Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4763]
The Committee on Financial Services, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 4763) to provide for a system of regulation of
digital assets by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and
the Securities and Exchange Commission, and for other purposes,
having considered the same, reports favorably thereon with an
amendment and recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 56
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 56
Related Hearings................................................. 72
Committee Consideration.......................................... 73
Committee Votes.................................................. 73
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 77
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 77
Congressional Budget Office Estimates............................ 77
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures 77
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 77
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 77
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 78
Earmark Identification........................................... 78
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 78
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 78
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 85
Minority Views................................................... 332
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
(a) Short Title.--This Act may be cited as the ``Financial Innovation
and Technology for the 21st Century Act''.
(b) Table of Contents.--The table of contents for this Act is as
follows:
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
TITLE I--DEFINITIONS; RULEMAKING; NOTICE OF INTENT TO REGISTER
Sec. 101. Definitions under the Securities Act of 1933.
Sec. 102. Definitions under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
Sec. 103. Definitions under the Commodity Exchange Act.
Sec. 104. Definitions under this Act.
Sec. 105. Joint rulemakings.
Sec. 106. Notice of intent to register for digital commodity exchanges,
brokers, and dealers.
Sec. 107. Notice of intent to register for digital asset brokers,
dealers, and trading systems.
Sec. 108. Commodity Exchange Act savings provisions.
Sec. 109. International harmonization.
Sec. 110. Implementation.
TITLE II-- OFFERS AND SALES OF DIGITAL ASSETS
Sec. 201. Exempted transactions in digital assets.
Sec. 202. Requirements for offers and sales of certain digital assets.
Sec. 203. Enhanced disclosure requirements.
Sec. 204. Certification of certain digital assets.
Sec. 205. Effective date.
TITLE III--REGISTRATION FOR DIGITAL ASSET INTERMEDIARIES AT THE
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Sec. 301. Treatment of digital commodities and other digital assets.
Sec. 302. Anti-fraud authority over permitted payment stablecoins.
Sec. 303. Registration of digital asset trading systems.
Sec. 304. Requirements for digital asset trading systems.
Sec. 305. Registration of digital asset brokers and digital asset
dealers.
Sec. 306. Requirements of digital asset brokers and digital asset
dealers.
Sec. 307. Rules related to conflicts of interest.
Sec. 308. Treatment of certain digital assets in connection with
federally regulated intermediaries.
Sec. 309. Exclusion for ancillary activities.
Sec. 310. Registration and requirements for notice-registered digital
asset clearing agencies.
Sec. 311. Treatment of custody activities by banking institutions.
Sec. 312. Effective date; administration.
TITLE IV--REGISTRATION FOR DIGITAL ASSET INTERMEDIARIES AT THE
COMMODITY FUTURES TRADING COMMISSION
Sec. 401. Commission jurisdiction over digital commodity transactions.
Sec. 402. Requiring futures commission merchants to use qualified
digital commodity custodians.
Sec. 403. Trading certification and approval for digital commodities.
Sec. 404. Registration of digital commodity exchanges.
Sec. 405. Qualified digital commodity custodians.
Sec. 406. Registration and regulation of digital commodity brokers and
dealers.
Sec. 407. Registration of associated persons.
Sec. 408. Registration of commodity pool operators and commodity
trading advisors.
Sec. 409. Exclusion for ancillary activities.
Sec. 410. Effective date.
TITLE V--INNOVATION AND TECHNOLOGY IMPROVEMENTS
Sec. 501. Codification of the SEC Strategic Hub for Innovation and
Financial Technology.
Sec. 502. Codification of LabCFTC.
Sec. 503. CFTC-SEC Joint Advisory Committee on Digital Assets.
Sec. 504. Study on decentralized finance.
Sec. 505. Study on non-fungible digital assets.
Sec. 506. Study on expanding financial literacy amongst digital asset
holders.
Sec. 507. Study on financial market infrastructure improvements.
TITLE VI--MISCELLANEOUS
Sec. 601. Findings; sense of Congress.
TITLE I--DEFINITIONS; RULEMAKING; NOTICE OF INTENT TO REGISTER
SEC. 101. DEFINITIONS UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT OF 1933.
Section 2(a) of the Securities Act of 1933 (15 U.S.C. 77b(a)) is
amended by adding at the end the following:
``(20) Affiliated person.--The term `affiliated person' means
a person (including a related person) that--
``(A) with respect to a digital asset issuer--
``(i) directly, or indirectly through one or
more intermediaries, controls, or is controlled
by, or is under common control with, such
digital asset issuer; and
``(ii) was described under clause (i) at any
point in the previous 3-month period; or
``(B) with respect to any digital asset--
``(i) beneficially owns 5 percent or more of
the units of such digital asset that are then
outstanding; and
``(ii) was described under clause (i) at any
point in the previous 3-month period.
``(21) Blockchain.--The term `blockchain' means any
technology--
``(A) where data is--
``(i) shared across a network to create a
public ledger of verified transactions or
information among network participants;
``(ii) linked using cryptography to maintain
the integrity of the public ledger and to
execute other functions; and
``(iii) distributed among network
participants in an automated fashion to
concurrently update network participants on the
state of the public ledger and any other
functions; and
``(B) composed of source code that is publicly
available.
``(22) Blockchain protocol.--The term `blockchain protocol'
means any executable software deployed to a blockchain composed
of source code that is publicly available and accessible,
including a smart contract or any network of smart contracts.
``(23) Blockchain system.--The term `blockchain system' means
any blockchain or blockchain protocol.
``(24) Decentralized network.--With respect to a blockchain
system to which a digital asset relates, the term
`decentralized network' means the following conditions are met:
``(A) During the previous 12-month period, no
person--
``(i) had the unilateral authority, directly
or indirectly, through any contract,
arrangement, understanding, relationship, or
otherwise, to control or materially alter the
functionality or operation of the blockchain
system; or
``(ii) had the unilateral authority to
restrict or prohibit any person who is not a
digital asset issuer, related person, or an
affiliated person from--
``(I) using, earning, or transmitting
the digital asset;
``(II) deploying software that uses
or integrates with the blockchain
system;
``(III) participating in a
decentralized governance system with
respect to the blockchain system; or
``(IV) operating a node, validator,
or other form of computational
infrastructure with respect to the
blockchain system.
``(B) During the previous 12-month period--
``(i) no digital asset issuer or affiliated
person beneficially owned, in the aggregate, 20
percent or more of the total amount of units of
such digital asset that--
``(I) can be created, issued, or
distributed in such blockchain system;
and
``(II) were freely transferrable or
otherwise used or available to be used
for the purposes of such blockchain
system;
``(ii) no digital asset issuer or affiliated
person had the unilateral authority to direct
the voting, in the aggregate, of 20 percent or
more of the outstanding voting power of such
digital asset or related decentralized
governance system; or
``(iii) the digital asset did not include
voting power with respect to any decentralized
governance system of the blockchain system.
``(C) During the previous 3-month period, the digital
asset issuer, any affiliated person, or any related
person has not implemented or contributed any
intellectual property to the source code of the
blockchain system that materially alters the
functionality or operation of the blockchain system,
unless such implementation or contribution to the
source code--
``(i) addressed vulnerabilities, errors,
regular maintenance, cybersecurity risks, or
other technical changes to the blockchain
system; or
``(ii) were adopted through the consensus or
agreement of a decentralized governance system.
``(D) During the previous 3-month period, neither any
digital asset issuer nor any affiliated person
described under paragraph (20)(A) has marketed to the
public the digital assets as an investment.
``(E) During the previous 12-month period, all
issuances of units of such digital asset through the
programmatic functioning of the blockchain system were
end user distributions.
``(25) Decentralized governance system.--
``(A) In general.--The term `decentralized governance
system' means, with respect to a blockchain system, any
rules-based system permitting persons using the
blockchain system or the digital assets related to such
blockchain system to form consensus or reach agreement
in the development, provision, publication, management,
or administration of such blockchain system.
``(B) Relationship of persons to decentralized
governance systems.--Persons acting through a
decentralized governance system shall be treated as
separate persons unless such persons are under common
control.
``(C) Exclusion.--The term `decentralized governance
system' does not include a system in which--
``(i) a person or group of persons under
common control have the ability to--
``(I) unilaterally alter the rules of
consensus or agreement for the
blockchain system; or
``(II) determine the final outcome of
decisions related to the development,
provision, publication, management, or
administration of such blockchain
system;
``(ii) a person or group of persons is
directly engaging in an activity that requires
registration with the Commission or the
Commodity Futures Trading Commission other
than--
``(I) developing, providing,
publishing, managing, or administering
a blockchain system; or
``(II) an activity with respect to
which the organization is exempt from
such registration; or
``(iii) a person or group of persons seeking
to knowingly evade the requirements imposed on
a digital asset issuer, a related person, an
affiliated person, or any other person
registered (or required to be registered) under
the securities laws, the Financial Innovation
and Technology for the 21st Century Act, or the
Commodity Exchange Act.
``(26) Digital asset.--
``(A) In general.--The term `digital asset' means any
fungible digital representation of value that can be
exclusively possessed and transferred, person to
person, without necessary reliance on an intermediary,
and is recorded on a cryptographically secured public
distributed ledger.
``(B) Exclusions.--The term `digital asset' does not
include--
``(i) any note, stock, treasury stock,
security future, security-based swap, bond,
debenture, evidence of indebtedness,
certificate of interest or participation in any
profit-sharing agreement, collateral-trust
certificate, preorganization certificate or
subscription, or transferable share; or
``(ii) any asset, which based on its terms
and other characteristics, is, represents, or
is functionally equivalent to an agreement,
contract, or transaction that is--
``(I) a contract of sale of a
commodity (as defined under section 1a
of the Commodity Exchange Act) for
future delivery or an option thereon;
``(II) a security futures product;
``(III) a swap;
``(IV) an agreement, contract, or
transaction described in section
2(c)(2)(C)(i) or 2(c)(2)(D)(i) of the
Commodity Exchange Act;
``(V) a commodity option authorized
under section 4c of the Commodity
Exchange Act; or
``(VI) a leverage transaction
authorized under section 19 of the
Commodity Exchange Act.
``(C) Rule of construction.--Nothing in this
paragraph shall be construed to create a presumption
that a digital asset is a representation of any type of
security not excluded from the definition of digital
asset.
``(D) Relationship to a blockchain system.--A digital
asset is considered to relate to a blockchain system if
the digital asset is intrinsically linked to the
blockchain system, including--
``(i) where the digital asset's value is
reasonably expected to be generated by the
programmatic functioning of the blockchain
system;
``(ii) where the digital asset has voting
rights with respect to the decentralized
governance system of the blockchain system; or
``(iii) where the digital asset is issued
through the programmatic functioning of the
blockchain system.
``(E) Treatment of certain digital assets sold
pursuant to an investment contract.--A digital asset
offered or sold or intended to be offered or sold
pursuant to an investment contract is not and does not
become a security as a result of being sold or
otherwise transferred pursuant to that investment
contract.
``(27) Digital asset issuer.--
``(A) In general.--With respect to a digital asset,
the term `digital asset issuer' means any person that,
in exchange for any consideration--
``(i) issues or causes to be issued a unit of
such digital asset to a person; or
``(ii) offers or sells a right to a future
issuance of a unit of such digital asset to a
person.
``(B) Exclusion.--The term `digital asset issuer'
does not include any person solely because such person
deploys source code that creates or issues units of a
digital asset that are only distributed in end user
distributions.
``(C) Prohibition on evasion.--It shall
Purpose and Summary
Introduced on July 20, 2023, by Representative Glenn ``GT''
Thompson with Representatives French Hill, Dusty Johnson, Tom
Emmer, and Warren Davidson as original cosponsors, H.R. 4763,
the Financial Innovation and Technology for the 21st Century
Act, provides the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)
with new jurisdiction over digital commodities and clarifies
the Securities and Exchange Commission's (SEC) jurisdiction
over digital assets offered as part of an investment contract.
Additionally, the Act establishes a process to permit the
secondary market trading of digital commodities if they were
initially offered as part of an investment contract. Finally,
the Act imposes robust customer protections on all entities
required to be registered with the CFTC and the SEC. Additional
cosponsors include Representatives Marcus Molinaro, Henry
Cuellar, Wiley Nickel, John Curtis, Jim Banks, Patrick McHenry,
and Ritchie Torres.
Background and Need for Legislation
H.R. 4763, as marked up, establishes a digital asset market
structure framework that is consistent with existing regulatory
financial market requirements, but recognizes the unique
characteristics of digital assets. This functional framework
provides digital asset firms with regulatory certainty and
reduces the regulatory turbulence created by jurisdictional
infighting and regulation-by-enforcement. The reported
legislation will ensure the next generation of financial
innovation develops in the United States.
Innovation
Digital assets have the potential to make our financial
system more efficient and accessible to consumers. At a June 6,
2023, hearing before the Committee on Agriculture (June 2023
HAC Hearing), former CFTC Chairman Chris Giancarlo
characterized the existing financial architecture, which stores
value on the balance sheets of proprietary commercial firms, as
slow, expensive, unstable, and exclusive. He testified that
blockchain technology and digital assets provide a new
architecture of value, finance, banking, and money that is more
reliable and inclusive. At the same hearing, Coinbase Global,
Inc. Chief Legal Officer Paul Grewal testified that ``digital
assets are creating new ways to store and transfer value while
making existing systems--like the financial system--better,''
including providing a means for ``cheaper, faster, and more
reliable international payments.'' Former CFTC Commissioner Dan
Berkovitz also testified that ``[d]igital assets and the
associated blockchain technologies have the potential to
transform the availability, scope, and efficiency of financial
services to American consumers and businesses and across the
globe.''
As the House Committee on Financial Services (HFSC) and
House Committee on Agriculture (HAC) heard in testimony across
multiple hearings, digital assets are changing the way we
conduct business globally. Digital assets serve as the
foundation for developments in blockchain systems that can in
turn facilitate improvements in supply chain management,
identity verification, file storage, and numerous other
industries.
In testimony before HFSC on June 13, 2023 (June 2023 HFSC
Hearing), Dr. Emin G. Gun Sirer underscored the stakes of
failing to allow digital assets to flourish in the United
States, stating:
As we move towards a more digitally-native world,
aided by AI, virtual reality, and a work-from-home
society, we will have to rely increasingly on
digitally-native transfer and programmability of value.
He further testified:
Blockchains are the clear technological answer to
these needs and are definitively synergistic with the
global economy. The addressable market for digitizing
the world's assets and transferring value safely across
the internet is greater than the sum of all the value
of all existing assets. Failure to see the power of
blockchain technology--whether due to a lack of
understanding or misplaced fears of the technology--
will have disastrous consequences. Failure to rapidly
provide sensible regulatory frameworks will not only
undermine economic growth but also make it easier for
bad actors to conduct illicit activities.
Further, when Dr. Tonya Evans, a professor at Penn State
Dickinson Law, testified before the House Financial Services
Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology and
Inclusion on March 9, 2023, she underscored how far the United
States is from ``a sensible regulatory framework.'' Dr. Evans
explained:
It remains unclear how responsible builders and
market participants in the future of money, work, and
creativity can operate confidently, efficiently, and
with clarity. Without such a foundation, private
industry development will be left in a holding pattern
or will simply move valuable tax dollars and
opportunities to jurisdictions with clearer rules and
policies that encourage, rather than stifle,
innovation.
At an April 27, 2023, hearing before the Committee on
Agriculture's Subcommittee on Commodity Markets, Digital
Assets, and Rural Development (April 2023 HAC Hearing), Hedera
Head of Global Policy Nilmini Rubin testified:
[T]he ability of blockchains to provide immutable,
auditable, and order-based records enables businesses
and organizations to store, track and monitor data in
new and powerful ways.
Ms. Rubin testified further that blockchains can provide
new tools to more effectively and efficiently ``store, track,
and monitor data to reduce waste, fraud, and abuse, and provide
economic, social, and environmental benefits.'' She described
examples of these initiatives, including data storage and
provenance verification to support human rights reporting,
value exchange supporting rural development, transparent
platforms supporting the environment, supply chain traceability
supporting waste reduction, supply chain monitoring supporting
vaccine safety, and supply chain tracking supporting
pharmaceutical safety.
At a May 10, 2023, joint hearing of the Financial Services
Committee's Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial
Technology and Inclusion and the Committee on Agriculture's
Subcommittee on Commodity Markets, Digital Assets, and Rural
Development (May 2023 Joint Hearing), Kraken Chief Legal
Officer Marco Santori testified:
[T]his discussion is not just about people using
tokens or people using digital assets. This discussion
is about people using the product of those digital
assets, the functional use cases that exist today, and
this Congress has heard from witnesses who have laid
bare some of those uses.
I can add a couple to that pile, but maybe one in
particular that I think illustrates that distinction
between the use case and the coin. Today, when you
watch a video on your phone, and we all probably watch
videos on our phone from time to time, those videos are
recorded in far-off places using different standards,
resolutions, color schemes, et cetera. Transforming
that into a version that fits on your phone takes
computing and processing power. It takes time and
effort. And it is expensive. There are blockchain-based
networks now that coordinate and incentivize that
process, it is called transcoding, so that end-users
can see that video that is being recorded in a
different resolution on their phone, on their screen,
on a big screen, on IMAX, right?
People are using that technology today to view videos
of all kinds, mundane use cases that have nothing to do
with blockchain technology. But those use cases are
being provisioned and delivered because of functional
networks in digital assets.
Economic Impact
The lack of a comprehensive federal regulatory framework
for digital assets has led to many digital asset innovators
moving offshore to pursue development overseas, at the expense
of U.S. economic growth. Other countries are rushing to build
frameworks and become developmental hubs for the digital asset
ecosystem. Currently, the largest trading platform and the
largest stablecoin issuer are based outside of the United
States. Many entrepreneurs are warning against doing business
in the United States and advocating for digital asset companies
to move offshore.
Many jurisdictions are successfully building digital asset
regulatory frameworks and incorporating distributed ledger
technology into their economies. For example, the European
Union recently approved its Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA)
regulation, and the United Kingdom will soon finalize its own
digital asset regulatory proposal. To emphasize this impact,
Coy Garrison, former counsel to SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce,
testified at the June 2023 HFSC Hearing about the economic
impact resulting from other countries regulating digital assets
while the U.S. remains inactive:
The status quo puts the U.S. at a competitive
disadvantage. The European Union, Canada, Dubai, and
Hong Kong are examples of jurisdictions that in recent
months have implemented new legislation or regulations
for digital assets, which create attractive
destinations for entities that are made to feel
increasingly unwelcome by regulators here in the U.S.
This is not empty rhetoric: I have travelled to two of
these jurisdictions in the past six months to explore
business opportunities under these new foreign
regulatory regimes, and I have regular conversations
with industry participants in the U.S. actively
considering moving to new jurisdictions.
At the June 2023 HAC Hearing, Robinhood Markets, Inc. Chief
Legal, Compliance and Corporate Affairs Officer Daniel M.
Gallagher testified:
The current environment is bad for American consumers
who want greater access to digital assets, bad for
innovation in the blockchain and digital asset
industries, and bad for the already-eroding competitive
position of the U.S. with regard to digital asset
markets. Regulatory clarity for digital assets is,
therefore, critical: it would allow token issuers,
exchanges, intermediaries, and other market
participants to provide products and services their
customers want without the constant threat of crippling
enforcement actions, and would help ensure that the
U.S. remains the global leader in responsible
blockchain and digital asset innovation, as well as
vibrant, appropriately regulated digital asset markets.
Customer Risk
The current regulatory framework for digital assets fails
to provide adequate consumer protection. At the June 2023 HFSC
Hearing, Mr. Garrison, testified that:
The status quo fails to protect people who trade or
hold digital assets on centralized exchanges. [ . . . ]
The status quo also creates a business environment
where responsible actors in the digital asset industry
are hindered in their potential to innovate, add jobs
to the economy, and realize the benefits of their
technology. They are also limited in their ability to
compete against traditional institutions.
Digital commodities account for approximately 70% of the
digital assets traded today. Because there is no federal
oversight of the digital commodity marketplace, there are no
federally mandated customer protections for at least 70% of the
digital asset market today, including requirements pertaining
to customer disclosures, segregation of customer funds, and
conflicts of interest. Additionally, without registration and
oversight of digital commodity intermediaries and trading
platforms, customers are unable to discern reputable entities
from the disreputable ones. Consequently, customers face
significant risks with respect to the digital commodities they
purchase, how they purchase those commodities, how an
intermediary or trading platform custodies their commodities,
and their ability to access those commodities, especially if
the intermediary or trading platform holding their commodities
dissolves. At the May 2023 Joint Hearing, Former CFTC Chairman
Timothy Massad testified that:
[I]nvestor protection on crypto trading and lending
platforms is woefully inadequate. These platforms do
not observe standards common in our financial markets
that ensure protection of customer assets, prohibition
of conflicts of interest, prevention of fraud and
manipulation, and adequate transparency, among other
things. That was made painfully obvious last year by
the failures of trading platform FTX, crypto lender
Celsius, the Terra/Luna stablecoin and others,
resulting in hundreds of thousands of investors
suffering losses.
At the June 2023 HAC Hearing, CFTC Chairman Rostin Behnam
testified:
The bankruptcy of several large digital asset
platforms erased billions of dollars in customer funds.
Multiple large market participants allegedly engaged in
manipulative and abusive trading activity, including
through opaque arrangements with affiliated trading
platforms, undermining confidence in these nascent
markets. Cybersecurity vulnerabilities continue to be
exploited in weekly hacks, resulting in billions of
dollars in lost funds.
These customer protection failures highlight the urgent
need for legislation to provide robust customer protections for
U.S. citizens trading digital commodities. At the June 2023 HAC
Hearing, Mr. Gallagher testified:
[M]illions of Americans--including millions of
Robinhood customers--want to participate and are
participating responsibly in the digital asset economy,
and they will continue to do so whether in the U.S. or
through foreign platforms. We believe policymakers
should support policy solutions that encourage
Americans to engage in digital asset markets through
responsible, appropriately regulated U.S. firms, rather
than incentivizing people to participate through often
unregulated or lightly regulated foreign platforms.
Regulatory Gap
Currently, there is no comprehensive federal regulatory
regime for the cash or spot digital commodity markets. The
Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) and the CFTC regulations
promulgated thereunder provide a comprehensive regulatory
regime for the trading of commodity derivatives, including
digital commodity derivatives (e.g., buying or selling Bitcoin
futures contracts). This includes registration and regulatory
requirements for exchanges and intermediaries. Under the CEA,
the CFTC also has ``after-the-fact'' enforcement jurisdiction
over fraud and manipulation in the cash or spot commodity
markets (e.g., buying or selling a commodity, including digital
commodities, like Bitcoin). However, the CFTC has no power to
impose registration and regulatory requirements for exchanges
or intermediaries, or on market participants in the cash or
spot digital commodity markets. This lack of a comprehensive
federal regulatory framework for digital commodity cash or spot
transactions is referred to as the ``spot market regulatory
gap.''
Daniel Gorfine, former Chief Innovation Officer at the
CFTC, testified at the House Financial Services Subcommittee on
Digital Assets, Financial Technology and Inclusion's hearing on
April 27, 2023 (April 27 HFSC Hearing), stating:
The overall regulatory landscape for digital assets
has not changed significantly since Bitcoin first
traded in 2009--which means that there is no
comprehensive market oversight framework.''
At the May 2023 Joint Hearing, Former CFTC Chair Massad
testified:
Four years ago, I wrote a paper published by the
Brookings Institute that began with the following
sentence: ``There is a gap in the regulation of crypto
assets that Congress needs to fix.''
The gap I talked about then was the absence of a
federal regulator for the spot market in crypto tokens
that are not securities, such as bitcoin. It still
exists, and it is made more complicated by the ongoing
debate we have had about how to classify digital
assets: are they securities or commodities, or
something else?
At the June 2023 HAC Hearing, CFTC Chairman Behnam
testified about the need for legislation to fill the regulatory
gap. Chair Behnam testified:
I have consistently highlighted the need for
Congressional action to address the lack of federal
regulation over the digital commodity market.
Chair Behnam added that the Financial Stability Oversight
Council's (FSOC) Report on Digital Asset Financial Stability
Risks and Regulation (Oct. 2022) (FSOC Report) called on
Congress to enact legislation to fill the clear regulatory gap
over the spot market for digital assets that are not
securities.
The FSOC Report succinctly summarized the spot-market gap:
U.S. law provides for limited direct federal
oversight of spot markets for crypto-assets that are
not securities . . . As a result, those markets may not
feature robust rules and regulations designed to ensure
orderly and transparent trading, to prevent conflicts
of interest and market manipulation, and to protect
investors and the economy more broadly. Indeed, U.S.
regulators have found possible sources of fraud and
manipulation in the spot Bitcoin market.
The spot markets for crypto-assets that are not
securities provide relatively fewer protections for
retail investors compared to other financial markets
that have significant retail participation. In
addition, crypto-asset platforms in the spot market for
non-security crypto-assets engage in practices that are
commonly subjected to greater regulation in other
financial markets. In similarly structured financial
markets, trading rules apply related to practices of
trade execution and settlement to ensure fairness and
transparency and to limit abusive trading practices
more generally.
* * * * * * *
Significant market integrity and investor protection
issues may persist because of the limited direct
federal oversight of these spot markets, due to abusive
trading practices, inadequate protections for custodied
assets, or other practices. Increased interconnections
between this market and traditional financial
institutions could pose financial stability
vulnerabilities. In addition, if the scale of crypto-
asset activities were to increase rapidly, these issues
could pose financial stability issues regardless of
interconnections with the traditional financial system.
In the light of these gaps, the FSOC Report recommended
that Congress pass legislation to address their concerns:
To address this regulatory gap, the Council
recommends that Congress pass legislation that provides
for explicit rulemaking authority for federal financial
regulators over the spot market for crypto-assets that
are not securities. The Council recommends that this
rulemaking authority should not interfere with or
weaken market regulators' current jurisdictional
remits. The rulemaking authority should cover a range
of subjects, including but not limited to conflicts of
interest; abusive trading practices; public trade
reporting requirements; recordkeeping; governance
standards; cybersecurity requirements; customer asset
segregation; capital and margin; custody, settlement,
and clearing; orderly trading; transparency; any
further anti-fraud authorities that may be necessary;
investor protection; dispute resolution; operating
norms; and a genera
Committee Consideration
The Committee on Financial Services met in open session on
July 26, 2023, and ordered H.R. 4763 to be reported favorably
to the House as amended by a recorded vote of 35 ayes to 15
nays (Record vote no. FC-76), a quorum being present. Before
the question was called to order the bill favorably reported,
the Committee adopted an amendment in the nature of a
substitute offered by Mr. Hill by voice vote.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires the Committee to list the record votes
on the order to report legislation and amendments thereto. H.R.
4763 was ordered reported favorably to the House as amended by
a recorded vote of 35 ayes to 15 nays (Record vote no. FC-76),
a quorum being present.
An amendment offered by Mr. Foster, no. 1, was not agreed
to by voice vote, a quorum being present.
An amendment offered by Mr. Sherman, no. 2, was not agreed
to by voice vote, a quorum being present.
An en bloc vote for amendments offered by Ms. Waters, no.
3, Mr. Lynch, no. 11, and Mr. Lynch, no. 13, was not agreed to
by a recorded vote of 19 ayes to 29 nays, a quorum being
present (Record vote no. FC-75).
An amendment by Mr. Gottheimer, no. 4, was agreed to by
voice vote, a quorum being present.
An amendment by Mr. Lynch, no. 6, was agreed to by voice
vote, a quorum being present.
An amendment by Mr. Himes, no. 7, was agreed to by voice
vote, a quorum being present.
An amendment by Mr. Nickel, no. 8, was agreed to by voice
vote, a quorum being present.
An amendment by Mr. Horsford, no. 9, was agreed to by voice
vote, a quorum being present.
An amendment by Mr. Lynch, no. 12, was not agreed to by
voice vote, a quorum being present.
Committee Overisght Findings
Pursuant to clause 3(c) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the findings and recommendations of
the Committee based on oversight activities under clause
2(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives,
are incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
Performance Goals and Objectives
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the goal of H.R. 4763 is to ensure
that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has
jurisdiction over digital commodities and clarifies the
Securities and Exchange Commission's (SEC) jurisdiction over
digital assets offered as part of an investment contract,
including imposing robust customer protections on all entities
required to be registered with the CFTC and the SEC.
Congressional Budget Office Estimates
The Committee has requested but not received a cost
estimate from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office.
However, pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee will adopt as its own the cost estimate by the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office once it has been
prepared.
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures
The Committee has requested but not received an estimate
from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office. However,
pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, once an estimate has been prepared by
the Director of the Congressional Budget Office, as required by
section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1973, the
Committee will adopt as its own the estimate of new budget
authority, entitlement authority, or tax expenditures or
revenues contained in the cost estimate.
Federal Mandates Statement
The Committee has requested but not received an estimate
from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office of the
Federal mandates pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act. The Committee will adopt the estimate once
it has been prepared by the Director.
Advisory Committee Statement
Pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 1004(b), H.R. 4763 requires the CFTC
and the SEC to form a Joint Advisory Committee on Digital
Assets comprised of digital asset marketplace stakeholders. The
functions of the proposed Joint Advisory Committee on Digital
Assets could not be performed by an agency or advisory
committee already in existence.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Earmark Identification
With respect to clause 9 of rule XXI of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee has carefully reviewed
the provisions of the bill and states that the provisions of
the bill do not contain any Congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits within the meaning of the
rule.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee states that no
provision of the bill establishes or reauthorizes a program of
the Federal Government known to be duplicative of another
Federal program, including any program that was included in a
report to Congress pursuant to section 21 of the Public Law
111-139 or the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance.
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation
TITLE I--DEFINITIONS; RULEMAKING; NOTICE OF INTENT TO REGISTER
Sec. 101. Definitions under the Securities Act of 1933
Section 101 provides for definitions under the Securities
Act of 1933.
Sec. 102. Definitions under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
Section 102 provides for definitions under the Securities
Exchange Act of 1934.
Sec. 103. Definitions under the Commodity Exchange Act
Section 103 is within the House Committee on Agriculture's
jurisdiction pursuant to rule X. The House Committee on
Agriculture's Report of H.R. 4763 includes a summary of this
section.
Sec. 104. Definitions under this Act
Section 104 provides for definitions under this Act.
Sec. 105. Joint rulemakings
Section 105 provides for joint rulemakings between the
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity
Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), including joint rulemakings
related to defining key terms in the Act, the oversight of
dually registered exchanges, and the oversight of mixed digital
asset transactions. Section 105 requires a joint rulemaking
related to mixed digital asset transactions and prohibits the
Financial Crimes Enforcement Network from issuing any rule that
would limit self-custody by an individual. Additionally,
Section 105 requires the SEC and CFTC to jointly issue
rulemakings regarding the process to delist an asset for
trading under the notice of intent to register period.
Sec. 106. Notice of intent to register for CFTC intermediaries
Section 106 is within the House Committee on Agriculture's
jurisdiction pursuant to rule X. The House Committee on
Agriculture's Report of H.R. 4763 includes a summary of this
section.
Sec. 107. Notice of intent to register for SEC intermediaries
Section 107 permits a digital asset broker (DAB), digital
asset dealer (DAD), or digital asset trading system (DATS) to
file a notice of intent to register with the SEC. The filer
must submit information regarding its operations to the
Commission, submit to inspection by the Commission, and be a
member of FINRA. As a member of FINRA, it must also apply with
all applicable membership requirements, including risk
disclosures for customers and segregation of customer assets.
Filing a notice provides the filer with an exemption from
registration as an intermediary with the SEC with respect to
digital asset transactions, until such time as the rules are
written and permanent registration commences. It does not limit
the authority of the CFTC or SEC to bring anti-fraud or anti-
manipulation enforcement actions or to require a filer to
delist a digital asset. Finally, Section 107 provides that it
is unlawful for a filer to knowingly provide a false statement
to the SEC.
Sec. 108. Commodity Exchange Act savings provisions
Section 108 is within the House Committee on Agriculture's
jurisdiction pursuant to rule X. The House Committee on
Agriculture's Report of H.R. 4763 includes a summary of this
section.
Sec. 109. International harmonization
Section 109 requires the CFTC and the SEC to work with
foreign regulators to establish consistent international
standards for the regulation of digital asset markets.
Sec. 110. Implementation
Section 110 requires the CFTC and the SEC to promulgate all
rules required by the Act no later than 360 days after
enactment of the Act.
TITLE II--OFFERS AND SALES OF DIGITAL ASSETS
Sec. 201. Exempted transactions in digital assets
Section 201 establishes an exemption from the securities
laws for a digital asset issuer's sale of digital assets that
meet the following conditions: (1) the issuer's total sales of
the digital asset over the prior 12 months does not exceed $75
million; (2) a non-accredited investor's purchases of the
digital asset from the issuer over the prior 12 months are less
than the greater of 10% of the purchaser's annual income or 10%
of their net worth; (3) the purchaser does not own more than
10% of the units of the digital asset after the completion of
the transaction; and (4) the transaction involves the sale of a
digital asset as part of an investment contract.
The digital asset issuer must file information with the
Commission as prescribed by the Act. The digital asset issuer
must file annual and semiannual reports until a defined period
after the blockchain system is certified as decentralized. Any
intermediaries involved in the offer or sale of a unit of a
digital asset under this exemption must be registered with the
SEC. A unit of a digital asset acquired from the digital asset
issuer in reliance on this exemption is a restricted digital
asset.
Sec. 202. Requirements for offers and sales of certain digital assets
Section 202 sets out the conditions under which certain
persons are permitted to engage in restricted digital asset
transactions and digital commodity transactions. Generally,
restricted digital assets are permitted to trade on a DATS
under the supervision of the SEC and digital commodities are
permitted to trade on a DCE under the supervision of the CFTC.
Related and affiliated persons are subject to more restrictions
on when they may sell digital assets that they hold. This
section also exempts end user distributions--broad, non-
discretionary distributions issued for no more than nominal
consideration--from the securities laws.
Sec. 203. Enhanced disclosure requirements
Section 203 provides for a new disclosure regime for
digital assets. The information required to be disclosed is
focused on the nature of the risks surrounding digital assets,
including source code, project economics, development plan,
related and affiliated persons, and material risk factors.
Sec. 204. Certification of certain digital assets
Section 204 provides for a process for a blockchain
relating to a digital asset to be certified as decentralized.
The certification process permits any person to certify to the
SEC that the blockchain network meets the requirements of the
Act. As part of this process, an individual will submit general
information pertaining to the blockchain network and an
analysis of the factors on which decentralization is based. The
certification is considered automatically approved after 60
days unless the Commission issues a stay. The SEC may rebut the
certification, which may be appealed by the party making the
certification to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C.
Circuit.
Sec. 205. Effective date
Section 205 provides that the provisions under this Title
will take effect one year after enactment or, in the case of
rulemakings under the Title, not less than 60 days after
publication of the final rule.
TITLE III--REGISTRATION FOR DIGITAL ASSET INTERMEDIARIES AT THE
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Sec. 301. Treatment of digital commodities and other digital assets
Section 301 excludes digital commodities and permitted
payment stablecoins from the definition of a security under the
securities laws. It also specifies that DATS shall not be
deemed a ``facility'' of an exchange.
Sec. 302. Antifraud authority over payment stablecoins
Section 302 provides the SEC with anti-fraud and anti-
manipulation authority over transactions with or involving
permitted payment stablecoins that occur on or with a SEC
registered entity. It also provides the SEC with limited
authority to transactions in permitted payment stablecoins,
when transacted by or through an entity registered with the
Commission. Finally, section 302 specifies that the SEC shall
have no authority over the design, structure, issuance,
redemption, financial resources, collateral, or any other
aspect of a payment stablecoin's operation.
Sec. 303. Registration of Digital Asset Trading Systems
Section 303 establishes a registration framework for DATS.
It also provides for the dual registration of a DATS as a DCE
registered with the CFTC.
Section 304. Requirements for Digital Asset Trading Systems
Section 304 establishes the requirements for DATS. The SEC
is instructed to prescribe rules in various areas including
order display, fair access, security of automated systems,
examinations, and reporting. DATS may not act as custodians and
are required to hold customer restricted digital assets in a
qualified digital asset custodian.
Section 304 also sets out the rules for qualified digital
asset custodians, including requirements that it be adequately
supervised and appropriately regulated by a federal, state, or
foreign banking regulator.
Section 305. Registration of Digital Asset Brokers and Digital Asset
Dealers
Section 305 establishes a registration framework for DAB
and DAD. It requires digital asset brokers and dealers to be
members of FINRA. Digital asset brokers and dealers may
register with the CFTC as digital commodity brokers and
dealers.
Section 306. Requirements of Digital Asset Brokers and Digital Asset
Dealers
Section 306 subjects digital asset brokers and dealers to
the same antifraud authorities that currently exist within
securities laws. The section also requires digital asset
brokers and dealers to comply with requirements including
capital, recordkeeping, segregation of customer funds, and use
of a qualified digital asset custodian. Customers may waive
customer segregation requirements so that digital asset brokers
and dealers may use their digital assets to participate in a
blockchain service. Digital asset brokers and digital asset
dealers under this section are treated as financial
institutions, requiring their compliance with the Bank Secrecy
Act.
Sec. 307. Rules related to conflicts of interest
Section 307 amends securities laws to ensure that each
digital asset trading system, digital asset broker, digital
asset dealer, and notice-registered digital asset clearing
agency reasonably implement policies that mitigate any
conflicts of interest and transactions or arrangements with
affiliates.
Sec. 308. Treatment of certain digital assets in connection with
federally regulated intermediaries
Section 308 adds digital assets to ``covered securities''
which are exempt from state blue sky law registration
requirements.
Sec. 309. Exclusion for ancillary activities
Section 309 exempts certain ancillary activities related to
the operation and maintenance of blockchain networks from SEC
regulation, although not from the Commission's anti-fraud or
anti-manipulation enforcement authorities.
Ancillary activities include validating or providing
incidental services with respect to a restricted digital asset,
providing user-interfaces for a blockchain network, publishing
and updating software, or developing wallets for blockchain
networks.
Sec. 310. Registration and requirements for notice-registered digital
asset clearing agencies
Section 310 permits digital asset brokers and dealers whose
operations do not involve digital commodities and banks
providing custody of digital assets to register as a notice-
registered digital asset clearing agency. SEC rules regarding
this section shall not take effect until at least a year after
enactment.
Sec. 311. Treatment of custody activities by banking institutions
Section 311 prevents federal regulators from imposing
requirements on financial institutions to include customers'
assets as liabilities on their balance sheets or from holding
additional capital against these assets, except as necessary to
mitigate against operational risks as determined by the
appropriate federal banking agency.
Section 312. Effective date; administration
Section 312 provides that the provisions under this Title
will take effect one year after enactment or, in the case of
rulemakings under the Title, not less than 60 days after
publication of the final rule. Further, it limits, for three
years, the deposit of registration fees in the SEC's Reserve
Fund.
TITLE IV--REGISTRATION FOR DIGITAL ASSET INTERMEDIARIES AT THE
COMMODITY FUTURES TRADING COMMISSION
Sec. 401. Commission jurisdiction over digital commodity transactions
Section 401 is within the House Committee on Agriculture's
jurisdiction pursuant to rule X. The House Committee on
Agriculture's Report of H.R. 4763 includes a summary of this
section.
Sec. 402. Requiring futures commission merchants to use qualified
digital commodity custodians
Section 402 is within the House Committee on Agriculture's
jurisdiction pursuant to rule X. The House Committee on
Agriculture's Report of H.R. 4763 includes a summary of this
section.
Sec. 403. Trading certification and approval for digital commodities
Section 403 is within the House Committee on Agriculture's
jurisdiction pursuant to rule X. The House Committee on
Agriculture's Report of H.R. 4763 includes a summary of this
section.
Sec. 404. Registration of digital commodity exchanges
Section 404 is within the House Committee on Agriculture's
jurisdiction pursuant to rule X. The House Committee on
Agriculture's Report of H.R. 4763 includes a summary of this
section.
Sec. 405. Qualified digital commodity custodians
Section 405 is within the House Committee on Agriculture's
jurisdiction pursuant to rule X. The House Committee on
Agriculture's Report of H.R. 4763 includes a summary of this
section.
Sec. 406. Registration and regulation of digital commodity brokers and
dealers
Section 406 is within the House Committee on Agriculture's
jurisdiction pursuant to rule X. The House Committee on
Agriculture's Report of H.R. 4763 includes a summary of this
section.
Sec. 407. Registration of associated persons
Section 407 is within the House Committee on Agriculture's
jurisdiction pursuant to rule X. The House Committee on
Agriculture's Report of H.R. 4763 includes a summary of this
section.
Sec. 408. Registration of commodity pool operators and commodity
trading advisors
Section 408 is within the House Committee on Agriculture's
jurisdiction pursuant to rule X. The House Committee on
Agriculture's Report of H.R. 4763 includes a summary of this
section.
Sec. 409. Exclusion for ancillary activities
Section 409 is within the House Committee on Agriculture's
jurisdiction pursuant to rule X. The House Committee on
Agriculture's Report of H.R. 4763 includes a summary of this
section.
Sec. 410. Effective date
Section 410 is within the House Committee on Agriculture's
jurisdi
Minority Views
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Chair Gary Gensler
has repeatedly and unambiguously stated that most digital
assets are in fact securities.\1\ Unfortunately, most digital
assets firms have chosen not to register with the SEC and in
response, Chair Gensler has been diligent in utilizing the
resources at his disposal to crack down on this mass
noncompliance.\2\ To the extent that Chair Gensler's
enforcement actions have been challenged in court,\3\ the SEC
has prevailed again and again with stunning consistency with
the exception of one outlier case that may yet be reversed on
appeal.\4\ Despite the lengths that SEC Chair Gensler has gone
to provide regulatory clarity for digital assets, the crypto
industry continues to insist that there is a lack of regulatory
clarity without providing much of any detail on how the current
securities law framework doesn't work for their industry.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Most Cryptocurrencies Are Securities, Says SEC Chair,
Investopedia (Sept. 8, 2022).
\2\Gensler defends SEC's crypto crackdown in marathon House
hearing, CNBC (Apr. 18, 2023).
\3\Ripple says it will fight the SEC lawsuit `all the way through',
CNBC (Sept. 12, 2023); see also Crypto firms facing US SEC charges find
hope in Ripple ruling, experts say, Reuters (July 17, 2023).
\4\Judge grants SEC request to file motion for appeal in Ripple
case, CoinTelegraph (Aug. 17, 2023); see also Judge Rejects Ripple
Ruling Precedent in Denying Terraform Labs' Motion to Dismiss SEC
Lawsuit, CoinDesk (Aug. 1, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In response to ambiguous industry complaints, H.R. 4763
would create a new, alternative legal framework specifically
for digital assets. Rather than providing greater regulatory
clarity, this bill provides more than 200 pages of new
definitions and legal tests that only create more confusion and
uncertainty. For example, while the ``Howey'' test, which is
the current standard for determining whether something is a
security under current law, has decades of judicial precedent
to clarify how to apply it in different situations, the new
definitions and tests in this bill come with zero judicial
precedent, making it very unclear how these new standards would
be applied by the courts. The current securities law framework
has served us well for nearly a century, evolving with various
technological innovations in the industry. There is simply no
good reason to throw all of that away in favor of a complicated
new framework that caters to a single industry that refuses to
follow the rules.
We agree with federal regulators and the GAO who have
stated that there are discrete gaps in the current federal
regulatory regime regarding digital assets.\5\ This includes
providing spot market authority for the CFTC, ensuring the SEC
has extraterritorial reach overseas, and providing regulators
with oversight of affiliates and subsidiaries of digital asset
businesses. Such authorities could have helped the SEC act
against FTX, or its affiliated Alameda Research (which was
functioning as an unregistered hedge fund) before its collapse
and would provide similar oversight as authorities banking
regulators have to examine affiliates and subsidiaries of most
banks. We believe that we should be focusing on these discrete
issues and leveraging the current securities law framework
rather than throwing it out the window.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\See FSOC, Report on Digital Asset Financial Stability Risks and
Regulation (Oct. 3, 2022); U.S. Government Accountability Office,
Blockchain in Finance: Legislative and Regulatory Actions Are Needed to
Ensure Comprehensive Oversight of Crypto Assets (Jun. 22, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While H.R. 4763 creates a great deal of confusion, a few
things are crystal clear. First, this bill would exempt digital
assets from several consumer, investor, and market protections
that otherwise currently apply to them under existing
securities laws. Specifically, under the bill, it is likely
that most digital assets would be considered commodities soon
after they are issued on any of the current blockchains. By
shifting a substantial portion of the digital assets market to
the commodities regime, the bill removes several critical
protections that apply to securities and not commodities.
Simply put, the CFTC regulatory framework was created for and
operates for sophisticated and large institutional traders
while SEC's framework governs the issuance of investment
products meant for everyday retail investors and retirees. This
bill also does not require the structural separation that is
currently in place under securities laws of broker/dealers,
exchanges, and clearing houses to prevent conflicts of
interest. Furthermore, the Investment Company Act and the
Investment Advisers Act--regulations designed to minimize
conflicts of interest that can arise in complex operations--
would not apply to digital commodities in this bill.\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Section 301(c) of the bill provides that the definition of the
term ``security'' in the Investment Advisers Act ``does not include a
digital commodity or a permitted payment stablecoin.'' Similarly,
Section 301(d) provides that the definition of the term ``security'' in
the Investment Company Act ``does not include a digital commodity or a
permitted payment stablecoin.'' H.R. 4763.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Second, this bill would allow the commingling of funds,
which was a major factor in the fall of FTX. Specifically,
while this bill establishes restrictions on the commingling of
consumer funds by digital asset broker/dealers, it creates a
procedure where consumers can waive this protection. It is not
difficult to imagine crypto exchanges or trading facilities
encouraging this waiver either as part of the service agreement
(not unlike the forced arbitration clauses that exist today) or
making it easy for consumers or investors to check a box
without realizing that doing so gives the trading firm ability
to commingle customer assets with that of the firm or its
affiliated hedge funds. When FTX collapsed in November 2022,
one of the shocking discoveries in the aftermath was that FTX
had been commingling customer funds to make undisclosed
investments and trade against its own customers. When the dust
had settled, over one million users were owed $8.7 billion in
bankruptcy proceedings.\7\ The collapse of FTX demonstrated the
scale of harm possible when commingling occurs, and H.R. 4763
would legitimize this practice.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\FTX Bankruptcy Team Says the Exchange Owed Customers $8.7B,
CoinDesk (June 26, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Third, H.R. 4763 would create new opportunities for
regulatory arbitrage. Specifically, the bill's definition of
``digital asset'' is overly broad, raising the possibility that
traditional financial instruments could get swept into the
lighter touch regulatory regime designed for digital assets
under this bill. Private industry may be incentivized to
structure assets and asset pools to avoid the specific
categories excluded from the definition.
Fourth, H.R. 4763 not only fails to provide any new funding
for the SEC, which would be responsible for implementing much
of this highly complicated new regime, but also rescinds $150
million from the SEC's Reserve Fund, a fund created by Dodd-
Frank to fund long term IT projects or to respond to unforeseen
events, like the 2010 Flash Crash and the pandemic. This bill
takes these funds and proposes $120 million in resources to the
CFTC over a 5-year period, which is significantly less than the
amount CFTC Chairman Rostin Behnam said would be needed.\8\ In
addition, the bill does not provide for ongoing funding for the
agency, such as fees that could be levied on crypto firms. At
the same time, Republicans are proposing cuts to these
agencies' budgets through the appropriations process. Earlier
this year, President Joe Biden requested that Congress provide
$411 million for the CFTC in fiscal year (FY) 2024, a 12.6%
increase from the FY 2023 enacted level\9\ and $2.436 billion
for the SEC.\10\ However, House Republicans have advanced steep
budget cuts through the Default on America Act.\11\ Their plan
revealed that Republicans would impose a 22% cut across the
board for non-defense spending.\12\ The Financial Services and
General Government Appropriations bill, released by the House
Appropriations Committee earlier this year, prohibits the
implementation of certain SEC rules and cuts the SEC's budget
by 8% from FY 2023.\13\ Chair Gensler has explained that ``that
funding level may not be enough to address staffing and
technological needs.''\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\House Ag Committee looks at digital assets regulatory bill, Dems
ask how to pay for it, CoinTelegraph (June 6, 2023).
\9\PL 117-328.
\10\Gensler Cheers $2.4B Funding Proposal for SEC in Biden Budget,
Blockworks (Mar. 31, 2023).
\11\Kevin McCarthy Speaker of the House, House GOP Leadership
Statement on the House GOP Plan to Address the Debt Ceiling (Apr. 19,
2023).
\12\The White House, State Fact Sheets: MAGA House Republicans'
Default on America Act Would Have Devastating Impacts Across America
(May 2, 2023).
\13\Womack Remarks at FY24 Financial Services and General
Government Markup, House Committee on Appropriations (June 22, 2023).
\14\SEC's Gensler Calls CFTC `Not As Robust' On Crypto, Law360
(July 19, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While Republicans accepted a few amendments, they rejected
critical changes Democrats proposed including:
Ranking Member Waters' amendment no. 3,
which would preserve the current securities law
framework and offer targeted and meaningful fixes to
address discrete issues in order to better protect
investors in the digital assets ecosystem. These narrow
fixes respond to recommendations from the FSOC to
provide the CFTC with spot market authority over
digital assets not deemed securities by the SEC and
provide the SEC with extraterritorial jurisdiction and
oversight into affiliates. This amendment also directs
the SEC to issue a report and provide testimony to
Congress on whether broader changes to the SEC's
oversight of digital assets are necessary.
Rep. Lynch's amendment no. 11, which would
strike Section 311 of the bill, ``Treatment of custody
activities by banking institutions.'' This section
conflicts with the SEC's SAB 121 which directs banks
and public companies to list digital assets as
liabilities on their balance sheets.
Rep. Lynch's amendment no. 13, which would
direct the SEC, CFTC, and CFPB to issue rules to ensure
investor and consumer protections for digital assets
that exist for securities and commodities.
Rep. Foster's amendment no. 1, which would
direct FinCEN to establish a method for the application
and issuance of a crypto license for individuals with
operational control over a digital wallet.
Rep. Sherman's amendment, which would strike
the bill and designates all digital assets and related
derivatives to be considered securities and subject to
the jurisdiction of the SEC, including all digital
asset exchanges as securities exchanges and subject to
the full jurisdiction of the SEC.
Rep. Lynch's amendment, which would
authorize such funding as may be necessary for the CFTC
and the SEC to execute this bill.
Rep. Pressley's amendment, which was
withdrawn, but would prevent Members of Congress, their
employees, and other federal employees from using non-
public information obtained through their official
positions for personal benefit, such as in stock market
trading.\15\ The STOCK Act provides for greater
transparency by requiring Congress and federal
employees to report certain investment activities,
while preventing insider trading, strengthening ethics,
and strengthening public trust. Rep. Pressley's
proposal would treat digital assets as the same for the
purposes of the STOCK Act. Republicans indicated an
interest in working with Democrats on this proposal.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Public Law No. 112-105, 112th Congress (2011-2012); see also
STOCK Act: Meaning, Overview, Criticisms, Investopedia (Aug. 31, 2022).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rep. Lynch's amendment, which would strike
part of Section 306 ``Requirements of Digital Asset
Brokers and Digital Asset Dealers,'' to protect
consumers from being directed to waive guardrails
around commingling their funds with the funds of the
entity.
Rep. Green amendment, no. 14,\16\ which was
withdrawn with the commitment that Rep. Hill would work
with him on whistleblower protections in the
legislation. His amendment would confirm that nothing
in the bill would prevent the SEC or CFTC from going
after bad actors in the digital asset ecosystem, even
in relation to entities filing a notice of intent to
register. This amendment also ensures that the SEC can
pursue enforcement in illegal market activities, such
as price manipulation, insider trading, Ponzi schemes,
fraud, wash trading, common ownership of tokens trading
on an exchange against consumers, and prop trading/
affiliated trading.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\HFSC, Rep. Green Amendment No. 14 to H.R. 4763 (July 26, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Finally, the following groups are opposed to the
legislation: American Association for Justice, American
Economic Liberties Project, Americans for Financial Reform,
Center for American Progress, Center for Responsible Lending,
Consumer Action, Consumer Federation of America, Consumer
Reports, Demand Progress, Institute for Agriculture and Trade
Policy, National Consumer Law Center (on behalf of its low-
income clients), National Community Reinvestment Coalition,
North American Securities Administrators Association, Open
Markets Institute, Public Citizen, Revolving Door Project, Rise
Economy (formerly California Reinvestment Coalition), Strong
Economy for All Coalition, Texas Appleseed, 20/20 Vision,
Woodstock Institute.
For these reasons, we strongly oppose H.R. 4763.
Sincerely,
Maxine Waters,
Ranking Member.
Nydia M. Velazquez,
David Scott,
Al Green,
Bill Foster,
Juan Vargas,
Brad Sherman,
Stephen F. Lynch,
Emanuel Cleaver, II,
Joyce Beatty,
Vicente Gonzalez,
Sean Casten,
Rashida Tlaib,
Nikema Williams,
Ayanna Pressley,
Sylvia R. Garcia,
Members of Congess.