Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 2794]
The Committee on Homeland Security, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 2794) to secure the international borders of the
United States, and for other purposes, having considered the
same, reports favorably thereon with an amendment and
recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 19
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 20
Hearings......................................................... 20
Committee Consideration.......................................... 21
Committee Votes.................................................. 21
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 30
Correspondence with Other Committees............................. 31
C.B.O. Estimate, New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and
Tax Expenditures............................................... 35
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 35
Duplicative Federal Programs..................................... 35
Statement of General Performance Goals and Objectives............ 35
Congressional Earmarks, Limited Tax Benefits, and Limited Tariff
Benefits....................................................... 35
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 35
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 35
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 35
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 44
Minority Views................................................... 66
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
(a) Short Title.--This Act may be cited as the ``Border Reinforcement
Act of 2023''.
(b) Table of Contents.--The table of contents for this Act is as
follows:
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
Sec. 2. Definitions.
Sec. 3. Border wall construction.
Sec. 4. Strengthening the requirements for barriers along the southern
border.
Sec. 5. Border and port security technology investment plan.
Sec. 6. Border security technology program management.
Sec. 7. U.S. Customs and Border Protection technology upgrades.
Sec. 8. U.S. Customs and Border Protection personnel.
Sec. 9. Anti-Border Corruption Act reauthorization.
Sec. 10. Establishment of workload staffing models for U.S. Border
Patrol and Air and Marine Operations of CBP.
Sec. 11. Operation Stonegarden.
Sec. 12. Air and Marine Operations flight hours.
Sec. 13. Eradication of carrizo cane and salt cedar.
Sec. 14. Border patrol strategic plan.
Sec. 15. U.S. Customs and Border Protection spiritual readiness.
Sec. 16. Restrictions on funding.
Sec. 17. Collection of DNA and biometric information at the border.
Sec. 18. Eradication of narcotic drugs and formulating effective new
tools to address yearly losses of life; ensuring timely updates to U.S.
Customs and Border Protection field manuals.
Sec. 19. Publication by U.S. Customs and Border Protection of
operational statistics.
Sec. 20. Alien criminal background checks.
Sec. 21. Prohibited identification documents at airport security
checkpoints; notification to immigration agencies.
Sec. 22. Prohibition against any COVID-19 vaccine mandate or adverse
action against DHS employees.
Sec. 23. CBP One app limitation.
Sec. 24. Report on designation of Mexican cartels as foreign terrorist
organizations.
Sec. 25. GAO study on costs incurred by States to secure the southwest
border.
Sec. 26. Report by Inspector General of the Department of Homeland
Security.
Sec. 27. Offsetting authorizations of appropriations.
Sec. 28. Report to Congress on foreign terrorist organizations.
Sec. 29. Assessment by Inspector General of the Department of Homeland
Security on the mitigation of unmanned aircraft systems at the
southwest border.
SEC. 2. DEFINITIONS.
In this Act:
(1) CBP.--The term ``CBP'' means U.S. Customs and Border
Protection.
(2) Commissioner.--The term ``Commissioner'' means the
Commissioner of U.S. Customs and Border Protection.
(3) Department.--The term ``Department'' means the Department
of Homeland Security.
(4) Operational control.--The term ``operational control''
has the meaning given such term in section 2(b) of the Secure
Fence Act of 2006 (Public Law 109-367; 8 U.S.C. 1701 note).
(5) Secretary.--The term ``Secretary'' means the Secretary of
Homeland Security.
(6) Situational awareness.--The term ``situational
awareness'' has the meaning given such term in section
1092(a)(7) of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal
Year 2017 (Public Law 114-328; 6 U.S.C. 223(a)(7)).
(7) Unmanned aircraft system.--The term ``unmanned aircraft
system'' has the meaning given such term in section 44801 of
title 49, United States Code.
SEC. 3. BORDER WALL CONSTRUCTION.
(a) In General.--
(1) Immediate resumption of border wall construction.--Not
later than seven days after the date of the enactment of this
section, the Secretary shall resume all activities related to
the construction of the border wall along the international
border between the United States and Mexico that were underway
or being planned for prior to January 20, 2021.
(2) Use of funds.--To carry out this section, the Secretary
shall expend all unexpired funds appropriated or explicitly
obligated for the construction of the border wall that were
appropriated or obligated, as the case may be, for use
beginning on October 1, 2019.
(3) Use of materials.--Any unused materials purchased before
the date of the enactment of this section for construction of
the border wall may be used for activities related to the
construction of the border wall in accordance with paragraph
(1).
(b) Plan to Complete Tactical Infrastructure and Technology.--Not
later than 90 days after the date of the enactment of this section and
annually thereafter until construction of the border wall has been
completed, the Secretary shall submit to the appropriate congressional
committees an implementation plan, including annual benchmarks for the
construction of 200 miles of such wall and associated cost estimates
for satisfying all requirements of the construction of the border wall,
including installation and deployment of tactical infrastructure,
technology, and other elements as identified by the Department prior to
January 20, 2021, through the expenditure of funds appropriated or
explicitly obligated, as the case may be, for use, as well as any
future funds appropriated or otherwise made available by Congress.
(c) Definitions.--In this section:
(1) Appropriate congressional committees.--The term
``appropriate congressional committees'' means the Committee on
Homeland Security and the Committee on Appropriations of the
House of Representatives and the Committee on Homeland Security
and Governmental Affairs and the Committee on Appropriations of
the Senate.
(2) Tactical infrastructure.--The term ``tactical
infrastructure'' includes boat ramps, access gates,
checkpoints, lighting, and roads associated with a border wall.
(3) Technology.--The term ``technology'' includes border
surveillance and detection technology, including linear ground
detection systems, associated with a border wall.
SEC. 4. STRENGTHENING THE REQUIREMENTS FOR BARRIERS ALONG THE SOUTHERN
BORDER.
Section 102 of the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant
Responsibility Act of 1996 (Division C of Public Law 104-208; 8 U.S.C.
1103 note) is amended--
(1) by amending subsection (a) to read as follows:
``(a) In General.--The Secretary of Homeland Security shall take such
actions as may be necessary (including the removal of obstacles to
detection of illegal entrants) to design, test, construct, install,
deploy, integrate, and operate physical barriers, tactical
infrastructure, and technology in the vicinity of the southwest border
to achieve situational awareness and operational control of the
southwest border and deter, impede, and detect unlawful activity.'';
(2) in subsection (b)--
(A) in the subsection heading, by striking ``Fencing
and Road Improvements'' and inserting ``Physical
Barriers'';
(B) in paragraph (1)--
(i) in the heading, by striking ``fencing''
and inserting ``barriers'';
(ii) by amending subparagraph (A) to read as
follows:
``(A) Reinforced barriers.--In carrying out this
section, the Secretary of Homeland Security shall
construct a border wall, including physical barriers,
tactical infrastructure, and technology, along not
fewer than 900 miles of the southwest border until
situational awareness and operational control of the
southwest border is achieved.'';
(iii) by amending subparagraph (B) to read as
follows:
``(B) Physical barriers and tactical
infrastructure.--In carrying out this section, the
Secretary of Homeland Security shall deploy along the
southwest border the most practical and effective
physical barriers, tactical infrastructure, and
technology available for achieving situational
awareness and operational control of the southwest
border.'';
(iv) in subparagraph (C)--
(I) by amending clause (i) to read as
follows:
``(i) In general.--In carrying out this
section, the Secretary of Homeland Security
shall consult with the Secretary of the
Interior, the Secretary of Agriculture,
appropriate representatives of State, Tribal,
and local governments, and appropriate private
property owners in the United States to
minimize the impact on natural resources,
commerce, and sites of historical or cultural
significance for the communities and residents
located near the sites at which physical
barriers, tactical infrastructure, and
technology are to be constructed. Such
consultation may not delay such construction
for longer than seven days.''; and
(II) in clause (ii)--
(aa) in subclause (I), by
striking ``or'' after the
semicolon at the end;
(bb) by amending subclause
(II) to read as follows:
``(II) delay the transfer to the
United States of the possession of
property or affect the validity of any
property acquisition by the United
States by purchase or eminent domain,
or to otherwise affect the eminent
domain laws of the United States or of
any State; or''; and
(cc) by adding at the end the
following new subclause:
``(III) create any right or liability
for any party.''; and
(v) by striking subparagraph (D);
(C) in paragraph (2)--
(i) by striking ``Attorney General'' and
inserting ``Secretary of Homeland Security'';
(ii) by striking ``this subsection'' and
inserting ``this section''; and
(iii) by striking ``construction of fences''
and inserting ``the construction of physical
barriers, tactical infrastructure, and
technology'';
(D) by amending paragraph (3) to read as follows:
``(3) Agent safety.--In carrying out this section, the
Secretary of Homeland Security, when designing, testing,
constructing, installing, deploying, integrating, and operating
physical barriers, tactical infrastructure, or technology,
shall incorporate such safety features into such design, test,
construction, installation, deployment, integration, or
operation of such physical barriers, tactical infrastructure,
or technology, as the case may be, that the Secretary
determines are necessary to maximize the safety and
effectiveness of officers and agents of the Department of
Homeland Security or of any other Federal agency deployed in
the vicinity of such physical barriers, tactical
infrastructure, or technology.''; and
(E) in paragraph (4), by striking ``this subsection''
and inserting ``this section'';
(3) in subsection (c)--
(A) by amending paragraph (1) to read as follows:
``(1) In general.--Notwithstanding any other provision of
law, the Secretary of Homeland Security shall waive all legal
requirements necessary to ensure the expeditious design,
testing, construction, installation, deployment, integration,
operation, and maintenance of the physical barriers, tactical
infrastructure, and technology under this section. The
Secretary shall ensure the maintenance and effectiveness of
such physical barriers, tactical infrastructure, or technology.
Any such action by the Secretary shall be effective upon
publication in the Federal Register.'';
(B) by redesignating paragraph (2) as paragraph (3);
and
(C) by inserting after paragraph (1) the following
new paragraph:
``(2) Notification.--Not later than seven days after the date
on which the Secretary of Homeland Security exercises a waiver
pursuant to paragraph (1), the Secretary shall notify the
Committee on Homeland Security of the House of Representatives
and the Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs
of the Senate of such waiver.''; and
(4) by adding at the end the following new subsections:
``(e) Technology.--In carrying out this section, the Secretary of
Homeland Security shall deploy along the southwest border the most
practical and effective technology available for achieving situational
awareness and operational control.
``(f) Definitions.--In this section:
``(1) Advanced unattended surveillance sensors.--The term
`advanced unattended surveillance sensors' means sensors that
utilize an onboard computer to analyze detections in an effort
to discern between vehicles, humans, and animals, and
ultimately filter false positives prior to transmission.
``(2) Operational control.--The term `operational control'
has the meaning given such term in section 2(b) of the Secure
Fence Act of 2006 (Public Law 109-367; 8 U.S.C. 1701 note).
``(3) Physical barriers.--The term `physical barriers'
includes reinforced fencing, the border wall, and levee walls.
``(4) Situational awareness.--The term `situational
awareness' has the meaning given such term in section
1092(a)(7) of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal
Year 2017 (Public Law 114-328; 6 U.S.C. 223(a)(7)).
``(5) Tactical infrastructure.--The term `tactical
infrastructure' includes boat ramps, access gates, checkpoints,
lighting, and roads.
``(6) Technology.--The term `technology' includes border
surveillance and detection technology, including the following:
``(A) Tower-based surveillance technology.
``(B) Deployable, lighter-than-air ground
surveillance equipment.
``(C) Vehicle and Dismount Exploitation Radars
(VADER).
``(D) 3-dimensional, seismic acoustic detection and
ranging border tunneling detection technology.
``(E) Advanced unattended surveillance sensors.
``(F) Mobile vehicle-mounted and man-portable
surveillance capabilities.
``(G) Unmanned aircraft systems.
``(H) Tunnel detection systems and other seismic
technology.
``(I) Fiber-optic cable.
``(J) Other border detection, communication, and
surveillance technology.
``(7) Unmanned aircraft system.--The term `unmanned aircraft
system' has the meaning given such term in section 44801 of
title 49, United States Code.''.
SEC. 5. BORDER AND PORT SECURITY TECHNOLOGY INVESTMENT PLAN.
(a) In General.--Not later than 180 days after the date of the
enactment of this section, the Commissioner, in consultation with
covered officials and border and port security technology stakeholders,
shall submit to the appropriate congressional committees a strategic 5-
year technology investment plan (in this section referred to as the
``plan''). The plan may include a classified annex, if appropriate.
(b) Contents of Plan.--The plan shall include the following:
(1) An analysis of security risks at and between ports of
entry along the northern and southern borders of the United
States.
(2) An identification of capability gaps with respect to
security at and between such ports of entry to be mitigated in
order to--
(A) prevent terrorists and instruments of terror from
entering the United States;
(B) combat and reduce cross-border criminal activity,
including--
(i) the transport of illegal goods, such as
illicit drugs; and
(ii) human smuggling and human trafficking;
and
(C) facilitate the flow of legal trade across the
s
Purpose and Summary
The security of our nation hinges on how effectively the
Federal government controls who and what enters the United
States both at and between the official ports of entry. The
Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is charged with the
critical mission to secure our nation's borders and ports of
entry against a wide array of domestic threats. A porous border
is a conduit for transnational criminal organizations, human
smugglers, and drug traffickers. Even more concerning, an open
border is a vulnerability that terrorists unequivocally attempt
to exploit.\1\ Supporting and overseeing DHS's efforts to
secure the nation's borders is a principal responsibility of
the House Committee on Homeland Security.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/stats/cbp-enforcement-statistics.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
For the last two and a half years, the United States has
experienced a record-breaking number of alien encounters,
apprehensions, drug seizures, and gotaways, both known and
unknown. Consequently, the need to find a permanent border
security solution is even more urgent in these crucial times.
The Committee maintains that operational control of our borders
must be achieved through smart deployments of physical
infrastructure, technology, and personnel.
H.R. 2794 specifically requires the Secretary of DHS to
immediately resume all activities related to the construction
of the border wall using previously appropriated, unexpired
funds. To avoid waste, the bill also allows for the use of
materials in relation to construction that were purchased prior
to the date of enactment. This legislation mandates technology
capability deployment tailored to the specific threats and
needs of frontline law enforcement.
H.R. 2794 is focused on the crux of this historic crisis
created by President Biden and Secretary Mayorkas. Frontline
agents are the most important border security resource at the
Nation's disposal. Tactical infrastructure and technology are
powerful force multipliers, but the goal of border security is,
and will always be, successful apprehension and interdiction.
For this reason, this bill mandates that the U.S. Border Patrol
employ no fewer than 22,000 full time equivalent agents, who
are barred from performing the duties of processing
coordinators. Hiring and retention of frontline personnel have
been serious challenges for the Department, most acutely within
the Border Patrol. This bill streamlines the way that veterans
of the United States Armed Forces, and existing law enforcement
officers can be hired by waiving the polygraph requirement to
help the agency meet these lofty personnel goals. Moreover, to
retain talented agents, the Committee has authorized retention
bonuses for certain qualifying U.S. Border Patrol agents.
While much of the narrative that surrounds border security
is rightly focused on efforts to secure the Southwest border,
the Committee also aims to take action concerning certain DHS
programs and activities that are wasteful or encourage illegal
activity, including restricting funding for non-governmental
organizations (NGOs) who enable and facilitate the Mexican
cartels' human and drug trafficking and smuggling practices.
Moreover, the law has been clear for decades that DHS is
required to complete a biometric exit system--with this bill,
the Committee remedies what the Biden Administration refuses to
enforce by requiring DHS certify to Congress its compliance
with biometrics and DNA requirements. Furthermore, the bill
necessitates DHS to ensure its access to criminal history
databases of all countries of origin and transit for aliens
encountered by CBP. Taking an all-encompassing approach, this
bill remedies many significant challenges facing DHS and within
its realm of jurisdiction, provides for a more secure nation
while simultaneously deterring illegal mass migration.
Background and Need for Legislation
Given that the number of aliens presenting at ports of
entry and illegal aliens entering the United States between
ports of entry has drastically increased over the past two and
a half years, the threat posed by drug cartels, transnational
criminal organizations, and known or suspected terrorists
remains extraordinarily high. Over the years, Congress has
appropriated billions of dollars to strengthen border security
through new investments in personnel, technology, and physical
infrastructure; nonetheless, our borders are measurably less
secure than they were several years ago under the prior
administration.
Rather than continue the flawed approaches of the current
administration, this bill provides DHS with a clear direction
to secure the border. This multi-layered approach is designed
to deter, detect, and help interdict illegal cross-border
activity at the border, especially between ports of entry where
the crisis is most prominent. This bill clearly and effectively
communicates Congress' intent: the United States will not
tolerate illicit activity at our borders.
Hearings
The Committee held the following hearings in the 118th
Congress that informed H.R. 2794:
On February 28, 2023, the Full Committee held a hearing
entitled ``Every State is a Border State: Examining Secretary
Mayorkas' Border Crisis.'' The Committee received testimony
from Rebecca Kiessling, Private Citizen; the Honorable Mark
Lamb, Sheriff of Pinal County, Arizona; Robert J. Trenschel,
President and CEO of Yuma Regional Medical Center; and David J.
Bier, Associate Director of Immigration Studies, CATO
Institute.
On March 15, 2023, the Full Committee held a field hearing
entitled ``Failure by Design: Examining Secretary Mayorkas'
Border Crisis.'' The Committee received testimony from the
Honorable Raul L. Ortiz, Chief, U.S. Border Patrol, U.S.
Department of Homeland Security; Steven W. Cagen, Assistant
Director, Countering Transnational Organized Crime, Homeland
Security Investigations, U.S. Immigration and Customs
Enforcement; Colonel Steven C. McCraw, Director, Texas
Department of Public Safety; Sheriff Brad Coe, Kinney County
Sheriff's Office; and Chris Cabrera, Vice President, National
Border Patrol Council.
On April 19, 2023, the Full Committee held a hearing
entitled ``A Review of the Fiscal Year 2024 Budget Request for
the Department of Homeland Security.'' The Committee received
testimony from the Honorable Alejandro Mayorkas, Secretary,
U.S. Department of Homeland Security.
Committee Consideration
The Committee met on Wednesday, April 26, 2023, a quorum
being present, to consider H.R. 2794 and ordered the measure to
be favorably reported to the House, as amended, by a recorded
vote of 18 yeas to 15 nays.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII requires the Committee to list the
recorded votes on the motion to report legislation and
amendments thereto.
1. An amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute offered by Mr. Menendez of New Jersey to
strike Section 3. The amendment failed by a recorded
vote of 12 Yeas to 14 Nays (Rollcall No. 5)
Committee Record Vote No. 5
Menendez of New Jersey Amendment No. 02 to Green (TN) Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 2794
Failed: 12 Yeas to 14 Nays
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Majority Members Vote Minority Members Vote
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. McCaul..................................... ............ Mr. Thompson (MS).................. Yea
Mr. Higgins, LA................................ Nay Ms. Jackson Lee.................... ............
Mr. Guest...................................... Nay Mr. Payne.......................... Yea
Mr. Bishop, NC................................. Nay Mr. Swalwell....................... Yea
Mr. Gimenez.................................... Nay Mr. Correa......................... Yea
Mr. Pfluger.................................... Nay Mr. Carter (LA).................... Yea
Mr. Garbarino.................................. Nay Mr. Thanedar....................... Yea
Ms. Greene.................................... Nay Mr. Magaziner...................... Yea
Mr. Gonzales (TX).............................. ............ Mr. Ivey........................... Yea
Mr. LaLota..................................... Nay Mr. Goldman........................ ............
Mr. Ezell...................................... ............ Mr. Garcia (CA).................... Yea
Mr. D'Esposito................................. ............ Mrs. Ramirez....................... Yea
Ms. Lee (FL)................................... Nay Mr. Menendez....................... Yea
Mr. Luttrell................................... Nay Ms. Clarke (NY).................... Yea
Mr. Strong..................................... Nay Ms. Titus.......................... Yea
Mr. Brecheen................................... Nay
Mr. Crane...................................... Nay
Mr. Green (TN) Chairman........................ Nay
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. An amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute offered by Mr. Carter of Louisiana to amend
Section 4. The amendment failed by a recorded vote of
14 Yeas to 16 Nays (Rollcall No. 6)
Committee Record Vote No. 6
Carter of Louisiana Amendment No. 03 to Green (TN) Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 2794
Failed: 14 Yeas to 16 Nays
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Majority Members Vote Minority Members Vote
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. McCaul..................................... ............ Mr. Thompson (MS).................. Yea
Mr. Higgins, LA................................ Nay Ms. Jackson Lee.................... Yea
Mr. Guest...................................... Nay Mr. Payne.......................... Yea
Mr. Bishop, NC................................. Nay Mr. Swalwell....................... Yea
Mr. Gimenez.................................... Nay Mr. Correa......................... Yea
Mr. Pfluger.................................... Nay Mr. Carter (LA)................... Yea
Mr. Garbarino.................................. Nay Mr. Thanedar....................... Yea
Ms. Greene..................................... Nay Mr. Magaziner...................... Yea
Mr. Gonzales (TX).............................. ............ Mr. Ivey........................... ............
Mr. LaLota..................................... Nay Mr. Goldman........................ Yea
Mr. Ezell...................................... Nay Mr. Garcia (CA).................... Yea
Mr. D'Esposito................................. Nay Mrs. Ramirez....................... Yea
Ms. Lee (FL)................................... Nay Mr. Menendez....................... Yea
Mr. Luttrell................................... Nay Ms. Clarke (NY).................... Yea
Mr. Strong..................................... Nay Ms. Titus.......................... Yea
Mr. Brecheen................................... Nay
Mr. Crane...................................... Nay
Mr. Green (TN) Chairman........................ Nay
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. An amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute offered by Mr. Garcia of California to
strike Section 16. The amendment failed by a recorded
vote of 12 Yeas to 15 Nays (Rollcall No. 7).
Committee Record Vote No. 7
Garcia of California Amendment No. 013 to Green (TN) Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 2794
Failed: 12 Yeas to 15 Nays
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Majority Members Vote Minority Members Vote
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. McCaul..................................... Nay Mr. Thompson (MS).................. Yea
Mr. Higgins, LA................................ Nay Ms. Jackson Lee.................... ............
Mr. Guest...................................... Nay Mr. Payne.......................... Yea
Mr. Bishop, NC................................. Nay Mr. Swalwell....................... ............
Mr. Gimenez.................................... Nay Mr. Correa......................... Yea
Mr. Pfluger.................................... Nay Mr. Carter (LA).................... Yea
Mr. Garbarino.................................. ............ Mr. Thanedar....................... Yea
Ms. Greene..................................... Nay Mr. Magaziner...................... Yea
Mr. Gonzales (TX).............................. ............ Mr. Ivey........................... Yea
Mr. LaLota..................................... ............ Mr. Goldman........................ Yea
Mr. Ezell...................................... Nay Mr. Garcia (CA).................... Yea
Mr. D'Esposito................................. Nay Mrs. Ramirez...................... Yea
Ms. Lee (FL)................................... Nay Mr. Menendez....................... Yea
Mr. Luttrell................................... Nay Ms. Clarke (NY).................... Yea
Mr. Strong..................................... Nay Ms. Titus.......................... ............
Mr. Brecheen................................... Nay
Mr. Crane...................................... Nay
Mr. Green (TN) Chairman........................ Nay
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4. An amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute offered by Mr. Guest of Mississippi to
clarify intent and prohibited services of Section 16.
The amendment was agreed to by a recorded vote of 17
Yeas to 15 Nays (Rollcall No. 8).
Committee Record Vote No. 8
Guest of Mississippi Amendment No. 08 to Green (TN) Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 2794
Agreed to: 17 Yeas to 15 Nays
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Majority Members Vote Minority Members Vote
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. McCaul..................................... Yea Mr. Thompson (MS).................. Nay
Mr. Higgins, LA................................ Yea Ms. Jackson Lee.................... Nay
Mr. Guest...................................... Yea Mr. Payne.......................... Nay
Mr. Bishop, NC................................. Yea Mr. Swalwell....................... Nay
Mr. Gimenez.................................... Yea Mr. Correa......................... Nay
Mr. Pfluger.................................... Yea Mr. Carter (LA).................... Nay
Mr. Garbarino.................................. Yea Mr. Thanedar....................... Nay
Ms. Greene..................................... Yea Mr. Magaziner...................... Nay
Mr. Gonzales (TX).............................. ............ Mr. Ivey........................... Nay
Mr. LaLota..................................... Yea Mr. Goldman........................ Nay
Mr. Ezell...................................... Yea Mr. Garcia (CA).................... Nay
Mr. D'Esposito................................. Yea Mrs. Ramirez....................... Nay
Ms. Lee (FL)................................... Yea Mr. Menendez....................... Nay
Mr. Luttrell................................... Yea Ms. Clarke (NY).................... Nay
Mr. Strong..................................... Yea Ms. Titus.......................... Nay
Mr. Brecheen................................... Yea
Mr. Crane...................................... Yea
Mr. Green (TN) Chairman........................ Yea
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5. An amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute offered by Mr. Thompson of Mississippi to
provide pay parity for CBP officers and Border Patrol
agents. The amendment failed by a recorded vote of 14
Yeas to 17 Nays (Rollcall No. 9).
Committee Record Vote No. 9
Thompson of Mississippi Amendment No. 032 to Green (TN) Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 2794
Failed: 14 Yeas to 17 Nays
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Majority Members Vote Minority Members Vote
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. McCaul..................................... Nay Mr. Thompson (MS).................. Yea
Mr. Higgins, LA................................ Nay Ms. Jackson Lee.................... Yea
Mr. Guest...................................... Nay Mr. Payne.......................... Yea
Mr. Bishop, NC................................. Nay Mr. Swalwell....................... Yea
Mr. Gimenez.................................... Nay Mr. Correa......................... Yea
Mr. Pfluger.................................... Nay Mr. Carter (LA).................... Yea
Mr. Garbarino.................................. Nay Mr. Thanedar....................... Yea
Ms. Greene..................................... Nay Mr. Magaziner...................... Yea
Mr. Gonzales (TX).............................. ............ Mr. Ivey........................... Yea
Mr. LaLota..................................... Nay Mr. Goldman........................ Yea
Mr. Ezell...................................... Nay Mr. Garcia (CA).................... Yea
Mr. D'Esposito................................. Nay Mrs. Ramirez....................... ............
Ms. Lee (FL)................................... Nay Mr. Menendez....................... Yea
Mr. Luttrell................................... Nay Ms. Clarke (NY).................... Yea
Mr. Strong..................................... Nay Ms. Titus.......................... Yea
Mr. Brecheen................................... Nay
Mr. Crane...................................... Nay
Mr. Green (TN) Chairman........................ Nay
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6. An amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute offered by Mr. Thompson of Mississippi to
adjust Border Patrol to CBP workforce staffing model.
The amendment failed by a recorded vote of 15 Yeas to
17 Nays (Rollcall No. 10).
Committee Record Vote No. 10
Thompson of Mississippi Amendment No. 06 to Green (TN) Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 2794
Failed: 15 Yeas to 17 Nays
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Majority Members Vote Minority Members Vote
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. McCaul..................................... Nay Mr. Thompson (MS).................. Yea
Mr. Higgins, LA................................ Nay Ms. Jackson Lee.................... Yea
Mr. Guest...................................... Nay Mr. Payne.......................... Yea
Mr. Bishop, NC................................. Nay Mr. Swalwell....................... Yea
Mr. Gimenez.................................... Nay Mr. Correa......................... Yea
Mr. Pfluger.................................... Nay Mr. Carter (LA).................... Yea
Mr. Garbarino.................................. Nay Mr. Thanedar....................... Yea
Ms. Greene..................................... Nay Mr. Magaziner...................... Yea
Mr. Gonzales (TX).............................. ............ Mr. Ivey........................... Yea
Mr. LaLota..................................... Nay Mr. Goldman........................ Yea
Mr. Ezell...................................... Nay Mr. Garcia (CA).................... Yea
Mr. D'Esposito................................. Nay Mrs. Ramirez....................... Yea
Ms. Lee (FL)................................... Nay Mr. Menendez....................... Yea
Mr. Luttrell................................... Nay Ms. Clarke (NY).................... Yea
Mr. Strong..................................... Nay Ms. Titus.......................... Yea
Mr. Brecheen................................... Nay
Mr. Crane...................................... Nay
Mr. Green (TN) Chairman........................ Nay
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7. An amendment to the Amendment in the Nature of a
Substitute offered by Mr. Thompson of Mississippi to
insert a new section at the end of the bill preserving
the rights of CBP employees to unionize. The amendment
failed by a recorded vote of 15 Yeas to 17 Nays
(Rollcall No. 11).
Committee Record Vote No. 11
Thompson of Mississippi Amendment No. 020 to Green (TN) Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute to H.R. 2794
Failed: 15 Yeas to 17 Nays
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Majority Members Vote Minority Members Vote
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mr. McCaul..................................... Nay Mr. Thompson (MS).................. Yea
Mr. Higgins, LA................................ Nay Ms. Jackson Lee.................... Yea
Mr. Guest...................................... Nay Mr. Payne.......................... Yea
Mr. Bishop, NC................................. Nay Mr. Swalwell....................... Yea
Mr. Gimenez.................................... Nay Mr. Correa......................... Yea
Mr. Pfluger.................................... Nay Mr. Carter (LA).................... Yea
Mr. Garbarino.................................. Nay Mr. Thanedar....................... Yea
Ms. Greene..................................... Nay Mr. Magaziner...................... Yea
Mr. Gonzales (TX).............................. ............ Mr. Ivey........................... Yea
Mr. LaLota..................................... Nay Mr. Goldman........................ Yea
Mr. Ezell...................................... Nay Mr. Garcia (CA).................... Yea
Mr. D'Esposito................................. Nay Mrs. Ramirez....................... Yea
Ms. Lee (FL)................................... Nay Mr. Menendez....................... Yea
Mr. Luttrell................................... Nay Ms. Clarke (NY).................... Yea
Mr. Strong..................................... Nay Ms. Titus.......................... Yea
Mr. Brecheen................................... Nay
Mr. Crane...................................... Nay
Mr. Green (TN) Chairman........................ Nay
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Minority Views
On behalf of Committee on Homeland Security Democrats, I
submit these Minority Views in opposition to H.R. 2794--a
cruel, extreme, and unworkable bill that doubles down on the
Trump Administration's failed, illegal, and inhumane MAGA
immigration and border policies.
On April 26, 2023, the Committee on Homeland Security met
for nearly 17 hours to consider H.R. 2794. The Majority
circulated the 69-page amendment in the nature of a substitute
(ANS) and the underlying bill just 15 minutes prior to when
required under Rule V of the Committee's Rules. It was the
first time Committee Democrats, the Department of Homeland
Security, and Customs and Border Protection (CBP) got to see a
measure that, if enacted, would upend border enforcement
operations and villainize not only vulnerable migrants, but
also the community and religious organizations working to
provide them with basic necessities. Furthermore, for all the
rhetoric from the Republicans about wanting to keep fentanyl
out of this country, the bill provides no resources to station
a single new officer in a port of entry--even though successive
Administrations have acknowledged that more than 90 percent of
this deadly drug come through ports of entry.
During the nearly 17 hours that the Committee met to
consider the Green ANS, Democrats offered 43 measures to remedy
significant shortcomings in the bill and append new provisions
to bolster CBP operations and build upon the Fiscal Year 2023
Omnibus Appropriations Act (Omnibus) which, under Democratic
leadership, provided over $17 billion to CBP to not only
enhance port of entry operations but also increase funding to
the U.S. Border Patrol by 17 percent. All 43 amendments were
rejected by Committee Republicans.
H.R. 2794 also doubles down on a failed strategy: wasting
money on Trump's impractical border wall--a wall Mexico did not
and will not pay for. The bill purports to pay for new wall
construction with unspent border wall balances but DHS has not
been able to identify any such funding. Further, Republicans
have failed to secure a Congressional Budget Office estimate to
provide a ballpark estimate of what it will cost to realize
Donald Trump's dream of a border wall. Regarding former-
President Trump's failed border policies, I would note that
Democrats offered an amendment to allow Committee Republicans
the opportunity to repudiate the Trump Administration's cruel
and ineffective Zero Tolerance family separation policy, but
all Committee Republicans opposed it.
Instead of providing bipartisan solutions to fix our broken
immigration system, H.R. 2794, along with the extreme MAGA
immigration bill advanced by Republicans on the House Judiciary
Committee, would tear at the fabric of American values by
drastically limiting asylum opportunities, while doing nothing
to create an orderly system. This xenophobic bill flies in the
face of religious values that Republicans claim to live by.
This cruel bill villainizes refugee relief organizations in
the United States and cuts off DHS funding for vital services
to immigrants. During consideration of H.R. 2794, Democrats
effectively argued that the bill punished local officials,
religious and other nonprofits--and even residents--who provide
basic care and support to children and families fleeing
horrific conditions we would never tolerate for ourselves or
our loved ones. Republicans protested but, well past midnight,
offered an amendment to alter the damaging language. Still,
even with the adoption of that amendment, offered by Mr. Guest,
H.R. 2794 would still bar DHS from providing funds to community
and religious organizations working with immigrants and
countless others that have provided life-saving services. The
Guest amendment fails to remedy address many far-reaching
consequences of the bill that Democrats highlighted--such as,
for example, a prohibition on DHS funds to FEMA's
nongovernmental disaster response partners for lodging or
transportation out of a disaster zone unless the organization
is able to verify the immigration status of all individuals it
assists.
Finally, I would note that during consideration of H.R.
2794, Democrats offered a range of amendments targeted at
improving the livelihood and wellbeing of the entire frontline
CBP workforce, and all were rejected. Republicans even rejected
an amendment I offered to increase the number of CBP Officers
at ports of entry by 1,700--the number needed according to
CBP's workforce staffing model. And while Republicans may tout
that H.R. 2794 would increase the number of Border Patrol
agents to 22,000, it does not undo the fact that at the same
time this measure was under consideration in Committee, House
Republicans approved legislation that would force DHS to cut
2,400 CBP Officers and Agents from its ranks.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Letter to the Honorable Rosa L. DeLauro from Zephranie Buetow,
Assistant Secretary for Legislative Affairs, U.S. Department of
Homeland Security (March 18, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
At best, H.R. 2794 is a cynical effort to exploit irregular
migration at the southwest border--which is expected to
intensify with the termination of Title 42 health
restrictions--to make political points with Donald Trump and
his devoted extreme MAGA base. The hardworking civil servants
who work to keep our borders secure deserve so much better.
Bennie G. Thompson,
Ranking Member,
Committee on Homeland Security.
[all]