Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 2640]
The Committee on the Judiciary, to whom was referred the
bill (H.R. 2640) to provide for reform of the asylum system and
protection of the border, having considered the same, reports
favorably thereon with an amendment and recommends that the
bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 35
Background and Need for the Legislation.......................... 35
Hearings......................................................... 66
Committee Consideration.......................................... 66
Committee Votes.................................................. 67
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 89
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures........................ 89
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate........................ 89
Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects.......................... 89
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 89
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 89
Advisory on Earmarks............................................. 90
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 90
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 90
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 90
Correspondence................................................... 91
Section-by-Section Analysis...................................... 97
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 107
Minority Views................................................... 264
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all that follows after the enacting clause and insert
the following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
(a) Short Title.--This Act may be cited as the ``Border Security and
Enforcement Act of 2023''.
(b) Table of Contents.--The table of contents for this Act is as
follows:
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
TITLE I--ASYLUM REFORM AND BORDER PROTECTION
Sec. 101. Short title.
Sec. 102. Safe third country.
Sec. 103. Credible fear interviews.
Sec. 104. Clarification of asylum eligibility.
Sec. 105. Exceptions.
Sec. 106. Employment authorization.
Sec. 107. Asylum fees.
Sec. 108. Rules for determining asylum eligibility.
Sec. 109. Firm resettlement.
Sec. 110. Notice concerning frivolous asylum applications.
Sec. 111. Technical amendments.
Sec. 112. Requirement for procedures relating to certain asylum
applications.
TITLE II--BORDER SAFETY AND MIGRANT PROTECTION
Sec. 201. Short title.
Sec. 202. Inspection of applicants for admission.
Sec. 203. Operational detention facilities.
TITLE III--ENSURING UNITED FAMILIES AT THE BORDER
Sec. 301. Short title.
Sec. 302. Clarification of standards for family detention.
TITLE IV--PROTECTION OF CHILDREN
Sec. 401. Short title.
Sec. 402. Findings.
Sec. 403. Repatriation of unaccompanied alien children.
Sec. 404. Special immigrant juvenile status for immigrants unable to
reunite with either parent.
Sec. 405. Rule of construction.
TITLE V--VISA OVERSTAYS PENALTIES
Sec. 501. Short title.
Sec. 502. Expanded penalties for illegal entry or presence.
TITLE VI--IMMIGRATION PAROLE REFORM
Sec. 601. Short title.
Sec. 602. Immigration parole reform.
Sec. 603. Implementation.
Sec. 604. Cause of action.
Sec. 605. Severability.
TITLE VII--LEGAL WORKFORCE
Sec. 701. Short title.
Sec. 702. Employment eligibility verification process.
Sec. 703. Employment eligibility verification system.
Sec. 704. Recruitment, referral, and continuation of employment.
Sec. 705. Good faith defense.
Sec. 706. Preemption and States' rights.
Sec. 707. Repeal.
Sec. 708. Penalties.
Sec. 709. Fraud and misuse of documents.
Sec. 710. Protection of Social Security Administration programs.
Sec. 711. Fraud prevention.
Sec. 712. Use of employment eligibility verification photo tool.
Sec. 713. Identity authentication employment eligibility verification
pilot programs.
Sec. 714. Inspector General audits.
Sec. 715. Agriculture Workforce Study.
Sec. 716. Repealing regulations.
TITLE I--ASYLUM REFORM AND BORDER PROTECTION
SEC. 101. SHORT TITLE.
This title may be cited as the ``Asylum Reform and Border Protection
Act of 2023''.
SEC. 102. SAFE THIRD COUNTRY.
Section 208(a)(2)(A) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C.
1158(a)(2)(A)) is amended--
(1) by striking ``if the Attorney General determines'' and
inserting ``if the Attorney General or the Secretary of
Homeland Security determines--'';
(2) by striking ``that the alien may be removed'' and
inserting the following:
``(i) that the alien may be removed'';
(3) by striking ``, pursuant to a bilateral or multilateral
agreement, to'' and inserting ``to'';
(4) by inserting ``or the Secretary, on a case by case
basis,'' before ``finds that'';
(5) by striking the period at the end and inserting ``; or'';
and
(6) by adding at the end the following:
``(ii) that the alien entered, attempted to enter, or arrived
in the United States after transiting through at least one
country outside the alien's country of citizenship,
nationality, or last lawful habitual residence en route to the
United States, unless--
``(I) the alien demonstrates that he or she applied
for protection from persecution or torture in at least
one country outside the alien's country of citizenship,
nationality, or last lawful habitual residence through
which the alien transited en route to the United
States, and the alien received a final judgment denying
the alien protection in each country;
``(II) the alien demonstrates that he or she was a
victim of a severe form of trafficking in which a
commercial sex act was induced by force, fraud, or
coercion, or in which the person induced to perform
such act was under the age of 18 years; or in which the
trafficking included the recruitment, harboring,
transportation, provision, or obtaining of a person for
labor or services through the use of force, fraud, or
coercion for the purpose of subjection to involuntary
servitude, peonage, debt bondage, or slavery, and was
unable to apply for protection from persecution in each
country through which the alien transited en route to
the United States as a result of such severe form of
trafficking; or
``(III) the only countries through which the alien
transited en route to the United States were, at the
time of the transit, not parties to the 1951 United
Nations Convention relating to the Status of Refugees,
the 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees,
or the United Nations Convention against Torture and
Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or
Punishment.''.
SEC. 103. CREDIBLE FEAR INTERVIEWS.
Section 235(b)(1)(B)(v) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8
U.S.C. 1225(b)(1)(B)(v)) is amended by striking ``there is a
significant possibility'' and all that follows, and inserting ``,
taking into account the credibility of the statements made by the alien
in support of the alien's claim, as determined pursuant to section
208(b)(1)(B)(iii), and such other facts as are known to the officer,
the alien more likely than not could establish eligibility for asylum
under section 208, and it is more likely than not that the statements
made by, and on behalf of, the alien in support of the alien's claim
are true.''.
SEC. 104. CLARIFICATION OF ASYLUM ELIGIBILITY.
(a) In General.--Section 208(b)(1)(A) of the Immigration and
Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1158(b)(1)(A)) is amended by inserting after
``section 101(a)(42)(A)'' the following: ``(in accordance with the
rules set forth in this section), and is eligible to apply for asylum
under subsection (a)''.
(b) Place of Arrival.--Section 208(a)(1) of the Immigration and
Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1158(a)(1)) is amended--
(1) by striking ``or who arrives in the United States
(whether or not at a designated port of arrival and including
an alien who is brought to the United States after having been
interdicted in international or United States waters),''; and
(2) by inserting after ``United States'' the following: ``and
has arrived in the United States at a port of entry (including
an alien who is brought to the United States after having been
interdicted in international or United States waters),''.
SEC. 105. EXCEPTIONS.
Paragraph (2) of section 208(b) of the Immigration and Nationality
Act (8 U.S.C. 1158(b)(2)) is amended to read as follows:
``(2) Exceptions.--
``(A) In general.--Paragraph (1) shall not apply to
an alien if the Secretary of Homeland Security or the
Attorney General determines that--
``(i) the alien ordered, incited, assisted,
or otherwise participated in the persecution of
any person on account of race, religion,
nationality, membership in a particular social
group, or political opinion;
``(ii) the alien has been convicted of any
felony under Federal, State, tribal, or local
law;
``(iii) the alien has been convicted of any
misdemeanor offense under Federal, State,
tribal, or local law involving--
``(I) the unlawful possession or use
of an identification document,
authentication feature, or false
identification document (as those terms
and phrases are defined in the
jurisdiction where the conviction
occurred), unless the alien can
establish that the conviction resulted
from circumstances showing that--
``(aa) the document or
feature was presented before
boarding a common carrier;
``(bb) the document or
feature related to the alien's
eligibility to enter the United
States;
``(cc) the alien used the
document or feature to depart a
country wherein the alien has
claimed a fear of persecution;
and
``(dd) the alien claimed a
fear of persecution without
delay upon presenting himself
or herself to an immigration
officer upon arrival at a
United States port of entry;
``(II) the unlawful receipt of a
Federal public benefit (as defined in
section 401(c) of the Personal
Responsibility and Work Opportunity
Reconciliation Act of 1996 (8 U.S.C.
1611(c))), from a Federal entity, or
the unlawful receipt of similar public
benefits from a State, tribal, or local
entity; or
``(III) possession or trafficking of
a controlled substance or controlled
substance paraphernalia, as those
phrases are defined under the law of
the jurisdiction where the conviction
occurred, other than a single offense
involving possession for one's own use
of 30 grams or less of marijuana (as
marijuana is defined under the law of
the jurisdiction where the conviction
occurred);
``(iv) the alien has been convicted of an
offense arising under paragraph (1)(A) or (2)
of section 274(a), or under section 276;
``(v) the alien has been convicted of a
Federal, State, tribal, or local crime that the
Attorney General or Secretary of Homeland
Security knows, or has reason to believe, was
committed in support, promotion, or furtherance
of the activity of a criminal street gang (as
defined under the law of the jurisdiction where
the conviction occurred or in section 521(a) of
title 18, United States Code);
``(vi) the alien has been convicted of an
offense for driving while intoxicated or
impaired, as those terms are defined under the
law of the jurisdiction where the conviction
occurred (including a conviction for driving
while under the influence of or impaired by
alcohol or drugs), without regard to whether
the conviction is classified as a misdemeanor
or felony under Federal, State, tribal, or
local law, in which such intoxicated or
impaired driving was a cause of serious bodily
injury or death of another person;
``(vii) the alien has been convicted of more
than one offense for driving while intoxicated
or impaired, as those terms are defined under
the law of the jurisdiction where the
conviction occurred (including a conviction for
driving while under the influence of or
impaired by alcohol or drugs), without regard
to whether the conviction is classified as a
misdemeanor or felony under Federal, State,
tribal, or local law;
``(viii) the alien has been convicted of a
crime--
``(I) that involves conduct amounting
to a crime of stalking;
``(II) of child abuse, child neglect,
or child abandonment; or
``(III) that involves conduct
amounting to a domestic assault or
battery offense, including--
``(aa) a misdemeanor crime of
domestic violence, as described
in section 921(a)(33) of title
18, United States Code;
``(bb) a crime of domestic
violence, as described in
section 40002(a)(12) of the
Violence Against Women Act of
1994 (34 U.S.C. 12291(a)(12));
or
``(cc) any crime based on
conduct in which the alien
harassed, coerced, intimidated,
voluntarily or recklessly used
(or threatened to use) force or
violence against, or inflicted
physical injury or physical
pain, however slight, upon a
person--
``(AA) who is a
current or former
spouse of the alien;
``(BB) with whom the
alien shares a child;
``(CC) who is
cohabitating with, or
who has cohabitated
with, the alien as a
spouse;
``(DD) who is
similarly situated to a
spouse of the alien
under the domestic or
family violence laws of
the jurisdiction where
the offense occurred;
or
``(EE) who is
protected from that
alien's acts under the
domestic or family
violence laws of the
United States or of any
State, tribal
government, or unit of
local government;
``(ix) the alien has engaged in acts of
battery or extreme cruelty upon a person and
the person--
Purpose and Summary
H.R. 2640, the Border Security and Enforcement Act of 2023,
introduced by Rep. Tom McClintock (R-CA), would close loopholes
for claims of asylum and withholding of removal, fortify border
security by ending the Biden Administration's ``catch-and-
release'' policy, end the illegal use of parole, expand
penalties for visa overstayers, reduce incentives for illegal
immigration by mandating nationwide E-Verify, and close
longstanding loopholes in the processing of both accompanied
and unaccompanied alien children.
Background and Need for the Legislation
A. General Background
Since President Biden took office in January 2021, U.S.
Customs and Border Protection (CBP) officials have encountered
more than 5 million illegal aliens along the southwest
border.\1\ During December 2022, CBP encountered 251,487
illegal aliens crossing the southwest border--the highest
recorded number of encounters in a single month and an average
of 8,100 illegal alien encounters per day.\2\ This figure
eclipses all of the record-high monthly encounter numbers
previously set by the Biden Administration.\3\ Meanwhile, the
Biden Administration has released nearly 2 million illegal
aliens encountered along the southwest border into American
communities.\4\ Additionally, since President Biden took
office, more than 1.5 million known illegal alien ``gotaways''
have successfully crossed the southwest border undetected.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\U.S. Customs and Border Protection, Southwest Land Border
Encounters, Dep't of Homeland Security (last accessed Apr. 25, 2023),
https://www.cbp.gov/newsroom/stats/southwest-land-border-encounters
[hereinafter CBP Southwest Land Border Encounters].
\2\Id.
\3\Id.
\4\Texas v. Biden, Case No: 2:21-cv-00067-Z (N.D. Texas) (Brief For
America First Legal Foundation As Amicus Curiae In Support of
Respondents, Defendants' Monthly Report For Mar. 2022, Defendants'
Monthly Report For April 2022, Defendants' Monthly Report For May 2022,
Defendants' Monthly Report For June 2022); MPP Reimplementation Report,
July 2022, MPP Reimplementation Report, Aug. 2022, MPP Reimplementation
Report, Sept. 2022, MPP Reimplementation Report Oct. 2022, MPP
Reimplementation Report Nov. 2022, MPP Reimplementation Report, Dec.
2022, MPP Reimplementation Report, Jan. 2023, MPP Reimplementation
Report, Feb. 2023, provided to Committee Staff by U.S. Dep't of
Homeland Security.
\5\Neil Munro, Border Patrol Chief: 1.5 Million `Gotaway' Migrants
During Biden's Term, Breitbart (Mar. 15, 2023), https://
www.breitbart.com/politics/2023/03/15/border-patrol-chief-1-5-million-
gotaway-migrants-during-bidens-term/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to record numbers of illegal alien encounters
at the border, the Biden Administration has created illegal
programs to categorically parole hundreds of thousands of
additional aliens into the United States. For example, in
response to ``almost four times as many Venezuelans''
attempting to cross the southwest border than the year before,
in October 2022, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS)
announced the creation of such a program for Venezuelan
nationals, which would allow up to 24,000 Venezuelans into the
United States.\6\ On January 5, 2023, DHS--purportedly in
preparation for the end of Title 42--expanded the illegal
categorical parole program to Cubans, Haitians, and
Nicaraguans, and increased the allowable number to at least
360,000 qualifying nationals each year.\7\ On April 26, 2023,
DHS announced additional categorical parole programs for
nationals of El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, and Colombia.\8\
These categorical parole programs are a blatant attempt by the
Biden Administration to ensure the mass release of aliens into
the United States, without the negative publicity associated
with videos of aliens rushing across the southwest border
illegally.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\DHS Announces New Migration Enforcement Process for Venezuelans,
U.S. Dep't of Homeland Security (Oct. 12, 2022), https://www.dhs.gov/
news/2022/10/12/dhs-announces-new-migration-enforcement-process-
venezuelans (emphasis added).
\7\DHS Continues to Prepare for End of Title 42; Announces New
Border Enforcement Measures and Additional Safe and Orderly Processes,
U.S. Dep't of Homeland Security (Jan. 5, 2023), https://www.dhs.gov/
news/2023/01/05/dhs-continues-prepare-end-title-42-announces-new-
border-enforcement-measures-and.
\8\Fact Sheet: U.S. Government Announces Sweeping New Actions to
Manage Regional Migration, U.S. Dep't of Homeland Security (Apr. 27,
2023), https://www.dhs.gov/news/2023/04/27/fact-sheet-us-government-
announces-sweeping-new-actions-manage-regional-migration.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Because of the Biden Administration's open-borders
policies, the immigration court system backlog has grown over
50 percent, from 1.2 million at the end of fiscal year (FY)
2020, to nearly 1.9 million at the end of the first quarter of
FY 2023.\9\ Many of those are asylum claims that ultimately
will be unsuccessful. H.R. 2640 will help end the abuse of U.S.
immigration laws by aliens and the Biden Administration alike.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Executive Office for Immigration Review, Adjudication
Statistics: Pending Cases, New Cases, and Total Completions, U.S. Dep't
of Justice (last accessed Apr. 16, 2022), https://www.justice.gov/eoir/
page/file/1242166/download.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
B. Background on Asylum
i. Overview of Asylum
Asylum is a discretionary benefit that ultimately provides
permanent residence and the ability to naturalize to aliens who
meet the definition of a ``refugee'' under the Immigration and
Nationality Act (INA). ``Refugees'' are defined as aliens who
are unwilling or unable to return to their country of
citizenship because of persecution based on race, religion,
nationality, membership in a social group, or political
opinion.\10\ An alien seeking asylum must demonstrate either
past persecution or a well-founded fear of future
persecution.\11\ Under current law, persecution is ``a threat
to the life or freedom of, or the infliction of suffering or
harm upon, those who differ in a way regarded as
offensive.''\12\ A ``well-founded fear'' consists of a
``reasonable'' fear of persecution, rather than a ``clear
probability'' of persecution.\13\ Currently, therefore, an
alien may receive a discretionary grant of asylum by
establishing past persecution or a well-founded fear of future
persecution where one of the five enumerated grounds is at
least one central reason for the persecution.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\See INA Sec. 101(a)(42).
\11\See Id.
\12\Matter of Acosta, 19 I. & N. Dec. 211, 222 (BIA 1985).
\13\INS v. Cardoza-Fonseca, 480 U.S. 421 (1987).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
ii. Credible Fear Process
For millions of aliens, the process to remain indefinitely
in the United States under the guise of applying for asylum
begins at the southwest border through a credible fear
interview. Under the INA, certain aliens encountered at the
border are subject to expedited removal, in which they are
ordered removed from the United States without further review
or hearing.\14\ That removal provision, however, does not apply
to any alien who indicates an intention to apply for asylum or
otherwise expresses a fear of persecution.\15\ In those cases,
an asylum officer conducts a credible fear interview to
determine whether ``there is a significant possibility'' that
the alien could establish eligibility for asylum.\16\ The
Supreme Court has acknowledged that this standard is even lower
than the standard for asylum, as ``[t]he applicant need not
show that he or she is in fact eligible for asylum--a `credible
fear' equates to only a `significant possibility' that the
alien would be eligible.''\17\ At least one federal district
court has quantified this standard, stating that ``to prevail
at a credible fear interview, the alien need only show a
`significant possibility' of a one in ten chance of
persecution, i.e., a fraction of ten percent.''\18\ The
legislative history of the credible fear standard likewise
reflects that the standard was meant to be low.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\See INA Sec. 235(b)(1)(A).
\15\Id.
\16\See INA Sec. 235(b)(1)(B)(v).
\17\Dep't of Homeland Sec. v. Thuraissigiam, 140 S. Ct. 1959, 1965
(2020).
\18\Grace v. Whitaker, 344 F. Supp. 3d 96, 127 (D.D.C. 2018)
(quoting Cardoza-Fonseca, 480 U.S. at 431-32, aff'd in part, rev'd in
part and remanded sub nom. Grace v. Barr, 965 F.3d 883 (D.C. Cir.
2020)).
\19\See, e.g., 142 Cong. Rec. S11491-02 (statement of former Sen.
Orrin Hatch).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under the statute, if an asylum officer finds that an alien
has established a credible fear of persecution, the alien is
then placed in full removal proceedings before an immigration
judge.\20\ That process can take years. In FY 2022, the average
completion time for immigration cases at the immigration court
level was more than four years.\21\ To make matters worse, the
Biden Administration has ignored the requirement to place such
aliens in removal proceedings by issuing aliens a Notice to
Appear (NTA).\22\ Instead, for a period of time, the Biden
Administration issued aliens a Notice to Report, with
instructions to report to a local Immigration and Customs
Enforcement (ICE) office to be served with an NTA.\23\ Those
offices, however, are backlogged for years, with New York
City's ICE office ``fully booked through October 2032.''\24\
Offices in Jacksonville, Florida, were mostly booked through
June 2028; in Miami, through January 2028; and in Atlanta,
through January 2027.\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\See INA Sec. 235(b)(1)(B)(ii).
\21\Circumvention of Lawful Pathways, 88 Fed. Reg. 11704, 11716
(proposed Feb. 23, 2023) (to be codified at 8 C.F.R. 208, 1208).
\22\See INA Sec. 235(b)(1)(B)(ii); 8 C.F.R. Sec. 1239.1(a) (``Every
removal proceeding conducted under [8 U.S.C. Sec. 1229a] to determine
the deportability or inadmissibility of an alien is commenced by the
filing of a notice to appear with the immigration court.'').
\23\Fla. v. United States, No. 3:21-CV-1066-TKW-ZCB, 2023 WL
2399883, at *4 (N.D. Fla. Mar. 8, 2023).
\24\Steven Nelson, NYC ICE office ``fully booked'' for migrant
appointments through late 2032: document, N.Y. Post (Mar. 13, 2023),
https://nypost.com/2023/03/13/nyc-ice-office-fully-booked-for-migrant-
appointments-through-late-2032/.
\25\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consequently, aliens realize that claiming a fear of
persecution at the southwest border is their ticket into the
United States, and the number of encounters and credible fear
claims reflects that reality. The Government Accountability
Office (GAO) found that, between FY 2014 and FY 2018, the
caseload of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS)
nearly doubled--``from about 56,000 to almost 109,000 referrals
for credible and reasonable fear screenings.''\26\ Meanwhile,
asylum officers found that an alien had established a credible
fear in 77 percent of all screenings.\27\ This number rose to
87 percent at family residential centers.\28\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\26\U.S. Gov't Accountability Office, GAO-20-250, Immigration:
Actions Needed to Strengthen USCIS's Oversight and Data Quality of
Credible and Reasonable Fear Screenings (Feb. 2020), https://
www.gao.gov/assets/gao-20-250.pdf.
\27\Id. (During the same time, by contrast, ``officers made
positive determinations in about 30 percent of reasonable fear
screenings.'') (Emphasis added).
\28\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
When combined with a lack of detention and the Biden
Administration's clear defiance of the immigration statutes, a
low credible fear standard incentives mass illegal immigration
into the United States by aliens whose claims most likely will
be denied ultimately. For instance, in FY 2022, for asylum
cases originating with a credible fear claim at the border,
only 13.69 percent of applications were granted; 10.99 percent
were denied; 7.71 percent were administratively closed; and
40.23 percent were abandoned, not adjudicated, withdrawn, or
``other.''\29\ Aliens in 27.37 percent of cases originating
with a credible fear claim did not even bother filing an asylum
application after being placed into full removal
proceedings.\30\ Between FY 2008 and FY 2022, aliens in 39.36
percent of such cases did not even file an asylum
application.\31\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\Executive Office for Immigration Review, Adjudication
Statistics: Asylum Decision and Filing Rates in Cases Originating with
a Credible Fear Claim, U.S. Dep't of Justice (last accessed Feb. 10,
2023), https://www.justice.gov/eoir/page/file/1062976/download. (These
numbers mirrored the overall numbers from 2008 through 2019, with
``only 14 percent of aliens who claimed [a] credible fear of
persecution or torture [being] granted asylum'' during that time). See
also Biden v. Texas, 554 F. Supp. 3d 818, 831 (S.D. Tex. 2021).
\30\Id.
\31\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Biden Administration itself has admitted this loophole
is a problem, acknowledging that while ``[a] full 83 percent of
the people who were subject to [expedited removal] and claimed
fear from 2014 to 2019 were referred to an [immigration judge]
for [removal] proceedings,'' only ``15 percent of those cases
that were completed were granted asylum or some other form of
protection.''\32\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\32\Circumvention of Lawful Pathways, 88 Fed. Reg. 11704 (proposed
Feb. 23, 2023) (to be codified at 8 C.F.R. 208, 1208).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
iii. Frivolity and Fraud in the Asylum Process
Once in immigration proceedings, most asylum applicants
present invalid claims based on several situations that the
Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) and federal courts of
appeals have repeatedly rejected. For example, many aliens seek
asylum due to gang violence occurring in their home countries.
According to current case law, however, ``asylum is not offered
for those who are unfortunate enough to be victims of ordinary
crime or generalized chaos.''\33\ To sufficiently establish
persecution, an alien must demonstrate those actions against
him do ``not encompass purely private actions.''\34\ Current
law states that ``the persecution must be inflicted by the
government, or by private actors whom the government is unable
or unwilling to control.''\35\ If a petitioner can ``relocate
to another part of his country of nationality and it would be
reasonable under the circumstances to expect him to do so,'' he
will not receive asylum.\36\ Only when the government is
``unable or unwilling to control'' forces that persecute an
alien is affirmative state action unnecessary to establish
eligibility for asylum and withholding of removal.\37\ This
exception does not include a general fear of gang violence.\38\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\33\Escobar v. Holder, 657 F.3d 537, 543 (7th Cir. 2011).
\34\Jonaitiene v. Holder, 660 F.3d 267, 270 (7th Cir. 2011).
\35\Id.
\36\Oryakhil v. Mukasey, 528 F.3d 993, 998 (7th Cir. 2008).
\37\See Tesfamichael v. Gonzales, 469 F.3d 109, 113 (5th Cir.
2006). See generally Matter of A-B-, 27 I. & N. Dec. 316 (A.G. 2018).
\38\See, e.g., Harmon v. Holder, 758 F.3d 728, 735 (6th Cir. 2014)
(``General conditions of rampant violence alone are insufficient to
establish eligibility.''); Constanza v. Holder, 647 F.3d 749, 753 (8th
Cir. 2011) (rejecting as too broad the particular social groups of ``a
family that experienced gang violence'' and ``persons resistant to gang
violence''); Sicaju-Diaz v. Holder, 663 F.3d 1, 4 (1st Cir. 2011)
(rejecting PSG of ``wealthy individuals returning to Guatemala from a
lengthy stay in the United States'' and stating that, [i]n a poorly
policed country, rich and poor are all prey to criminals who care about
nothing more than taking it for themselves.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Aliens also continue to pursue claims for asylum and
withholding of removal based on other frequently-rejected
circumstances such as gang recruitment;\39\ perceptions of
wealth or affluence;\40\ and additional reasons that are not
tied to any protected ground of race, religion, nationality,
political opinion, or membership in a particular social
group.\41\ Aliens also attempt to fit myriad claims into the
protected ground of a ``particular social group,'' a phrase
which, in 1993, now-Justice Samuel Alito described as ``almost
completely open-ended.''\42\ Without addressing these frequent
invalid bases for asylum and withholding of removal, certain
courts (such as the U.S. Courts of Appeals for the Fourth
Circuit and the Ninth Circuit) continue to chip away at
precedent and the standards for asylum and withholding of
removal.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\39\See, e.g., Matter of E-A-G-, 24 I. & N. Dec. 591, 594 (BIA
2008) (rejecting PSG of those opposed to gang recruitment).
\40\See, e.g., Matter of A-M-E- & J-G-U-, 24 I. & N. Dec. 69, 76
(BIA 2007) (``The characteristic of wealth or affluence is simply too
subjective, inchoate, and variable to provide the sole basis for
membership in a particular social group. We therefore find that the
respondents have not demonstrated that `wealthy Guatemalans' constitute
a particular social group.'').
\41\See, e.g., Gjetani v. Barr, 968 F.3d 393, 397 (5th Cir. 2020)
(``Courts have condemned all manner of egregious and even violent
behavior while concluding they do not amount to persecution.''); Majd
v. Gonzales, 446 F.3d 590, 595 (5th Cir. 2006) (holding that
persecution ``does not encompass all treatment that our society regards
as unfair, unjust, or even unlawful or unconstitutional. If persecution
were defined that expansively, a significant percentage of the world's
population would qualify for asylum in this country--and it seems most
unlikely that Congress intended such a result. Persecution must be
extreme conduct to qualify for asylum protection.'').
\42\Fatin v. I.N.S., 12 F.3d 1233, 1238 (3r
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6)(A) of House rule XIII,
the following hearings were used to develop H.R. 2640: ``The
Biden Border Crisis: Part I,'' a hearing held on February 1,
2023, before the Judiciary Committee. The Committee heard
testimony from the following witnesses:
Brandon Dunn, co-founder, Forever15Project;
The Honorable Mark J. Dannels, Sheriff,
Cochise County, Arizona;
The Honorable Dale Lynn Carruthers, County
Judge, Terrell County, Texas; and
The Honorable Ricardo Samaniego, County
Judge, El Paso County, Texas.
The hearing addressed how President Biden's open-borders
policies affect Americans with rising crime, fentanyl-related
deaths, and lawlessness at the southwest border and beyond.
The Judiciary Committee also held a hearing in Yuma,
Arizona, titled ``The Biden Border Crisis: Part II'' on
February 23, 2023. The Committee heard testimony from the
following witnesses:
Dr. Robert Trenschel, President and CEO,
Yuma Regional Medical Center;
The Honorable Leon Wilmot, Sheriff, Yuma
County, Arizona; and
Jonathan Lines, Supervisor, District 2, Yuma
County, Arizona.
The hearing spotlighted how the Biden Administration's
refusal to secure the border devastates one of numerous border
communities, including by draining the local hospital of
resources, plaguing residents with increased crime, and
flooding American communities with fentanyl and other illegal
drugs.
Committee Consideration
On April 19, 2023, the Committee met in open session and
ordered the bill, H.R. 2640, favorably reported with an
amendment in the nature of a substitute, by a roll call vote of
23 to 15, a quorum being present.
Committee Votes
In compliance with clause 3(b) of House rule XIII, the
following roll call votes occurred during the Committee's
consideration of H.R. 2640:
1. Vote on Amendment #1 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Mr.
Nadler, failed 12-18
2. Vote on Amendment #2 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Ms.
Lofgren, failed 11-17
3. Vote on Amendment #3 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Mr.
Massie, failed 18-18
4. Vote on Amendment #4 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Ms.
Lofgren, failed 8-21
5. Vote on Amendment #7 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Ms.
Jayapal, failed 12-22
6. Vote on Amendment #9 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Mr.
Correa, failed 10-19
7. Vote on Motion to Table the Appealing of the Ruling of
the Chair in respect to the germaneness of Amendment #10 to
H.R. 2640 ANS offered by Mr. Schiff, passed 17-12
8. Vote on Amendment #11 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Mr.
Johnson (GA), failed 10-20
9. Vote on Amendment #12 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Ms.
Jackson Lee, failed 13-21
10. Vote on Amendment #13 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Ms.
Scanlon, failed 13-23
11. Vote on Amendment #14 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Ms.
Scanlon, failed 13-22
12. Vote on Amendment #15 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Ms.
Scanlon, failed 12-21
13. Vote on Amendment #16 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Ms.
Jackson Lee, failed 12-21
14. Vote on Amendment #17 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Ms.
Jackson Lee, failed 12-22
15. Vote on Amendment #18 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Mr.
Schiff, failed 13-22
16. Vote on Amendment #19 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Mr.
Ivey, failed 14-22
17. Vote on Amendment #20 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Mr.
Cicilline, failed 14-21
18. Vote on Amendment #21 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Mr.
Cicilline, failed 14-23
19. Vote on Amendment #22 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Ms.
Jayapal, failed 13-23
20. Vote on Amendment #24 to H.R. 2640 ANS, offered by Mr.
Ivey, failed 14-23
21. Vote on Favorably Reporting H.R. 2640, as amended,
passed 23-15
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Committee Oversight Findings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee advises that the findings and recommendations of the
Committee, based on oversight activities under clause 2(b)(1)
of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives, are
incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives and section
308(a) of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 and with respect
to eh requirements of clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII of the Rules
of the House of Representatives and section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the Committee has requested
but not received a cost estimate for this bill from the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office. The Committee has
requested but not received from the Director of the
Congressional Budget Office a statement as to whether this bill
contains any new budget authority, spending authority, credit
authority, or an increase or decrease in revenues or tax
expenditures. The Chairman of the Committee shall cause such
estimate and statement to be printed in the Congressional
Record upon its receipt by the Committee.
Congressional Budget Office Cost Estimate
With respect to the requirement of clause 3(c)(3) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, a cost
estimate provided by the Congressional Budget Office pursuant
to section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 was not
made available to the Committee in time for the filing of this
report. The Chairman of the Committee shall cause such estimate
to be printed in the Congressional Record upon its receipt by
the Committee.
Committee Estimate of Budgetary Effects
With respect to the requirements of clause 3(d)(1) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, the
Committee adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section
402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII, no provision
of H.R. 2640 establishes or reauthorizes a program of the
federal government known to be duplicative of another federal
program.
Performance Goals and Objectives
The Committee states that pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of
House rule XIII, H.R. 2640 would reduce frivolous claims and
close loopholes related to applications for asylum and
withholding of removal by amending sections 208 and 235 of the
INA. H.R. 2640 also would strengthen border safety by
reiterating detention requirements for arriving aliens;
mandating a return of aliens to the contiguous country from
which they arrived if certain detention, return, or removal
requirements are not met; and allowing the DHS Secretary to
suspend the entry of certain aliens if there is no operational
control of the border. The bill also ensures that family units
remain united at the border by eliminating the presumption that
accompanied alien children should not be detained and removing
the requirement for state licenses for family facilities. H.R.
2640 also would reform processes related to unaccompanied alien
children to ensure that children from contiguous and non-
contiguous countries are afforded the same protections. In
addition, H.R. 2640 would increase penalties for aliens who
overstay their visas and would ensure that the immigration
parole authority cannot be abused. Finally, H.R. 2640 would
ensure a legal workforce and reduce the employment incentives
of illegal immigration by amending section 274A of the INA to
mandate nationwide E-Verify.
Advisory on Earmarks
In accordance with clause 9 of House rule XXI, H.R. 2640
does not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in clauses
9(d), 9(e), or 9(f) of House rule XXI.
Federal Mandates Statement
An estimate of federal mandates prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget office pursuant to section 423 of the
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act was not made available to the
Committee in time for the filing of this report. The Chairman
of the Committee shall cause such estimate to be printed in the
Congressional Record upon its receipt by the Committee.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act (Pub. L. 104-
1).
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Section-by-Section Analysis
TITLE I: BORDER SECURITY AND ENFORCEMENT ACT OF 2023
Sec. 101. Short Title. This section states the title of
Title I as the ``Asylum Reform and Border Protection Act of
2023.''
Sec. 102. Safe third country. This section amends section
208(a)(2)(A) of the Immigration and Nationality Act to allow
the Department of Homeland Security to remove aliens seeking
asylum to safe third countries where they would have access to
a full and fair procedure for applying for asylum without the
current necessity for bilateral agreements with those
countries.
This section also makes aliens ineligible for asylum if
they have transited through at least one country outside their
country of citizenship, nationality, or last habitual residence
en route to the United States unless the aliens can show that
(1) they applied for protection in at least one of those
countries and received a final judgment denying the protection;
(2) they were a victim of trafficking; or (3) the countries in
which they transited en route to the United States were not
parties to the relevant international protection treaties.
Sec. 103. Credible fear interviews. This section changes
the current credible fear standard from requiring that an alien
merely show a ``significant possibility'' that he or she could
establish eligibility for asylum to requiring that an alien
show that it is more likely than not that he or she could
establish asylum eligibility and that it is more likely than
not that the statements made by the alien in support of the
alien's claim are true.
Sec. 104. Clarification of asylum eligibility. This section
conditions eligibility for asylum on arriving in the United
States at a port of entry.
Sec. 105. Exceptions. This section creates new exceptions
to asylum eligibility.
Paragraph (2)(A). In General. This paragraph closes the
asylum loophole for criminal aliens by rendering aliens who
commit or are convicted of certain crimes ineligible for
asylum. Those offenses include the possession of false
identification documents, certain controlled substance
offenses, gang-related crimes, driving under the influence,
child abuse, domestic violence, and extreme cruelty or battery.
Paragraph (2)(B). Special Rules. This paragraph grants
broad discretion to the Attorney General to find that other
criminal activity constitutes a particularly serious crime that
makes an alien ineligible for asylum. For certain crimes, the
section allows the Attorney General and Secretary of Homeland
Security to consider facts beyond the conviction documents to
more fully assess whether an alien has engaged in a
disqualifying activity. The paragraph allows adjudicators to
consider Interpol Red Notices in determining whether an alien
has committed a serious nonpolitical crime.
Paragraph (2)(C). Specific Circumstances. This paragraph
specifies that an applicant for asylum and withholding of
removal cannot meet the definition of a refugee based on
circumstances such as personal animus, generalized disapproval
of gang and cartel activity, resistance to gang recruitment,
and gang affiliation.
Paragraph (2)(D). Definitions and Clarifications. This
paragraph adds definitions for ``felony'' and ``misdemeanor''
and streamlines the analysis to determine whether certain
criminal aliens are ineligible for asylum. This paragraph also
gives adjudicators a guide to determine when certain orders
modifying, vacating, or clarifying an alien's underlying
conviction or sentence continue to have immigration
consequences.
Sec. 106. Employment Authorization. This section clarifies
when employment authorization terminates, including during an
appeal to a federal court and after a denial by an asylum
officer. The section creates statutory bars to employment
authorization for aliens who would be found ineligible for
asylum based on grounds such as criminal conduct, manner of
entry, and firm resettlement.
Sec. 107. Asylum fees. This section requires a fee of at
least $50 for each asylum application and reiterates that the
fee cannot exceed the cost of adjudicating the application.
Sec. 108. Rules for determining asylum eligibility: This
section provides additional guidance to determine whether an
alien is a refugee for purposes of an application for asylum
and withholding of removal.
Paragraph 1. Particular Social Group. This paragraph
clarifies that a ``particular social group'' must exist
independently of the alleged persecution and cannot be based on
one of several grounds that the Board of Immigration Appeals
and several federal courts of appeals have repeatedly rejected,
such as criminal activity, gang recruitment, and perceived
wealth.
Paragraph 2. Political Opinion. This paragraph clarifies
that a political opinion requires expressive behavior in
furtherance of a specific cause and does not include general
disapproval of gang activity.
Paragraph 3. Persecution. This paragraph clarifies that
persecution cannot be based on the mere existence of a law or
policy unless the evidence reflects that such law or policy
would be applied to the asylum applicant personally.
Persecution also cannot be based on the conduct of rogue
officials acting outside the scope of their official capacity.
Paragraph 4. Discretionary Determination. This paragraph
outlines discretionary factors to consider in the grant of
asylum, including an alien's use of fraudulent documents. The
provision states that a favorable exercise of discretion
generally is not permitted in other circumstances, such as when
the alien has failed to pay taxes, has accrued more than one
year of unlawful presence in the United States, or has had
multiple asylum applications denied. The provision creates
exceptions if the alien establishes extraordinary circumstances
or exceptional and extremely unusual hardship.
Paragraph 5. Limitation. This provision states that an
alien cannot use his or her failure to define a particular
social group as a basis for a motion to reopen or reconsider an
application for asylum or withholding of removal unless certain
procedural requirements are met.
Paragraph 6. Stereotypes. This paragraph states that
evidence based on stereotypes of an entire country or culture
is inappropriate and is not admissible in adjudicating an
asylum application unless the evidence shows that the
persecutor himself holds such views of the applicant for asylum
and withholding of removal.
Paragraph 7. Definitions. This section defines ``membership
in a particular social group,'' ``political opinion,'' and
``persecution'' for purposes of determining whether an
applicant for asylum and withholding of removal is a refugee as
defined in the Immigration and Nationality Act.
Sec. 109. Firm resettlement. This section states that the
firm resettlement bar applies if an alien either (1) resided in
a country through which the alien traveled before entering the
United States and in which the alien was eligible for or
received any permanent or non-permanent but indefinitely
renewable legal status; or (2) the alien resided in a country
for at least one year after departing the alien's country of
nationality and before entering into the United States.
Sec. 110. Notice concerning frivolous asylum applications.
This section clarifies that the notice of the consequences of
filing a frivolous asylum application, which is contained in
the application itself, is sufficient to advise an applicant of
those consequences. This section further clarifies what the
Secretary of Homeland Security or Attorney General must
determine to sustain a frivolity finding and bars an alien who
is found to have filed a frivolous application from receiving
any future immigration benefits.
Sec. 111. Technical amendments. These amendments add the
Secretary of Homeland Security to certain sections in which
only the Attorney General is currently included.
Sec. 112. Requirement for Procedures Relating to Certain
Asylum Applications. This section requires the Attorney General
to create expedited adjudication procedures for asylum
applicants from certain Western Hemisphere countries that have
been sanctioned by the United States. The expedited procedures
apply to nationals from Cuba, Nicaragua, and Venezuela.
TITLE II: BORDER SAFETY AND MIGRANT PROTECTION ACT OF 2023
Sec. 201. Short Title. This section states the title of
Title II as the ``Border Safety and Migrant Protection Act of
2023.''
Sec. 202. Inspection of applicants for admission. This
section reiterates that the class of aliens subject to
expedited removal includes aliens who are present in the United
States without being admitted or paroled and those arriving in
the country outside of a port of entry.
This section also reiterates the mandatory detention
requirement of certain aliens who are applicants for admission
and restricts parole and release of such individuals unless the
aliens are either removed to another country in which their
life or freedom would not be threatened, or the aliens are
returned to the contiguous country from which they arrived for
the pendency of their immigration proceedings.
This section mandates that aliens be returned to a
contiguous country for the pendency of their immigration
proceedings if the Secretary of Homeland Security cannot comply
with the obligations to detain aliens or remove them to a safe
third country.
This section also allows for the suspension of entry of
certain inadmissible aliens if the Secretary deems the
suspension necessary to achieve ``operational control'' of the
border. The section also provides states standing to sue if the
Secretary violates the detention, return, or removal
provisions.
Sec. 203. Operational Detention Facilities. This section
requires the Secretary of Homeland Security to take all
necessary actions to restore detention facilities that were in
operation as of January 20, 2021, but were subsequently closed
or that had capacity reduced, altered, or discontinued.
This section specifies the facilities to which the mandate
applies, at a minimum, and requires regular status reports to
Congress. The section also mandates notification to Congress
when detention capacity reaches 90, 95, and 100 percent.
TITLE III: ENSURING UNITED FAMILIES AT THE BORDER ACT OF 2023
Sec. 301. Short Title. This section states the title of
Title III as the ``Ensuring United Families at the Border Act
of 2023.''
Sec. 302. Clarification of Standards for Family Detention.
In response to certain provisions of the Flores Stipulated
Settlement Agreement being applied to accompanied minors, this
provision states that there is no presumption that an
accompanied minor should not be detained.
This section requires that the Secretary of Homeland
Security maintain the care and custody of aliens together with
their children while any charges for illegally crossing the
border are pending with the Department of Justice. The
provision also states that it is the sense of Congress that
Title III satisfies the requirements of the Flores Settlement
Agreement as applied to accompanied minors.
This section also preempts state licensing requirements for
facilities used to detain families and children.
TITLE IV: PROTECTION OF CHILDREN ACT OF 2023
Sec. 401. Short Title. This section states the title of
Title IV as the ``Protection of Children Act of 2023.''
Sec. 402. Findings. This section makes specific findings
related to the crisis of unaccompanied alien children (UACs) at
the southwest border.
Sec. 403. Repatriation of Unaccompanied Alien Children.
This section requires that all UACs, regardless of whether they
are nationals of a contiguous country, be safely and
expeditiously returned to their country of origin, provided
that they are not victims of trafficking or do not claim a
credible fear of persecution.
This section requires that UACs who are victims of severe
forms of trafficking or who claim a credible fear of
persecution receive a hearing before an immigration judge
within 14 days and allows DHS to hold a UAC for up to 30 days
to ensure a speedy judicial process.
This section also requires HHS to provide DHS with
biographical information regarding the sponsors or family
members to whom the minors are released.
This section mandates that DHS follow up with the sponsors
of UACs to verify the sponsor's immigration status and issue
notices for the sponsor to appear in immigration court when
appropriate.
This section reaffirms the privilege of UACs to have access
to counsel to represent them in immigration court but
emphasizes that such representation is at no expense to the
United States taxpayer.
Sec. 404. Special immigrant juvenile status for immigrants
unable to reunite with either parent. Due to a mistake in
current law, juveniles can obtain green cards as Special
Immigrant Juveniles (SIJs) if they can show that they have been
abandoned by a single parent even though another parent is
present in the U.S. and is able and willing to care for them.
Many UACs seek green cards through the SIJ process once in the
United States. This section clarifies that special immigrant
green cards are available only to juveniles who have lost or
been abandoned by both parents.
Sec. 405. Rule of Construction. This section emphasizes
that nothing in Title IV shall be construed to limit practices
and procedures that involve (1) screening a UAC to determine
whether the UAC has a credible fear of persecution, (2)
screening a UAC to determine whether the UAC is a victim of
trafficking, or (3) the current policy of HHS requiring a home
study for UACs under 12 years old.
TITLE V: STOP VISA OVERSTAYS ACT
Sec. 501. Short Title. This section states the title of
Title V as the ``Stop Visa Overstays Act.''
Sec. 502. Expanded Penalties for Illegal Entry or Presence.
This section places visa overstay, which is currently solely an
immigration violation, on par with illegal entry as a
misdemeanor criminal offense punishable by up to six months
imprisonment for the first offense. This section specifies that
an alien who fails to maintain his or her nonimmigrant status
for an aggregate period of 10 days shall be fined or imprisoned
or both.
This section also increases the civil penalties for illegal
entry from between $50 and $250 to between $500 and $1,000 and
mandates the fine for a subsequent offense be double the
initial fine. The section subjects visa overstayers to those
same civil penalties.
TITLE VI: IMMIGRATION PAROLE REFORM ACT OF 2023
Sec. 601. Short Title. This section states the title of
Title VI as the ``Immigration Parole Reform Act of 2023.''
Sec. 602. Immigration Parole Reform. This section prohibits
the Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security from
granting parole ``according to eligibility criteria describing
an entire class of potential parole recipients,'' otherwise
known as categorical parole.
This section requires that, with narrow exceptions, parole
may only be granted to aliens who are not present in the United
States and clarifies that parole is not an admission for
purposes of adjustment of status.
This section codifies two existing categorical parole
programs: the Cuban Family Reunification Parole program, and
another for the spouse or children of active-duty military
service members. It also allows the DHS Secretary to grant
parole to an alien who is enrolled in a Remain in Mexico-type
program for purposes of the alien being escorted to an
immigration hearing, attending the hearing, and being escorted
back to the contiguous country in which the alien was awaiting
immigration proceedings.
This section narrows the scope of the current humanitarian
and significant public benefit authority to align with the
intent of Congress that parole be used rarely and in individual
circumstances, and not as a workaround of the law or to admit
groups of aliens who would not otherwise be eligible to enter
the U.S.
This section clarifies what is meant by ``case-by-case''
adjudication of parole applications.
This section precludes aliens granted parole from receiving
employment authorization documents with the exception of those
in the existing Cuban Family Reunification Parole and the
military family parole programs.
This section clarifies that parole cannot be used as an
avenue for adjustment of status to that of a lawful permanent
resident, or to gain any other immigration benefit if the
alien's underlying immigration status allows for such
adjustment or benefit.
This section limits the initial grant of parole to the
shorter of: (1) the time it takes to complete the activity for
which parole was granted; or (2) one year. Allows a one-time
extension of parole for that period.
This section requires DHS to report annually to the House
and Senate Judiciary Committees regarding aliens paroled during
the previous year, including the total number of aliens paroled
into the United States and the type of parole granted.
Sec. 603. Implementation. This section makes the changes
effective 30 days after the date of enactment of the act and
allows aliens granted parole prior to January 1, 2023, to
continue in their parole status pursuant to the laws in effect
on the date parole was granted.
Sec. 604. Cause of Action. This section creates standing so
state attorneys general can hold DHS accountable if DHS grants
parole in violation of the law.
Sec. 605. Severability. This section states that, if any
provision of the legislation is found to be unconstitutional,
the other provisions in the legislation remain unaffected.
TITLE VII: LEGAL WORKFORCE ACT
Sec. 701. Short Title. This section states the title of
Title VII as the ``Legal Workforce Act.''
Sec. 702. Employment Eligibility Verification Process.
Proof of Employment Eligibility and
Identity. This section requires that the employer
attest, in an electronic or paper form, that they have
verified the employment eligibility of the individual
seeking employment by obtaining the individual's Social
Security Number (SSN) or immigrant identification
number and examining acceptable documents presented by
the individual to establish work eligibility and
identity. It requires that the employer use E-Verify to
check the work eligibility of the individual. This
section reduces the number of acceptable documents for
proof of work eligibility and identity.
Retention of Attestation Form. This section
requires that the employer retain a paper, microfiche,
or electronic copy of the attestation form for the
latter of three years or one year after the date of
employment termination.
Verification. This section requires the
employer to record the E-Verify verification code for
employees when they receive confirmation or final non-
confirmation of work authorization. It allows an
employee who receives a tentative non-confirmation to
use the secondary verification process in place under
E-Verify. This section states that an employer may
terminate the employment of individuals who receive a
final non-confirmation and if they do not terminate
employment they must notify DHS of the
Minority Views
I. INTRODUCTION
H.R. 2640 is cruel, extreme, and unworkable legislation
that continues the Republicans' anti-immigrant, enforcement-
only approach to immigration. It would wreck our economy,
destroy the asylum system, criminalize visa overstays, send
unaccompanied children back to dangerous situations, and jail
children indefinitely. We should all be working together to fix
the broken immigration system. Democrats are ready to work with
serious Republicans to pass meaningful changes, just as we did
with the Farm Workforce Modernization Act and the American
Dream and Promise Act in prior congresses.
Unfortunately, this bill is not a serious attempt to reform
our broken immigration system. It does nothing to address the
root causes of migration, improve border security, or create
additional legal pathways for people to enter the United States
lawfully. If we can create a more humane immigration system
that recognizes both the horrific conditions that cause
migrants to flee and the contributions of immigrants to
America, we can decrease unauthorized crossings, strengthen our
economy, and protect migrants and citizens from harm.
Republicans want to take us back to the failed, illegal,
and immoral policies of the Trump administration. President
Trump's radical, inhumane, and racist immigration actions
weakened the U.S. economy, undermined our moral standing in the
world, led to increased numbers of migrants at the southern
border and did not make us any safer. In the absence of a
credible plan to fix our broken immigration system, Republicans
have resorted to political stunts instead of real solutions. If
Republicans were truly concerned with securing the border, they
would work with Democrats to secure our ports of entry, expand
legal pathways for migrants, and address the root causes of
migration. Immigration reform is a complex problem that
requires comprehensive solutions, and an enforcement-only
strategy simply doesn't work.
H.R. 2640 consists of seven titles, each of which would
unleash untold suffering on migrants fleeing unspeakable
conditions, and it would be particularly devastating to
children.
Title I would completely upend the asylum
system (making it nearly impossible for anyone to come
to our borders and seek asylum) as well as the process
in place for unaccompanied children.
Title II would require that all migrants
seeking admission without a visa be detained, removed,
or subjected to a ``Return to Mexico''-style program.
Title III would mandate indefinite detention
for all asylum-seeking families and other immigrants
attempting to enter the United States without a visa.
Title IV would subject all unaccompanied
children to an even more draconian version of the
expedited removal process, allow children to be
detained in Customs and Border Protection (CBP)
facilities for an entire month, and summarily send
children back into the hands of smugglers and those
seeking to exploit them.
Title V would criminalize overstaying visas
and status violations, subjecting first-time violators
to up to 6 months in prison and civil penalties of up
to $1,000.
Title VI would severely restrict the
administration's ability to parole individuals into the
United States, including ending the current parole
initiatives for Ukrainians fleeing Russia and certain
military families, and would strip most parolees of
their ability to obtain work authorization.
Title VII would require all U.S. employers
to use the E-Verify system without the necessary due
process protections for workers or reforms to the
immigration system to make mandatory E-Verify workable.
This legislation is not a serious solution for our broken
immigration system.
II. H.R. 2640 WOULD COMPLETELY UPEND THE ASYLUM SYSTEM
Title I, the ``Asylum Reform and Border Protection Act of
2023,'' would slash protections for asylum seekers and other
vulnerable populations. Indeed, the bill does not reform our
asylum system as much as dismantle it. Doubling down on Donald
Trump's anti-humanitarian policies, Title I would return asylum
seekers of all ages and circumstances to further persecution,
and too often, death.
Republicans predicate this bill on their belief that our
asylum system is rife with fraud and abuse. However, there is
no reliable evidence to support this position. Nearly every
group that works with asylees offers compelling evidence of
legitimate claims and rampant human rights abuses in sending
countries that drive many of these individuals to seek
sanctuary.
Most problematically, this title: (1) authorizes DHS to
deport virtually every asylum seeker that reached the United
States through a third country, such as Mexico; (2) makes
sweeping changes to the definitions of various grounds of
asylum, including particular social group and political
opinion; (3) impracticably elevates the evidentiary standard in
credible fear screenings; and (4) introduces wide-reaching new
bars to asylum, including (a) barring anyone (including
unaccompanied children) who entered between ports of entry from
obtaining asylum; (b) barring from asylum any individual who
has or could have had even temporary status in a third country;
and (c) massively expanding the criminal bars to asylum and
allowing adjudicators to use unreliable evidence, such as
Interpol Red Notices and facts not found by a criminal court,
as proof that the applicant committed a crime.
While the Majority claims that these provisions close
loopholes in our humanitarian system, in reality, when taken
together, they serve as a wholesale ban on asylum. Only the
lucky few who can come directly to the United States and meet
the significantly narrowed asylum grounds would be able to
obtain protection.
Due to the numerous concerns about how this title would
decimate our asylum system, Democrats offered amendments that
would strike Title I in its entirety, exempt individuals
fleeing from communist and totalitarian countries from the
asylum bars for individuals who cross between ports of entry,
and exempt all unaccompanied children, then unaccompanied
children under the age of 5, or unaccompanied children under
the age of one from the asylum bar. These amendments were all
defeated on party line roll call votes.
III. ATTEMPTS TO FIX H.R. 2640 FAIL TO MITIGATE CONCERNS THAT THE BILL
WOULD BE UNWORKABLE AND INHUMANE
Title II, the ``Border Safety and Migrant Protection Act of
2023,'' seems to be the Majority's attempt at creating a more
palatable version of H.R. 29, the ``Border Safety and Security
Act of 2023,'' legislation so extreme that even Republicans
called it un-American and un-Christian and blocked it from
consideration on the House Floor.\1\ Despite the fig leaf of
modest improvement, H.R. 2640 utterly fails in creating a
workable and humane asylum system.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Emily Brooks and Rafael Bernal, Tensions High as House GOP
Tackles Take Two at Border Bill, The Hill (Mar. 28, 2023) https://
thehill.com/latino/3920921-tensions-high-as-house-gop-tackles-take-two-
at-border-bill/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The title shares much of the prior attempt's problems--it
would overturn our current asylum system and require the
Secretary of Homeland Security to detain, deport, or return to
Mexico all asylum seekers who attempt to enter the United
States at the border without a visa. During the markup,
Representative Roy (R-TX) offered an amendment that was adopted
by the Committee that stripped out the provision of the bill
that requires the Secretary of Homeland Security to suspend the
entry of all asylum seekers if he cannot detain, deport, or
return them all to Mexico. However, this title still
constitutes an unprecedented attack on our asylum system and an
attempt to unilaterally force Mexico to accept our asylum
seekers.
No Congress--under Republican or Democratic leadership--has
ever appropriated sufficient resources to detain all migrants.
The cost of detaining all migrants would be astronomical--in
2015, the conservative American Action Forum estimated that
detaining every undocumented migrant in the country would cost
approximately $35.7 billion.\2\ In contrast, former President
Trump requested $3.1 billion for detention space in FY 2021.\3\
The research further estimates that deporting all undocumented
migrants and continuing to enforce a strict deportation scheme
into the future would cost anywhere between $419.6 billion and
$619.4 billion.\4\ Former President Trump's 2021 budget
requested $49.7 billion for all of DHS, including for its non-
immigration-related components.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Ben Gitis & Laura Collins, The Budgetary and Economic Costs of
Addressing Unauthorized Immigration: Alternative Strategies, Am. Action
Forum (Mar. 6, 2015) https://www.americanactionforum.org/research/the-
budgetary-and-economic-costs-of-addressing-unauthorized-immigration-
alt/.
\3\A Budget for America's Future, Office of Management and Budget
(Feb. 10, 2020), https://trumpwhitehouse.archives.gov/wp-content/
uploads/2020/02/budget_fy21.pdf.
\4\Gitis & Collins, supra note 1.
\5\Office of Management and Budget, supra note 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Likewise, the use of Remain in Mexico and Title 42 exposed
migrants to extreme danger and served as a boon to the cartels.
As of February 2021, there were over 1,500 publicly reported
cases of murder, rape, torture, kidnapping and other violent
assaults against migrants returned under Remain in Mexico.\6\
Our restrictive policies have also caused Mexico to harden its
own policies--deporting thousands and detaining others in
crowded detention facilities in extremely poor conditions.\7\
Continuing to push migrants back into Mexico will only serve to
further put vulnerable migrants at risk, as we saw all too well
when migrants in an immigration center in Ciudad Juarez were
left to be burned alive in March.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Id.
\7\Raquel Aldana, Migrant deaths in Mexico put spotlight on US
policy that shifted immigration enforcement south, The Conversation
(Apr. 1, 2023), https://theconversation.com/migrant-deaths-in-mexico-
put-spotlight-on-us-policy-that-shifted-immigration-enforcement-south-
202896.
\8\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, as part of Representative Roy's amendment, the
Majority added a new provision to the bill which would reopen
numerous closed Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)
detention facilities that were shut down due to egregious human
rights abuses. This includes the Irwin County Detention Center,
the site of numerous horrifying allegations of detainees forced
to undergo unnecessary invasive gynecological procedures.\9\
These facilities were closed for good reasons, and the fact
that Republicans wish to reopen them is deeply disturbing.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Morgan Lee, Senate panel finds `extraordinary disturbing'
medical procedures at closed Georgia immigration jail, FOX 5 Atlanta
(Nov. 16, 2022), https://www.fox5atlanta.com/news/irwin-county-
detention-center-surgeries-senate-investigation.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Many of Democrats' concerns with this section centered on
Representative Roy's wrongheaded idea to close the border to
all asylum seekers if the Secretary of Homeland Security cannot
detain, deport, or return to Mexico all asylum seekers. We
submitted an amendment to exempt individuals fleeing from
communist and totalitarian countries from that provision before
Representative Roy filed his amendment removing it. The
amendment was opposed on a party line vote.
IV. H.R. 2640 WOULD HAVE A DEVASTATING IMPACT ON CHILDREN AND FAMILIES
Title III, the ``Ensuring United Families at the Border
Act,'' would require indefinite family detention for any
families attempting to enter the United States to seek asylum,
as well as any families who previously entered the United
States without visas. It would also require family detention
throughout the pendency of a parent's immigration case which
could take years. The bill argues that it satisfies the
provisions of the Flores Settlement Agreement for children
detained with their families, which is intended to ensure that
migrant children are released from detention as expeditiously
as possible, and that any children who cannot be released be
transferred to facilities licensed by the States as appropriate
for housing dependent children. The Flores Agreement is only in
place until ``publication of final regulations implementing
th[e] Agreement'' are put in place.\10\ It is unclear, however,
how this bill, which directly contravenes the purpose of
Flores, could be considered to be ``implementing'' the
Agreement.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\Stipulated Settlement Agreement, Jenny Lissette Flores v. Reno,
Case No. 85-4544-RJK (C.D. CA 1997), para.40.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The harm of detaining children is clear: According to the
American Academy of Pediatrics, ``there is no evidence that any
amount of time in detention is `safe' for children. In fact,
even short periods of detention can cause psychological trauma
and long-term mental health risks for children.''\11\ According
to a physician and psychiatrist who investigated family
detention facilities for the Department of Homeland Security's
Office of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties, ``shorter lengths
of detention did not sufficiently mitigate the harmful
conditions that we observed and their deleterious consequences;
most of the harms we documented were in families detained less
than 20 days.''\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Devin Miller, Pediatricians speak out: Detention is not the
answer to family separation, American Academy of Pediatrics (Jul. 24,
2018) https://publications.aap.org/aapnews/news/12792.
\12\Letter to Joseph R. Biden, President of the United States, and
Alejandro Mayorkas, Secretary, Dep't of Homeland Security from Dr.
Scott A. Allen & Dr. Pamela McPherson re: Renewed Concerns of DHS
Medical Experts Regarding Harms to Children Caused by Family Detention
(Mar. 8, 2023) https://assets.law360news.com/1584000/1584237/
letter.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The bill applies retroactively, which means a family who
has been waiting for their asylum hearing for three years,
during which time they have been living and working in the
United States would be required to be remanded into immigration
detention. Finally, the bill has a specific provision to keep
family units together if the parent is prosecuted under 8
U.S.C. Sec. 1325(a) for improper entry. This is the crime the
Trump administration used as a pretext to separate families in
2018. Because this provision requires family units to stay in
DHS custody while this prosecution is pending, it also seems to
contemplate an unworkable scenario where DHS detention
facilities would be required to have camera access to federal
criminal courts. Further, there is no mention of what occurs if
the parent is sentenced to jail time as a result of
prosecution. The answer is family separation.
The dangers posed by this title are clear. This would lead
to harmful family detention and family separation. As such,
Democrats proposed an amendment that would delay the
implementation of this title until all the families separated
under the Trump administration are reunited. This amendment was
defeated on a party-line vote.
V. H.R. 2640 WOULD STRIP VITAL PROTECTIONS FROM UNACCOMPANIED CHILDREN
Title IV, the so-called ``Protection of Children Act of
2023,'' would subject all unaccompanied children to a summary
removal process that is even worse than the one currently
applicable to unaccompanied children from Mexico. It removes
the current requirement that CBP ensure that a child is capable
of making an independent decision to voluntarily withdraw his
or her application for admission to the country. According to
CBP policy, young children under the age of 14 (also known as
``tender age'') are presumed to be lacking capacity to make an
independent decision to withdraw and therefore CBP transfers
them to ORR custody for further screening and the opportunity
to appear in immigration court.\13\ This rule also currently
applies to children with intellectual disabilities or other
issues which would prevent them from having the capacity to
make an independent decision. Removing this vital protection
will result in the rapid deportation of tender age children and
those with disabilities.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Unaccompanied Alien Children: Actions Needed to Ensure Children
Receive Required Care in DHS Custody, U.S. Govn't Accountability Office
(Jul. 14, 2015), https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-15-521.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furthermore, this title would result in the lengthy
detention of many children because it eliminates the current
requirement that DHS transfer children within 72 hours to HHS
custody. This title would also limit the provision of attorneys
to unaccompanied children through federal programs because it
contains a strict prohibition on the use of government funds
for legal counsel. Additionally, it limits crucial protections
like Special Immigrant Juvenile Status visas from certain
children, limiting the legal pathways previously available to
them and increasing the likelihood that they are deported to
abusive situations in their home counties.
This title does nothing to protect children and instead,
every provision would harm children, particularly those in
danger of trafficking. If implemented, this title would result
in the rapid return of a child to his or her country of origin
without an adequate assessment of whether the child has a fear
of persecution or trafficking. For these reasons, Democrats
offered amendments to ensure that children in custody are
transferred within 72 hours to be in the care of child welfare
experts and to allow for government appointed counsel for
unaccompanied children. These amendments were struck down on
party line votes.
VI. H.R. 2640 WOULD SUBJECT INDIVIDUALS WHO OVERSTAY A VISA BY MISTAKE
OR FOR REASONS BEYOND THEIR CONTROL TO CRUEL CRIMINAL PENALTIES
Title V, the ``Visa Overstays Penalties Act,'' would
criminalize overstaying a visa or violating a nonimmigrant
status for an aggregate of 10 or more days. First-time
violators could receive up to 6 months in prison and/or up to
$1,000 fines. Subsequent violations would subject them to 2
years in prison and/or up to $2,000 in fines. The title's text
does not co