Dissenting Views
[To accompany H.R. 4460]
The Committee on House Administration to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 4460) to amend the National Voter Registration
Act of 1993 and the Help America Vote Act of 2002 to ensure
that only eligible American citizens may participate in
elections for Federal office, and for other purposes, having
considered the same, reports favorably thereon without
amendment and recommends that the bill do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 2
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 3
Committee Action................................................. 13
Committee Consideration.......................................... 15
Committee Votes.................................................. 15
Statement of Constitutional Authority............................ 17
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 18
Statement of Budget Authority and Related Items.................. 18
Congressional Budget Office Estimate............................. 18
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 18
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 19
Advisory on Earmarks............................................. 19
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 19
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 19
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 19
Section-by-Section Analysis...................................... 19
Changes in Existing Law as Reported.............................. 20
Purpose and Summary
H.R. 4460, the Non-citizens: Outlawed from Voting in Our
Trusted Elections Act of 2023 or the NO VOTE for Non-Citizens
Act of 2023, introduced by Representative Morgan H. Griffith
(VA-09), prohibits the use of any federal taxpayer dollars to
support voting by non-citizens anywhere in the country,
regardless of State or local law that may otherwise permit non-
citizens to vote in a State-controlled election for State and/
or local offices. Specifically, this means that no federal
funds may be used to develop or maintain a voter registration
list that contains non-citizens or to develop or use a ballot
that is made available to non-citizens in elections where non-
citizens can vote. In effect, the NO VOTE For Non-Citizens Act
of 2023 would require bifurcated elections in any State that
permits non-citizens to vote in its State-controlled elections,
a federal election, where only eligible American citizens may
vote, and a State-controlled election, that allows non-citizens
to vote for State and/or local offices according to State law.
Further to this point, the NO VOTE for Non-Citizens Act of 2023
would impose an additional penalty on any such State by
reducing by 30 percent the amount of federal elections grant
funds available to support its citizen-only federal elections.
The legislation also clarifies that the National Voter
Registration Act allows States to remove noncitizens from their
voter rolls at any time. It requires any federal government
entity to provide States, upon request, with the information
relevant to the status of an individual as a registered voter
in federal elections. Finally, as noncitizens cannot serve on a
federal jury, the bill requires United States federal district
courts to transmit the names of noncitizens dismissed as
potential jurors to the relevant State Chief Election Official
so that they can ensure the individual is not listed on the
State's voter roll.
The U.S. Constitution protects the right of citizens of the
United States to vote, and federal law makes it unlawful for
noncitizens to vote in federal elections. As some local
jurisdictions permit noncitizens to vote in local elections,
this legislation clarifies that no federal dollars may be used
to fund those efforts and effectively requires States that
permit non-citizens to vote in their State-controlled elections
for State and/or local office to bifurcate their elections in
order to protect and reserve the federal franchise only for
eligible American citizens. As a further penalty, any such
State will also see reduced by 30 percent their share of any
future federal election grants, which can be used only to
support the state's citizen-only federal elections. States also
need access to the information necessary to remove noncitizens
from their voter rolls, which, in many cases, is maintained
only by the federal government. That is why the legislation
requires federal entities to provide information they possess
with respect to an individual's citizenship status to states
upon request and requires all United States federal district
courts to transmit the names of noncitizens dismissed as
potential jurors to the relevant state Chief Election Official
so that they can ensure the individual is not listed on the
state's voter roll.
Background
Article I, Section 4 of the United States Constitution\1\
(``the Elections Clause'') explains that the States have the
primary authority over election administration, the ``times,
places, and manner of holding elections[.]'' Conversely, the
Constitution grants the Congress a purely secondary role to
alter or create election laws only in the extreme cases of
invasion, legislative neglect, or obstinate refusal to pass
election laws.\2\ As do other aspects of our federal system,
this division of sovereignty continues to serve to protect one
of Americans' most precious freedoms, the right to vote.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\U.S. Const. art. I, Sec. 4, cl. 1 (``[t]he Times, Places and
Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be
prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress
may at any time by Law make or alter such Regulations . . .'').
Further, Article II, Section I gives States the power to appoint
presidential and vice-presidential electors in a manner that their
legislature may direct. See U.S. Const. art. II, Sec. 1, cl. 2. As with
the Elections Clause, Congress has limited power over the selection of
presidential and vice-presidential electors.
\2\Although the text of the Elections Clause, read literally and
without the benefit of context, might suggest Congress has unlimited
authority in this space, an examination of an examination of history,
precedent, the Framers' words, debates concerning ratification, the
Supreme Court, and the Constitution itself provide that this is not the
case. See Report: The Elections Clause: States' Primary Constitutional
Authority Over Elections, Comm. on H. Admin. (Republicans) (Aug. 12,
2021), https://republicanscha.house.gov/sites/
republicans.cha.house.gov/files/documents/
Report_The%20Elections%20Clause_States%20Primary%20Constitutional%20
Authority%20over%20Elections%20%28Aug%2011%202021%29.pdf.
\3\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The federal Constitution contains several voting rights
amendments, all of which only protect ``the right of citizens
of the United States'' in the voting process.\4\ To enforce
those rights, federal law makes it unlawful for non-citizens to
vote in federal elections.\5\ Similarly, federal law prohibits
foreign nationals\6\ from contributing or donating in
connection with a federal, state, or local election,\7\ making
a contribution or donation to a committee of a political
party,\8\ or making an expenditure (including an independent
expenditure) or disbursement for an electioneering
communication.\9\ Although the Supreme Court of the United
States has never been presented with the question whether the
foreign national prohibition violates the First Amendment, it
has previously affirmed a three-judge court's decision,
authored by then-Judge Kavanaugh, that upheld the foreign
national prohibition with respect to foreign nationals who
wanted to make contributions to federal and State
candidates.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\See U.S. Const. Amend. XV, Sec. 1 ``The right of citizens of the
United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United
States or by any State on account of race, color, or previous condition
of servitude.''; U.S. Const. Amend. XIX, Sec. 1 ``The right of citizens
of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the
United States or by any State on account of sex.''; U.S. Const. Amend.
XXIV, Sec. 1 ``The right of citizens of the United States to vote in
any primary or other election for President or Vice President, for
electors for President or Vice President, or for Senator or
Representative in Congress, shall not be denied or abridged by the
United States or any State by reason of failure to pay any poll tax or
other tax.''; U.S. Const. Amend. XXVI, Sec. 1 ``The right of citizens
of the United States, who are eighteen years of age or older, to vote
shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on
account of age.''
\5\See 18 U.S.C. Sec. 611. Each of the voting rights amendments
listed in the previous footnote provide the authority for Congress to
enforce the amendment by appropriate legislation. In South Carolina v.
Katzenbach, the Supreme Court held that Congress has the power to act
under this authority as it would any of its powers under Article I,
Section 8 as articulated in McCulloch v. Maryland. See South Carolina
v. Katzenbach, 383, U.S. 301, 326-27 (1966). Even if a State has the
sovereign authority, no State should permit non-citizens to cast
ballots in State or local elections. See U.S. Const. Amend. XIV; U.S.
Const. Amend. XV; U.S. Const. Amend. XIX; U.S. Const. Amend. XXIV; U.S.
Const. Amend. XXVI.
\6\Federal law defines foreign national as an individual who is not
a citizen of the United States and not lawfully admitted for permanent
residence under 8 U.S.C. Sec. 1101(a)(20) or a foreign principal, as
defined in 22 U.S.C. Sec. 611(b).
\7\52 U.S.C. Sec. 30121(a)(1)(A).
\8\Id. at Sec. 30121(a)(1)(B).
\9\Id. at Sec. 30121(a)(1)(C). Federal law defines an
electioneering communication as ``any broadcast, cable, or satellite
communication which--refers to a clearly identified candidate for
Federal office; is made within--60 days before a general, special, or
runoff election for the office sought by the candidate; or 30 days
before a primary or preference election, or a convention or caucus of a
political party that has authority to nominate a candidate, for the
office sought by the candidate; and in the case of a communication
which refers to a candidate for an office other than President or Vice
President, is targeted to the relevant electorate.'' Id. at
Sec. 30104(f)(3).
\10\See Bluman v. FEC, 800 F. Supp. 2d 281, 288 (D.D.C. 2011),
aff'd, 565 U.S. 1104 (2012). Importantly, the three-judge decision did
not rely on Congress' power under the Elections Clause of Article I,
Section 4 to justify the foreign national spending prohibition. On
November 30, 2023, the U.S. House of Representatives Committee on House
Administration passed H.R. 3229, Stop Foreign Funds in Elections Act
out of committee. That legislation prohibits foreign nationals from
making a contribution or donation of money or other thing of value, or
to make an express or implied promise to make a contribution or
donation to a State or local ballot initiative, referendum, or recall
election. Like the decision referenced above, the Committee does not
believe H.R. 3229 would be enacted pursuant to the Elections Clause.
Cf. Report: The Elections Clause: States' Primary Constitutional
Authority Over Elections, Comm. on H. Admin. (Republicans) (Aug. 12,
2021),https://republicanscha.house.gov/sites/republicans.cha.house.gov/
files/documents/
Report_The%20Elections%20Clause_States%20Primary%20Constitutional%20
Authority%20over%20Elections%20%28Aug%2011%202021%29.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While the Elections Clause provides States the primary
authority over election administration, it and other
constitutional provisions also provide States the power to
establish voter qualifications. Specifically, ``Article I,
Sec. 2, cl. 1, provides that electors in each State for the
House of Representatives `shall have the Qualifications
requisite for Electors of the most numerous Branch of the State
Legislature,' and the Seventeenth Amendment adopts the same
criterion for senatorial elections.''\11\ Similarly, Article II
gives State legislatures the power to appoint presidential
electors\12\ and every State has delegated this responsibility
to its voters.\13\ States can establish voter qualifications
for voters voting in a presidential election that do not run
afoul of other constitutional commands.\14\ These explicit
constitutional commands make clear that States are given the
authority to establish voter qualifications, not Congress; a
principle the Supreme Court has reaffirmed twice in the past
decade.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Ariz., Inc, 133 S.Ct. 2247,
2258 (2013).
\12\U.S. Const. Art. II, Sec. 1, cl. 2 ``Each state shall appoint,
in such manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a number of
electors . . .'' See also Bush v. Gore, 531 U.S. 98, 104 (2000) (``The
individual citizen has no federal constitutional right to vote for
electors for the President of the United States unless and until the
state legislature chooses a statewide election as the means to
implement its power to appoint members of the electoral college.'')
\13\See Chiafalo v. Washington, 140 S.Ct. 2316, 2328 (2020)
(``State election laws evolved to reinforce that development, ensuring
that a State's electors would vote the same way as its citizens. As
noted earlier, state legislatures early dropped out of the picture; by
the mid-1800s, ordinary voters chose electors.'').
\14\See Williams v. Rhodes, 393 U.S. 23, 28-29 (1968) (``State laws
enacted pursuant to Art. II, Sec. 1, of the Constitution to regulate
the selection of electors must meet the requirements of the Equal
Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.'') See also Bush v.
Gore, 531, U.S. 98, 104-05 (``The right to vote is protected in more
than the initial allocation of the franchise. Equal protection applies
as well to the manner of its exercise. Having once granted the right to
vote on equal terms, the State may not, by later arbitrary and
disparate treatment, value one person's vote over that of another.'').
\15\See Inter Tribal Council of Ariz., Inc, 133 S.Ct. at 2258;
Husted v. A. Phillip Randolph Institute, 138 S. Ct. 1833, 1846 (2018)
(``The Constitution gives States the authority to set the
qualifications for voting in congressional elections, Art. I, Sec. 2,
cl. 1; Amdt. 17, as well as the authority to set the ``Times, Places
and Manner'' to conduct such elections in the absence of contrary
congressional direction, Art. I, Sec. 4, cl. 1.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Every State has used its constitutional authority to
establish voter qualifications often consisting of age,
residency, and citizenship requirements.\16\ Several States
have enshrined U.S. citizenship in their State constitution as
a qualification for voters to vote in State elections.\17\ The
Constitution permits States to enforce their U.S. citizenship
qualification in different ways. Some States require applicants
to provide documentary proof of citizenship\18\ while others
only require the applicant to swear or affirm they are a
citizen of the United States.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\See Kramer v. Union Free School District, 395 U.S. 621, 625
(1969) (`` . . . States have the power to impose reasonable
citizenship, age, and residency requirements on the availability of the
ballot.''); See also Carrington v. Rash, 380 U.S. 89, 91 (1965)
(``There can be no doubt either of the historic function of the States
to establish, on a nondiscriminatory basis, and in accordance with the
Constitution, other qualifications for the exercise of the
franchise.'').
\17\See Laws permitting noncitizens to vote in the United States,
Ballotpedia, available at https://ballotpedia.org/
Laws_permitting_noncitizens_to_vote_in_the_United_States.
\18\See, e.g. A.R.S. Sec. 16-121.01; MS Code Sec. 23-15-15.
\19\See MINN. STAT. 201.071 (2023) (explaining that an applicant
must certify they are a citizen of the United States when they register
to vote, but no documentary proof of citizenship is required.) See also
National Mail Voter Registration Form, U.S. Election Assistance
Commission (Dec. 29, 2023), https://www.eac.gov/voters/national-mail-
voter-registration-form (the National Mail Voter Registration Form only
requires applicants registering to vote in a federal election to swear
or affirm they are a United States citizen.).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The National Voter Registration Act (``NVRA'') was signed
into law by President Bill Clinton in 1993 ``to establish
procedures that will increase the number of eligible citizens
who register to vote in elections for Federal office; . . .
protect the integrity of the electoral process; and . . .
ensure that accurate and current voter registration rolls are
maintained.''\20\ The legislation is commonly referred to as
the ``motor voter'' law because it requires States to provide
individuals with voter registration materials when they apply
for a driver's license.\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\52 U.S.C. Sec. 20501(b).
\21\Id. at Sec. 20503(a).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Although almost every State does not allow noncitizens to
vote in their elections, over 20 States allow noncitizens to
apply for driver's licenses.\22\ Unfortunately, because of
human error in the process at the counter or in the computer
system, noncitizens will be given voter registration forms and
might unlawfully register to vote in at least some situations.
This is not a hypothetical as Pennsylvania admitted that just a
few years ago it had inadvertently allowed over 10,000
noncitizens to register to vote via this process,\23\ and Texas
has had similar problems with nearly 100,000 registrations.\24\
And now that Pennsylvania and other States have implemented
automatic voter registration when an applicant obtains a new or
renewed driver license or identification card, unless the
applicant affirmatively opts-out, there is a strong possibility
that at least some noncitizens will continue to end up on the
voter rolls.\25\ When Illinois implemented automatic voter
registration like this several years ago, hundreds of
noncitizens ended up on the voter rolls.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\See States Offering Driver's Licenses to Immigrants, National
Conference of State Legislatures (Mar. 13, 2023), https://www.ncsl.org/
immigration/states-offering-drivers-licenses-to-immigrants.
\23\Rowan Scarborough, Stephen Dinan, Pennsylvania admits to 11,000
noncitizens registered to vote, Washington Times (Jan. 30, 2019),
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2019/jan/30/pennsylvania-11000-
non-citizens-registered-vote/.; Pam Fessler, Some Noncitizens Do Wind
Up Registered To Vote, But Usually Not On Purpose, National Public
Radio (Feb. 26, 2019), https://www.npr.org/2019/02/26/697848417/some-
noncitizens-do-wind-up-registered-to-vote-but-usually-not-on-purpose.
\24\Alexa Ura, Texas' renewed voter citizenship review is still
flagging citizens as ``possible non-U.S. citizens'', The Texas Tribune
(Dec. 17, 2021), https://www.texastribune.org/2021/12/17/texas-voter-
roll-review/.
\25\Governor Shapiro Implements Automatic Voter Registration in
Pennsylvania, Joining Bipartisan Group of States That Have Taken
Commonsense Step to Make Voter Registration More Streamlined and
Secure, Governor Josh Shapiro (Sept. 19, 2023), https://
www.governor.pa.gov/newsroom/governor-shapiro-implements-automatic-
voter-registration-in-pennsylvania-joining-bipartisan-group-of-states-
that-have-taken-commonsense-step-to-make-voter-registration-more-
streamlined-and-secure/.
\26\Mike Lowe, Hundreds of non-citizens registered to vote in
Illinois due to technical glitch, WGN9 (Jan. 21, 2020), https://
wgntv.com/news/hundreds-of-non-citizens-registered-to-vote-in-illinois-
due-to-technical-glitch/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jurisdictions that allow noncitizen voting or those that
inadvertently or negligently place noncitizens on their voter
rolls cause problems for federal district courts that utilize a
State's voter registration list to identify prospective jurors.
Federal law prohibits noncitizens from serving on a federal
jury.\27\ However, to find prospective jurors that are a
representative cross section of the relevant community, federal
district courts utilize State databases, including the States'
``voter registration lists or the lists of actual voters of the
political subdivisions within the district or division.''\28\
As a result, federal district courts that utilize these lists
with noncitizens on them and call, only to dismiss noncitizen
jurors because they cannot serve on a federal jury. But federal
law does not require the federal district court to transmit
that dismissed noncitizen juror to the State for removal from
the rolls.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\27\28 U.S.C. Sec. 1865(b)(2).
\28\Id. at Sec. 1863(b)(2).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The NVRA allows States to remove registered voters from its
voter rolls if the registrant requests it, if State law
prohibits those individuals from exercising the franchise by
reason of criminal conviction or mental incapacity, or if the
State carries out a general program to remove voters that have
died or moved.\29\ With the exceptions provided for in the
preceding sentence, a State, within 90 days prior of a primary
or general election for federal office can undertake a program
with the purpose of systematically removing ineligible voters
from its voter rolls.\30\ In addition, the NVRA also imposes
strict guidelines the State must follow in carrying out a
program to remove voters that have moved.\31\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\52 U.S.C. Sec. Sec. 20507(a)(3)-(4).
\30\Id. at Sec. 20507(c)(2)(A).
\31\Id. at Sec. 20507(b)-(e).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While the NVRA is premised squarely on citizens voting in
federal elections,\32\ it does not expressly provide States
with the authority to remove noncitizens from voter rolls. The
NVRA's silence on this question only makes matters worse when
combined with its convoluted provision concerning the timing of
a State's removal of ineligible registrants from its voter
rolls. For example, in 2012, the Florida Secretary of State
removed identified noncitizens from the State's voter rolls
within the 90-day period before the primary and general
election.\33\ When this program was challenged as unlawfully
occurring within the NVRA's restricted 90-day timeframe, the
district court held noncitizen removal was exempt from the
NVRA's restrictions because those only applied to registrants
who were lawfully registered to vote in the first instance.\34\
But the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
reversed the district court, holding that the 90-day timeframe
applies to any systematic removal program except for those that
execute removal upon request or death of the registrant, or as
provided by State law by reason of criminal conviction or
mental incapacity.\35\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\32\See Id. at Sec. Sec. 20501(a)-(b) (explaining that in the NVRA,
Congress found the right of citizens to vot
Committee Action
INTRODUCTION AND REFERRAL
On July 3, 2023, Representative Morgan H. Griffith (VA-09)
introduced H.R. 4460, the NO VOTE for Non-Citizens Act of 2023.
The bill was referred to the U.S. House of Representatives
Committee on House Administration and to the U.S. House of
Representatives Committee on Judiciary.
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6)(A) of House rule XIII,
in the 118th Congress, the Committee held two full committee
hearings and one subcommittee hearing to develop H.R. 4460.
1. On April 27, 2023, the Committee held a full
committee hearing titled, ``American Confidence in
Elections: State Tools to Promote Voter Confidence.''
The hearing focused on Title I of H.R. 4563, the
American Confidence in Elections Act, what tools States
need to boost voter integrity and strengthen voter
confidence, and how the federal government can provide
States with access to the information needed to
accomplish these goals. Witnesses included the
Honorable Ken Cuccinelli, Chairman, Election
Transparency Initiative, the Honorable Hans von
Spakovsky, Manager, Election Law Reform Initiative and
Senior Legal Fellow, the Heritage Foundation, the
Honorable Mac Warner, West Virginia Secretary of State,
the Honorable Donald Palmer Commissioner, U.S. Election
Assistance Commission, and Mr. Joseph Paul Gloria,
Chief Executive Officer for Operations, Election
Center.\75\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\75\American Confidence in Elections: State Tools to Promote Voter
Confidence: Hearing Before the H. Comm. On Admin., 118th Cong. (2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. On May 24, 2023, the Committee on House
Administration Subcommittee on Elections held a
subcommittee hearing titled, ``American Confidence in
Elections: Ensuring Every Eligible American has the
Opportunity to Vote--and for their Vote to Count
According to Law.'' The hearing highlighted the strong
election integrity reforms that have passed throughout
several States and how important it is for States to
learn from other States' successes in the election
arena. Witnesses included: Mr. Joseph Burns, Lawyer,
Law Office of Joseph T. Burns, PLLC, Ms. Lisa Dixon,
Executive Director, Lawyers Democracy Fund (now the
Center for Election Confidence), Mr. Thor Hearne,
Founding Partner, True North Law, LLC, The Honorable
Scot Turner, Executive Director, Eternal Vigilance
Action Inc., and Mr. Deuel Ross, Deputy Director of
Litigation, NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund,
Inc.\76\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\76\American Confidence in Elections: Ensuring Every Eligible
American has the Opportunity to Vote--and for their Vote to Count
According to Law: Hearing Before the Subcomm. On Elections of the H.
Comm. On Admin., 118th Cong. (2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. On July 10, 2023, the Committee held a full
committee field hearing titled, ``American Confidence
in Elections: The Path to Election Integrity Across
America.'' The hearing outlined the newly introduced
H.R. 4563, the American Confidence in Elections Act,
and highlighted the successes of S.B. 202 (Georgia),
2021. Witnesses included the Honorable Hans von
Spakovsky, Manager, Election Law Reform Initiative and
Senior Legal Fellow, the Heritage Foundation, Dr.
Kathleen Ruth, former Vice Chair, Fulton County,
Georgia, Board of Registration and Elections, Mrs.
Vernetta Keith Nuriddin, Elections Consultant, City of
Milton, Georgia, and Ms. Cathy Woolard, Chair, Fulton
County, Georgia, Board of Registration and
Elections.\77\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\77\American Confidence in Elections: The Path to Election
Integrity Across America: Hearing Before the H. Comm. On Admin., 118th
Cong. (2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Consideration
On November 30, 2023, the U.S. House Committee on House
Administration met in open session and ordered the bill, H.R.
4460, NO VOTE for Non-Citizens Act of 2023, reported favorably
to the House of Representatives, by a record vote of eight to
two, a quorum being present.
Committee Votes
In compliance with clause 3(b) of House rule XIII, the
following record vote occurred during the Committee's
consideration of H.R. 4460:
1. Vote on an amendment to H.R. 4460, offered by
Morelle, J., failed by a record vote of 7 noes and 3
ayes. Noes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M.,
Murphy, G., Bice, S., D'Esposito, A., Lee. L. Ayes:
Morelle, J., Sewell, T., Torres, N.
2. Vote to report H.R. 4460 favorably to the House of
Representatives, passed by a record vote of 8 ayes and
2 noes. Ayes: Steil, B., Loudermilk, B., Griffith, M.,
Murphy, G., Bice, S., Carey, D'Esposito, A., M., Lee.
L. Noes: Morelle, J., Torres, N.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Statement of Constitutional Authority
Congress has the power to enact this legislation pursuant
to the following:
Article I, Section 2, Clause 1--``The House
of Representatives shall be composed of Members chosen
every second Year by the People of the several States,
and the Electors in each State shall have the
Qualifications requisite for Electors of the most
numerous Branch of the State Legislature.''\78\ This
clause informs Congress that the general authority to
establish voter qualifications for the U.S. House rests
with the States and not with the Congress.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\78\U.S. Const. art. I, Sec. 2, cl. 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Article I, Section 4, Clause 1--``The Times,
Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and
Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by
the Legislature thereof . . .''\79\ This clause,
consistent with contemporary thought and context,
informs Congress that the primary authority to set
election law and to administer federal elections rests
with the States and not with the Congress.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\79\U.S. Const. art. I, Sec. 4, cl. 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Article I, Section 8, Clause 1--``To lay and
collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the
Debts and provide for the common Defence and general
Welfare of the United States; . . .''\80\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\80\U.S. Const. art. I, Sec. 8, cl. 1.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Article I, Section 8, Clause 4--``To
establish an uniform Rule of Naturalization, . . .
throughout the United States,''\81\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\81\U.S. Const. art. I, Sec. 8, cl. 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Article I, Section 8, Clause 18--``To make
all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for
carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all
other Powers vested by this Constitution in the
Government of the United States, or in any Department
or Officer thereof.''\82\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\82\U.S. Const. art. I, Sec. 8, cl. 18.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Article II, Section 1, Clause 2--``Each
State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature
thereof may direct, a Number of Electors, equal to the
whole Number of Senators and Representatives to which
the State may be entitled in the Congress: . . .''\83\
This clause informs the Congress that the authority to
name presidential and vice presidential electors rests
with States.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\83\U.S. Const. art. II, Sec. 1, cl. 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Article IV, Section 4--``The United States
shall guarantee to every State in this Union a
Republican Form of Government, and shall protect each
of them against Invasion; . . .''\84\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\84\U.S. Const. art. IV, Sec. 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Fifteenth, Nineteenth, Twenty-Fourth,
and Twenty-sixth Amendments--``The right of citizens of
the United States to vote . . .''\85\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\85\U.S. Const. Amend. XV; U.S. Const. Amend. XIX; U.S. Const.
Amend. XXIV; U.S. Const. Amend. XXVI.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Seventeenth Amendment--``The Senate of
the United States shall be composed of two Senators
from each State, elected by the people thereof, for six
years; and each Senator shall have one vote. The
electors in each State shall have the qualifications
requisite for electors of the most numerous branch of
the State legislatures. . . .''\86\ This clause informs
Congress that the general authority to establish voter
qualifications for the U.S. Senate rests with the
States and not with the Congress.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\86\U.S. Const. Amend. XVII.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Oversight Findings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee advises that the findings and recommendations of the
Committee, based on oversight activities under clause 2(b)(1)
of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives, are
incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
Statement of Budget Authority and Related Items
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives and section 308(a)(I) of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the Committee provides the
following opinion and estimate with respect to new budget
authority, entitlement authority, and tax expenditures. The
Committee believes that there will be savings of an
indeterminate amount attributed with this legislation as
currently Maryland, Vermont, California, and the District of
Columbia permit noncitizen voting. Under this legislation,
these jurisdictions will receive a 30 percent reduction in
their HAVA funds.
Congressional Budget Office Estimate
With respect to the requirement of clause 3(c)(3) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, a cost
estimate provided by the Congressional Budget Office pursuant
to section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 was not
made available to the Committee in time for the filing of this
report. The Chairman of the Committee shall cause such an
estimate to be printed in the Congressional Record if it is
received by the Committee.
Performance Goals and Objectives
The performance goals and objectives of H.R. 4460 are to
prohibits the use of any federal taxpayer dollars to support
voting by non-citizens anywhere in the country, regardless of
State or local law that may otherwise permit non-citizens to
vote in a State-controlled election for State and/or local
offices. This ensures that no federal funds may be used to
develop or maintain a voter registration list that contains
non-citizens or to develop or use a ballot that is made
available to non-citizens in elections where non-citizens can
vote. This legislation requires bifurcated elections in any
State that permits non-citizens to vote in its State-controlled
elections, a federal election, where only eligible American
citizens may vote, and a State-controlled election, that allows
non-citizens to vote for State and/or local offices according
to State law. Further, this legislation imposes an additional
penalty on any such State by reducing by 30 percent the amount
of federal elections grant funds available to support its
citizen-only federal elections. It also clarifies that the NVRA
allows States to remove noncitizens from their voter rolls at
any time. It requires any federal government entity to provide
States, upon request, with the information relevant to the
status of an individual as a registered voter in federal
elections. Finally, as noncitizens cannot serve on a federal
jury, the bill requires United States federal district courts
to transmit the names of noncitizens dismissed as potential
jurors to the relevant State Chief Election Official so that
they can ensure the individual is not listed on the State's
voter roll.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII, no provision
of H.R. 4460 establishes or reauthorizes a program of the
federal government known to be duplicative of another federal
program.
Advisory on Earmarks
In accordance with clause 9 of House rule XXI, H.R. 4460
does not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in clauses
9(d), 9(e), or 9(f) of House rule XXI.
Federal Mandates Statement
An estimate of federal mandates prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 423 of the
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act was not made available to the
Committee in time for the filing of this report. The Chairman
of the Committee shall cause such an estimate to be printed in
the Congressional Record if it is received by the Committee.
Advisory Committee Statement
H.R. 4460 does not establish or authorize any new advisory
committees.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short title; findings; sense of Congress
Section 1(a) provides the short title of the bill. The full
title is the Non-citizens: Outlawed from Voting in Our Trusted
Elections Act of 2023 or the NO VOTE for Non-Citizens Act of
2023.
Section 1(b) provides findings for the legislation that the
right to vote in the United States belongs to citizens of the
United States, Congress has the constitutional authority to
prevent noncitizens from voting in federal elections,
noncitizens should not be placed on Federal voter registration
lists, and noncitizens being removed from these lists will
promote voter confidence in election processes and outcomes.
Section 1(b)(2) provides a Sense of Congress that States
need to do more to clean their voter rolls under the National
Voter Registration Act, States should not permit noncitizens to
vote in their elections even if they have the power to do so,
noncitizen voting weakens the value of citizenship and sows
distrust in our elections, and Congress might take further
action to ensure States are cleaning their voter rolls in the
future.
Section 2. ensuring only eligible american citizens may participate
in Federal elections
Section 2(a) amends the National Voter Registration Act to
clarify that States can remove noncitizens from their voter
rolls.
Section 2(b) amends the National Voter Registration Act to
require States or local jurisdictions that allow noncitizens to
vote in their elections to maintain a voter registration list
that is separate from the list of registrants that are citizens
of the United States and eligible to vote in Federal elections.
Section 2(c) amends the Help America Vote Act of 2002 to
require States or local jurisdictions that allow noncitizens to
vote in their elections to maintain separate ballots for
noncitizen voters that cannot vote in Federal elections and
citizens of the United States that can.
Section 2(d) cuts any State or local jurisdiction's Federal
Help America Vote Act funds by 30 percent if they allow
noncitizens to vote in their elections. It also prohibits any
federal funds from being used to maintain a separate voter
registration list under 2(b) or separate ballots under 2(c).
Section 2(e) requires any federal government entity with
information relevant to the status of an individual registered
to vote in Federal elections in a State to provide that State,
upon request, information about the voter in a secure,
accurate, and timely manner.
Section 2(f) requires any United States Federal district
court that dismisses a noncitizen juror because noncitizen
jurors cannot serve on a federal jury to provide the
individual's name and information to the chief State election
official of the State in which the individual resides and the
Attorney General so the individual can be removed from the
State's voter rolls.
Section 2(g) amends the National Voter Registration Act to
restate the criminal penalties associated with noncitizen
voting in federal elections under 18 U.S.C. Sec. 611.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
NATIONAL VOTER REGISTRATION ACT OF 1993
* * * * * * *
SEC. 8. REQUIREMENTS WITH RESPECT TO ADMINISTRATION OF VOTER
REGISTRATION.
(a) In General.--In the administration of voter registration
for elections for Federal office, each State shall--
(1) ensure that any eligible applicant is registered
to vote in an election--
(A) in the case of registration with a motor
vehicle application under section 5, if the
valid voter registration form of the applicant
is submitted to the appropriate State motor
vehicle authority not later than the lesser of
30 days, or the period provided by State law,
before the date of the election;
(B) in the case of registration by mail under
section 6, if the valid voter registration form
of the applicant is postmarked not later than
the lesser of 30 days, or the period provided
by State law, before the date of the election;
(C) in the case of registration at a voter
registration agency, if the valid voter
registration form of the applicant is accepted
at the voter registration agency not later than
the lesser of 30 days, or the period provided
by State law, before the date of the election;
and
(D) in any other case, if the valid voter
registration form of the applicant is received
by the appropriate State election official not
later than the lesser of 30 days, or the period
provided by State law, before the date of the
election;
(2) require the appropriate State election official
to send notice to each applicant of the disposition of
the application;
(3) provide that the name of a registrant may not be
removed from the official list of eligible voters
except--
(A) at the request of the registrant;
(B) as provided by State law, by reason of
criminal conviction or mental incapacity; or
(C) as provided under paragraph (4);
(4) conduct a general program that makes a reasonable
effort to remove the names of ineligible voters from
the official lists of eligible voters by reason of--
(A) the death of the registrant; [or]
(B) the registrant's status as a noncitizen
of the United States; or
[(B)] (C) a change in the residence of the
registrant, in accordance with subsections (b),
(c), and (d);
(5) inform applicants under sections 5, 6, and 7 of--
(A) voter eligibility requirements; and
(B) penalties provided by law for submission
of a false voter registration application;
[and]
(6) ensure that the identity of the voter
registration agency through which any particular voter
is registered is not disclosed to the public[.]; and
(7) in the case of a State that allows individuals
who are not citizens of the United States to vote in
elections for public office in the State or any local
jurisdiction of the State, ensure that the name of any
registrant who is not a citizen of the United States is
maintained on a voter registration list that is
separate from the official list of eligible voters with
respect to registrants who are citizens of the United
States.
(b) Confirmation of Voter Registration.--Any State program or
activity to protect the integrity of the electoral process by
ensuring the maintenance of an accurate and current voter
registration roll for elections for Federal office--
(1) shall be uniform, nondiscriminatory, and in
compliance with the Voting Rights Act of 1965 (42
U.S.C. 1973 et seq.); and
(2) shall not result in the removal of the name of
any person from the official list of voters registered
to vote in an election for Federal office by reason of
the person's failure to vote, except that nothing in
this paragraph may be construed to prohibit a State
from using the procedures described in subsections (c)
and (d) to remove an individual from the official list
of eligible voters if the individual--
(A) has not either notified the applicable
registrar (in person or in writing) or
responded during the period described in
subparagraph (B) to the notice sent by the
applicable registrar; and then
(B) has not voted or appeared to vote in 2 or
more consecutive general elections for Federal
office.
(c) Voter Removal Programs.--(1) A State may meet the
requirement of subsection (a)(4) by establishing a program
under which--
(A) change-of-address information supplied by the
Postal Service through its licensees is used to
identify registrants whose addresses may have changed;
and
(B) if it appears from information provided by the
Postal Service that--
(i) a registrant has moved to a different
residence address in the same registrar's
jurisdiction in which the registrant is
currently registered, the registrar changes the
registration records to show the new address
and sends the registrant a notice of the change
by forwardable mail and a postage prepaid pre-
addressed return form by which the registrant
may verify or correct the address information;
or
(ii) the registrant has moved to a different
residence address not in the same registrar's
jurisdiction, the registrar uses the notice
procedure described in subsection (d)(2) to
confirm the change of address.
(2)(A) A State shall complete, not later than 90 days prior
to the date of a primary or general election for Federal
office, any program the purpose of which is to systematically
remove the names of ineligible voters from the official lists
of eligible voters.
(B) Subparagraph (A) shall not be construed to preclude--
(i) the removal of names from official lists of
voters on a basis described in paragraph (3) (A) or (B)
or [(4)(A)] (4)(A) or (B) of subsection (a); or
(ii) correction of registration records pursuant to
this Act.
(d) Removal of Names From Voting Rolls.--(1) A State shall
not remove the name of a registrant from the official list of
eligible voters in elections for Federal office on the ground
that the registrant has changed residence unless the
registrant--
(A) confirms in writing that the registrant has
changed residence to a place outside the registrar's
jurisdiction in which the registrant is registered; or
(B)(i) has failed to respond to a notice described in
paragraph (2); and
(ii) has not voted or appeared to vote (and, if
necessary, correct the registrar's record of the
registrant's address) in an election during the period
beginning on the date of the notice and ending on the
day after the date of the second general election for
Federal office that occurs after the date of the
notice.
(2) A notice is described in this paragraph if it is a
postage prepaid and pre-addressed return card, sent by
forwardable mail, on which the registrant may state his or her
current address, together with a notice to the following
effect:
(A) If the registrant did not change his or her
residence, or changed residence but remained in the
registrar's jurisdiction, the registrant should return
the card not later than the time provided for mail
registration under subsection (a)(1)(B). If the card is
not returned, affirmation or confirmation of the
registrant's address may be required before the
registrant is permitted to vote in a Federal election
during the period beginning on the date of the notice
and ending on the day after the date of the second
general election for Federal office that occurs after
the date of the notice, and if the registrant does not
vote in an election during that period the registrant's
name will be removed from the list of eligible voters.
(B) If the registrant has changed residence to a
place outside the registrar's jurisdiction in which the
registrant is registered, information concerning how
the registrant can continue to be eligible to vote.
(3) A voting registrar shall correct an official list of
eligible voters in elections for Federal office in accordance
with change of residence information obtained in conformance
with this subsection.
(e) Procedure for Voting Following Failure To Return Card.--
(1) A registrant who has moved from an address in the area
covered by a polling place to an address in the same area
shall, notwithstanding failure to notify the registrar of the
change of address prior to the date of an election, be
permitted to vote at that polling place upon oral or written
affirmation by the registrant of the change of address before
an election official at that polling place.
(2)(A) A registrant who has moved from an address in the area
covered by one polling place to an address in an area covered
by a second polling place within the same registrar's
jurisdiction and the same congressional district and who has
failed to notify the registrar of the change of address prior
to the date of an election, at the option of the registrant--
(i) shall be permitted to correct the voting records
and vote at the registrant's former polling place, upon
oral or written affirmation by the registrant of the
new address before an election official at that polling
place; or
(ii)(I) shall be permitted to correct the voting
records and vote at a central location within the same
registrar's jurisdiction designated by the registrar
where a list of eligible voters is maintained, upon
written affirmation by the registrant of the new
address on a standard form provided by the registrar at
the central location; or
(II) shall be permitted to correct the voting records
for purposes of voting in future elections at the
appropriate polling place for the current address and,
if permitted by State law, shall be permitted to vote
in the present election, upon confirmation by the
registrant of the new address by such means as are
required by law.
(B) If State law permits the registrant to vote in the
current election upon oral or written affirmation by the
registrant of the new address at a polling place described in
subparagraph (A)(i) or (A)(ii)(II), voting at the other
locations described in subparagraph (A) need not be provided as
options.
(3) If the registration records indicate that a registrant
has moved from an address in the area covered by a polling
place, the registrant shall, upon oral or written affirmation
by the registrant before an election official at that polling
place that the registrant continues to reside at the address
previously made known to the registrar, be permitted to vote at
that polling place.
(f) Change of Voting Address Within a Jurisdiction.--In the
case of a change of address, for voting purposes, of a
registrant to another address within the same registrar's
jurisdiction, the registrar shall correct the voting
registration list accordingly, and the registrant's name may
not be removed from the official list of eligible voters by
reason of such a change of address except as provided in
subsection (d).
(g) Conviction in Federal Court.--(1) On the conviction of a
person of a felony in a district court of the United States,
the United States attorney shall give written notice of the
conviction to the chief State election official designated
under section 10 of the State of the person's residence.
(2) A notice given pursuant to paragraph (1) shall include--
(A) the name of the offender;
(B) the offender's age and residence address;
(C) the date of entry of the judgment;
(D) a description of the offenses of which the
offender was convicted; and
(E) the sentence imposed by the court.
(3) On request of the chief State election official of a
State or other State official with responsibility for
determining the effect that a conviction may have on an
offender's qualification to vote, the United States attorney
shall provide such additional information as the United States
attorney may have concerning the offender and the offense of
which the offender was convicted.
(4) If a conviction of which notice was given pursuant to
paragraph (1) is overturned, the United States attorney shall
give the official to whom the notice was given written notice
of the vacation of the judgment.
(5) The chief State election official shall notify the voter
registration officials of the local jurisdiction in which an
offender resides of the information received under this
subsection.
(h) Reduced Postal Rates.--(1) Subchapter II of chapter 36 of
title 39, United States Code, is amended by adding at the end
the following:
* * * * * * *
(2) The first sentence of section 2401(c) of title 39, United
States Code, is amended by striking out ``and 3626(a)-(h) and
(j)-(k) of this title,'' and inserting in lieu thereof
``3626(a)-(h), 3626(j)-(k), and 3629 of this title''.
(3) Section 3627 of title 39, United States Code, is amended
by striking out ``or 3626 of this title,'' and inserting in
lieu thereof ``3626, or 3629 of this title''.
(4) The table of sections for chapter 36 of title 39, United
States Code, is amended by inserting after the item relating to
section 3628 the following new item:
``3629. Reduced rates for voter registration purposes.''.
(i) Public Disclosure of Voter Registration Activities.--(1)
Each State shall maintain for at least 2 years and shall make
available for public inspection and, where available,
photocopying at a reasonable cost, all records concerning the
implementation of programs and activities conducted for the
purpose of ensuring the accuracy and currency of official lists
of eligible voters, except to the extent that such records
relate to a declination to register to vote or to the identity
of a voter registration agency through which any particular
voter is registered.
(2) The records maintained pursuant to paragraph (1) shall
include lists of the names and addresses of all persons to whom
notices described in subsection (d)(2) are sent, and
information concerning whether or not each such person has
responded to the notice as of the date that inspection of the
records is made.
(j) Definition.--For the purposes of this section, the term
``registrar's jurisdiction'' means--
(1) an incorporated city, town, borough, or other
form of municipality;
(2) if voter registration is maintained by a county,
parish, or other unit of government that governs a
larger geographic area than a municipality, the
geographic area governed by that unit of government; or
(3) if voter registration is maintained o
Dissenting Views
H.R. 4460 would slash Help America Votes Act (``HAVA'')
funds that are critically needed to keep our elections safe--
investments necessary to the success of our free and fair
elections. HAVA funds are disbursed at a statewide level and
benefit everyone--our election infrastructure safeguards the
rights of every American.
For example, under H.R. 4460, California would lose 30
percent of its HAVA funds. Committee Republicans might have
forgotten Republican candidates received almost four million
votes in California in 2022. In fact, over 13 percent of 2022
voters live in just four states--California, New York,
Maryland, and Vermont. These four states--which send 23
Republicans to Congress, including the former Republican
Speaker of the House and the Chair of the Republican
Conference--could lose a third of their HAVA funds under this
bill. Voters in those states would see their election
infrastructure weakened by House Republicans. These voters
would cast ballots in elections that are underfunded--and
therefore necessarily less secure and more vulnerable to
malicious acts.
The dedicated public servants who administer the elections
for the 11 percent of the Republican Conference from the four
states above would lose essential funding as a punishment for
decisions made outside of their control. At a time when
election administrators have repeatedly told this Committee of
their dire need for increased funding, slashing these funds
would be a grave mistake.
Do Committee Republicans support the power of states to
create their own laws, to govern themselves? Are they for local
control? Or do they want to use federal power to override and
overrule local governments? Committee Republicans seem to enjoy
waxing poetic about states' rights and local control. But H.R.
4460 directly contradicts those principles: It strongarms local
jurisdictions and mandates extreme partisan restrictions.
Committee Democrats emphatically support election security,
but this bill does not increase the security of our elections.
With the 2024 elections fast approaching, Congress should be
focusing on how it can support election administrators coast to
coast. Instead, Republicans have advanced this recycled
provision of the American Confidence in Elections Act (``ACE
Act'') that would slash already scarce funding for election
administrators while mandating mandate heavy-handed voter
purges using flawed systems that would disproportionately
target naturalized citizens.
Committee Republicans have pushed a false narrative that
the confidence of the American people is in crisis and have
perpetuated election denialism and lies about insecure
elections. H.R. 4460 would actually make our elections less
secure. This bill would erode confidence in American elections,
as voters would see their already underfunded election
officials lose more resources.
Joseph D. Morelle,
Ranking Member.
[all]