Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 3446]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on the Judiciary, to whom was referred the
bill (H.R. 3446) to impose certain limitations on consent
decrees and settlement agreements by agencies that require the
agencies to take regulatory action in accordance with the terms
thereof, and for other purposes, having considered the same,
reports favorably thereon with an amendment and recommends that
the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 5
Background and Need for the Legislation.......................... 5
Hearings......................................................... 6
Committee Consideration.......................................... 7
Committee Votes.................................................. 7
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 12
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures........................ 12
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate........................ 12
Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects.......................... 13
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 13
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 13
Advisory on Earmarks............................................. 14
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 14
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 14
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 14
Section-by-Section Analysis...................................... 14
Dissenting Views................................................. 16
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all that follows after the enacting clause, and insert
the following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Sunshine for Regulatory Decrees and
Settlements Act of 2023''.
SEC. 2. DEFINITIONS.
In this Act--
(1) the terms ``agency'' and ``agency action'' have the
meanings given those terms under section 551 of title 5, United
States Code;
(2) the term ``covered civil action'' means a civil action--
(A) seeking to compel agency action;
(B) alleging that an agency is unlawfully withholding
or unreasonably delaying an agency action relating to a
regulatory action that would affect the rights of--
(i) private persons other than the person
bringing the action; or
(ii) a State, local, or tribal government;
and
(C) brought under--
(i) chapter 7 of title 5, United States Code;
or
(ii) any other statute authorizing such an
action;
(3) the term ``covered consent decree'' means--
(A) a consent decree entered into in a covered civil
action; and
(B) any other consent decree that requires agency
action relating to a regulatory action that affects the
rights of--
(i) private persons other than the person
bringing the action; or
(ii) a State, local, or tribal government;
(4) the term ``covered consent decree or settlement
agreement'' means a covered consent decree and a covered
settlement agreement; and
(5) the term ``covered settlement agreement'' means--
(A) a settlement agreement entered into in a covered
civil action; and
(B) any other settlement agreement that requires
agency action relating to a regulatory action that
affects the rights of--
(i) private persons other than the person
bringing the action; or
(ii) a State, local, or tribal government.
SEC. 3. CONSENT DECREE AND SETTLEMENT REFORM.
(a) Pleadings and Preliminary Matters.--
(1) In general.--In any covered civil action, the agency
against which the covered civil action is brought shall publish
the notice of intent to sue and the complaint in a readily
accessible manner, including by making the notice of intent to
sue and the complaint available online not later than 15 days
after receiving service of the notice of intent to sue or
complaint, respectively.
(2) Entry of a covered consent decree or settlement
agreement.--A party may not make a motion for entry of a
covered consent decree or to dismiss a civil action pursuant to
a covered settlement agreement until after the end of
proceedings in accordance with paragraph (1) and subparagraphs
(A) and (B) of paragraph (2) of subsection (d) or subsection
(d)(3)(A), whichever is later.
(b) Intervention.--
(1) Rebuttable presumption.--In considering a motion to
intervene in a covered civil action or a civil action in which
a covered consent decree or settlement agreement has been
proposed that is filed by a person who alleges that the agency
action in dispute would affect the person, the court shall
presume, subject to rebuttal, that the interests of the person
would not be represented adequately by the existing parties to
the action.
(2) State, local, and tribal governments.--In considering a
motion to intervene in a covered civil action or a civil action
in which a covered consent decree or settlement agreement has
been proposed that is filed by a State, local, or tribal
government, the court shall take due account of whether the
movant--
(A) administers jointly with an agency that is a
defendant in the action the statutory provisions that
give rise to the regulatory action to which the action
relates; or
(B) administers an authority under State, local, or
tribal law that would be preempted by the regulatory
action to which the action relates.
(c) Settlement Negotiations.--Efforts to settle a covered civil
action or otherwise reach an agreement on a covered consent decree or
settlement agreement shall--
(1) be conducted pursuant to the mediation or alternative
dispute resolution program of the court or by a district judge
other than the presiding judge, magistrate judge, or special
master, as determined appropriate by the presiding judge; and
(2) include any party that intervenes in the action.
(d) Publication of and Comment on Covered Consent Decrees or
Settlement Agreements.--
(1) In general.--Not later than 60 days before the date on
which a covered consent decree or settlement agreement is filed
with a court, the agency seeking to enter the covered consent
decree or settlement agreement shall publish in the Federal
Register and online--
(A) the proposed covered consent decree or settlement
agreement; and
(B) a statement providing--
(i) the statutory basis for the covered
consent decree or settlement agreement; and
(ii) a description of the terms of the
covered consent decree or settlement agreement,
including whether it provides for the award of
attorneys' fees or costs and, if so, the basis
for including the award.
(2) Public comment.--
(A) In general.--An agency seeking to enter a covered
consent decree or settlement agreement shall accept
public comment during the period described in paragraph
(1) on any issue relating to the matters alleged in the
complaint in the applicable civil action or addressed
or affected by the proposed covered consent decree or
settlement agreement.
(B) Response to comments.--An agency shall respond to
any comment received under subparagraph (A).
(C) Submissions to court.--When moving that the court
enter a proposed covered consent decree or settlement
agreement or for dismissal pursuant to a proposed
covered consent decree or settlement agreement, an
agency shall--
(i) inform the court of the statutory basis
for the proposed covered consent decree or
settlement agreement and its terms;
(ii) submit to the court a summary of the
comments received under subparagraph (A) and
the response of the agency to the comments;
(iii) submit to the court a certified index
of the administrative record of the notice and
comment proceeding; and
(iv) make the administrative record described
in clause (iii) fully accessible to the court.
(D) Inclusion in record.--The court shall include in
the court record for a civil action the certified index
of the administrative record submitted by an agency
under subparagraph (C)(iii) and any documents listed in
the index which any party or amicus curiae appearing
before the court in the action submits to the court.
(3) Public hearings permitted.--
(A) In general.--After providing notice in the
Federal Register and online, an agency may hold a
public hearing regarding whether to enter into a
proposed covered consent decree or settlement
agreement.
(B) Record.--If an agency holds a public hearing
under subparagraph (A)--
(i) the agency shall--
(I) submit to the court a summary of
the proceedings;
(II) submit to the court a certified
index of the hearing record; and
(III) provide access to the hearing
record to the court; and
(ii) the full hearing record shall be
included in the court record.
(4) Mandatory deadlines.--If a proposed covered consent
decree or settlement agreement requires an agency action by a
date certain, the agency shall, when moving for entry of the
covered consent decree or settlement agreement or dismissal
based on the covered consent decree or settlement agreement,
inform the court of--
(A) any required regulatory action the agency has not
taken that the covered consent decree or settlement
agreement does not address;
(B) how the covered consent decree or settlement
agreement, if approved, would affect the discharge of
the duties described in subparagraph (A); and
(C) why the effects of the covered consent decree or
settlement agreement on the manner in which the agency
discharges its duties is in the public interest.
(e) Submission by the Government.--
(1) In general.--For any proposed covered consent decree or
settlement agreement that contains a term described in
paragraph (2), the Attorney General or, if the matter is being
litigated independently by an agency, the head of the agency
shall submit to the court a certification that the Attorney
General or head of the agency approves the proposed covered
consent decree or settlement agreement. The Attorney General or
head of the agency shall personally sign any certification
submitted under this paragraph.
(2) Terms.--A term described in this paragraph is--
(A) in the case of a covered consent decree, a term
that--
(i) converts into a nondiscretionary duty a
discretionary authority of an agency to
propose, promulgate, revise, or amend
regulations;
(ii) commits an agency to expend funds that
have not been appropriated and that have not
been budgeted for the regulatory action in
question;
(iii) commits an agency to seek a particular
appropriation or budget authorization;
(iv) divests an agency of discretion
committed to the agency by statute or the
Constitution of the United States, without
regard to whether the discretion was granted to
respond to changing circumstances, to make
policy or managerial choices, or to protect the
rights of third parties; or
(v) otherwise affords relief that the court
could not enter under its own authority upon a
final judgment in the civil action; or
(B) in the case of a covered settlement agreement, a
term--
(i) that provides a remedy for a failure by
the agency to comply with the terms of the
covered settlement agreement other than the
revival of the civil action resolved by the
covered settlement agreement; and
(ii) that--
(I) interferes with the authority of
an agency to revise, amend, or issue
rules under the procedures set forth in
chapter 5 of title 5, United States
Code, or any other statute or Executive
order prescribing rulemaking procedures
for a rulemaking that is the subject of
the covered settlement agreement;
(II) commits the agency to expend
funds that have not been appropriated
and that have not been budgeted for the
regulatory action in question; or
(III) for such a covered settlement
agreement that commits the agency to
exercise in a particular way discretion
which was committed to the agency by
statute or the Constitution of the
United States to respond to changing
circumstances, to make policy or
managerial choices, or to protect the
rights of third parties.
(f) Review by Court.--
(1) Amicus.--A court considering a proposed covered consent
decree or settlement agreement shall presume, subject to
rebuttal, that it is proper to allow amicus participation
relating to the covered consent decree or settlement agreement
by any person who filed public comments or participated in a
public hearing on the covered consent decree or settlement
agreement under paragraph (2) or (3) of subsection (d).
(2) Review of deadlines.--
(A) Proposed covered consent decrees.--For a proposed
covered consent decree, a court shall not approve the
covered consent decree unless the proposed covered
consent decree allows sufficient time and incorporates
adequate procedures for the agency to comply with
chapter 5 of title 5, United States Code, and other
applicable statutes that govern rulemaking and, unless
contrary to the public interest, the provisions of any
Executive order that governs rulemaking.
(B) Proposed covered settlement agreements.--For a
proposed covered settlement agreement, a court shall
ensure that the covered settlement agreement allows
sufficient time and incorporates adequate procedures
for the agency to comply with chapter 5 of title 5,
United States Code, and other applicable statutes that
govern rulemaking and, unless contrary to the public
interest, the provisions of any Executive order that
governs rulemaking.
(g) Annual Reports.--Each agency shall submit to Congress an annual
report that, for the year covered by the report, includes--
(1) the number, identity, and content of covered civil
actions brought against and covered consent decrees or
settlement agreements entered against or into by the agency;
and
(2) a description of the statutory basis for--
(A) each covered consent decree or settlement
agreement entered against or into by the agency; and
(B) any award of attorneys fees or costs in a civil
action resolved by a covered consent decree or
settlement agreement entered against or into by the
agency.
SEC. 4. MOTIONS TO MODIFY CONSENT DECREES.
If an agency moves a court to modify a covered consent decree or
settlement agreement and the basis of the motion is that the terms of
the covered consent decree or settlement agreement are no longer fully
in the public interest due to the obligations of the agency to fulfill
other duties or due to changed facts and circumstances, the court shall
review the motion and the covered consent decree or settlement
agreement de novo.
SEC. 5. EFFECTIVE DATE.
This Act shall apply to--
(1) any covered civil action filed on or after the date of
enactment of this Act; and
(2) any covered consent decree or settlement agreement
proposed to a court on or after the date of enactment of this
Act.
Purpose and Summary
H.R. 3446, the Sunshine for Regulatory Decrees and
Settlements Act of 2023, introduced by Rep. Victoria Spartz (R-
IN), will check problematic sue and settle arrangements and
related settlement-driven rulemaking by ensuring that federal
agencies are transparent in such rulemaking and by imposing
other requirements.
Background and Need for the Legislation
Pro-regulatory private parties, such as activist
environmental groups, often use sue and settle tactics to
obtain favorable agency actions.\1\ For example, these
organizations sue agencies for failure to timely promulgate
rules necessitated by statute. The agency then settles with the
private party. However, the terms of the settlement can bind
the agency's discretion, including discretion in rulemaking,
and can limit the need to account for public feedback, which
achieves the private party's preferred policy outcomes with
less transparency.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Government Litigation and the Need for Reform: Hearing Before
the Subcomm. On the Const. and Limited Gov't of the H. Comm. on the
Judiciary, 118th Cong. (2023) (testimony of Andrew Grossman, Partner,
Baker Hostetler, at 1) [hereinafter Grossman Testimony].
\2\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
By statute, Congress often requires agencies to meet
certain deadlines for promulgating rules.\3\ The same statutes
that establish an agency's rulemaking deadlines can include a
clause authorizing citizen suits by qualifying parties if the
agency fails to meet those deadlines.\4\ While the goal of the
deadline is to spur prompt agency action, the threat of a
lawsuit does not always have its intended effect. In some
cases, the agency may not have a sufficient incentive to act
quickly due to agency priorities, resource constraints, or
other factors. These competing interests result in agencies
acting on a different schedule than Congress required,\5\
making the agency vulnerable to lawsuits for inaction.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Jacob Gersen & Anne Joseph O'Connell, Deadlines in
Administrative Law, 156 U. Pa. L. Rev. 923, 925 (2008).
\4\David B. Rivkin Jr. & Adam Doverspike, Do Sue and Settle
Practices Undermine Congressional Intent for Cooperative Federalism on
Environmental Matters?, 15 Federalist Soc'y Rev. 2, 39 (2014) (citing
42 U.S.C. Sec. 7604(a)(2); 33 U.S.C. Sec. 1365(a)(2)).
\5\See Grossman Testimony, at 1-2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Certain pro-regulatory private parties have become experts
at leveraging citizen suits--not just to force the agency to
meet its deadlines, but also to achieve the plaintiffs' desired
policy objectives.\6\ To settle these citizen suits, agencies
may agree to issue new regulations (effectively written in
conjunction with the plaintiffs) in ways that are inconsistent
with the notice-and-comment process that Congress established
for rulemaking.\7\ Rather than risk the strictures of a court
order mandating an outcome the agency may dislike, the agency
and the plaintiff settle on a mutually agreed upon policy
approach that binds the agency in ways the plaintiff favors.\8\
Such settlements can have a significant effect on rulemaking,
but without the same public scrutiny other agency rulemaking
receives--leading to policy outcomes not intended by Congress
but which agency bureaucrats favor.\9\ These types of
settlements can reward private interests and hinder an agency's
fulfillment of its broader mandate.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\See generally id. at 1-2.
\7\See Rivken & Doverspike, supra note 4, at 39, 41.
\8\See Jim Rossi, Bargaining in the Shadow of Administrative
Procedure: The Public Interest in Rulemaking Settlement, 51 Duke L. J.
1015, 1016 (2001).
\9\See id. at 1016-17.
\10\See Grossman Testimony, at 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
One example of how sue and settle cases lead to abuse
occurred when WildEarth Guardians and the Center for Biological
Diversity advocated that the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
(FWS) implement the Endangered Species Act to include hundreds
of additional species.\11\ When FWS did not issue its
rulemaking timely under the authorizing legislation, the two
groups sued the agency and negotiated an agreement that allowed
the two entities to dictate the agency's priorities--which also
diverted much of FWS's funds to the entities' projects.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\See generally Examining `Sue and Settle' Agreements: Part I:
Joint Hearing Before the Subcomm. on the Interior, Energy and Env't.
and the Subcomm. on Intergovernmental Aff. of the H. Comm. on Oversight
and Gov't. Reform, 115th Cong. (2017).
\12\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On June 6, 2023, Mr. Andrew Grossman, a partner at Baker
Hostetler, testified on the issue of sue and settle at a
hearing of the Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited
Government of the Committee on the Judiciary. Mr. Grossman
testified that sue and settle ``raises serious concerns about
the conduct and resolution of litigation that seeks to compel
agency action, set agency priorities, and (in some instances)
influence the content of regulations or other agencies
actions.''\13\ He supported the policy of the H.R. 3446 in his
testimony.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Grossman Testimony, at 1.
\14\Id. at 11.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6)(A) of House rule XIII, a
hearing titled ``Government Litigation and the Need for
Reform,'' was held on June 6, 2023, before the Subcommittee on
the Constitution and Limited Government of the Committee on the
Judiciary. The Subcommittee heard testimony from the following
witnesses:
Kirby West, Attorney, Institute for Justice
Andrew Grossman, Partner, Baker Hostetler
John Shu, Attorney and Legal Commentator
Todd Phillips, Principal, Phillips Policy
Consulting, LLC
The hearing addressed how different aspects of government
litigation, including sue and settle tactics, require reform.
Committee Consideration
On June 14, 2023, the Committee met in open session and
order the bill, H.R. 3446, favorably reported with an amendment
in the nature of a substitute, by a roll call vote of 14 to 10,
a quorum being present.
Committee Votes
In compliance with clause 3(b) of House rule XIII, the
following roll call votes occurred during the Committee's
consideration of H.R. 3446:
1. Vote on Amendment #1 to H.R. 3446 ANS offered by Mr.
Johnson of Georgia--failed 10 ayes to 14 nays.
2. Vote on Amendment #2 to H.R. 3446 ANS offered by Mr.
Ivey--failed 11 ayes to 13 nays.
3. Vote on Amendment #3 to H.R. 3446 ANS offered by Mr.
Neguse--failed 9 ayes to 15 nays.
4. Vote on favorably reporting H.R. 3446, as amended--
passed 14 ayes to 10 nays.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Committee Oversight Findings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee advises that the findings and recommendations of the
Committee, based on oversight activities under clause 2(b)(1)
of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives, are
incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures
Clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives does not apply where a cost estimate and
comparison prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office under section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974 has been timely submitted prior to filing of the report
and is included in the report. Such a cost estimate is included
in this report.
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate
With respect to the requirement of clause 3(c)(3) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and section
402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the Committee has
received the enclosed cost estimate for H.R. 3446 from the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office:
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
H.R. 3446 would modify the process used to develop consent
decrees and settlement agreements that compel federal agencies
to take specified regulatory actions. Under the bill, a summary
of all such complaints against federal agencies, the terms of
covered agreements, and awards of attorneys' fees would need to
be published in an electronic format and would be subject to
public comment prior to filing with federal courts. The bill
also would require that negotiations over covered actions be
conducted through mediation or alternative dispute resolution
programs and would require federal agencies to submit reports
to the Congress describing the statutory basis and details of
the agreements into which they enter. Finally, agencies would
need to certify to courts their approval of those agreements,
and if agencies seek modifications of an agreement courts would
be required to perform a complete review as if the modified
agreement were a new one.
Using information from the Department of Justice (DOJ)
about the number of covered agreements litigated in recent
years and the average workload for those cases, CBO expects
that the bill would affect roughly 10 to 20 actions annually.
On average, CBO estimates that the cost to perform the
additional work under the bill would average about $80,000 per
case. Most of those additional costs would arise because
litigation would probably take longer under the bill and
agencies would face additional administrative requirements,
including the requirements for undergoing mediation, taking
public comment, and reporting to the Congress. CBO expects that
most of the additional workload incurred under the bill would
be performed by attorneys and other staff at DOJ. In total, CBO
estimates that implementing H.R. 3446 would cost $6 million
over the 2024-2028 period; that spending would be subject to
the availability of appropriated funds.
Enacting H.R. 3446 could affect direct spending. Under
several statutes, successful plaintiffs are entitled to
repayment of attorneys' fees through the Treasury's Judgment
Fund. Because the bill would lengthen the process of developing
agreements for some cases, the amount of reimbursable
attorneys' fees could increase. However, the increased length
of the process to finalize those actions might deter some
future lawsuits and decrease the number of future cases. On
net, CBO expects that the number of affected cases would be
small and that enacting the bill would increase direct spending
by less than $500,000 in every year and over the 2024-2033
period.
Finally, the bill could change the number of negotiated
settlements that occur. CBO does not have a basis for
projecting costs or savings for the federal government arising
from any change in the number of such settlements under the
bill.
The CBO staff contact for this estimate is Jon Sperl. The
estimate was reviewed by H. Samuel Papenfuss, Deputy Director
of Budget Analysis.
Phillip L. Swagel,
Director, Congressional Budget Office.
Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(d)(1) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section
402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII, no provision
of H.R. 3446 establishes or reauthorizes a program of the
federal government known to be duplicative of another federal
program.
Performance Goals and Objectives
The Committee states that pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of
House rule XIII, H.R. 3446 would check problematic sue and
settle arrangements and related settlement-driven rulemaking by
ensuring that federal agencies are transparent in such
rulemaking and by imposing other requirements.
Advisory on Earmarks
In accordance with clause 9 of House rule XXI, H.R. 3446
does not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in clauses
9(d), 9(e), or 9(f) of House Rule XXI.
Federal Mandates Statement
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act (Pub. L. 104-
1).
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short Title. This section sets forth the short
title of the bill as the ``Sunshine for Regulatory Decrees and
Settlements Act of 2023.''
Section 2. Definitions. This section establishes
definitions for the terms ``agency,'' ``agency action,''
``covered civil action,'' ``covered consent decree,'' ``covered
consent decree or settlement agreement,'' and ``covered
settlement agreement.''
Section 3. Consent Decree And Settlement Reform. This
section includes a number of reforms to agency consent decrees
and settlements:
Subsection (a), Pleadings and preliminary matters
Requires an agency being sued to publish a
notice of intent to sue and a copy of the complaint in
a readily accessible manner within 15 days of receiving
service.
Prohibits a party from moving to enter a
covered consent decree or to dismiss a civil action
pursuant to a covered settlement agreement until after
certain requirements are met.
Subsection (b), Intervention
Establishes a rebuttable presumption that
persons filing a motion to intervene and alleging an
interest in the proceeding would not have their
interests represented by the present parties.
Requires a court to consider whether a state,
local, or tribal government seeking intervention
administers relevant statutory provisions jointly with
the agency defendant, or administers an authority the
relevant regulatory action would preempt.
Subsection (c), Settlement negotiations
Requires settlement negotiations to be
conducted under the alternative dispute resolution
program of the court, or by a district judge who is not
adjudicating the civil action.
Requires settlement negotiations to include
any party that intervenes in the action.
Subsection (d), Publication of and comment on covered
consent decrees or settlement agreements
Requires, no later than 60 days before a
settlement's filing with the court, that the agency
publish in the Federal Register and online the consent
decree or settlement agreement and a statement
providing the relevant statutory basis and description
of terms.
Requires that any agency seeking to enter a
consent decree or settlement accept public comment on
such and respond to all comments.
Requires that, when the agency moves that the
court enter the consent decree or settlement agreement,
that the agency: (i) inform the court of the relevant
statutory basis and terms; (ii) submit to the court a
summary of comments received and agency response; and
(iii) submit and make the administrative record
accessible.
Requires the court to include in the court's
record the agency's submitted index of the
administrative record.
Allows the agency to hold a public hearing
about the proposed consent decree or settlement
agreement and sets forth requirements related to the
hearing record.
If the consent decree or settlement agreement
requires agency action by a date certain, the agency
must inform the court of any required regulatory action
the agency has failed to take and must provide related
analysis.
Subsection (e), Submission by the government
Requires that the Attorney General or agency
head certify approval for covered consent decrees or
settlement agreements that contain certain terms.
Subsection (f), Review by court
Establishes a rebuttable presumption that it
is proper to allow amicus participation of a person who
filed public comments or participated in a public
hearing relating to a covered consent decree or
settlement agreement.
Requires the court to ensure that the consent
decree or settlement agreement allows enough time for
the agency to comply with statutory rulemaking
requirements.
Subsection (g), Annual reports
Requires each agency to submit an annual
report describing civil actions brought against the
agency and consent decrees or settlement agreements
entered into by the agency, and the statutory basis for
each consent decree or settlement agreement and any
attorney's fees or costs awarded.
Section 4. Motions To Modify Consent Decrees. This section
requires courts to review consent decrees and settlement
agreements de novo when an agency moves for modification for
specific reasons.
Section 5. Effective Date. Makes the Act applicable to any
civil action filed on or after the date of enactment, and to
any consent decree or settlement agreement proposed to a court
on or after the date of enactment.
Dissenting Views
Introduction
For the fifth time in 11 years, the Majority has chosen
once again to advance the so-called ``Sunshine for Regulatory
Decrees and Settlements Act,'' a proposal that, if enacted,
would put the American people at grave risk of harm from a vast
array of threats. This bill, which is H.R. 3446 this Congress,
is the latest effort in the Republicans' longstanding canon of
proposals to protect corporate interests by undermining
environmental, health, safety, and consumer protections enacted
through the agency rulemaking process.
Regulations protect Americans from a wide array of risks
that confront them in their daily lives--ranging from toxic air
and water to defective cars, unsafe workplaces, tainted baby
formula, dangerous medications, and financial fraud. Because
Republicans lack the popular support to undo these protections
outright, they have designed a series of bills--including H.R.
3446--to gum up the regulatory process by which agencies can
issue these lifesaving regulations.
H.R. 3446 follows this blueprint by imposing numerous and
unnecessary new procedural burdens on agencies and courts to
dissuade them from using consent decrees and settlement
agreements to resolve civil actions filed to compel agency
compliance with the law--civil actions that Congress authorized
to facilitate enforcement of its mandates.
Among these burdens are the requirements that agencies
solicit public comments on such proposed consent decrees and
settlement agreements and that they respond to each public
comment before submitting proposed consent decrees and
settlement agreements to the court. The bill would also require
courts to presume, subject to rebuttal, that almost any private
third party is entitled to intervene in litigation concerning a
regulatory action and would require that such third party be
permitted to participate in settlement negotiations between the
litigants.
Although H.R. 3446's proponents allege that agencies and
interest groups collude to ``sue and settle'' in order to avoid
compliance with the rulemaking procedures set forth in the
Administrative Procedure Act (APA),\1\ as well as other
statutes, no credible evidence supports this allegation.
Moreover, the allegation ignores long-established procedures
that circumscribe the ability of agencies to enter consent
decrees and settlement agreements. In addition to being
unnecessary, H.R. 3446 would effectively delay and possibly
derail agencies' efforts to implement congressionally mandated
public health and environmental safeguards. In addition, the
bill will encourage costly and wasteful litigation, leaving
American taxpayers to bear the expense. H.R. 3446 also
overrides the judiciary's traditional role in managing
litigation and resolving disputes equitably and efficiently.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\5 U.S.C. Sec. Sec. 551-59, 701-06, 1305, 3105, 3344, 5372, 7521.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In recognition of H.R. 3446's many serious flaws, the
Coalition for Sensible Safeguards--an alliance of more than 150
consumer, labor, research, faith, and other public-interest
groups--strongly opposed substantively identical legislation in
past Congresses, most recently in the 115th Congress, stating
that this bill ``would create a gauntlet of duplicative,
burdensome, and time-consuming procedures that apply to
settlements and decrees, once again slowing down the rulemaking
process and preventing federal law from being effectively
implemented.''\2\ Similarly, a coalition of 29 environmental
groups--including the Center for Biological Diversity,
Earthjustice, Environmental Defense Fund, and Sierra Club--
opposed the bill because it would ``undermine the enforcement
of federal laws and impede the resolution of various consumer
protection, anti-discrimination, environmental, and public
health cases before our federal courts.''\3\ In 2015, the Obama
Administration issued a veto threat against a substantively
identical proposal, stating that such proposal ``would impose
additional, unnecessary procedural requirements that would
seriously undermine the ability of agencies to execute their
statutory mandates,'' while addressing a ``nonexistent problem
that is already prohibited by Federal regulations: collusion
between agencies, interest groups, and the courts to avoid
compliance with the rulemaking procedures.''\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Letter to Rep. Bob Goodlatte (R-VA), Chair, & Rep. John Conyers,
Jr. (D-MI), Ranking Member, H. Comm. on the Judiciary, from the
Coalition for Sensible Safeguards (July 11, 2017) (on file with the H.
Comm. on the Judiciary, Democratic Staff); Coalition for Sensible
Safeguards, Members, http://sensiblesafeguards.org/about-us/members/
(last visited on Oct. 6, 2017).
\3\Letter to Rep. Bob Goodlatte (R-VA), Chair, & Rep. John Conyers,
Jr. (D-MI), Ranking Member, H. Comm. on the Judiciary, from 29 public-
interest organizations (July 11, 2017) (on file with the H. Committee
on the Judiciary, Democratic Staff).
\4\Executive Office of the President, Office of Management and
Budget, Statement of Administration Policy on H.R. 712, the ``Sunshine
for Regulatory Decrees and Settlements Act of 2015'' (2016), http://
www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/?pid=111576.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For these reasons and others discussed below, I strongly
oppose H.R. 3446 and I respectfully dissent from the
Committee's views on this legislation.
Description and Background
H.R. 3446, the ``Sunshine for Regulatory Decrees and
Settlements Act of 2023,'' is intended to address the alleged
problem of collusion between public-interest plaintiffs and
sympathetic federal agencies in entering into consent decrees
or settlement agreements that oblige the agency to take a
particular action regarding a regulatory action, such as a
rulemaking, often under a certain timeline. The bill's
proponents call this alleged phenomenon ``sue and settle.''
A description of the bill's substantive provisions, as
ordered reported, follows. Section 2 defines various terms. Of
significance, section 2(1) imports the definitions of
``agency'' and ``agency action'' from the APA. As a result,
H.R. 3446 would apply to executive branch as well as
independent agencies.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Independent regulatory agencies, as opposed to executive branch
agencies, are considered ``independent'' because the President has
limited authority to remove their leaders, who can only be removed for
cause, rather than simply serving at the President's pleasure. Such
agencies are usually styled ``commissions'' or ``boards'' (e.g.,
National Labor Relations Board, Securities and Exchange Commission).
Stephen G. Breyer et al., Administrative Law and Regulatory Policy 100
(4th ed. 1999).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 2(2) defines ``covered civil action'' as meaning a
civil action that: (1) seeks to compel agency action; (2)
alleges that an agency is unlawfully withholding or
unreasonably delaying ``agency action relating to a regulatory
action'' that affects the rights of private third parties or
state, local, or tribal governments; and (3) is brought
pursuant to the judicial review provisions of the APA or any
other statute authorizing judicial review of agency action. The
scope of and distinction between ``agency action'' and
``regulatory action'' are not entirely clear, nor is the
meaning of ``rights'' or ``private persons.'' Given that these
are threshold terms, their vagueness is likely to lead to
litigation over whether H.R. 3446's provisions apply to a given
proposed consent decree or settlement agreement.
Section 2(3) defines ``covered consent decree'' as a
consent decree in a covered civil action and any other consent
decree requiring agency action concerning a rulemaking or other
regulatory action that affects private third parties or state,
local, or tribal governments. Thus, H.R. 3446 would apply not
just to consent decrees in covered civil actions, but also in
matters that are not ``covered civil actions.''
Section 2(4) defines ``covered consent decree or settlement
agreement'' as a covered consent decree and a covered
settlement agreement. This definition's purpose is unclear.
Section 2(5) defines ``covered settlement agreement'' in a
manner similar to the definition for ``covered consent
decree,'' except that it applies to settlement agreements
rather than consent decrees. As with ``covered consent
decrees,'' this means that H.R. 3446 could apply to settlement
agreements in cases that are not ``covered civil actions''
under the bill.
Section 3 of the bill sets forth several new procedures
that agencies and parties in litigation must follow before a
court may enter a consent decree or settlement agreement, as
well as certain rebuttable presumptions that courts must make.
Section 3(a)(1) requires a defendant agency in a covered
civil action to post online a copy of the notice of intent to
sue and the complaint in the covered civil action not later
than 15 days after receiving service of each. Section 3(a)(2)
prohibits a party to a civil action from moving to enter a
covered consent decree or to dismiss a civil action pursuant to
a covered settlement agreement until after compliance with the
bill's notice and comment requirements or after a public
hearing allowed under the bill, whichever is later.
Section 3(b)(1) applies a unique standard for third-party
intervention in covered civil actions. Specifically, it
requires a court, when considering a motion to intervene in a
covered civil action or in a civil action in which a covered
consent decree or settlement agreement is proposed, to presume
that the interests of ``a person who alleges that the agency
action in dispute would affect the person'' would not be
adequately represented by the parties to the action. This
places the burden on the non-moving parties to show that they
can adequately represent the putative intervenor's interests,
in contrast to current law, which places the burden on the
party seeking intervention to demonstrate that its interests
are not adequately represented by the parties per Federal Rule
of Civil Procedure 24.
With respect to motions to intervene by state, local, and
tribal governments, section 3(b)(2) requires a court to ``take
due account of whether the movant'' jointly administers with a
defendant federal agency the statutory provisions giving rise
to the underlying lawsuit or administers under state, local, or
tribal law an authority that would be preempted by the
regulatory action at issue in the underlying lawsuit.
Section 3(c) outlines certain requirements regarding the
negotiation to settle a covered civil action or to reach an
agreement on a covered consent decree or settlement agreement.
Section 3(c)(1) requires that such negotiation be conducted
pursuant to the court's alternative dispute resolution program
or by a judge other than the presiding judge, a magistrate, or
a special master, as the presiding judge may determine.
Notably, section 3(c)(2) requires that such settlement
negotiations also include any intervening party.
Section 3(d) imposes a series of notice and comment
procedures on agencies before they can file a covered consent
decree or settlement agreement with a court. Section 3(d)(1)
requires an agency to publish in the Federal Register and post
online a proposed covered consent decree or settlement
agreement and a description of its terms (including whether it
provides for attorneys' fees or costs and a basis for such
award) at least 60 days before such consent decree or
settlement agreement is filed with a court.
Section 3(d)(2)(A) requires the agency to accept public
comment on any issue in the underlying civil action or
regarding the proposed consent decree or settlement agreement
during that minimum 60-day period provided for in section
3(d)(1). Section 3(d)(2)(B) requires the agency to respond to
any public comments. Section 3(d)(2)(C) requires an agency,
when moving to enter a proposed consent decree or settlement
agreement, to: (1) inform the court of the statutory basis for
the proposed consent decree or settlement agreement and a
summary of public comments that it has received; (2) submit to
the court a certified index of the administrative record of the
notice and comment proceeding; and (3) make the administrative
record available to the court. Finally, section 3(d)(2)(D)
requires the court to include in its record of the underlying
civil action the administrative record submitted by an agency,
as well as any documents listed in the index that any party or
amicus curiae appearing before the court submits.
Section 3(d)(3) allows an agency to hold a public hearing
on whether to enter into a proposed covered consent decree or
settlement agreement and outlines the procedures for holding
such a hearing.
Section 3(d)(4) requires an agency to present to the court
certain explanations before moving to enter a covered consent
decree or settlement agreement, or to dismiss the civil action
based on the covered consent decree or settlement agreement,
when the agency is required to take an action by a date certain
pursuant to such decree or settlement. The agency must
describe: (1) any required regulatory action that the agency
has not taken and that the decree or settlement does not
address; (2) a description of how the decree or settlement
would affect the discharge of such required regulatory action;
and (3) why the effects of the decree or settlement on the
discharge of required regulatory action would be in the public
interest.
Section 3(e) codifies long-standing guidelines, known as
the Meese Memo, that Justice Department and other agency
attorneys follow to ensure that they do not enter into consent
decrees or settlement agreements to circumvent the normal
rulemaking process. These guidelines are already codified in
the Code of Federal Regulations.\6\ Section 3(e)(1) provides
that if a covered consent decree or settlement agreement
contains certain terms as set forth in section 3(e)(2), the
Attorney General or the head of an independent agency
(depending on which agency is the litigating party) must submit
to the court a signed certification that he or she approves the
proposed consent decree or settlement agreement. Section
3(e)(2) sets forth the terms that would subject a proposed
covered decree or settlement to the certification requirement.
For covered consent decrees, these terms are those that: (1)
convert an agency's discretionary rulemaking authority into a
nondiscretionary rulemaking obligation; (2) commit an agency to
expend funds for the regulatory action at issue that have not
been appropriated and budgeted; (3) commit an agency to seek a
particular appropriation or budget authorization; (4) divest an
agency of discretion committed to it by statute or the
Constitution; or (5) affords relief that the court otherwise
would not have authority to grant. For covered settlement
agreements, the terms triggering the certification requirement
are those that: (1) remedy the agency's failure to comply with
the covered settlement agreement, other than a revival of the
underlying civil action; and (2) interferes with agency
rulemaking procedures under the APA, another statute, or
executive order; commits the agency to expend non-appropriated
and non- budgeted funds for the regulatory action at issue; or
commits the agency to exercise discretion in a particular way
when the discretion was committed to it by statute or the
Constitution to respond to changing circumstances, to make
policy or managerial choices, or to protect the rights of third
parties.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\28 C.F.R. Sec. Sec. 0.160-0.163.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 3(f) imposes certain requirements on courts with
respect to proposed covered consent decrees and settlement
agreements. Section 3(f)(1) requires a court reviewing a
proposed covered consent decree or settlement agreement to
presumptively allow amicus participation by any party who filed
public comments or participated in a public hearing regarding
such proposed decree or settlement. Section 3(f)(2) prohibits a
court from entering a covered consent decree or settlement
agreement unless it provides an agency sufficient time or
procedures for the agency to comply with the APA's rulemaking
procedures or other statutes and executive orders that govern
rulemaking.
Section 3(g) requires agencies to submit annual reports to
Congress that include the number, ``identity,'' and content of
covered civil actions brought against the agency as well as
covered consent decrees or settlement agreements that the
agency has entered into. Additionally, the report must describe
the statutory basis for each covered consent decree or
settlement agreement entered into by the agency and for any
award of attorneys' fees or costs in the underlying civil
action.
Section 4 of the bill specifies that when an agency moves
to modify a covered consent decree or settlement agreement
because it is no longer ``fully in the public interest due to
the obligations of the agency to fulfill other duties or due to
changed facts and circumstances,'' the court must review the
decree or settlement de novo.
Section 5 states that the bill's provisions apply to
covered civil actions filed on or after the bill's enactment
date. It further provides that the bill's provisions apply to
all covered consent decrees and covered settlement agreements
proposed on or after the bill's enactment date.
Concerns With H.R. 3446
I. H.R. 3446 IS A SOLUTION IN SEARCH OF A PROBLEM
H.R. 3446's proponents contend that this legislation is
needed because federal agencies allegedly intentionally collude
with public-interest organizations and other private-citizen
plaintiffs in entering into consent decrees or settlements as a
way of circumventing proper rulemaking procedures. Tellingly,
however, these proponents offer no credible proof in support of
their contention. For example, at the hearing on substantively
similar legislation in the 114th Congress, William Kovacs, then
a Senior Vice President at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce,
testified that as ``a result of the sue and settle process, the
agency intentionally transforms itself from an independent
actor that has discretion to perform its duties in a manner
best serving the public interest, into an actor subservient to
the binding terms of settlement agreements, including using its
congressionally-appropriated funds to achieve the demands of
specific outside groups.''\7\ In support of his statement,
rather than citing objective evidence, he cited the Chamber's
own 2013 study.\8\ Indeed, at the most recent hearing on this
legislation held in June 2023, Majo