Purpose and Summary
H.R. 3089, the NDO Fairness Act, introduced by Rep. Scott Fitzgerald (R-WI), would amend Title II of the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, known as the Stored Communications Act. The bill sets limits on when a governmental entity may delay notifying an individual after accessing the individual's private electronic communications (e.g., email) and after a governmental entity obtains a nondisclosure order for a service provider to prevent the service provider from notifying the individual that their data has been subpoenaed. Background and Need for the Legislation A. BACKGROUND i. The Stored Communications Act In 1986, Congress enacted the Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA) to prevent unauthorized government access to private electronic communications (e.g., email). Title II of the ECPA, the Stored Communications Act (SCA), focuses on the privacy of, and government access to, stored electronic communications--often in the possession of companies like Google, Apple, Microsoft, or Verizon.\1\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \1\18 U.S.C. Sec. 2701-2712. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Two key parts of the SCA are now codified in sections 2703 and 2705 of title 18. Under section 2703, if the government issues a subpoena, obtains a search warrant, or obtains a court order, the government may access the contents of electronic communications held by a service provider, in some cases without providing notice to the person whose communications are being seized and examined.\2\ Section 2703(d) authorizes a court to order a service provider to produce electronic communications to the government if the government has shown specific and articulable facts sufficient to establish reasonable grounds to believe that the contents it seeks are relevant and material to an ongoing criminal investigation.\3\ However, some courts have held that this ``reasonable grounds'' standard is less strict than ``probable cause'' and may be constitutionally insufficient in some circumstances.\4\ In addition, subsection 2703(d) ``does not even require a prosecutor to provide facts justifying the need for secrecy. The template merely blindly asserts that any disclosure would `seriously jeopardize' the investigation for a variety of boilerplate reasons.''\5\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \2\18 U.S.C. Sec. 2703. \3\18 U.S.C. Sec. 2703(d). \4\Charles Doyle, Privacy: An Overview of the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, at 42, Cong. Research Serv., (Oct. 9, 2012); United States v. Warshak, 631 F.3d 266, 288 (6th Cir. 2010). \5\Secrecy Orders and Prosecuting Leaks: Potential Legislative Responses to Deter Prosecutorial Abuse of Power: Hearing Before the H. comm. on the Judiciary, 117th Cong. (2021) (written testimony of Tom Burt, Corporate Vice President, Customer Security & Trust, Microsoft Corp. at 3). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Section 2705 consists of two central parts. Subsection (a) authorizes the government to delay providing notice to a subscriber for up to 90 days, which may be extended repeatedly, if the government shows that there is ``reason to believe'' that notification may have an adverse result (e.g., danger to safety, or destruction of evidence).\6\ Orders signed by some judges may only include ``a cursory assertion that the government has satisfied any or all of the statutory factors authorizing secrecy.''\7\ Subsection (b) allows for additional secrecy by prohibiting the service provider from disclosing the government's access to anyone and subsection (b) does not limit the duration of a nondisclosure order. The nondisclosure order may be issued for ``such period as the court deems appropriate.''\8\ This open-endedness means that a service provider could be indefinitely prohibited from notifying affected customers about the government's access to private user data. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \6\18 U.S.C. Sec. 2705(a). \7\Secrecy Orders and Prosecuting Leaks: Potential Legislative Responses to Deter Prosecutorial Abuse of Power: Hearing Before the H. comm. on the Judiciary, 117th Cong. (2021) (written testimony of Tom Burt, Corporate Vice President, Customer Security & Trust, Microsoft Corp. at 3). \8\18 U.S.C. Sec. 2705(b). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- ii. Overview of Nondisclosure Orders and Department of Justice Policies and Procedures a. The Department of Justice's Use of Nondisclosure Orders The Department of Justice's (DOJ) excessive use and potential abuse of nondisclosure orders is rampant and an ongoing issue. The DOJ often uses court orders to prohibit service providers from notifying their customers that the government has seized their emails and other private information. Service providers are then left with little to no recourse to contest the orders, because it is up to the court as to when, if ever, to remove the order. At times, courts grant orders ``even for routine investigations without any meaningful analysis of either the need for secrecy or the orders'' compliance with constitutional rights.''\9\ According to Microsoft, ``federal law enforcement has consistently presented [the company] with 2,400 to 3,500 secrecy orders each year, or 7-10 per day, representing one-quarter to one-third of all the legal demands [it] received.''\10\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \9\Secrecy Orders and Prosecuting Leaks: Potential Legislative Responses to Deter Prosecutorial Abuse of Power: Hearing Before the H. comm. on the Judiciary, 117th Cong. (2021) (written testimony of Tom Burt, Corporate Vice President, Customer Security & Trust, Microsoft Corp. at 2). \10\Id. at 3-4. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- b. DOJ Policies and Procedures Under the Trump Administration, in October 2017, then- Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein issued a memorandum to DOJ law enforcement components and prosecutors that outlined the policies required to obtain nondisclosure orders pursuant to section 2705(b).\11\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \11\Memorandum on Policy Regarding Applications for Protective Orders Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Sec. 2705(b), U.S. DEP'T OF JUSTICE (Oct. 2017). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- According to the memorandum, prosecutors who apply for nondisclosure orders must follow several steps: 1. conduct an individualized and meaningful assessment of need; 2. tailor the application to include the factual basis that identifies the need for a gag order, including the potential for data destruction, risk of flight, or risk of harm to the public; 3. prosecutors may seek a single order that covers multiple grand jury subpoenas issued as part of the same investigation; 4. unless justified by exigent circumstances, prosecutors may only seek to delay notice for up to one year; 5. the judge may direct abbreviated or lengthier periods for orders; and 6. subsequent extensions may be sought if the factors justifying protection remain.\12\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \12\Id.; DOJ Manual 9-13.700--Applications for Protective Orders Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Sec. 2705(b). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- These policies were also added to the DOJ's current Justice Manual. iii. DOJ Subpoenas During Leak Investigations On June 10, 2021, the New York Times reported that DOJ prosecutors issued a grand jury subpoena on February 6, 2018, to Apple for data from 73 phone numbers and 36 email addresses as part of a wide-ranging investigation into the sources behind leaks of classified information related to the debunked Russia collusion investigation and other national security matters.\13\ Twelve accounts included those connected to the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence (HPSCI), including the former Ranking Member and a former Committee member, along with some of their staff, former aides, and family members.\14\ The Times also reported that in 2017, DOJ sent Microsoft a subpoena related to a personal email account for a congressional staff member.\15\ In addition, on June 5, 2021, the New York Times revealed that it had been under a gag order regarding a subpoena for Google to share data of four of Times reporters.\16\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \13\Katie Benner, et al., Hunting Leaks, Trump Officials Focused on Democrats in Congress, N.Y. Times (Jun. 10, 2021). \14\Id. \15\Jack Nicas, et al., In Leak Investigation, Tech Giants Are Caught Between Courts and Customers, N.Y. Times (Jun. 11, 2021). \16\Charlie Savage and Katie Benner, U.S. Waged Secret Legal Battle to Obtain Emails of 4 Times Reporters, N.Y. Times (Jun. 5, 2021). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- HPSCI apparently learned of the subpoena on May 5, 2021, when after a three-year gag order expired (initially issued for one year, then renewed twice), the company alerted the subjects of the subpoena.\17\ HPSCI members were reportedly ``animated'' during a DOJ briefing and tried to uncover which official initiated the investigation and subpoena.\18\ The former Ranking Member and former Committee member called the subpoena ``an attack on the separation of powers.''\19\ The former Committee member claimed that records of his family members (including a minor) had been obtained.\20\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \17\Jack Nicas, et al., In Leak Investigation, Tech Giants Are Caught Between Courts and Customers, N.Y. Times (Jun. 11, 2021); See also, Clare Foran, et al., Justice Department watchdog to investigate data seizure as House Democrats discuss impacts of leak probe, CNN (Jun. 11, 2021). \18\Id.; See also, Manu Raju, et al., Trump Justice Department subpoenaed Apple for data from House Intelligence Committee Democrats, sources say, CNN (Jun. 10, 2021). \19\Rebecca Heilweil, The Trump administration forced Apple to turn over lawmakers' data. Democrats are outraged, Vox (Jun. 14, 2021). \20\Manu Raju, et al., Trump Justice Department subpoenaed Apple for data from House Intelligence Committee Democrats, sources say, CNN (Jun. 10, 2021). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Wall Street Journal has since confirmed that DOJ obtained the data as part of its fact-gathering investigation into congressional staffers leaking classified information, rather than the lawmakers themselves being targets of the investigation.\21\ According to the reporting, ``current and former Justice Department officials described the subpoena as part of a fact-gathering effort and denied that it was politically motivated.''\22\ The Journal further reported that senior DOJ officials at the time the subpoena was issued, including then-Attorney General Sessions and his deputy, Rosenstein, have said that they had no knowledge of the subpoena.\23\ It is unknown whether prosecutors had obtained the necessary approval to issue the subpoena. In 2018, the DOJ prosecuted Senate Intelligence Committee staffer James Wolfe for leaking non-public information about Committee matters to reporters.\24\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \21\Aruna Viswanatha and Sadie Gurman, Trump Justice Department's Leak Probe Wasn't Aimed at Lawmakers, Wall St. J. (Jun. 23, 2021). \22\Id. \23\Id. \24\Adam Goldman, et al., Ex-Senate Aide Charged in Leak Case Where Times Reporter's Records Were Seized, N.Y. Times (Jun. 7, 2018). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- a. Response from Trump-era DOJ officials On June 11, 2021, during a Politico interview, former Attorney General William Barr said that he was not aware that any Members' records were obtained in a leak probe, pointing to the fact that cases that the Attorney General weighs in on would have been recommended by career officials in the Criminal Division and elsewhere in the Department.\25\ He added that President Trump never directed him to target lawmakers for investigation, saying that President Trump ``was not aware of who we were looking at in any of these cases. I never discussed the leak cases with [President] Trump. He didn't really ask me any of the specifics.''\26\ Likewise, according to Business Insider, former Attorney General Sessions and his deputy Rod Rosenstein have denied knowledge of the subpoena.\27\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \25\Id. \26\Manu Raju, et al., Trump Justice Department subpoenaed Apple for data from House Intelligence Committee Democrats, sources say, CNN (Jun. 10, 2021). \27\Tom Porter, Top Justice Department officials Sessions, Barr and Rosenstein all deny knowledge of secret subpoenas targeting Democratic lawmakers, Business Insider (Jun. 13, 2021). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- b. Congressional response to the news about DOJ's subpoenas In response to the reporting, then-House Speaker Nancy Pelosi denounced the investigation, saying, ``These actions appear to be yet another egregious assault on our democracy waged by the former president.''\28\ On June 14, 2021, Democrat Members of the Senate Judiciary Committee wrote Attorney General Garland for more information, including copies of the subpoenas and more details on the Office of Legal Counsel's approval.\29\ That day, Attorney General Garland said that he directed his deputy Lisa Monaco to bolster the Department's procedures for obtaining records from Members of Congress, specifically ``to evaluate and strengthen the department's existing policies and procedures for obtaining records of the legislative branch.''\30\ However, actions by the DOJ and FBI against Project Veritas have raised serious concerns about the enforcement of the policy that Attorney General Garland implemented--and President Biden endorsed--against federal law enforcement seizing records from journalists.\31\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \28\Id. \29\Letter from Richard Durbin, Chairman, S. Comm. on Judiciary, to Merrick B. Garland, Attorney General (Jun. 14, 2021). \30\Press Release, Dep't. of Justice, Statement from Attorney General Merrick B. Garland, (June 14, 2021); See also, Matt Zapotosky, Garland says Justice Department will strengthen policies for obtaining lawmakers' records, W. Post (June 14, 2021); See also, Sadie Gurman, After Apple Subpoenas, Justice Department Rethinks Policies on Getting Lawmakers' Records, Wall St. J. (June 14, 2021). \31\Memorandum from Atty Gen. Merrick Garland, U.S. Dep't of Justice, Use of Compulsory Process to Obtain Information From, or Records of, Members of the News Media (July 19, 2021); Eric Tucker, Justice Dept. says it'll no longer seize reporters' records, AP News (June 5, 2021); Alexandra Jaffe, Biden won't allow Justice Dept. to seize reporters' records, AP News (May 21, 2021). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- c. The DOJ's secret actions involving Project Veritas In the course of Project Veritas' news-gathering activities in late 2020, the organization obtained a diary purported to belong to President Biden's daughter.\32\ Project Veritas could not determine the legitimacy of the diary and chose not to publish its contents.\33\ Instead, the organization reportedly handed over the diary to law enforcement.\34\ Then, on November 6, 2021, FBI agents reportedly executed a search of the residence of Project Veritas founder James O'Keefe in connection with an investigation relating to the diary.\35\ Two days prior to the raid of O'Keefe's residence, the FBI reportedly also searched the homes of two former Project Veritas associates in connection with an investigation relating to the diary.\36\ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \32\James O'Keefe, FBI and Southern District of New York Raid Project Veritas Journalists' Homesk, Project Veritas (Nov. 5, 2021). \33\Id. \34\Id. \35\Michael S. Schmidt, et al., F.B.I. Searches James O'Keefe's Home in Ashley Biden Diary Theft Inquiry, N.Y. Times (Nov. 6, 2021). \36\Amy B. Wang and Devlin Barrett, FBI searches Project Veritas associates in probe over diary purportedly belonging to Biden's daughter, Wash. Post (Nov. 5, 2021); Michael S. Schmidt and Adam Goldman, Project Veritas Tells Judge It Was Assured Biden Diary Was Legally Obtained, N.Y. Times (Nov. 12, 2021). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- According to O'Keefe, the Department of Justice requested that the Project Veritas journalists not disclose the existence of the warrant.\37\ Yet, within an hour of the FBI's raid, the New York Times published a story about the search, even though the search warrant and the subject matter of the search warrant were apparently part of a grand jury investigation and should have been nonpublic.\38\ The Times later published information from confidential and sensitive documents belonging to Project Veritas, including legal advice obtained relating to its news gathering activities.\39\ On the same day, a federal judge in New York ordered the Department to stop extracting and reviewing the contents of Project Veritas materials that the FBI seized.\40\ The court's order and the Times's publishing of nonpublic Project Veritas information has raised questions about whether any Department employee leaked, or contributed to the leak of, any nonpublic information as part of this investigation. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- \37\James O'Keefe, FBI and Southern District of New York Raid Project Veritas Journalists' Homes, Project Veritas (Nov. 5, 2021). \38\Id. \39\Adam Goldman and Mark Mazzetti, Project Veritas and the Line Between Journalism and Political Spying, N.Y. Times (Nov. 11, 2021). \40\Order, In re Search Warrant dated November 5, 2021, 21 MAG 10685 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 11, 2021). --------------------------------------------------------------------------- These actions also raise concerns about the enforcement of the policy that Attorney General Garland implemented just months before concerning searching and seizing records from journalists and media organizations. President Biden endorsed Attorney General Garland's prohibition, saying that it is ``simply, simply wrong'' to confiscate journalists' records and that he would not allow the Department to do so.\41\ Similarl