Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 4766]
The Committee on Financial Services, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 4766) to provide for the regulation of payment
stablecoins, and for other purposes, having considered the
same, reports favorably thereon with an amendment and
recommends that the bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 11
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 11
Related Hearings................................................. 16
Committee Consideration.......................................... 17
Committee Votes.................................................. 17
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 23
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 23
Congressional Budget Office Estimates............................ 23
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures 23
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 23
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 23
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 23
Earmark Identification........................................... 23
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 24
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 24
Minority Views................................................... 28
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Clarity for Payment Stablecoins Act of
2023''.
SEC. 2. DEFINITIONS.
In this Act:
(1) Bank secrecy act.--The term ``Bank Secrecy Act'' means--
(A) section 21 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act
(12 U.S.C. 1829b);
(B) chapter 2 of title I of Public Law 91-508 (12
U.S.C. 1951 et seq.); and
(C) subchapter II of chapter 53 of title 31, United
States Code.
(2) Board.--The term ``Board'' means the Board of Governors
of the Federal Reserve System.
(3) Comptroller.--The term ``Comptroller'' means the
Comptroller of the Currency.
(4) Corporation.--The term ``Corporation'' means the Federal
Deposit Insurance Corporation.
(5) Digital asset.--The term ``digital asset'' means any
digital representation of value which is recorded on a
cryptographically-secured distributed ledger.
(6) Distributed ledger.--The term ``distributed ledger''
means technology where data is shared across a network that
creates a public digital ledger of verified transactions or
information among network participants and the data is linked
using cryptography to maintain the integrity of the public
ledger and execute other functions.
(7) Federal qualified nonbank stablecoin issuer.--The term
``Federal qualified nonbank stablecoin issuer'' means a nonbank
entity approved by the primary Federal payment stablecoin
regulator, pursuant to section 5, to issue payment stablecoins.
(8) Institution-affiliated party.--With respect to a
permitted payment stablecoin issuer, the term ``institution-
affiliated party'' means any director, officer, employee, or
person in control of, or agent for, the permitted payment
stablecoin issuer.
(9) Insured depository institution.--The term ``insured
depository institution'' means--
(A) an insured depository institution, as defined in
section 3 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12
U.S.C. 1813); and
(B) an insured credit union, as defined in section
101 of the Federal Credit Union Act (12 U.S.C. 1752).
(10) Monetary value.--The term ``monetary value'' means a
national currency or deposit (as defined under Section 3 of the
Federal Deposit Insurance Act) denominated in a national
currency.
(11) National currency.--The term ``national currency'' means
a Federal Reserve note, (as the term is used in the first
undesignated paragraph of section 16 of the Federal Reserve Act
(12 U.S.C. 411)), money issued by a central bank, and money
issued by an intergovernmental organization pursuant to an
agreement by one or more governments.
(12) Nonbank entity.--The term ``nonbank entity'' means a
person that is not an insured depository institution or
subsidiary of an insured depository institution.
(13) Payment stablecoin.--The term ``payment stablecoin''
means a digital asset--
(A) that is or is designed to be used as a means of
payment or settlement;
(B) the issuer of which--
(i) is obligated to convert, redeem, or
repurchase for a fixed amount of monetary
value; and
(ii) represents will maintain or creates the
reasonable expectation that it will maintain a
stable value relative to the value of a fixed
amount of monetary value; and
(C) that is not--
(i) a national currency; or
(ii) a security issued by an investment
company registered under section 8(a) of the
Investment Company Act of 1940 (15 U.S.C. 80a-
8(a)).
(14) Permitted payment stablecoin issuer.--The term
``permitted payment stablecoin issuer'' means--
(A) a subsidiary of an insured depository institution
that has been approved to issue payment stablecoins
under section 5;
(B) a Federal qualified nonbank payment stablecoin
issuer that has been approved to issue payment
stablecoins under section 5; or
(C) a State qualified payment stablecoin issuer.
(15) Person.--The term ``person'' means an individual,
partnership, company, corporation, association (incorporated or
unincorporated), trust, estate, cooperative organization, or
other entity.
(16) Primary federal payment stablecoin regulator.--
(A) In general.--The term ``primary Federal payment
stablecoin regulator'' means--
(i) with respect to an insured depository
institution (other than an insured credit
union) or a subsidiary of an insured depository
institution (other than an insured credit
union), the appropriate Federal banking agency
of such insured depository institution (as
defined under section 3 of the Federal Deposit
Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1813));
(ii) with respect to an insured credit union
or a subsidiary of an insured credit union, the
National Credit Union Administration;
(iii) with respect to a Federal qualified
nonbank payment stablecoin issuer that is not a
national bank, the Board; and
(iv) with respect to any entity chartered by
the Comptroller, the Comptroller.
(B) Primary federal payment stablecoin regulators.--
The term ``primary Federal payment stablecoin
regulators'' means the Comptroller, the Board, the
Corporation, and the National Credit Union
Administration.
(17) Registered public accounting firm.--The term
``registered public accounting firm'' has the meaning given
that term under section 2 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (15
U.S.C. 7201).
(18) State.--The term ``State'' means each of the several
States, the District of Columbia, and each territory of the
United States.
(19) State qualified payment stablecoin issuer.--The term
``State qualified payment stablecoin issuer'' means an entity
that--
(A) is legally established and approved to issue
payment stablecoins by a State payment stablecoin
regulator; and
(B) issues a payment stablecoin in compliance with
the requirements under section 4.
(20) State payment stablecoin regulator.--The term ``State
payment stablecoin regulator'' means a State agency that has
primary regulatory and supervisory authority in such State over
entities that issue payment stablecoins.
(21) Subsidiary of an insured credit union.--With respect to
an insured credit union, the term ``subsidiary of an insured
credit union'' means--
(A) an organization providing services to the insured
credit union that are associated with the routine
operations of credit unions, as described under section
107(7)(I) of the Federal Credit Union Act (12 U.S.C.
1757(7)(I)); and
(B) a credit union service organization, as such term
is used under part 712 of title 12, Code of Federal
Regulations, with respect to which the insured credit
union has an ownership interest or to which the insured
credit union has extended a loan.
SEC. 3. LIMITATION ON WHO MAY ISSUE A PAYMENT STABLECOIN.
It shall be unlawful for any person other than a permitted payment
stablecoin issuer to issue a payment stablecoin for use by any person
in the United States.
SEC. 4. REQUIREMENTS FOR ISSUING PAYMENT STABLECOINS.
(a) Standards for the Issuance of Payment Stablecoins.--
(1) In general.--Permitted payment stablecoin issuers shall--
(A) maintain reserves backing the issuer's payment
stablecoins outstanding on an at least one to one
basis, with reserves comprising--
(i) United States coins and currency
(including Federal reserve notes);
(ii) funds held as insured demand deposits or
insured shares at insured depository
institutions, subject to limitations
established by the Corporation and the National
Credit Union Administration, respectively, to
address safety and soundness risks of such
insured depository institutions;
(iii) Treasury bills with a maturity of 90
days or less;
(iv) repurchase agreements with a maturity of
7 days or less that are backed by Treasury
bills with a maturity of 90 days or less; or
(v) central bank reserve deposits;
(B) publicly disclose the issuer's redemption policy;
(C) establish procedures for timely redemption of
outstanding payment stablecoins; and
(D) publish the monthly composition of the issuer's
reserves on the website of the issuer, containing--
(i) the total number of outstanding payment
stablecoins issued by the issuer; and
(ii) the amount and composition of the
reserves described under subparagraph (A).
(2) Prohibition on rehypothecation.--Reserves described under
paragraph (1)(A) may not be pledged, rehypothecated, or reused,
except for the purpose of creating liquidity to meet reasonable
expectations of requests to redeem payment stablecoins, such
that reserves in the form of Treasury bills may be pledged as
collateral for repurchase agreements with a maturity of 90 days
or less, provided that either--
(A) the repurchase agreements are cleared by a
central clearing counterparty that is approved by the
primary Federal payment stablecoin regulator; or
(B) the permitted payment stablecoin issuer receives
the prior approval of the primary Federal payment
stablecoin regulator.
(3) Monthly certification; examination of reports by
registered public accounting firm.--
(A) In general.--A permitted payment stablecoin
issuer shall, each month, have the information
disclosed in the previous month-end report required
under paragraph (1)(D) examined by a registered public
accounting firm.
(B) Certification.--Each month, the Chief Executive
Officer and Chief Financial Officer of a permitted
payment stablecoin issuer shall submit an certification
as to the accuracy of the monthly report to--
(i) the primary Federal payment stablecoin
regulator; or
(ii) in the case of a State qualified payment
stablecoin issuer, to the State payment
stablecoin regulator.
(C) Criminal penalty.--Any person who submits a
certification required under subparagraph (B) knowing
that such certification is false shall be subject to
the criminal penalties set forth under section 1350(c)
of title 18, United States Code.
(4) Capital, liquidity, and risk management requirements.--
The primary Federal payment stablecoin regulators shall,
jointly, issue--
(A) capital requirements applicable to permitted
payment stablecoin issuers, which may not exceed what
is sufficient to ensure the permitted payment
stablecoin issuer's ongoing operations;
(B) liquidity requirements applicable to permitted
payment stablecoin issuers, which may not exceed what
is sufficient to ensure the financial integrity of the
permitted payment stablecoin issuer and the ability of
the issuer to meet the financial obligations of the
issuer, including redemptions; and
(C) risk management requirements applicable to
permitted payment stablecoin issuers, tailored to the
business model and risk profile of the permitted
payment stablecoin issuer.
(5) Treatment under the bank secrecy act.--A permitted
payment stablecoin issuer shall be treated as a financial
institution for purposes of the Bank Secrecy Act.
(6) Limitation on activities.--A permitted payment stablecoin
issuer may only issue payment stablecoins, redeem payment
stablecoins, manage related reserves (including purchasing and
holding reserve assets), provide custodial or safekeeping
services for payment stablecoins or private keys of payment
stablecoins, and undertake other functions that directly
support the work of issuing and redeeming payment stablecoins.
(b) Rulemaking.--
(1) In general.--The primary Federal payment stablecoin
regulators may issue such orders and regulations as may be
necessary to administer and carry out the requirements of this
section, including to establish conditions, and to prevent
evasions thereof.
(2) Joint issuance of regulation.--All regulations issued to
carry out this section shall be issued jointly by the primary
Federal payment stablecoin regulators.
(3) Rulemaking deadline.--Not later than the end of the 180-
day period beginning on the date of enactment of this Act, the
Federal payment stablecoin regulators shall issue regulations
to carry out this section.
SEC. 5. APPROVAL OF SUBSIDIARIES OF INSURED DEPOSITORY INSTITUTIONS AND
FEDERAL QUALIFIED NONBANK PAYMENT STABLECOIN
ISSUERS.
(a) In General.--
(1) Application.--
(A) In general.--Any insured depository institution
that seeks to issue payment stablecoins through a
subsidiary and any nonbank entity (other than a State
qualified payment stablecoin issuer) that seeks to
issue payment stablecoins shall file an application
with the primary Federal payment stablecoin regulator.
(B) Timing.--With respect to an application filed
under this paragraph, the primary Federal payment
stablecoin regulator shall inform the applicant whether
the applicant has submitted a complete application
within 45 days of receiving the application.
(C) Completion of application.--With respect to an
application filed under this paragraph, once the
primary Federal payment stablecoin regulator has
informed the applicant that the application is
complete, such application shall be deemed to be
complete unless the primary Federal payment stablecoin
regulator determines that a significant change in
circumstances requires otherwise.
(2) Evaluation of applications.--A complete application
received under paragraph (1) shall be evaluated by the primary
Federal payment stablecoin regulator using the factors
described in paragraph (3).
(3) Factors to be considered.--The factors described in this
paragraph are the following:
(A) The ability of the applicant (or, in the case of
an applicant that is an insured depository institution,
the subsidiary of the applicant), based on the
financial condition and resources, to meet the
requirements set forth in section 4.
(B) The general character and fitness of the
management of the applicant.
(C) The risks presented by the applicant and benefits
provided to consumers.
(4) Timing for decision; grounds for denial.--
(A) Timing.--The primary Federal payment stablecoin
regulator shall render a decision on an application no
later than 120 days after informing the applicant that
the application is complete.
(B) Deni
Purpose and Summary
Introduced on July 20, 2023, by Representative Patrick
McHenry, H.R. 4766, the Clarity for Payment Stablecoins Act of
2023, provides a clear federal regulatory framework for issuing
payment stablecoins intended to be used as a means of payment.
The bill balances customer protection with innovation by
establishing a framework that allows new entrants into the
marketplace.
Background and Need for Legislation
Stablecoins are a digital asset designed to offer price
stability to enable them to be used in a similar manner to
currency. Stablecoins seek to be less volatile than other
digital assets by being pegged to another asset's value. Today,
stablecoins are primarily used in the United States to
facilitate trading, lending, or borrowing of other digital
assets, predominantly on or through digital asset trading
platforms. Stablecoins provide protection for individuals
because they allow individuals to enter and exit the digital
asset markets efficiently.
Currently, there is no federal regulatory framework for
stablecoin issuers. Most states have yet to create regulatory
frameworks for digital asset businesses, forcing potential
stablecoin issuers to leverage existing state money transmitter
statutes. But most state money transmitter statutes were not
crafted to address digital asset businesses, including payment
stablecoin issuers and related activities. New York is an
example of one state that has established a strong regulatory
framework specific to firms engaged in virtual currency
activities. The framework sets forth baseline requirements
focused on the backing and redeemability of the payment
stablecoin, reserves, and attestations. New York State
Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) evaluates a range of
additional risks prior to authorizing a regulated virtual
currency entity to issue a stablecoin, including but not
limited to cybersecurity; Bank Secrecy Act/anti-money-
laundering (BSA/AML) and sanctions compliance; consumer
protection; and safety and soundness of the issuing entity,
among others. House Financial Services Committee (Committee)
Republicans believe that while payment stablecoins hold promise
as a potential cornerstone of a modern payment system, they
must be issued under a clear regulatory framework.
Committee Republicans are not alone in recognizing the
tremendous potential for payment stablecoins and the need for a
federal regulatory framework. In November 2021, the President's
Working Group on Financial Markets, the Federal Deposit
Insurance Corporation, and the Office of the Comptroller of the
Currency released its Report on Stablecoins (PWG Report), which
included a proposed federal regulatory framework to address
existing and potential risks of stablecoins. The PWG Report
identified several potential risks and benefits while
recommending that Congress act promptly to enact legislation
ensuring stablecoins are subject to a federal prudential
regulatory framework. Specifically, the PWG Report recommended
that Congress enact legislation requiring stablecoins to be
issued only by insured depository institutions.
During the 117th Congress, following the PWG Report's
release, the Committee began developing legislation to
establish a federal framework for issuing payment stablecoins
for both banks and nonbanks. During this process, Committee
Republicans developed a framework, hosted numerous roundtables,
and participated in two hearings focused on the aspects of
payment stablecoin legislation.
At a hearing in December 2021, Paxos's CEO and Co-Founder,
Charles Cascarilla, highlighted existing issues within the
United States' payment system and potential benefits of
stablecoins:
``At any given time, there are trillions of dollars'
worth of capital held up in transactions that have not
yet settled. Remittance recipients and other payees
don't have access to their funds. Money that could help
others or be productively deployed is unnecessarily
trapped in limbo. Whole industries have developed to
take advantage of these delays, often to the detriment
of those who can least afford it. How many overdraft
fees could have been avoided if people received their
money immediately after it was sent? [. . .]Digital
assets, and the blockchains they're built on, offer a
better alternative.''
During the same hearing, Stellar Development Foundation CEO
and Executive Director, Denelle Dixon, highlighted a pilot
program that Money Gram International was testing on the
Stellar network to demonstrate that stablecoins are actively
solving the issues Mr. Cascarilla raised in his testimony.
Several witnesses also highlighted the disparities between the
United States' approach to regulation compared to other
jurisdictions.
At a hearing in February 2022, the Department of the
Treasury (Treasury) also highlighted the risks of Congress not
enacting a comprehensive federal regulatory framework for
payment stablecoin issuers. The Under Secretary of the Treasury
for Domestic Finance, Nellie Liang, emphasized that:
``Stablecoins are not subject to standards to address
concerns about run risk, payment system risk, or
concentration of economic power. Some of the largest
stablecoin issuers operate with limited regulatory
oversight, raising significant questions about whether
these stablecoins are adequately backed and other
aspects of their operations. The regulatory frameworks
that apply to stablecoin issuers and service providers
are inconsistent, creating opportunities for regulatory
arbitrage and uncertainty among stablecoin users.''
The Financial Stability Oversight Council (FSOC) also
recognizes the need for legislation. At a hearing in May 2022,
Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen testified before the Committee
in her capacity as Chair of FSOC and underscored the urgency of
stablecoin legislation, explaining that FSOC is ``eager to work
with [the Committee] to ensure that payment stablecoins and
their arrangements are subject to a federal prudential
framework on a consistent and comprehensive basis.'' FSOC
emphasized this point in its October 2022 Report on Digital
Asset Financial Stability Risks and Regulation, recommending
that ``Congress pass legislation that would create a
comprehensive federal prudential framework for stablecoin
issuers that also addresses the associated market integrity,
investor and consumer protection, and payment system risks.''
During the 118th Congress, the Committee held three
hearings and several member roundtables focused on payment
stablecoins. Through these hearings and roundtables, the
Committee received feedback and input from Republican and
Democratic members. This feedback resulted in the introduction
of H.R. 4766, the Clarity for Payment Stablecoins Act of 2023.
The Clarity for Payment Stablecoins Act sets minimum
standards for a potential issuer to be authorized to issue
payment stablecoins in the United States. The bill includes
multiple pathways--not just through banks--for payment
stablecoin issuers to obtain approval to issue a payment
stablecoin. It is important for there to be pathways for
nonbanks to obtain approval. Former Chief Policy Officer at the
Blockchain Association, Jake Chervinsky, testified before the
Committee on April 19, 2023, and explained, ``forcing all
stablecoin issuers to obtain bank charters would severely
restrict innovation without any attendant regulatory benefit,
since stablecoins issued by properly regulated non-bank firms
will be equally safe and sound as those issued by banks.''
The bill provides three pathways to obtain Federal approval
to issue payment stablecoins. First, banks and credit unions
may obtain approval from their appropriate Federal banking
agency or the National Credit Union Administration Board
(NCUA), as appropriate, to issue a payment stablecoin through a
subsidiary. Second, non-bank entities chartered by the Office
of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) may obtain approval
from the OCC to issue a payment stablecoin. Third, non-banks,
non-OCC chartered entities, may obtain approval from the
Federal Reserve to issue a payment stablecoin.
In addition, the bill provides a state pathway for
obtaining approval to issue payment stablecoins. Given that
some states have enacted robust regulatory frameworks for
payment stablecoins, and others may in the future, the Clarity
for Payment Stablecoins Act of 2023 preserves a state pathway.
During a hearing before the Committee on June 13, 2023, the Co-
Founder, Chairman, and CEO of Circle, Jeremy Allaire, explained
that ``in the U.S., the states have been the laboratory of
fintech innovation for the past 25 years, and we should
celebrate that fact. Indeed, the innovations that we are
addressing today became possible only through our broad-based
state regulatory system.'' NYDFS Superintendent Adrienne Harris
likewise testified that:
``The best path forward is to build on the well-
established dual banking regulatory system--where state
and federal regulators share supervisory and regulatory
authority. The dual banking system takes advantage of
the comparative strengths of federal and state
regulators. Federal regulators are able to
comprehensively address macroprudential considerations
and establish foundational consumer and market
protections. Meanwhile, states can act more nimbly to
respond to industry developments and support
responsible innovation given their ability to modernize
regulations more quickly and leverage their more
immediate understanding of consumer needs.''
The Clarity for Payment Stablecoins Act preserves the state
pathway for payment stablecoin issuers by emulating core
aspects of the United States' dual-banking system. Under the
state pathway, an entity that has received approval from a
state agency with regulatory and supervisory authority over
payment stablecoin issuers may issue payment stablecoins
provided that it meets certain minimum standards established in
the bill. These ``state qualified payment stablecoin issuers''
are subject to oversight by the Federal Reserve to ensure that
they comply with the minimum standards.
As the PWG report, testimonies from Secretary Yellen and
Undersecretary Liang, and the testimonies of several other
witnesses have made clear, there is a need for uniform
standards for payment stablecoin issuers in the United States.
The Clarity for Payment Stablecoins Act addresses this need by
establishing requirements for reserves, redemption,
attestations, and examinations, as well as minimum standards
for capital, liquidity, and risk management. The bill further
establishes, at a minimum, that payment stablecoin issuers must
disclose and submit, at least monthly, a certification
regarding the reserves. The Committee encourages further
development in this area to promote greater transparency on
reserves, including using developing technology such as zero
knowledge proofs, which may eventually allow for real-time
verification of reserves.
In the absence of legislation and clear jurisdictional
boundaries, there will continue to be substantial regulatory
uncertainty. First, under the status-quo, payment stablecoins
and activities involving payment stablecoins may fall under the
jurisdiction of several federal regulators depending on the
composition of the stablecoin reserve assets and the range of
activities in which an issuer engages. For example, the
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Chairman Gary Gensler
has asserted that ``stablecoins may have attributes of
investment contracts,'' which would subject stablecoins to SEC
oversight. Yet, Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)
Chairman Rostin Benham has asserted that stablecoins are
commodities under existing law and regulation, thereby
subjecting them to CFTC oversight. As Columbia Business School
Adjunct Professor Austin Campbell testified in an April 19,
2023, Committee hearing:
``Someone attempting to launch or manage a stablecoin
in the United States doesn't know if they can issue on
a public blockchain, doesn't know if they can get
banking relationships, and doesn't know if they have to
answer to a state financial regulator, a federal
banking regulator, or the SEC, who all often have
mutually contradictory answers as to
responsibilities.''
The Clarity of Payment Stablecoins Act resolves this
uncertainty by establishing a clear prudential regulatory
framework for payment stablecoins. The Clarity for Payment
Stablecoins Act also addresses the market confusion and
disruption that resulted from the SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin
No. 121 (SAB 121). SAB 121 upends precedent regarding the
accounting treatment of custodial assets for banks and makes it
much more difficult for financial institutions to provide
custodial services for digital assets, including payment
stablecoins, by requiring certain entities to record on their
balance sheet a liability and a corresponding asset at the fair
value of the digital assets that they are safeguarding and
includes certain disclosure requirements. As Davis Polk &
Wardwell LLP Partner Zachary Zweihorn testified in an April 27,
2023, Committee hearing, ``the interaction of SAB 121 and the
broker-dealer capital rules also make broker-dealer custody of
digital assets economically infeasible--similar to concerns
raised with regard to custody by banks.'' The Clarity for
Payment Stablecoins Act resolves this market disruption by
prohibiting Federal agencies from implementing SAB 121 in its
current form.
As Treasury Under Secretary Liang testified, ``if
stablecoins are backed by high-quality assets, their risk is
quite low, and they can form a building block--a cornerstone--
of a payment system.'' The Clarity for Payment Stablecoins Act
establishes robust standards that will ensure the integrity of
payment stablecoin in the U.S. This comprehensive framework
will enable further development of stablecoin uses, many of
which will have great benefit for our financial system.
RELATED HEARINGS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearings were used to develop H.R. 4766:
118th Congress
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on March
8, 2023, titled ``The Federal Reserve's Semi-Annual Monetary
Policy Report.''
The Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology
and Inclusion of the Committee on Financial Services held a
hearing on March 9, 2023, titled ``Coincidence or Coordinated?
The Administration's Attack on the Digital Asset Ecosystem.''
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on April
18, 2023, titled ``Oversight of the Securities and Exchange
Commission.''
The Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology
and Inclusion of the Committee on Financial Services held a
hearing on April 19, 2023, titled ``Understanding Stablecoins'
Role in Payments and the Need for Legislation.''
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on May
16, 2023, titled ``Oversight of Prudential Regulators.''
The Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology
and Inclusion of the Committee on Financial Services held a
hearing on May 18, 2023, titled ``Putting the `Stable' in
`Stablecoins:' How Legislation Will Help Stablecoins Achieve
Their Promise.''
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on June
13, 2023, titled ``The Future of Digital Assets: Providing
Clarity for the Digital Asset Ecosystem.''
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on June
21, 2023, titled ``The Federal Reserve's Semi-Annual Monetary
Policy Report.''
117th Congress
The Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations held a
hearing on June 30, 2021, titled ``Will the Crypto Frenzy Lead
to Financial Independence and Early Retirement or Financial
Ruin?''
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
December 8, 2021, titled ``Digital Assets and the Future of
Finance: Understanding the Challenges and Benefits of Financial
Innovation in the United States.''
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
February 8, 2022, titled ``Digital Assets and the Future of
Finance: The President's Working Group on Financial Markets'
Report on Stablecoins.''
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on March
2, 2022, titled ``Monetary Policy and the State of the
Economy.''
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on May
26, 2022, titled ``Digital Assets and the Future of Finance:
Examining the Benefits and Risks of a U.S. Central Bank Digital
Currency.''
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on June
23, 2022, titled ``Monetary Policy and the State of the
Economy.''
116th Congress
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on July
27, 2019, titled ``Examining Facebook's Proposed Cryptocurrency
and Its Impact on Consumers, Investors, and the American
Financial System.''
The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
October 23, 2019, titled ``An Examination of Facebook and Its
Impact on the Financial Services and Housing Sectors.''
115th Congress
The Subcommittee on Capital Markets held a hearing on March
14, 2018, titled ``Examining the Cryptocurrencies and ICO
Markets.''
The Subcommittee on Monetary and Trade held a hearing on
July 18, 2018, titled ``The Future of Money: Digital
Currency.''
Committee Consideration
The Committee on Financial Services met in open session on
July 27, 2023, and ordered H.R. 4766 to be reported favorably
to the House as amended by a recorded vote of 34 ayes to 16
nays (Record vote no. FC-86), a quorum being present. Before
the question was called to order the bill favorably reported,
the Committee adopted an amendment in the nature of a
substitute offered by Mr. McHenry by a recorded vote of 34 ayes
to 16 nays (Record vote no. FC-85).
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires the Committee to list the record votes
on the order to report legislation and amendments thereto. H.R.
4766 was ordered reported favorably to the House as amended by
a recorded vote of 34 ayes to 16 nays (Record vote no. FC-86),
a quorum being present.
An amendment offered by Mr. Foster, no. 1, was not agreed
to by a recorded vote of 21 ayes to 28 nays, a quorum being
present (Record vote no. FC-82).
An amendment offered by Mrs. Beatty, no. 4, was not agreed
to by a recorded vote of 21 ayes to 29 nays, a quorum being
present (Record vote no. FC-83).
An amendment by Mr. Sherman, no. 5, was not agreed to by a
recorded vote of 16 ayes to 34 nays, a quorum being present
(Record vote no. FC-84).
COMMITTEE OVERISGHT FINDINGS
Pursuant to clause 3(c) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the findings and recommendations of
the Committee, based on oversight activities under clause
2(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives,
are incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
PERFORMANCE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the goal of H.R. 4766 is to ensure a
clear regulatory framework for the issuance of payment
stablecoins that are designed to be used as a means of payment,
while protecting customers and fostering innovation by
establishing a clear framework to allow new entrants into the
marketplace.
CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE ESTIMATES
The Committee has requested but not received a cost
estimate from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office.
However, pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee will adopt as its own the cost estimate by the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office once it has been
prepared.
NEW BUDGET AUTHORITY, ENTITLEMENT AUTHORITY, AND TAX EXPENDITURES
The Committee has requested but not received an estimate
from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office. However,
pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, once an estimate has been prepared by
the Director of the Congressional Budget Office, as required by
section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1973, the
Committee will adopt as its own the estimate of new budget
authority, entitlement authority, or tax expenditures or
revenues contained in the cost estimate.
FEDERAL MANDATES STATEMENT
The Committee has requested but not received an estimate
from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office of the
Federal mandates pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act. The Committee will adopt the estimate once
it has been prepared by the Director.
ADVISORY COMMITTEE STATEMENT
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
APPLICABILITY TO LEGISLATIVE BRANCH
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
EARMARK IDENTIFICATION
With respect to clause 9 of rule XXI of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee has carefully reviewed
the provisions of the bill and states that the provisions of
the bill do not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits within the meaning of the
rule.
DUPLICATION OF FEDERAL PROGRAMS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee states that no
provision of the bill establishes or reauthorizes a program of
the Federal Government known to be duplicative of another
Federal program, including any program that was included in a
report to Congress pursuant to section 21 of the Public Law
111-139 or the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance.
SECTION-BY-SECTION ANALYSIS OF THE LEGISLATION
Section 1. Short title
This section states H.R. 4766 is the ``Clarity for Payment
Stablecoins Act of 2023.''
Section 2. Definitions
Section 2 defines various terms, including digital asset,
distributed ledger, payment stablecoin, permitted payment
stablecoin issuer, and primary federal payment stablecoin
regulator, among others. A permitted payment stablecoin issuer
is one that has been approved under one of the pathways made
available under the bill.
Section 3. Limitation on who may issue a payment stablecoin
Section 3 prohibits the issuance of payment stablecoins for
use by any person in the United States by any entity other than
those approved as a permitted stablecoin issuer under the bill.
Section 4. Requirements for issuing payment stablecoins
Section 4 establishes minimum standards that all payment
stablecoin issuers must comply with, regardless of the path
that they choose. Payment stablecoin issuers must maintain
reserves on a one-to-one basis with assets comprised of coins
and currency, deposits held at insured depository institutions,
short-term Treasury bills, short-term repurchase agreements,
and central bank reserve deposits.
Such reserves may not be rehypothecated except for limited
purposes. Payment stablecoin issuers must establish and
publicly disclose policies and procedures regarding redemption.
Issuers must also publish the composition of their reserves
monthly, which must be examined monthly by a registered public
accounting firm and provide monthly certifications from the
Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer to the
primary regulator as to the accuracy of these reports.
Additionally, payment stablecoin issuers are treated as
financial institutions for purposes of the Bank Secrecy Act and
must adhere to all requirements.
This section also places limitations on the activities of a
payment stablecoin issuer and requires the primary federal
payment stablecoin regulators to issue joint rulemakings
establishing capital, liquidity, and risk management standards,
as well as other rules necessary to carry out this section.
Section 5. Approval of subsidiaries of insured depository institutions
and federal qualified nonbank issuers
Section 5 establishes a process for payment stablecoin
issuers that seek to gain approval through a primary federal
payment stablecoin regulator to issue payment stablecoins. The
bill enables depository institutions to issue a payment
stablecoin through a subsidiary that is approved by the
appropriate Federal banking agency or the NCUA, as appropriate.
Entities chartered by the OCC may issue a payment stablecoin if
approved by the OCC. Lastly, a nonbank entity may be deemed a
Federal qualified nonbank payment stablecoin issuer, if
approved by the Federal Reserve.
This section requires the primary Federal payment
stablecoin regulator to render a decision on the application
within a certain timeframe. If the primary Federal payment
stablecoin regulator fails to issue a decision within the
timeframe, the application is deemed approved. Factors that the
primary Federal payment stablecoin regulator may consider when
assessing the application include the payment stablecoin
issuer's ability to meet the standards established in Section 4
of the bill, the character and fitness of the payment
stablecoin issuer's management team, and the risks presented by
the applicant and benefits provided to consumers. The regulator
may only deny an application if it determines the activities of
the applicant would be unsafe or unsound based on these factors
and must provide a written explanation for the denial that
includes the shortcomings of the application and
recommendations on how those shortcomings could be addressed.
The payment stablecoin issuer is permitted to appeal the
denial through a process established under the bill. The
primary Federal payment stablecoin regulators must report to
Congress on payment stablecoin issuer applications that have
been pending for 6 months or more. This section shall take
effect the earlier of 18 months following enactment or 120 days
after final regulations are issued. The primary Federal payment
stablecoin regulator shall notify Congress once beginning to
process applications. Additionally, the primary Federal payment
stablecoin regulator may waive the application requirements for
12 months if the entity has an application pending.
Section 6. Supervision and enforcement with respect to subsidiaries of
insured depository institutions (IDIs) and federal qualified
nonbank stablecoin issuers
Section 6 establishes supervision and enforcement standards
for payment stablecoin issuers under the oversight of a primary
Federal payment stablecoin regulator. Subsidiaries of IDIs are
subject to supervision by the primary Federal payment
stablecoin regulator in the same manner as such IDI.
Federal qualified nonbank stablecoin issuers are required
to submit reports on financial condition and compliance with
this Act to their primary federal regulator upon request and
are subject to examinations. Both Federal qualified nonbank
payment stablecoin issuers and subsidiaries of IDIs that issue
payment stablecoins must comply with the requirements of the
Gramm-Leach Bliley Act.
The enforcement provisions are similar to the enforcement
powers under the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 U.S.C. 1818)
and provides federal payment stablecoin regulators authority to
pursue suspension and prohibition actions, cease-and-desist
actions, and civil money penalties against a payment stablecoin
issuer or institution-affiliated party of a permitted payment
stablecoin issuer if the primary Federal payment stablecoin
regulator determines that such permitted payment stablecoin
issuer or an institution-affiliated party is violating or has
violated this Act or any regulation or order issued under this
Act.
Section 7. State qualified payment stablecoin issuers
Section 7 establishes that state payment stablecoin
regulators can continue to charter and supervise state
qualified payment stablecoin issuers that meet the requirements
of section 4.
The state regulator will retain their supervisory,
examination, and enforcement authority over state qualified
payment stablecoins issuers. State regulators may enter into
memorandums of understanding with the Federal Reserve by mutual
agreement and must share information with the Federal Reserve.
The Federal Reserve has enforcement authority, as specified
in section 6, over the state qualified payment stablecoin
issuers or an institution-affiliated party of such issuer for
violations of the Act under certain circumstances. State
qualified payment stablecoin issuers must comply with the
requirements of the Gramm-Leach Bliley Act. The provisions of
this section do not preempt any State law and do not supersede
any State licensing requirement.
Section 8. Customer protection
Section 8 establishes standards for entities that provide
custodial services for payment stablecoins. Entities must treat
customer property as belonging to the customer and take steps
to protect the property from claims of creditors as well as
segregate customer assets from assets belonging to the
custodian and are prohibited from commingling.
These custodians must be regulated by a federal regulator
or subject to supervision by a state bank supervisor that
shares information with the Federal Reserve and meets certain
standards, including segregation requirements and the
prohibition on commingling. Finally, the entities must submit
information, in such form as the Federal Reserve determines, to
the Federal Reserve on their business operations and processes
to protect customer assets.
The requirements of this section shall not apply to any
entity solely on the basis that such person engages in the
business of providing hardware or software to facilitate a
customer's own custody or safekeeping of the customer's payment
stablecoins or private keys.
Section 9. Interoperability standards
Section 9 requires the primary federal payment stablecoin
regulators to work with the National Institute of Standards and
Technology, other relevant standard setting organizations, and
State governments to consider standards for compatibility and
interoperability of payment stablecoins.
Section 10. Moratorium on endogenously collateralized stablecoins
Section 10 imposes a two-year moratorium on the creation or
issuance of endogenously collateralized stablecoins and
requires Treasury to conduct a study on endogenously
collateralized stablecoins and report to the relevant
Committees within one year. An endogenously collateralized
stablecoin is any digital asset in which its originator has
represented will be converted, redeemed, or repurchased for a
fixed amount of monetary value; and that relies solely on the
value of another digital asset created or maintained by the
same originator to maintain the fixed price.
Section 11. Report on rulemaking status
Section 11 requires the primary federal payment stablecoin
regulators to provide the relevant Committees with an update on
the status of rulemakings required under this Act within 6
months.
Section 12. Authority of banking institutions
Section 12 clarifies the authority of depository
institutions and trust companies, as appropriate, to tokenize
deposits, utilize distributed ledger for books and records, and
provide custodial services for payment stablecoins.
Additionally, this section prevents federal agencies from
requiring entities to account for assets held in custody on
their balance sheet; hold additional regulatory capital against
these assets, except as necessary to mitigate against
operational risks inherent with the custody or safekeeping
services, as determined by the appropriate federal banking
agency, NCUA, state bank supervisor, or state credit union
supervisor; or recognize a liability for any obligations
related to activities or services performed for digital assets
that the entity does not own if that liability would exceed the
expense recognized in the income statement as a result of the
corresponding obligation. This section overturns SEC SAB 121.
Section 13. Clarifying that payment stablecoins are not securities
Section 13 clarifies that the term ``security'' under the
securities laws does not include a payment stablecoin issued by
a permitted payment stablecoin issuer.
Minority Views
Ranking Member Waters worked closely with Chair McHenry
over several months, and in particular the weeks leading up to
the July markup to achieve a bipartisan bill on stablecoins.
Unfortunately, Chair McHenry abruptly ended those negotiations
and blamed the White House for derailing ongoing discussions.
He, instead, decided to move forward with H.R. 4766, which is
lacking in several ways that are outlined below.
Stablecoins are a specific type of cryptocurrency that
tries to peg its value to another asset like the dollar, the
imprimatur of the federal government. Bipartisan negotiations
on legislation began in part in response to a Report on
Stablecoins (PWG Report) issued in November 2021 by the
President's Working Group on Financial Markets (PWG) along with
the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC), and the
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), urging Congress
to pass legislation to improve oversight and regulation of
stablecoins.\1\ The Financial Stability Oversight Council
(FSOC)'s report on digital assets also reaffirmed concerns
regarding certain regulatory gaps in crypto-asset activities
and recommendations for Congress.\2\ These reports, in addition
to subsequent testimony from Federal officials noted that a
strong Federal framework was needed to oversee stablecoins,
with robust reserve requirements. And given that stablecoins
represent the issuance of a new form of money, Federal
guardrails are integral, as our central bank, the Federal
Reserve handles monetary policy and our money supply. When the
PWG called on Congress to pass legislation to improve the
oversight and regulation of stablecoins, they emphasized the
need for Federal, not state, prudential authority over
stablecoins to address risks like stablecoin runs, systemic
risk, and concentration of economic power. Nevertheless, H.R.
4766 would hand the keys to addressing these national risks to
the states, and a key issue with this bill would be the
patchwork of state regulation that would promote a race to the
bottom.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\President's Working Group on Financial Markets, FDIC, and OCC,
Report on Stablecoins, at 1 (Nov. 2021).
\2\FSOC, Report on Digital Asset Financial Stability Risks and
Regulation (Oct. 3, 2022).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
As it stands, the current Republican bill does not have the
support of the White House, the U.S. Treasury, or the Federal
Reserve and falls short in the following ways:
McHenry's bill promotes a race to the bottom
by creating 58 different licenses with Federal
regulatory approval and robust oversight over only 2 of
the licenses, which are the licenses for banks and Fed-
approved nonbanks. Moreover, this legislation allows
individual states to preempt each other. Texas, for
example, would have no ability to stop coins from being
issued in their state from New York.
The bill allows all commercial entities like
Amazon, Walmart, or Facebook to create their own
stablecoins, or affiliate with a stablecoin issuers.
Facebook, with its own coin, could become effectively a
global bank with 2 billion customers overnight. We have
already begun to see corporations launching their own
stablecoin while there is still no Federal framework
for regulation, oversight, and enforcement of these
assets. For example, only a few days after the markup,
PayPal launched its own U.S. dollar-denominated
stablecoin, PayPal USD (PYUSD) issued by Paxos Trust
Company, and made available on Venmo and various crypto
exchanges.\3\ By allowing commercial entities to engage
in what is essentially financial services, the bill
undermines a prohibition against such activities dating
back to the 1930s and the passage of Glass Stegall, and
would allow for the creation of super monopolies with
dangerous amounts of economic and political power.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\See PayPal, PayPal Launches U.S. Dollar Stablecoin (Aug. 7,
2023); see also House Committee on Financial Services, Ranking Member
Waters' Statement on PayPal's Launch of U.S. Dollar Stablecoin (Aug. 9,
2023); and Rep. Sean Casten, Letter to Daniel H. Schulman President and
Chief Executive Officer of PayPal (Aug. 14, 2023). In September 20,
PayPal announced the PYUSD stablecoin is available on Venmo. See also,
PayPal's PYUSD stablecoin is now available on Venmo, TechCrunch (Sept.
20, 2023). PayPal, with 435 million customers globally, exceeds the
number of online accounts at all of the megabanks combined. Due to
PayPal's size and reach, Federal oversight and enforcement of its
stablecoin operations are critical in ensuring consumer protection and
addressing financial stability concerns.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
While the sponsors suggest that state-
regulated non-bank issuers would still have oversight
by the Federal Reserve, the bill provides no
supervisory or regulatory authority to the Federal
Reserve. Simply stating that the Fed has
``supervisory'' authorities does not make such
authorities so. The bill, for example, does not
describe the authority to examine, the authority to
issue cease and desist orders, or to even levy a
penalty. Any non-bank entity would easily prove in
court that the Fed has no authority to do anything
related to it. Notably, given the direct connection of
stablecoins to the money supply and the conduct of
monetary policy, no other global regime undermines
their central bank's authority.
With respect to enforcement, the bill
generally stipulates that the Fed can take enforcement
action in exigent circumstances, but again, it grants
no actual enforcement authority to the Fed with respect
to state-licensed entities.
Despite extensive testimony and public
statements by stablecoin issuers and crypto firms about
the promise that crypto would promote a fair and
equitable financial system, Republicans excluded all
references to ``diversity and inclusion'' consistent
with their culture wars, and rejected an amendment by
Rep. Beatty to correct such deficiencies in the bill.
The bill's framework to oversee stablecoins
departs dramatically from regulatory frameworks of
comparable activities. For example, the dual banking
system requires Federal regulatory pre-approval and
robust oversight of state-chartered banks. While there
have been concerns raised about how robust the
regulation and oversight of money transmitters are,
even money transmitters must get a license in each
state they operate. In the bill, however, a stablecoin
issuer would only have to get a license in one state,
but its stablecoins could freely be exchanged in all
states.
H.R. 4766 does not authorize Federal
oversight of third-party vendors of payment stablecoin
issuers (other than custodial wallets to a limited
degree), even though such vendors may be critical to
ensuring the functioning and stability of the
stablecoin. For comparison, banking regulators do have
such oversight authority of the vendors of traditional
banks.
The bill does not include any financial
resource requirements to ensure custodial wallets are
resilient, while exempting many wallet providers given
the way state regulatory frameworks are automatically
deemed to be comparable to the Federal framework for
wallet providers. For comparison, banks are required to
maintain minimum levels of capital and liquidity to
ensure they can handle any withdrawals from their
customers.
Despite the urging of the PWG and FSOC to
address the systemic risks of stablecoins, the bill
does not mandate that regulators consider financial
stability when approving payment stablecoins.
While Gramm-Leach-Bliley's cybersecurity and
data privacy requirements apply to federally regulated
stablecoin issuers, those standards are not applied to
state-regulated issuers.
The bill only provides a weak application of
Bank Secrecy Act/Anti-Money Laundering laws and states
have limited capacity and inclination to oversee
compliance with such laws.
H.R. 4766 does not require regulatory
approval for mergers and acquisitions of payment
stablecoin issuers, rendering the already weak initial
application process moot if the entity can be sold to
other ownership groups.
The following Democratic amendments were rejected by
Republicans or withdrawn:
Rep. Foster's amendment would strike
provisions that exempt self-hosted wallets from
regulations. Specifically, it would strike a provision
in the bill that excludes hardware or software
providers for self-custody from customer protections.
It would also strike a provision that would stop
regulators from taking action to restrict the use of
self-hosted wallets.
Rep. Beatty's amendment would add language
requiring diversity and inclusion data reporting by
payment stablecoin issuers.
Rep. Sherman's amendment classifies all
stablecoins as securities and stablecoin exchanges as
securities exchanges under the jurisdiction of the SEC.
Rep. Velazquez's amendment was withdrawn
after the Chair indicated he would work with the Member
on the amendment. It would grant the primary Federal
payment stablecoin regulators, in consultation with
FinCEN, the ability to establish additional standards
for permitted stablecoin issuers operating in high-risk
money laundering and related financial crimes areas.
Rep. Casten's amendment was withdrawn after
Rep. Hill committed to working on the amendment before
the bill is brought to the floor. His amendment directs
each primary Federal payment stablecoin regulator to
issue regulations prohibiting the employment of
manipulation, deceptive devices, and price
manipulation.
Finally, this bill is opposed by the following groups:
Americans for Financial Reform (AFR), Action on Race and the
Economy (ACRE), Center for LGBTQ Economic Advancement &
Research (CLEAR), Center for Responsible Lending, Demand
Progress National Fair Housing Alliance, National Community
Reinvestment Coalition (NCRC), National Consumer Law Center
(NCLC), Public Citizen, Revolving Door Project, Texas
Appleseed, U.S. PIRG, Virginia Citizens Consumer Council, 20/20
Vision.
For these reasons, we oppose H.R. 4766.
Sincerely,
Maxine Waters,
Ranking Member.
Nydia M. Velaquez,
David Scott,
Al Green,
Bill Foster,
Brad Sherman,
Stephen F. Lynch,
Emanuel Cleaver II,
Joyce Beatty,
Juan Vargas,
Sean Casten,
Rashida Tlaib,
Nikema Williams,
Vicente Gonzalez,
Ayanna Pressley,
Sylvia R. Garcia,
Members of Congress.