.C. Sec. 1225(b)(1)(B)(iii)(IV) (``Any alien subject
to the procedures under this clause shall be detained pending a final
determination of credible fear of persecution and, if found not to have
such a fear, until removed.''); 8 U.S.C. Sec. 1225(b)(2)(A) (``. . .
the alien shall be detained for a proceeding under section 1229a of
this title'').
\23\See Jennings v. Rodriguez, 583 U.S. 281, 302 (2018).
\24\Florida v. United States, 660 F. Supp. 3d 1239, 1273 (N.D. Fla.
2023).
[E]ffectively turned the Southwest Border into a
meaningless line in the sand and little more than a
speedbump for aliens flooding into the country by
prioritizing ``alternatives to detention'' over actual
detention and by releasing more than a million aliens
into the country--on ``parole'' or pursuant to the
exercise of ``prosecutorial discretion'' under a wholly
inapplicable statute--without even initiating removal
proceedings.\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\Id. at 1249.
Despite such clear detention requirements, Secretary
Mayorkas has routinely released illegal aliens into the United
States.\26\ Beginning in March 2021, Border Patrol authorized
the release of aliens arriving at the southwest border without
first serving them with a Notice to Appear (NTA) and placing
them in removal proceedings, as the statute requires.\27\
Instead, the Biden Administration issued aliens a Notice to
Report, with instructions to report to a local ICE office to be
served with an NTA.\28\ Those offices, however, are backlogged
for years, with New York City's ICE office at 99 percent
capacity through December 2033.\29\ Offices in Miramar,
Florida, were mostly booked through January 2029; in Chicago,
through January 2028; and in Dallas, through January 2027.\30\
Similarly, CBP also adopted a ``Parole+ATD'' policy, in which
aliens were released into the United States through parole and
``alternatives to detention,'' which could have included ankle
monitoring or an alien ``periodically `checking in' with ICE
remotely through a smartphone app or over the telephone.''\31\
Since January 2021, the Administration has released millions of
illegal aliens into the United States, with at least 3,095,577
having ``no confirmed departure from the United States as of
September 30, 2023.''\32\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\See 8 U.S.C. Sec. 1225(b)(1)(B)(ii); see also 8 C.F.R.
Sec. 1239.1(a) (``Every removal proceeding conducted under [8 U.S.C.
Sec. 1229a] to determine the deportability or inadmissibility of an
alien is commenced by the filing of a notice to appear with the
immigration court.'').
\27\Florida, 660 F. Supp. 3d at 1250, 1255-56.
\28\Id.
\29\Top 10 Parole/NTR Appointment Backlog Locations Chart provided
to H. Comm. on the Judiciary Staff by U.S. Immigr. and Customs Enf't
(Jan. 31, 2024) (on file with Comm.).
\30\Id.
\31\Florida, 660 F. Supp. 3d at 1259.
\32\See H. Comm. on the Judiciary, Interim Staff Rep., New Data
Reveal Worsening Magnitude of the Biden Border Crisis and Lack of
Interior Immigr. Enf't, at 2-3 (Jan. 18, 2024), https://
judiciary.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/republicans-judiciary.house.gov/
files/evo-media-document/2024-01-18-new-data-reveal-worsening-
magnitude-of-the-biden-border-crisis-and-lack-of-interior-immigration-
enforcement.pdf?_gl=1*um0tzz*_ga*MTEwNTc0NDU4Ni4xNjc1ODY1NjU0*_ga_
1818ZEQW81*MTcwNzQxNDIxNS4xMy4xLjE3MDc0MTU2NzQuMC4wLjA [hereinafter
Jan. Interim Staff Rep.].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although the Supreme Court has previously considered a
portion of the statute--INA Sec. 235(b)(2)(C)--and held that
``the contiguous-territory return authority'' (Migrant
Protection Protocols) was not mandatory, the Court emphasized
that it did not ``resolve the parties' arguments regarding
whether [Sec. ] [235](b)(2)(A) must be read in light of
traditional principles of law enforcement discretion, and
whether the Government is lawfully exercising its parole
authorities pursuant to [Sec. Sec. ] [212](d)(5) and
[236](a).''\33\ Instead, the Court ``merely [held] that
[Sec. ][235](b)(2)(C) means what it says: `may' means `may,'
and the INA itself does not require the Secretary to continue
exercising his discretionary authority under these
circumstances.''\34\ Therefore, challenges can still be made to
an Administration's violation of the detention and removal
requirements under Sec. 235.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\33\Biden v. Texas, 597 U.S. 785, 807 (2022).
\34\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
MASS RELEASE AND PAROLE UNDER INA Sec. 236
The Biden Administration has also abused the parole and
release provisions under INA Sec. 236 to mass release aliens
into the United States. That provision contemplates an alien's
potential parole or release after having been arrested ``[o]n a
warrant issued by the [DHS Secretary].''\35\ The Supreme Court
has highlighted that Sec. 236 ``applies to aliens already
present in the United States'' and is distinct from the
mandatory detention provisions for applicants for admission
(i.e., illegal aliens who arrive at the border).\36\
Nonetheless, the Biden Administration has used Sec. 236 to
release into the United States illegal aliens arriving at the
southwest border.\37\ A federal judge held that DHS violated
Sec. 236 by releasing such aliens instead of detaining them as
required under Sec. 235.\38\ The judge noted the Biden
Administration's ``administrative sophistry,'' in which it
``us[ed] an `arrest' warrant as [a] de facto release
warrant.''\39\ On February 13, 2024,
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6)(A) of House rule XIII,
the following hearing was used to develop H.R. 7322: ``The
Border Crisis: Is the Law Being Faithfully Executed?'' a
hearing held on June 7, 2023, before the Subcommittee on
Immigration Integrity, Security, and Enforcement of the
Committee on the Judiciary. The Subcommittee heard testimony
from the following witnesses:
Chad Wolf, Former Acting Secretary, U.S.
Department of Homeland Security; Executive Director and
Chief Strategy Officer, America First Policy Institute;
Joseph Edlow, Former Acting Director, U.S.
Citizenship and Immigration Services; Founder, the
Edlow Group;
Steven G. Bradbury, Distinguished Fellow,
Executive Vice President's Office, The Heritage
Foundation; and
Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, Policy Director, The
American Immigration Council.
The hearing addressed how the Biden Administration has
implemented policies that not only are designed to encourage
illegal immigration but also violate immigration law as set by
Congress.
Committee Consideration
On February 15, 2024, the Committee met in open session and
order the bill, H.R. 7322, favorably reported with an amendment
in the nature of a substitute, by a roll call vote of 19 to 11,
a quorum being present.
Committee Votes
In compliance with clause 3(b) of House rule XIII, the
following roll call votes occurred during the Committee's
consideration of H.R. 7322:
1. Vote on Amendment #1 to H.R. 7322 ANS offered by Mr.
Nadler--failed 12 ayes to 17 nays.
2. Vote on Amendment #2 to H.R. 7322 ANS offered by Ms.
Jayapal--failed 10 ayes to 18 nays.
3. Vote on favorably reporting H.R. 7322, as amended--
passed 19 ayes to 11 nays.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Committee Oversight Findings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee advises that the findings and recommendations of the
Committee, based on oversight activities under clause 2(b)(1)
of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives, are
incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures
Clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives does not apply where a cost estimate and
comparison prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office under section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974 has been timely submitted prior to filing of the report
and is included in the report. Such a cost estimate is included
in this report.
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate
With respect to the requirement of clause 3(c)(3) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and section
402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the Committee has
received the enclosed cost estimate for H.R. 7322 from the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
H.R. 7322 would grant standing to state governments to
bring action against the federal government in a federal
district court for the purpose of seeking injunctive relief
from immigration enforcement decisions that have harmed the
state or its residents.
CBO expects that enacting H.R. 7322 could result in a small
increase in the number of suits filed in federal courts related
to immigration enforcement. The federal judiciary charges fees
to file suit in a district court. Those fees are recorded as
revenues and can be spent by the judiciary without further
appropriation. Because the expected increase in the number of
lawsuits is small, CBO estimates that enacting H.R. 7322 would
increase revenues and the associated direct spending by less
than $500,000 over the 2024-2034 period. The net decrease in
the deficit would be negligible.
Lawsuits brought by states under H.R. 7322 could result in
injunctive relief that affects the federal budget. For example,
injunctive relief could change the number or immigration status
of people residing in the United States, which would affect
their receipt of federal benefits. However, CBO has no basis to
estimate the direction or magnitude of those effects because we
cannot predict the number or content of future lawsuits that
would occur under the legislation, the decisions made by
federal agencies, or the outcomes of future litigation.
The CBO staff contacts for this estimate are David Rafferty
and Kevin Laden. The estimate was reviewed by H. Samuel
Papenfuss, Deputy Director of Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(d)(1) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section
402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII, no provision
of H.R. 7322 establishes or reauthorizes a program of the
federal government known to be duplicative of another federal
program.
Performance Goals and Objectives
The Committee states that pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of
House rule XIII, H.R. 7322 would allow state attorneys general,
or other authorized state officials, to bring a civil action
against the DHS Secretary, Secretary of State, or Attorney
General for violations of certain immigration laws that harm
the state or its residents.
Advisory on Earmarks
In accordance with clause 9 of House rule XXI, H.R. 7322
does not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in clauses
9(d), 9(e), or 9(f) of House Rule XXI.
Federal Mandates Statement
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act (Pub. L. 104-
1).
Section-by-Section Analysis
Sec. 1. Short title. The ``Standing Up to the Executive
branch for Immigration Enforcement Act,'' or the ``SUE for
Immigration Enforcement Act.''
Sec. 2. Enforcement by an Attorney General of a State. This
section authorizes state attorneys general to bring a civil
action against the DHS Secretary, Secretary of State, or
Attorney General for violations of certain immigration laws
that harm the state or its residents. The bill allows such
officials to bring a civil suit for violations of the case-by-
case parole limitation under Immigration and Nationality Act
(INA) Sec. 212(d)(5), the detention and removal requirements
under INA Sec. 235, the parole and release limitations under
INA Sec. 236, the detention requirements under INA
Sec. 241(a)(2), and the visa sanctions requirements under INA
Sec. 243. It also expedites the disposition of such civil
actions.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
IMMIGRATION AND NATIONALITY ACT
* * * * * * *
TITLE II--IMMIGRATION
* * * * * * *
Chapter 2--Qualifications for Admission of Aliens; Travel Control of
Citizens and Aliens
* * * * * * *
general classes of aliens ineligible to receive visas and ineligible
for admission; waivers of inadmissibility
Sec. 212. (a) Classes of Aliens Ineligible for Visas or
Admission.--Except as otherwise provided in this Act, aliens
who are inadmissible under the following paragraphs are
ineligible to receive visas and ineligible to be admitted to
the United States:
(1) Health-related grounds.--
(A) In general.--Any alien--
(i) who is determined (in accordance
with regulations prescribed by the
Secretary of Health and Human Services)
to have a communicable disease of
public health significance;
(ii) except as provided in
subparagraph (C), who seeks admission
as an immigrant, or who seeks
adjustment of status to the status of
an alien lawfully admitted for
permanent residence, and who has failed
to present documentation of having
received vaccination against vaccine-
preventable diseases, which shall
include at least the following
diseases: mumps, measles, rubella,
polio, tetanus and diphtheria toxoids,
pertussis, influenza type B and
hepatitis B, and any other vaccinations
against vaccine-preventable diseases
recommended by the Advisory Committee
for Immunization Practices,
(iii) who is determined (in
accordance with regulations prescribed
by the Secretary of Health and Human
Services in consultation with the
Attorney General)--
(I) to have a physical or
mental disorder and behavior
associated with the disorder
that may pose, or has posed, a
threat to the property, safety,
or welfare of the alien or
others, or
(II) to have had a physical
or mental disorder and a
history of behavior associated
with the disorder, which
behavior has posed a threat to
the property, safety, or
welfare of the alien or others
and which behavior is likely to
recur or to lead to other
harmful behavior, or
(iv) who is determined (in accordance
with regulations prescribed by the
Secretary of Health and Human Services)
to be a drug abuser or addict,
is inadmissibility.
(B) Waiver authorized.--For provision
authorizing waiver of certain clauses of
subparagraph (A), see subsection (g).
(C) Exception from immunization requirement
for adopted children 10 years of age or
younger.--Clause (ii) of subparagraph (A) shall
not apply to a child who--
(i) is 10 years of age or younger,
(ii) is described in subparagraph (F)
or (G) of section 101(b)(1); and
(iii) is seeking an immigrant visa as
an immediate relative under section
201(b),
if, prior to the admission of the child, an
adoptive parent or prospective adoptive parent
of the child, who has sponsored the child for
admission as an immediate relative, has
executed an affidavit stating that the parent
is aware of the provisions of subparagraph
(A)(ii) and will ensure that, within 30 days of
the child's admission, or at the earliest time
that is medically appropriate, the child will
receive the vaccinations identified in such
subparagraph.
(2) Criminal and related grounds.--
(A) Conviction of certain crimes.--
(i) In general.--Except as provided
in clause (ii), any alien convicted of,
or who admits having committed, or who
admits committing acts which constitute
the essential elements of--
(I) a crime involving moral
turpitude (other than a purely
political offense) or an
attempt or conspiracy to commit
such a crime, or
(II) a violation of (or a
conspiracy or attempt to
violate) any law or regulation
of a State, the United States,
or a foreign country relating
to a controlled substance (as
defined in section 102 of the
Controlled Substances Act (21
U.S.C. 802)),
is inadmissible.
(ii) Exception.--Clause (i)(I) shall
not apply to an alien who committed
only one crime if--
(I) the crime was committed
when the alien was under 18
years of age, and the crime was
committed (and the alien
released from any confinement
to a prison or correctional
institution imposed for the
crime) more than 5 years before
the date of application for a
visa or other documentation and
the date of application for
admission to the United States,
or
(II) the maximum penalty
possible for the crime of which
the alien was convicted (or
which the alien admits having
committed or of which the acts
that the alien admits having
committed constituted the
essential elements) did not
exceed imprisonment for one
year and, if the alien was
convicted of such crime, the
alien was not sentenced to a
term of imprisonment in excess
of 6 months (regardless of the
extent to which the sentence
was ultimately executed).
(B) Multiple criminal convictions.--Any alien
convicted of 2 or more offenses (other than
purely political offenses), regardless of
whether the conviction was in a single trial or
whether the offenses arose from a single scheme
of misconduct and regardless of whether the
offenses involved moral turpitude, for which
the aggregate sentences to confinement were 5
years or more is inadmissible.
(C) Controlled substance traffickers.--Any
alien who the consular officer or the Attorney
General knows or has reason to believe--
(i) is or has been an illicit
trafficker in any controlled substance
or in any listed chemical (as defined
in section 102 of the Controlled
Substances Act (21 U.S.C. 802)), or is
or has been a knowing aider, abettor,
assister, conspirator, or colluder with
others in the illicit trafficking in
any such controlled or listed substance
or chemical, or endeavored to do so; or
(ii) is the spouse, son, or daughter
of an alien inadmissible under clause
(i), has, within the previous 5 years,
obtained any financial or other benefit
from the illicit activity of that
alien, and knew or reasonably should
have known that the financial or other
benefit was the product of such illicit
activity,
is inadmissible.
(D) Prostitution and commercialized vice.--
Any alien who--
(i) is coming to the United States
solely, principally, or incidentally to
engage in prostitution, or has engaged
in prostitution within 10 years of the
date of application for a visa,
admission, or adjustment of status,
(ii) directly or indirectly procures
or attempts to procure, or (within 10
years of the date of application for a
visa, entry, or adjustment of status)
procured or attempted to procure or to
import, prostitutes or persons for the
purpose of prostitution, or receives or
(within such 10-year period) received,
in whole or in part, the proceeds of
prostitution, or
(iii) is coming to the United States
to engage in any other unlawful
commercialized vice, whether or not
related to prostitution,
is inadmissible.
(E) Certain aliens involved in serious
criminal activity who have asserted immunity
from prosecution.--Any alien--
(i) who has committed in the United
States at any time a serious criminal
offense (as defined in section 101(h)),
(ii) for whom immunity from criminal
jurisdiction was exercised with respect
to that offense,
(iii) who as a consequence of the
offense and exercise of immunity has
departed from the United States, and
(iv) who has not subsequently
submitted fully to the jurisdiction of
the court in the United States having
jurisdiction with respect to that
offense,
is inadmissible.
(F) Waiver authorized.--For provision
authorizing waiver of certain subparagraphs of
this paragraph, see subsection (h).
(G) Foreign government officials who have
committed particularly severe violations of
religious freedom.--Any alien who, while
serving as a foreign government official, was
responsible for or directly carried out, at any
time, particularly severe violations of
religious freedom, as defined in section 3 of
the International Religious Freedom Act of 1998
(22 U.S.C. 6402), is inadmissible.
(H) Significant traffickers in persons.--
(i) In general.--Any alien who
commits or conspires to commit human
trafficking offenses in the United
States or outside the United States, or
who the consular officer, the Secretary
of Homeland Security, the Secretary of
State, or the Attorney General knows or
has reason to believe is or has been a
knowing aider, abettor, assister,
conspirator, or colluder with such a
trafficker in severe forms of
trafficking in persons, as defined in
the section 103 of such Act, is
inadmissible.
(ii) Beneficiaries of trafficking.--
Except as provided in clause (iii), any
alien who the consular officer or the
Attorney General knows or has reason to
believe is the spouse, son, or daughter
of an alien inadmissible under clause
(i), has, within the previous 5 years,
obtained any financial or other benefit
from the illicit activity of that
alien, and knew or reasonably should
have known that the financial or other
benefit was the product of such illicit
activity, is inadmissible.
(iii) Exception for certain sons and
daughters.--Clause (ii) shall not apply
to a son or daughter who was a child at
the time he or she received the benefit
described in such clause.
(I) Money laundering.--Any alien--
(i) who a consular officer or the
Attorney General knows, or has reason
to believe, has engaged, is engaging,
or seeks to enter the United States to
engage, in an offense which is
described in section 1956 or 1957 of
title 18, United States Code (relating
to laundering of monetary instruments);
or
(ii) who a consular officer or the
Attorney General knows is, or has been,
a knowing aider, abettor, assister,
conspirator, or colluder with others in
an offense which is described in such
section;
is inadmissible.
(3) Security and related grounds.--
(A) In general.--Any alien who a consular
officer or the Attorney General knows, or has
reasonable ground to believe, seeks to enter
the United States to engage solely,
principally, or incidentally in--
(i) any activity (I) to violate any
law of the United States relating to
espionage or sabotage or (II) to
violate or evade any law prohibiting
the export from the United States of
goods, technology, or sensitive
information,
(ii) any other unlawful activity, or
(iii) any activity a purpose of which
is the opposition to, or the control or
overthrow of, the Government of the
United States by force, violence, or
other unlawful means,
is inadmissible.
(B) Terrorist activities.--
(i) In general.--Any alien who--
(I) has engaged in a
terrorist activity;
(II) a consular officer, the
Attorney General, or the
Secretary of Homeland Security
knows, or has reasonable ground
to believe, is engaged in or is
likely to engage after entry in
any terrorist activity (as
defined in clause (iv));
(III) has, under
circumstances indicating an
intention to cause death or
serious bodily harm, incited
terrorist activity;
(IV) is a representative (as
defined in clause (v)) of--
(aa) a terrorist
Dissenting Views
After a string of setbacks for conservative governors and
state attorneys general, in which courts have properly found
that states have no standing to sue the federal government over
certain immigration policies, Republicans are attempting to
invent grounds for standing, where none plainly exists. For the
reasons below, I urge all Members to oppose this legislation.
To begin with, this bill may very well be unconstitutional.
It goes directly against the Supreme Court's settled precedent
in Spokeo, Inc. v. Robins, which explicitly states that a
statutory right to sue does not constitute an injury for
purposes of standing.\1\ Standing is a constitutional
requirement under Article III, which vests the Judicial Branch
with ``[t]he judicial Power of the United States,''\2\ but
specifies that this power extends only to ``Cases'' and
``Controversies.''\3\ The Supreme Court has repeatedly noted
the importance of standing in upholding our system of
separation of powers, observing that ``[n]o principle is more
fundamental to the judiciary's proper role in our system of
government than the constitutional limitation of federal-court
jurisdiction to actual cases or controversies.''\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Spokeo, Inc. v. Robins, 578 U.S. 330 at 341 (2016).
\2\U.S. Const. Art. III, Sec. 1.
\3\U.S. Const. Art. III, Sec. 2.
\4\Raines v. Byrd, 521 U.S. 811, 818 (1997).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This is particularly salient in the immigration context,
where the Executive Branch must exercise its discretion under
its constitutional and statutory authority to enforce
immigration law because of limited resources and the impact
such decisions may have on its primary role in matters of
foreign policy and commerce. Congress cannot by statute alone
elevate all de facto injuries--if any--that may result from the
Executive Branch's exercise of discretion in immigration
enforcement matters to meet the requirements of Article III
standing. Here, this bill would deem that States have standing
to sue so long as the state or its residents suffer any degree
of harm, while appearing only to exclude financial harms that
are less than $100. This bill is a transparent attempt to
permit States to dictate immigration policy to the federal
government through the courts. Congress simply cannot ignore
the Constitution's standing requirements to do so.
The Supreme Court most recently addressed the issue of
states' standing to sue the federal government over immigration
enforcement matters in United States v. Texas.\5\ In that 2023
decision, the Court held, 8-1 that Texas and Louisiana lacked
Article III standing to bring suit against the federal
government over its purported violation of federal immigration
statutes that, according to the states, required it to arrest
more criminal noncitizens pending removal.\6\ The states had
argued that they had standing to bring suit because the federal
government's failure to comply with those statutory mandates
had imposed costs on the states, such as the costs of
incarceration or the provision of social services like health
care and education to noncitizens who should have been arrested
by the federal government.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\599 U.S. 670 (2023).
\6\Id. at 674, 676, 686.
\7\Id. at 674.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In outlining its standing analysis, the Court emphasized
that ``Article III of the Constitution confines the federal
judicial power to `Cases' and `Controversies,''' which ``exist
only if a plaintiff has standing to sue--a bedrock
constitutional requirement . . .''\8\ It further highlighted
that the ``principle of Article III standing is `built on a
single basic idea--the idea of separation of powers.'''\9\ And
that ``standing doctrine helps safeguard the Judiciary's
proper--and properly limited--role in our constitutional
system,''\10\ preventing ``the judicial process from being used
to usurp the powers of the political branches.''\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Id. at 675.
\9\Id. (quoting Allen v. Wright, 468 U.S. 737, 752 (1984)).
\10\Id. at 675-676.
\11\Id. at 676 (quoting Clapper v. Amnesty Int'l USA, 568 U.S. 398,
408 (2013)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In rejecting the states' standing argument, the Court noted
that the states had failed to cite any precedent, history, or
tradition of courts ordering the Executive Branch to change its
arrest or prosecution policies so that it makes more arrests or
initiates more prosecutions, and that it had, in fact,
previously found that plaintiffs lack standing to bring such a
suit.\12\ The Court reasoned that there were several good
reasons why this was the case, including the fact that when the
Executive Branch chooses not to arrest or prosecute someone, it
does not exercise coercive power over an individual and,
therefore, does not infringe upon interests that courts
normally protect.\13\ Additionally, the Court noted, lawsuits
alleging insufficient arrests or prosecution run against the
Executive Branch's Article II authority to enforce the law,
which includes the discretion to determine enforcement
priorities in the face of lack of resources and shifting public
safety and public welfare needs.\14\ The Court noted that by
``concluding that Texas and Louisiana lack standing here, we
abide by and reinforce the proper role of the Federal Judiciary
under Article III.''\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Id. at 677.
\13\Id. at 678.
\14\Id.
\15\Id. at 681. In dicta, the Court noted several potential
instances where it might find standing in cases concerning the
Executive Branch's alleged failure to make more arrests or bring more
prosecutions. These included (1) suits alleging selective prosecution
claims under the Equal Protection Clause; (2) cases where Congress
elevated de facto injuries to the status of legally cognizable injuries
redressable by a federal court by defining a set of plaintiffs who have
suffered ``concrete harms'' from executive under-enforcement and
specifically authorizing courts to enter orders requiring the Executive
Branch to make additional arrests or prosecutions; (3) cases where the
Executive Branch wholly abandoned its statutory responsibilities to
make arrests or bring prosecutions; (4) a challenge to Executive Branch
policy involving both the Executive Branch's enforcement priorities and
its provision of legal benefits or legal status; and (5) cases
concerning policies governing the continued detention of noncitizens
who have already been arrested. Id. at 681-683.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Despite clear precedent that Congress cannot create
standing where none exists, this bill attempts to provide an
end-run around the Court's ruling in United States v. Texas and
to give states standing to sue under certain provisions of the
Immigration Nationality Act (INA), including the two sections
specifically rejected by the Court in that case. To rectify
this, at markup, I offered an amendment to strike those two
sections from this bill. Republicans defeated this amendment on
a party line vote. The majority did not provide substantive
arguments against this amendment beyond arguing that dicta by
Justice Kavanaugh in this opinion left open the idea of
legislation by Congress.
Additionally, many of the immigration provisions covered in
this bill contain standards that have never been met, and no
Congress or administration has ever provided or requested the
funding to attempt to meet them. Republicans likewise disagree
with the administration's straightforward interpretation of the
parole provision of the INA, which is in line with 70 years of
presidential precedent. Any concerns about a ``violation'' of
these provisions would be an expression of displeasure with
policy choices and not an argument that an administration is
willfully ignoring the law. Just as such policy differences
could not provide a legitimate justification for the absurd
impeachment of Secretary Mayorkas on similar grounds, they
likewise do not constitute legitimate injuries for the purposes
of standing.
To rectify this, at markup, Representative Jayapal (D-WA)
offered an amendment to strike the parole section from this
bill. Republicans defeated this amendment on a party line vote.
The majority did not provide substantive arguments against this
amendment beyond arguing that they do not like the current
administration's use of parole.
For all of these reasons, I dissent, and I urge all of my
colleagues to oppose this legislation.
Jerrold Nadler,
Ranking Member.
[all]