Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 3724]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Education and the Workforce, to whom was
referred the bill (H.R. 3724) to amend the Higher Education Act
of 1965 to prohibit recognized accrediting agencies and
associations from requiring, encouraging, or coercing
institutions of higher education to meet any political litmus
test or violate any right protected by the Constitution as a
condition of accreditation, having considered the same, reports
favorably thereon with an amendment and recommends that the
bill as amended do pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Accreditation for College Excellence
Act of 2023''.
SEC. 2. PROHIBITION ON POLITICAL LITMUS TESTS IN ACCREDITATION OF
INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION.
(a) Operating Procedures Required.--Section 496(c) of the Higher
Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b(c)) is amended--
(1) by striking ``and'' at the end of paragraph (8);
(2) in paragraph (9), by striking the period at the end and
inserting ``; and''; and
(3) by adding at the end the following:
``(10) confirms that the standards for accreditation of the
agency or association do not--
``(A) except as provided in subparagraph (B)--
``(i) require, encourage, or coerce any
institution to--
``(I) support, oppose, or commit to
supporting or opposing--
``(aa) a specific partisan,
political, or ideological
viewpoint or belief or set of
such viewpoints or beliefs; or
``(bb) a a specific viewpoint
or belief or set of viewpoints
or beliefs on social, cultural,
or political issues; or
``(II) support or commit to
supporting the disparate treatment of
any individual or group of individuals
on the basis of any protected class
under Federal civil rights law, except
as required by Federal law or a court
order; or
``(ii) assess an institution's or program of
study's commitment to any ideology, belief, or
viewpoint;
``(B) prohibit an institution--
``(i) from having a religious mission,
operating as a religious institution, or being
controlled by a religious organization (in a
manner described in paragraph (1), (2), (3),
(4), (5), or (6) of section 106.12(c) of title
34, Code of Federal Regulations (as in effect
on the date of the enactment of this
paragraph)), or from requiring an applicant,
student, employee, or independent contractor
(such as an adjunct professor) of such an
institution to--
``(I) provide or adhere to a
statement of faith; or
``(II) adhere to a code of conduct
consistent with the stated religious
mission of such institution or the
religious tenets of such organization;
or
``(ii) from requiring an applicant, student,
employee, or contractor to take an oath to
uphold the Constitution of the United States;
or
``(C) require, encourage, or coerce an institution of
higher education to violate any right protected by the
Constitution.''.
(b) Limitation on Scope of Criteria.--Section 496(g) of the Higher
Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1099b(g)) is amended to read as
follows:
``(g) Limitation on Scope of Criteria.--
``(1) In general.--The Secretary shall not establish criteria
for accrediting agencies or associations that are not required
by this section.
``(2) Institutional eligibility.--An institution of higher
education shall be eligible for participation in programs under
this title if the institution is in compliance with the
standards of its accrediting agency or association that assess
the institution in accordance with subsection (a)(5),
regardless of any additional standards adopted by the agency or
association for purposes unrelated to participation in programs
under this title.''.
Purpose
H.R. 3724 amends the Higher Education Act of 1965 to
prohibit recognized accrediting agencies and associations from
requiring, encouraging, or coercing institutions of higher
education to meet any political litmus test or violate any
right protected by the Constitution as a condition of
accreditation.
Committee Action
115TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearings
On April 27, 2017, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing on ``Strengthening Accreditation to
Better Protect Students and Taxpayers.'' The purpose of the
hearing was to review the concerns that the current
accreditation system is no longer focused on ensuring a high-
quality education experience and examine ways to strengthen its
mechanics to provide accountability for both students and
taxpayers. Testifying before the Committee were Dr. Mary Ellen
Petrisko, President, WASC Senior College and University
Commission, Alameda, CA; Dr. George A. Pruitt, President,
Thomas Edison State University, Trenton, NJ; Mr. Ben Miller,
Senior Director for Postsecondary Education, Center for
American Progress, Washington, D.C.; and Dr. Michale S.
McComis, Executive Director, Accrediting Commission of Career
Schools and Colleges, Arlington, VA.
116TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearings
On April 3, 2019, the Committee's Higher Education and
Workforce Investment Subcommittee held a hearing on
``Strengthening Accountability in Higher Education to Better
Serve Students and Taxpayers.'' The purpose of the hearing was
to review the triad accountability system of higher education,
of which accrediting agencies and associations compromise one-
third of the entities responsible for holding institutions
accountable to students and taxpayers. Testifying before the
Committee were Dr. Nicholas Hillman, Associate Professor of
Education Leadership and Policy Analysis, University of
Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI; Ms. Melissa Emrey-Arras,
Director of Education, Workforce, and Income Security, United
States Government Accountability Office, Washington D.C.; Mr.
Noe Ortega, Deputy Secretary of the Office of Postsecondary and
Higher Education, Pennsylvania Department of Education,
Harrisburg, PA; and Dr. Barbara Brittingham, President, New
England Commission of Higher Education, Wakefield, MA.
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On July 27, 2023, the Committee's Higher Education and
Workforce Development Subcommittee held a hearing on ``Lowering
Costs and Increasing Value for Students, Institutions, and
Taxpayers.'' The purpose of the hearing was to discuss with
policy experts the root causes of student debt and how to lower
the cost of college through reforms to the postsecondary
education accountability system, including reforms to the
accreditation system that prioritize academics over a social
justice agenda. Testifying before the Subcommittee were Mr.
Michael B. Horn, Author and Co-Founder of the Clayton
Christensen Institute for Disruptive Innovation, Lexington, MA;
Mr. Stig Leschly, President and Founder, Postsecondary
Commission, Boston, MA; Dr. Stephanie Cellini, Professor of
Public Policy and Public Administration, and of Economics,
George Washington University, Washington, D.C.; and Dr. Andrew
Gillen, Senior Policy Analyst, Texas Public Policy Foundation,
Austin, TX.
Second Session--Hearings
On March 7, 2024, the Committee's Higher Education and
Workforce Development Subcommittee held a hearing on
``Divisive, Excessive, Ineffective: The Real Impact of DEI on
College Campuses.'' The purpose of the hearing was to examine
ways in which institutions and accreditors are engaging in
harmful diversity, equity, and inclusion practices (DEI),
including accreditors with DEI-based standards that
institutions are obligated to meet. Testifying before the
Subcommittee were Dr. Erec Smith, Associate Professor of
Rhetoric, York College of Pennsylvania, Cato Research Fellow,
York, PA; Dr. James Murphy, Director of Career Pathways and
Post-Secondary Policy, Education Reform Now, Washington, D.C.;
Dr. Stanley Goldfarb, Chair, Do No Harm, Bryn Mawr, PA; and Dr.
Jay Greene, Senior Research Fellow, The Heritage Foundation's
Center for Education Policy, Fayetteville, AK.
Legislative Action
On May 25, 2023, Higher Education and Workforce Development
Subcommittee Chairman Burgess Owens (R-UT) introduced the
Accreditation for College Excellence (ACE) Act of 2023 (H.R.
3724) with Representatives Brandon Williams (R-NY), Byron
Donalds (R-FL), and Erin Houchin (R-IN). The bill was referred
solely to the Committee on Education and the Workforce. On
March 21, 2024, the Committee considered H.R. 3724 in
legislative session and reported it favorably, as amended, to
the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of 24-14. The
Committee considered the following amendments to H.R. 3724:
1. Representative Owens offered an Amendment in the
Nature of a Substitute (ANS) that makes technical
changes to the text to align the language more closely
to the same prohibition included in the text of H.R.
6951, the College Cost Reduction Act, which the
Committee passed on January 31, 2024. The amendment was
adopted by voice vote.
2. Representative Suzanne Bonamici (D-OR) offered an
amendment to require religious institutions that seek a
core curricula exemption from their accreditor to
publish a description of the request and final
determination by the accreditor. The amendment failed
by a recorded vote of 14-23.
Committee Views
INTRODUCTION
Accrediting agencies or associations (accreditors) that
force institutions to subscribe to certain partisan beliefs or
viewpoints, such as DEI, quash academic freedom and therefore
are antithetical to American exceptionalism. Further, the
prevalence of DEI-based standards is concerning at a time when
the value of a degree has decreased\1\ and the cost of college
has increased.\2\ Accreditors that require colleges to adopt
DEI initiatives are forcing colleges to make the DEI
bureaucracy a priority instead of lowering college costs for
students and taxpayers. H.R. 3724, the Accreditation for
College Excellence Act, would allow institutions to regain
academic freedom by prohibiting accreditors from requiring
institutions to meet partisan and ideological litmus tests to
receive accreditation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\https://freopp.org/is-college-worth-it-a-comprehensive-return-
on-investment-analysis-1b2ad17f84c8.
\2\https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2023/college-tuition-and-fees-up-4-
7-percent-since-february-2020.htm.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
TODAY'S IDEOLOGY
There is no one definition of DEI. Rather, DEI is a
framework of practices that has ideological roots in neo-
Marxist theory that attribute virtually all group differences
to systemic discrimination.\3\ These practices are grounded in
``critical race theory'' (CRT), which is a legal framework
developed in the 1970s and 1980s\4\ that argues that racism is
always subconsciously occurring and impacting society, even if
it does not exist in the law. The CRT movement has spread
beyond the legal field to become an activist crusade that
questions and seeks to change mainstream institutions. Kimberle
Crenshaw, the theorist who coined the term CRT, has called for
the creation of a ``counter-hegemony'' to challenge traditional
liberalism.\5\ On its surface, DEI seems to promote values that
all people would agree with, but in practice modern DEI works
against the definitions of its own values of ``diversity,''
``equity,'' and ``inclusion'' by prioritizing certain groups
over others. DEI argues that, regardless of equal treatment
under the law, discrimination always will be present within
society due to power struggles between social groups. According
to DEI in its current form, inequality of outcome is
discrimination; therefore, inequality of outcome must be
prevented to be sure that discrimination has been truly
addressed. Further, merit, fairness, and equality under law are
insufficient to remedy this inequality of outcomes, so equal
opportunity is abandoned for favored treatment of certain
groups so as to achieve the desired equal outcomes.
Fundamentally, modern DEI divides individuals into groups based
on stereotyped social constructs and treats them according to
their group identity rather than as autonomous agents with the
freedom to make their own choices and shape their own lives.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\https://thehill.com/opinion/education/3718803-what-do-we-really-
mean-by-diversity-equity-and-inclusion/.
\4\https://www.edweek.org/leadership/what-is-critical-race-theory-
and-why-is-it-under-attack/2021/05.
\5\https://www.aei.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Prohibit-
Diversity-Equity-and-Inclusion-Statements.pdf?x91208.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unfortunately, postsecondary education has embraced Marxist
ideology through DEI, to inform many aspects of university
life. Beyond problems with Marxist theory itself, more
generally no partisan viewpoints or ideologies should ever be
taken as a framework for postsecondary education. Universities
should be marketplaces for all ideas, and this is undermined by
the embrace of any one ideological framework.
There are multiple ways in which DEI has manifested in
postsecondary education. First, standardized tests, and
universities' use of them as evaluative measures, have been
criticized by DEI proponents as being ``inequitable'' due to
different student outcomes. The National Education Association
described standardized tests as ``instruments of racism and a
biased system.''\6\ Advocate group FairTest says that
standardized testing poses ``racial, class, gender, and
cultural barriers''\7\ and as a result reports that over 2,000
U.S. colleges are now test-optional or test-free when it comes
to SAT or ACT scores. To fight supposed ``systemic racism,'' at
least 40 medical institutions have dropped the requirement that
all applicants take the MCAT.\8\ Arguments against standardized
testing embody DEI's framework for outcomes. Standardized
tests, by nature, ask all students the same questions
regardless of their diverse background, objectively evaluating
the individual's ability without consideration of their race,
gender, or socioeconomic class. To DEI advocates, however,
standardized tests are designed to target certain social
groups. Rather than seeing difference of outcome as a sign of
individual capability, DEI advocates see it as symptomatic of a
system of oppression, again focusing on the group rather than
the individual. Despite these criticisms of standardized tests,
some universities that were previously test-optional have
recently announced a return to standardized tests because they
recognize that eliminating standardized tests can have the
opposite effect. In announcing its decision, Dartmouth said,
``SAT/ACTs can be especially helpful in identifying students
from less-resourced backgrounds who would succeed at Dartmouth
but might otherwise be missed in a test-optional
environment.''\9\ In other words, DEI values ultimately
undermine the very individuals it purports to help, reducing
them to victims of circumstance and members of a monolithic
group rather than as individuals with potential.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\https://www.nea.org/nea-today/all-news-articles/racist-
beginnings-standardized-testing.
\7\https://fairtest.org/about/.
\8\https://breakpoint.org/medical-education-infected-with-dei/.
\9\https://thehill.com/homenews/education/4458907-the-days-of-
optional-sat-scores-may-be-coming-to-an-end/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A further effect of DEI on postsecondary education can be
seen in changing tenure standards. The American Association of
University Professors found that over 20 percent of
institutions responding to a recent survey said they include
DEI criteria in their tenure standards and another almost 40
percent reported they are considering adding them.\10\ These
DEI statements are not simple ``anti-discrimination''
statements but rather are coerced commitments to a larger
ideology. Further, a 2021 American Enterprise Institute report
found that one out of every five American professors is hired
based on his or her commitment to the principles of DEI instead
of on his or her merit.\11\ Conformity toward any ideology is
directly at odds with the principles of academic freedom, and
it is troubling that increasingly tenure is being granted not
solely based on the academic and teaching excellence of
professors but rather based on their commitment to an ideology.
This proliferation of DEI administrators places importance on
adherence to a social and ideological movement rather than on
education and serving students.\12\ Although DEI costs
significant resources, there is very little evidence such
efforts help students.\13\ What there is evidence of is the
rising cost of college.\14\ Every dollar a university puts into
a DEI administrator hire is a dollar a university is not
putting toward faculty devoted to core curriculum, direct
student resources, or lowering tuition for students.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\https://www.aaup.org/file/
2022_AAUP_Survey_of_Tenure_Practices.pdf.
\11\https://www.aei.org/research-products/report/other-than-merit-
the-prevalence-of-diversity- equity-and-inclusion-statements-in-
university-hiring/.
\12\https://www.heritage.org/education/report/diversity-university-
dei-bloat-the-academy.
\13\https://www.heritage.org/education/commentary/dei-doesnt-work-
taxpayers-shouldnt-pay-it.
\14\https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2023/college-tuition-and-fees-up-
4-7-percent-since-february-2020.htm.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Another effect of DEI on universities is the ballooning of
administrative positions and resources dedicated to DEI
initiatives. These DEI offices and staff at universities share
similarly vague mission statements but seem to have little
practical impact on student success outcomes.\15\ The 2021
report Diversity University: DEI Bloat in the Academy found
that large public universities averaged 45 DEI personnel, with
some institutions well surpassing that number: the University
of Michigan had 163 DEI staff, the University of Virginia and
the Ohio State University each had 94 DEI staff, and Virginia
Tech, the University of California Berkley, Stanford
University, the University of Illinois, and the University of
Maryland all had between 70 and 90 DEI personnel on campus.\16\
This hiring spree of DEI administrators further injures
students by deprioritizing hiring for other chronically
understaffed departments and offices. For example, the
University of Michigan has roughly 14 DEI staff for every one
person providing services to students with disabilities.\17\ An
updated 2024 analysis of the University of Michigan's DEI
office found there to be 241 paid DEI employees and that
payroll costs for those employees exceeding $30 million
annually.\18\ To put that amount in context, with that same
amount the University could instead cover in-state tuition for
over 1,700 undergraduate students. Further, DEI officers are
often paid at significantly higher rates than professors. For
example, the university's Chief Diversity Administrator has a
salary of $402,800, over two times the average salary of a
professor.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\https://www.heritage.org/education/report/diversity-university-
dei-bloat-the-academy.
\16\Ibid.
\17\Ibid.
\18\https://www.thecollegefix.com/umich-now-has-more-than-500-jobs-
dedicated-to-dei-payroll-costs-exceed-30-million/. The institution
disputes the total number because some faculty are part-time and have
other responsibilities at the institution.
\19\Ibid.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
ACCREDITORS' ROLE
Accreditation is a non-governmental peer review process
created by colleges and universities to review and improve the
academic quality of postsecondary institutions and programs.
Accreditors are voluntary, private organizations composed of
members from accredited schools. The postsecondary
accreditation system predates the Higher Education Act of 1965
(HEA), but within the HEA Congress required institutions to be
accredited by a nationally recognized accrediting agency or
association as a condition of receiving federal funding.\20\ In
order for an accreditor to assess institution quality for the
purposes of HEA funding, the accreditor must first be
recognized by the Department of Education (ED). Section 496 of
the HEA outlines the operating procedures accreditors must meet
before they can be a recognized accreditor.\21\ H.R. 3724
amends section 496(c) of the HEA to specifically require that
an accreditor confirm it has no standards in place to require,
encourage, or coerce an institution to support or oppose a
partisan or ideological litmus test. Additionally, accreditors
that wish to be recognized must renew recognition every five
years. Therefore, H.R. 3724 will ensure that accreditors
regularly confirm that no litmus test standards exist before
recognition is renewed, providing ongoing protection from
future attempts to push ideological standards on institutions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\Higher Education Act of 1965, Pub. L. No. 89-329, Sec. 801.
\21\HEA Section 496(c).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Section 496 also outlines the process which institutions
must undergo to be recognized by an accreditor and the
requirements accreditors may hold institutions to maintain
their accreditation status. Accreditation of colleges and
universities generally serves the following two purposes:
assuring quality and fostering continuous improvement. The
federal government and the public rely on accreditation as a
signal that an accredited institution meets at least a minimum
standard of quality and that federal funds are flowing only to
credible, legitimate, and high-quality institutions.
Conversely, colleges and universities use the accreditation
process as a way to help shape and guide the continuous
improvement of their institutions and academic programs. There
are 10 statutory standards of accreditation that are most
commonly referenced when discussing what the law requires
accreditors to consider and require institutions to measure
themselves against. Accreditors, in coordination with their
member institutions, develop criteria around the required
statutory standards. To gain accreditation, an institution or
program must be evaluated through a number of steps outlined by
an accreditor. These procedures are guided, in part, by the
federal requirements in the HEA and by regulation; however, the
specific procedures for evaluation reviews adopted by
accreditation agencies vary by agency. Importantly, section
496(g) of the HEA also includes an ``elastic clause'' that
allows accreditors to impose additional conditions for HEA
Title IV eligibility.\22\ This provision has allowed
accreditors to impose many additional requirements on
instituti
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
H.R. 3724, the Accreditation for College Excellence Act of
2023, amends the Higher Education Act of 1965 (HEA) in ways
Committee Democrats firmly believe will lower the quality of
higher education. The bill proposes changes to the standards
under which accrediting bodies determine the quality of
institutions of higher education. These changes are solutions
in search of problems. The provisions in this bill are largely
a rehash of proposals the Committee marked up earlier this
session in H.R. 6951, the so-called College Cost Reduction Act,
which the Committee passed on a party-line vote.\1\ They were
bad policy then, and remain so now.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\The majority provided no rationale as to why they chose to mark
up nearly identical language less than two months after its initial
consideration by the Committee. However, the use of Committee time to
consider a bill with no meaningful chance of consideration or passage
in the Senate, let alone approval by the President is what explains the
fact that the analysis that follows largely mirrors that which will
appear in forthcoming minority views on H.R. 6951.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Background
Current law mandates operating procedures that any
accrediting agency seeking federal recognition must follow when
making determinations of school or program quality.\2\ The
procedures currently mandated by HEA are designed to ensure
accreditors are monitoring schools in a timely and common sense
fashion to ensure quality. This includes conducting ad hoc
supervision as needed when schools create new programs or
expand to new campuses, ensuring schools have policies around
the transfer of credit that students are aware of, and that
schools have plans in place to support students completing
their education in the event of loss of accreditation.\3\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Higher Education Act of 1965, Sec. 496, 20 U.S.C. 1099b.
\3\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
``Litmus Tests''
On its face, H.R. 3724 makes slight modifications to the
requirements HEA places on federally recognized accrediting
agencies. First, the bill adds a provision\4\ under which
accrediting agencies must confirm that they do not require or
entice a school to take a stance on any ``specific partisan,
political, or ideological viewpoint or belief or set of such
viewpoints and beliefs.''\5\ At markup, Chairwoman Virginia
Foxx (R-NC) stated this provision ``ensures colleges are not
forced to commit to the principles of DEI to receive
accreditation.''\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\4\H.R. 6951, Sec. 311(c)(5). This same provision is titled the
``Prohibition on Litmus Tests'' in H.R. 6951, the College Cost
Reduction Act. Although this phrase does not appear in H.R. 3724, this
provision is nearly identical to the ``Prohibition on Litmus Tests''
provision included in H.R. 6951, marked up by the Committee on Jan. 31,
2024.
\5\H.R. 3724, Sec. 2(a)(3).
\6\Press Release, H. Comm. on Educ. & the Workforce, Chairwoman
Foxx Delivers Opening Remarks at Markup to Bolster Workforce and
Advance Academic Freedom, Mar. 21, 2024, https://edworkforce.house.gov/
news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=410332.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs on college
campuses are designed with the recognition that most college
campuses are currently serving students from demographics they
were not initially designed to serve. While no two DEI programs
are identical, The Century Foundation has provided a broad
definition of the three key terms as they are used in practice
on college campuses.
Diversity refers to the range of different identities
within a particular space, whether it is based on race,
gender identification, sexual orientation, or other
factors; organizations seeking diversity value having a
community that represents humanity across the full
range of identities. Equity refers to the allocation of
an adequate amount of attention and/or resources toward
each identity to ensure that all groups can reach a
similar outcome; an organization seeking equity would
counter a community member's disadvantage by allocating
more resources and support toward that person. Finally,
inclusion refers to an organization's policies that
ensure its overall culture is welcoming to all
identities; an organization seeking inclusion could
create rules for conducting meetings or guidelines for
what would be considered inappropriate conversations .
. . DEI programs in colleges and universities aim to
create a campus culture that values and celebrates all
students' diverse life experiences and cultural
backgrounds. The central values of DEI are to ensure
equal access to success in higher education and provide
extra resources to specific populations to achieve
success standards similar to their peers. Universities
must provide adequate resources and tools for students
from different backgrounds to excel, considering
historical circumstances that often hindered their
access to higher education. In short, DEI programs
strive to foster an inclusive and equitable educational
environment for all students.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Jordan Nellums, Universities Need to Mount and Offensive for
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion, The Century Foundation, Aug. 17,
2023, https://tcf.org/content/commentary/universities-need-to-mount-an-
offensive-for-diversity-equity-and-inclusion/. For a thorough debunking
of the myths surrounding DEI, and a direct refutation of much of the
anti-DEI rhetoric espoused in Committee proceedings during the 118th
Congress, see USC Race & Equity Ctr., Truths About DEI on College
Campuses, 2024, https://race.usc.edu/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Harper-
and- Associates-DEI-Truths-Report.pdf.
Republicans have not wasted a chance to denounce DEI
initiatives in industry, governmental, and educational
settings. For example, the ruling in the Havard and UNC
affirmative action cases--in no way related to DEI--has been
used as pretext for many Republicans to declare all DEI
initiatives unconstitutional. Thirteen Republican state
attorneys general wrote a joint letter to the CEOs of the
Fortune 100 companies stating that ``diversity, equity, and
inclusion'' (DEI) efforts may amount to ``overt and pervasive
racial discrimination . . . [that] violates both state and
federal law.''\8\ This initial insistence of DEI's prima facie
illegality has diminished as more states have passed laws to
actually prohibit DEI programs in higher education--laws that
would arguably be unnecessary if those initial claims of DEI
illegality were true.\9\ And in the most absurd sign of
irrationality toward DEI, Republican state officials have taken
to claiming DEI efforts are the cause of any and all societal
ills including school fights, airplane malfunctions, and the
collision of a container ship with a bridge and its subsequent
collapse.\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Letter from Kris Kobach, Atty. Gen. of Kan. & 12 other State
Attys. Gen. to the CEOs of the Fortune 100 Companies (July 13, 2023),
https://ago.mo.gov/wp-content/uploads/corporate-
racial-discrimination-multistate.pdf.
\9\DEI Legislation Tracker, Chron. of Higher Educ., https://
www.chronicle.com/article/here-are-the-states-where-lawmakers-are-
seeking-to-ban-colleges-dei-efforts?sra=true (last visited Mar. 29,
2024).
\10\Summer Ballentine, Missouri attorney general is accused of
racial bias for pinning a student fight on diversity program,
Associated Press, Mar. 26, 2024; Ayana Archie, The Texas attorney
general is investigating a supplier of Boeing 737 parts, Nat'l. Pub.
Radio, Mar. 29, 2024 (``Paxton's office will be requesting documents
related to `the company's organization, conduct and management,' as
well as its diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) practices to examine
`whether those commitments are unlawful or are compromising the
company's manufacturing processes,'''); Erin Alberty, Utah lawmaker
blames DEI for Baltimore bridge collapse despite cargo ship collision,
Axios, Mar. 27, 2024.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 3724 also prohibits an accrediting agency from
requiring, encouraging, or coercing schools to ``support or
commit to supporting the disparate treatment of any individual
or group of individuals on the basis of any protected class
under Federal civil rights law, except as required by Federal
law or a court order''.\11\ This statement only makes sense in
a context where one believes DEI programs result in such
disparate treatment. This is counter to what DEI programs are
designed to do, which is to make campuses welcoming
environments for all students.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\H.R. 3724, Sec. 2(a)(3).
\12\USC Race & Equity Ctr., supra note 6, at 49 (``Claims that DEI
programs mandate racial bias education or promote unequal treatment of
individuals are unfounded and ignore many of the core principles of
DEI, which are addressing systemic barriers to equity and ensuring that
all individuals have equal opportunities to succeed.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In a recent article examining this issue, the Chronicle of
Higher Education found that while accreditors are examining
college DEI policies as part of their assessment, that
examination is largely focused on determining whether schools
are living up to what the universities themselves are claiming
they are doing.\13\ For example the article cites Cal Lutheran,
a school whose accreditor raised concerns around their
treatment of faculty of color (30% of the school's
instructional staff) and the school's outcomes measures for
varying student populations. The school's President was quoted
as saying the school was not taking action ``. . . because [the
accreditor] says we have to, . . . . [W]e're doing it because
it's the right thing to do and it's mission-driven.''\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Eric Kelderman, The New Accountability: How accreditors are
measuring colleges' diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts, The
Chronicle of Higher Education, Apr. 3, 2023, https://www.chronicle.com/
article/the-new-accountability (``Today, six out of the seven major
institutional accreditors are developing ways to assess how colleges
serve historically underrepresented students, by examining
institutions' mission statements, the disparate outcomes between white
students and students of color, the diversity of their faculties, and
testimonies of community members about discrimination they face at the
colleges.'')
\14\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Absent any evidence that accreditors are denying schools
accreditation based on DEI policies, the question occurs as to
why are these provisions in H.R. 3724 necessary? Committee
Democrats believe the litmus test provision's desired effects
are two-fold.
Republicans have long sought to politicize the academy and
blur the lines between academic theory, research, scientific
method, political viewpoints, and belief.\15\ H.R. 3724's first
effect will be to further this effort by inserting this
blurring of lines directly into the assessment of academic
quality of a school's programs itself. Any academic discipline
that includes a ``controversial'' view could be one that
accreditors fear assessing, lest they run afoul of this
provision. Accreditors are further refrained from assessing an
institution or program of study's commitment to any ideology,
belief, or viewpoint.\16\ For example, if H.R. 3724 became law,
would a program accreditor, in assessing the quality of a
university environmental science program, be forced to ignore
that the program banned the teaching of the consensus
scientific belief that man-made climate change is real because
it was seen as ``political'' or merely a ``viewpoint''? The
litmus test provision will result in a chilling effect setting
in among accreditors, scaring them from taking an honest look
at a school's claims as to its mission or the quality its
programs, for fear they may wade into waters that could be
considered ``controversial''.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\E.g., Luke Jones, Ohio bill would ban colleges from discussing
diversity, climate change, WKRC, May 8, 2023, https://dayton247now.com/
news/local/ohio-bill-would-ban-colleges-discussing-diversity-climate-
change-senate-bill-sb-83-controversial-topics-banned-public-private-
universities-schools-inclusion-equity-illegal-topics-chinese-
government-schools-cincinnati-ohio; Columbia L. Sch., Sabin Ctr. for
Climate Change L., Silencing Science Tracker, https://climate.
law.columbia.edu/content/silencing-science-tracker.
\16\H.R. 3724, Sec. 2(a)(3).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Second, the litmus test provisions will dissuade
accreditors from making any assessment of what a school
purports to do in the field of DEI. This will allow schools to
stand up Potemkin DEI policies that promise an institutional
focus on creating a campus welcoming to all, knowing full well
their accreditor will not actually hold them accountable for
these policies. As the racial demographics of college students
continue to diversify,\17\ this could result in students
attending schools that claim to welcome them, only to find
those claims have never been verified.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\See, e.g., Audrey Williams June, As America Grows More Diverse,
a State's Colleges Follow Suit, Chron. of Higher Educ., Sept. 7, 2021.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Religious Institutions
The second half of H.R. 3724 focuses on accreditation for
religious colleges and universities. Religiously affiliated
institutions of higher education have been a part of our nation
since its early beginnings.\18\ Data from Integrated
Postsecondary Education Data System shows that during the 2022-
2023 Academic Year, 14.5 percent of U.S. institutions of higher
education were religiously affiliated.\19\ And though the total
number of higher education institutions fell by 14.4 percent
from 2010 to 2020, the number of religiously affiliated
institutions fell only 3.3 percent during this same time
period.\20\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Jessica Rose Daniels & Jacqueline N. Gustafson, Faith-Based
Institutions, Institutional Mission, and the Public Good, High. Learn.
Res. Commun., https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1132798.pdf (last
visited on Feb. 12, 2024).
\19\U.S. Dep't of Educ., Integrated Postsecondary Education Data
System (IPEDS), Data Collection 2022 for Title IV-participating IHEs
with a Religious affiliation.
\20\Ricardo Azziz, Are Faith-Based Colleges in Trouble? It
Depends., Higher Ed Dive (Aug. 14, 2023), https://www.highereddive.com/
news/are-faith-based-colleges-in-trouble-it-depends/690597/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under current law, accreditors must consistently apply and
enforce standards that respect an institution's mission,
including its religious mission, by basing decisions only on
the standards of accreditation.\21\ Current regulations also
already provide certain safeguards for the missions of
religious institutions while still maintaining the authority of
accreditors to require that curricula at such institutions meet
core components. Specifically, regulations state that an agency
meets its obligations related to consistency in decision-
making, if an accrediting agency
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\20 U.S.C. Sec. 1099b(a)(4); 34 C.F.R. Sec. Sec. 600.18(a)-
(b)(3).
Bases decisions regarding accreditation and
preaccreditation on the agency's published standards
and does not use as a negative factor the institution's
religious mission-based policies, decisions, and
practices [in the following areas: (1) curricula; (2)
faculty, (3) faculties, equipment, and supplies; (4)
student support services; (5) recruiting and admissions
practices, academic calendars, catalogs, publicans,
grading, and advertising] provided, however, that the
agency may require that the institution's or program's
curricula include all core components required by the
agency.\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\34 C.F.R. Sec. 602.18(b)(3) (emphasis added).
Thus, current regulations already restrict accrediting
agencies from interfering in a religious institution's
religious mission and operations in several areas, while
importantly affirming the continued authority of accrediting
agencies to ensure institutions meet required core curricula
components. It should be noted that the regulations mentioned
above were promulgated by the Trump administration in 2019, and
the U.S. Department of Education acknowledged, at that time, it
had ``not received any formal complaints about an institution's
negative treatment during the accreditation process because of
its adherence to a religious mission.''\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\Student Assistance General Provisions, The Secretary's
Recognition of Accrediting Agencies, The Secretary's Recognition of
Procedures for State Agencies, 84 Fed. Reg. 58834, 58861 (Nov. 1, 2019)
(codified at 34 C.F.R. Parts 600, 602, 603, 654, 668, and 674).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In contrast, H.R. 3724 proposes to protect the religious
mission and operations of religious institutions without
including that second vital policy piece: ensuring that
accrediting agencies maintain the authority to require
institutions to meet their curriculum standards. Moreover, H.R.
3724 is the second proposal considered by this Committee in
several weeks to weaken the accreditation process specifically
for religious institutions. H.R. 6951, the College Cost
Reduction Act, as passed by the Committee in January, proposed
a sweeping exemption allowing religious institutions to skirt
accreditation standards for core curricula requirements when
those standards were not consistent with the institution's
religious mission.\24\ Taken together, these legislative
proposals could undermine the accreditation process and
potentially mislead students that their chosen program of study
meets the stated accreditation standards without exception. As
a result, students may not be aware if they are not being
instructed in the core curriculum for their chosen program of
study. Committee Democrats believe that students have a
fundamental right to know if their program of study does not
meet accreditation standards. Under H.R. 3724, building upon
the already-reported H.R. 6951, students at religious
institutions may not be afforded the opportunity to learn what
other students in their field do, putting them at an unrealized
disadvantage when entering the workforce.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\The College Cost Reduction Act, H.R. 6951, 118th Congress (as
reported by the Committee on Education and the Workforce, January 31,
2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In summation, H.R. 3724 fails to preserve the important
function of accreditors to confirm that programs of study meet
stated core curricula standards. Since religious institutions
are currently able to execute the requirements of the law to
meet accreditation standards while maintaining their religious
identities, in addition to the fact that the current system
works