Background and Need for Legislation
According to the Wall Street Journal, nearly 60 percent of
Americans have had to cut back on spending on live
entertainment because of rising costs, with 37 percent of
survey respondents saying they cannot keep up with the rising
price of events they would like to attend, and 20 percent being
willing to take out debt to continue to afford their favorite
entertainment activities.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Robbie Whelan and Anne Steele, It's Getting Too Expensive to
Have Fun, Wall Street Journal (Oct. 2023), https://www.wsj.com/economy/
consumers/its-getting-too-expensive-to-have-fun-a59e9df8.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Junk fees associated with event ticketing are commonplace
and allow ticket sellers to increase their revenue without
providing clear and timely disclosures about the actual cost of
buying tickets.\2\ In addition to encouraging consumers to
spend more than they had intended to, these fees make it nearly
impossible for consumers to comparison shop for the best deal
across ticketing platforms. Consumers find these fees to be
frustrating, and that they lack transparency leading to
material information being omitted from pricing information.
This often harms consumers who are price shopping for the best
value and misleads consumers about total cost they will pay.
These fees is that they are often levied after the checkout
process has been nearly completed. One expert, Jeff Galak, a
professor of marketing at Carnegie Mellon University's Tepper
School of Business, explained that ``[b]y the time the fee is
tacked on, it's too late . . . It's either actually too late,
like `I'm standing at the hotel check-in desk, I don't have a
choice anymore.' Or it's apparently too late.''\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Clear Barrett, `Drip Pricing' is a Scandal, Financial Times
(Sept. 2023), https://www.ft.com/content/44ae564c-2758-415f-9728-
20a8bc092ffb.
\4\Stacey Vanek Smith, What my $30 Hamburger Reveals About Fees and
how Companies use them to Jack Up Prices, NPR (July 2023), https://
www.npr.org/2023/07/27/1189665392/fees-
inflation-white-house-service-hidden.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R 3950 requires a ban on speculative ticket sales. A
speculative ticket is a ticket that the seller does not have
constructive possession of at the time of sale. Speculative
tickets can artificially drive up the price of tickets on
secondary markets and cause confusion for consumers who believe
they are purchasing an event ticket at the time of sale.\5\
This legislation would not prohibit a secondary market ticket
issuer and secondary ticket exchange from offering a service to
a consumer to obtain an event ticket on behalf of the consumer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\Rolling Stone, Beyonce Tickets Aren't on Sale Yet. Scalpers Are
Trying to Sell Them. (February 2023) (https://www.rollingstone.com/
music/music-news/beyonce-tickets-scalpers-specula tive-tickets-
ticketmaster-stubhub-1234672209/).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consumers have expressed frustration with receiving refunds
for postponed or cancelled events.\6\ H.R. 3950 would require a
refund for any event that is postponed or cancelled. It would
also require ticket sellers to disclose clearly and
conspicuously their policy regarding issuing refunds.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\Angry Fans Say First the Concerts Were Canceled, Then the
Refunds, New York Times (January 21, 2021).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Deceptive URLs are another major issue in the event
ticketing industry. These deceptive websites look like they are
affiliated with a venue or team but are not. These URLs can
deceive consumers and cause confusion.\7\ H.R 3950 would ban
deceptive URLs and require secondary market ticket issuers and
exchanges clearly state that they are engaged in the secondary
sale of an event ticket.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\House Committee on Energy and Commerce, Testimony of David
Touhey, Principal, Connett Consulting, Hearing on Proposals to Enhance
Product Safety and Transparency for Americans, 118th Cong. (September
27, 2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
By requiring sellers of event tickets on the primary and
secondary markets to disclose comprehensive information to
consumers about ticket prices, ticket procurement service,
refunds, and by curbing deceptive websites claiming to sell
event tickets, H.R. 3950 will enhance the transparency of the
event ticketing market for consumers. Additionally, it will
provide an enforcement mechanism for fake and deceptive
websites claiming to be selling legitimate event tickets.
Committee Action
On September 27, 2023, the Subcommittee on Innovation,
Data, and Commerce held a hearing on H.R. 3950, as well a
discussion draft to address speculative ticketing reforms. The
hearing title was ``Proposals to Enhance Product Safety and
Transparency for Americans.'' The Subcommittee received
testimony from:
Kathleen Callahan, Owner, Xpertech Auto
Repair;
Scott Benavidez, Chairman, Automotive
Service Association;
Steven Michael Gentine, Counsel, Arnold &
Porter, LLP;
John Breyault, Vice President of Public
Policy, Telecommunications and Fraud, National
Consumers League; and,
David Touhey, Principal, Connett Consulting,
appearing on behalf of International Association of
Venue Managers.
On November 2, 2023, the Subcommittee on Innovation, Data,
and Commerce met in open markup session and forwarded H.R.
3950, without amendment, along with a separate bill to restrict
speculative ticketing, to the full Committee by voice vote.
On December 5 and 6, 2023, the full Committee on Energy and
Commerce met in open markup session and ordered H.R. 3950, as
amended (including of H.R. 6568, the Speculative Ticketing
Oversight and Prohibition Act, to restrict speculative
ticketing), favorably reported to the House by a record vote of
45 yeas and 0 nays.
Congressional Budget Office Estimate
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII, the following is
the cost estimate provided by the Congressional Budget Office
pursuant to section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974:
Summary of legislation: On December 6, 2023, the House
Committee on Energy and Commerce ordered reported 41 bills.
This document provides estimates for 7 of those bills.
The bills would require the Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
to enforce new prohibitions and requirements or would direct
the Department of Commerce to study various issues and report
to the Congress.
Estimated Federal cost: The bills' costs fall within budget
function 370 (commerce and housing credit).
Basis of estimate: For this estimate, CBO assumes that the
bills will be enacted near the middle of fiscal year 2024. The
estimated costs do not include any interaction effects among
the bills. If all seven bills were combined and enacted as a
single piece of legislation, the estimated costs would be
different from the sum of the separate estimates, although CBO
expects that any difference would be small.
CBO estimates that implementing each of the seven bills
would cost between $1 million and $4 million over the 2024-2029
period; that spending would be subject to the availability of
appropriated funds.
Four bills--H.R. 2964, H.R. 3950, H.R. 6125, and H.R.
6543--would each increase revenues by an insignificant amount.
Entities that fail to meet each of those bills' new
requirements could face civil penalties, which are recorded in
the federal budget as revenues. To some extent, collection of
any civil fines would depend on the amount of appropriations
provided by future appropriation acts to pay for enforcement.
In addition, whether the FTC would pursue civil penalties or
some other remedy for violations is unclear. In any event, CBO
expects that companies would generally comply with the new
requirements and that any additional revenues collected over
the 2024-2034 period would be insignificant for each bill.
H.R. 2964, WIPPES Act: The bill would require manufacturers
and suppliers of disposable wipes to clearly mark their
products with a ``do not flush'' label and symbol. The FTC
would enforce those requirements.
Based on the cost of similar provisions, CBO estimates that
implementing H.R. 2964 would cost the FTC $4 million to issue
guidance and to monitor and enforce violations. In addition,
CBO estimates that enacting the bill could increase civil
penalty collections, which are recorded in the federal budget
as revenues, by an insignificant amount.
H.R. 3950, TICKET Act: The bill would require companies
that issue tickets or that sell tickets on the secondary market
to clearly display the total price of any ticket, including
itemizing any fees not included in the base ticket price. That
requirement would apply to live events at venues with an
attendance capacity of 200 people or more. The FTC would
enforce those requirements.
Based on the cost of similar provisions, CBO estimates that
implementing H.R. 3950 would cost the FTC $4 million to issue
guidance and to monitor and enforce violations. In addition,
CBO estimates that enacting the bill could increase civil
penalty collections, which are recorded in the federal budget
as revenues, by an insignificant amount.
H.R. 5146, Advancing Gig Economy Act: The bill would
require the Department of Commerce to study and report to the
Congress within two years of enactment on how the gig economy
affects U.S. businesses.
Based on the cost of similar studies, CBO estimates that
implementing H.R. 5146 would cost $2 million over two years for
the work of four employees, at an annual cost of about $220,000
each, along with purchases of data and survey contracts.
H.R. 5390, Critical Infrastructure Manufacturing
Feasibility Act: The bill would require the Department of
Commerce to study and report to the Congress within one year of
enactment on the feasibility of manufacturing in the United
States products in critical infrastructure sectors that now are
imported because of supply chain constraints.
Based on the cost of similar studies, CBO estimates that
implementing H.R. 5390 would cost $1 million for one year for
the work of four employees, at a cost of about $220,000 each,
along with purchases of data and survey contracts.
H.R. 5398, Advancing Tech Startups Act: The bill would
require the Department of Commerce to study and report to the
Congress within two years of enactment on how technology
startup companies affect the U.S. economy.
Based on the cost of similar studies, CBO estimates that
implementing H.R. 5398 would cost $2 million over two years for
the work of four employees, at an annual cost of about $220,000
each, along with purchases of data and survey contracts.
H.R. 6125, Online Dating Safety Act of 2023: The bill would
require providers of online dating services to notify a user if
they are contacted by a member whose account was suspended or
terminated because of fraudulent activity. The FTC would
enforce those requirements.
Based on the cost of similar provisions, CBO estimates that
implementing H.R. 6125 would cost the FTC $4 million to issue
guidance and to monitor and enforce violations. In addition,
CBO estimates that enacting the bill could increase civil
penalty collections, which are recorded in the federal budget
as revenues, by an insignificant amount.
H.R. 6543, No Hidden FEES Act of 2023: The bill would
require providers of short-term lodging and websites that
advertise or offer such lodging to display each mandatory fee
required to complete a booking. The FTC would enforce those
requirements.
Based on the cost of similar provisions, CBO estimates that
implementing H.R. 6543 would cost the FTC $4 million to issue
guidance and to monitor and enforce violations. In addition,
CBO estimates that enacting the bill could increase civil
penalty collections, which are recorded in the federal budget
as revenues, by an insignificant amount.
Pay-As-You-Go considerations: CBO estimates that enacting
H.R. 2964, H.R. 3950, H.R. 6125, and H.R. 6543 would each
increase revenues by less than $500,000 over the 2024-2034
period; therefore, pay-as-you-go procedures apply to those
bills.
Increase in long-term net direct spending and deficits:
None of the bills would increase net direct spending or on-
budget deficits in any of the four consecutive 10-year periods
beginning in 2035.
Mandates: The following bills--H.R. 2964, H.R. 3950, H.R.
6125, and H.R. 6543--would impose mandates as defined in the
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (UMRA).
H.R. 2964, WIPPES Act: The bill would impose
intergovernmental and private-sector mandates, but CBO
estimates that the costs to comply with those mandates would
not exceed the thresholds established in UMRA ($100 million and
$200 million in 2024, respectively, adjusted annually for
inflation).
H.R. 2964 would preempt some state and local laws governing
the labeling of certain disposable wipes. Although the
preemptions would limit the application of state and local
laws, they would impose no duty on state or local governments
that would result in significant spending or loss of revenues.
The bill would require manufacturers of certain disposable
wipes to clearly mark their products with a ``do not flush''
label and symbol. Because manufacturers already are complying
with similar laws enacted in California, Illinois, and several
other states, CBO estimates that the cost for manufacturers to
comply with the mandate would be small.
H.R. 3950, TICKET Act: The bill would impose private-sector
mandates as defined in UMRA on ticket sellers and resellers by
requiring certain changes, including new refund policies, to
the ticketing process. CBO estimates that the aggregate cost to
comply with the mandates would be above the threshold
established in UMRA for private-sector mandates ($200 million
in 2024, adjusted annually for inflation).
Under the bill, if an event is canceled, ticket sellers and
resellers would be required to refund the full ticket price,
including taxes and fees, to purchasers. If an event is
postponed, sellers and resellers would be required to offer
customers either a full refund or a replacement ticket, if
available, subject to the customer's preference. Sellers also
would be required to disclose this refund policy. The bill
allows for exceptions to this policy in cases where the
cancellation or postponement is beyond the control of the
ticket issuer, such as natural disasters. Based on discussions
with industry sources, a substantial share of sellers and
resellers already provide full refunds for canceled events but
few offer refunds for postponed events. Considerable
uncertainty surrounds the ways that federal regulations might
define what is within the control of a ticket issuer in the
event of a cancellation or postponement or what might
constitute comparable replacement events. Given the large size
of the industry and the amount of revenue generated by ticketed
events, CBO estimates that the cost of the mandate would exceed
the threshold for private-sector mandates.
H.R. 3950 also would require ticket sellers and resellers
to make certain up-front disclosures to consumers. They would
need to disclose the total ticket prices, including taxes and
fees. Those disclosures would occur when the ticket is first
displayed to the consumer and in any advertisements or
marketing. The bill also would require sellers and resellers to
provide purchasers with an itemized list of the base price and
all fees. Information from the industry indicates that most
ticket sellers have already begun to provide the total cost to
consumers in advance; thus, CBO expects that the additional
requirements in the bill would have small costs for ticket
sellers and resellers.
The bill also would require ticket resellers to disclose to
consumers that they are resellers before any purchase is
complete. Sellers and resellers would be prohibited from
advertising or selling any ticket that the seller does not
actually or constructively possess. In certain instances,
sellers also would be prohibited from revealing to consumers
and using the names of venues, teams, artists, and events in
their online domain names. CBO expects that those disclosures
and prohibitions would impose minimal costs on the sellers.
The bill contains no intergovernmental mandates as defined
in UMRA.
H.R. 6125, Online Dating Safety Act of 2023: The bill would
impose intergovernmental and private-sector mandates, but CBO
estimates that the costs to comply with those mandates would
not exceed the thresholds established in UMRA ($100 million and
$200 million in 2024, respectively, adjusted annually for
inflation).
The bill would preempt state laws governing fraud
notifications issued by online dating services. Although the
preemptions would limit the application of state and local
laws, they would impose no duty on state or local governments
that would result in significant spending or loss of revenues.
H.R. 6125 would require providers of online dating services
to send a fraud notification to consumers who receive a message
from any member who has been banned by the service. Because
some states already require those fraud notifications, most
dating services have implemented the policy regardless of the
consumer's location. Therefore, CBO expects that the cost to
comply with the mandate would be small.
H.R. 6543, No Hidden FEES Act of 2023: The bill would
impose intergovernmental and private-sector mandates, but CBO
estimates that the costs to comply with those mandates would
not exceed the thresholds established in UMRA ($100 million and
$200 million in 2024, respectively, adjusted annually for
inflation).
The bill would preempt state and local laws governing the
display of prices for short-term lodging. Although the
preemptions would limit the application of state and local
laws, they would impose no duty on state or local governments
that would result in significant spending or loss of revenues.
H.R. 6543 would prohibit providers, online booking
websites, and advertisers of short-term lodging from displaying
prices that do not include all mandatory fees. Information from
industry sources and the FTC indicates that several lodging
providers already comply with provisions in the bill, and CBO
expects the cost for other entities to comply would be small
because they already possess the fee information required to be
displayed.
Previous CBO estimate: On October 25, 2023, CBO transmitted
a cost estimate for S. 1303, the TICKET Act, as reported by the
Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation on
September 12, 2023. Under H.R. 3950, regulated companies would
be required to fulfill requirements that are additional to
those specified in S. 1303; for example, if an event is
canceled or postponed, a ticket seller would need to provide a
full refund or replacement ticket. In addition, H.R. 3950 would
require the FTC to report to the Congress on its enforcement of
the Better Online Ticket Sales Act of 2016. CBO's estimated
federal costs for both bills are the same. Because of the
additional refund requirements on ticket sellers and resellers
in H.R. 3950, CBO has determined that the cost of the private-
sector mandates is above the threshold.
Estimate prepared by: Federal Costs: David Hughes,
Mandates: Rachel Austin and Grace Watson.
Estimate reviewed by: Justin Humphrey, Chief, Finance,
Housing, and Education Cost Estimates Unit; Kathleen
FitzGerald, Chief, Public and Private Mandates Unit; H. Samuel
Papenfuss, Deputy Director of Budget Analysis.
Estimate approved by: Phillip L. Swagel, Director,
Congressional Budget Office.
FEDERAL MANDATES STATEMENT
The Committee adopts as its own the estimate of Federal
mandates prepared by the Director of the Congressional Budget
Office pursuant to section 423 of the Unfunded Mandates Reform
Act.
STATEMENT OF GENERAL PERFORMANCE GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of rule XIII, the general
performance goal or objective of this legislation is to provide
the following in the field of event ticketing: upfront, all-
inclusive ticket price disclosures; speculative ticketing ban;
limit the use of deceptive websites in the sale of event
tickets; provide refund requirements; and study the FTC's
enforcement of the Better Online Ticket Sales Act of 2016.
DUPLICATION OF FEDERAL PROGRAMS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of rule XIII, no provision of
H.R. 3950 is known to be duplicative of another Federal
program, including any program that was included in a report to
Congress pursuant to section 21 of Public Law 111-139 or the
most recent Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance.
RELATED COMMITTEE AND SUBCOMMITTEE HEARINGS
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(6) of rule XIII, the following
related hearing was used to develop or consider H.R. 3950:
On September 27, 2023, the Subcommittee on
Innovation, Data, and Commerce held a hearing on H.R.
3950, as well a discussion draft to address speculative
ticketing reforms. The hearing title was ``Proposals to
Enhance Product Safety and Transparency for
Americans.'' The Subcommittee received testimony from:
Kathleen Callahan, Owner,
Xpertech Auto Repair;
Scott Benavidez, Chairman,
Automotive Service Association;
Steven Michael Gentine, Counsel,
Arnold & Porter, LLP;
John Breyault, Vice President of
Public Policy, Telecommunications and Fraud,
National Consumers League; and,
David Touhey, Principal, Connett
Consulting, appearing on behalf of
International Association of Venue Managers
COMMITTEE COST ESTIMATE
Pursuant to clause 3(d)(1) of rule XIII, the Committee
adopts as its own the cost estimate prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 402 of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974
EARMARK, LIMITED TAX BENEFITS, AND LIMITED TARIFF BENEFITS
Pursuant to clause 9(e), 9(f), and 9(g) of rule XXI, the
Committee finds that H.R. 3950 contains no earmarks, limited
tax benefits, or limited tariff benefits.
ADVISORY COMMITTEE STATEMENT
No advisory committees within the meaning of section 5(b)
of the Federal Advisory Committee Act were created by this
legislation.
APPLICABILITY TO LEGISLATIVE BRANCH
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
SECTION-BY-SECTION ANALYSIS OF THE LEGISLATION
Section 1. Short title
Section 1 provides that the Act may be cited as the
``Transparency In Charges for Key Events Ticketing Act'' or the
``TICKET Act.''
Section 2. All inclusive ticket price disclosure
Section 2 makes it unlawful for a ticket issuer, secondary
market ticket issuer, or secondary market ticket exchange to
offer for sale an event ticket unless: (1) the issuer or
exchange clearly and conspicuously displays the total event
ticket price; (2) clearly and conspicuously discloses to a
prospective purchaser the total event ticket price the first
time the price is displayed and anytime thereafter throughout
the ticket buying process; and (3) provides an itemized list of
the base event ticket price and each ticket fee prior to the
completion of the purchase of a ticket.
Section 3. Speculative ticketing ban
Section 3 prohibits an issuer or ticket exchange from
selling, offering for sale, or advertising such sale of an
event ticket for a ticket that the issuer or exchange does not
have actual or constructive possession of. This section does
not prohibit an issuer or exchange from offering a service to
consumers to obtain an event ticket on behalf of the consumer
so long as the issuer or exchange complies with the following:
(1) does not list the service as an event ticket; (2) maintains
clear, distinct, and easily discernable separation between the
service and event tickets through unavoidable visual
demarcation that persists throughout the entire service
selection and purchasing process; (3) clearly and conspicuously
discloses before selection of the service that the service is
not an event ticket and the purchase of such a service does not
guarantee an event ticket; (4) should the service be unable to
obtain the specified event ticket, provides the consumer that
purchased the service, within a reasonable amount of time, a
full refund for the total cost of the service, or subject to
availability a replacement ticket in the same or comparable
location with customer approval; and (5) does not exceed ticket
numerical limitations set by the venue and artist for each
respective event.
Section 4. Deceptive websites
Section 4 states that issuers and exchanges must: (1)
provide a clear and conspicuous statement before purchase that
the issuer or exchange is engaged in the secondary sale of
tickets; (2) not state that the issuer or exchange is
affiliated with or endorsed by a venue, team, or artist, unless
such a partnership agreement has been executed; (3) shall not
use a domain name or any subdomain thereof, in t