Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 7683]
[Including cost estimate of the Congressional Budget Office]
The Committee on Education and the Workforce, to whom was
referred the bill (H.R. 7683) to amend the Higher Education Act
of 1965 to require institutions of higher education to adopt
and adhere to principles of free speech, and for other
purposes, having considered the same, reports favorably thereon
with an amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do
pass.
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Respecting the First Amendment on
Campus Act''.
SEC. 2. SENSE OF CONGRESS.
The Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1001 et seq.) is amended
by inserting after section 112 the following new section:
``SEC. 112A. SENSE OF CONGRESS; CONSTRUCTION; DEFINITION.
``(a) Sense of Congress.--
``(1) Adoption of chicago principles.--The Congress--
``(A) recognizes that free expression, open inquiry,
and the honest exchange of ideas are fundamental to
higher education;
``(B) acknowledges the profound contribution of the
Chicago Principles to the freedom of speech and
expression; and
``(C) calls on nonsectarian institutions of higher
education to adopt the Chicago Principles or
substantially similar principles with respect to
institutional mission that emphasizes a commitment to
freedom of speech and expression on university campuses
and to develop and consistently implement policies
accordingly.
``(2) Political litmus tests.--The Congress--
``(A) condemns public institutions of higher
education for conditioning admission to any student
applicant, or the hiring, reappointment, or promotion
of any faculty member, on the applicant or faculty
member pledging allegiance to or making a statement of
personal support for or opposition to any political
ideology or movement, including a pledge or statement
regarding diversity, equity, and inclusion, or related
topics; and
``(B) discourages any institution from requesting or
requiring any such pledge or statement from an
applicant or faculty member, as such actions are
antithetical to the freedom of speech protected by the
First Amendment to the Constitution.
``(b) Construction.--Nothing in sections 112B through 112E shall be
construed to infringe upon, or otherwise impact, the protections
provided to individuals under titles VI and VII of the Civil Rights Act
of 1964 (42 U.S.C. 2000d et seq.).
``(c) Definition.--For purposes of sections 112C, 112D, and 112E, the
term `covered public institution' means an institution of higher
education that is--
``(1) a public institution; and
``(2) participating in a program authorized under title
IV.''.
SEC. 3. DISCLOSURE OF FREE SPEECH POLICIES.
The Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1001 et seq.), as amended
by section 2 of this Act, is further amended by inserting after section
112A the following new section:
``SEC. 112B. DISCLOSURE OF POLICIES RELATED TO FREEDOM OF SPEECH,
ASSOCIATION, AND RELIGION.
``(a) In General.--No institution of higher education shall be
eligible to participate in any program under title IV unless the
institution certifies to the Secretary that the institution has
annually disclosed to current and prospective students and faculty--
``(1) any policies held by the institutions related to--
``(A) speech on campus, including policies limiting--
``(i) the time when such speech may occur;
``(ii) the place where such speech may occur;
or
``(iii) the manner in which such speech may
occur;
``(B) freedom of association, if applicable; and
``(C) freedom of religion, if applicable; and
``(2) the right to a cause of action under section 112E, if
the institution is a public institution.
``(b) Intended Beneficiaries.--The certification specified in
subsection (a) shall include an acknowledgment from the institution
that the students and faculty are the intended beneficiaries of the
policies disclosed in the certification.''.
SEC. 4. FREEDOM OF ASSOCIATION AND RELIGION.
The Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. 1001 et seq.), as amended
by section 3 of this Act, is further amended by inserting after section
112B the following new section:
``SEC. 112C. FREEDOM OF ASSOCIATION AND RELIGION.
``(a) Students' Bill of Rights to Further Protect Speech and
Association.--
``(1) Protected rights.--A covered public institution shall
comply with the following requirements:
``(A) Recognized student organizations.--A covered
public institution that has recognized student
organizations shall comply with the following
requirements:
``(i) Faculty advisors.--
``(I) In general.--A covered public
institution may not deny recognition to
a student organization because the
organization is unable to obtain a
faculty advisor or sponsor, if the
organization meets each of the other
content- and viewpoint-neutral
institutional requirements for such
recognition.
``(II) Alternative.--An institution
described in subclause (I) shall ensure
that any policy or practice related to
the recognition of a student
organization--
``(aa) in the case of an
organization that meets each of
the other content- and
viewpoint-neutral institutional
requirements for such
recognition but is unable to
obtain a faculty advisor or
sponsor, provides for an
alternative to any requirement
that a faculty or staff member
serve as the faculty advisor or
sponsor as a condition for
recognition of the student
organization, which alternative
may include--
``(AA) waiver of such
requirement; or
``(BB) the
institution assigning a
faculty or staff member
to such organization;
and
``(bb) does not require a
faculty or staff member of the
institution assigned to serve
as faculty advisor pursuant to
item (aa)(BB) to participate
in, or support, the
organization other than by
performing the purely
administrative functions
required of a faculty advisor.
``(ii) Appeal options for recognition.--
``(I) In general.--A covered public
institution shall provide an appeals
process by which a student organization
that has been denied recognition by the
institution may appeal to an
institutional appellate entity for
reconsideration.
``(II) Requirements.--The appeal
process shall--
``(aa) require the covered
public institution to provide a
written explanation for the
basis for the denial of
recognition in a timely manner,
which shall include a copy of
all policies relied upon by the
institution as a basis for the
denial;
``(bb) require the covered
public institution to provide
written notice to the students
seeking recognition of the
appeal process and the timeline
for hearing and resolving the
appeal;
``(cc) allow the students
seeking recognition to obtain
outside counsel to represent
them during the appeal; and
``(dd) ensure that such
appellate entity did not
participate in any prior
proceeding related to the
denial of recognition to the
student organization.
``(B) Distribution of funds to student
organizations.--A covered public institution that
collects a mandatory fee from students for the costs of
student activities or events (or both), and provides
funds generated from such student fees to one or more
recognized student organizations of the institution,
shall--
``(i) establish and make publicly available
clear, objective, content- and viewpoint-
neutral, and exhaustive standards to be used by
the institution to determine--
``(I) the total amount of funds made
available for allocations to the
recognized student organizations; and
``(II) the allocations of such total
amount to individual recognized student
organizations;
``(ii) ensure that allocations are made to
the recognized student organizations in
accordance with the standards established
pursuant to clause (i);
``(iii) upon the request of a recognized
student organization that has been denied all
or a portion of an allocation described in
clause (ii), provide to the organization, in
writing (which may include electronic
communication) and in a timely manner, the
specific reasons for such denial, copies of all
policies relied upon by the institution as
basis for the denial, and information of the
appeals process described in clause (iv); and
``(iv) provide an appeals process by which a
recognized student organization that has been
denied all or a portion of an allocation
described in clause (ii) may appeal to an
institutional appellate entity for
reconsideration, which appeals process--
``(I) shall require the covered
public institution to provide written
notice to the students seeking an
allocation through the appeal process
and the timeline for hearing and
resolving the appeal;
``(II) allow the students seeking an
allocation to obtain outside counsel to
represent them during the appeal; and
``(III) require the institution to
ensure that such appellate entity did
not participate in any prior proceeding
related to such allocation.
``(C) Assessment of security fees for events.--A
covered public institution shall establish and make
publicly available clear, objective, content- and
viewpoint-neutral, and exhaustive standards to be used
by the institution to--
``(i) determine the amount of any security
fee for an event or activity organized by a
student or student organization; and
``(ii) ensure that a determination of such an
amount may not be based, in whole or in part,
on--
``(I) the content of expression or
viewpoint of the student or student
organization;
``(II) the content of expression of
the event or activity organized by the
student or student organization;
``(III) the content of expression or
viewpoint of an invited guest of the
student or student organization; or
``(IV) an anticipated reaction by
students or the public to the event.
``(D) Protections for invited guests and speakers.--A
covered public institution shall establish and make
publicly available clear, objective, content- and
viewpoint-neutral, and exhaustive standards to be used
by the institution related to the safety and protection
of speakers and guests who are invited to the
institution by a student or student organization.
``(2) Definitions.--In this subsection:
``(A) Recognized student organization.--The term
`recognized student organization' means a student
organization that has been determined by a covered
public institution to meet institutional requirements
to qualify for certain privileges granted by the
institution, such as use of institutional venues,
resources, and funding.
``(B) Security fee.--The term `security fee' means a
fee charged to a student or student organization for an
event or activity organized by the student or student
organization on the campus of the institution that is
intended to cover some or all of the costs incurred by
the institution for additional security measures needed
to ensure the security of the institution, students,
faculty, staff, or surrounding community as a result of
such event or activity.
``(b) Equal Campus Access.--A covered public institution shall not
deny to a religious student organization any right, benefit, or
privilege that is otherwise afforded to other student organizations at
the institution (including full access to the facilities of the
institution and official recognition of the organization by the
institution) because of the religious beliefs, practices, speech,
leadership standards, or standards of conduct of the religious student
organization.
``(c) Freedom of Association.--
``(1) Upholding freedom of association protections.--Any
student (or group of students) enrolled in an institution of
higher education that receives funds under this Act, including
through an institution's participation in any program under
title IV, shall--
``(A) subject to paragraph (3)(A), be able to form a
single-sex social organization, whether recognized by
the institution or not; and
``(B) be able to apply to join any single-sex social
organization; and
``(C) if selected for membership by any single-sex
social organization, be able to join, and participate
in, such single-sex organization, subject to its
standards for regulating its own membership, as
provided under paragraph (3)(C).
``(2) Nonretaliation against students of single-sex social
organizations.--An institution of higher education that
receives funds under this Act, including through an
institution's participation in any program under title IV,
shall not--
``(A) take any action to require or coerce a student
or prospective student who is a member or prospective
member of a single-sex social organization to waive the
protections provided under paragraph (1), including as
a condition of enrolling in the institution;
``(B) take any adverse action against a single-sex
social organization, or a student who is a member or a
prospective member of a single-sex social organization,
based on the membership practice of such organization
limiting membership only to individuals of one sex; or
``(C) impose a recruitment restriction (including a
recruitment restriction r
Committee Action
115TH CONGRESS
Second Session--Hearings
On September 24, 2018, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing on ``Examining First Amendment Rights
on Campus.'' The purpose of this hearing was to discuss how
institutions of higher education (IHEs) are and are not
protecting individual rights under the First Amendment to the
U.S. Constitution. Testifying before the Committee were Mr.
Zachary Wood, Author, Uncensored, New York, NY; Mr. Joseph
Cohn, Legislative and Policy Director, Foundation for
Individual Rights in Education, Philadelphia, PA; Ms. Suzanne
Nossel, Chief Executive Officer, PEN America, New York, NY; and
Mr. Ken Paulson, President, First Amendment Center, Nashville,
TN.
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On March 29, 2023, the Committee's Higher Education and
Workforce Development Subcommittee held a hearing on
``Diversity of Thought: Protecting Free Speech on College
Campuses.'' The purpose of this hearing was to highlight the
ways in which free speech rights are being violated on college
campuses and to discuss potential legislative solutions to
preserve this aspect of the First Amendment. Testifying before
the Subcommittee were Mrs. Cherise Trump, Executive Director,
Speech First, Washington, D.C.; Mr. Josiah Joner, Executive
Editor, The Stanford Review, Stanford, CA; Ms. Suzanne Nossel,
Chief Executive Officer, PEN America, New York, NY; and Mr.
Ilya Shapiro, Director of Constitutional Studies, Manhattan
Institute, Washington, D.C.
On March 7, 2024, the Committee's Higher Education and
Workforce Development Subcommittee held a hearing on
``Divisive, Excessive, Ineffective: The Real Impact of DEI on
College Campuses.'' The purpose of the hearing was to examine
ways in which institutions and accreditors are engaging in
harmful diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) practices,
including how those practices impact First Amendment rights.
Testifying before the Subcommittee were Dr. Erec Smith,
Associate Professor of Rhetoric, York College of Pennsylvania,
Cato Research Fellow, York, PA; Dr. James Murphy, Director of
Career Pathways and Post-Secondary Policy, Education Reform
Now, Washington, D.C.; Dr. Stanley Goldfarb, Chair, Do No Harm,
Bryn Mawr, PA; and Dr. Jay Greene, Senior Research Fellow, The
Heritage Foundation's Center for Education Policy,
Fayetteville, AR.
Legislative Action
On March 15, 2024, Representative Brandon Williams (R-NY)
introduced the Respecting the First Amendment on Campus Act
(H.R. 7683) with Representatives Glenn Thompson (R-PA) and
Virginia Foxx (R-NC).
The bill was referred solely to the Committee on Education
and the Workforce. On March 21, 2024, the Committee considered
H.R. 7683 in legislative session and reported it favorably, as
amended, to the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of
24-14. The Committee considered the following amendments to
H.R. 7683:
1. Representative Williams offered an Amendment in the
Nature of a Substitute that made one minor grammatical change
to the bill. The amendment was adopted by voice vote.
2. Representative Kathy Manning (D-NC) offered an amendment
that requires public colleges to explain during student
orientation the student protections under Title VI of the Civil
Rights Act and the procedures for filing a claim for
discrimination. The amendment was adopted by voice vote.
3. Representative Kathy Manning (D-NC) offered an amendment
that states that nothing in the bill is meant to prohibit IHEs
from taking action against a student organization that
knowingly provides material support or resources to an
organization designated as a foreign terrorist organization.
The amendment was adopted by voice vote.
Committee Views
INTRODUCTION
A university's key purpose is to create a marketplace of
ideas ordered to the pursuit of knowledge. Whether enrolled in
a liberal arts program, cybersecurity certificate, or in
medical school, students learn fundamental theories and must
know how to apply their knowledge to real world challenges,
often preparing arguments and confronting differing opinions
from their own as they seek, discover, and explore the best
ideas their peers and the world have to offer. Freedom of
speech and the other First Amendment rights have been a
cornerstone in advancing American postsecondary education. The
Supreme Court has long established that ``state colleges and
universities are not enclaves immune from the sweep of the
First Amendment.''\1\ Unfortunately, we regularly see the First
Amendment under attack at colleges and universities.\2\ H.R.
7683, the Respecting the First Amendment on Campus Act, ensures
that the First Amendment is upheld at public colleges and
universities as well as at private colleges and universities
that promise specific rights to their students and receive
federal funding through Title IV of the HEA. Learning the art
of disagreement, persuasion, and resolution produces better
students and citizens, not angry mobs who silence their
opposition or coerce conformity to specific ideologies and
beliefs. H.R. 7683 will uphold Americans' constitutional rights
and restore decency on college campuses.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Healy v. James, 408 U.S. 169 (1972); Widmar v. Vincent, 454 U.S.
263 (1981) which states ``our cases leave no doubt that the First
Amendment rights of speech and association extend to the campuses of
state universities.''
\2\https://www.insidehighered.com/news/quick-takes/2024/04/01/rep-
raskin-shouted-down-university-
maryland?utm_source=Inside+Higher+Ed&utm_campaign=685a187579-
DNU_2021_COPY_02&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_1fcbc04421-685a187579-
236720318&mc_cid=685a187579&mc_eid=c9e98a4375.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Modern Challenges to Free Speech on Campuses
Attacks on free speech can come from other students,
faculty, or the university leadership itself. They can be
either deliberate or inadvertent. Threats to free speech take
various forms: shout downs,\3\ disinvitations of speakers,\4\
free speech zones,\5\ security fees,\6\ political litmus
tests,\7\ and even physical violence in reaction to speech\8\
are pervasive on college campuses. Students and faculty should
never fear for their safety and livelihoods for expressing
differing, and often conservative, opinions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\https://www.insidehighered.com/news/students/free-speech/2023/
04/13/shouting-down-speakers-who-offend.
\4\https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2018/06/29/universities-
politically-controversial-commencement-speakers-student-protest-column/
734068002/.
\5\https://www.campusreform.org/article/georgia-schools-free-
speech-zone-policy-might-breaking-law-legal-group- finds-exclusive-/
24999.
\6\https://www.thefire.org/news/dartmouth-continues-violate-
college-republicans-rights-imposing-3600-security-fees-following.
\7\https://www.goldwaterinstitute.org/asus-dei-regime-mandates-
discriminatory-inclusivity-training-so-were-suing/.
\8\https://pen.org/press-release/pen-america-condemns-uc-berkeley-
protests-that-turned-violent-with-reported-antisemitic-bigotry/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shout Downs (the Heckler's Veto) and Disinvitations
Deliberate shout downs occur when protesters, generally
student led, attempt to disrupt or cancel a speech by yelling
over the speaker, issuing threats, or even rioting. When the
university either fails to stand up for the rights of the
speaker or suppresses the speaker's speech because of the
anticipated or actual reactions of the speaker's opponents, a
heckler's veto has occurred.
A stark example of a heckler's veto was seen when Stanford
law students shouted down U.S. Court of Appeals Judge Stuart
Kyle Duncan during an event hosted by the Federalist Society
Chapter at Stanford Law School. Judge Duncan had been invited
to lecture on recent decisions handed down by the Fifth
Circuit, but students heckling and shouting obscenities
directly at him prevented him from finishing his remarks.
Multiple Stanford administrators were in the room, but when
Judge Duncan asked them to intervene, a DEI administrator read
prepared remarks shaming the judge for his opinions and
claiming that he made students uncomfortable.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\https://www.foxnews.com/politics/new-video-shows-stanford-
protesters-heckling-trump-judge-as-dei-dean-appears-to-smirk.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While in some instances protestors are protected by the
First Amendment, free speech does not mean hecklers get to shut
down a campus event.\10\ Free speech is allowed in public
forums, but the Federalist Society event constituted a limited
public forum where viewpoint-neutral and reasonable
restrictions have been held as appropriate in the educational
setting.\11\ After calls for the university to take stronger
action to uphold the university's policies against this type of
free speech violation, on March 22, 2023, the Stanford Law Dean
released a letter more thoroughly reprimanding the actions that
took place as not in line with university free speech policy.
The letter also announced that students would be required to
take mandatory educational programming to better understand
freedom of speech and announced the DEI Dean would be
suspended.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/03/24/free-speech-
doesnt-mean-hecklers-get-shut-down-campus-debate/.
\11\Christian Legal Soc. Chapter of Univ. of Cal., Hastings College
of Law v. Martinez, 561 U.S. 661 (2010).
\12\https://law.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Next-Steps-
on-Protests-and-Free-
Speech.pdf?mkt_tok=ODg0LUZTQi0zMDcAAAGKqNfmUfz2S_PCzkgUjCQGrC2DR1ji-
TGeKtn3NnnIoJpAduaZaZdKteNsL5dGzCkk5cwWC_6vm8autYIUyUQO4uIJy6lLbBGo4
7NHk8_3iTA.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sadly, student acceptance of speaker shout downs remains
high. A recent survey found that 45 percent of students believe
blocking other students from attending a speech is
acceptable.\13\ Even more worrisome, 25 percent of students
believe using violence to stop speech is acceptable.\14\ This
threat of violence and campus disruption has led multiple
universities to preemptively cancel appearances by potentially
``offensive'' speakers who simply have views that are contrary
to the majority opinion on campus.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\https://www.thefire.org/research-learn/2024-college-free-
speech-rankings.
\14\Ibid.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Free speech zones and security fees
Institutions must allow for ample opportunities for speech
on campus. An institution may constitutionally craft a content
and viewpoint neutral process for placing reasonable time,
place, and manner restrictions on speech activities, but the
so-called ``free speech zones'' that exist at many universities
go much further. These oxymoronically named locations are
plainly at odds with the First Amendment: while ``free speech
zones'' have been propped up by some universities as areas
where students can speak their minds, they effectively prohibit
free speech anywhere outside the zone. Further, ``free speech
zones'' are often small and in out-of-the-way areas, and thus
add further restrictions to free speech. Still worse, sometimes
students can only conditionally use a ``free speech zone,''
often needing to comply with requirements like pre-registering
an event with an administrator, often days or weeks in advance,
or adhere to strict time limits on expressive activities. H.R.
7683 builds on Representative Greg Murphy's (R-NC) Campus Free
Speech Restoration Act to prohibit public institutions from
restricting an individual from freely engaging in noncommercial
expressive activity on campus, including in ``free speech
zones,'' except in limited and viewpoint-neutral circumstances
consistent with the First Amendment. At its core, the freedom
of speech allows for ample expression and should not be
repressed by public institutions that censor speech through
shout downs and other means. However, H.R. 7683 does state that
expressive activity does not include unprotected speech as
defined by Supreme Court precedents.
Even when an institution moves forward with appropriate
time, place, and manner restrictions, institutions sometimes
assess high security fees to cover the costs of maintaining
campus security during the visit of a controversial
speaker.\15\ While government actors may charge security fees
for those wishing to use public facilities for expressive
purposes, the Supreme Court has held that varying the amount of
security fees because of the anticipated hostility to speech is
unconstitutional.\16\ A student or student group hosting a
speaker cannot receive a drastically different security fee
assessment than another student or student group on the basis
that the event might draw protest. Institutions should remain
committed to only implementing content-neutral policies,
including security fee provisions. Representative Erin
Houchin's (R-IN) Student Bill of Rights would require public
institutions to make publicly available clear, objective, and
content-and-viewpoint neutral standards to determine the
security fees assessed for events. This policy is included
within H.R. 7683 to ensure colleges are abiding by content-
and-viewpoint neutral fee assessments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\https://www.yaf.org/news/berkeley-charges-conservative-
students-15k-exercise-first-amendment-rights/.
\16\Forsyth County, Georgia v. Nationalist Movement, 505 U.S. 123
(1992).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 7683 includes several other policies that would
protect speech from censorship. The bill includes a Sense of
Congress that non-sectarian institutions should adopt the well-
known Chicago Principles, or similar principles, that are a
model statement expressing an institution's commitment to
allowing free expression on campus.\17\ Additionally, H.R. 7683
would decrease the likelihood of incidents of speech censorship
by including Representative Kevin Kiley's (R-CA) Free Speech On
Campus Act, which would require institutions to provide written
educational materials during college orientation to explain
students' First Amendment rights. Lastly, H.R. 7683 maintains
robust accountability through transparency and requires all
institutions that choose to receive federal aid through Title
IV of the HEA to annually disclose any university policies
regarding rights to speech, association, and religious
expression as a condition of receiving aid. Increasing student
and faculty awareness of university policies will decrease
incidents of shout downs, cancellations, and disinvitations.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\https://provost.uchicago.edu/sites/default/files/documents/
reports/FOECommitteeReport.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Political Litmus Tests
Universities also preemptively discourage unwanted speech
and viewpoints through the use of political litmus tests. Many
prospective and current students and faculty are being
compelled to sign statements, provide specific statements, or
otherwise express support for a particular position or ideology
the institution wishes to propagate. Failure to adopt the
prescribed opinion can result in academic or professional
consequences for students and faculty. By pressuring students
and faculty to adopt a political position or ideology, these
university actions choke dissent and free inquiry. One such
document is the ``Diversity Statement'' that many universities
and colleges now require of applicants in their faculty hiring
processes. A 2021 American Enterprise Institute report found
that one out of every five American professors is hired based
on his or her commitment to the principles of DEI instead of
his or her merit.\18\ Representative Elise Stefanik's (R-NY)
Restoring Academic Freedom on Campus Act would require
institutions to end the use of political tests, such as
required DEI statements, in admission, hiring, and promotion
processes. A variation of this bill is included within H.R.
7683. Students and faculty must be free to question, research,
and argue in pursuit of knowledge. Institutions that use such
political tests and programming to shut out varying views
ensure ideological monopoly and conformity--both of which are
antithetical to a college education.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\https://www.aei.org/research-products/report/other-than-merit-
the-prevalence-of-diversity-equity-and-inclusion- statements-in-
university-hiring/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Freedom of Association and Religion
In addition to protecting free speech, H.R. 7683 protects
the right to assemble, which also guarantees individuals the
freedom to associate with others. The First Amendment extends
to government actors, including public institutions, which must
not deny students from joining or forming a student
organization, including a religious student organization. Court
decisions have also affirmed that religious student
organizations, as well as other student organizations, should
be allowed to require their leaders to subscribe to certain
leadership requirements.\19\ Public institutions must also
provide benefits to religious student organizations in the same
manner as all other student organizations.\20\ Representative
Tim Walberg's (R-MI) Equal Campus Access Act would prohibit a
public institution from denying a religious student group any
right similarly afforded to other student organizations because
of the religious group's beliefs, practices, or leadership
standards. This bill is included in H.R. 7683. Private
institutions are not obligated to provide the same association
opportunities or freedom of religion policies, but many private
colleges nevertheless support student organizations and
religious student organizations. If a private institution's
policies provide these promises, then they must uphold the
benefit.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\https://www.becketlaw.org/case/intervarsity-christian-
fellowship-v-university-iowa/.
\20\Rosenberger v. Rector and Visitors of the University of
Virginia, 515 U.S. 819 (1995).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Courts have also defined the rights of student
organizations specifically, as examples of institutions
abridging freedoms have come to light in a variety of ways.
H.R. 7683 includes Representative Houchin's Students Bill of
Rights Act to tackle the issues student organizations may face.
First, student groups seek ``recognition'' from
universities to receive a porti
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
H.R. 7683, the Respecting the First Amendment on Campus
Act, amends the Higher Education Act of 1965 (HEA) to create a
new compliance regime for public colleges and universities
around aspects of the Constitutionally-protected freedoms of
speech, religion and association. Supporters of H.R. 7683
suggest it protects freedoms for all students and faculty, but
such protections are only necessary if you first accept the
Majority's premise that there is a ``free speech crisis'' on
campuses around the country.\1\ This ``crisis'' does not exist,
as described by the Majority, and this bill is unnecessary. The
First Amendment has existed to protect the rights of free
expression on college campuses since 1791. Individuals can and
will continue to avail themselves of its protections--they do
not need any help from H.R. 7683 to do so.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Campus free speech was the subject of the last education-related
hearing held by the Majority in the 115th Congress before it lost the
gavel, and the third education-related hearing held by the Majority in
the 118th Congress when it regained the gavel. Examining First
Amendment Rights on Campus: Hearing Before the H. Comm. on Educ. & the
Workforce, 115th Cong. (2018); Diversity of Thought: Protecting Free
Speech on College Campuses: Hearing Before the Subcomm. on Higher Educ.
& Workforce Development of the H. Comm on Educ. & the Workforce, 118th
Cong. (2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
BACKGROUND ON THE FIRST AMENDMENT ON COLLEGE CAMPUSES
Despite the premise underlying H.R. 7683, public
institutions of higher education (IHEs) are state actors, and
must already comply with First Amendment protections related to
speech, religion, and association.\2\ College campuses are
often fora where controversial ideas are discussed both in and
out of classroom settings, and tensions may naturally run high.
Such discussions can be infused with hateful speech--speech
that while abhorrent, is constitutionally protected.\3\ This
results in situations where public IHEs are compelled to grant
fora to hateful speech they disagree with, lest they violate
the First Amendment. Tension around this issue has been at the
center of the response of many colleges to student discourse in
the aftermath of the October 7th Hamas attack on Israel.\4\
Similarly, when a student group brings a controversial speaker
to campus, public universities must provide a platform for such
speakers, even if a school reasonably believes the presence of
that speaker could result in commotion and counterprotest.\5\
Free speech on campus is not absolute--courts have held that
states (and by extension state colleges and universities) have
power to control access to their property and make
determination as to whether an area is a public forum with
largely unfettered free speech rights, or something lesser.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\E.g., Healy v. James, 408 U.S. 169, 180 (1972) (``At the outset
we note that state colleges and universities are not enclaves immune
from the sweep of the First Amendment.'').
\3\See Brandenburg v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 444, 447 (1969). Free speech
rights are not absolute. Over time courts have devised tests to
determine what types of speech are not deserving of First Amendment
protection. The result is three very narrowly tailored classes or types
of speech that the government, and by extension public IHEs, can
prohibit without violating the First Amendment. These are obscenity,
defamation, and fighting words. E.g., Chaplinsky v. New Hampshire, 315
U.S. 568 (1942).
\4\This specifically refers to Constitutionally protected speech
and not incidents that fall outside of First Amendment protection, or
speech and actions that could be considered harassment under Title VI
of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
\5\See, e.g., Am. C.L. Union, Speech on Campus, (Dec. 18, 2023),
https://www.aclu.org/documents/speech-campus.
\6\E.g., Turning Point USA v. Rhodes, 973 F.3d 868, 875-77 (8th
Cir., 2020) (``The First Amendment guarantees a right of free speech.
But while the First Amendment's text prohibits laws `abridging the
freedom of speech,' the freedom of speech enjoyed by citizens is not
absolute. The Constitution does not give Hoggard `unfettered latitude'
to speak and set up tables `wherever and whenever [s]he might choose.'
Rather, the State of Arkansas, `no less than a private owner of
property, has the power to preserve the property under its control for
the use to which it is lawfully dedicated.' As such, the First
Amendment does not require Arkansas to `freely . . . grant access to
all who wish to exercise their right to free speech' on its property
`without regard to the nature of the property or to the disruption that
might be caused by the speaker's activities.' Thus, the legality of
speech restrictions on state property `turns on the nature of the
property involved and the restrictions imposed.'(internal citations
omitted)).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the event that an individual believes that a public IHE
has infringed on its rights, they can sue for injunctive relief
and the remedy would be the IHE would be forced to stop the
infringement. However, state entities generally retain
sovereign immunity against money damage remedies.\7\ Similarly,
under the doctrine of qualified immunity, public school
officials themselves may only be held liable for damages under
certain proscribed circumstances.\8\ It is the elimination of
these immunities, not the protection of free speech, that is
the key to understanding H.R. 7683.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\U.S. Const. amend. XI.
\8\Turning Point, supra note 6. at 875 (``Qualified immunity
shields public officials from liability for civil damages if their
conduct did not 'violate clearly established statutory or
constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have
known.'')(internal quotes omitted).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 7683 IS A POOR SUBSTITUTE FOR THE FIRST AMENDMENT
Nothing currently prevents individuals from seeking
injunctive relief to stop a public IHE from violating their
First Amendment rights. H.R. 7683 simply abandons the First
Amendment as the protector of speech and creates instead a new
legislative scheme. In doing so it makes an end- run around the
civil rights principles of sovereign and qualified immunity
courts have consistently upheld in First Amendment cases.\9\
The bill adds four new substantive sections to HEA that dictate
how a public IHE must disclose free speech, religion, and
association policies, and proscribe specific rules a public IHE
must follow in regards to First Amendment activity that differ
from existing constitutional caselaw. The bill then creates a
specific cause of action to hold schools (and their staff)
liable for money damages for violating this new scheme by
conditioning a public IHE's participation in federal student
aid as an unequivocal waiver of sovereign immunity. This
conditioning has the added benefit of placing the bill in the
Committee's jurisdiction, as discussion of such Constitutional
issues would normally be the jurisdiction of the Committee on
the Judiciary. This is reinforced by including for good measure
the possibility a public IHE could lose that Title IV aid as
well for a violation of this new system.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\See, e.g., Cent. Va. Cmty. Coll. V. Katz, 546 U.S. 356, 360
(2006)(``Petitioners are Virginia institutions of higher education that
are considered ``arms of the State'' entitled to sovereign immunity.''
(internal quotes omitted).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Conservative speech, along with other First Amendment freedoms, thrive
on campus
The Majority continues to iterate its concerns about a free
speech crisis on campus and claims that H.R. 7683 will make
entire public university campuses a ```free speech zone' where
students are exposed to different opinions'', and ``learn how
to debate contested ideas''.\10\ They claim the lack of
``viewpoint diversity'' on campus inhibits the ability of
conservative students to express their views. Evidence suggests
that notwithstanding such a viewpoint imbalance, conservative
thought continues to flourish on college campuses. The
Majority's analysis consistently fails to acknowledge that
conservative speech on campus is propped up by a vast network
of outside organizations that support such speech,
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Press Release, H. Comm. on Educ. & the Workforce, Chairwoman
Foxx Delivers Opening Remarks at Markup to Bolster Workforce and
Advance Academic Freedom, Mar. 21, 2024, https://edworkforce.house.gov/
news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=410332.
. . . ranging from financial resources for campus
recruiting, conference travel, and summer fellowships
to opportunities to bring speakers onto campus and
templates for media blitzes. . . . [C]onservative
organizations not only channel activism, but also
create a career funnel that helps young activists find
paid internships and occupational opportunities within
the conservative sector. In contrast, students in the
progressive channel are unable to build upon external
sponsorships, but must navigate in more of a do-it-
yourself environment, both in terms of political
activism and future career prospects.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Daniel Meyer, Campus Activism in Polarized Times, 87 Higher
Educ. 813-818 (2023) (reviewing The Channels of Student Activism: How
the Left and Right Are Winning (and Losing) in Campus Politics Today by
Amy Binder and Jeffrey Kidder).
By their own accounts, there are over 2,000 College
Republicans chapters on American college campuses,\12\ over
2,000 chapters of Young Americans for Freedom,\13\ over 800
college chapters of Turning Point USA,\14\ and over 200
chapters of the Federalist Society at U.S. law schools.\15\
This is just the most public tip of the iceberg of
infrastructure and private capital dedicated to incubating
conservative thinkers and leaders on campus and vaulting them
into positions of political influence in Washington, D.C. and
state capitals around the country.\16\ Claims of a campus free
speech crisis simply perpetuate the need to continue to
subsidize more conservative voices on campus who then claim as
part of their activism, that there is a free speech crisis on
campus.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\College Republican National Committee, About CRNC, https://
www.crnc.org/about (last visited Mar. 30, 2024). This is distinct from
College Republicans of America, the Political Action Committee founded
former college republicans designed ``to empower, train, and develop
the next generation of Republican leaders. By providing resources,
training, networking opportunities, and incentives for students to
volunteer in our various initiatives, CRA enables our young Republicans
to advocate for conservative principles, support Republican candidates,
effect change in our communities, conserve our environment, secure
employment, and shape public policy.'' https://www.uscollegegop.com/.
\13\Young America's Foundation, Home Page, https://yaf.org/ (last
visited Mar.30, 2024) (``Young America's Foundation is the leading
organization for young conservatives. With more than 60 years of
experience and contacts on more than 2,000 campuses, we help students
like you find support, promote conservatism, and take action.'').
\14\Turning Point USA, College Program--Turning Point USA, https://
www.tpusa.com/college (last visited Mar. 30, 2024) (``Turning Point USA
College educates students about the importance of limited government,
freedom, and capitalism. This department has 48 full-time field
representatives that exist to educate, support, train, and empower
students through grassroots activism and peer-to-peer conversations. .
. . With nearly over 800+ college chapters, this program is the largest
and most impactful--successfully rebranding the movement to make it fun
and engaging to young people.'').
\15\The Federalist Society, Student Division, The Federalist
Society, https://fedsoc.org/divisions/student (last visited Mar. 30,
2024) (``Student Division programming fosters a network of conservative
and libertarian students eager to challenge the legal establishment as
lawyers, faculty, judges, and policy makers.''); The Federalist
Society, About Us, https://fedsoc.org/about-us#FAQ (last visited Apr.
1, 2024) (``Everyone is welcome to the programs of our more than 200
law school chapters, over 100 metropolitan lawyers chapters, and 15
nationwide practice groups. The several hundred events sponsored each
year by the Federalist Society are publicly advertised and are open to
the press and the general public.'')
\16\See, e.g., Julian Epp, Republicans Have Spent Millions on Youth
Outreach. And It's Working., The Nation, Oct. 6, 2022, https://
www.thenation.com/article/politics/raising-them-right-kyle-spencer-
conservative-youth/ (featuring discussion with Kyle Spencer, author of
Raising Them Right, The Untold Story of America's Ultraconservative
Youth Movement and Its Plot for Power).
\17\Id. (``Once the young conservatives began to latch onto the
culture wars--and particularly around the idea of ``free speech''--they
really started to gain traction. They spread this idea that young
conservatives were not allowed to speak on college campuses. If you
send that message enough, and then present yourself as the antidote,
that's pretty powerful.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 7683 is not limited to political speech. Portions of
the bill include new requirements for public IHEs in
recognizing both sectarian and religious student organizations.
Under H.R. 7683, public IHE's would have to ensure that any
student organization that wanted official recognition by the
school but could not achieve this for lack of a willing faculty
advisor had some path to official recognition.\18\ Further, the
bill would require public IHEs to develop specific procedures,
including appellate procedures, for determining how funds are
allocated to official organizations.\19\ The bill would require
all IHEs that receive Title IV aid (including private
institutions) to allow students to organize and join ``any
single-sex social organization'', regardless of whether such
organization has been recognized by the IHE.\20\ While the
Majority's rhetoric is not as explicit in these areas, the
implication of H.R. 7683 is that college administrations are
preventing students from joining groups en masse and stopping
religious groups from existing on campus. Again, the numbers do
not reflect this reality. There are over 350,000 fraternity and
410,000 sorority undergraduate members in the US.\21\ There are
over 2,000 American chapters of Campus Crusade for Christ and
nearly 600 U.S. colleges served by Hillel International.\22\
Just as there is no free speech crisis, there is not a crisis
on campus preventing students from joining organizations or
exercising their freedom of religion.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\H.R. 7683, Sec. 4 (creating HEA Sec. 112C(a)(1)(A)(i), Faculty
Advisors).
\19\Id. (creating HEA Sec. 112C(a)(1)(B), Distribution of Funds to
Student Organizations).
\20\Id. (creating HEA Sec. 112C(c), Freedom of Association).
\21\E.g., Elon University, IFC Fraternities and Sororities, https:/
/www.elon.edu/u/fraternity-and-sorority-life/about-us/councils/ifc/
(last visited Mar. 30, 2024); Cleveland Panhellenic CAPA, National
Panhellenic Conference, https://www.clevelandpanhellenic.org/ national-
panhellenic-conference#::text=NPC%20sororities%20are
%20located%20on,undergraduate %20members%20in%205%2C110 %20chapters.
(last visited Mar. 30, 2024). This represents the undergraduate
population of fraternities that belong to the North American
Interfraternity Conference and sororities that are members of the
National Panhellenic Conference. This number does not include the
approximately 4 million members of the fraternities and sororities that
compose the National Pan-Hellenic Conference (colloquially referred to
as the Divine Nine). Jay King, `Divine Nine' fraternities and
sororities continue to have powerful influence, Greenville Journal,
Feb. 22, 2022. Many of the chapters of these fraternities and
sororities are graduate chapters where members join after completing
their undergraduate degree, or chapters based not at specific schools
but cities, counties or other regional subdivisions, as participation
in the chapter extends through a member's entire life.
\22\Campus Crusade for Christ, International, Cru, https://
www.cru.org/us/en/communities/campus/collegebound/studentwelcome.html
(last visited Mar. 30, 2024); Hillel International, Find a Hillel,
https://www.hillel.org/find-a-hillel/?search=&location=&location-
distance=25mi&jewish-experience%5B%5D=has-hillel&college-
type=all&country=US (last visited Mar. 30, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While there is not a ``free speech'' crisis, or a ``freedom
of association crisis'' there are, however nearly 2,000 public
colleges and universities in the United States,\23\ each with
their own distinctive student bodies, campuses, and local,
state, and federal legal frameworks. As such there is an array
of differing rules and requirements (with corresponding
rationales and justifications) regulating free expression,
association, and student organizations on each campus.
Regardless of the situation on any particular campus, there are
self-evident simple rationales for many of these rules. Yet,
despite the lack of evidence of rampant First Amendment
violations unresolved by existing remedies afforded by the
First Amendment, H.R. 7683 would require schools to participate
in a compliance system for certain aspects of the First
Amendment expression on campus. As the American Council on
Education wrote in its joint letter with the American
Association of Community Colleges, the American Association of
State Colleges and Universities, the Association of American
Universities, the Association of Public and Land-grant
Universities, and the National Association of Independent
Colleges and Universities:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\Nat'l. Ctr. for Educ. Stats. Fast Facts--Educational
Institutions, https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=1122
(reporting that in 2020-21, there were 1.892 public postsecondary
institutions participating in HEA Title IV).
H.R. 7683 would inject the federal government in
higher education in a new and counterproductive fash