Dissenting Views
The Committee on Oversight and Accountability (Oversight
Committee), having considered this Report, reports favorably
thereon and recommends that the Report be approved.
The form of the Resolution that the Oversight Committee
would recommend to the House of Representatives citing Merrick
B. Garland, Attorney General, U.S. Department of Justice, for
contempt of Congress pursuant to this Report is as follows:
Resolved, That Merrick B. Garland, Attorney General, U.S.
Department of Justice, shall be found to be in contempt of
Congress for failure to comply with a congressional subpoena.
Resolved, That pursuant to 2 U.S.C. Sec. Sec. 192 and 194,
the Speaker of the House of Representatives shall certify the
report of the Oversight Committee, detailing the refusal of
Merrick B. Garland, Attorney General, U.S. Department of
Justice, to produce documents, records, and materials to the
Oversight Committee as directed by subpoena, to the United
States Attorney for the District of Columbia, to the end that
Attorney General Merrick B. Garland be proceeded against in the
manner and form provided by law.
Resolved, That the Speaker of the House shall otherwise
take all appropriate action to enforce the subpoena.
CONTENTS
Page
Executive Summary................................................ 2
Authority and Purpose............................................ 3
Background on the Investigation.................................. 6
The Attorney General's Failure to Produce the Subpoenaed Records
Warrants Contempt.............................................. 11
Conclusion....................................................... 16
Committee Consideration.......................................... 16
Committee Votes.................................................. 16
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 22
New Budget Authority and Tax Expenditures........................ 22
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 22
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 22
Advisory on Earmarks............................................. 22
Dissenting Views................................................. 22
Executive Summary
In the weeks following the February 5, 2024, release of
Special Counsel Robert K. Hur's report, the three House
Committees conducting an impeachment inquiry to determine
whether to draft articles of impeachment against President
Joseph R. Biden\1\ engaged with the Department of Justice to
obtain a limited set of documents and records related to the
report. After the Department declined to provide the Committees
with the relevant documents and records, the Committee on the
Judiciary (Judiciary Committee) and the Oversight Committee
issued identical subpoenas on February 27, 2024, to Attorney
General Merrick B. Garland compelling production of four
specific categories of documents and records, including audio
and video recordings of Special Counsel Hur's interviews with
President Biden and his ghostwriter, Mark Zwonitzer.\2\ The
Oversight Committee subpoenaed these materials for several
reasons--including to determine whether sufficient grounds
exist to draft articles of impeachment against President Biden
for consideration by the full House of Representatives and to
determine if legislation is needed to ensure that federal
agencies, including the National Archives and Records
Administration (NARA), adequately account for records and
documents meant to be returned to the federal government upon
an executive branch employee's departure from office.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\H.R. Res. 918, 118th Cong. (2023).
\2\Letter from Rep. Jim Jordan, Chairman. H. Comm. on the
Judiciary, and Rep. James Comer, Chairman, H. Comm. on Oversight &
Accountability, to Hon. Merrick B. Garland, Att'y Gen., U.S. Dep't of
Justice (Feb. 27, 2024) (hereinafter ``Subpoena Letter'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During Special Counsel Hur's investigation, his team
uncovered evidence that President Biden ``willfully retained
and disclosed classified materials after his vice presidency
when he was a private citizen.''\3\ Special Counsel Hur found
that then-Vice President Biden had ``strong motivations'' to
flout the rules for properly handling classified materials.\4\
In particular, Special Counsel Hur observed that ``months
before leaving office'' as vice president, President Biden
decided to write a book for ``an advance of $8 million.''\5\
The classified materials retained by President Biden were an
``invaluable resource that he consulted liberally'' while
writing his book so that he could give his ghostwriter ``raw
material . . . detailing meetings and events that would be of
interest to prospective readers and buyers of his book.''\6\
Additionally, Special Counsel Hur observed that President Biden
viewed the classified materials ``as an irreplaceable
contemporaneous record of some of the most important moments of
his vice presidency[,]'' which ``was valuable to him for many
reasons, including to help defend his record and buttress his
legacy as a world leader.''\7\ Despite this evidence, Special
Counsel Hur ultimately concluded that no criminal charges were
warranted.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Report on the Investigation Into Unauthorized Removal,
Retention, and Disclosure of Classified Documents Discovered at
Locations Including the Penn Biden Center and the Delaware Private
Residence of President Joseph R. Biden, Jr., Special Counsel Robert K.
Hur, U.S. Dep't of Justice at 1 (Feb. 2024) (hereinafter ``Hur
Report'').
\4\Id. at 231.
\5\Id. at 141, 231.
\6\Id. at 231.
\7\Id. at 231-32.
\8\Id. at 345.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
President Biden has vehemently denied the findings in
Special Counsel Hur's report and he and his legal team have
attempted to frame Special Counsel Hur's mention of President
Biden's poor memory as ``gratuitous.''\9\ Yet during his
testimony before the Committee, Special Counsel Hur stated
that, ``[t]he evidence and the President himself put his memory
squarely at issue.''\10\ In his report, Special Counsel Hur
noted that, during both his and Zwonitzer's interviews with
President Biden, the President's ``memory was significantly
limited,'' and he ``struggl[ed] to remember events and
strain[ed] at times to read and relay his own notebook
entries.''\11\ Special Counsel Hur also observed that President
Biden ``did not remember when he was vice president, forgetting
on the first day of the interview when his [vice presidential]
term ended,'' and ``did not remember, even within several
years, when his son Beau died.''\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\Rebecca Beitsch, et al., Special counsel overstepped mandate
with `gratuitous' Biden slams, say ex-DOJ Dems, THE HILL (Feb. 12,
2024) (```When the inevitable conclusion is that the facts and the
evidence don't support any charges,' said Ian Sams, a spokesman for the
White House's special counsel office, `you're left to wonder why this
report spends time making gratuitous and inappropriate criticisms of
the president.'''); see Letter from Mr. Richard Sauber, Special Counsel
to the President, The White House, and Mr. Bob Bauer, Personal Counsel
to Joseph R. Biden. Jr., to Mr. Bradley Weinsheimer, Assoc. Deputy
Att'y Gen., U.S. Dep't of Justice at 2-3 (Feb. 12, 2024) (``This is the
very definition of a derogatory comment . . . .'').
\10\Hearing on the Report of Special Counsel Robert Hur: Hearing
Before the H. Comm. on the Judiciary, 118th Cong. 17 (2024) (statement
of Special Counsel Robert K. Hur, U.S. Dep't of Justice) (hereinafter
``Hearing on Hur Report'').
\11\Hur Report, supra note 3, at 5, 207.
\12\Id. at 208.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Department continues to withhold key material
responsive to the subpoenas from the Oversight and Judiciary
Committees--specifically the audio recordings of Special
Counsel Hur's interviews with President Biden and Zwonitzer.
Its failure to fully comply with the Committees' subpoenas has
hindered the House's ability to adequately conduct oversight
over Special Counsel Hur regarding his investigative findings
and the President's retention and disclosure of classified
materials and impeded the Committees' impeachment inquiry.
Authority and Purpose
The Constitution vests the House of Representatives with
the ``sole Power of Impeachment''\13\ and provides that the
``President, Vice President and all civil Officers of the
United States, shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for,
and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and
Misdemeanors.''\14\ As the U.S. Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia Circuit has stated, ``[t]o level the grave
accusation that a President may have committed `Treason,
Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors,' U.S. Const.
art. II, Sec. 4, the House must be appropriately
informed.''\15\ Congress's authority to access information
during an impeachment investigation is broader in certain
instances than in a purely legislative investigation,\16\ a
fact that the executive branch traditionally has
recognized.\17\ Investigating and collecting all relevant
evidence is the traditional means by which the House begins an
impeachment inquiry.\18\ Indeed, conducting an impeachment
inquiry without all pertinent evidence would be an affront to
the Constitution and irreparably damage public faith in the
impeachment process.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\U.S. Const. art. I, Sec. 2, cl. 5.
\14\Id. art. II, Sec. 4.
\15\Comm. on Judiciary of U.S. House of Representatives v. McGahn,
968 F.3d 755, 765 (D.C. Cir. 2020) (en banc).
\16\Todd Garvey, Cong. Rsch. Serv.: Legal Sidebar, LSB11083,
Impeachment Investigations, Part II: Access, at 1 (2023) (``[T]here is
reason to believe that invocation of the impeachment power could
improve the committees' legal claims of access to certain types of
evidence relevant to the allegations of misconduct against President
Biden.''). See also In re Application of Comm. on Judiciary, 414 F.
Supp. 3d 129, 176 (D.D.C. 2019) (``[D]enying [the House Judiciary
Committee] evidence relevant to an impeachment inquiry could pose
constitutional problems.''), aff'd, 951 F.3d 589 (D.C. Cir. 2020),
vacated and remanded sub nom. on other grounds, DOJ v. House Comm. on
the Judiciary, 142 S. Ct. 46 (2021); In re Request for Access to Grand
Jury Materials, 833 F.2d 1438, 1445 (11th Cir. 1987) (concluding that
``limit[ing] the investigatory power of the House in impeachment
proceedings . . . would clearly violate separation of powers
principles'').
\17\See Garvey, supra note 16 (``As a historical matter, all three
branches have suggested that the House possesses a robust right of
access to information when it is investigating for impeachment
purposes.''); Jonathan David Schaub, The Executive's Privilege, 70 Duke
L.J. 1, 87 (2020) (``[P]residents and others have recognized throughout
the history of the country that their ability to withhold information
from Congress disappears in the context of impeachment.'').
\18\See, e.g., H.R. Rep. No. 116-346, at 28 (2019) (``Here,
consistent with historical practice, the House divided its impeachment
inquiry into two phases, first collecting evidence and then bringing
that evidence before the Judiciary Committee for its consideration of
articles of impeachment.''); H.R. Rep. No. 111-427, at 7 (2010)
(``[T]he impeachment inquiry was referred by the Committee on the
Judiciary to a Task Force on Judicial Impeachment . . . , comprised of
12 Committee Members, to conduct the investigation.''). See also
Hearing on the Basis for the Impeachment Inquiry of President Joseph R.
Biden: Before the H. Comm. on Oversight & Accountability, 118th Cong.
(Sept. 28, 2023) (statement of Jonathan Turley, Professor, The George
Washington University Law School); Memorandum from Rep. Jim Jordan,
Chairman, H. Comm. on the Judiciary, Rep. James Comer, Chairman, H.
Comm. on Oversight & Accountability, and Rep. Jason Smith, Chairman, H.
Comm. on Ways & Means, to Members of the H. Comm. on the Judiciary, H.
Comm. on Oversight & Accountability, and H. Comm. on Ways & Means
(Sept. 27, 2023) (hereinafter ``Sept. 27 Memo'').
\19\See In re Application of Comm. on Judiciary, 414 F. Supp. 3d at
176 (``Impeachment based on anything less than all relevant evidence
would compromise the public's faith in the process.''); In re Request
for Access to Grand Jury Materials, 833 F.2d at 1445 (``Public
confidence in a procedure as political and public as impeachment is an
important consideration justifying disclosure.''); In re Report and
Recommendation of June 5, 1972 Grand Jury, 370 F. Supp. 1219, 1230
(D.D.C. 1974) (``It would be difficult to conceive of a more compelling
need than that of this country for an unswervingly fair [impeachment]
inquiry based on all the pertinent information.'').
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On September 27, 2023, pursuant to the directive of the
Speaker, the Chairs of three House Committees (the Oversight,
Judiciary, and Ways and Means Committees) released a memorandum
setting forth the justification for and scope of the inquiry
into whether sufficient grounds exist to draft articles of
impeachment against President Biden.\20\ On December 13, 2023,
the House of Representatives adopted House Resolution 918,
directing these three Committees to continue the ongoing
impeachment inquiry.\21\ By approving House Resolution 918, the
House also adopted House Resolution 917,\22\ which provided
that ``[t]he authority provided by clause 2(m) of Rule XI of
the Rules of the House of Representatives to the Chairs of the
Committees . . . included, from the beginning of the existing
House of Representatives impeachment inquiry . . . and
continues to include, so long as the impeachment inquiry is
ongoing, the authority to issue subpoenas on behalf of such
Committees for the purpose of furthering the impeachment
inquiry.''\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\Sept. 27 Memo, supra note 18.
\21\H.R. Res. 918, 118th Cong. (2023).
\22\H.R. Res. 917, 118th Cong. (2023).
\23\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The subpoenas issued to the Department by the Oversight and
Judiciary Committees are part of the House's impeachment
inquiry. As explained in detail below, the requested documents
and materials are necessary to determine whether sufficient
grounds exist to draft articles of impeachment against
President Biden.
However, the impeachment inquiry is not the only purpose
underlying the Oversight Committee's subpoena; it was also
issued pursuant to the Committee's authority to conduct
legislative oversight.\24\ Article I of the Constitution vests
in Congress a ``broad'' and ``indispensable'' power to conduct
oversight and investigations that ``encompasses inquiries into
the administration of existing laws, studies of proposed laws,
and surveys in our social, economic or political system for the
purpose of enabling Congress to remedy them.''\25\ Pursuant to
the Rules of the House of Representatives, the Oversight
Committee has broad authority to investigate ``any matter'' at
``any time,'' and specific legislative jurisdiction over the
management of government operations and activities, NARA, and
public information and records.\26\ The House Rules also charge
the Oversight Committee with reviewing and studying the
operation of government activities at all levels, including the
Executive Office of the President.\27\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\See Rules of the U.S. House of Representatives, R. XI, cl.
2(m)(1) (2023) (providing that ``a committee or subcommittee is
authorized . . . (B) to require, by subpoena or otherwise, the
attendance and testimony of such witnesses and the production of such
books, records, correspondence, memoranda, papers, and documents as it
considers necessary''); Rules of the H. Comm. on Oversight &
Accountability, R. 12(g) (``The Chair of the Committee shall . . .
[a]uthorize and issue subpoenas as provided in House Rule XI, clause
2(m), in the conduct of any investigation or activity or series of
investigations or activities within the jurisdiction of the
Committee.''); Rules of the H. Comm. on the Judiciary, R. IV(a) (``A
subpoena may be authorized and issued by the Chair, in accordance with
clause 2(m) of rule XI of the House of Representatives, in the conduct
of any investigation or activity or series of investigations or
activities within the jurisdiction of the Committee, following
consultation with the Ranking Minority Member.'').
\25\Watkins v. United States, 354 U.S. 178, 187, 215 (1957).
\26\Rules of the House of Representatives, R. X, 118th Cong.
(2023).
\27\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To further the Committee's constitutionally mandated
oversight and legislative duties, the Committee must ensure
compliance with duly authorized congressional subpoenas. As the
principal investigatory committee of the U.S. House of
Representatives, the Oversight Committee has authority to
investigate the Special Counsel's activities with respect to
President Biden.\28\ The Committee on Oversight and
Accountability is the principal oversight committee of the U.S.
House of Representatives. In addition, the Committee is
investigating matters that are necessary to consider potential
legislative reforms. These potential legislative reforms may
include, among other things, assessing whether additional
requirements are necessary to properly account for sensitive or
classified materials in the possession of executive branch
officials and whether reforms are necessary to the Presidential
Records Act and Federal Records Act to ensure sensitive or
classified materials are not accessed by unauthorized parties.
The Oversight Committee is considering whether certain federal
agencies, such as NARA, require reform to adequately account
for records and documents meant to be returned to the federal
government upon an executive branch employee's departure from
office. The Oversight Committee has conducted transcribed
interviews of witnesses related to this investigation and has
sought additional transcribed interviews with current White
House officials. The Committee has issued a subpoena to the
former White House counsel who was involved in t
Dissenting Views
The Committee on Oversight and Accountability (the
``Committee'') has been conducting an impeachment inquiry into
President Joe Biden for a year and a half--essentially the
entire duration of the 118th Congress. To date, the Committee
has amassed more than 3.8 million pages of documents and 80
hours of testimony from transcribed interviews and depositions
of 19 witnesses. Nowhere in this mountain of material is there
any evidence of wrongdoing by the President--let alone an
impeachable offense. In fact, after 17 months of investigating,
Chairman James Comer has still not articulated any specific
high crime or misdemeanor that he believes President Biden has
committed.
Among the millions of pages of documents that Committee
Republicans have already received is a full transcript of
President Biden's interview with Special Counsel Robert K. Hur.
This transcript, which was produced to the Committee by the
Department of Justice (DOJ), accounts for the entirety of
President Biden's voluntary five-hour interview with the
Special Counsel. Nowhere in the transcript's 250 pages is there
any evidence that President Biden committed an impeachable
offense.
Desperate to blame someone--anyone--for the utter failure
of this impeachment inquiry, Republicans have contrived an
allegation that Attorney General Merrick Garland has impeded
their impeachment inquiry by preventing them from hearing
President Biden's interview with Special Counsel Hur by
withholding the audio recording. In fact, Republicans, and the
American public, can already read the full content of that
interview. We know what the President said. Hearing the
President's words rather than reading them will not change
those words and certainly won't suddenly reveal some new
evidence of an impeachable offense. The Attorney General has
given the Committee the information it sought: the contents of
the President's interview with Special Counsel Hur.
In fact, Attorney General Garland and the Biden
Administration have made substantial efforts to accommodate the
Committee's interest in Special Counsel Hur's investigation,
working in good faith to provide the Committee with all the
information it requested. In addition to the transcript of the
President's interview, the DOJ provided the entirety of the
Special Counsel's report; provided the full transcript of the
Special Counsel's interview with the President's ghost writer,
Mark Zwonitzer; made available the two classified documents
requested by the Committee; and provided requested
correspondence regarding the Special Counsel's report. In
addition, the DOJ facilitated the Special Counsel's testimony
about his report and investigation to the Committee on the
Judiciary. In other words, the DOJ and the Administration have
demonstrated extraordinary cooperation in providing the
Committee with all the information it sought. Yet Republicans
have responded by attempting to hold the Attorney General in
contempt based on meritless and preposterous claims of
obstruction.
I. Consideration of Meritless Contempt Resolution ``Was Not a Good Look
for Congress''
The after-hours Committee business meeting Chairman Comer
convened to consider this baseless contempt resolution was
marred by indecorous outbursts from Republican Members and
truncated debate that was abruptly cut off after consideration
of two Republican amendments and only a single Democratic
amendment--a violation of decades-long Committee precedent.
On Monday, May 13, 2024, Chairman Comer issued notice that
the Committee would hold a business meeting on Thursday, May
16, 2024, at 11:00 a.m., to consider a resolution recommending
that the House of Representatives hold Attorney General Merrick
Garland in contempt.\1\ The Republican Majority of the
Committee on the Judiciary also announced that it would hold a
business meeting that same day at 10:00 a.m. to consider a
substantially similar resolution.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\ Committee on Oversight and Accountability, Business Meeting
Notice (May 13, 2024) (online at https://docs.house.gov/meetings/GO/
GO00/20240516/117325/HMKP-118-GO00-20240516-SD001.pdf).
\2\See Committee on the Judiciary, Markup of Report Recommending
that the House of Representatives Cite Attorney General Merrick Garland
for Contempt of Congress (May 16, 2024) (online at https://
judiciary.house.gov/committee-activity/markups/markup-report-
recommending-house-representatives-cite-attorney-general).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
On Wednesday, May 15, 2024, at approximately 7:15 p.m.--the
night before the Committee meeting--Chairman Comer published a
notice stating without explanation that the business meeting
would be postponed to 8:00 p.m.\3\ It soon became evident that
Chairman Comer had postponed the meeting to accommodate
Republicans Members' travel schedules. Several Republican
Committee Members planned to travel to New York City to attend
the criminal trial of former President Donald Trump, who is
charged with 34 counts of falsifying business records for his
alleged participation in a hush money scheme intended to
silence his former mistresses prior to the 2016 presidential
election.\4\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Committee on Oversight and Accountability, Time Change: Business
Meeting Notice (May 15, 2024) (online at https://docs.house.gov/
meetings/GO/GO00/20240516/117325/HMKP-118-GO00-20240516-SD003.pdf).
\4\Id. These charges stand in addition to the numerous other
federal and state criminal charges pending against Donald Trump in
forums across the country, including four counts related to the January
6 attack on the Capitol and efforts to overturn the results of the 2020
election, ten counts related to efforts to reverse the 2020 election
results in Georgia, and 40 counts related to possession of classified
documents and obstructing federal efforts to retrieve them. See Keeping
Track of the Trump Criminal Cases, New York Times (May 8, 2024) (online
at www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/us/trump-investigations-charges-
indictments.html); Oversight Delays Garland Contempt Hearing for
Members to Attend Trump Trial, The Hill (May 15, 2024) (online at
https://thehill.com/homenews/4667089-oversight-delays-merrick-garland-
contempt-hearing-members-attend-donald-trump-trial/).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
At approximately 8:00 p.m., on May 16, 2024, Chairman Comer
convened the Oversight Committee to consider the contempt
resolution. By the time the Oversight Committee began its
business meeting, the Judiciary Committee had already favorably
reported their contempt resolution, rendering the Oversight
Committee's consideration of the analogous resolution both
duplicative and moot. Nonetheless, Chairman Comer proceeded
with the Committee's business meeting.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\5\See Committee on Oversight and Accountability, Full Committee
Business Meeting (May 16, 2024) (online at https://oversight.house.gov/
markup/full-committee-business-meeting-73/).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
It appears that immediately prior to the business meeting,
the James Comer for Congress committee--in collaboration with
WinRed, a Republican fundraising platform--circulated an email
``[f]rom the desk of Oversight Chairman James Comer'' seeking
campaign donations that referenced Chairman Comer's efforts to
hold Attorney General Garland in contempt of Congress and
asserting that ``Biden and his advisors are terrified that I
will release the recordings.''\6\ The letter was signed:
``James Comer, Chairman, House Oversight Committee.'' During
the Committee meeting, Chairman Comer refused to recognize Rep.
Stephen Lynch's point of order requesting the opinion of the
parliamentarian as to whether a motion to refer the Chairman's
conduct to the House Committee on Ethics would be in order.\7\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\See As GOP Demands Biden/Hur Audio, James Comer Gives Away the
Game, MSNBC (May 17, 2024) (online at www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/
maddowblog/gop-demands-bidenhur-audio-james-comer-gives-away-game-
rcna152752); see also Acyn (@Acyn), X (May 17, 2024) (online at https:/
/x.com/Acyn/status/1791323954168414469) (``Moskowitz's dramatic reading
of Comer's fundraising email is definitely worth a watch''); Committee
on Oversight and Accountability, Full Committee Business Meeting (May
16, 2024) (online at https://oversight.house.gov/markup/full-committee-
business-meeting-73/).
\7\Committee on Oversight and Accountability, Full Committee
Business Meeting (May 16, 2024) (online at https://oversight.house.gov/
markup/full-committee-business-meeting-73/).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
During the Committee meeting, after Republican Rep.
Marjorie Taylor Greene denigrated the appearance of Rep.
Jasmine Crockett and refused to apologize for her clear breach
of decorum and basic decency, the Chairman refused to rule Rep.
Greene had violated the rule against engaging in personalities,
finding her comments were merely ``indecorous.''\8\ Later, a
separate disparaging comment by Rep. Greene, this one directed
at Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, was ruled out of order by the
Chairman, who ordered that her words be stricken from the
record. However, with the exception of one Member, all
Committee Republicans voted to allow Rep. Greene to proceed in
order. As such, Rep. Greene was permitted to continue
participating in the business meeting and did not face any
consequences for repeatedly insulting fellow Members of the
Committee during the debate.\9\ Even the Speaker of the House,
Mike Johnson, concluded that the disarray Chairman Comer
allowed during the business meeting ``was not a good look for
Congress.''\10\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Id.
\9\Id.
\10\Johnson Slams Raucous Congressional Hearing Sparked by Marjorie
Taylor Greene's `Fake Eyelashes' Comment, ABC News (May 17, 2024)
(online at https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/johnson-disappointed-house-
committee-meeting-devolved-chaos-greenes/story?id=110337266).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Three hours into the Committee meeting, much of it wasted
by Committee Republicans' indecorous antics, and after just
three amendments--two Republican and one Democratic--had been
offered, Committee Republicans voted to cut off all debate and
the consideration of any further amendments by calling the
previous question. In doing so, Committee Republicans broke a
decades-long precedent, honored by Chairs of both parties, of
allowing fulsome debate and the consideration of all germane
amendments at Committee business meetings. At the time Rep.
Jake LaTurner moved the previous question, Chairman Comer knew
that Democratic Members intended to offer two further
amendments pursuant to a unanimous consent agreement to limit
debate being negotiated by the Committee's Republican and
Democratic staffs at the request of the Chairman. Over
Democratic Members' vociferous objection to prematurely cutting
off debate and the consideration of amendments, Chairman Comer
called a vote on Rep. LaTurner's motion to move the previous
question, forcing immediate votes on the pending amendments and
the underlying contempt report recommending that Attorney
General Garland be held in contempt. The report was adopted on
a party line vote with all Democratic Members opposed.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Committee on Oversight and Accountability, Full Committee
Business Meeting (May 16, 2024) (online at https://oversight.house.gov/
markup/full-committee-business-meeting-73/).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Under Chairman Comer's leadership, the Committee's
consideration of the resolution to hold Attorney General
Garland in contempt was a late-night spectacle unbecoming of
the Committee and indeed of the House of Representatives in
which Democratic Members were insulted and then prevented from
debating and offering amendments to the Chairman's baseless
contempt report.
II. Republicans are Trying to Hold the Attorney General in Contempt for
Information the Department of Justice has Already Provided
Committee Republicans assert that Attorney General Garland
should ``be found to be in contempt of Congress for failure to
comply with a congressional subpoena'' issued in identical form
by Oversight Committee Chairman Comer and Judiciary Committee
Chairman Jim Jordan.\12\ Specifically, Committee Republicans
speciously allege that the Attorney General has ``impeded
[their] impeachment inquiry'' against President Biden by
failing to provide audio recordings of President Biden's
voluntary interview with Special Counsel Hur, as well as the
audio recording of Special Counsel Hur's interview with his
ghostwriter, Mark Zwonitzer.\13\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Committee on Oversight and Accountability, Resolution
Recommending that the House of Representatives Find United States
Attorney General Merrick B. Garland in Contempt of Congress for Refusal
To Comply with a Subpoena Duly Issued by the Committee on Oversight and
Accountability (May 2024) (online at https://oversight.house.gov/wp-
content/uploads/2024/05/Garland-Contempt-Report-re-Hur-Report.pdf).
\13\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
To be clear, the DOJ and the Biden Administration have
provided the information sought by each of the subpoena's four
requests, including by providing full transcripts of the
Special Counsel's interviews of President Biden and Mr.
Zwonitzer. These transcripts already provide the Committee with
the content of these interviews. Hearing these interviews on an
audio tape rather than reading them in a transcript will not
change the content of these interviews.
A. DOJ AND THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION HAVE FULLY COOPERATED WITH THE
COMMITTEE'S SUBPOENA
On February 12, 2024, the Chairmen of the Committee on
Oversight and Accountability, Committee on the Judiciary, and
Committee on Ways and Means requested information from the DOJ
regarding Special Counsel Hur's investigation of the President,
including documents and communications related to the Special
Counsel's interviews of President Biden and his ghostwriter,
Mark Zwonitzer.\14\ The DOJ responded to the Chairmen's request
four days later, explaining that ``several of the materials
listed in [the] February 12 letter require review for
classification and protection of national defense information''
and, consistent with usual practice, the DOJ would conduct a
``review to assess confidentiality interests'' involving other
Executive Branch agencies.\15\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\14\Letter from Chairman James Comer, Committee on Oversight and
Accountability, Chairman Jim Jordan, Committee on the Judiciary, and
Chairman Jason Smith, Committee on Ways and Means, to Attorney General
Merrick Garland, Department of Justice (Feb. 12, 2024) (online at
https://oversight.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/DOJ-Transcript-
video-letter-02122024.FINAL_.pdf).
\15\Letter from Department of Justice to Chairman James Comer,
Committee on Oversight and Accountability, and Chairman Jim Jordan,
Committee on the Judiciary, and Chairman Jason Smith, Committee on Ways
and Means (Feb. 16, 2024) (online at https://
oversightdemocrats.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/democrats-
oversight.house.gov/files/evo-media-document/
DOJ.240216%2CResponse%20to%20Comer%20Jordan%20Smith%20re%20Biden%20
Classifed%20Docs%20-%20Hur%20021224.pdf).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Despite the DOJ's prompt response, Chairmen Comer and
Jordan each issued a subpoena on February 27, 2024, for the
following documents and information:
1. All documents and communications, including audio
and video recordings, related to the Special Counsel's
interview of President Joseph R. Biden Jr.;
2. All documents and communications, including audio
and video recordings, related to the Special Counsel's
interview of Mr. Mark Zwonitzer;
3. The documents identified as ``A9'' and ``A10'' in
Appendix A of Mr. Hur's report, which relate to
President Biden's December 11, 2015, call with then-
Ukrainian Prime Minister Arseniy Yatsenyuk; and
4. All communications between or among
representatives of the DOJ, including the Office of the
Special Counsel, the Executive Office of the President,
and President Biden's personal counsel referring or
relating to Special Counsel Hur's report.\16\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\Letter from Chairman James Comer, Committee on Oversight and
Accountability, and Chairman Jim Jordan, Committee on the Judiciary, to
Attorney General Merrick Garland, Department of Justice (Feb. 27, 2024)
(online at https://oversight.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/
Subpoena-Cover-Letter-to-AG-Garland_Hur-Report-Materials-Joint-Letter-
2-27-24.pdf).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The DOJ subsequently produced documents and information
responsive to each of the subpoena's four requests. On March 7,
the Department produced documents responsive to requests 3 and
4 of the Committee's February 27 subpoena, including ``the two
documents cited in the report that were requested by the
Committee,'' which the Department offered to make available
``through an in camera production in a facility appropriate for
viewing classified information,'' and ``communications between
the Department and the Executive Office of the President or
President Biden's personal counsel referring or relating to Mr.
Hur's report.''\17\ On March 12, the Department produced the
full transcript--totaling more than 250 pages--of the voluntary
interview Special Counsel Hur conducted with President Biden on
October 8, 2023. and October 9, 2023, responsive to request 1
of the Committee's subpoena.\18\ On April 8, 2024, the
Department produced the transcript of Special Counsel Hur's
interview with Mark Zwonitzer, responsive to request 2 of the
Committee's subpoena.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\Letter from Department of Justice to Chairman James Comer,
Committee on Oversight and Accountability (Mar. 7, 2024) (online at
https://oversightdemocrats.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/democrats-
oversight.house.gov/files/evo-media-document/2024.03.07-OUT-Comer-
SCO%20
Subpoena_0.pdf).
\18\Letter from Department of Justice to Chairman James Comer,
Committee on Oversight and