Purpose and Summary
H.R. 661, Sarah's Law, introduced by Rep. Randy Feenstra
(R-IA), would mandate immigration detention for illegal aliens
who are charged with, are arrested for, are convicted of, admit
having committed, or admit committing acts that constitute the
essential elements of any offense that resulted in the death or
serious bodily injury of another person. H.R. 661 also would
mandate that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) notify
the victim or the victim's family about the alien's identity,
immigration status, criminal history, custody status, and any
efforts by the United States government to remove the alien
from the country. The bill would require DHS to issue a
detainer for such aliens and take custody of them ``effectively
and expeditiously.''
Background and Need for the Legislation
On January 31, 2016, as 21-year-old Sarah Root drove home
after a day of celebrating her college graduation, an illegal
alien who was street racing while drunk slammed into Sarah's
SUV.\1\ Sarah passed away on February 4, 2016.\2\ A judge later
set the illegal alien's bond at $50,000.\3\ The illegal alien
posted bond and was released.\4\ To this day, the illegal alien
responsible for Sarah's murder remains at large.\5\ This bill
closes a glaring loophole in immigration law by mandating
immigration detention for certain aliens, like Sarah Root's
killer, who are arrested for, are charged with, or are
convicted of any crime that resulted in someone's death or
serious bodily injury. In doing so, H.R. 661 seeks to prevent
avoidable tragedies caused by illegal aliens and ensures that
dangerous criminal aliens are more quickly removed from the
United States.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Kathy A. Bolten, Trump uses Iowan's death as reason to
strengthen immigration laws, Des Moines Register (Apr. 16, 2016, 7:35
p.m.), https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/crime-and-courts/
2016/04/16/sarah-root-eswin-mejia/82902280/.
\2\Id.
\3\Id.
\4\Id.
\5\Sen. Joni Ernst, Prioritize the safety of the public over
illegal immigrants, Wash. Examiner (Feb. 1, 2024, 6:00 a.m.), https://
www.washingtonexaminer.com/restoring-america/2829732/prioritize-safety-
public-over-illegal-immigrants/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION'S FAILURE TO DETAIN AND REMOVE CRIMINAL ALIENS
In addition to the Biden Administration releasing more than
4.6 million illegal aliens into the United States in just three
years,\6\ President Biden and DHS Secretary Mayorkas have
ensured that most of those illegal aliens can remain in the
country indefinitely--even after they have committed a
crime.\7\ In fact, instead of detaining criminal aliens and
ensuring their quick removal from the United States, President
Biden and Secretary Mayorkas have made it more difficult for
ICE officers to arrest criminals.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\See H. Comm. on the Judiciary, Rep. on The Biden Border Crisis:
How the Biden Admin. Opened the Sw. Border and Abandoned Interior
Immigr. Enf't at App'x 1 (Oct. 9, 2023) [hereinafter Oct. Interim Staff
Rep.]; U.S. Customs and Border Prot., Custody and Transfer Statistics
FY 2023, U.S. Dep't of Homeland Sec. (last accessed Mar. 22, 2024);
U.S. Customs and Border Prot., Custody and Transfer Statistics FY 2024,
U.S. Dep't of Homeland Sec. (last accessed Mar. 22, 2024); Camilo
Montoya-Galvez, Biden administration has admitted more than 1 million
migrants into U.S. under parole policy Congress is considering
restricting, CBS NEWS (Jan. 22, 2024), https://www.cbsnews.com/news/
immigration-parole-biden-administration-1-million-migrants/ (reporting
that at least 596,600 aliens have been paroled into the United States
under illegal categorical parole programs); Latest UC Data, Total
Monthly Discharges to Individual Sponsors Only, U.S. Dep't of Health
and Human Servs. (last accessed Mar. 22, 2024); Off. of Refugee
Resettlement, Unaccompanied Children Released to Sponsors by State,
U.S. Dep't of Health and Human Servs. (last accessed Mar. 22, 2024);
U.S. Customs and Border Prot., CBP Releases February 2024 Monthly
Update, U.S. Dep't of Homeland Sec. (Mar. 22, 2024).
\7\See Oct. Interim Staff Rep., supra note 6, at 11-17.
\8\See id. at 14-16.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For three years, the Biden Administration has chosen to
ignore the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), which
specifies the grounds for which an alien ``shall . . . be
removed'' from the United States.\9\ Despite that mandate,
during the first eight months of the Biden Administration,
then-acting DHS Secretary David Pekoske, Acting ICE Director
Tae Johnson, and DHS Secretary Mayorkas issued three memoranda
that articulated different enforcement priorities for the new
Administration.\10\ In September 2021, Secretary Mayorkas
issued the third and final memo, entitled ``Guidelines for the
Enforcement of Civil Immigration Law'' (``Mayorkas Memo''),
outlining three enforcement priorities: national security,
public safety, and border security.\11\ As the Committee
detailed in an October 2023 staff report:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\8 U.S.C. Sec. 1227(a).
\10\See Texas v. United States, 40 F.4th 205, 213-214 (5th Cir.
2022).
\11\Id.; see Memorandum from Alejandro N. Mayorkas, Sec'y, Dep't of
Homeland Sec., to Tae Johnson, Acting Dir., U.S. Immigr. and Customs
Enf't, et al., ``Guidelines for the Enf't of Civil Immigr. Law'' (Sept.
30, 2021).
The Mayorkas Memo begins with the assumption that
``undocumented noncitizens'' work hard and contribute
to ``our communities'' and that ``bipartisan groups''
have ``tried to pass legislation that would provide a
path to citizenship or other lawful status for the
approximately 11 million undocumented noncitizens'' in
the country.
From that premise, Secretary Mayorkas articulated a
new policy that the mere fact that aliens are removable
pursuant to U.S. law ``should not alone be the basis of
an enforcement action against them.'' Under the
Mayorkas Memo, for instance, ``[b]efore ICE officers
[could] arrest and detain aliens as a threat to public
safety, they [were] now required to conduct an
assessment of the individual and the totality of facts
and circumstances, including various aggravating or
mitigating factors.'' In this assessment, ICE officers
were prohibited from relying solely on the fact of an
alien's conviction, regardless of the seriousness of
the underlying crime. After listing certain aggravating
and mitigating factors, the Mayorkas Memo states that
the listed factors were ``not exhaustive'' and that
``the overriding question is whether the noncitizen
poses a current threat to public safety.'' The Mayorkas
Memo also does not presumptively subject aliens with
aggravated felony convictions to enforcement action or
detention.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Oct. Interim Staff Rep., supra note 6, at 14-15.
Consequently, the Mayorkas Memo requires ``a lengthier review
process before an ICE officer can arrest or remove an illegal
alien,'' contributes to ``fewer ICE arrests of criminal
aliens,'' and is responsible for ``lower removal numbers.''\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Id. at 15.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The numbers speak for themselves: well over half a million
criminal aliens are on ICE's non-detained docket, meaning that
aliens with criminal convictions or pending criminal charges
are out on American streets and ``free to reoffend.''\14\
Moreover, ``in fiscal year 2023, ICE removed 41 percent fewer
aliens with criminal convictions and criminal charges than in
fiscal year 2020--and nearly 60 percent fewer than in fiscal
year 2019.''\15\ The lack of interior immigration enforcement
begins with far fewer arrests of criminal aliens. As the
Committee outlined in a January 2024 staff report:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\See H. Comm. on the Judiciary, Interim Staff Rep., New Data
Reveal Worsening Magnitude of the Biden Border Crisis and Lack of
Interior Immigr. Enf't, at 9 (Jan. 18, 2024), https://
judiciary.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/republicans-judiciary.house.gov/
files/evo-media-document/2024-01-18-new-data-reveal-worsening-
magnitude-of-the-biden-border-crisis-and-lack-of-interior-immigration-
enforcement.pdf [hereinafter Jan. Interim Staff Rep.].
\15\Id.
A comparison of administrative arrests by criminal
charge or conviction category further highlights the
differences in immigration enforcement between the
Trump and Biden Administrations. In fiscal year 2018,
the Trump Administration arrested aliens responsible
for 76,585 dangerous drug offenses compared to 40,698
under the Biden Administration in fiscal year 2023. For
assault offenses, the Trump Administration arrested
aliens with 50,753 criminal charges and convictions in
fiscal year 2018, with only 33,209 in fiscal year 2023.
For sex offenses, the number of was 6,888 in 2018 but
5,746 in 2023. Across the board, in categories ranging
from murder to kidnapping to weapons offenses, the
Trump Administration in 2018 arrested far more criminal
aliens than the Biden Administration in 2023.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\Id. at 8-9.
Meanwhile, the Biden Administration has lodged
significantly fewer detainers on criminal aliens than the Trump
Administration. To ensure that criminal aliens are deported,
ICE issues detainers on aliens who have been arrested ``and who
ICE has probable cause to believe are removable'' from the
United States.\17\ Under a detainer, ICE ``asks the other law
enforcement agency to notify ICE before a removable individual
is released from custody and to maintain custody of the [alien]
for a brief period of time'' so ICE can take custody of the
alien.\18\ Detainers not only preserve law enforcement
resources but also protect Americans by ensuring that dangerous
criminal aliens are not released into communities.\19\ In
fiscal year 2019, for example, ICE issued 165,487 detainers for
aliens whose criminal histories included 56,000 assaults,
14,500 sex crimes, 5,000 robberies, 2,500 homicides, and 2,500
kidnappings.\20\ During the first three fiscal years of the
Biden Administration, ICE lodged 44 percent fewer detainers
than during the first three fiscal years of the Trump
Administration.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\U.S. Immigr. and Customs Enf't, Detainers 101 (Sept. 27, 2022),
https://www.ice.gov/features/detainers.
\18\Id.
\19\See U.S. Immigr. and Customs Enf't, Fiscal Year 2019 Enf't and
Removal Operations Rep., U.S. Dep't of Homeland Sec. at 16 (2020),
https://www.ice.gov/sites/default/files/documents/Document/2019/
eroReportFY2019.pdf [hereinafter 2019 ICE Annual Rep.].
\20\Id.
\21\In fiscal years 2017, 2018, and 2019, ICE issued 484,990
detainers (142,356 in 2017, 177,147 in 2018, and 165,487 in 2019)
compared to 270,127 in fiscal years 2021, 2022, and 2023 (with just
65,940 issued in 2021, 78,829 in 2022, and 125,358 in 2023). See 2019
ICE Annual Report, supra note 19, at 17; U.S. Immigr. and Customs
Enf't, ICE Annual Report, Fiscal Year 2023, U.S. Dep't of Homeland Sec.
at 17 (Dec. 29, 2023), https://www.ice.gov/doclib/eoy/
iceAnnualReportFY2023.pdf [hereinafter 2023 ICE Annual Rep.].
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Removals have similarly declined under the Biden
Administration. From fiscal year 2017 through fiscal year 2019,
there were 749,462 total removals.\22\ From fiscal year 2021
through fiscal year 2023, there were 273,768 removals.\23\ The
significant drop in removals from the first three fiscal years
of the Trump Administration to the first three fiscal years of
the Biden Administration is also reflected in the number of
removals of aliens from the interior of the United States. From
fiscal year 2017 through fiscal year 2019, ICE removed 262,921
aliens from the interior of the U.S.\24\ From fiscal year 2021
through fiscal year 2023, ICE removed from the U.S. interior
only 104,016 aliens, a decrease of 60 percent from the first
three years of the Trump Administration.\25\ This marked
decrease in removals has occurred despite the fact that illegal
immigration has skyrocketed from the Trump Administration to
the Biden Administration, with a 244 percent increase in
southwest border encounters from fiscal years 2017, 2018, and
2019 to fiscal years 2021, 2022, and 2023.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\See U.S. Immigr. and Customs Enf't, Fiscal Year 2018 ICE Enf't
and Removal Operations Rep., U.S. Dep't of Homeland Sec. at 10, https:/
/www.ice.gov/doclib/about/offices/ero/pdf/eroFY2018Report.pdf
[hereinafter 2018 ICE Annual Rep.]; 2023 ICE Annual Rep., supra note
21, at 26.
\23\2023 ICE Annual Rep., supra note 21, at 26.
\24\2018 ICE Annual Rep., supra note 22, at 7; 2023 ICE Annual
Rep., supra note 21, at 28.
\25\2023 ICE Annual Rep., supra note 21, at 28.
\26\Compare U.S. Customs and Border Prot., Sw. Border Migration FY
2019, U.S. Dep't of Homeland Sec., https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/stats/
sw-border-migration/fy-2019 (last accessed Feb. 23, 2024), with U.S.
Customs and Border Prot., Sw. Land Border Encounters, U.S. Dep't of
Homeland Sec., https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/stats/southwest-land-
border-encounters (last accessed Feb. 23, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
CONSEQUENCES OF OPEN BORDERS AND LIMITED ENFORCEMENT
The real-life consequences of illegal immigration and a
lack of interior immigration enforcement are stark. On January
31, 2016, 21-year-old Sarah Root from Council Bluffs, Iowa, was
driving home after a day of celebrating her college graduation
near Omaha, Nebraska.\27\ On her way home, a 19-year-old
illegal alien who was street racing while drunk slammed into
Sarah's SUV, snapping Sarah's spine and fracturing her
skull.\28\ Within hours of Sarah's death on February 4, a judge
set the illegal alien's bond at $50,000.\29\ The alien, Eswin
G. Mejia, posted bond and was released the next day.\30\ Mejia
absconded and his whereabouts remain unknown to this day.\31\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\Kathy A. Bolten, Trump uses Iowan's death as reason to
strengthen immigration laws, Des Moines Register (Apr. 16, 2016, 7:35
p.m.), https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/crime-and-courts/
2016/04/16/sarah-root-eswin-mejia/82902280/.
\28\Id.
\29\Id.
\30\Id.
\31\See Ernst, supra note 5.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although Mejia was charged with ``motor vehicular
homicide,'' the Obama Administration refused to lodge a
detainer against him.\32\ Despite a request by Omaha police to
obtain an immigration detainer for Mejia, ``the agency
declined.''\33\ According to a contemporaneous news report, ICE
explained that it declined the detainer ``because Mejia had not
been convicted of a criminal charge'' and ``was not . . . an
`enforcement priority.'''\34\ At a 2016 hearing before the
Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, then-ICE Director
Sarah Saldana further justified the decision not to detain
Mejia by saying that, ``An individual from ICE looked at the
specific facts and circumstances related to that matter, had--
the individual had no criminal convictions, previous criminal
convictions, and made a determination based on his judgment
that he did not need to be detained.''\35\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\32\Fred Barbash, The story of Sarah Root, who Trump said was
sacrificed `on the altar of open borders', Wash. Post (July 22, 2016,
6:44 a.m.), https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2016/07/
22/the-story-of-sarah-root-who-trump-said-was-sacrificed-on-the-altar-
of-open-borders/.
\33\Id.
\34\Id.
\35\Criminal Aliens Released by the Dep't of Homeland Sec., Hearing
Before the Comm. on Oversight and Gov't Reform, 114th Cong. (Apr. 28,
2016) (Testimony of ICE Director Sarah Saldana), available at https://
www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-114hhrg23480/html/CHRG-
114hhrg23480.htm.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Eight years after Sarah Root's death, the Biden
Administration has not learned from the Obama Administration's
failures. Illegal alien criminals continue to victimize
American communities. Although not every crime that results in
death or serious bodily injury involves drunk driving, many do.
In Missouri in November 2023, for example, an illegal alien
from Honduras was sentenced to 10 years in prison ``for driving
drunk at 100 mph'' and killing another driver.\36\ In Colorado
in December 2023, an illegal alien from El Salvador\37\
allegedly drove drunk and killed a 46-year-old woman and her
16-year-old son when he drove his truck up to 100 mph and ran
into the victims' vehicle, causing it to crash into a tree.\38\
Despite having five previous DUI-related convictions, ``[a]
Boulder County judge sentenced [the illegal alien] to
probation, community service[,] and work release'' on December
8, 2023, in relation to two of those convictions, just four
days before the crash that killed the mother and son.\39\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\36\Steve Pokin, Undocumented driver gets 10 years for being drunk
and racing down Glenstone at 100 mph, killing a man, Springfield Daily
Citizen (Nov. 18, 2023), https://sgfcitizen.org/government/crime/
undocumented-driver-gets-10-years-for-being-drunk-and-racing-down-
glenstone-at-100-mph-killing-a-man/.
\37\Jennie Taer, EXCLUSIVE: Illegal Immigrant Deported Four Times
Charged With Killing Colorado Mother, Son In DUI Crash, Daily Caller
(Jan. 8, 2024, 1:42 p.m.), https://dailycaller.com/2024/01/08/illegal-
immigrant-deported-four-times-charged-killing-colorado-mother-son-dui-
crash/.
\38\Janet Oravetz, Man arrested in crash that killed mom, son had
multiple prior DUI offenses, 9News (Dec. 21, 2023, 9:44 a.m.), https://
www.9news.com/article/news/crime/man-charged-broomfield-double-fatal-
crash/73-f1f67f6e-18ae-4610-b66d-80183d1d2a56.
\39\Shaun Boyd, Colorado man charged in DUI crash that killed
Broomfield mother and son sentenced in 2 other DUI cases 4 days
earlier, CBS News (Dec. 22, 2023, 7:55 p.m.),
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short Title. ``Sarah's Law.''
Section 2. Mandatory Detention of Certain Aliens Charged
with a Crime Resulting in Death or Serious Bodily Injury. This
section mandates ICE immigration detention for certain aliens
who are charged with, are arrested for, are convicted of, admit
having committed, or admit committing acts that constitute the
essential elements of any crime that resulted in the death or
serious bodily injury of another person. The section also
requires DHS to issue a detainer for such aliens and take
custody of them ``effectively and expeditiously,'' and to
provide certain information about the alien and efforts to
remove the alien to the victim or victim's family.
Section 3. Savings Provision. This section clarifies that
nothing in the bill may be construed to limit victims' rights
under any other provision of law.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
IMMIGRATION AND NATIONALITY ACT
* * * * * * *
TITLE II--IMMIGRATION
* * * * * * *
Chapter 4--Inspection, Apprehension, Examination, Exclusion, and
Removal
* * * * * * *
apprehension and detention of aliens
Sec. 236. (a) Arrest, Detention, and Release.--On a warrant
issued by the Attorney General, an alien may be arrested and
detained pending a decision on whether the alien is to be
removed from the United States. Except as provided in
subsection (c) and pending such decision, the Attorney
General--
(1) may continue to detain the arrested alien; and
(2) may release the alien on--
(A) bond of at least $1,500 with security
approved by, and containing conditions
prescribed by, the Attorney General; or
(B) conditional parole; but
(3) may not provide the alien with work authorization
(including an ``employment authorized'' endorsement or
other appropriate work permit), unless the alien is
lawfully admitted for permanent residence or otherwise
would (without regard to removal proceedings) be
provided such authorization.
(b) Revocation of Bond or Parole.--The Attorney General at
any time may revoke a bond or parole authorized under
subsection (a), rearrest the alien under the original warrant,
and detain the alien.
(c) Detention of Criminal Aliens.--
(1) Custody.--The Attorney General shall take into
custody any alien who--
(A) is inadmissible by reason of having
committed any offense covered in section
212(a)(2),
(B) is deportable by reason of having
committed any offense covered in section
237(a)(2)(A)(ii), (A)(iii), (B), (C), or (D),
(C) is deportable under section
237(a)(2)(A)(i) on the basis of an offense for
which the alien has been [sentence] sentenced
to a term of imprisonment of at least 1 year,
[or]
(D) is inadmissible under section
212(a)(3)(B) or deportable under section
237(a)(4)(B)[,], or
(E)(i)(I) is inadmissible under paragraph
(6)(A), (6)(C), or (7) of section 212(a),
(II) is deportable under section 237(a)(1)(B)
as an alien whose nonimmigrant visa (or other
documentation authorizing admission into the
United States as a nonimmigrant) has been
revoked under section 221(i), or
(III) is deportable under section
237(a)(1)(C)(i), and
(ii) is charged with, is arrested for, is
convicted of, admits having committed, or
admits committing acts which constitute the
essential elements of any offense that resulted
in the death or serious bodily injury (as
defined in section 1365(h)(3) of title 18,
United States Code) of another person,
when the alien is released, without regard to whether
the alien is released on parole, supervised release, or
probation, and without regard to whether the alien may
be arrested or imprisoned again for the same offense.
(2) Release.--The Attorney General may release an
alien described in paragraph (1) only if the Attorney
General decides pursuant to section 3521 of title 18,
United States Code, that release of the alien from
custody is necessary to provide protection to a
witness, a potential witness, a person cooperating with
an investigation into major criminal activity, or an
immediate family member or close associate of a
witness, potential witness, or person cooperating with
such an investigation, and the alien satisfies the
Attorney General that the alien will not pose a danger
to the safety of other persons or of property and is
likely to appear for any scheduled proceeding. A
decision relating to such release shall take place in
accordance with a procedure that considers the severity
of the offense committed by the alien.
(3) Notification requirement.--Upon encountering or
gaining knowledge of an alien described in paragraph
(1), the Secretary of Homeland Security shall--
(A) obtain information from law enforcement
agencies and from other available sources
regarding the identity of any victims of the
crimes for which such alien was charged,
arrested, or convicted; and
(B) provide the victim or, if the victim is
deceased, a parent, guardian, spouse, or
closest living relative of such victim, with
information, on a timely and ongoing basis,
including--
(i) the alien's full name, aliases,
date of birth, and country of
nationality;
(ii) the alien's immigration status
and criminal history;
(iii) the alien's custody status and
any changes related to the alien's
custody; and
(iv) a description of any efforts by
the United States Government to remove
the alien from the United States.
(4) Detainer.--The Secretary of Homeland Security
shall issue a detainer for an alien described in
paragraph (1)(E) and, if the alien is not otherwise
detained by Federal, State, or local officials, shall
effectively and expeditiously take custody of the
alien.
(d) Identification of Criminal Aliens.--(1) The Attorney
General shall devise and implement a system--
(A) to make available, daily (on a 24-hour basis), to
Federal, State, and local authorities the investigative
resources of the Service to determine whether
individuals arrested by such authorities for aggravated
felonies are aliens;
(B) to designate and train officers and employees of
the Service to serve as a liaison to Federal, State,
and local law enforcement and correctional agencies and
courts with respect to the arrest, conviction, and
release of any alien charged with an aggravated felony;
and
(C) which uses computer resources to maintain a
current record of aliens who have been convicted of an
aggravated felony, and indicates those who have been
removed.
(2) The record under paragraph (1)(C) shall be made
available--
(A) to inspectors at ports of entry and to border
patrol agents at sector headquarters for purposes of
immediate identification of any alien who was
previously ordered removed and is seeking to reenter
the United States, and
(B) to officials of the Department of State for use
in its automated visa lookout system.
(3) Upon the request of the governor or chief executive
officer of any State, the Service shall provide assistance to
State courts in the identification of aliens unlawfully present
in the United States pending criminal prosecution.
(e) Judicial Review.--The Attorney General's discretionary
judgment regarding the application of this section shall not be
subject to review. No court may set aside any action or
decision by the Attorney General under this section regarding
the detention or release of any alien or the grant, revocation,
or denial of bond or parole.
* * * * * * *
Dissenting Views
H.R. 661 is an overly broad bill that would result in
extremely harsh and unintended consequences. It does nothing to
solve any problems with the immigration system and represents
yet another attempt by the Republican Majority to target and
scapegoat migrants.
This bill arises from a tragic case. In 2016, Sarah Root
was killed by Eswin G. Mejia, a drunk driver, who had been in
the country unlawfully since 2013. Mr. Mejia was charged with
motor vehicular homicide and the judge chose to set bail. After
a relative posted bail, Mr. Mejia was released, but he did not
show up for his mandatory drug testing and he remains at large
today. As a result, Ms. Root's alleged killer has not been
brought to justice.
Unfortunately, this bill will not solve the problem the
Majority says it will. If H.R. 661 had been in place at the
time of Ms. Root's death, ICE would have issued a detainer
after her alleged killer was charged with a crime, and if
resources allowed, would have taken custody of him and then
swiftly removed him from the country due to his previous
infractions. He would never have been transferred back to local
custody to face justice the way the Root family desires. State
and local prosecutors have consistently raised concerns about
ICE taking individuals into custody before criminal proceedings
are completed, which frustrates prosecutors, judges, and
victim's families. This legislation would only exacerbate the
problem.
In addition to not actually solving the issue at hand, this
bill is overly broad and would result in extremely harsh and
unintended consequences. Under this bill, any immigrant who is
present in the United States without admission or parole, or
whose nonimmigrant visa was revoked, would be subject to
mandatory detention if they were charged or even merely
arrested for an offense that resulted in the death or serious
bodily injury of another person. While at first glance, this
may seem reasonable, there are some very serious flaws with
this approach.
First, this bill would result in immigrants--even some
currently in a lawful status and who have been in the country
for a long time--being subjected to mandatory detention. There
are far too many examples of wrongful arrests or charges due to
mistaken identity or the use of flawed facial recognition
technology. For example, Scottsdale Arizona recently had to
settle a lawsuit for $200,000 with a woman who was wrongfully
arrested for a hit and run. If this woman was a DACA recipient
or had Temporary Protected Status (TPS), under this bill, she
would be subject to mandatory detention, even though she is in
a lawful status and was wrongfully arrested.
Moreover, under the Immigration and Nationality Act, a
noncitizen who is convicted of, or who admits to committing, a
Crime Involving Moral Turpitude, or a ``CIMT,'' is already
subject to mandatory detention. Offenses involving the intent
to cause or threaten bodily harm and recklessness involving a
conscious disregard of a known risk of death or bodily injury
are currently considered CIMTs. As a result, people who are
convicted of, or who admit committing, an act that results in
serious injury or death are already subject to mandatory
detention under our laws. But this bill goes way beyond that
and mandates detention even for noncitizens who are simply
charged with or arrested for an offense that resulted in the
death or serious bodily injury of another person, regardless of
the actual circumstances at hand.
Subjecting a wide range of people, including DACA and TPS
recipients, to mandatory detention is not a sensible policy
choice and not a good use of our limited enforcement resources.
Congress has never appropriated, and no administration has ever
requested, sufficient resources to detain all noncitizens who
fall under the ``mandatory detention'' categories.
At markup, Representative Jayapal (D-WA) offered an
amendment to strike the provision that would subject an
individual to mandatory detention solely based on an arrest or
charge. The amendment would have brought the bill more in line
with current law by requiring that an individual be convicted
of, or admit to, committing an offense that resulted in the
death or serious bodily injury of another person to be subject
to mandatory detention.
Republicans defeated the amendment on a party line vote.
The Majority did not provide any substantive arguments in
response to the amendment, nor did they address the issue of
wrongful arrest and the harsh unintended consequences that
could result from such an arrest. The Majority also failed to
recognize that immigration detention is not supposed to be a
backstop for the criminal system. Immigration detention is a
civil, non-punitive function.
This bill is a broad expansion of current law. It is also
unnecessary. Noncitizens who admit to, or who are convicted of,
serious offenses that resulted in the death or serious bodily
injury of another person are already subject to mandatory
detention under the Immigration and Nationality Act. People are
often wrongfully arrested or are arrested and never convicted
for a crime. Indiscriminately subjecting such people to
mandatory detention would result in a gross miscarriage of
justice.
For all of these reasons, I dissent, and I urge all of my
colleagues to oppose this legislation.
Jerrold Nadler,
Ranking Member.
[all]