Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 5403]
The Committee on Financial Services, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 5403) to amend the Federal Reserve Act to
prohibit the Federal reserve banks from offering certain
products or services directly to an individual, to prohibit the
use of central bank digital currency for monetary policy, and
for other purposes, having considered the same, reports
favorably thereon with an amendment and recommends that the
bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 2
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 3
Related Hearings................................................. 5
Committee Consideration.......................................... 7
Committee Votes.................................................. 7
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 11
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 11
Congressional Budget Office Estimates............................ 11
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures 11
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 11
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 11
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 11
Earmark Identification........................................... 12
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 12
Section-By-Section Analysis of the Legislation................... 12
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported............ 13
Minority Views................................................... 19
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``CBDC Anti-Surveillance State Act''.
SEC. 2. PROHIBITION ON FEDERAL RESERVE BANKS RELATING TO CERTAIN
PRODUCTS OR SERVICES FOR INDIVIDUALS AND
PROHIBITION ON DIRECTLY ISSUING A CENTRAL BANK
DIGITAL CURRENCY.
Section 16 of the Federal Reserve Act is amended by adding at the end
the following new paragraph:
``(18) A Federal reserve bank shall not--
``(A) offer products or services directly to an
individual;
``(B) maintain an account on behalf of an individual;
or
``(C) issue a central bank digital currency, or any
digital asset that is substantially similar under any
other name or label, directly to an individual.''.
SEC. 3. PROHIBITION ON FEDERAL RESERVE BANKS INDIRECTLY ISSUING A
CENTRAL BANK DIGITAL CURRENCY.
Section 16 of the Federal Reserve Act, as amended by section 2, is
further amended by adding at the end the following new paragraph:
``(19)(A) A Federal reserve bank shall not offer a central
bank digital currency, or any digital asset that is
substantially similar under any other name or label, indirectly
to an individual through a financial institution or other
intermediary.
``(B) Subparagraph (A) may not be construed to prohibit any
dollar-denominated currency that is open, permissionless, and
private, and fully preserves the privacy protections of United
States coins and physical currency.''.
SEC. 4. PROHIBITION ON THE USE OF CENTRAL BANK DIGITAL CURRENCY FOR
MONETARY POLICY.
Section 16 of the Federal Reserve Act, as amended by section 3, is
further amended by adding at the end the following new paragraph:
``(20) Prohibition on the use of central bank digital
currency for monetary policy.--The Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System and the Federal Open Market Committee
shall not use any central bank digital currency, or any digital
asset that is substantially similar under any other name or
label, to implement monetary policy.''.
SEC. 5. CENTRAL BANK DIGITAL CURRENCY.
(a) In General.--The Federal Reserve Act (12 U.S.C. 221 et seq.) is
amended by inserting after section 16 the following:
``SEC. 16A. CENTRAL BANK DIGITAL CURRENCY.
``(a) In General.--The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
System may not, absent Congressional authorization, issue a central
bank digital currency.
``(b) Central Bank Digital Currency Defined.--In this section, the
term `central bank digital currency' means a form of digital money or
monetary value, denominated in the national unit of account, that is a
direct liability of the Federal Reserve System.''.
(b) Treasury.--Chapter 3 of subtitle I of title 31 of the United
States Code is amended by inserting after section 316 the following:
``SEC. 317. CENTRAL BANK DIGITAL CURRENCY.
``(a) In General.--The Secretary of the Treasury may not, absent
Congressional authorization, direct the Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System to issue a central bank digital currency.
``(b) Central Bank Digital Currency Defined.--In this section, the
term `central bank digital currency' means a form of digital money or
monetary value, denominated in the national unit of account, that is a
direct liability of the central bank.''.
SEC. 6. PROTECTION FOR OPEN, PERMISSIONLESS, AND PRIVATE CURRENCY.
This Act and the amendments made by this Act shall not apply to any
dollar-denominated currency that is open, permissionless, and private,
and fully preserves the privacy protections of United States coins and
physical currency.''
Purpose and Summary
Introduced on September 12, 2023, by Representative Tom
Emmer, H.R. 5403, the CBDC Anti-Surveillance State Act, would
amend Section 16 of the Federal Reserve Act to prohibit the
Federal Reserve Banks from issuing a central bank digital
currency (CBDC), or any substantially similar digital asset,
directly or indirectly to individuals. Additionally, the bill
would prohibit the Federal Reserve System and the Federal Open
Market Committee from using a CBDC to implement monetary
policy. H.R. 5403 would also prohibit the Federal Reserve Banks
from maintaining an account on behalf of any individual and
offering products or services to any individual. The bill does
not prohibit the development or issuance of any dollar-
denominated currency that is open, permissionless, private, and
fully preserves the privacy protections of cash. Representative
Emmer first introduced the legislation in the 117th Congress.
H.R. 5403 has 164 cosponsors.
Background and Need for Legislation
A CBDC is a type of digital money that is denominated in
the national unit of account, a direct liability of the central
bank, and is different than traditional reserve bank balances
or settlement accounts. A CBDC may use an electronic record or
digital ``token'' to represent a fiat currency.
In general, a CBDC can be structured as a retail CBDC or as
a wholesale CBDC. A retail CBDC, either direct or indirect
(i.e., intermediated), is a digital liability of the central
bank that is widely available to the general public. In
contrast, a wholesale CBDC is a digital liability of the
central bank that would be restricted to financial institutions
for use during interbank settlement.
Retail CBDCs
Under a direct retail model, the Federal Reserve would be
responsible for developing and maintaining U.S. CBDC accounts.
The Federal Reserve would serve, in effect, as a consumer
banking entity and would need support from the Federal Reserve
Regional Banks to provide traditional banking services. Under
existing law, the Federal Reserve is not authorized to
establish or maintain accounts for individuals. Providing such
accounts would represent a sea change in the Federal Reserve's
role in the financial system and the economy.
Under an indirect retail model, consumers would hold a U.S.
CBDC in an account at a financial institution responsible for
providing traditional consumer banking services. The financial
institution would serve as the central bank's agent,
eliminating the need for the Federal Reserve to provide
consumer banking services. The financial institutions would be
responsible for wallet design, customer management, customer
screening, and transaction monitoring, including anti-money
laundering and combatting the financing of terrorism (AML/CFT)
controls.
The Federal Reserve does not have the legal authority to
implement a retail CBDC model. Congress' authority over coining
money is exclusive. The Supreme Court has recognized Congress'
power to coin money and regulate the value thereof, confirming
Congress' authority to regulate each phase of currency. Indeed,
Federal Reserve Chair Powell made clear the Federal Reserve
would not implement a retail CBDC ``without support from
Congress, and [this support] would ideally come in the form of
an authorizing law, rather than us trying to interpret our law
to enable this.'' Chair Powell confirmed this position on March
15, 2023, during the Committee's hearing on the Federal
Reserve's Semi-annual Monetary Policy Report.
Committee on Financial Services' Work on CBDCs
In the 117th Congress, the House Committee on Financial
Services' Task Force on Financial Technology held its first
CBDC-focused hearing on June 15, 2021, entitled ``Digitizing
the Dollar: Investigating the Technological Infrastructure,
Privacy, and Financial Inclusion Implications of Central Bank
Digital Currencies.'' At that hearing, Committee Republicans
emphasized that Congress and the Federal Reserve should
exercise caution and have a better understanding of the
implications a U.S. CBDC would have on the Federal Reserve and
its monetary policy tools; potential risks to our existing
payments system; private sector competition and innovation; and
the impact on American's privacy, civil liberties, and
security.
On November 15, 2021, Committee Republicans issued
principles to use to evaluate a U.S. CBDC. These principles
held that any potential Federal Reserve-issued digital currency
must: (1) maintain the dollar as the world's reserve currency
and the preeminence of the U.S. payment system; (2) not impede
ongoing development of stablecoins; (3) promote private sector
innovation and foster competition; and (4) address privacy and
security protections. Collectively, these principles ensure
that any proposal does not allow the Federal Reserve or any
other government agency to monopolize or weaponize a CBDC.
Further, these principles ensure policymakers thoroughly weigh
the risks of a U.S. CBDC.
In January 2022, in response to a Federal Reserve's
discussion paper, Committee Republicans restated their guiding
principles and emphasized the need for Congressional
authorization. Committee Republicans also requested additional
information from the Federal Reserve regarding its work on a
CBDC and the January 2022 discussion paper highlighting
significant concerns, including:
Role of the Federal Reserve and Impact on
Monetary Policy: The Federal Reserve does not have the
ability to support a retail CBDC. Expanding central
bank activity into retail banking will likely increase
politization of the Federal Reserve, negatively
affecting the Federal Reserve's performance of its
monetary and regulatory functions. In addition, a
retail CBDC could directly impact monetary policy and
interest rate control by altering the supply of
reserves in the banking system and the long-term size
of the Federal Reserve's balance sheet. A retail CBDC
could also impact credit markets and result in the
Federal Reserve offering products and services
traditionally reserved for retail banking institutions.
Impact to the Structure of our Financial
System: A retail CBDC would fundamentally change the
structure of the U.S. financial system. A retail CBDC
would reduce the amount of deposits in the banking
system, which in turn could increase bank funding
expenses. It would also reduce the availability of and
raise the cost of credit for individuals and
businesses. In addition, the ability to quickly convert
bank deposits into a retail CBDC could make bank runs
more likely. As emphasized in the Federal Reserve's
January 2022 discussion paper, ``prudential
supervision, government deposit insurance, and access
to central bank liquidity may be insufficient to stave
off large outflows of commercial bank deposits into
CBDC in the event of financial panic.''
Impact to Private Sector Innovation and
Digital Assets: A retail CBDC would inherently compete
with private sector efforts to develop widely used
stablecoins. If issued under a clear regulatory
framework, stablecoins could help provide more
efficient retail payments. Stablecoins could be a
source of healthy competition and help reach a wider
range of consumers. Many traditional financial firms
are exploring stablecoin arrangements to increase
efficiency in payments. Indeed, the Presidential
Working Group and Financial Markets report on
stablecoins opined, ``several existing stablecoin
issuers and entities with stablecoin projects . . .
have the stated ambition for the stablecoins they
create to be used widely by retail users to pay for
goods and services, by corporations in the context of
supply chain payments, and in the context of
international remittances.''
Lack of Increased Financial Inclusion: A
primary argument for retail CBDCs is to foster greater
financial inclusion. It is unclear how indirect retail
CBDCs would reach this end, as unbanked individuals
have difficulty paying banking fees and are often
distrustful of financial institutions. Since indirect
retail CBDCs still rely on financial institutions for
intermediation, unbanked individuals would continue to
face the same challenges.
The fact is: the Federal Reserve has failed to identify the
current payment system inefficiencies a CBDC will address or
what problems a CBDC will solve for Americans. As a result, the
CBDC Anti-Surveillance State Act is necessary to prohibit the
Federal Reserve from issuing a retail CBDC under a direct or
indirect model. This will ensure Federal Reserve cannot
transform itself into a retail bank able to collect personal
financial data on Americans. This will likewise prevent the
Federal Reserve from launching a CBDC intermediated through
financial institutions. The bill also prohibits the Federal
Reserve from using any CBDC to implement monetary policy,
ensuring the Federal Reserve cannot use a CBDC as a tool to
control the American economy. As amended, this bill prohibits
the Federal Reserve and the Treasury Department from moving
forward with a CBDC without authorization from Congress. The
legislation also protects innovation and any future development
of digital cash.
Related Hearings
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
hearings were used to develop H.R. 5403:
118TH CONGRESS
--The Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology
and Inclusion held a hearing on September 14, 2023, titled
``Digital Dollar Dilemma: The Implications of a Central Bank
Digital Currency and Private Sector Alternatives.''
--The Subcommittee on National Security, Illicit Finance,
and International Financial Institutions held a hearing on June
7, 2023, titled ``Dollar Dominance: Preserving the U.S.
Dollar's Status as the Global Reserve Currency.''
--The Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology
and Inclusion held a hearing on May 18, 2023, titled ``Putting
the `Stable' in `Stablecoins:' How Legislation Will Help
Stablecoins Achieve Their Promise.''
--The Subcommittee on Digital Assets, Financial Technology
and Inclusion held a hearing on April 19, 2023, titled
``Understanding Stablecoins'' Role in Payments and the Need for
Legislation.''
117TH CONGRESS
--The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
June 23, 2022, titled ``Monetary Policy and the State of the
Economy.''
--The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on May
26, 2022, titled ``Digital Assets and the Future of Finance:
Examining the Benefits and Risks of a U.S. Central Bank Digital
Currency.''
--The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
April 6, 2022, titled ``The Annual Testimony of the Secretary
of the Treasury on the State of the International Financial
System.''
--The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
March 2, 2022, titled ``Monetary Policy and the State of the
Economy.''
--The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
February 8, 2022, titled ``Digital Assets and the Future of
Finance: The President's Working Group on Financial Markets'
Report on Stablecoins.''
--The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
December 8, 2021, titled ``Digital Assets and the Future of
Finance: Understanding the Challenges and Benefits of Financial
Innovation in the United States.''
--The Subcommittee on National Security, International
Development, and Monetary Policy held a hearing on July 27,
2021, titled ``The Promises and Perils of Central Bank Digital
Currencies.''
--The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
July 14, 2021, titled ``Monetary Policy and the State of the
Economy.''
--The Task Force on Financial Technology held a hearing on
June 15, 2021, titled ``Digitizing the Dollar: Investigating
the Technological Infrastructure, Privacy, and Financial
Inclusion Implications of Central Bank Digital Currencies.''
--The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
February 24, 2021, titled ``Monetary Policy and the State of
the Economy.''
116TH CONGRESS
--The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
June 17, 2020, titled ``Monetary Policy and the State of the
Economy.''
--The Task Force on Financial Technology held a hearing on
June 11, 2020, titled ``Inclusive Banking During a Pandemic:
Using Fed accounts and Digital Tools to Improve Delivery Of
Stimulus Payments.''
--The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
February 11, 2020, titled ``Monetary Policy and the State of
the Economy.''
--The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
October 23, 2019, titled ``An Examination of Facebook and Its
Impact on the Financial Services and Housing Sectors.''
--The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
July 17, 2019, titled ```Examining Facebook's Proposed
Cryptocurrency and Its Impact on Consumers, Investors, and the
American Financial System.''
--The Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on
July 10, 2019, titled ``Monetary Policy and the State of the
Economy.''
115TH CONGRESS
--The Subcommittee on Monetary Policy and Trade held a
hearing on July 18, 2018, titled ``The Future of Money: Digital
Currency.''
113TH CONGRESS
--The Subcommittee on Monetary Policy and Trade held a
hearing on July 11, 2014, titled ``The Production and
Circulation of Coins and Currency.''
Committee Consideration
The Committee on Financial Services met in open session on
September 20, 2023, and ordered H.R. 5403 to be reported
favorably to the House as amended by a recorded vote of 27 ayes
to 20 nays (Record vote no. FC-108), a quorum being present.
Before the question was called to order the bill favorably
reported, the Committee adopted an amendment in the nature of a
substitute offered by Mr. Emmer by voice vote.
Committee Votes
Clause 3(b) of rule XIII of the Rules of the House of
Representatives requires the Committee to list the record votes
on the order to report legislation and amendments thereto. H.R.
5403 was ordered reported favorably to the House as amended by
a recorded vote of 27 ayes to 20 nays (Record vote no. FC-108),
a quorum being present.
An amendment offered by Ms. Waters, no. 1, was not agreed
to by a recorded vote of 20 ayes to 27 nays, a quorum being
present (Record vote no. FC-106).
An amendment offered by Mr. Lynch, no. 2, was not agreed to
by a recorded vote of 20 ayes to 27 nays, a quorum being
present (Record vote no. FC-107).
Committee Oversight Findings
Pursuant to clause 3(c) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the findings and recommendations of
the Committee, based on oversight activities under clause
2(b)(1) of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives,
are incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
Performance Goals and Objectives
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the goal of H.R. 5403 is to amend
Section 13 of the Federal Reserve Act to prohibit the Federal
Reserve Banks from issuing a CBDC, or any substantially similar
digital asset, directly or indirectly to individuals, and to
prohibit the Federal Reserve System and the Federal Open Market
Committee from using a CBDC to implement monetary policy.
Congressional Budget Office Estimates
The Committee has requested but not received a cost
estimate from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office.
However, pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee will adopt as its own the cost estimate by the
Director of the Congressional Budget Office once it has been
prepared.
New Budget Authority, Entitlement Authority, and Tax Expenditures
The Committee has requested but not received an estimate
from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office. However,
pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, once an estimate has been prepared by
the Director of the Congressional Budget Office, as required by
section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1973, the
Committee will adopt as its own the estimate of new budget
authority, entitlement authority, or tax expenditures or
revenues contained in the cost estimate.
Federal Mandates Statement
The Committee has requested but not received an estimate
from the Director of the Congressional Budget Office of the
Federal mandates pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded
Mandates Reform Act. The Committee will adopt the estimate once
it has been prepared by the Director.
Advisory Committee Statement
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Earmark Identification
With respect to clause 9 of rule XXI of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee has carefully reviewed
the provisions of the bill and states that the provisions of
the bill do not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits within the meaning of the
rule.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives, the Committee states that no
provision of the bill establishes or reauthorizes a program of
the Federal Government known to be duplicative of another
Federal program, including any program that was included in a
report to Congress pursuant to section 21 of the Public Law
111-139 or the most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic
Assistance.
Section-by-Section Analysis of the Legislation
Section 1. Short title
This section cites H.R. 5403 as the ``CBDC Anti-
Surveillance State Act of 2023.''
Section 2. Prohibition on federal reserve banks relating to certain
products or services for individuals and prohibition on
directly issuing a central bank digital currency
This section amends section 16 of the Federal Reserve Act
to prohibit any Federal Reserve Bank from offering products or
services directly to individuals, maintaining an account on
behalf of individuals, or issuing a CBDC directly to
individuals. This section also prohibits any Federal Reserve
Bank from issuing any digital asset that is substantially
similar to a CBDC directly to individuals.
Section 3. Prohibition of federal reserve banks indirectly issuing a
central bank digital currency
This section amends section 16 of the Federal Reserve Act
to prohibit the Federal Reserve Banks from issuing a CBDC, or
any digital asset that is substantially similar, indirectly to
individuals, including through a financial intermediary. The
prohibition under this section would not apply to any dollar-
denominated currency that is open, permissionless, and private.
Section 4. Prohibition on the use of central bank digital currency for
monetary policy
This section would prohibit the Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System and the Federal Open Market Committee
from using any CBDC, or any digital asset that is substantially
similar, to implement monetary policy.
Section 5. Central Bank Digital Currency
This section amends the Federal Reserve Act by defining a
CBDC as a ``form of digital money or monetary value,
denominated in the national unit of account, that is a direct
liability of the Federal Reserve System.'' This section
prohibits the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve from
issuing a CBDC without Congressional authorization.
Further, this section prohibits the Secretary of the
Treasury from directing the Board of Governors of the Federal
Reserve to issue a CBDC without Congressional authorization.
Section 6. Protection for open, permissionless, and private currency
This section clarifies that all amendments made by H.R.
5403 shall not apply to any dollar-denominated currency that is
open, permissionless, and private, and fully preserves the
privacy protections of United States coins and physical
currency.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (new matter is
printed in italics and existing law in which no change is
proposed is shown in roman):
FEDERAL RESERVE ACT
* * * * * * *
note issues.
Sec. 16. Federal Reserve notes, to be issued at the
discretion of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
System for the purpose of making advances to Federal Reserve
banks through the Federal reserve agents as hereinafter set
forth and for no other purpose, are hereby authorized. The said
notes shall be obligations of the United States and shall be
receivable by all national and member banks and Federal Reserve
banks and for all taxes, customs, and other public dues. They
shall be redeemed in lawful money on demand at the Treasury
Department of the United States, in the city of Washington,
District of Columbia, or at any Federal Reserve bank.
Any Federal Reserve bank may make application to the local
Federal Reserve agent for such amount of the Federal Reserve
notes hereinbefore provided for as it may require. Such
application shall be accompanied with a tender to the local
Federal Reserve agent of collateral in amount equal to the sum
of the Federal Reserve notes thus applied for and issued
pursuant to such application. The collateral security thus
offered shall be notes, drafts, bills of exchange, or
acceptances acquired under section 10A, 10B, 13, or 13A of this
Act, or bills of exchange endorsed by a member bank of any
Federal Reserve district and purchased under the provisions of
section 14 of this Act, or bankers' acceptances purchased under
the provisions of said section 14, or gold certificates, or
Special Drawing Right certificates, or any obligations which
are direct obligations of, or are fully guaranteed as to
principal and interest by, the United States or any agency
thereof, or assets that Federal Reserve banks may purchase or
hold under section 14 of this Act or any other asset of a
Federal reserve bank. In no event shall such collateral
security be less than the amount of Federal Reserve notes
applied for. The Federal Reserve agent shall each day notify
the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System of all
issues and withdrawals of Federal Reserve notes to and by the
Federal Reserve bank to which he is accredited. The said Board
of Governors of the Federal Reserve System may at any time call
upon a Federal Reserve bank for additional security to protect
the Federal Reserve notes issued to it. Collateral shall not be
required for Federal Reserve notes which are held in the vaults
of, or are otherwise held by or on behalf of, Federal Reserve
banks.
Federal Reserve notes shall bear upon their faces a
distinctive letter and serial number which shall be assigned by
the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System to each
Federal Reserve bank. Federal Reserve notes unfit for
circulation shall be canceled, destroyed, and accounted for
under procedures prescribed and at locations designated by the
Secretary of the Treasury. Upon destruction of such notes,
credit with respect thereto shall be apportioned among the
twelve Federal Reserve banks as determined by the Board of
Governors of the Federal Reserve System.
The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System shall
have the right, acting through the Federal Reserve agent, to
grant in whole or in part, or to reject entirely the
application of any Federal Reserve bank for Federal Reserve
notes; but to the extent that such applicaton may be granted
the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System shall,
through its local Federal Reserve agent, supply Federal Reserve
notes to the banks so applying, and such bank shall be charged
with the amount of the notes issued to it and shall pay such
rate of interest as may be established by the Board of
Governors of the Federal Reserve System on only that amount of
such notes which equals the total amount of its outstanding
Federal Reserve notes less the amount of gold certificates held
by the Federal Reserve agent as collateral security. Federal
Reserve notes issued to any such bank shall, upon delivery,
together with such notes of such Federal Reserve bank as may be
issued under section 18 of this Act upon security of United
States 2 per centum Government bonds, become a first and
paramount lien on all the assets of such bank.
Any Federal Reserve bank may at any time reduce its
liability for outstanding Federal Reserve notes by depositing
with the Federal Reserve agent its Federal Reserve notes, gold
certificates, Special Drawing Right certificates, or lawful
money of the United States. Federal Reserve notes so deposited
shall not be reissued, except upon compliance with the
conditions of an original issue. The liability of a Federal
Reserve bank with respect to its outstanding Federal Reserve
notes shall be reduced by any amount paid by such bank to the
Secretary of the Treasury under section 4 of the Old Series
Currency Adjustment Act.
Any Federal Reserve bank may at its discretion withdraw
collateral deposited with the local Federal Reserve agent for
the protection of its Federal Reserve notes issued to it and
shall at the same time substitute therefor other collateral of
equal amont with the approval of the Federal Reserve agent
under regulations to be prescribed by the Board of Governors of
the Federal Reserve System. Any Federal Reserve bank may retire
any of its Federal Reserve notes by depositing them with the
Federal Reserve agent or with the Treasurer of the United
States, and such Federal Reserve bank shall thereupon be
entitled to receive back the collateral deposited with the
Federal Reserve agent for the security of such notes. Any
Federal Reserve bank shall further be entitled to receive back
the collateral deposited with the Federal Reserve agent for the
security of any notes with respect to which such bank has made
payment to the Secretary of the Treasury under section 4 of the
Old Series Currency Adjustment Act. Federal Reserve notes so
deposited shall not be reissued except upon compliance with the
conditions of an original issue.
All Federal Reserve notes and all gold certificates, Special
Drawing Right certificates, and lawful money issued to or
deposited with any Federal Reserve agent under the provisions
of the Federal Reserve Act shall hereafter be held for such
agent, under such rules and regulations as the Board of
Governors of the Federal Reserve System may prescribe, in the
joint custody of himself and the Federal Reserve bank to which
he is accredited. Such agent and such Federal Reserve bank
shall be jointly liable for the safekeeping of such Federal
Reserve notes, gold certificates, Special Drawing Right
certificates, and lawful money. Nothing herein contained,
however, shall be construed to prohibit a Federal Reserve agent
from depositing gold certificates and Special Drawing Right
certificates with the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
System, to be held by such Board subject to his order, or with
the Treasurer of the United States for the purposes authorized
by law.
In order to furnish suitable notes for circulation as
Federal reserve notes, the Secretary of the Treasury shall
cause plates and dies to be engraved in the best manner to
guard against counterfeits and fraudulent alterations, and
shall have printed therefrom and numbered such quantities of
such notes of the denominations of $1, $2, $5, $10, $20, $50,
$100, $500, $1,000, $5,000, $10,000 as may be required to
supply the Federal reserve banks. Such notes shall be in form
and tenor as directed by the Secretary of the Treasury under
the provisions of this Act and shall bear the distinctive
numbers of the several Federal reserve banks through which they
are issued.
When such notes have been prepared, the notes shall
be delivered to the Board of Governors of the Federal
Reserve System subject to the order of the Secretary of
the Treasury for the delivery of such notes in
accordance with this Act.
The plates and dies to be procured by the Secretary of the
Treasury for the printing of such circulating notes shall
remain under his control and direction, and the expenses
necessarily incurred in executing the laws relating to the
procuring of such notes, and all other expenses incidental to
their issue and retirement, shall be paid by the Federal
reserve banks, and the Board of Governors of the Federal
Reserve System shall include in its estimate of expenses levied
against the Federal reserve banks a sufficient amount to cover
the expenses herein provided for.
The Secretary of the Treasury may examine the
plates, dies, bed pieces, and other material used in
the printing of Federal Reserve notes and issue
regulations relating to such examinations.
Any appropriation heretofore made out of the general funds
of the Treasury for engraving plates and dies, the purchase of
distinctive paper, or to cover any other expense in connection
with the printing of national-bank notes or notes provided for
by the Act of May thirtieth, nineteen hundred and eight, and
any distinctive paper that may be on hand at the time of the
passage of this Act may be used in the discretion of the
Secretary for the purposes of this Act, and should the
appropriations heretofore made be insufficient to meet the
requirements of this Act in addition to circulating notes
provided for by existing law, the Secretary is hereby
authorized to use so much of any funds in the Treasury not
otherwise appropriated for the purpose of furnishing the notes
aforesaid: Provided, however, That nothing in this section
contained shall be construed as exempting national banks or
Federal reserve banks from their liability to reimburse the
United States for any expenses incurred in printing and issuing
circulating notes. (Omitted from U.S. Code)
Every Federal reserve bank shall receive on deposit at par
from depository institutions or from Federal reserve banks
checks and other items, including negotiable orders of
withdrawal and share drafts and drafts drawn upon any of its
depositors, and when remitted by a Federal reserve bank, checks
and other items, including negotiable orders of withdrawal and
share drafts and drafts drawn by any depositor in any other
Federal reserve bank or depository institution upon funds to
the credit of said depositor in said reserve bank or depository
institution. Nothing herein contained shall be construed as
prohibiting a depository institution from charging its actual
expense incurred in collecting and remitting funds, or for
exchange sold to its patrons. The Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System shall, by rule, fix the charges to be
collected by the depository institutions from its patrons whose
checks and other items, including negotiable orders of
withdrawal and share drafts are cleared through the Federal
reserve Bank and the charge which may be imposed for the
service of clearing or collection rendered by the Federal
reserve bank.
The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System shall
make and promulgate from time to time regulations governing the
transfer of funds and charges therefor among Federal reserve
banks and their branches, and may at its discretion exercise
the functions of a clearing house for such Federal reserve
banks, or may designate a Federal reserve bank to exercise such
functions, and may also require each such bank to exercise the
functions of a clearing house for depository institutions.
The Secretary of the Treasury is hereby authorized and
directed to receive deposits of gold or of gold certificates or
of Special Drawing Right certificates with the Treasurer or any
Assistant Treasurer of the United States when tendered by any
Federal Reserve bank or Federal Reserve agent for credit to its
or his account with the Board of Governors of the Federal
Reserve System. The Secretary shall prescribe by regulation the
form of receipt to be issued by the Treasurer or Assistant
Treasurer to the Federal Reserve bank or Federal Reserve agent
making the deposit, and a duplicate of such receipt shall be
delivered to the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
System by the Treasurer at Washington upon proper advices from
any Assistant Treasurer that such deposit has been made.
Deposits so made shall be held subject to the orders of the
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System and deposits
of gold or gold certificates shall be payable in gold
certificates, and deposits of Special Drawing Right
certificates shall be payable in Special Drawing Right
certificates, on the order of the Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System to any Federal Reserve bank or Federal
Reserve agent at the Treasury or at the subtreasury of the
United States nearest the place
Minority Views
H.R. 5403's misguided premise does not accurately portray
the potential goals of a central bank digital currency (CBDC).
A CBDC is a digital currency that is issued by a country's
central bank and the value of which is pegged to the national
currency. 130 countries around the world, representing 98% of
global GDP, are at various stages of exploring a CBDC.\1\ This
includes the U.S., which has been researching a CBDC following
an executive order from the Biden administration. The misguided
premise of this bill is based on the Chinese CBDC, the eCNY,
which was among the first CBDCs to be implemented, and the
design of which included additional government surveillance.
However, there is nothing inherent about a CBDC that
necessitates additional surveillance. In fact, there are design
features that could be built in (and that Congress could
mandate) that would ensure transparency regarding the lack of
surveillance.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Atlantic Council, Central BankDigital Currency Tracker (Accessed
Sept. 7, 2023).
\2\House Financial Services Committee (HFSC), Testimony of Raul
Carrillo, Digital Dollar Dilemma: The Implications of a Central Bank
Digital Currency and Private Sector Alternatives, 118th Cong. (Sept.
14, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 5403 would effectively prohibit the issuance of a CBDC
in the U.S. before we have even had a chance to fully explore
the benefits, challenges, and design options. As other
countries race ahead and compete to develop and implement CBDCs
to harness what could prove to be critical in the evolving
global financial landscape, this bill would keep the U.S.
behind the starting line. To the extent that cryptocurrencies
offer certain benefits, a CBDC could offer those same benefits
while having a greater potential to gain broad public trust and
utilization (especially after numerous digital assets have been
used to defraud Americans), overcome challenges with regard to
interchangeability, avoid volatility in value, and prioritize
financial inclusion and consumer protection. CBDCs may also
have the potential to provide faster payment transactions and
lower transaction fees for consumers and small businesses.
Importantly, many have pointed out that the primacy of the
U.S. dollar could be challenged if CBDCs issued by other
central banks or cryptocurrencies pegged to other national
currencies gain traction as the preferred method of payment in
international trade transactions.\3\ For example, in a 2019
letter to the Federal Reserve Chair Jerome H. Powell, Rep.
French Hill and Rep. Bill Foster echoed these issues stating:
``With the potential for digital currencies to further take on
the characteristics and utility of paper money, it may become
increasingly imperative that the Federal Reserve take up the
project of developing a U.S. dollar digital currency. We are
concerned that the primacy of the U.S. Dollar could be in long-
term jeopardy from wide adoption of digital fiat
currencies.''\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\International Monetary Fund (IMF), The Global Currency Power of
the US Dollar: Problems and Prospects (Mar. 2022); see also
Congressional Research Service (CRS), Central Bank Digital Currencies:
Policy Issues (Feb. 7, 2022).
\4\Letter from Rep. French Hill and Rep. Bill Foster to the
Honorable Jerome H. Powell, Chairman of the Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System (Sept. 30, 2019).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Moreover, this bill is poorly drafted to achieve its
purported purposes, reflecting the rushed process by which this
bill has moved forward. For example, during the debate of the
bill, Representative Lynch pointed out that the addition of
Section 5 in the Amendment in the Nature of a Substitute
effectively negates parts of Section 2 and all of Sections 3
and 4 in the bill. Specifically, Section 5 would prohibit the
issuance of a CBDC altogether absent Congressional
authorization, whereas Sections 2, 3, and 4 would only prohibit
the issuance of a CBDC subject to certain terms. Rep. Lynch
also highlighted how sweeping the bill's definition for a CBDC
was, and how it could materially interfere with the Fed's
ability to conduct monetary policy. Specifically, the ANS
defines a CBDC as a ``form of digital money or monetary value,
denominated in the national unit of account, that is a direct
liability of the Federal Reserve System.''\5\ Under this
definition, a CBDC may extend beyond a central bank digital
currency to broadly cover all liabilities of the Fed, including
paper currency and bank deposits held by the Fed, which would
raise significant issues with the Fed's ability to conduct
monetary policy more generally, outside of issues pertaining to
digital currencies. During the debate, Rep. Pressley also
pointed out that Section 2 of the bill is also overly broad,
affecting the Fed's activities far beyond the provision of
CBDCs. Specifically, Section 2 would prevent the Fed's 12
Federal Reserve banks from offering any products or services
directly to an individual or maintaining an account on behalf
of an individual.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\HFSC, ANS to H.R. 5403 (Sept. 20, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In the markup, Democrats proposed two amendments to this
bill that were rejected by Republicans:
Ranking Member Waters proposed an amendment
that would ensure that nothing in the bill would take
effect unless Treasury makes the determination and
reports to Congress that the absence of a U.S. CBDC
would not enable the Chinese Yuan to replace the U.S.
dollar as the principal global reserve currency.
Representative Lynch proposed an amendment
that would ensure that nothing in the bill would take
effect unless Treasury determines that a CBDC cannot be
designed in a manner that promotes consumer data
privacy.
Finally, Committee Democrats unanimously rejected this
bill, and it is opposed by Americans for Financial Reform,
Demand Progress, Public Citizen, and Take on Wall Street.
For these reasons, we oppose H.R. 5403.
Sincerely,
Maxine Waters,
Ranking Member, Committee on
Financial Services.
Nydia M. Velazquez,
Gregory W, Meeks,
Stephen F, Lynch,
Emanuel Cleaver, II,
Joyce Beatty,
Brad Sherman,
David Scott,
Al Green,
Bill Foster,
Juan Vargas,
Sean Casten,
Sylvia R, Garcia,
Brittany Pettersen,
Rashida Tlaib,
Nikema Williams,
Members of Congress.