Committee Action
118TH CONGRESS
First Session--Hearings
On February 8, 2023, the Committee on Education and the
Workforce held a hearing on ``American Education in Crisis.''
The purpose of the hearing was to examine the state of American
education, including the need to add additional transparency
and accountability into the system, to update the education
system to serve the needs of students and families, and to
protect and restore the rights of parents to have a say in
their children's education; issues around school choice and
charter schools were also discussed. Specifically, Chairwoman
Virginia Foxx (R-NC) mentioned the surge in enrollment that
charter schools have seen in recent years. Additionally,
Representative Jim Banks (R-IN) questioned Governor Jared Polis
(D-CO) regarding his support for charter schools after the
Governor wrote a letter to make the case for charter schools by
saying they are some of the most innovative, accessible, and
successful schools in Colorado. Testifying before the Committee
were Ms. Virginia Gentles, Director, Education Freedom Center,
Independent Women's Forum, Arlington, VA; Dr. Monty Sullivan,
President, Louisiana Community and Technical College System,
Baton Rouge, LA; Mr. Scott Pulsipher, President, Western
Governors University, Salt Lake City, UT; and The Honorable
Jared Polis, Governor, State of Colorado, Denver, CO.
On April 18, 2023, the Committee's Subcommittee on Early
Childhood, Elementary, and Secondary Education held a hearing
on ``School Choice: Expanding Educational Freedom for All.''
The purpose of the hearing was to examine the need to expand
educational freedom through school choice policies, including
charter schools. During the hearing, witness and former Member
of Congress Luke Messer (R-IN) stated, ``In America today, it's
hard to find a public policy issue in which Republican,
Democrat, independent, Latino, African American, and millennial
voters all agree, yet poll after poll shows 70 to even 90
percent support for these groups for various forms of school
choice.'' Testifying before the Committee were the Honorable
Luke Messer, former Member of Congress and President, Invest in
Education, Washington D.C.; Mrs. Denisha Allen, Senior Fellow,
American Federation for Children, Jacksonville, FL; Dr. Lindsey
Burke, Director of the Center for Education Policy, Heritage
Foundation, Washington D.C.; and Mr. Derek Black, Professor of
Law and Ernest F. Hollings Chair in Constitutional Law,
University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC.
On July 24, 2023, the Committee's Subcommittee on Early
Childhood, Elementary, and Secondary Education held a hearing
on ``Generational Learning Loss: How Pandemic School Closures
Hurt Students.'' The purpose of the hearing was to examine the
devastating impact of pandemic school closures and the learning
loss it created. Additionally, Chairwoman Foxx stated her
belief that school choice is essential to getting students back
on track in the classroom, with witness Darrell Bradford
agreeing by mentioning that ``by some reports a million kids no
longer attend their neighborhood public school, and about two-
thirds of those kids have chosen charter schools.'' Testifying
before the Committee were Dr. Nat Malkus, Senior Fellow and
Deputy Director, Education Policy Studies, American Enterprise
Institute, Washington, D.C.; Mr. Derrell Bradford, President,
50CAN: the 50-State Campaign for Achievement Now, New York, NY;
Ms. Catherine Truitt, Superintendent, North Carolina Department
of Public Instruction, Raleigh, NC; and Ms. Mary-Patricia Wray,
Parent, Baton Rouge, LA.
Second Session--Hearings
On March 6, 2024, the Committee's Subcommittee on Early
Childhood, Elementary, and Secondary Education held a hearing
on ``Proven Results: Highlighting the Benefits of Charter
Schools for Students and Families.'' The purpose of the hearing
was to examine the benefits of charter schools, to showcase
their sustained track record of raising students' academic
achievement (particularly in the wake of pandemic-era learning
loss), and to highlight how charter schools can be part of a
vibrant school choice ecosystem that empowers parents to choose
the best education options for their children. During the
hearing, witness Kenneth Campbell commended Representative
Julia Letlow (R-LA) for introducing legislation that would help
charter schools solve two of their biggest hurdles: access to
facilities and access to resources necessary to help educators
and community leaders strengthen their charter applications.
Additionally, Representative Letlow urged the Committee to
consider H.R. 6418, which would help ensure high-quality
perspective charter school applicants have the tools and
assistance they need to successfully complete the process.
Testifying before the Committee were Dr. Macke Raymond, Founder
and Director, Center for Research on Education Outcomes,
Stanford University, Stanford, CA; Mr. Robert Pondiscio, Senior
Fellow, American Enterprise Institute, Greenville, NY; Mr.
Kenneth Campbell, CEO, New Schools for Baton Rouge, Baton
Rouge, LA; and Dr. Julian Vasquez Heilig, Founding Board
Member, Network for Public Education, Augusta, MI.
Legislative Action
On November 15, 2023, Representative Julia Letlow
introduced H.R. 6418, the Empower Charter School Educators to
Lead Act, with Representatives Jill Tokuda (D-HI), John James
(R-MI), Juan Ciscomani (R-AZ), Erin Houchin (R-IN) as original
co-sponsors. On March 21, 2024, the Committee considered H.R.
6418 in a legislative session and reported it favorably, as
amended, to the House of Representatives by a recorded vote of
22-13. The Committee considered the following amendments to
H.R. 6418:
1. Representative Letlow offered an amendment in the
nature of a substitute that strikes the introduced
bill's increase in the percentage of grant awards that
may be spent on administration (leaving the current cap
in place), replaces a reference to a ``revolving loan
fund'' with ``technical assistance in assessing
financial options,'' and makes minor language
adjustments for clarity and conformity with existing
statute. The amendment passed by a recorded vote of 22-
13.
2. Representative Haley Stevens (R-MI) offered an
amendment that prohibits using any CSP grants for
virtual charter schools, including pre-planning,
development, or technical assistance for virtual
charter schools. The amendment failed by a recorded
vote of 13-22.
3. Ranking Member Bobby Scott (D-VA) offered an
amendment that would require that the initial charter
school plan include an assessment of segregation in the
community in which the proposed charter school will be
located, a strategy for how the proposed charter school
will effectively address desegregation in the
community, and an assurance that the strategy will be
carried out. The amendment failed by a recorded vote of
13-22.
Committee Views
INTRODUCTION
Every student deserves a high-quality education that
prepares him or her for success later in life. Unfortunately,
traditional public schools often have failed to meet the needs
of students. While some traditional public schools are doing
good work, too many students are trapped in failing districts
that provide poor instruction, ignore the concerns of parents,
and fail to prepare students for a successful life.
Charter schools can provide a vital lifeline for students
left behind by failing traditional public schools. Charter
schools serve nearly four million students across 45 states.
Unfortunately, there are not nearly enough high-quality charter
schools, and launching a new school can be a daunting process.
Aspiring charter school leaders must generally complete
extraordinarily lengthy and complex charter applications in
their spare time, often with little financial or technical
support.
Representative Letlow's bipartisan Empower Charter School
Educators to Lead Act (H.R. 6418) would help remedy this
problem by allowing states the option to use their existing
grant funds to support potential charter school leaders at the
pre-planning stage. It also would allow states to provide more
technical assistance to applicants.
Background on charter schools
A public charter school is a publicly funded elementary or
secondary school operated according to the terms of a charter
or contract granted by a charter authorizer. The terms of a
charter typically provide the charter school operator with
increased operational autonomy in exchange for greater
accountability for results or student outcomes. These
accountability reviews typically weigh factors such as the
schools' operational and fiscal health as well as student
academic performance. Authorizers are the entities that are
granted authority by a state legislature to approve, oversee,
renew, and close charter schools. These are typically public
agencies, such as local school districts and state educational
agencies. Charter schools do not draw students from an assigned
area; rather, families apply to send their children to them. If
demand for enrollment in a charter school exceeds space,
students are usually picked by lottery.\1\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\https://publiccharters.org/charter-schools-program/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
There are roughly 7,800 charter schools and campuses
serving approximately 3.7 million students in 45 states, the
District of Columbia, Guam, and Puerto Rico. Charter schools
serve 7.5 percent of the approximately 50 million public school
students in the United States. The number of charter schools
and campuses has more than doubled since the 2005-2006 school
year, and enrollment has more than tripled.\2\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\https://publiccharters.org/what-is-a-charter-school/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Most charter schools are located in urban areas (58
percent), but charter schools are also found in suburban areas
(25 percent), rural areas (11 percent), and towns (5 percent).
Charter schools have historically served proportionately more
students of color and more students from low-income communities
than district schools.\3\ Seventy percent of charter school
students, versus 53 percent of district school students, are
students of color.\4\ Most charter schools are free standing
(57 percent), meaning they are independently operated. The
other 43 percent contract with external organizations to assist
with operation management. There are two types of management
organizations: charter management organizations (CMOs) and
education management organizations (EMOs). CMOs are nonprofit
organizations and manage 32 percent of charter schools
nationwide, while EMOs are management organizations with a for-
profit tax status and manage 11 percent of charter schools.\5\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\https://data.publiccharters.org/digest/charter-school-data-
digest/where-are-charter-schools-
located/.
\4\https://data.publiccharters.org/digest/charter-school-data-
digest/who-attends-charter-schools/.
\5\https://data.publiccharters.org/digest/charter-school-data-
digest/who-manages-charter-
schools/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Background on charter school results
Charter schools tend to have a positive effect on students'
academic achievement. A 2023 study from Stanford's Center for
Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO) focused on the progress
that students make over an academic year and found that the
typical charter school student had reading and math gains that
outpaced their peers in traditional public schools (TPS) they
otherwise would have attended. On average, charter school
students learned the equivalent of an additional six days per
year in math and 16 days per year in reading.\6\ Eighty-three
percent of charter school students performed the same as or
better than their peers in reading, and 75 percent performed
the same as or better in math.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\https://ncss3.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Credo-
NCSS3-ExecutiveSummary.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
According to CREDO, the gains are especially pronounced in
urban charter schools, where students gain an additional 29
days of growth per year in reading and 28 additional days in
math.\7\ Suburban charter school students also had stronger
growth in reading, adding 14 days, while in math they added
three days. Charter school students in rural areas had the
equivalent of five additional days of learning in reading but
10 fewer days of growth in math than their TPS peers. The one
major exception to these results was virtual charter schools,
which enroll about 6 percent of charter school students;
virtual charter students achieved 58 fewer days of learning in
reading and 124 fewer days in math.\8\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\https://ncss3.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Credo-
NCSS3-Report.pdf.
\8\https://ncss3.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Credo-
NCSS3-ExecutiveSummary.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Academic achievement also is especially pronounced for at-
risk students. Students in poverty achieve an additional 23
days of learning in reading and 17 days in math; English
language learners achieve an additional six days in reading and
eight days in math. Also, many charters have narrowed the
achievement gap between black and white students; about 7
percent of charter schools even reverse the achievement gap,
with black students performing equal or better than their white
peers.\9\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\https://ncss3.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Credo-
NCSS3-Report.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Charter schools have proven popular with parents and
families. A 2022 national survey conducted by The Harris Poll
found that 81 percent of parents support expanding the number
of slots in existing public charter schools in their area and
78 percent want more public charter school offerings in their
area.\10\ A January 2023 poll from EdChoice found that 70
percent of parents and 61 percent of all adults support charter
schools.\11\ A January 2024 survey from National School Choice
Week found that 72 percent of parents considered new schools
for their children last year compared to just 52 percent in
2022, a 35 percent increase. Lastly, just 29 percent of parents
said that the same school type works well for all of the
children in their home.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\https://www.publiccharters.org/our-work/publications/never-
going-back-analysis-parent-
sentiment-education.
\11\https://edchoice.morningconsultintelligence.com/.
\12\https://schoolchoiceweek.com/survey/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Background on the need for assistance in starting a charter school and
H.R. 6418
As the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools notes,
the charter school application process can be extraordinarily
lengthy and complex.\13\ Further, aspiring charter school
leaders generally must complete these applications in their
spare time, often with little financial or technical support
from philanthropy, their state, or other sources. These
constraints can present formidable barriers to entry for the
educators and school leaders who know their communities best
and might be best positioned to open a new school.\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\https://publiccharters.org/news/how-the-empower-charter-school-
educators-to-lead-act-
supports-equity-and-innovation/.
\14\https://publiccharters.org/news/how-the-empower-charter-school-
educators-to-lead-act-
supports-equity-and-innovation/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Establishing a modest amount of funding for the pre-
planning stage of charter development could enable more
aspiring charter leaders to develop, refine, and submit charter
school applications.
The charter school community has also noted the need for
states to provide more technical assistance to applicants.\15\
A recent National Charter School Resource Center report showed
that most state entity grantees of the federal CSP concentrated
their technical assistance funds on issues such as helping
schools meet the needs of students with disabilities and
English learners.\16\ A separate study found that state
entities often use technical assistance to provide pre-award
workshops, share resources on grant management and application,
and provide post-award grants management instruction.\17\
Expanding the amount of grant funds that may be spent on
technical assistance activities would provide states the
flexibility to target resources to where they are needed most.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\https://publiccharters.org/news/how-the-empower-charter-school-
educators-to-lead-act-
supports-equity-and-innovation/.
\16\https://charterschoolcenter.ed.gov/resource/how-2017-2019-
state-entity-grantees-are-using-technical-assistance-set-aside-funds.
\17\https://charterschoolcenter.ed.gov/sites/default/files/upload/
reports/How-2017-2019-State-
Entity-Grantees-Are-Using-TA-Set-Aside-Funds.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Representative Letlow's bipartisan Empower Charter School
Educators to Lead Act (H.R. 6418) would authorize state
entities to use up to 5 percent of their federal CSP grants to
make pre-planning awards (of no more than $100,000 each) to
prospective charter applicants (or public or nonprofit entities
that will support prospective applicants) and increase the
percentage of CSP grant funds state entities may use for state
technical assistance from 7 percent to 10 percent.
Note that the bill does not create a new program or contain
a new authorization. Neither does the bill micro-manage how
state entities allocate funds. Instead, the bill simply gives
state entities the option to devote a share of their CSP grant
to aspiring charter leaders and the option to devote more CSP
resources to technical assistance.
Conclusion
With likely hundreds of thousands of students on charter
school waiting lists nationwide, policymakers should be doing
everything possible to support the development of additional
high-quality charter schools. Polling shows that parents of all
political, racial, and socioeconomic backgrounds support
charter schools and want more educational options. This bill
would enable more promising schools to get off the ground, more
parents to choose what is best for their children's education,
and more children to get an education that is best suited t
Minority Views
INTRODUCTION
H.R. 6418, the Empower Charter School Educators to Lead
Act, would allow charter school developers to use Charter
School Program funds as pre-planning grants to develop ideas
for charter schools. The Majority claims that H.R. 6418, the
Empower Charter School Educators to Lead Act, will ``support
high-quality charter school developers so we can continue to
expand learning opportunities for our students.\1\'' However,
the bill is largely duplicative of current law and increases
opportunities for waste, fraud, and abuse of government
funding.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\Press Release, Rep. Julia Letlow (LA-05), Rep. Jill Tokuda (HI-
02), Rep. John James (MI-10), and Rep. Juan Ciscomani (AZ-06) Introduce
the Empower Charter School Educators to Lead Act (Nov. 16, 2023),
https://letlow.house.gov/media/press-releases/rep-julia-letlow-la-05-
rep-jill-tokuda-hi-02-rep-john-james-mi-10-and-rep-juan.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY OF CONCERNS
H.R. 6418 is Largely Duplicative of Current Law But Removes Basic
Guardrails
Republicans assert that H.R. 6418 ``authorizes State
Entities who receive grants through the Charter Schools Program
(CSP) to use a portion of their funding to support the
application process and development of new charter schools''
but claim that ``[current law] does not allow funding to be
used for the planning phase of charter schools.''\2\ They fail
to acknowledge that current law does support charter school
planning and development but it includes requirements that are
geared toward ensuring a developer has taken official action to
solidify their intentions--that is, submitting an application
to a charter authorizer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
CSP is comprised of several grant programs, authorized by
the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA),\3\ that have
the purpose of ``supporting innovation; providing financial
assistance for the planning, design, and initial implementation
of charter schools; increasing the number of high-quality
charter schools; encouraging states to provide charter schools
facilities financing; and strengthening the charter school
authorizing process.''\4\ H.R. 6418 would amend the CSP grant
program specifically designed to provide funds to state
entities\5\ (hereinafter referred to as ``CSP Grants to State
Entities''\6\). Under this program, state entities ``must use
at least 90% of the funds received to award []grants to
eligible applicants to enable them to open and prepare for the
operation of a new charter school or replicate or expand an
existing high-quality charter school.''\7\ To be eligible for a
grant through the current CSP Grants to State Entities program,
a charter school developer must have applied to a charter
authorizer to open a charter school but it is not necessary as
a condition of receiving the funding that the application has
been approved. Once funds are received, a grantee may use up to
18 months for planning purposes. Under current law, there is no
guarantee that a proposed charter school for which a developer
received a grant will open, but at the very least, the
developer must have applied to a charter authorizer. The
requirement that the developer apply to a charter authorizer
before receiving grant is an important first step in the
charter school process, as charter authorizers are charged with
determining which charter schools can open, establishing both
operational and academic expectations, overseeing a charter
school's performance, and determining which charter agreements
to renew and which charter schools should close.\8\ Applying to
an authorizer demonstrates serious intent and commitment on the
part of the developer as they have to meet the application
requirements that have been established by the charter
authorizer and state law, and it begins the process of working
with the charter authorizer to determine whether the
application will be approved, which may include guidance and
feedback from the charter authorizer.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\20 U.S.C. Sec. Sec. 7221-7221j.
\4\Rebecca R. Skinner & Isobel Sorenson, Cong. Rsch. Serv., IF12601
ESEA: Charter Schools Program, 1, (2024), https://www.crs.gov/reports/
pdf/IF12601/IF12601.pdf.
\5\20 U.S.C. Sec. 7221b defines a ``state entity'' as a state
educational agency, a state charter school board, a governor of a state
or a charter schools support organization.
\6\U.S. Dep't of Educ., Expanding Opportunities Through Quality
Charter Schools Program (CSP) Grants to State Entities, https://
oese.ed.gov/offices/office-of-discretionary-grants-support-services/
charter-schools-program/state-entities/ (last visited April 1, 2024).
\7\Id. Technically, states are the entities awarded grants through
the CSP Grants to State Entities grants program; states then provide
subgrants to eligible applicants. 20 U.S.C. Sec. 7221b. For the purpose
of this report, subgrants from the state will be referred to as grants.
\8\Jamison White, How Are Charter Schools Held Accountable?, Nat'l
All. for Pub. Charter Schs. (Dec. 19, 2023, updated Dec. 22, 2023),
https://data.publiccharters.org/digest/charter-school-data-digest/who-
authorizes-charter-schools/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Yet H.R. 6418 would remove that requirement--a guardrail
that ensures that a developer is working with a charter
authorizer--by making charter school developers\9\ eligible for
``pre-charter planning'' grants prior to submitting an
application to a charter authorizer. To be clear, H.R. 6418
eliminates this critical step necessary for receiving federal
funds without any added requirements for transparency or
accountability by a charter school developer. Moreover, the
bill would create a set-aside for these funds by reducing the
amount of CSP Grants to State Entities that, as stated
previously, are already designed to go to charter school
developers who have begun the process of planning a new or
replicating or expanding an existing high-quality charter
school. This has the potential to reduce the impact of the
funds as originally designed, that is, the ability of an
existing high-quality charter school to successfully serve more
students and ensure that those students receive a high-quality
education.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\9\The bill defines the term ``charter school developer'' in this
instance as an entity led by educators with not less than 54 months
working in a school, summer school, of after school program and who
have ``demonstrated leadership competencies and success with students,
as determined by'' a state entity. In addition, the charter school
developer must have completed an initial charter school plan, including
``a description of the educational needs of the community'' and ``how
the planned charter school will be suited to meet those needs.'' See
Empower Charter School Educators to Lead Act, H.R. 6418, 118th Cong.
Sec. 2 (2023).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 6418 also enables states to use funds from CSP Grants
to State Entities to help developers locate, access, and
renovate facilities and secure financial support. However,
funds under other CSP grant programs can already be used for
these purposes. CSP Credit Enhancement Grants (CEGs)\10\``are
made to public or private entities (or a combination of the
two) for the development of credit enhancement initiatives to
assist charter schools in acquiring, constructing, or
renovating facilities.''\11\ In addition, CEGs ``may be used to
guarantee, insure, and reinsure bonds, notes, evidences of
debt, and interests therein; guarantee and insure leases of
personal and real property; facilitate financing by identifying
lending sources and encouraging private lending to, or for the
benefit of, charter schools; and facilitate the issuance of
bonds by charter schools or other public entities for the
benefit of charter schools.''\12\ Further, CSP Facilities
Incentive Grants\13\ (also called Per-Pupil Facilities Grants)
``provide[] funds to states to establish or enhance and
administer per-pupil facilities allowances to help charter
schools obtain facilities'' in states that permit such per-
pupil facilities aid.\14\ Still, the bill would expand funding
available for these already-permitted activities.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\10\20 U.S.C. Sec. 7221c.
\11\Skinner, supra note 4 at 2.
\12\Id.
\13\20 U.S.C. Sec. 7221c.
\14\Skinner, supra note 4 at 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 6418 Could Increase Lack of Accountability, Transparency, and
Oversight Resulting in Conflicts of Interest, Profiteering, and
Waste, Fraud, and Abuse in Charter Schools
There is data demonstrating that some funding that is used
to plan and open charter schools is used by charter schools
that either never come to fruition or open and then close. A
2022 audit by the U.S. Department of Education's (ED) Office of
Inspector General (OIG) found that for CSP funds distributed
between 2013 and 2016, grantees opened or expanded only 51
percent of the schools promised and for which they received
funding.\15\ Former Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos
disclosed that from school year 2006-2007 to school year 2013-
2014, $70 million in CSP funding was provided to 634 charter
schools that did not open or were not likely to open.\16\ And
according to a report by the Network for Public Education, the
numbers for that same time period are much higher--over $502
million was awarded to schools that never opened or opened and
closed.\17\ While these are substantial amounts, without any
new accountability guardrails or requirements of expertise, it
would not be surprising if these numbers were higher if H.R.
6418 were to become law.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\U.S. Dep't of Educ. Off. of Inspector Gen., ED-OIG/A21IL0034,
Effectiveness of Charter School Programs in Increasing the Number of
Charter Schools (Sept. 21, 2022), https://www.oversight.gov/sites/
default/files/oig-reports/ED/FY22A21IL0034020724v100SECURED.pdf.
\16\Letter from Sec. Betsy DeVos to Rep. Raul Grijalva (June 28,
2019), https://networkforpubliceducation.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/
12/Sec-DeVos-CSP-Response-6-28-19.pdf.
\17\Still Asleep at the Wheel: How the Federal Charter Schools
Program Results in a Pileup of Fraud and Waste, Network for Pub. Educ.,
https://networkforpubliceducation.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Still-
Asleep-at-the-Wheel.pdf (last visited Mar. 28, 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Other audits have found additional financial issues. In a
2016 audit of charter school management, ED's OIG found lack of
accountability of federal funds; waste, fraud, and abuse; and
schools not providing students the services required by federal
programs.\18\ A 2023 ED OIG audit found that charter school
management did not always address compliance issues relating
``to their uses of Replication and Expansion grant funds,
fiscal control, and fund accounting'' and that charter schools
``with highly problematic applications'' still received
millions of federal dollars from CSP.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\18\U.S. Dep't of Educ. Off. of Inspector Gen., ED-OIG/A02M0012,
Nationwide Assessment of Charter and Education Management Organizations
(Sept. 2016), https://www.oversight.gov/sites/default/files/oig-
reports/a02m0012.pdf.
\19\U.S. Dep't of Educ. Off. of Inspector Gen., ED-OIG/A18IL0009,
The U.S. Department of Education's Processes for Overseeing Charter
Schools Program Grants to Charter Management Organizations for the
Replication and Expansion of High-Quality Charter Schools (Aug. 3,
2023), https://oig.ed.gov/sites/default/files/reports/2024-03/
FY23A18IL0009012924SECUREDv100.pdf; Valerie Strauss, How did this
charter school get a nearly $2 million federal grant?, Wash. Post (Dec.
6, 2023), https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2023/12/06/how-did-
this-charter-school-get-big-federal-grant/.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 6418 paves the way for further misuse of federal funds
because the bill does not require the charter school developer
or entity supporting the developer to have applied to a charter
authorizer to open a charter school. As discussed above, the
importance of working with a charter authorizer from the outset
should not be underestimated. While state laws vary on the
roles and responsibilities of charter authorizers, and there
are both good and bad actors, in general it is the role of such
authorizers to establish expectations and parameters around
charter schools and oversee their performance, including which
to open, renew, and close.\20\ In addition, the bill has no
requirement of charter experience by a charter school
developer, no guarantee the charter school developer will reach
the application stage much less get approved or be opened, no
requirement that the initial charter school plan consider
evidence or standards of high-quality, and no limits on for-
profit charter school managers. By expanding CSP funds to
``pre-charter planning'' grants prior to application without
any expectations or limitations, the bill creates further lack
of transparency and accountability and greater potential for
waste, fraud, and abuse.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\Authorizing Matters, Nat'l Ass'n of Charter Sch. Authorizers,
https://qualitycharters.org/authorizingmatters/ (last visited Mar. 28,
2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
H.R. 6418 Ignores Issues Found in Some Charter Schools
When public charter schools are established and run with
oversight, accountability, and protections for students and
families, they can be a tool to achieving high-quality
educational opportunities for students. While there are
certainly high-quality charter schools, it is worth noting that
there are concerns and issues that have surrounded many charter
schools for decades, including: whether charter schools meet
the same academic outcomes of traditional public schools\21\;
reports that charter schools are more segregated than
traditional public schools, most recently for suburban Black,
Latino, and Asian students\22\; reports that charter schools
often utilize harsher punishment methods than traditional
public schools, and Black students and students with
disabilities are disproportionately punished;\23\ the fact that
charter schools are not bound to hire only certified teachers
the way traditional public schools are;\24\ reports that
charter school teachers tend to be less experienced, have
higher turnover rates, lower pay, less job security, and more
challenging working conditions than teachers in traditional
public schools;\25\ and data showing the enrollment of students
with disabilities in charter schools consistently lags behind
traditional public schools, and once enrolled, students with
disabilities are ``pushed out'' of charter schools at a higher
rate than their non-disabled peers.\26\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\21\See, e.g., Philip Gleason, et al., The Evaluation of Charter
School Impacts: Final Report, Nat'l Ctr. for Educ. Evaluation and Reg'l
Assistance Report No. 2010-4029 (June 2010), https://eric.ed.gov/
?id=ED510573; see also Will S. Dobbie and Roland G. Fryer, Charter
Schools and Labor Market Outcomes, Nat'l Bur. of Econ. Rsch. (Aug.
2016), https://www.nber.org/papers/w22502.
\22\Erica Frankenberg, & Chungmei Lee, Charter Schools and Race: A
Lost Opportunity for Integrated Education, Educ. Pol'y Analysis
Archives (Sept. 5, 2003), https://epaa.asu.edu/index/EPA/article/view/
260/386; Erica Brandenburg, et al., Choice without Equity: Charter
School Segregation and the Need for Civil Rights Standards, The C. R..
Project (Jan. 2010), https://civilrightsproject.ucla.edu/research/k-12-
education/integration-and-diversity/choice-without-equity-2009-report/
frankenberg-choices-without-equity-2010.pdf; Erica Brandenburg&
Genevieve Siege, Understanding Suburban School Segregation: Toward a
Renewed Civil Rights Agenda, The C. R.. Project (Feb. 2024), https://
overnights/research/k-12-education/integration-and-diversity/
understanding-suburban-school-segregation-toward-a-renewed-civil-
rights-agenda/suburban-segregation-021224-v2.pdf.
\23\Mikailla Carwin, The Charter School Network: The
Disproportionate Discipline of Black Students, The City Univ. of N.Y.
L. Rev. (2018), https://academicworks.cuny.edu/cgi/
viewcontent.cgi?article=1445&context=clr; see, e.g., Gov't
Accountability Off., GAO-17-165, District of Columbia Charter Schools:
Multi-Agency Plan Needed to Continue Progress Addressing High and
Disproportionate Discipline Rates (Feb. 9, 2017), https://www.gao.gov/
products/gao-17-165.
\24\Am. Univ. Sch. of Educ., Charter School vs. Public School:
Differences in Teaching Environments, (Dec. 22, 2020), https://
soeonline.american.edu/blog/charter-school-vs-public-school/; Shawgi
Tell, Countless Charter Schools Hire Many Uncertified Teachers, Hampton
Inst. (June 27, 2021), https://www.hamptonthink.org/read/countless-
charter-schools-hire-many-uncertified-teachers.
\25\Id.; Am. Univ. Sch. of Educ., Charter School vs. Public School:
Differences in Teaching Environments, (Dec. 22, 2020), https://
soeonline.american.edu/blog/charter-school-vs-public-school/.
\26\School Choice Series: Charter Schols--Implications for Students
with Disabilities, Nat'l Council on Disability (Nov. 2018), https://
www.ncd.gov/report/choice-and-vouchers-implications-for-students-with-
disabilities/ at page 55.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The bill is silent on all of these issues. Once again,
school choice appears to be of primary importance to the
Majority, more so than other important issues, such as
students' academic outcomes and students' civil rights.
Democratic Amendments Offered During the Markup of H.R. 6418
Committee Democrats proffered two amendments in response to
H.R. 6418. In order to ensure that students receive a quality
education and taxpayers funds are responsibly spent, Rep.
Stevens offered an amendment to prohibit states from using
grant funds received from the federal government for virtual
charter schools. In order to combat increased segregation in
charter schools and take a step towards fulfilling the promise
of Brown v. Board of Education,\27\ Ranking Member Scott
offered an amendment requiring prospective charter school
developers to conduct an assessment of segregation in the
community in which the proposed charter school will be located,
a strategy for how the proposed charter school will effectively
address desegregation i