Dissenting Views
The Committee on the Judiciary, having considered this
Report, reports favorably thereon and recommends that the
Report be approved.
The form of the Resolution that the Committee on the
Judiciary would recommend to the House of Representatives
citing Merrick B. Garland, Attorney General, U.S. Department of
Justice, for contempt of Congress pursuant to this Report is as
follows:
Resolved, That Merrick B. Garland, Attorney General, U.S.
Department of Justice, shall be found to be in contempt of
Congress for failure to comply with a congressional subpoena.
Resolved, That pursuant to 2 U.S.C. Sec. Sec. 192 and 194,
the Speaker of the House of Representatives shall certify the
report of the Committee on the Judiciary, detailing the refusal
of Merrick B. Garland, Attorney General, U.S. Department of
Justice, to produce documents, records, and materials to the
Committee on the Judiciary as directed by subpoena, to the
United States Attorney for the District of Columbia, to the end
that Attorney General Merrick B. Garland be proceeded against
in the manner and form provided by law.
Resolved, That the Speaker of the House shall otherwise
take all appropriate action to enforce the subpoena.
CONTENTS
Page
Executive Summary................................................ 2
Authority and Purpose............................................ 3
Background on the Investigation.................................. 5
The Attorney General's Failure to Produce the Subpoenaed Records
Warrants Contempt.............................................. 11
Conclusion....................................................... 15
Committee Consideration.......................................... 16
Committee Votes.................................................. 16
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 27
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures........................ 27
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 27
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 27
Advisory on Earmarks............................................. 27
Dissenting Views................................................. 27
Executive Summary
In the weeks following the February 5, 2024, release of
Special Counsel Robert K. Hur's report, the three House
Committees conducting an impeachment inquiry to determine
whether to draft articles of impeachment against President
Joseph R. Biden\1\ engaged with the Department of Justice to
obtain a limited set of documents and records related to the
report. After the Department declined to provide the Committees
with the relevant documents and records, the Committee on the
Judiciary (``Judiciary Committee'') and the Committee on
Oversight and Accountability (``Oversight Committee'') issued
identical subpoenas on February 27, 2024, to Attorney General
Merrick B. Garland compelling production of four specific
categories of documents and records, including audio and video
recordings of Special Counsel Hur's interviews with President
Biden and his ghostwriter, Mark Zwonitzer.\2\ The Judiciary
Committee subpoenaed these materials for several reasons--
including to determine whether sufficient grounds exist to
draft articles of impeachment against President Biden for
consideration by the full House of Representatives and to
determine if legislation is needed to codify procedures
governing the Department's special counsel investigations or to
strengthen the Department's commitment to impartial justice. To
date, the Department has refused to produce the audio
recordings.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\H.R. Res. 918, 118th Cong. (2023).
\2\Letter from Rep. Jim Jordan, Chairman. H. Comm. on the
Judiciary, and Rep. James Comer, Chairman, H. Comm. on Oversight &
Accountability, to Hon. Merrick B. Garland, Att'y Gen., U.S. Dep't of
Justice (Feb. 27, 2024) (hereinafter ``Subpoena Letter'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During Special Counsel Hur's investigation, his team
uncovered evidence that President Biden ``willfully retained
and disclosed classified materials after his vice presidency
when he was a private citizen.''\3\ Special Counsel Hur found
that then-Vice President Biden had ``strong motivations'' to
flout the rules for properly handling classified materials.\4\
In particular, Special Counsel Hur observed that ``months
before leaving office'' as vice president, President Biden
decided to write a book for ``an advance of $8 million.''\5\
The classified materials retained by President Biden were an
``invaluable resource that he consulted liberally'' while
writing his book so that he could give his ghostwriter ``raw
material . . . detailing meetings and events that would be of
interest to prospective readers and buyers of his book.''\6\
Additionally, Special Counsel Hur observed that President Biden
viewed the classified materials ``as an irreplaceable
contemporaneous record of some of the most important moments of
his vice presidency[,]'' which ``was valuable to him for many
reasons, including to help defend his record and buttress his
legacy as a world leader.''\7\ Despite this evidence, Special
Counsel Hur ultimately concluded that no criminal charges were
warranted.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Report on the Investigation Into Unauthorized Removal,
Retention, and Disclosure of Classified Documents Discovered at
Locations Including the Penn Biden Center and the Delaware Private
Residence of President Joseph R. Biden, Jr., Special Counsel Robert K.
Hur, U.S. Dep't of Justice at 1 (Feb. 2024) (hereinafter ``Hur
Report'').
\4\Id. at 231.
\5\Id. at 141, 231.
\6\Id. at 231.
\7\Id. at 231-32.
\8\Id. at 345.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
President Biden has vehemently denied the findings in
Special Counsel Hur's report and he and his legal team have
attempted to frame Special Counsel Hur's mention of President
Biden's poor memory as ``gratuitous.''\9\ Yet during his
testimony before the Committee, Special Counsel Hur stated
that, ``[t]he evidence and the President himself put his memory
squarely at issue.''\10\ In his report, Special Counsel Hur
noted that, during both his and Zwonitzer's interviews with
President Biden, the president's ``memory was significantly
limited,'' and he ``struggle[ed] to remember events and
strain[ed] at times to read and relay his own
[handwriting].''\11\ Special Counsel Hur also observed that
President Biden ``did not remember when he was vice
president,'' ``for[got] when his [vice presidential] term
ended,'' and ``did not remember, even within several years,
when his son Beau died.''\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Rebecca Beitsch, et al., Special counsel overstepped mandate
with `gratuitous' Biden slams, say ex-DOJ Dems, The Hill (Feb. 12,
2024) (```When the inevitable conclusion is that the facts and the
evidence don't support any charges,' said Ian Sams, a spokesman for the
White House's special counsel office, `you're left to wonder why this
report spends time making gratuitous and inappropriate criticisms of
the president.'''); see Letter from Mr. Richard Sauber, Special Counsel
to the President, The White House, and Mr. Bob Bauer, Personal Counsel
to Joseph R. Biden. Jr., to Mr. Bradley Weinsheimer, Assoc. Deputy
Att'y Gen., U.S. Dep't of Justice at 2-3 (Feb. 12, 2024) (``This is the
very definition of a derogatory comment''. . . .).
\10\Hearing on the Report of Special Counsel Robert Hur: Hearing
Before the H. Comm. on the Judiciary, 118th Cong. 17 (2024) (statement
of Special Counsel Robert K. Hur, U.S. Dep't of Justice) (hereinafter
``Hearing on Hur Report'').
\11\Hur Report, supra note 3, at 207.
\12\Id. at 207-08.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Department continues to withhold key material
responsive to the subpoenas from the Judiciary and Oversight
Committees--specifically the audio recordings of Special
Counsel Hur's interviews with President Biden and Zwonitzer.
Its failure to fully comply with the Committees' subpoenas has
hindered the House's ability to adequately conduct oversight
over Special Counsel Hur regarding his investigative findings
and the President's retention and disclosure of classified
materials and impeded the Committees' impeachment inquiry.
Authority and Purpose
The Constitution vests the House of Representatives with
the ``sole Power of Impeachment''\13\ and provides that the
``President, Vice President and all civil Officers of the
United States, shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for,
and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and
Misdemeanors.''\14\ As the U.S. Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia Circuit has stated, ``[t]o level the grave
accusation that a President may have committed `Treason,
Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors,' U.S. Const.
art. II, Sec. 4, the House must be appropriately
informed.''\15\ Congress's authority to access information
during an impeachment investigation is broader in certain
instances than in a purely legislative investigation,\16\ a
fact that the executive branch traditionally has
recognized.\17\ Investigating and collecting all relevant
evidence is the traditional means by which the House begins an
impeachment inquiry.\18\ Indeed, conducting an impeachment
inquiry without all pertinent evidence would be an affront to
the Constitution and irreparably damage public faith in the
impeachment process.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\U.S. Const. art. I, Sec. 2, cl. 5.
\14\Id. art. II, Sec. 4.
\15\Comm. on Judiciary of U.S. House of Representatives v. McGahn,
968 F.3d 755, 765 (D.C. Cir. 2020) (en banc).
\16\Todd Garvey, Cong. Rsch. Serv.: Legal Sidebar, LSB11083,
Impeachment Investigations, Part II: Access, at 1 (2023) (``[T]here is
reason to believe that invocation of the impeachment power could
improve the committees' legal claims of access to certain types of
evidence relevant to the allegations of misconduct against President
Biden.''). See also In re Application of Comm. on Judiciary, 414 F.
Supp. 3d 129, 176 (D.D.C. 2019) (``[D]enying [the House Judiciary
Committee] evidence relevant to an impeachment inquiry could pose
constitutional problems.''), aff'd, 951 F.3d 589 (D.C. Cir. 2020),
vacated and remanded sub nom. on other grounds, DOJ v. House Comm. on
the Judiciary, 142 S. Ct. 46 (2021); In re Request for Access to Grand
Jury Materials, 833 F.2d 1438, 1445 (11th Cir. 1987) (concluding that
``limit[ing] the investigatory power of the House in impeachment
proceedings . . . would clearly violate separation of powers
principles'').
\17\See Garvey, supra note 16 (``As a historical matter, all three
branches have suggested that the House possesses a robust right of
access to information when it is investigating for impeachment
purposes.''); Jonathan David Schaub, The Executive's Privilege, 70 Duke
L.J. 1, 87 (2020) (``[P]residents and others have recognized throughout
the history of the country that their ability to withhold information
from Congress disappears in the context of impeachment.'').
\18\See, e.g., H.R. Rep. No. 116-346, at 28 (2019) (``Here,
consistent with historical practice, the House divided its impeachment
inquiry into two phases, first collecting evidence and then bringing
that evidence before the Judiciary Committee for its consideration of
articles of impeachment.''); H.R. Rep. No. 111-427, at 7 (2010)
(``[T]he impeachment inquiry was referred by the Committee on the
Judiciary to a Task Force on Judicial Impeachment . . ., comprised of
12 Committee Members, to conduct the investigation.''). See also
Hearing on the Basis for the Impeachment Inquiry of President Joseph R.
Biden: Before the H. Comm. on Oversight & Accountability, 118th Cong.
(Sept. 28, 2023) (statement of Jonathan Turley, Professor, The George
Washington University Law School); Memorandum from Rep. Jim Jordan,
Chairman, H. Comm. on the Judiciary, Rep. James Comer, Chairman, H.
Comm. on Oversight & Accountability, and Rep. Jason Smith, Chairman, H.
Comm. on Ways & Means, to Members of the H. Comm. on the Judiciary, H.
Comm. on Oversight & Accountability, and H. Comm. on Ways & Means
(Sept. 27, 2023) (hereinafter ``Sept. 27 Memo'').
\19\See In re Application of Comm. on Judiciary, 414 F. Supp. 3d at
176 (``Impeachment based on anything less than all relevant evidence
would compromise the public's faith in the process.''); In re Request
for Access to Grand Jury Materials, 833 F.2d at 1445 (``Public
confidence in a procedure as political and public as impeachment is an
important consideration justifying disclosure.''); In re Report and
Recommendation of June 5, 1972 Grand Jury, 370 F. Supp. 1219, 1230
(D.D.C. 1974) (``It would be difficult to conceive of a more compelling
need than that of this country for an unswervingly fair [impeachment]
inquiry based on all the pertinent information.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On September 27, 2023, pursuant to the directive of the
Speaker, the Chairs of three House Committees (the Judiciary,
Oversight, and Ways and Means Committees) released a memorandum
setting forth the justification for and scope of the inquiry
into whether sufficient grounds exist to draft articles of
impeachment against President Biden.\20\ On December 13, 2023,
the House of Representatives adopted House Resolution 918,
directing these three Committees to continue the ongoing
impeachment inquiry.\21\ By approving House Resolution 918, the
House also adopted House Resolution 917,\22\ which provided
that ``[t]he authority provided by clause 2(m) of rule XI of
the Rules of the House of Representatives to the Chairs of the
Committees . . . included, from the beginning of the existing
House of Representatives impeachment inquiry . . . and
continues to include, so long as the impeachment inquiry is
ongoing, the authority to issue subpoenas on behalf of such
Committees for the purpose of furthering the impeachment
inquiry.''\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\Sept. 27 Memo, supra note 18.
\21\H.R. Res. 918, 118th Cong. (2023).
\22\H.R. Res. 917, 118th Cong. (2023).
\23\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The subpoenas issued to the Department by the Judiciary and
Oversight Committees are part of the House's impeachment
inquiry. As explained in detail below, the requested documents
and materials are necessary to determine whether sufficient
grounds exist to draft articles of impeachment against
President Biden.
However, the impeachment inquiry is not the only purpose
underlying the Committee's subpoena; it was also issued
pursuant to the Committee's authority to conduct legislative
oversight.\24\ Article I of the Constitution vests in Congress
a ``broad'' and ``indispensable'' power to conduct oversight
and investigations that ``encompasses inquiries into the
administration of existing laws, studies of proposed laws, and
surveys in our social, economic or political system for the
purpose of enabling Congress to remedy them.''\25\ Pursuant to
the Rules of the House of Representatives, the Committee on the
Judiciary is authorized to conduct oversight of the Department
and of criminal justice matters in the United States to inform
potential legislative reforms.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\See Rules of the U.S. House of Representatives, R. XI, cl.
2(m)(1) (2023) (providing that ``a committee or subcommittee is
authorized . . . (B) to require, by subpoena or otherwise, the
attendance and testimony of such witnesses and the production of such
books, records, correspondence, memoranda, papers, and documents as it
considers necessary''); Rules of the H. Comm. on Oversight &
Accountability, R. 12(g) (``The Chair of the Committee shall . . .
[a]uthorize and issue subpoenas as provided in House Rule XI, clause
2(m), in the conduct of any investigation or activity or series of
investigations or activities within the jurisdiction of the
Committee.); Rules of the H. Comm. on the Judiciary, R. IV(a) (``A
subpoena may be authorized and issued by the Chair, in accordance with
clause 2(m) of rule XI of the House of Representatives, in the conduct
of any investigation or activity or series of investigations or
activities within the jurisdiction of the Committee, following
consultation with the Ranking Minority Member.'').
\25\Watkins v. United States, 354 U.S. 178, 187, 215 (1957).
\26\Rules of the U.S. House of Representatives, R. X, cl. 1(l)
(2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To further the Committee's constitutionally mandated
oversight and legislative duties, the Committee must ensure
compliance with duly authorized congressional subpoenas. The
information that the Committee requires, and the Department is
in possession of, is necessary for the Committee to consider
potential legislative reforms to the Department and its use of
special counsels to conduct investigations of current and
former Presidents of the United States. These potential
legislative reforms may include, among other things, codifying
certain procedures governing the Department's special counsel
investigations to better ensure that the Department pursues
impartial justice. The circumstances of Special Counsel Hur's
investigative findings and President Biden's public denial of
these findings demonstrate why such potential legislative
reforms may be necessary.
Background on the Investigation
According to the report of Special Counsel Robert K. Hur,
in November 2022, Patrick Moore, one of President Biden's
personal attorneys, discovered 44 pages of documents
``classified up to the Top Secret level'' stemming from his
tenure as Vice President at President Biden's office in
Washington, D.C., located at the Penn Biden Center.\27\ Moore
notified his colleague Bob Bauer, who then notified White House
Counsel Stuart Delery.\28\ The same day, the White House
Counsel's Office passed the information along to the National
Archives and Records Administration (NARA), which retrieved the
documents, and referred the case to the Department and Federal
Bureau of Investigation (FBI).\29\ Additionally, between
December 2022 and January 2023, Bauer, Moore, and another Biden
personal counsel, Jennifer Miller, discovered additional
classified materials, also from his tenure as Vice P
Committee Consideration
On May 16, 2024, the Committee met in open session and
ordered the report favorably reported to the House with an
amendment in the nature of a substitute by a recorded vote of
18 to 15, a quorum being present.
Committee Votes
In compliance with clause 3(b) of House rule XIII, the
Committee states that the following recorded votes occurred
during the Committee's consideration of the Report:
1. Vote on Amendment #1 to the Report ANS offered by
Mr. Nadler--failed 8 ayes to 17 nays.
2. Vote on Amendment #2 to the Report ANS offered by
Mr. Johnson--failed 5 ayes to 12 nays.
3. Vote on Amendment #3 to the Report ANS offered by
Ms. Dean--failed 5 ayes to 12 nays.
4. Vote on Amendment #4 to the Report ANS offered by
Mr. Johnson--failed 5 ayes to 12 nays.
5. Vote on Amendment #5 to the Report ANS offered by
Ms. Dean--failed 5 ayes to 12 nays.
6. Vote on Amendment #6 to the Report ANS offered by
Mr. Ivey--failed 8 ayes to 9 nays.
7. Vote on Amendment #7 to the Report ANS offered by
Mr. Swalwell--failed 9 ayes to 12 nays.
8. Vote on Amendment #8 to the Report ANS offered by
Ms. Scanlon--failed 9 ayes to 12 nays.
9. Vote on Amendment #9 to the Report ANS offered by
Mr. Armstrong--passed 15 ayes to 11 nays.
10. Vote on favorably reporting the Report, as
amended--passed 18 ayes to 15 nays.
[GRAPHIC(S) NOT AVAILABLE IN TIFF FORMAT]
Committee Oversight Findings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee advises that the findings and recommendations of the
Committee, based on oversight activities under clause 2(b)(1)
of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives, are
incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures
The Committee finds the requirements of clause 3(c)(2) of
rule XIII and section 308(a) of the Congressional Budget Act of
1974, and the requirements of clause 3(c)(3) of rule XIII and
section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974, to be
inapplicable to this Report. Accordingly, the Committee did not
request or receive a cost estimate from the Congressional
Budget Office and makes no findings as to the budgetary impacts
of this Report or costs incurred to carry out the Report.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII, no provision
of this Report establishes or reauthorizes a program of the
federal government known to be duplicative of another federal
program.
Performance Goals and Objectives
The Committee states that pursuant to clause 3(c)(4) of
House rule XIII, this Report is to enforce the Committee's
authority to subpoena and obtain testimony related to
determining whether sufficient grounds exist to impeach
President Joseph Robinette Biden Jr., and legislative reforms
to the Department of Justice and its use of a special counsel
to conduct investigations of current and former Presidents of
the United States.
Advisory on Earmarks
In accordance with clause 9 of House rule XXI, this Report
does not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in clauses
9(d), 9(e), or 9(f) of House Rule XXI.
Dissenting Views
I. Introduction
The Majority is clearly disappointed that Special Counsel
Robert Hur declined to bring charges against President Biden,
the latest blow in a long line of apparent disappointments.
After spending more than twenty million taxpayer dollars on a
weaponization subcommittee going nowhere, after conducting
dozens of witness interviews, and after reviewing millions of
pages of documents, the Majority has failed to find even a
shred of evidence of wrongdoing by the President. Their
impeachment investigation fizzled out before they could even
clearly articulate a charge. A total lack of policy
accomplishments only compounds their obvious frustration as we
approach the last months of this do-nothing Republican
Congress.
Against this backdrop of failure, the Majority makes one,
last-ditch effort to make it look at least like a member of
President Biden's cabinet did something wrong. To be clear, the
contempt citation the Majority recommends against U.S. Attorney
General Merrick Garland is an absolute farce.
The Attorney General and the Department of Justice have
provided the Committee with all the information it requires to
conduct any legitimate oversight activity. The only discrepancy
between what the Majority requested and what the Department has
produced is a set of audio files--recordings of the interviews
the Special Counsel conducted with President Biden and his
ghost writer. The Majority has never demonstrated a legitimate
reason for obtaining these audio files and certainly cannot
justify a contempt citation on this ground alone.
For a start, the Department of Justice has long since
produced written transcripts of these interviews. The
Department has also expressed serious and legitimate concern
that releasing the audio files would have a chilling effect on
high-profile witnesses in future criminal investigations. To
that end, the President, in consultation with the Attorney
General, has claimed Executive Privilege over the remaining
audio files.
It seems painfully obvious that the Majority wants these
recordings because they hope to find something they can use to
embarrass President Biden. They have certainly amplified
manipulated audio and video evidence for political purposes in
the past. The only surprise is that--after so many of their
members have admitted that their single motivation is to
provide political cover for Donald Trump--the Majority still
feels the need to hide behind a half-hearted interest in
``vocal tone, pace, inflections, verbal nuance, and other
idiosyncrasies.'' What a sham.
This contempt proceeding is a political stunt and nothing
more. It should be roundly defeated.
II. Background
On January 12, 2023, Attorney General Merrick Garland
appointed Robert Hur, formerly the Trump-appointed U.S.
Attorney for the District of Maryland, as Special Counsel
charged with investigating President Biden's handling of
classified documents.\1\ Hur focused on five categories of
documents: (1) documents related to Afghanistan, in particular
a handwritten memo from then-Vice President Biden to President
Obama dated November 28, 2009, detailing his concerns about
deploying additional troops to the country;\2\ (2) personal
notebooks from the President's time as Vice President;\3\ (3)
certain documents found at the Penn Biden Center, including
documents related to negotiations about the Iran nuclear
deal;\4\ (4) documents found at the University of Delaware
dating to the President's time as a senator;\5\ and (5) other
documents found in the President's Delaware home, including
briefing binders from trips that the President took while he
was vice president.\6\ Over the course of Hur's 15-month probe,
his investigators conducted 173 interviews of 147 witnesses and
reviewed more than seven million documents. Hur submitted his
345-page final report to Attorney General Garland on February
5, 2024, and Garland publicly released it in full on February
8, 2024.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Press Release, Appointment of Robert K. Hur as Special Counsel,
U.S. Dep't of Justice (Jan. 12, 2023), https://www.justice.gov/d9/2023-
01/Order.Appointment%20of%20Robert%20
Hur.11223%20%28002%29.pdf.
\2\Special Counsel Robert K. Hur, Report on the Investigation Into
Unauthorized Removal, Retention, and Disclosure of Classified Documents
Discovered at Locations Including the Penn Biden Center and the
Delaware Private Residence of President Joseph R. Biden, Jr., U.S.
Dep't of Justice at 145-48 (Feb. 8, 2024), https://www.justice.gov/
storage/report-from-special-counsel-robert-k-hur-february-2024.pdf
[Hereinafter Hur Report].
\3\Id. at 2-3.
\4\Id. at 256-311.
\5\Id. at 312-25.
\6\Id. at 326-33.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Hur Report exonerates President Biden of any
prosecutable charges. Specifically, to be charged with the
unauthorized retention of national defense information under
the Espionage Act, the government must show that ``(1) the
defendant had unauthorized possession of a document, writing or
note; (2) the document, writing, or note related to the
national defense; and (3) the defendant willfully retained the
document, writing, or note and failed to deliver it to an
employee or officer entitled to receive it.''\7\ Hur found that
there was no evidence that the President willfully retained
classified information. He also found that the President likely
did not know certain information was classified and that he
likely believed he was permitted to retain certain documents as
personal records. Hur's report also distinguished Biden's
conduct from that of President Trump.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\Id. at 178 (citation omitted).
\8\Id. at 10-11, 250.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On February 7, 2024, the Attorney General notified the
Committee that Special Counsel Hur had concluded his
investigation.\9\ The following day, the Attorney General
produced the entire unredacted report to Congress and made it
available to the public.\10\ Four days later, Chairman Jordan,
along with House Oversight Chairman James Comer, and House Ways
& Means Chairman Jason Smith wrote to the Attorney General and
demanded that he produce to the Committees:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Letter from the Hon. Merrick B. Garland, Att'y Gen., to the Hon.
Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm. on the Judiciary, et al. (Feb. 7, 2024).
\10\See Letter from the Hon. Merrick B. Garland, Att'y Gen., to the
Hon. Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm. on the Judiciary, et al. (Feb. 8,
2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. All documents and communications, including audio
and video recordings, related to the Special Counsel's
interview of President Biden;
2. All documents and communications, including audio
and video recordings, related to the Special Counsel's
interview of Mark Zwonitzer;
3. The documents identified as ``A9'' and ``A10'' in
Appendix A of Mr. Hur's report, which relate to
President Biden's December 11, 2015 call with then-
Ukrainian Prime Minister Arseniy Yatsenyuk; and
4. All communications between or among
representatives of the Department of Justice, including
the Office of the Special Counsel, the Executive Office
of the President, and President Biden's personal
counsel referring or relating to Mr. Hur's report.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Letter from the Hon. James Comer, Chairman, H. Comm. on
Oversight & Accountability, et al. to the Hon. Merrick Garland, Att'y
Gen. (Feb. 12, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On February 16, 2024, the Department of Justice responded
noting that ``[s]everal of the materials listed in your
February 12 letter require review for classification and
protection of national defense information'' and informed the
Members that ``the Department will conduct a review to assess
confidentiality interests and will share materials with
Executive Branch entities with equities in the content of the
materials to determine whether those other entities will assert
any confidentiality interests of their own.''\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Letter from Carlos Felip Uriarte, Asst. Att'y Gen., to the Hon.
James Comer, Chairman, H. Comm. on Oversight & Accountability, et al.
(Feb. 16, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On February 27, 2024, the Chairmen Jordan and Comer
responded to the DOJ by issuing a subpoena for the requested
documents, claiming that the Department ``offered no timeframe
by which it expected to make productions'' or ``any commitment
that it would produce all of the material requested.''\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\Letter from the Hon. James Comer, Chairman, H. Comm. on
Oversight & Accountability, & the Hon. Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm.
on the Judiciary, to the Hon. Merrick B. Garland, Att'y Gen. (Feb. 27,
2024), https://judiciary.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/republicans-
judiciary.
house.gov/files/evo-media-document/2024-02-
27%20JDJ%20to%20DOJ%20re%20subpoena.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The DOJ responded to the subpoena on March 7, 2024, with
two productions requested by the Committees: (1) the documents
identified as ``A9'' and ``A10'' in Appendix A of the Hur
Report, and (2) communications between the DOJ and the
Executive Office of the President or President Biden's personal
counsel related to Special Counsel Hur's report.\14\ The DOJ
also expressed disappointment that the Committee chose to serve
a subpoena ``less than three weeks after Mr. Hur's report was
transmitted to Congress and only seven business days after the
Department made clear it was working expeditiously to respond
in good faith to congressional requests'' and said that the
subpoena was ``premature and unnecessary given the amount of
information the committee has already received and the
Department's proactive efforts to prepare for responding to
congressional requests on this matter.''\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\ See Letter from Carlos Felip Uriarte, Asst. Att'y Gen., to the
Hon. Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm. on the Judiciary (Mar. 7, 2024).
\15\Id. at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On March 9, 2024, the Chairmen Jordan and Comer wrote yet
another letter to the Attorney General claiming that the DOJ
had yet to fully comply with their subpoenas.\16\ On March 12,
before Special Counsel Hur was set to testify before the
Judiciary Committee, the DOJ produced the transcripts of
Special Counsel Hur's interview of President Biden.\17\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\Letter from the Hon. James Comer, Chairman, H. Comm. on
Oversight & Accountability, & the Hon. Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm.
on the Judiciary, to the Hon. Merrick B. Garland, Att'y Gen. (Mar. 9,
2024).
\17\See Letter from Carlos Felip Uriarte, Asst. Att'y Gen., to the
Hon. Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm. on the Judiciary (Mar. 12, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On March 25, 2024, Chairmen Jordan and Comer once again
notified the DOJ that their compliance with the subpoena was
deficient and requested that the Department provide audio
recordings of Special Counsel Hur's interview of President
Biden and transcripts and audio recordings of Special Counsel
Hur's interview of President Biden's ghostwriter, Mark
Zwonitzer.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\Letter from the Hon. James Comer, Chairman, H. Comm. on
Oversight & Accountability, & the Hon. Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm.
on the Judiciary, to the Hon. Merrick B. Garland, Att'y Gen. (Mar. 25,
2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On April 8, 2024, the DOJ provided the transcripts of
Special Counsel Hur's interviews of ghostwriter Mark Zwonitzer,
which took place on July 31, 2023 and January 4, 2024.\19\ The
DOJ's cover letter notes that the Committees have responded to
the Department's productions with ``escalation and threats of
criminal contempt.''\20\ Further, the DOJ wrote, ``We are
therefore concerned that the Committees are disappointed not
because you didn't receive information, but because you did. We
urge the Committees to avoid conflict rather than seek
it.''\21\ The Committees responded on April 15, 2024, claiming
that the DOJ's ``response to the subpoenas remains inadequate,
suggesting that you are withholding records for partisan
purposes and to avoid political embarrassment for President
Biden.''\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\See Letter from Carlos Felip Uriarte, Asst. Att'y Gen., to the
Hon. Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm. on the Judiciary & the Hon. James
Comer, Chairman, H. Comm. on Oversight & Accountability (Apr. 8, 2024).
\20\Letter from Carlos Felip Uriarte, Asst. Att'y Gen., to the Hon.
Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm. on the Judiciary & the Hon. James Comer,
Chairman, H. Comm. on Oversight & Accountability at 1 (Apr. 8, 2024).
\21\Id.
\22\Letter from the Hon. James Comer, Chairman, H. Comm. on
Oversight & Accountability, & the Hon. Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm.
on the Judiciary, to the Hon. Merrick B. Garland, Att'y Gen. at 1 (Apr.
15, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On May 16, 2024, the Department responded again to the
Committee's requests, including the February 27, 2024,
subpoena, to inform the Committees ``that the President has
asserted executive privilege over the requested audio
recordings and is making a protective assertion of privilege
over any remaining materials responsive to the subpoenas that
have not already been produced.''\23\ In an accompanying
letter, the Attorney General explained that the Department has
a vested interest in protecting ``materials related to a closed
criminal investigation where disclosure is likely to damage
future law enforcement efforts,'' which ``is the case
here.''\24\ The Attorney General further expressed concern that
producing audio recordings to the Committees ``would raise an
unacceptable risk of undermining the Department's ability to
conduct similar high-profile criminal investigations--in
particular, investigations where the voluntary cooperation of
White House officials is exceedingly important.''\25\ Further,
the Attorney General explained that the Committees'
``articulated need for the audio recordings is insufficient to
meet any potentially applicable standard,'' and that the audio
recordings will ``not reveal any information relevant to the
Committees' stated needs that is not available in the
transcripts and other documents that are already in the
Committees' possession.''\26\ The Attorney General requested
that the President make a protective assertion of executive
privilege.\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\Letter from Hon. Carlos F. Uriarte, Assistant Att'y Gen., U.S.
Dep't of Justice, to Rep. Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm. on the
Judiciary, and Rep. James Comer, Chairman, H. Comm. on Oversight &
Accountability at 1 (May 16, 2024).
\24\Letter from the Hon. Merrick B. Garland, Att'y Gen. to The
President at 1 (May 15, 2024).
\25\Id. at 3-4.
\26\Id. at 3, 9.
\27\Id. at 11.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On May 16, 2024, the White House also wrote to the
Committees explaining that ``the President's longstanding
commitment to protecting the integrity, effectiveness, and
independence of the Department of Justice and its law
enforcement investigations'' caused his assertion of executive
privilege.\28\ The White House noted the obvious partisan
motivations behind the Committees' actions, writing, ``[t]he
absence of a legitimate need for the audio recordings lays bare
your likely goal--to chop them up, distort them, and use them
for partisan political purposes.''\29\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\28\Letter from Edward N. Siskel, Counsel to the President, to Rep.
Jim Jordan, Chairman, H. Comm. on the Judiciary, and Rep. James Comer,
Chairman, H. Comm. on Oversight & Accountability at 1 (May 16, 2024).
\29\Id. at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
III. Concerns
A. THE MAJORITY MISREPRESENTS THE FACTUAL RECORD
As a threshold matter, the Majority severely misrepresents
the record throughout its report in numerous material respects.
It is undisputed that Republican-appointed Special Counsel Hur
exonerated President Biden. Hur found insufficient evidence to
prove beyond a reasonable doubt that President Biden willfully
retained any of the classified documents, and in some cases
that the documents themselves were not even classified. The
Majority's shameful portrayal of President Biden as senile or
``incompetent'' is also false and not supported by the special
counsel's own record. President Biden's age was not a material
aspect of Hur's decision to decline prosecution, contrary to
assertions by members of the Majority. Finally, the report
ignores clear historical context provided by the special
counsel regarding President Biden's retention and use of his
notebook, which other Presidents have done.
1. President Biden was Cleared from any Criminal Charges
Special Counsel Hur focused on five categories of documents
in the investigation: (1) documents related to Afghanistan, in
particular a handwritten memo from then-Vice President Biden to
President Obama dated November 28, 2009, detailing his concerns
about deploying additional troops to the country;\30\ (2)
personal notebooks from the President's time as Vice
President;\31\ (3) certain documents found at the Penn Biden
Center, including documents related to negotiations about the
Iran nuclear deal;\32\ (4) documents found at the University of
Delaware dating to the President's time as a senator;\33\ and
(5) other documents found in the President's Delaware home,
including briefing binders from trips that the President took
while he was vice president.\34\ With respect to each category
of documents, Hur found that there was no evidence that the
President willfully retained any classified information, and in
some cases found that the information was not actually
classified.
---------------