Background and Need for Legislation
OVERVIEW Federal lands offer an abundance of outdoor recreation opportunities including but not limited to hiking, biking, rock climbing, camping, kayaking, canoeing, skiing, hunting, fishing, and recreational shooting. More Americans than ever are choosing to recreate outdoors at national parks and on public lands. The major federal land management agencies saw over 580 million visitors in 2022.\1\ The most recent data show approximately 312 million visitors to National Park Service (NPS) sites, 67 million to U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) National Wildlife Refuge System lands, 42 million to Bureau of Land Management (BLM) public lands, and 159 million to U.S. Forest Service (USFS) areas annually.\2\ Unfortunately, outdoor recreation opportunities are not always easily accessible. Barriers to outdoor recreation include cumbersome and costly permitting processes, closed recreation destinations, dilapidated infrastructure, outdated technology, and lack of defined access due to bureaucratic red tape or cost-prohibitive fees. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\National Park Service, Visitation Numbers, https://www.nps.gov/ aboutus/visitation-numbers.htm; U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Data Shared with Committee Staff, Mar. 17, 2023; Bureau of Land Management, Public Land Statistics 2021, June 2022, https://www.blm.gov/sites/ default/files/docs/2022-07/Public_Land_Statistics_2021_508.pdf; United States Forest Service, National Visitor Use Monitoring Survey Results National Summary Report, Sept. 2023, https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/ default/files/2022-National-Visitor-Use-Monitoring-Summary-Report.pdf. \2\Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- To unleash the full potential of outdoor recreation on our public lands, Chairman Westerman (R-AR) and Ranking Member Grijalva (D-AZ) introduced H.R. 6492, the bipartisan ``Expanding Public Lands Outdoor Recreation Experiences (EXPLORE) Act'' on November 29, 2023. This bill is the culmination of several hearings held in the Committee on Natural Resources since the beginning of the 118th Congress and incorporates a dozen bipartisan recreation bills also processed through the committee. This legislation is the House companion of the bipartisan legislation S. 873 (Manchin/Barrasso), the ``America's Outdoor Recreation Act of 2023.''\3\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \3\Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee Chairman Manchin (D-WV) and Ranking Member Barrasso (R-WY) introduced sister legislation earlier this year. S. 873 (Manchin/Barrasso), ``America's Outdoor Recreation Act of 2023,'' https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/ senate-bill/873. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- TITLE I: OUTDOOR RECREATION AND INFRASTRUCTURE Outdoor recreation on public lands helps fuel the $1.1 trillion outdoor recreation economy.\4\ According to new data released in November 2023 by the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA), the total annual gross output of the outdoor recreation economy grew by $238 billion over the past year.\5\ The outdoor recreation economy accounts for $563.7 billion, or 2.2 percent of gross domestic product (GDP), and supports nearly 5 million jobs.\6\ In terms of GDP, these numbers represent growth of nearly $110 billion compared to the prior year.\7\ The outdoor recreation economy continues to outpace growth in the overall U.S. economy, with recreation growing by 4.8 percent compared to just 1.9 percent for the overall economy.\8\ Title I of the EXPLORE Act focuses on expanding and improving outdoor recreation opportunities and infrastructure to sustain and support the outdoor recreation economy. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \4\Bureau of Economic Analysis, ``Outdoor Recreation Satellite Account, U.S. and States, 2022,'' Nov. 17, 2023, https://www.bea.gov/ sites/default/files/2023-11/orsa1123.pdf. \5\Id. \6\Id. \7\Bureau of Economic Analysis, ``Outdoor Recreation Satellite Account, U.S. and States, 2021,'' Nov. 9, 2022, https://www.bea.gov/ news/2022/outdoor-recreation-satellite-account-us-and-states-2021. \8\Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The economic impact of recreating on federal lands stretches far beyond the entrance gates and into surrounding communities--often referred to as gateway communities. At the local level, outdoor recreation generates $59.2 billion in state and local tax revenue annually.\9\ In 2022, visitors to national parks generated a record high of $50.3 billion in economic benefits and spent an estimated $23.9 billion in gateway communities.\10\ Title I of the EXPLORE Act addresses some of the most pressing challenges facing national parks and gateway communities, such as overcrowding, lack of affordable housing, and antiquated technologies. The bill contains several provisions that would improve technology and encourage innovative private partnerships to address strains to recreation infrastructure. For example, the bill improves visitor experiences by facilitating increased broadband deployment in national parks and developed recreation sites. The bill also creates pilot programs to provide real-time visitation data in heavily used recreation sites, which will provide the public with more reliable data and alleviate overcrowding. Title I also creates new affordable housing opportunities by allowing private entities to lease underutilized USFS administrative sites for housing. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \9\Outdoor Industry Association, ``The Outdoor Recreation Economy,'' https://outdoorindustry.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/ OIA_RecEconomy_FINAL_Single.pdf. \10\2022 National Park Visitor Spending Effects, National Park Service, Accessed Aug. 29, 2023, https://www.nps.gov/nature/customcf/ NPS_Data_Visualization/docs/NPS_2022_Visitor_ Spending_Effects.pdf. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The EXPLORE Act maintains and improves access to some of the most beloved recreation activities in America. The bill incentivizes the creation of new long-distance bike trails. Biking is one of the fastest growing sectors in the outdoor recreation economy, with expectations that mountain biking will grow to $16.9 billion by 2030.\11\ Increases in ridership have pushed current trails to the limit, necessitating the creation of new trails to satisfy high biking demands. Along with non- motorized vehicles like bikes, the legislation also benefits motorized recreation by requiring agencies to update maps of off-highway vehicle areas. Off-highway vehicle (OHV) recreation accounts for an estimated $68 billion in economic output annually and creating more certainty regarding open trails will help encourage more OHV use.\12\ The legislation also improves camping opportunities by restoring campsites and creating public-private partnerships to renovate existing campsites. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \11\Market Research Future, Global Mountain Bike Market Overview, Swapnil Palwe, Mar. 2023, https://www.marketresearchfuture.com/reports/ mountain-bike-market-5165. \12\SEMA, ``Off-Roading: Critical Industry to the U.S. Economy,'' https://sites.sema.org/ext- assets/government-affairs/advocacy/pdfs/SEMA_One_Pagers_OffRoading.pdf. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Importantly, this title of the legislation would protect the use of fixed anchors used by rock climbers in iconic wilderness destinations. Climbing is an incredibly important recreational activity on public lands, with the federal land management agencies managing approximately 60 percent of the nation's climbing areas encompassing ``20,000 discrete cliffs, boulders and alpine objectives inside and outside of designated wilderness.''\13\ Some of the most iconic climbing destinations in the country are within wilderness areas, such as El Capitan in Yosemite National Park, Joshua Tree's Wonderland of Rocks, portions of the White Mountains National Forest, and Red Rock Canyon National Recreation Area.\14\ To climb properly and ensure safety, permanent bolts and fixed anchors are placed and maintained along established climbing routes, including in wilderness areas. In November 2023, NPS and USFS announced a proposed directive that numerous outdoor recreationists slammed as jeopardizing climber safety and limiting access.\15\ Section 122 of the bill would codify the use of fixed anchors in wilderness areas, creating certainty for the rock-climbing community and ensuring the continuation of rock climbing on public lands. As reflected in the committee hearing on the EXPLORE Act, the committee notes that the current draft guidance from NPS and USFS is inconsistent with this provision and would allow for the prohibition of fixed anchors in wilderness areas. It is the intent of the EXPLORE Act that the agencies issue new guidance that codifies and affirms the use of rock climbing with fixed anchors in wilderness areas as an appropriate and allowable activity. This is consistent with the long-standing practice of rock climbing in these destinations that predates the Wilderness Act of 1964. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \13\Access Fund et al., Letter in support of the Protecting America's Rock Climbing Act, Mar. 22, 2023, https:// static1.squarespace.com/static/638927954320c12d8056bbbd/t/ 641b285e73dcac 627ce41eca/1679501406863/Sign-on+Letter+Supporting+Protect+ America%27s+Rock+Climbing+Act-03222023-1000MT.pdf. \14\Id. \15\Access Fund, ``New NPS and USFS Proposals Would Limit Climbing and Threaten Iconic Routes,'' Nov. 17, 2023, https:// www.accessfund.org/latest-news/new-nps-and-usfs-proposals-would-limit- climbing-and-threaten-iconic-routes. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Several provisions in the EXPLORE Act aim to promote recreation opportunities among sportsmen and women. Hunting, shooting, and trapping comprise the third largest share of economic activity among conventional outdoor recreation activities, generating $27.3 billion in economic output annually.\16\ Reliable access to federal lands and waters is crucial for the approximately 32 million Americans who engage in target shooting annually and the 101.6 million Americans (or roughly 40 percent of the population over the age of 16) who engage in some type of hunting, fishing, or wildlife-related activity.\17\ The EXPLORE Act requires USFS and BLM to establish new target shooting ranges in every national forest and BLM district that does not currently have a shooting range, make a public list of national forests and BLM districts that currently have shooting ranges, and prevent the closure of target shooting ranges. The bill also removes red tape and reduces costs for small filming crews on federal lands. This is a serious issue for hunters, who use promotional videos to encourage the next generation of sportsmen and women to participate in hunting activities. In addition, the bill allows for inspections and the decontamination of boats for fishermen in federal waters to address aquatic invasive species. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \16\Id. \17\Department of the Interior, ``New 5-Year Report Shows 101.6 Million Americans Participated in Hunting, Fishing & Wildlife Activities,'' Sept. 7, 2017, https://www.doi.gov/pressreleases/new-5- year-report-shows-1016-million-americans-participated-hunting-fishing- wild life. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Title I also codifies and improves existing programs that rely on public-private partnerships to promote outdoor recreation. The bill makes several improvements to the American Battlefield Protection Program (ABPP) by allowing Tribes, non- profit organizations, and educational institutions to directly apply for grants, clarifying Congress's intent regarding the acquisition of priority battlefields, and updating battlefield reports based on new technology. Since its conception, the ABPP has helped protect more than 100 battlefields in 42 states and protect battlefield lands at 110 battlefield sites in 19 states.\18\ These changes will help sustain this important program and protect the most hallowed sites in our nation. Additionally, the legislation codifies the Outdoor Recreation Legacy Partnership Program and makes important modifications, such as expanding the eligibility of towns and cities that are able to apply for this program. It is the intent of the committee that this provision codifies the existing program, rather than directing the agencies to create a duplicative program. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \18\National Park Service, ``American Battlefield Protection Program: What We Do,'' https://www.nps.gov/orgs/2287/whatwedo.htm. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The committee notes that while prior hearings were held on H.R. 930, the ``Ski Hill Resources for Economic Development (SHRED) Act of 2023,'' this legislation was ultimately not included in the EXPLORE Act due to Congressional budgetary rules. The committee recognizes the importance of U.S. ski resorts to the outdoor recreation economy, which receive more than 60.6 million ski and snowboard visits annually, generating an estimated $29 billion to the GDP and supporting over 533,000 jobs.\19\ The committee recognizes that the USFS has struggled to keep pace with permitting for needed infrastructure improvements and capital investments at existing resorts. While the EXPLORE Act does not include any specific fee retention authority, the committee encourages the USFS to continue working with ski area partners to improve the efficiency and predictability of ski area permit administration. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \19\National Ski Areas Association, ``The Economic Impact of Skiing and Snowboarding,'' Nov. 2020, https://nsaa.org/webdocs/Media_Public/ IndustryStats/Economic_Impact_2020-21.pdf. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Finally, in addition to promoting these individual recreation activities, the EXPLORE Act ensures recreation remains a priority among federal land managers in accordance with existing multiple use mandates. The bill codifies the existing Federal Interagency Council on Outdoor Recreation so agencies can share best practices for increasing access to various recreation opportunities. Land managers must also assess existing recreation resources, evaluate their maintenance needs, and identify other underutilized recreation opportunities that may be promoted to lessen resource strains. The bill contains good governance provisions requiring agencies to track the amount of federal funding currently going toward outdoor recreation resources. TITLE II: ACCESS AMERICA A growing body of research shows that, in addition to providing economic benefits, outdoor recreation is associated with considerable wellness advantages, including improved physical and mental health.\20\ Nature-based recreation has been shown to improve cognition, decrease anxiety, and alleviate symptoms of depression.\21\ For groups like veterans or individuals with disabilities, who disproportionately suffer from depression and mental distress, the health benefits of outdoor recreation take on a heightened significance. Public lands play an outsized role in providing affordable, accessible recreation opportunities for these groups, along with people of all ages. Title II of the EXPLORE Act focuses on reducing barriers to access our public lands among key groups, including military servicemembers, veterans, and Gold Star Families; individuals with disabilities; and children. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \20\The Wellness Benefits of the Great Outdoors, U.S. Forest Service, Mar. 24, 2021, https://www.fs.usda.gov/features/wellness- benefits-great-outdoors. \21\Nancy Qwynne Lackey, Deborah A. Tysor, G. David McNay, Leah Joyner, Kensey H. Baker & Camilla Hodge (2021) Mental health benefits of nature-based recreation: a systematic review, Annals of Leisure Research, 24:3, 379-393. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Public lands are critical in ensuring affordable access to outdoor recreation opportunities for military service members, veterans, and Gold Star Families. Veterans ``often describe distinctive connections between their service to the country and the public lands they later return to visit.''\22\ Numerous studies have shown that outdoor recreation, particularly on our public lands, can be very helpful and healing to veterans' rehabilitation.\23\ Engaging in outdoor activities like hiking, camping, and nature-based therapies can provide a therapeutic environment that improves their mood and alleviates symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), ultimately enhancing their recovery and overall well-being.\24\ Recreating outdoors is particularly important for the estimated 50 percent of post- 9/11 veterans who experience some combination of combat-related emotional, psychological, or physical injuries.\25\ Despite the importance of our public lands to veterans and military service members, federal land managers often lack a cohesive national strategy that prioritizes outdoor programs for veterans. According to one study, ``even as public land agencies begin to appreciate ways they can shape therapeutic landscapes, it will require a degree of intentionality to support [outdoor programs for veterans (OPVs)] and promote opportunities for people to gather, seek therapeutic experiences, or heal across physical and managerial landscapes.''\26\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \22\Id. \23\National Environmental Education Foundation, ``Five Studies That Show How Spending Time In Nature Helps Veterans'', Sarah Hubbart, Nov. 1, 2022, https://www.neefusa.org/story/health-and-environment/ five-studies-show-how-spending-time-nature-helps-veterans; Forge Health, Hiking Can Help Veterans Heal and Find Peace, n.d., https:// forgehealth.com/hiking-can-help-veterans-heal-and-find-peace/. \24\Id. \25\Havlick, et al., ``Therapeutic landscapes, outdoor programs for veterans, and public lands,'' Social Science & Medicine 268 (2021) 113540. \26\Id. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Title II of the EXPLORE Act improves access and opportunities for military service members, veterans, and Gold Star Families to enjoy outdoor recreation on federal lands. The legislation develops a national strategy to increase recreation visits to federal lands by veterans, members of the Armed Forces, and Gold Star Families. The bill helps increase these recreation visits by promoting partnerships with various organizations to host more veterans' recreation events on public lands and assisting in the planning and