Minority Views
[To accompany H.R. 8752] The Committee on Appropriations submits the following report in explanation of the accompanying bill making appropriations for the Department of Homeland Security for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2025. INDEX TO BILL AND REPORT Page number Bill Report TITLE I--DEPARTMENTAL MANAGEMENT, INTELLIGENCE, SITUATIONAL AWARENESS, AND OVERSIGHT Office of the Secretary and Executive Management... 1 5 Operations and Support..................... 1 5 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 13 Federal Assistance......................... 13 Management Directorate............................. 3 13 Operations and Support..................... 3 14 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 3 15 Federal Protective Service................. 3 16 Intelligence, Analysis, and Situational Awareness.. 3 16 Operations and Support..................... 3 16 Office of Inspector General........................ 4 17 Operations and Support..................... 4 17 Administrative Provisions.......................... 4 18 TITLE II--SECURITY, ENFORCEMENT, AND INVESTIGATIONS U.S. Customs and Border Protection................. 11 19 Operations and Support..................... 11 19 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 12 28 U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement........... 13 32 Operations and Support..................... 13 33 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 14 46 Transportation Security Administration............. 15 46 Operations and Support..................... 15 46 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 15 49 Research and Development................... 16 49 Coast Guard........................................ 16 49 Operations and Support..................... 16 50 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 17 53 Research and Development................... 17 55 Health Care Fund Contribution.............. 56 Retired Pay................................ 18 56 United States Secret Service....................... 18 56 Operations and Support..................... 18 57 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 20 58 Research and Development................... 20 58 Administrative Provisions.......................... 20 58 TITLE III--PROTECTION, PREPAREDNESS, RESPONSE, AND RECOVERY Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency... 43 61 Operations and Support..................... 43 61 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 44 68 Research and Development................... 68 Federal Emergency Management Agency................ 44 69 Operations and Support..................... 44 69 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 44 71 Federal Assistance......................... 44 71 Disaster Relief Fund....................... 49 74 National Flood Insurance Fund.............. 49 75 Administrative Provisions.......................... 51 75 TITLE IV--RESEARCH, DEVELOPMENT, TRAINING, AND SERVICES U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.......... 56 75 Operations and Support..................... 56 76 Federal Assistance......................... 78 Federal Law Enforcement Training Centers........... 57 78 Operations and Support..................... 57 79 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 57 79 Science and Technology Directorate................. 57 79 Operations and Support..................... 57 80 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 58 80 Research and Development................... 58 81 Countering Weapons of Mass Destruction Office...... 58 85 Operations and Support..................... 58 85 Procurement, Construction, and Improvements 58 85 Research and Development................... 59 85 Federal Assistance......................... 59 86 Administrative Provisions.......................... 59 86 TITLE V--GENERAL PROVISIONS This Act........................................... 91 House of Representatives Reporting Requirements.... 91 Overview The Department of Homeland Security (DHS), now in its 21st year of operation, has grown to over 260,000 employees, making it the third largest Federal Cabinet department. DHS is responsible for vital homeland and national defense operations across eight operational components. From border security to keeping the flying public safe, to protecting our Nation's key leadership and guarding against cybersecurity threats to the country's critical infrastructure, the Department ensures the Nation is well equipped to respond to both natural and man-made disasters. The Committee recommendation includes $94,421,588,000 in total discretionary appropriations for the Department of Homeland Security, including $64,805,000,000 within the bill's 302(b) budget allocation, $6,121,588,000 in discretionary appropriations offset by fee collections, and $22,741,000,000 as an allocation adjustment for major disaster response and recovery activities. The overall total is an increase of $4,674,006,000 above the fiscal year 2024 level. The total within the allocation is $2,965,000,000 above the fiscal year 2024 level. Homeland Security Investments Investments in this bill are intended to balance competing priorities across the Department's important missions, all of which are critical to the security of the Nation, including providing funding for: physical barriers, border security technology, and Border Patrol Agents; the deployment of additional Non-Intrusive Inspection machines at ports of entry (POEs) to increase the detection of fentanyl; artificial and machine learning capabilities to reduce manual review of cargo and vehicle images; continuing recapitalization of the Coast Guard's surface and aviation fleets, including continued support for the Fast Response Cutter, Waterways Commerce Cutter, and Offshore Patrol Cutter programs; and cybersecurity defense tools and technology to protect government networks and critical infrastructure. Border Security For the last three years, migrant encounters have skyrocketed, straining U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agents and officers in the field. In lieu of managing the crisis at the border through the use of temporary and costly measures that have minimal impact on illicit migration flows, this bill includes long-term border security investments that seek to increase the agency's ability to deter illicit border activity. With the funds provided, the bill sustains funding for a Border Patrol end strength of 22,000 agents and recommends the following: $50,600,000 for autonomous surveillance towers; $50,000,000 for workforce care; $30,000,000 for innovative technology; $20,756,000 for Border Patrol Agent and U.S. Customs Officer recruitment infrastructure; $14,000,000 for tactical aerostats; $10,440,000 for cross-border tunnel threat detection; and $4,000,000 for Carrizo cane control. Within CBP's Procurement, Construction, and Improvements account, the recommendation includes: $600,000,000 for physical barrier construction; $300,000,000 for border technology; $53,900,000 for Light Enforcement Helicopters; $18,500,000 for UH-60 Medium Lift Helicopter conversions; and $18,000,000 for Enforcement System Unification and Interoperability. Immigration Enforcement As encounters at our Nation's borders reach an overwhelming and unprecedented level, and as the number of migrants who have final orders of removal exceeds 1,300,000, it is the responsibility of this Committee to provide appropriate funding to deter, detain, and deport those who do not have a legal basis to remain in this country or those who seek to harm our citizens and communities. In stark contrast to this administration's policies and priorities, the Committee provides appropriate resources for U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to fund significant increases for the critical components of a robust enforcement and removal apparatus, such as 50,000 detention beds--16,000 more than this administration requested. The recommendation also includes additional funding for transportation and removal operations to ensure that ICE executes its statutory authority to perform necessary interior enforcement actions. Transportation Security The Transportation Security Administration's (TSA) implementation of changes to the agency's pay structure has caused dramatic increases to the agency's budget, which have come at the expense of other priorities. This bill provides $198,428,000 for aviation screening infrastructure to restore some of the cuts that were necessary to fund the agency's pay structure changes. The bill also restores funding for canine and local law enforcement officer reimbursements. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security The bill provides $2,930,857,000 for the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) to sustain investments in securing Federal civilian executive branch networks and helping state, local, tribal, and territorial governments and critical infrastructure companies secure both cyber and physical infrastructure. The amount is $57,849,000 above the fiscal year 2024 enacted level. Citizenship and Immigration Processing With few exceptions, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) has historically operated as a fee-funded agency, with its operating expenses originating primarily from fees charged to applicants and petitioners seeking immigration benefits. The bill returns to this traditional funding structure and includes appropriated funding only for the E- Verify program. The Committee is encouraged by cost recovery improvements due to the new USCIS fee structure. Fiscal Year 2025 Pay Raise The recommendation does not provide funding for the fiscal year 2025 civilian pay raise for the Department. The Committee encourages the Department to find savings to support the pay raise through reductions in non-mission critical areas, such as administrative expenses, contracted services, and non-essential travel. References in the Report This report refers to certain entities, persons, funds, and documents as follows: the ``Department of Homeland Security'' is referenced as DHS or the Department; ``full-time equivalents'' are referred to as FTE; ``Government Accountability Office'' is referenced as GAO; ``Information Technology'' is referred to as IT; ``Office of Inspector General'' is referenced as OIG; ``program, project, and activity'' is referred to as PPA; any reference to ``the Secretary'' should be interpreted to mean the Secretary of Homeland Security; ``component'' should be interpreted to mean an agency, administration, or directorate within DHS; any reference to ``SLTT'' should be interpreted to mean state, local, tribal, and territorial; and ``budget request'' or ``the request'' should be interpreted to mean the budget of the U.S. Government for fiscal year 2025 that was submitted to Congress on March 11, 2024. TITLE I--DEPARTMENTAL MANAGEMENT, INTELLIGENCE, SITUATIONAL AWARENESS, AND OVERSIGHT Mission The mission of Departmental Management, Intelligence, Situational Awareness, and Oversight is to provide leadership and services to DHS components; formulate policy guidance and directives; disseminate intelligence; identify and track performance measurements relating to DHS missions; and provide oversight for all DHS operations. Office of the Secretary and Executive Management Appropriation, fiscal year 2024....................... $404,695,000 Budget request, fiscal year 2025...................... 358,466,000 Recommended in the bill............................... 281,358,000 Bill compared with: Appropriation, fiscal year 2024................... -123,337,000 Budget request, fiscal year 2025.................. -77,108,000 The Office of the Secretary and Executive Management (OSEM) plans and executes departmental strategies to accomplish agency objectives and provides policy guidance to departmental components. OPERATIONS AND SUPPORT Appropriation, fiscal year 2024....................... $363,582,000 Budget request, fiscal year 2025...................... 323,466,000 Recommended in the bill............................... 281,358,000 Bill compared with: Appropriation, fiscal year 2024................... -82,224,000 Budget request, fiscal year 2025.................. -42,108,000 The recommendation includes the following increases above the fiscal year 2024 enacted level: $3,702,000 for the Office of Health Security (OHS); $601,000 for the Office of General Counsel; and $46,000 for the Office of Citizenship and Immigration Services Ombudsman. The recommendation includes the following decreases below the fiscal year 2024 enacted level: $36,754,000 for the Office of the Secretary; $28,641,000 for the Office of the Immigration Detention Ombudsman; $18,345,000 for the Office of Strategy, Policy, and Plans; $875,000 for the Office of Privacy; $639,000 for the Office of Public Affairs; $604,000 for the Office of Partnership and Engagement; $393,000 for the Office for Civil Rights and Civil Liberties; and $322,000 for the Office of Legislative Affairs. 2026 FIFA World Cup.--The Committee recognizes that cities hosting events related to the 2026 World Cup face critical public safety needs that require adequate preparation. These include ensuring swift secure communications abilities among first responders and emergency services; working with Federal and SLTT jurisdictions to provide emergency services; and ensuring a safe environment for all attendees, residents, and visitors to the U.S. However, the Committee is concerned with the lack of Departmental budget planning for the 2026 World Cup. Not later than 60 days after the date of enactment of this Act, the Secretary is directed to brief the Committee on the estimated Department budgetary requirements, security, and other logistical support required to adequatel