Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 8281]
The Committee on House Administration, to whom was referred
the bill (H.R. 8281) to amend the National Voter Registration
Act of 1993 to require proof of United States citizenship to
register an individual to vote in elections for Federal office,
and for other purposes, having considered the same, reports
favorably thereon with an amendment and recommends that the
bill as amended do pass.
CONTENTS
Page
Purpose and Summary.............................................. 7
Background and Need for Legislation.............................. 8
Committee Action................................................. 23
Committee Consideration.......................................... 24
Committee Votes.................................................. 24
Committee Oversight Findings..................................... 24
Statement of Budget Authority and Related Items.................. 24
Congressional Budget Office Estimate............................. 25
Performance Goals and Objectives................................. 25
Duplication of Federal Programs.................................. 25
Advisory on Earmarks............................................. 25
Federal Mandates Statement....................................... 25
Advisory Committee Statement..................................... 26
Applicability to Legislative Branch.............................. 26
Section-by-Section Analysis...................................... 26
Changes in Existing Law as Reported.............................. 29
Minority Views................................................... 47
The amendment is as follows:
Strike all after the enacting clause and insert the
following:
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the ``Safeguard American Voter Eligibility
Act'' or the ``SAVE Act''.
SEC. 2. ENSURING ONLY CITIZENS ARE REGISTERED TO VOTE IN ELECTIONS FOR
FEDERAL OFFICE.
(a) Definition of Documentary Proof of United States Citizenship.--
Section 3 of the National Voter Registration Act of 1993 (52 U.S.C.
20502) is amended--
(1) by striking ``As used'' and inserting ``(a) In General.--
As used''; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
``(b) Documentary Proof of United States Citizenship.--As used in
this Act, the term `documentary proof of United States citizenship'
means, with respect to an applicant for voter registration, any of the
following:
``(1) A form of identification issued consistent with the
requirements of the REAL ID Act of 2005 that indicates the
applicant is a citizen of the United States.
``(2) A valid United States passport.
``(3) The applicant's official United States military
identification card, together with a United States military
record of service showing that the applicant's place of birth
was in the United States.
``(4) A valid government-issued photo identification card
issued by a Federal, State or Tribal government showing that
the applicant's place of birth was in the United States.
``(5) A valid government-issued photo identification card
issued by a Federal, State or Tribal government other than an
identification described in paragraphs (1) through (4), but
only if presented together with one or more of the following:
``(A) A certified birth certificate issued by a
State, a unit of local government in a State, or a
Tribal government which--
``(i) was issued by the State, unit of local
government, or Tribal government in which the
applicant was born;
``(ii) was filed with the office responsible
for keeping vital records in the State;
``(iii) includes the full name, date of
birth, and place of birth of the applicant;
``(iv) lists the full names of one or both of
the parents of the applicant;
``(v) has the signature of an individual who
is authorized to sign birth certificates on
behalf of the State, unit of local government,
or Tribal government in which the applicant was
born;
``(vi) includes the date that the certificate
was filed with the office responsible for
keeping vital records in the State; and
``(vii) has the seal of the State, unit of
local government, or Tribal government that
issued the birth certificate.
``(B) An extract from a United States hospital Record
of Birth created at the time of the applicant's birth
which indicates that the applicant's place of birth was
in the United States.
``(C) A final adoption decree showing the applicant's
name and that the applicant's place of birth was in the
United States.
``(D) A Consular Report of Birth Abroad of a citizen
of the United States or a certification of the
applicant's Report of Birth of a United States citizen
issued by the Secretary of State.
``(E) A Naturalization Certificate or Certificate of
Citizenship issued by the Secretary of Homeland
Security or any other document or method of proof of
United States citizenship issued by the Federal
government pursuant to the Immigration and Nationality
Act.
``(F) An American Indian Card issued by the
Department of Homeland Security with the classification
`KIC'.''.
(b) In General.--Section 4 of the National Voter Registration Act of
1993 (52 U.S.C. 20503) is amended--
(1) in subsection (a), by striking ``subsection (b)'' and
inserting ``subsection (c)'';
(2) by redesignating subsection (b) as subsection (c); and
(3) by inserting after subsection (a) the following new
subsection:
``(b) Requiring Applicants to Present Documentary Proof of United
States Citizenship.--Under any method of voter registration in a State,
the State shall not accept and process an application to register to
vote in an election for Federal office unless the applicant presents
documentary proof of United States citizenship with the application.''.
(c) Registration With Application for Motor Vehicle Driver's
License.--Section 5 of the National Voter Registration Act of 1993 (52
U.S.C. 20504) is amended--
(1) in subsection (a)(1), by striking ``Each State motor
vehicle driver's license application'' and inserting ``Subject
to the requirements under section 8(j), each State motor
vehicle driver's license application'';
(2) in subsection (c)(1), by striking ``Each State shall
include'' and inserting ``Subject to the requirements under
section 8(j), each State shall include'';
(3) in subsection (c)(2)(B)--
(A) in clause (i), by striking ``and'' at the end;
(B) in clause (ii), by adding ``and'' at the end; and
(C) by adding at the end the following new clause:
``(iii) verify that the applicant is a citizen of the
United States;'';
(4) in subsection (c)(2)(C)(i), by striking ``(including
citizenship)'' and inserting ``, including the requirement that
the applicant provides documentary proof of United States
citizenship''; and
(5) in subsection (c)(2)(D)(iii), by striking ``; and'' and
inserting the following: ``, other than as evidence in a
criminal proceeding or immigration proceeding brought against
an applicant who knowingly attempts to register to vote and
knowingly makes a false declaration under penalty of perjury
that the applicant meets the eligibility requirements to
register to vote in an election for Federal office; and''.
(d) Requiring Documentary Proof of United States Citizenship With
National Mail Voter Registration Form.--Section 6 of the National Voter
Registration Act of 1993 (52 U.S.C. 20505) is amended--
(1) in subsection (a)(1)--
(A) by striking ``Each State shall accept and use''
and inserting ``Subject to the requirements under
section 8(j), each State shall accept and use''; and
(B) by striking ``Federal Election Commission'' and
inserting ``Election Assistance Commission'';
(2) in subsection (b), by adding at the end the following:
``The chief State election official of a State shall take such
steps as may be necessary to ensure that residents of the State
are aware of the requirement to provide documentary proof of
United States citizenship to register to vote in elections for
Federal office in the State.'';
(3) in subsection (c)(1)--
(A) in subparagraph (A), by striking ``and'' at the
end;
(B) in subparagraph (B) by striking the period at the
end and inserting ``; and''; and
(C) by adding at the end the following new
subparagraph:
``(C) the person did not provide documentary proof of United
States citizenship when registering to vote.''; and
(4) by adding at the end the following new subsection:
``(e) Ensuring Proof of United States Citizenship.--
``(1) Presenting proof of united states citizenship to
election official.--An applicant who submits the mail voter
registration application form prescribed by the Election
Assistance Commission pursuant to section 9(a)(2) or a form
described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subsection (a) shall not
be registered to vote in an election for Federal office
unless--
``(A) the applicant presents documentary proof of
United States citizenship in person to the office of
the appropriate election official not later than the
deadline provided by State law for the receipt of a
completed voter registration application for the
election; or
``(B) in the case of a State which permits an
individual to register to vote in an election for
Federal office at a polling place on the day of the
election and on any day when voting, including early
voting, is permitted for the election, the applicant
presents documentary proof of United States citizenship
to the appropriate election official at the polling
place not later than the date of the election.
``(2) Notification of requirement.--Upon receiving an
otherwise completed mail voter registration application form
prescribed by the Election Assistance Commission pursuant to
section 9(a)(2) or a form described in paragraph (1) or (2) of
subsection (a), the appropriate election official shall
transmit a notice to the applicant of the requirement to
present documentary proof of United States citizenship under
this subsection, and shall include in the notice instructions
to enable the applicant to meet the requirement.
``(3) Accessibility.--Each State shall, in consultation with
the Election Assistance Commission, ensure that reasonable
accommodations are made to allow an individual with a
disability who submits the mail voter registration application
form prescribed by the Election Assistance Commission pursuant
to section 9(a)(2) or a form described in paragraph (1) or (2)
of subsection (a) to present documentary proof of United States
citizenship to the appropriate election official.''.
(e) Requirements for Voter Registration Agencies.--Section 7 of the
National Voter Registration Act of 1993 (52 U.S.C. 20506) is amended--
(1) in subsection (a)--
(A) in paragraph (4)(A), by adding at the end the
following new clause:
``(iv) Receipt of documentary proof of United States
citizenship of each applicant to register to vote in elections
for Federal office in the State.''; and
(B) in paragraph (6)--
(i) in subparagraph (A)(i)(I), by striking
``(including citizenship)'' and inserting ``,
including the requirement that the applicant
provides documentary proof of United States
citizenship''; and
(ii) by redesignating subparagraph (B) as
subparagraph (C); and
(iii) by inserting after subparagraph (A) the
following new subparagraph:
``(B) ask the applicant the question, `Are you a citizen of
the United States?' and if the applicant answers in the
affirmative require documentary proof of United States
citizenship prior to providing the form under subparagraph
(C);''; and
(2) in subsection (c)(1), by inserting ``who are citizens of
the United States'' after ``for persons''.
(f) Requirements With Respect to Administration of Voter
Registration.--Section 8 of the National Voter Registration Act of 1993
(52 U.S.C. 20507) is amended--
(1) in subsection (a)--
(A) by striking ``In the administration of voter
registration'' and inserting ``Subject to the
requirements of subsection (j), in the administration
of voter registration''; and
(B) in paragraph (3)--
(i) in subparagraph (B), by striking ``or''
at the end; and
(ii) by adding at the end the following new
subparagraphs:
``(D) based on documentary proof or verified
information that the registrant is not a United States
citizen; or
``(E) the registration otherwise fails to comply with
applicable State law;'';
(2) by redesignating subsection (j) as subsection (l); and
(3) by inserting after subsection (i) the following new
subsections:
``(j) Ensuring Only Citizens Are Registered to Vote.--
``(1) In general.--Notwithstanding any other provision of
this Act, a State may not register an individual to vote in
elections for Federal office held in the State unless, at the
time the individual applies to register to vote, the individual
provides documentary proof of United States citizenship.
``(2) Additional processes in certain cases.--
``(A) Process for those without documentary proof.--
``(i) In general.--Subject to any relevant
guidance adopted by the Election Assistance
Commission, each State shall establish a
process under which an applicant who cannot
provide documentary proof of United States
citizenship under paragraph (1) may, if the
applicant signs an attestation under penalty of
perjury that the applicant is a citizen of the
United States and eligible to vote in elections
for Federal office, submit such other evidence
to the appropriate State or local official
demonstrating that the applicant is a citizen
of the United States and such official shall
make a determination as to whether the
applicant has sufficiently established United
States citizenship for purposes of registering
to vote in elections for Federal office in the
State.
``(ii) Affidavit requirement.--If a State or
local official makes a determination under
clause (i) that an applicant has sufficiently
established United States citizenship for
purposes of registering to vote in elections
for Federal office in the State, such
determination shall be accompanied by an
affidavit developed under clause (iii) signed
by the official swearing or affirming the
applicant sufficiently established United
States citizenship for purposes of registering
to vote.
``(iii) Development of affidavit by the
election assistance commission.--The Election
Assistance Commission shall develop a uniform
affidavit for use by State and local officials
under clause (ii), which shall--
``(I) include an explanation of the
minimum standards required for a State
or local official to register an
applicant who cannot provide
documentary proof of United States
citizenship to vote in elections for
Federal office in the State; and
``(II) require the official to
explain the basis for registering such
applicant to vote in such elections.
``(B) Process in case of certain discrepancies in
documentation.--Subject to any relevant guidance
adopted by the Election Assistance Commission, each
State shall establish a process under which an
applicant can provide such additional documentation to
the appropriate election official of the State as may
be necessary to establish that the applicant is a
citizen of the United States in the event of a
discrepancy with respect to the applicant's documentary
Purpose and Summary
H.R. 8281, the Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act
(``SAVE'' Act), introduced by Representative Chip Roy (TX-21)
with forty-six original co-sponsors, amends the National Voter
Registration Act (``NVRA'') to require individuals registering
to vote in a federal election, under any voter registration
method, to provide their State with documentary proof of U.S.
citizenship before the State can accept and process their voter
application. For applicants registering without documentary
proof of U.S. citizenship, State officials can cross-check the
applicant's information across federal and State databases and
determine within twenty-four hours whether the applicant is a
citizen. The SAVE Act also clarifies that States can remove
noncitizens from their voter rolls, requires States to
establish a program to remove noncitizens from their voter
rolls, and gives States no-cost access to several federal and
State databases to do so. It also expands the NVRA's existing
private right of action to empower citizens to bring civil
suits against State election officials that fail to uphold the
Act's proof of citizenship requirement and adds criminal
penalties for election officials, including executive branch
officials, that register noncitizens to vote in Federal
elections. Federal law makes it unlawful for noncitizens to
vote in federal elections but following the Supreme Court's
decision in Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Ariz., Inc.,\1\
States have been prevented from asking applicants registering
to vote for documentary proof of U.S. citizenship.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\133 S.Ct. 2247 (2013).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
This has frustrated both the federal prohibition against
noncitizen voting as well as State prohibitions. Combined with
States refusing to clean their voter rolls under the NVRA and
the over 7 million illegal aliens that have come into the U.S.
under President Biden, Americans do not have confidence that
federal elections are free from foreign interference. The SAVE
Act requires States to ensure that only U.S. citizens are
voting in federal elections.
Background
Article I, Section 4 of the United States Constitution\2\
(``the Elections Clause'') explains that the States have the
primary authority over election administration, the ``times,
places, and manner of holding elections''[.] State authority to
administer elections for federal office was not a power
reserved by the States, but was instead expressly delegated to
them under the Constitution.\3\ The Elections Clause also
grants Congress a purely secondary role\4\ to alter or create
election laws, and regulate how federal elections are held.\5\
As do other aspects of our federal system, this division of
sovereignty continues to serve to protect one of Americans'
citizens most precious freedoms, the right to vote.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\2\U.S. Const. art. I, Sec. 4, cl. 1 (``[t]he Times, Places and
Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be
prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress
may at any time by Law make or alter such Regulations . . .'').
\3\U.S. Term Limits, Inc. v. Thornton, 514 U.S. 779, 804 (1995).
\4\Although the text of the Elections Clause, read literally and
without the benefit of context, might suggest Congress has unlimited
authority in this space, an examination of an examination of history,
precedent, the Framers' words, debates concerning ratification, the
Supreme Court, and the Constitution itself provide that this is not the
case. See Report: The Elections Clause: States' Primary Constitutional
Authority Over Elections, Comm. on H. Admin. (Republicans) (Aug. 12,
2021), https://republicanscha.house.gov/sites/
republicans.cha.house.gov/files/doc uments/
Report_The%20Elections%20Clause_States%20Primary%20Constitutional%20Auth
ority %20over%20Elections%20%28Aug%2011%2021%29.pdf.
\5\Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Ariz., Inc, 133 S.Ct. 2247,
2257 (2013).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The federal Constitution contains several voting rights
amendments, all of which only protect ``the right of citizens
of the United States'' in the voting process.\6\ To enforce
those rights, federal law makes it unlawful for noncitizens to
vote in federal elections.\7\ Similarly, federal law prohibits
foreign nationals\8\ from contributing or donating in
connection with a federal, state, or local election,\9\ making
a contribution or donation to a committee of a political
party,\10\ or making an expenditure (including an independent
expenditure) or disbursement for an electioneering
communication.\11\ Although the Supreme Court of the United
States has never been presented with the question whether the
foreign national prohibition violates the First Amendment, it
has previously affirmed a three-judge court's decision,
authored by then-Judge Kavanaugh, which upheld the foreign
national prohibition with respect to foreign nationals who
wanted to make contributions to federal and State
candidates.\12\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\See U.S. Const. Amend. XV, Sec. 1 ``The right of citizens of the
United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United
States or by any State on account of race, color, or previous condition
of servitude.''; U.S. Const. Amend. XIX, Sec. 1 ``The right of citizens
of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the
United States or by any State on account of sex.''; U.S. Const. Amend.
XXIV, Sec. 1 ``The right of citizens of the United States to vote in
any primary or other election for President or Vice President, for
electors for President or Vice President, or for Senator or
Representative in Congress, shall not be denied or abridged by the
United States or any State by reason of failure to pay any poll tax or
other tax.''; U.S. Const. Amend. XXVI, Sec. 1 ``The right of citizens
of the United States, who are eighteen years of age or older, to vote
shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on
account of age.''
\7\See 18 U.S.C. Sec. 611. Each of the voting rights amendments
listed in the previous footnote provide the authority for Congress to
enforce the amendment by appropriate legislation. In South Carolina v.
Katzenbach, the Supreme Court held that Congress has the power to act
under this authority as it would any of its powers under Article I,
Section 8 as articulated in McCulloch v. Maryland. See South Carolina
v. Katzenbach, 383, U.S. 301, 326-27 (1966). Allowing non-citizens to
cast ballots in American elections weakens our electoral system,
directly and indirectly impacts Federal policy and funding decisions
and candidate choice through the election of State and local officials,
dilutes the value of citizenship, and sows distrust in our elections
system; even if a State has the sovereign authority, no State should
permit noncitizens to cast ballots in State or local elections. See
U.S. Const. Amend. XIV; U.S. Const. Amend. XV; U.S. Const. Amend. XIX;
U.S. Const. Amend. XXIV; U.S. Const. Amend. XXVI.
\8\Federal law defines foreign national as an individual who is not
a citizen of the United States and not lawfully admitted for permanent
residence under 8 U.S.C. Sec. 1101(a)(20) or a foreign principal, as
defined in 22 U.S.C. Sec. 611(b).
\9\52 U.S.C. Sec. 30121(a)(1)(A).
\10\Id. at Sec. 30121(a)(1)(B).
\11\Id. at Sec. 30121(a)(1)(C). Federal law defines an
electioneering communication as ``any broadcast, cable, or satellite
communication which--refers to a clearly identified candidate for
Federal office; is made within--60 days before a general, special, or
runoff election for the office sought by the candidate; or 30 days
before a primary or preference election, or a convention or caucus of a
political party that has authority to nominate a candidate, for the
office sought by the candidate; and in the case of a communication
which refers to a candidate for an office other than President or Vice
President, is targeted to the relevant electorate.'' Id. at
Sec. 30104(f)(3).
\12\See Bluman v. FEC, 800 F. Supp. 2d 281, 288 (D.D.C. 2011),
aff'd, 565 U.S. 1104 (2012). Importantly, the three-judge decision did
not rely on Congress' power under the Elections Clause of Article I,
Section 4 to justify the foreign national spending prohibition. Cf.
Report: The Elections Clause: States' Primary Constitutional Authority
Over Elections, Comm. on H. Admin. (Republicans) (Aug. 12, 2021),
https://republicanscha.house.gov/sites/republicans.cha.house.gov/files/
documents/
Report_The%20Elections%20Clause_States%20Primary%20Constitutional%20Au
thority%20over%20Elections%20%28Aug%2011%2021%29.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Every State has used its constitutional authority to
establish voter qualifications, often consisting of age,
residency, and citizenship requirements.\13\ Several States
have enshrined U.S. citizenship in their State constitution as
a qualification for voters to vote in State elections.\14\ To
enforce both the federal and State constitutional and statutory
prohibitions on noncitizen voting, several States have enacted
documentary proof of citizenship requirements when applicants
register to vote.\15\ But as explained below, following the
Supreme Court's interpretation of the National Voter
Registration Act (``NVRA'') in Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council
of Ariz., Inc (``ITCA'') as well as other lower court
decisions, States have been relegated to enforcing the federal
and State prohibitions on noncitizen voting by requiring
applicants to sign, under penalty of perjury, that they are a
citizen without being able to ask for documentary proof.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\13\See Kramer v. Union Free School District 395 U.S. 621, 625
(1969) (`` . . . States have the power to impose reasonable
citizenship, age, and residency requirements on the availability of the
ballot.''); See also Carrington v. Rash, 380 U.S. 89, 91 (1965)
(``There can be no doubt either of the historic function of the States
to establish, on a nondiscriminatory basis, and in accordance with the
Constitution, other qualifications for the exercise of the
franchise.'')
\14\See Laws permitting noncitizens to vote in the United States,
Ballotpedia, available at https://ballotpedia.org/
Laws_permitting_noncitizens_to_vote_in_the_United_States.
\15\See, e.g. A.R.S. Sec. 16-121.01; MS Code Sec. 23-15-15; K.S.A.
25-2309.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The NVRA was signed into law by President Bill Clinton in
1993 ``to establish procedures that will increase the number of
eligible citizens who register to vote in elections for Federal
office; . . . protect the integrity of the electoral process;
and . . . ensure that accurate and current voter registration
rolls are maintained.''\16\ In conjunction with the
Constitution's voting rights amendments, Congress also found
that ``the right of citizens of the United States to vote is a
fundamental right''[.]\17\ The legislation is commonly referred
to as the ``motor voter'' law because it requires States to
provide individuals with voter registration materials when they
apply for a driver's license.\18\ However, effective August 1,
1994, the NVRA exempted States from its requirements that they
either had no voter-registration requirements or had election-
day voter registration at polling places with respect to
elections for federal office.\19\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\16\52 U.S.C. Sec. 20501(b).
\17\Id. at Sec. 20501(a).
\18\Id. at Sec. 20503(a).
\19\Id. Sec. 20503(b). Those States are Idaho, Minnesota,
New Hampshire, North Dakota, Wisconsin, and Wyoming. Of these, North
Dakota is the only one that does not have voter registration.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE NVRA AND NONCITIZENS
Although almost no States allow noncitizens to vote in
their elections, over 20 States do allow noncitizens to apply
for driver's licenses.\20\ Unfortunately, because of human
error in the process at the counter or in the computer system,
noncitizens will be given voter registration forms and might
unlawfully register to vote in at least some of these
situations. This is not a hypothetical as Pennsylvania admitted
that just a few years ago it had inadvertently allowed over
10,000 noncitizens to register to vote via this process,\21\
and Texas has had similar problems with nearly 100,000
registrations.\22\ And now that Pennsylvania and other States
have implemented automatic voter registration when an applicant
obtains a new or renewed driver license or identification card
unless the applicant affirmatively opts-out, there is a strong
possibility that at least some noncitizens will continue to end
up on the voter rolls.\23\ When Illinois implemented automatic
voter registration several years ago, hundreds of noncitizens
ended up on the voter rolls.\24\ More recently, Ohio announced
it was removing upwards of 100 noncitizens from their
rolls\25\, a Georgia audit found more than 1,600 noncitizens
had attempted to register to vote\26\, and Virginia recently
removed almost 1,500 noncitizens from its rolls.\27\
Remarkably, the Public Legal Interest Legal Foundation has
found that in California, Florida, Texas, Virginia,
Pennsylvania, and New Jersey, noncitizens that admitted they
were not U.S. citizens were still incorrectly registered to
vote.\28\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\See States Offering Driver's Licenses to Immigrants, National
Conference of State Legislatures (Mar. 13, 2023), https://www.ncsl.org/
immigration/states-offering-drivers-licenses-to-immi grants.
\21\Rowan Scarborough, Stephen Dinan, Pennsylvania admits to 11,000
noncitizens registered to vote, Washington Times (Jan. 30, 2019),
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2019/jan/30/pennsylvania-11000-
non-citizens-registered-vote/.; Pam Fessler, Some Noncitizens Do Wind
Up Registered To Vote, But Usually Not On Purpose, National Public
Radio (Feb. 26, 2019), https://www.npr.org/2019/02/26/697848417/some-
noncitizens-do-wind-up-registered-to-vote-but-usually-not-on-purpose.
\22\Alexa Ura, Texas' renewed voter citizenship review is still
flagging citizens as ``possible non-U.S. citizens'', The Texas Tribune
(Dec. 17, 2021), https://www.texastribune.org/2021/12/17/texas-voter-
roll-review/.
\23\Governor Shapiro Implements Automatic Voter Registration in
Pennsylvania, Joining Bipartisan Group of States That Have Taken
Commonsense Step to Make Voter Registration More Streamlined and
Secure, Governor Josh Shapiro (Sept. 19, 2023), https://
www.governor.pa.gov/newsroom/governor-shapiro-implements-automatic-
voter-registration-in-pennsylvania-joining-bip artisan-group-of-states-
that-have-taken-commonsense-step-to-make-voter-registration-more-stre
amlined-and-secure/.
\24\Mike Lowe, Hundreds of non-citizens registered to vote in
Illinois due to technical glitch, WGN9 (Jan. 21, 2020), https://
wgntv.com/news/hundreds-of-non-citizens-registered-to-vote-in-ill
inois-due-to-technical-glitch/.
\25\Anders Hagstrom, Ohio purges `non-citizens' from state voter
rolls, calls on Biden admin for data ahead of 2024 election, Fox News
(May 14, 2024), https://www.foxnews.com/politics/ohio-purges-non-
citizens-state-voter-rolls-calls-biden-admin-data-ahead-2024-election.
\26\Ga. elections chief finds 1,634 noncitizen voting attempts,
1226 (April 11, 2022), https://www.wrdw.com/2022/04/11/watch-live-ga-
elections-news-conference/.
\27\VA Records Show Non-citizens Voting, EPEC News, available at
https://epec.info/2024/03/22/va-records-show-non-citizens-voting/.
\28\Testimony of J. Christian Adams, Before the U.S. House of
Representatives Committee on House Administration (May 16, 2024),
https://docs.house.gov/meetings/HA/HA00/20240516/117312/HHRG-118-HA00-
Wstate-AdamsJ-20240516.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
In addition to driver's licenses, noncitizens are eligible
for a variety of federal and State benefit programs. On the
federal level, such programs include the Supplemental Nutrition
Assistance Program, the Supplemental Security Income Program,
Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, and Medicaid, among
others.\29\ At the State level, such programs include New
York's Safety Net Assistance, California's CalFresh Food
Assistance Program, and California's Cash Assistance Program
for Immigrants, among others.\30\ As with driver's licenses,
when noncitizens apply for and receive government benefits,
there is a possibility their names end up on the voter rolls.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\29\Abigail F. Kolker, Noncitizen Eligibility for Federal Public
Assistance: Policy Overview, CRS Report RL33809, https://
crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/RL/RL33809.
\30\Fact Sheet: Immigrants and Public Benefits, National
Immigration Forum, https://immigrationforum.org/wp-content/uploads/
2018/08/Immigrants-and-Public-Benefits-FINALupdat ed.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unfortunately, the risk of unlawful noncitizen voting in
federal and State elections is not a myth. In the 1996 federal
midterm election for California's 46th District, the House
committee charged with investigating the race found ```clear
and convincing' evidence that 624 aliens had voted illegally in
the Dornan-Sanchez election and circumstantial evidence that
another 196 aliens also had done so.''\31\ In 2011, Fairfax
County, Virginia, discovered over 278 noncitizens on the voter
roll and learned that 117 of them had illegally voted in
Virginia elections.\32\ Over the past decade, several different
Arizona counties reported finding hundreds noncitizens on the
voter rolls and determined some of them illegally voted in
federal elections.\33\ Other jurisdictions like Chicago,
Illinois, San Diego County, California, and Alleghany County,
Pennsylvania have all dealt with similar problems and learned
that noncitizens had illegally voted.\34\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\31\Hans von Spakovsky, J. Christian Adams, Despite Liberals'
Hysterical Denials, Aliens Are Registering and Voting, The Daily Signal
(June 6, 2024), https://www.dailysignal.com/2024/06/06/despite-
liberals-hysterical-denial-aliens-are-registering-and-voting/.
\32\Id.
\33\Id.
\34\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Today, it is more likely than ever before that noncitizens
that apply for and receive federal benefits could end up on a
State's voter rolls. On March 7, 2021, President Joe Biden
signed an executive order, ``Executive Order on Promoting
Access to Voting''\35\ (``President Biden's order'') that turns
every federal agency into a voter registration agency\36\ under
the NVRA. Under President Biden's order, federal agencies are
required to ``consider ways to expand citizens'' opportunities
to register to vote and to obtain information about, and
participate in, the electoral process.''\37\ As such, the head
of each federal agency is required to evaluate how the agency
can promote voter registration and voter participation,
including, but not limited to, providing voting information in
the course of activities or services that directly engage with
the public through agency materials, websites, online forms,
social media platforms, and providing links on agency websites
to State online voter registration systems. In addition, the
agency head should attempt to provide access to voter
registration services and vote-by-mail ballot applications in
the course of activities or services that directly engage with
the public, including assisting applicants in completing voter
registration and vote-by-mail ballot applications, and
soliciting and facilitating nonpartisan third-party
organizations and State officials to provide voter registration
services on agency premises. As a result, noncitizens are more
likely than ever to encounter voter registration materials when
they engage with a federal agency\38\, as recently confirmed by
the Alabama Secretary of State Wes Allen.\39\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\35\Exec. Order No. 14019, 86 Fed. Reg 19569 (Mar. 7, 2021).
\36\52 U.S.C. Sec. 20502(5).
\37\Exec. Order No. 14019, 86 Fed. Reg 19569 (Mar. 7, 2021).
\38\On November 30, 2023, the Committee on House Administration met
in open session and passed H.R. 6493, the Safeguarding Electoral
Integrity Act of 2023. The legislation, as amended, repeals President
Biden's Executive Order on Promoting Access to Voting, and requires
plans made under it to be submitted to various congressional
committees.
\39\Wes Allen Exposes Federal Government Policy of Providing Voter
Registration Forms to Non-Citizens, Alabama Secretary of State (June 5,
2024), https://www.sos.alabama.gov/news room/wes-allen-exposes-federal-
government-policy-providing-voter-registration-forms-non.
----------
Committee Action
INTRODUCTION AND REFERRAL
On May 7, 2024, Representative Chip Roy (TX-21) with forty-
six original co-sponsors introduced H.R. 8281, the Safeguard
American Voter Eligibility Act. The bill was referred to the
U.S. House of Representatives Committee on House
Administration.
Hearings
For the purposes of clause 3(c)(6)(A) of House rule XIII,
in the 118th Congress, the Committee held one full committee
hearing to develop H.R. 8281.
1. On May 16, 2024, the Committee held a full
committee hearing titled, ``American Confidence in
Elections: Preventing Noncitizen Voting and Other
Foreign Interference.'' The hearing highlighted the
dangers associated with noncitizen voting, how States
do not have the tools nor resources to clean their
voter rolls, and what steps Congress can take to
rectify these problems. It also touched on the
loopholes in the federal campaign finance system that
allow foreign nationals to spend money in U.S.
elections and how Congress can close those loopholes.
Witnesses included the Honorable Cord Byrd, Florida
Secretary of State, the Honorable Hans A. von
Spakovsky, Manager, Election Law Reform Initiative and
Senior Legal Fellow, the Heritage Foundation, the
Honorable J. Christian Adams, President and Chief
Executive Officer of the Public Interest Legal
Foundation, Caitlin Sutherland, Executive Director of
Americans for Public Trust, and Michael Waldman,
President and Chief Executive Officer of the Brennan
Center for Justice.\116\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\116\American Confidence in Elections: Preventing Noncitizen Voting
and Other Foreign Interference: Hearing Before the H. Comm. On Admin.,
118th Cong. (2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Committee Consideration
On May 23, 2024, the U.S. House Committee on House
Administration met in open session and ordered the bill, H.R.
8281, Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act ANS as amended,
reported favorably to the House of Representatives, by a record
vote of six to one, a quorum being present.
Committee Votes
In compliance with clause 3(b) of House rule XIII, the
following votes occurred during the Committee's consideration
of H.R. 8281:
1. Vote on an amendment to H.R. 8281, offered by Mr.
Morelle, failed by a record vote of 6 noes and 1 aye.
Noes: Steil, B., Griffith, M., Bice, S., Carey, M.,
D'Esposito, A., Lee, L. Aye: Morelle, J.
2. Vote to adopt an amendment to H.R. 8281, offered
by Mrs. Lee, passed by a record vote of 6 ayes and 1
no. Ayes: Steil, B., Griffith, M., Bice, S., Carey, M.,
D'Esposito, A., Lee, L. No: Morelle, J.
3. Vote to adopt H.R. 8281 ANS, as amended, passed by
a record vote of 6 ayes and 1 no. Ayes: Steil, B.,
Griffith, M., Bice, S., Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee,
L. No: Morelle, J.
4. Vote to report H.R. 8281 ANS, as amended, to the
House of Representatives, passed by a record vote of 6
ayes and 1 no. Ayes: Steil, B., Griffith, M., Bice, S.,
Carey, M., D'Esposito, A., Lee, L. No: Morelle, J.
Committee Oversight Findings
In compliance with clause 3(c)(1) of House rule XIII, the
Committee advises that the findings and recommendations of the
Committee, based on oversight activities under clause 2(b)(1)
of rule X of the Rules of the House of Representatives, are
incorporated in the descriptive portions of this report.
Statement of Budget Authority and Related Items
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(2) of rule XIII of the Rules of the
House of Representatives and section 308(a)(I) of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974, the Committee provides the
following opinion and estimate with respect to new budget
authority, entitlement authority, and tax expenditures. The
Committee believes that there will be additional costs
attributable to H.R. 8281. The legislation gives States cost
free access to federal databases housed in the Department of
Homeland Security, the Social Security Administration, and
other federal and State databases where citizenship information
might be stored. For States to clean their voter rolls on an
ongoing basis and, in some cases, determine whether an
applicant registering to vote is a U.S. citizen, they will need
to frequently access these databases.
Congressional Budget Office Estimate
With respect to the requirement of clause 3(c)(3) of rule
XIII of the Rules of the House of Representatives, a cost
estimate provided by the Congressional Budget Office pursuant
to section 402 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 was not
made available to the Committee in time for the filing of this
report. The Chairman of the Committee shall cause such an
estimate to be printed in the Congressional Record if it is
received by the Committee.
Performance Goals and Objectives
The performance goals and objectives of H.R. 8281 are to
require individuals registering to vote in a federal election,
under any voter registration method, to provide their State
with documentary proof of U.S. citizenship before the State can
accept and process their voter application; but for applicants
registering without documentary proof of U.S. citizenship,
State officials can cross- check the applicant's information
across federal and State databases and determine whether the
applicant is a citizen within twenty-four hours. The
legislation also clarifies that States can remove noncitizens
from their voter rolls, requires States to establish a program
to remove noncitizens from their voter rolls, and gives States
no-cost access to several federal and State databases to do so.
It also expands the NVRA's existing private right of action to
empower citizens to bring civil suits against State election
officials that fail to uphold the act's proof of citizenship
requirement and adds criminal penalties for election officials,
including executive branch officials, that register noncitizens
to vote in Federal elections. Finally, the legislation tasks
the Election Assistance Commission with providing guidance to
States to help implement some of the legislation's
requirements.
Duplication of Federal Programs
Pursuant to clause 3(c)(5) of House rule XIII, no provision
of H.R. 8281 establishes or reauthorizes a program of the
federal government known to be duplicative of another federal
program.
Advisory on Earmarks
In accordance with clause 9 of House rule XXI, H.R. 8281
does not contain any congressional earmarks, limited tax
benefits, or limited tariff benefits as defined in clauses
9(d), 9(e), or 9(f) of House rule XXI.
Federal Mandates Statement
An estimate of federal mandates prepared by the Director of
the Congressional Budget Office pursuant to section 423 of the
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act was not made available to the
Committee in time for the filing of this report. The Chairman
of the Committee shall cause such an estimate to be printed in
the Congressional Record if it is received by the Committee.
The legislation contains several unfunded mandates. First, it
imposes a federal documentary proof of U.S. citizenship
requirement on individuals registering to vote in a federal
election that States, registering individuals to vote, will
need to comply with. Second, the legislation requires States to
establish a program where they identify noncitizens by using
federal and State databases in order to remove them from their
voter rolls. While the legislation does give States no-cost
access to these databases, there are no funds provided to help
States carry out this process or inform registered voters they
have been removed from the rolls. Finally, the legislation
tasks the Election Assistance Commission with developing
guidance that States must implement for individuals with a
disability and general guidance that States might choose to
implement to comply with Section 2 of this legislation
generally.
Advisory Committee Statement
H.R. 8281 does not establish or authorize any new advisory
committees.
Applicability to Legislative Branch
The Committee finds that the legislation does not relate to
the terms and conditions of employment or access to public
services or accommodations within the meaning of section
102(b)(3) of the Congressional Accountability Act.
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Short title
The section provides the short title of the bill, the
``Safeguard American Voter Eligibility (``SAVE Act'').
Section 2. Ensuring only citizens are registered to vote in elections
for federal office
Section 2(b)(1)-(5) defines Documentary Proof of
Citizenship (``DPOC'') and gives the methods that will qualify
including: (1) REAL ID if it indicates the applicant is a
citizen, (2) U.S. passport, (3) applicant's official U.S.
military ID card with U.S. military record of service showing
the applicant was born in the US., (4) valid government-issued
photo ID showing the applicant was born in the U.S., or (5)
valid government-issued photo ID (that does not provide proof
of citizenship) in conjunction with Section 2 (b)(5)(A):
(A) certified birth certificate;
(B) extract from a U.S. hospital Record of
Birth created when the applicant was born that indicate
the applicant was born in the U.S.;
(C) final adoption decree showing the
applicant's name and that the applicant's place of
birth was in the U.S.;
(D) A Consular Report of Birth Abroad of a
citizen of the U.S. or a certification of the
applicant's Report of Birth of a U.S. citizen issued by
the Secretary of State;
(E) Naturalization Certificate issued by the
Department of Homeland Security; or
(F) An American Indican Card issued by the
Department of Homeland Security
If an applicant does not provide the above
documentation, they cannot register to vote. This
includes by mail (on the federal form) or in person at
the DMV or at a voter registration center.
Section 2(b) also mandates all States to require DPOC under
any method the State accepts for registering to vote for
federal elections.
Section 2(c) requires that individuals registering to vote
in federal elections while receiving a State's Motor Vehicle
license must show DPOC that conforms with section 2 (b)(1 5).
Section 2(d)(2) requires the chief election official of
each State to take necessary steps to make sure the public is
aware of the new DPOC requirements.
Section 2(e)(a)(A) requires applicants who use the federal
mail voter registration form to register to vote to show DPOC
to the appropriate State election official in person in order
for the State to register the individual to vote.
Section 2(e)(3) requires each state to work with the
Election Assistance Commission to ensure individuals with a
disability who submit a mail-in voter registration application
are accommodated to present DPOC to the appropriate election
official.
Section 2(f)(3) requires a State or local official to sign
an affidavit affirming or swearing that the individual without
DPOC has provided evidence to establish themselves as a U.S.
citizen for the purpose of registering to vote in federal
elections.
The EAC is tasked with developing this
affidavit that includes:
An explanation of the minimum
standards required for a State officials to
register an applicant who cannot provide DPOC;
A requirement that the State
official must explain the basis for registering
such applicant to vote in such elections.
Section 2(f)(3) requires each state to establish a process
under which an applicant who has discrepancies with their DPOC
can provide clarifying additional documents to explain such
discrepancies.
Section 2(f)(3) & Section 2(f)(4)(A)(B)(C)(D) requires
States to take steps to ensure only U.S. citizens are
registered to vote and to establish a program within 30 days
after the bill's enactment to accomplish this goal.
States can rely on the
Department of Homeland Security's SAVE
database, the Social Security Administration,
State agencies that supply State ID's or
driver's licenses, or other sources, including
databases that provide U.S. citizenship.
In conjunction with the above,
federal agencies are required to respond to
State requests within 24 hours of the request.
Agencies cannot charge States a
fee for the information or for database access.
Section 2(f)(3) also requires the Secretary of Homeland
Security to conduct an investigation to determine whether to
initiate the removal process of non-citizens, who were
unlawfully registered to vote, under the Immigration and
Nationality Act.
Section 2(f)(3) also requires States to remove voters from
their rolls if they are given information providing that a
registered voter is not a citizen of the United States.
Section 2(g) clarifies that the National Voter Registration
Act (``NVRA'') allows States to remove noncitizens from their
voter rolls.
Section 2(h) amends the national mail voter registration
form to include a section requiring a State or local election
official to record the type of document the applicant presented
as documentary proof of U.S. citizenship, including the date of
issuance, the date of expiration (if any), the office which
issued the document, and any unique identification number
associated with the document.
Section 2(i) expands the NVRA's existing private right of
action, to include claims against election officials that
register applicants to vote without documentary proof of U.S.
citizenship.
Section 2(j) also adds a criminal penalty to the NVRA
against those who register applicants who do not provide
documentary proof of citizenship. It also makes it a crime for
an officer or employee of the executive branch to provide
material assistance to a noncitizen attempting to register to
vote in a federal election.
Penalties include fines and or
imprisonment not to exceed 5 years.
Section 2(k) provides that this legislation and the NVRA
will continue to not apply to States that do not have voter
registration. However, this legislation, in addition to the
NVRA's public records requirements, will apply in States that
are NVRA exempt unless the State adopts this legislation's core
provisions not later than 60 days before an election for
federal office.
Section 3. Election Assistance Commission guidance
Requires the Election Assistance Commission to adopt and
transmit guidance to each State's Chief Election Official to
implement the bill's requirements in section 2. This must be
done within 10 days after the bill's enactment.
Section 4. Inapplicability of Paperwork Reduction Act
The Paperwork Reduction Act will not apply to the
development or modifications of voter registration material
provided in this bill.
Section 5. Duty of Secretary of Homeland Security to notify election
officials of naturalization
Requires Secretary of Homeland Security to provide notice
to the State's Chief Election Officer (usually the Secretary of
State) when a noncitizen that lives in the State becomes a
citizen of the United States.
Section 6. Rule of construction regarding provisional ballots
Rule of construction keeping the provisional ballot laws of
every State in place with the caveat that the applicant must
provide (or the State when it gets the information) proof of
citizenship for their vote to be counted.
Section 7. Rule of construction regarding effect on state exemptions
from other federal laws
Rule of construction providing that this legislation should
not be construed to unexempt States from other exemptions it
has under federal law.
Section 8. Effective date
The legislation becomes effective on the date of enactment.
Changes in Existing Law Made by the Bill, as Reported
In compliance with clause 3(e) of rule XIII of the Rules of
the House of Representatives, changes in existing law made by
the bill, as reported, are shown as follows (existing law
proposed to be omitted is enclosed in black brackets, new
matter is printed in italics, and existing law in which no
change is proposed is shown in roman):
NATIONAL VOTER REGISTRATION ACT OF 1993
* * * * * * *
SEC. 3. DEFINITIONS.
[As used] (a) In General._As used in this Act--
(1) the term ``election'' has the meaning stated in
section 301(1) of the Federal Election Campaign Act of
1971 (2 U.S.C. 431(1));
(2) the term ``Federal office'' has the meaning
stated in section 301(3) of the Federal Election
Campaign Act of 1971 (2 U.S.C. 431(3));
(3) the term ``motor vehicle driver's license''
includes any personal identification document issued by
a State motor vehicle authority;
(4) the term ``State'' means a State of the United
States and the District of Columbia; and
(5) the term ``voter registration agency'' means an
office designated under section 7(a)(1) to perform
voter registration activities.
(b) Documentary Proof of United States Citizenship.--As used
in this Act, the term ``documentary proof of United States
citizenship'' means, with respect to an applicant for voter
registration, any of the following:
(1) A form of identification issued consistent with
the requirements of the REAL ID Act of 2005 that
indicates the applicant is a citizen of the United
States.
(2) A valid United States passport.
(3) The applicant's official United States military
identification card, together with a United States
military record of service showing that the applicant's
place of birth was in the United States.
(4) A valid government-issued photo identification
card issued by a Federal, State or Tribal government
showing that the applicant's place of birth was in the
United States.
(5) A valid government-issued photo identification
card issued by a Federal, State or Tribal government
other than an identification described in paragraphs
(1) through (4), but only if presented together with
one or more of the following:
(A) A certified birth certificate issued by a
State, a unit of local government in a State,
or a Tribal government which--
(i) was issued by the State, unit of
local government, or Tribal government
in which the applicant was born;
(ii) was filed with the office
responsible for keeping vital records
in the State;
(iii) includes the full name, date of
birth, and place of birth of the
applicant;
(iv) lists the full names of one or
both of the parents of the applicant;
(v) has the signature of an
individual who is authorized to sign
birth certificates on behalf of the
State, unit of local government, or
Tribal government in which the
applicant was born;
(vi) includes the date that the
certificate was filed with the office
responsible for keeping vital records
in the State; and
(vii) has the seal of the State, unit
of local government, or Tribal
government that issued the birth
certificate.
(B) An extract from a United States hospital
Record of Birth created at the time of the
applicant's birth which indicates that the
applicant's place of birth was in the United
States.
(C) A final adoption decree showing the
applicant's name and that the applicant's place
of birth was in the United States.
(D) A Consular Report of Birth Abroad of a
citizen of the United States or a certification
of the applicant's Report of Birth of a United
States citizen issued by the Secretary of
State.
(E) A Naturalization Certificate or
Certificate of Citizenship issued by the
Secretary of Homeland Security or any other
document or method of proof of United States
citizenship issued by the Federal government
pursuant to the Immigration and Nationality
Act.
(F) An American Indian Card issued by the
Department of Homeland Security with the
classification `KIC'.
SEC. 4. NATIONAL PROCEDURES FOR VOTER REGISTRATION FOR ELECTIONS FOR
FEDERAL OFFICE.
(a) In General.--Except as provided in [subsection (b)]
subsection (c), notwithstanding any other Federal or State law,
in addition to any other method of voter registration provided
for under State law, each State shall establish procedures to
register to vote in elections for Federal office--
(1) by application made simultaneously with an
application for a motor vehicle driver's license
pursuant to section 5;
(2) by mail application pursuant to section 6; and
(3) by application in person--
(A) at the appropriate registration site
designated with respect to the residence of the
applicant in accordance with State law; and
(B) at a Federal, State, or nongovernmental
office designated under section 7.
(b) Requiring Applicants to Present Documentary Proof of
United States Citizenship.--Under any method of voter
registration in a State, the State shall not accept and process
an application to register to vote in an election for Federal
office unless the applicant presents documentary proof of
United States citizenship with the application.
[(b)] (c) Nonapplicability to Certain States.--[This Act does
not apply to a State] Except with respect to the requirements
under subsection (i) and (j) of section 8 in the case of a
State described in paragraph (2), this Act does not apply to a
State described in either or both of the following paragraphs:
(1) A State in which, under law that is in effect
continuously on and after August 1, 1994, there is no
voter registration requirement for any voter in the
State with respect to an election for Federal office.
(2) A State in which, under law that is in effect
continuously on and after August 1, 1994, or that was
enacted on or prior to August 1, 1994, and by its terms
is to come into effect upon the enactment of this Act,
so long as that law remains in effect, all voters in
the State may register to vote at the polling place at
the time of voting in a general election for Federal
office.
(d) Permitting States to Adopt Certain Requirements After
Enactment.--Subsections (i) and (j) of section 8 shall not
apply to a State described in subsection (c)(2) if the State,
by law or regulation, adopts requirements which are identical
to the requirements under such subsections not later than 60
days prior to the date of the first election for Federal office
which is held in the State after the date of the enactment of
the SAVE Act.
SEC. 5. SIMULTANEOUS APPLICATION FOR VOTER REGISTRATION AND
APPLICATION FOR MOTOR VEHICLE DRIVER'S LICENSE.
(a) In General.--(1) [Each State motor vehicle driver's
license application] Subject to the requirements under section
8(j), each State motor vehicle driver's license application
(including any renewal application) submitted to the
appropriate State motor vehicle authority under State law shall
serve as an application for voter registration with respect to
elections for Federal office unless the applicant fails to sign
the voter registration application.
(2) An application for voter registration submitted under
paragraph (1) shall be considered as updating any previous
voter registration by the applicant.
(b) Limitation on Use of Information.--No information
relating to the failure of an applicant for a State motor
vehicle driver's license to sign a voter registration
application may be used for any purpose other than voter
registration.
(c) Forms and Procedures.--(1) [Each State shall include]
Subject to the requirements under section 8(j), each State
shall include a voter registration application form for
elections for Federal office as part of an application for a
State motor vehicle driver's license.
(2) The voter registration application portion of an
application for a State motor vehicle driver's license--
(A) may not require any information that duplicates
information required in the driver's license portion of
the form (other than a second signature or other
information necessary under subparagraph (C));
(B) may require only the minimum amount of
information necessary to--
(i) prevent duplicate voter registrations;
[and]
(ii) enable State election officials to
assess the eligibility of the applicant and to
administer voter registration and other parts
of the election process; and
(iii) verify that the applicant is a citizen
of the United States;
(C) shall include a statement that--
(i) states each eligibility requirement
[(including citizenship)], including the
requirement that the applicant provides
documentary proof of United States citizenship;
(ii) contains an attestation that the
applicant meets each such requirement; and
(iii) requires the signature of the
applicant, under penalty of perjury;
(D) shall include, in print that is identical to that
used in the attestation portion of the application--
(i) the information required in section
8(a)(5) (A) and (B);
(ii) a statement that, if an applicant
declines to register to vote, the fact that the
applicant has declined to register will remain
confidential and will be used only for voter
registration purposes; and
(iii) a statement that if an applicant does
register to vote, the office at which the
applicant submits a voter registration
application will remain confidential and will
be used only for voter registration purposes[;
and], other than as evidence in a criminal
proceeding or immigration proceeding brought
against an applicant who knowi
Minority Views
REPUBLICANS ARE PLANNING TO UNDERMINE THE 2024 ELECTION
The clear purpose of H.R. 8281 is to prime the American
people to question the outcome of the 2024 election. In 2020,
President Trump and his allies tried to subvert the outcome of
the presidential election by spreading numerous lies that the
election had been tainted by widespread fraud and
irregularities--claims that led to the deadly January 6, 2021,
attack on the Capitol.\1\ Indeed, one of the leaders of the
effort to subvert the election in Congress was now-Speaker Mike
Johnson, who led 126 of his Republican colleagues in filing an
amicus brief that would have, if successful, disenfranchised
millions of Americans and broken the back of American
democracy.\2\ But in 2020, Republicans' attempts to overturn
the election, while profoundly damaging, were unsuccessful.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\1\See generally Final Report, House Report 117-663, Select
Committee to Investigate the January 6th Attack on the United States
Capitol, 117th Cong. (2nd Sess. 2022).
\2\Andrew Solender, 126 House Republicans Now Support Lawsuit To
Overturn Election In Updated Brief, Forbes (Dec. 11, 2020), https://
www.forbes.com/sites/andrewsolender/2020/12/11/126 -house-republicans-
now-support-lawsuit-to-overturn-election-in-updated-brief/
?sh=7daf8913e5db.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAGA extremists are hoping to be more successful this
November. President Trump and his allies in Congress, including
Speaker Johnson and Committee Republicans, are laying the
groundwork to contest the 2024 election--beginning by echoing
disproven claims about fraudulent noncitizen voting. Despite
Republican allegations, there is absolutely no evidence of any
widespread noncitizen voting in federal elections.\3\ Speaker
Johnson has himself admitted this, saying that claims of
noncitizen voting in federal elections was not ``provable.''\4\
But in the face of all evidence,\5\ Republicans are intent on
creating a problem where there is none, so Americans lose
confidence in the security of American elections. By so doing,
they hope Americans will be more likely to believe future
baseless claims of massive fraud so that Republicans' attempts
to overturn the 2024 election will be more likely to succeed.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\3\Aaron Blake, Mike Johnson's telling comment on GOP's (lack of)
voter-fraud evidence, Wash. Post (May 9, 2024), https://
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2024/05/09/republican-bogus-claims-
vote-fraud/.
\4\Scott Wong et al., Speaker Mike Johnson and Trump allies who
tried to overturn the 2020 election roll out voting `integrity' bill,
NBC News (May 8, 2024), https://www.nbcnews.com/poli
tics/congress/speaker-johnson-trump-allies-tried-overturn-2020-
election-roll-new-vot-rcna151256.
\5\For further information on the lack of widespread noncitizen
voting in federal elections, see A Solution in Search of a Problem:
Noncitizen Voting Almost Never Happens below.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A SOLUTION IN SEARCH OF A PROBLEM: NONCITIZEN VOTING ALMOST
NEVER HAPPENS
Noncitizens are not voting in state or federal elections--
certainly not at any scale significant enough to sway any
American election--and there is overwhelming evidence showing
as much. First and foremost, it is already illegal for
noncitizens to vote in federal elections. Federal law declares
that it is ``unlawful for any alien to vote in any election
held solely or in part for the purpose of electing a candidate
for the office of President, Vice President, Presidential
elector, Member of the Senate, Member of the House of
Representatives, Delegate from the District of Columbia, or
Resident Commissioner.''\6\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\6\18 U.S.C. Sec. 611.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Further, not only is it already illegal for noncitizens to
vote in federal elections, federal law also makes the ``the
procurement or submission of voter registration applications
that are known by the person to be materially false,
fictitious, or fraudulent''\7\ a felony that could result in a
five-year prison term and subsequent deportation. The processes
in place to protect American elections are both sturdy and
comprehensive.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\7\52 U.S.C. Sec. 20511.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Why would a noncitizen ``risk everything--[their] freedom,
[their] life in the United States, [their] ability to be near
[their] family--just to cast a single ballot?''\8\ Quite
simply, they would not: Every reliable, verifiable study ever
done on the topic has proved that noncitizen voting in state
and federal elections is ``vanishingly rare.''\9\ Indeed,
``[t]he idea that large numbers of people who are in this
country illegally would take the risk of being detected to cast
a single vote in a presidential election is nonsensical on its
face.''\10\ As Michael Waldman, Committee Democrats' witness
for the May 16, 2024, hearing on the Safeguard American Voter
Eligibility Act (``SAVE Act''), has compellingly written:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\8\Sean Morales-Doyle, Noncitizens Are Not Voting in Federal or
State Elections--Here's Why, Brennan Ctr. for Justice (Apr. 12, 2024),
https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/noncitizens-
are-not-voting-federal-or-state-elections-heres-why.
\9\Id.
\10\Blake, supra note 3.
For starters, let's say it as clearly as possible: it
is already illegal for noncitizens to vote. They are
prohibited from voting in federal elections and state
elections in every state. It is very, very illegal.
There are strong penalties in the law. And states have
strong systems in place to ensure that noncitizens
don't vote--whether on purpose or, as may be more
likely, because they are misinformed about their
eligibility.\11\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\11\Michael Waldman, Noncitizen Voting Is Already Illegal--and
Vanishingly Rare, Brennan Ctr. for Justice (Apr. 17, 2024), https://
www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/noncitizen-voting-
already-illegal-and-vanishingly-rare.
A study by the Brennan Center found that suspected cases of
noncitizen voting in state or federal elections--including
those that have not been proven in a court of law--account for
0.0001 percent of all ballots cast. The conservative Cato
Institute has found that ``noncitizens don't illegally vote in
detectable numbers.''\12\ Whit Ayres, a longtime Republican
pollster, has admitted ``there is no evidence of widespread
voter fraud that would influence the results of an
election.''\13\ And as noted above, even Speaker Johnson
conceded that there is no evidence of noncitizen voting, an
admission The Washington Post called a ``telling comment.''\14\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\12\Alex Nowrasteh, Noncitizens Don't Illegally Vote in Detectable
Numbers, Cato Inst. (Nov. 25, 2020), https://www.cato.org/blog/
noncitizens-dont-illegally-vote-detectable-numbers.
\13\Colby Itkowitz et al., Noncitizen voting is extremely rare.
Republicans are focusing on it anyway., Wash. Post (May 9, 2024),
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2024/05/09/noncitizen-voting-
trump-johnson-elections/.
\14\Blake, supra note 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Further, evidence for illegal registration and voting would
be exceptionally easy to find, compared to almost every other
crime--just by attempting to register to vote, a noncitizen
would create a paper trail of criminal activity for state and
federal authorities.\15\ Indeed, officers at the United States
Citizenship and Immigration Services specifically investigate
possible past registration and voting during the naturalization
process.\16\ Republicans' claims about noncitizen voting ignore
the facts and defy common sense.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\15\Morales-Doyle, supra note 8.
\16\Id.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Republicans have no real interest in preventing noncitizen
voting in state and federal elections because there is no
problem with noncitizens voting in elections. H.R. 8281 is
instead part of Republicans' evolving election denialism, a
spectacle as they shift their focus away from November 2020 and
toward November 2024.
THE SAVE ACT OVERVIEW
On Wednesday, May 8, 2024, Speaker Johnson joined
Congressman Chip Roy (R-TX) and Senator Mike Lee (R-UT) at a
press conference on the Capitol steps to announce the
introduction of the SAVE Act,\17\ a bill that would require
voters to provide documentary proof of citizenship (``DPOC'')
when registering to vote in federal elections. They were joined
at this press conference by noted election deniers such as
Cleta Mitchell, Ken Cuccinelli, and Stephen Miller. This press
conference followed the April 12, 2024, press conference held
by Speaker Johnson and former President Trump at the Mar-a-Lago
country club calling for (redundant) legislation meant to
prevent noncitizens from voting in federal elections.\18\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\17\Other attendees included Congressman Brian Babin (R-TX),
Congressman Pat Fallon (R-TX), Congressman Randy Weber (R-TX), and
conservative activists.
\18\Lisa Mascaro & Jill Colvin, Trump gives support to embattled
Speaker Mike Johnson at pivotal Mar-a-Lago meet, AP (Apr. 12, 2024),
https://apnews.com/article/trump-speaker-johnson-maralago-congress-
c6eaace204882df054795cf70a5fe60a.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The SAVE Act would create extreme DPOC requirements
nationwide, burdening every potential voter and particularly
affecting people who have difficulty obtaining the required
DPOC, including married women who have changed their names,
students, the elderly, lower income people, members of Tribal
nations, and naturalized citizens. The bill's requirements
would be the most severe voter identification or proof of
citizenship law in the nation, even more burdensome than
Arizona's infamous DPOC law that has been subjected to repeated
successful federal lawsuits.\19\ The bill would do all of this
to prevent a problem that does not exist--an entirely
pretextual enterprise to frighten American voters and set the
stage for a January 6 redux.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\19\See, e.g., Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, 570 U.S.
1 (2013); Mi Familia Vota v. Fontes, _F.Supp.3d., _2024 WL 862406 (D.
Ariz. 2024); Consent Decree, ECF No. 20, Lulac v. Regan, No. 2:17-cv-
04102(D. Ariz. June 4, 2018), https://campaignlegal.org/sites/default/
files/Consent%20Decree.pdf.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
A. Acceptable Forms of Documentary Proof of Citizenship
This bill would amend the National Voter Registration Act
(``NVRA''), which currently prohibits states from requiring
DPOC from applicants that register under the NVRA's
registration provisions,\20\ to mandate states require
Americans to provide DPOC to register to vote. The following
forms ofDPOC would be allowable:\21\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\20\See Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, 670 U.S. 1, 20
(2013); Fish v. Schwab, 957 F.3d 1105, 1136 (10th Cir. 2020); Fish v.
Kobach, 840 F.3d 710, 750 (10th Cir. 2016).
\21\H.R. 8182, 118th Cong. (2nd Sess. 2024).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. a form of photo identification consistent with the
REAL ID Act of 2005 that indicates the applicant is a
citizen;\22\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\22\This requirement is bizarre; identification issued pursuant to
REAL ID does not list a person's citizenship status, and indeed REAL
IDs are available to noncitizens.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. a valid United States passport;
3. a military identification card coupled with a
military service record showing the applicant's place
of birth was in the United States;\23\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\23\Tracking down and submitting a military service record is
likely a significant burden for military voters.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
4. a valid government-issued photo identification
card from a federal, state, or Tribal government
showing the applicant's place of birth was in the
United States;\24\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\24\Apart from passports, most government-issued forms of
identification do not list places of birth--merely current residence.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
5. a valid form of photo identification issued by a
federal, state, or Tribal government (such as a
standard driver's license) that does not comport with
(4) above, so long as it is coupled with:
a. a certified birth certificate (with
several qualifiers);
b. an extract from a United States hospital
record of birth showing the applicant's place
of birth in the United States;
c. a final adoption decree showing the
person's name and that their place of birth was
within the United States;
d. a Consular Report of Birth Abroad or a
Report of Birth of a United States citizen
issued by the Secretary of State;
e. a Naturalization Certificate or
Certificate of Citizenship issued by the
Secretary of Homeland Security; or
f. an American Indian Card issued by the
Secretary of Homeland Security with the
classification ``KIC.''\25\
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
\25\The Kickapoo Act of 1983 enabled Mexican-born members of the
Kickapoo Tribe of Oklahoma and the Kickapoo Traditional Tribe of Texas
to acquire United States citizenship and free passage over the United
States-Mexico border through a special naturalization process. The law
did not provide for issuance of Certificate of Citizenship to
individuals who acquired citizenship through the Kickapoo Act, however,
but rather provided for a small, laminated card that included a
classification code ``KIC.'
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
The SAVE Act would not allow states to accept or process a
voter registration application without first receiving the
required DPOC.
B. Amending the Requirements of the National Mail Voter Registration
Form
The SAVE Act would disallow states from accepting the
NVRA's mail voter registration application unless the applicant
presents DPOC in person at the office of an appropriate
election official. If a state received an otherwise completed
voter registration application without DPOC, the state would be
required to notify the applicant that additional DPOC is
needed. By requiring people to travel to the office of an
election official, this provision of the SAVE Act would
essentially gut the utility of the mail voter registration
application.
The SAVE Act would also require individuals to bring DPOC
to vote if they live in a state with same-day voter
registration and intend on both registering to vote and casting
a ballot at the same time. This would pose a significant burden
to many voters, most of whom do not show up to their polling
places with their passports or birth certificates.
C. Process for those without documentary proof of citizenship
The SAVE Act creates a process for individuals without DPOC
so unclear it would likely be unworkable. The bill states that
the Election Assistance Commission shall provide guidance for
states to accept voter registrations from individuals who lack
DPOC, but that the process shall include an applicant (1)
signing an attestation under penalty of perjury that they are a
United States citizen, and (2) submitting ``such other evidence
to the appropriate State official demonstrating that the
applicant is a citizen of the United States.'' What this
``other evidence''--that is not already included in the list of
acceptable DPOC--could be is unclear.
Further, upon receiving the signed attestation and the
additional, undefined proof of citizenship, the SAVE Act would
require election officials to make their own determination as
to whether the applicant may properly register to vote--and
then sign an affidavit themselves explaining their basis for
allowing the applicant to register to vote.
D. State Coordination with Federal Agencies
A portion of the SAVE Act includes much of the substance of
the Protecting American Voters Act (H.R. 3162), also sponsored
by Congressman Roy, which would require the Secretary of
Homeland Security and the Commissioner of the Social Security
Administration to provide any state election official with
``such information as may be necessary'' for the official to
verify that a potential voter is in fact a citizen--a process
that would be rife with flaws and overburden two already-taxed
agencies. H.R. 3162 was previously marked up by the Committee
on November 20, 2023.
The Social Security Administration (``SSA'') has previously
explained that sharing this information for voter registration
purposes is non-mission work for SSA and would divert critical
agency resources needed to administer SSA's programs.
Additionally, SSA is not the authoritative source for U.S.
citizenship status--SSA's citizenship data is a snapshot in
time and many people may have changed status (become citizens)
and may not have notified SSA.
E. Private Right of Action
The SAVE Act would amend the NVRA's private right of action
contained in 5.2 U.S.C. 20510(b)(l) to allow for suits against
``an election official who registers an applicant to vote in an
election for Federal office who fails to present documentary
proof of United States citizenship.'' This would undoubtably
result in an avalanche of litigation against election officials
in blue states, where the former president has repeatedly
alleged noncitizen voting is rampant.
F. Criminal Penalties Against Election Officials
The SAVE Act would amend the NVRA's criminal penalties
contained in 52 U.S.C. 20511 to subject any election official
w